Skip navigation
The Habeas Citebook: Prosecutorial Misconduct - Header

New York State Police, Trooper Joseph P. Santopietro Letter of Censure, 2017

Download original document:
Brief thumbnail
This text is machine-read, and may contain errors. Check the original document to verify accuracy.
----

\,_.;

GEORGE P. BEACH
SUPERINTENDENT

MAJOR JOSEPH A. TRIPODO
TROOP COMMANDER

STATE OF NEW YORK

NEW YORK STATE POLICE
TROOP "F" HEADQUARTERS
55 CRYSTAL RUN ROAD
MIDDLETOWN, NY 10941
(845) 344-5300

January 9, 2017
Trooper Joseph P. Santopietro
New York State Police
Middletown, New York

LETTER OF CENSURE

Dear Trooper Santopietro:
On August 19, 2016, you were operating your assigned Division vehicle when you
were involved in a troop car accident. This accident has been reviewed at Troop Headquarters and it
was determined to have been preventable on your part. On January 9, 2017 you appeared before me,
executed a waiver, and requested that I adjudicate the disciplinary action.
This accident occurred while you were driving westbound on Interstate 84 and
attempting to enter the Exit ramp at 3E. As a result of traveling at an unsafe speed, you were unable
to negotiate the curved segment of the ramp and in doing so, you lost control of the troop car and
drove off the paved portion of the west shoulder. Upon leaving the roadway, your vehicle struck a
highway delineator and then drove down an embankment where it subsequently incurred
undercarriage damage. Although there were no injuries associated with this accident, as a
professional driver, you are expected to drive more carefully.

It is my decision that you receive a letter of censure for your actions. I trust that you
will accept this censure in the spirit that it is given and that you will drive more cautiously in the
future.
Sincerely,

- I
._.l_c:::A /
Major Joseph A. Tripodo
Troop Commander
TroopF

~

NEW YORK STATE POLICE

MEMORANDUM

TROOP F

STATION

DATE

December 21, 2016

TO:

Deputy Superintendent Stephen J. Smith, Field Commander ·
Attn: Major, Division Traffic/

FROM:

Major Joseph A. Tripodo, roop Commander

SUBJECT:

TROOP CAR A IDENT- 08/19/16
TROOPER JO EPH P. SANTOPIETRO

Middletown

Reference is made to the attached self-explanatory investigative report regarding the
above subject.
I have reviewed this accident and it is my opinion that it was preventable.
Member has consented to adjudication by the Troop Commander under the provisions
of Article 3, Disciplinary Action, Rules of the New York State Police. Results of the adjudication
will be forwarded to you upon completion of same.

Attach.

NEW YORK STATE POLICE

MEMORANDUM

TROOP F

STATION

DATE

December 21, 2016

TO:

Majo,r Joseph A. Tripodo, Troop Commander

FROM:

T/Sergeant Scott Mohl, Troop Traffic Supervisor

SUBJECT:

TROOP CAR ACCIDENT- 08/19/16
TROOPER JOSEPH P. SANTOPIETRO

Middletown

x/C"ll{

Reference is made to the attached self-explanatory investigative report regarding the
above subject.
I have reviewed this accident and it is my opinion that it was preventable.
The primary cause of this accident was unsafe speed.

Attach.

Genl. 7

NEW YORK STATE POLICE

MEMORANDUM
Troop£_Station

Headquarters

Date

December 20, 2016

To:

Major Joseph A. Tripodo, Troop Commander, Troop F

From:

Sergeant William J. Meyers~

Subject:

DIVISION VEHICLE PDAA - F106
TROOPER JOSEPH P. SANTOPIETRO - EOD 06/28/04

Reference is made to Administrative Message Report AMSSM2 l 360JJ7B, dated
August 19, 2016, and the attached investigative report of Sergeant WILLIAM J. lvffiYERS
On August 19, 2016, at approximately 2:45PM, Trooper JOSEPH P.
SANTOPIETRO was operating Division vehicle Fl 06. As Trooper SANTOPIETRO was exiting
Interstate 84 at Exit 3E he failed to negotiate the curved portion of the ramp and drove off the
west shoulder and down an embankment. Division Vehicle Fl06 and a highway delineator were
damaged. Trooper SANTOPIETRO was not injured as a result of the collision.

Investigation into this matter has determined the culpability for the collision lies
solely with Trooper SANTOPIETRO and could only have been prevented by him. Trooper
SANTOPIETRO's inattention and failure to keep right caused this collision. It is recommended
that the collision be classified as preventable.

Genl. 7

NEW YORK STATE POLICE

MEMORANDUM
TroopLStation
Date

SP Middletown

August 19th, 2016

To:

Major Joseph A. Tripodo, troop Commander, troop F

From:

T=pe, J~eph P. Sa•top;,1,.

Subject:

DIVISION VEHICLE PROPERTY DAMAGE ACCIDENT - F106

~

Member is constructing this Memorandum as ordered by I/Sergeant WILLIAM J.
MEYERS in regards to DIVISION VEHICLE PROPERTY DAMAGE ACCIDENT - F106
to which Member was driving on August 19th , 2016. I have b()en advised of my rights to
representation pursuant to Article 16.2 of the contract and provide the following account.

Member was operating marked division vehicle F106 at approximately 2:45pm, on
August 19th, 2016 and failed to negotiate turn at exit 3E on 184, in Town of Wawayanda, Orange
County New York. Member attempted to correct vehicle and subsequently failed, leaving the
roadway onto grassy shoulder and down embankment. Member was uninjured from accident. ·

GENL 84

REV 3/2011

2 STATION

u

2A TZS

SP MIDDLETOWN

F044

F

◄

NEW Y ORK STATE P OLICE

CASE NO

7086625

C
0
M

p

L
A

C-1

COMfllAIHANT

•
10

EMPLOYER

11

PlACE OF OCCURRfHCE- SPECIFIC LOCATION

ADDRESS

118 C-T-V

T/WAWAYANDA

A

1. .

I

11C

I ,,

C-l•VCOOE

F3668

I

OATE OCCURRED

08/ 19/16

CHARACTER Of CASE

t7

DIVISION VEHICLE AA - 1 VEHICLE PROPERTY DAMAGE

I

2 :45PM

115
COUNTS

18

1

)

.

BUS ?HONE

)

(

COUNTY

TIME OCCURRED

AOORESS

I

PHONE

108

I ORANGE
11A

i

•(

OCCUPATION

I

ONNER lf OTHER THAN COMPlAlNANT

,.

7

COUNTY

I

C

MIOOLE

EXIT 3E DECELERATION RAMP FROM W/B 1-84

"

5 CASE NO

I

FIRST

AOORE SS

N

T

lASTHAME

3A TZS

C

F

1 TROOP

e

I

3 STATIOH

B

INV E S TIGATION REPO RT

WEATI-IER

DATE REPORTWc

1,

TM REPORTED

08/19/16

2:47 PM

181 CLEAR

D RAIN

0 SLEET

0 CLOUDY

□ FOG

□ SNOW

,.

CASE NO

7086625

CC CODE

MVE5058

s
E

D
A
T
A

"'
p

STOI.EN (S)
USED IN CRIME (C)

CODE:

COO£

P-1

CRIM. MISCH (M)

EVIDENCE (E)
GENL. 2(A)

RECOVERED (R)

TERM. MSG. (T)

21

OTHER (O)

DESCRIPTION

QTY

R
0
p

---------- -------------- --- ------------------------ ------- ---- -------

E

R
T

---- ------ --------

y

22

V
E
H

.,
w
E
A
p
0
N

..

D
0

U

V-1

-~~

USED IN CRIME

O CRMMISCH

DESCRIPTION - M4KE

COLO!!

&o0Y. MOOE.l

BUGLD

CHARGER

W-1
0
0
0
0
0

0

0 USED IN CRIME

RIFLE

••
•

SHOTGUN

T

OTHER

Q

PISTOL

I

2C3CDXKT1 EH356790

0

SER"'L NO

C
I

UNLAWFUL POSS.

BLUE □

SILVER 0

0 OTHER

N

M

BANK DRAWN ON· AOORfSS

NAME OF RECEIVER

u

N

DOCUMENT DATE

I

T

"

D
A
M

,.
'"

STATE

REG NO

STOLEN
CAl -GA

NY

□ YES
□ YES

O NO
ONO

------ -- ----- -----

□ OTHER
NAME OF O'NNER OR LICENSEE
ADDRESS

I

UCENSEHO

DATE lSSUEO

COUNTY Of ISSUE

IREASON

0 NO ACCT
INSUFF FUNDS

0 ACCTCLSD
□ FORGERY

0

I
DOCUMENT AMOUNT

J

I

ROS FlREO

UNEXPENDED ROUNDS

I

NAME OF MAKER -10 OR AOORESS OIVEN

LOAOEo O

TOT CAPACTTV

I

0

I
UtllOAOEO □

FINIS>!

p

------- -----------

SUSPECT
OTHERIOl

14
F106
L STOlEN MV - KEY IN IGNITION
I
I RECOVERED- RUNNING CONDITION I

VIN-K>NO

LAWFUL SURRENDER
..

KJNO Of DOCUMENT

0-1

O Rl;COVERED

MAt(f - TYPE MODEL

0

REVOLVER

15

C] ACC NON-MV

YR MFG

AUTO/ VAN 140554 MLG 25532

C

E

-------- --- -------

IDENTIFIABLE
□ YES ONO
PHOTO - SUSPECT
□ YES O NO

DOCNO

MONEY PROPERT'I' Oft SERVICE OBTAINED

-- ----------------

OESCAISE OR LIST PHYSICAL DAMAGE OR ARY OTMER LOSS

FRONT AND REAR END DAMAGE

7,849.66

------ ------ -----INSUR
HO

V-1

I 181

PROPERTY INSURED?

YES

O NO

DATE

08

NAME Of INSURER

SELF INSURED / STATE OF NEW YORK
0£SCRWTION

19

16

AMOUNT OF INSURANCE

TOTAL VALUE

"

I FULL

7,849.66

,,
fi1 m
,,... ...~

TOWED BY ADAMIS TO TROOP F HEADQUARTERS

Q

I

s

p
0
20

I

WT-1

NAME (\AST FIRST WOOLE)- ~ESS

AGE

ooe

'

:

T

N

E

s
s

--

Cl>

D

w

MONETARY VALUE

fO- SERIAL NUMBER

'

:

''
'

::l
0

z

,f;;'

,,i;:
0

z

0

y

,~ -~...
...

11

~

''

30

'

REPORT DATE

16

GENL 84A

REV. 3/2011

1-!0SMALAA trOAPK'f'tlQ.AH
Oi\TEOf'DEATM

CORONtR OR MGOICA.l EXI\I.ANER

coo,

AUTO/tSY

NAM£ (LAST. n RST UlQ~

S-2
:Y:
I r.,..::T:::IJ.=o,
, ~UUUR
=!!!
,Es""""...,__

PA'n1CM.OGGT

)QNNOTIFED

YES □ NO □

ADDAUS

YES □ NO □

coo
"'" _ _ .___~----------r
r-::"=°"":.,::=:,.,.=oro:::•""-= = - -- -- - - -- -..__....._
AGE

_ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ __

C

,t

A.UTC,PS'(

I,

:M

•~1f

PA.TttO~OOIST

..,,

YES O NO □
AOOOlS5

S-3

YES

°""

t-::= =~ = - - - - - -- - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - -- ,-:H
:;:(>$PIT
=A:':"
LAN
-::,'~
l>'Oll
= l'H'f=
Sl=.:...:::H_ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _..__.....__ _ .___ ~ - - - --.
CATEOf"DU.TH

CORONER OR M! DICAl~ U l

AU10 P$.Y

PAfflO~OGf&T

JQH NO'TIFl!D

YES □ NO □

YES □ NO □

AOORl:S-$ • N.

T-1

U

EOD 06/28/04 SP MIDDLETOWN • TIM

M

T-2
'f, t-----t-- --+-- - - -- - - -- - - - -- - - -- - - - -- -- -- - - -- - t--t--- t--......__ ......- 1

I
·T

T-3
T-4

it. t--T--5-t----+-- - - - - -- - -- - - - -- - - -- - -- - - - -- -----+--+--+- --'-- .......- --1
E 1--'---1---+---- - - - -- -- -- - - - - -- - -- - - -- - - -- ----1--1-- +--_,___.....__-t
T-6,
T-7

w

Tmf NO.

Hf

.....

Vlf

-:A~~,~
uOG:l!'•""--=-=':'!
.....
!:=,::
..:-:-,.~mu:=-.._
,,
_

S ~CTIOI(

IAV/

_ .___ _,__ _ ....______________ ____ _ r:::coo=,m=----+===
- - --+-:::==..-DATE ISSUED
EXnWm

,J :..

YES □ NO □
- -- - - - - - -- - - -----...L..- - - - - -1--:,= ~---'-- -t-7~.;;..;..=,_
W I

""'r"',rt"•"'"
" ••""·-...-:-.,""c,=--r-:-l<T
: :---r-:W
:-::_
f: ----.-.,.,"":::,.:--r--:E,::E;:,$,
, -C
,.,R'='
M"°•

SECTIOfl

.:E ·1-',"'uoo=-•-"",._,_=..!>.OOflf~::.,~....,==nn=•- -'-----''-----'-- -...__ _ ______ _________ __r:::eOI/NIY
==------t--=::==- - --;---==;;:;-CATE l»uB>

t:i.

EXJRAllllE

NO □

YES
N().

sn.nON
M
N O YES E t-----1~---i--'---'-+-- - - - -- - -- -----i
s
Q 181 NO
S
U •
A
I □ YES G

I

:- .~ ,::

IP
-.17, ·

R

Et---- +--t----'----'---+- - - - -- - ------1

y £!1l NO

S

D

D

181

CIA

C/EC

CIINV

6YWH0M

YES 181 NO O

SGT. MARK A. PRESTIGIACOMO

□
C/1.JtlF

□

Ol'EN

□ OTHER

□ YES

PHOTO$ l Al<,l;.N

NO.

CUS.TEO FOlt LAH.HT PA1~tl

YES O N0181

NIWE A~OA.CORESS OfA.Gf>tC'r NOf'IJIEOOJt.ReQYESTm

SPONDED

.OA
·311

NO.

1r YE.8,NAIIE OF PUUON IHCHARGE- If NO H.AMtOF PiRSONWOlltle:D

YES □ NO □

fWlE{S)OF' VC ENSU(S)

U$1/ES3,._ME

SLA

THE PRESENCE OR ABSENCE OF ANY INDMDUAL FACTOR IS INDICATED BY A •yes· OR 'NO"

;$ .

o t--------------------,-----------------------1
YES O NO O
WITNESS TO CRIME
YES O NO O
PROPERTY TRACEABLE/IDENTIFIABLE

t. :1------ - -- - - - - -- - -- - - - -- --+--- - - -- - - -- -- - - - -- - - - -- - - --t
YES O NO O
IDENTIFICATION/DESCRIPTION OF SUSPECTNEHICLE
YES O NO O
DISTINCTIVE/SIGNIFICANT MO
,A. t--- - - -- - - -- - - -- - - - - -- - --+----- - -- - - - - - - -- - -- -------1
' ~C YES O NO O
SIGNIFICANT PHYSICAL EVIDENCE
YES O NO O
SIGNIFICANT COMMUNITY INTEREST

F

....

.E _ e_-1_G_E_N_L_1_o_F_TP_R_._SA
_ITT_o_P_1_ET
_R
_o_
N E-2 GENL 34D

t--- ------ - - --------------- ---.

_ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ __ _

ct-------------- -------- ---+-- ---------- ------------ - -1
L.

'. cf

s

,

~

E-3 PHOTO CONTACT SHEET

t-E_-4_C
_O
_P_Y_O
_F_AM
_ S_M_
E_SS_A
_G_E_A
_n_l1S_M2
_ 1_36_0J
_J_7_8~ - - -- -- - -+ - - - -- - - -- - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - t

-t------ ---- -------- --- - - ----.

t-E-·S_MV
_ 1_04_A_ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ __ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _

E-6 MV1 04L

Et-------------------------+------------- - ------------1
E-7

·S

·,!.

ESTIMATE OF REPAIRS

ooa,_,.

WW'ONS

SUM

0

VfflNEG.SES

0

0
SHll:l.,C

~0.

<J

=F044

J.Pl>Rt:1V«>

4M. STJ\TION

7086625
1ZS

0

1

S!GNo\TIJREAHD WJK

2028
.Qi U $~Jro!O.

1ITLU

C1MS

""""'"" 0
$MleLO KO:

..,.

»Pff'OVED.

GENL 84B

Page 1

REV. 3'2011

NEW YORK STATE POLICE
TI<OOP

STATION

F

SP MIDDLETOWN

COMPlAINANT-tASTNAME. FIRST, MJDDLE

CONTINUATION SHEET
CASE NO.

SJS 7086625

1. On 08/19/16, at approximately 2:47PM, I was contacted by (T-1) Trooper JOSEPH P. SANTOPIETRO (EOD
06/28/04)) Troop F TIM , who advised that he had just run off the the Exit 3E deceleration ramp as he was exiting
from Interstate 84 west bound in Division vehicle F106. I contacted Major Joseph A. Tripodo who assigned me to
investigate.
2. On 08/19/16, the scene is described as follows, the Interstate 84 Exit 3E ramp has a straight deceleration section
the progresses into a curve and ends where it meets State Route 17M. The roadway is paved. I observed (V-1)
Divison vehicle F106 off the west shoulder and down an embankment. There was damage to the front and rear of
the vehicle and a road delineator had been struck. The damage was consistant with driving off the roadway and
striking a delineator.
3. On 08/19/16, Trooper SANTOPIETRO (T-1) was interviewed and slated he failed to negotiate the curve and drove
Division vehicle F106 off the west shoulder of the ramp and down the embankment. Trooper SANTOPIETRO (T-1)
states he was not injured as a result of the collision. Trooper SANTOPIETRO was directed to submit a memorandum,
attached as Enclosure #1.
4. On 08/19/16, Sergeant MARK A. PRESTIGIACOMO photograghed the scene and the damage to Division vehicle
F106 (V-1 ). Gen I 34D and photocontact sheet are attached as Enclosures #2 and #3 respectively..
5. On 08/19/16, Administrative Message# AMSM21360JJ7B was completed. A copy of the Administrative Message
is attached as Enclosure #4.
6. On 08/20/16, Sergeant MARK A. PRESTIGIACOMO completed an MV104A - Police Accident Report and a
MV104L - Report of Motor Vehicle Accident Police Line of Duty Accident. Copies are attached as Enclosures #5 and
#6 respectively.
7. On 8/2616, at the direction of DONALD E. WIEBOLDT, Troop F MEMS 11, an estimate of repairs in the amount of
$7,849.66 was prepared by T&C Auto Body, ST 17M; Middletown, NY. A copy of the estimate is attached as
Enclosure #7.
8. Closed by Investigation.

Administrative Message Report
Print\Run Date 08/19/2016

AMS # AMSM21360JJ7B
Date\Time Reported\Discovered
08/19/2016 14:45

Agency ORI

TZS

NYSP MIDDLETOWN

F044

Message
DIVISION VEHICLE - PDAA
Investigated By

Units Responded

T/SGT. WILLIAM J . MEYERS, SGT. MARK
A. PRESTIGIACOMO

UF

Photos YES

Videotape NO

Narrative
On this date at approximately 2:45 p.m., Trooper JOSEPH P. SANTOPIETRO, Troop F TIM detail , operating F106, a 2014
Dodge Charger, was exiting Interstate 84 westbound at Exit 3E in the Town of Wawayanda when he failed to negotiate a curve
on the off ramp. F106 exited the roadway off the west shoulder of the ramp, struck a delineator and continued down a small
embankment. No injuries reported .
Major Joseph A. Tripodo advised by T /Sgt. W illiam J. Meyers.

#Vehicles

1

# Injured
0

County
ORANGE

# Deceased

0

Apparent Cause
PENDING INVESTIGATION

C/TNName
WAWAYANDA, TOWN OF - 3668

Location\ Street Name \ Mile Post Marker
INTERSTATE 84 W/B EXIT 3E OFF RAMP

Weather Conditions

Road Conditions
1 - DRY

1 - CLEAR

Description of Damage
FRONT AND REAR DAMAGE
Criminal Action

Sent Date \ Sent Time
08/19/2016 19:49
Notification

Sent By
PRESTIGIACOMO MARK

Auth::zud

I

MAJOR JOSEPH A. TRIPODO

TROOP

Driver Information 1- - - - ~
Driver Name
SANTOPIETRO, JOSEPH P
Address
1220 WASHINGTON AVE

Gender

License State

M
City
ALBANY

State
NY

Chemical Test NO
Driver Charged NO
Zip
12226

Violations
Driver Member?
YES

Member Rank
TROOPER

Date of Entry
06/28/2004

Owner Information 1
Name (exactly as printed on registration)
NYSP,

Page 1 of 2

Member Shield

Member Shift

5241

B

Address
1220 WASHINGTON AVE

City
ALBANY

Insurance Company and Code
994 - GOVERNMENT OWNED
[ Vehicle Information 1
License Plate #
State
POLICE
NY

Vehicle Year
2014

Van#
140554

State
NY

Make
DODG

Zip
12226

VIN#
2C3CDXKT1 EH356790

Mileage
25532

School Bus
Comm. Veh.
NYSPVeh.

NO
NO
YES

Equipment
Damage

NO

Front Airbags Deployed
Side Airbags Deployed
Fire Suppression Deployed
Equipment Damage
Description

Page 2 of 2

NO
NO
NO

• Plige 1

Pages

of 2

New York State Department of Motor Vehicles

Local Codes

POLICE ACCIDENT REPORT

1086625
SP2 F12 60JG99

□

MV-104A (6/04)

AMENDED REPORT

i="rr.::ic=r---..::,:-~---,,,ear=---1 Day of Week
8
1;
2016
FRIDAY

No. of
Vehicles

Mi!itary Time

14:45

No. Injured No. KiUed Not Investigated at Scene

1

0

0

Left Scene Police Photo

0

i-,.;;;d;ntR~~;Wcted - -

~Yes

0

VEHICLE
VEHICLE 1- Driver
License JD Number
Driver Name - exactly
as printed on license

S1ato of Lie.

NY
SANTOPIETRO, JOSBPH P

Address (ln:C,ude Number and Street)
1220 WASHINGTON AVE
State

Fiii=-i:-T,im--r--.r.:=--isex

U~lieetlsed

NY
fllo..of ~pan!s

□

M

01

Name•8l<acwasP,l'in1&<1onreg:;:istrati=;::·o=n...aL-=:....-+s;:-ex:::"""- p~~~4~~:,~-:.,;;.--_-.,,-"-=' --- --if

4 NYS POLI CE,
1 Addreaa (Include NWl\Det alld Street)
1220 WASH AVE BLDG 22

ti!E-

AplNo.

~e

QiyuTown

Stale

ALBANY

Zip Code

12226

NY

Plate Number

Ststa ol Reg. Vehide Year & Mal<e

POLICE

NY

VellicleType

2014 DODG

POLI ..

Tielalt/AmlSI
Number(s)

6

1
V
E

mom than 34 feet 1001,1;
operaled with an overweight permit;

H

I
C
L Box 1 - Point of Impact
E Box 2 - Most Dilmage
Enter up to 1hree
1 ere damage codes

2

3
2

4
7

9

ACCIDENT DIAGRAM

5

Vehicle By: ADAMI S
Towed To: SP .MI DDLETOWN
VEHICLE DAMAGE CODING:
t.13 SEE DIAGRAM ON RIGHT.

14. UNDERCARRIAGE 17. DEMOLISHED
U . TRAlLER
18. NO DAMAGE
1&. OVERTIIRNED
19.OTHER

.

· Reference Marker

'
•8 • 4 •I

:o

'
,1

1 , 1 :9

:s

B ,3

1-....,,.....____

See the l ast page of the MV-10 4A for the

= =-'-"-~--~'~-·~··~· accident diagram.

'.(-(□. !.
"

.,

Place Where Accident Occurred:

4·589035

Road en which accident occurred

--I Longitude/Easting

553163

ORANGE

at 1) Intersecting street

Cost ot repairs to any Olle·vehicle wiU be mo~ than $1000.

0

10

Coon!inates {if avallab)e)
Latitude/Northing

County

9.

0

~ Yes

Unknown/Unable lo determine

City □ Village ~ Town

of

O No

WAlilAYANDA

I 84 W/B EXIT 3E OFF RAMP
(Route Number er sriei Name)

I 84 W/B

or Stre91
of _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _(Route
_ _Number
__ _
__Name)
_ _ __

or 2)

-.1ee-1-

miles

(Miepost, Nearest intersecting Route Number or Street Name)

Accident DewiptionfOfflcer's notes

V-1 was exiting Interstate 84 westbound at Exit 3E when OP V-1 failed to negotiate a curve on the
off ramp. V-l exited the roadway off the west shouldex of the off ramp, struck a delineator and
continued down a small grass embankment. PROPERTY DAMAGED BY VEHICLE # 01- DELINEATOR
NYS DOT
3233 US-6 MIDDLETOWN, NY 1 0940

·N
L------------------------------------------------------'
14
13

M

16

16

17BY

T018

Names of all Involved

SANTOPIETRO, JOSEPH

Date of Death Only

Page 2

of

2

Pages

New York State Department of Motor Vehicles

local Codes

POLICE ACCIDENT REPORT

7086625
□

SP2Fl260JG99

AMENDED REPORT

~•ea=sS~!"~~J!,~!Ooa..,1a:-__ay---~,-ac---l Day of Week
0

8

19

2016

FRIDAY

Military Time

14: 45

MV-104A (6/04)
No. of

Vehicles

l

No. Injured No. Killed

0

O

Not Investigated at Scene

D Left Scene

Accid~n'i Re~nitructed ~ - -□

□

Police Photos

~Yes □ No

a..
2

~

LL
LL

0

w

"'

f-

G)

X

w

INTERSTATE 84 W/6
T/WAWAYANDA
(NOT TO SCALE)

New York State Department of Motor Vehicles

REPORT OF MOTOR VEHICLE ACCIDENT
POLICE LINE OF DUTY ACCIDENT

□
Page 1

of

AMENDED REPORT

Pages

Precinct
F2 11
Local Accident Number

IMPORTANT: If you are the officer in charge, complete and sign
this form, and attach it to the MV-104A or MV-104AN.

7086625
SP2F1260JG99

Accident Date
8
Month

I

19
Day

Accident Time
In
/ 2016 Military
Year
Time

County

14: 45

ORANGE

NAMES OF DRIVERS: (Please Print or Type)

state ·

· ·otv~h. :· ip1ate

*

.M.1!.

R~.

Number

p

NY

POLICE

Qrivet

License··
..State
.. NY

~

Driver •
'.!Lic;:ense'

NUIJ1b~r___ ..

VEH 1
□

SANTOPIETRO

JOSEPH

VEH 2

VEH 3

VEH 4

VEH 5

VEH 6

Pursuant to Section 605 of the New York State Vehicle and Traffic Law, the attached Police Accident
Report is also the motorist report for vehicle number(s)
1
* Pursuant to Section 605(a)(4) of the Vehicle and Traffic Law, check only the box for each police officer operating a
police vehicle (as defined by V & T Section 132-a) during emergency operation (as defined by V&T Section 114-b)

when the accident occurred,
Signature of Owner or Police Vehicle/Police Agency Representative

Dale

08/26/2016
MV-104L (4/07)

12:45

'7"';,-:.S-d-7'

.,.,_../.;•~~

www.nysdmv.com

NCIC#

13502

~·

GENL. 34D /Rev 05/15\

DIGITAL PHOTO RECORD
STATION

INSTRUCTIONS:
CASE NUMBER

SP Middletown

FILI LEAD NUMBER

INCIDENT DATE

7086625

8/19/16

INVESTIGATING MEMBER

• Complete a separate form for each investigation
• Print or ---e all entries
I
PHOTO DATE
TIME
BEGAN
COMPLETED

T/Sgt. William J. Meyers

COMPLAINANT - DEFENDANT- OPERATOR- DECEASED

Division Vehicle - PDAA

Trooper Joseph P. Santopietro

COUNTY

ADDRESS OR LOCATION

Orange

Interstate 84 W/B Exit 3E T/Wawayanda

I ACTION REQUESTED
0 Bum To CD/OVD

Fl06 (2014 Dodge Charger)/Accident Scene
Kodak
IMAGE#

IMAGETYPEORFILEFORMAT

~ JPEG

O TIF O Raw

CAMERA
PHOTO ID#

I

3:36 PM

-

GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF SCENE/ ITEM($)

I

3:25 PM

Sgt. Mark A. Prestigiacomo

CASE TYPE

CAMERA

I

8/19/16

PHOTOGRAPHER'S NAME

I

PAGE#

DESCRIPTION:

1

OF

I

i:gJ Print _2

l:gJ Retain

DATE SUBMITTED TO FlU

MANNER SUBMITTED: (Check one)

8/19/16

i:gJ CD/DVD

IMAGE#

1

2743

FrontF106

39

2

2744

FrontF106

40

3

2745

Front Fl06

41

4

2746

Passenger Side Fl06

42

5

2747

RearF106

43

6

2748

Rear Fl06

44

7

2749

RearF106

45

8

2750

Driver Side F!06

46

9

2751

47

10

2752

11

2753

12

2754

13

2755

Scene facing west
Scene facing west
Scene facing west
Scene facing west
Scene facing east

48
49
50
51

14

52

15

53

16

54

17

55

18

56

19

57

20

58

21

59

22

60

23

61

24

62

25

63

26

64

27

65

28

66

29

67

30

68

31
32

69
70

33

71

34

72

35

73

36

74

37

75

38

76

CAMERA
PHOTO ID#

O E-MAIL O Other
DESCRIPTION:

08/ 19/2016 Middletown SJS-7086625 AMS-TCA/PDAA-Tpr. Joseph P. Santopietro-Fl 06 /Fwet.~:NPtt.e ..5

100_2743.J PG
8/19/2016 3:25.25 PM

100_ 274-4.JPG
8/19/2016 3:25:42 PM

100_2745.JPG
8/19/201 6 3:26:00 PM

100_2746.JPG
8/19/2016 3:26: 17 PM

100_2747 JPG
8/19/2016 3 :26:36 PM

100_2748.JPG
8/19/2016 3 :2 7:13 PM

100_2750.JPG
8/19/2016 3:27:47 PM

100_2751.JPG
8/19/2016 3:34:45 PM

100_ 2753.JPG
8/19/2016 3:35:57 PM

100_2754.JPG
8/19/2016 3:36:13 PM

Workfile ID:
Stlte ID:

T & C AUTO BODY, INC.

Bbee3422
7000221

770 Rt 17 M, Po Box 2164, MIDDLErOWN, NY
10940
Phone: (845) 343-3443
FAX: (845) 342-4330

Preliminary Estimate
Customer: New York state Police #140554

Job Number:

Written By: Chris
Insured:

New York Stlte Police
#140554

Type of Loss:

□ ark,

IA-941114

Policy#:

Oaim#:

Date of Loss:

Days to Repair:

O

Point of Impact:

owner:

Inspection Location:

New YorkStlte Police #140554

T & C AUTO BODY, INC.

55 Crystal Run Rd.

770 Rt 17 M

Middletown, NY 10941

Po Box 2164

(845) 344-5300 Business

Insurance company:

MIDDLETOWN, NY 10940
Repair Facility
(845) 343-3443 Business

VEHICLE
2014 DODG CHARGER POUCE AWD 4D SED 8-5.7L-FI Blue
VIN:

20CDXKT1EH356790

Interior Color:

Mileage In:

License:

F106

Exterior Color:

Mileage Out:

Stlte:

NY

Production Date:

TRANSMISSION
Automatic Transmission

Tinted Glass

4 Wheel Drive

Blue

Condition:

25,532

Vehide Out:

Good

Job#:

AM Radio

SEATS

Overhead Console

FM Radio

Oolh Seats

Stereo

Bucket Seats

POWER
Power Steering

CONVENIENCE
Air Conditioning

Search/Seek

Inten11ittent Wipers

Auxiliary Audio Connection

WHEELS
Styled Steel Wheels

Power Brakes

Tilt Wheel

SAFETY

PAINT

Power Windows

Cruise Control

Drivers Side Air Bag

Oear Coat Paint

Power Locks

Rear Defogger

Passenger Air Bag

OTHER

Power Mirrors

Keyless Entry

Anfi-Lock Brakes (4)

Traction Control

Power Driver Seat

Message Center

4 Wheel Disc Brakes

Stlbility Control

DECOR

Steering Wheel Touch Controls

Front Side Impact Air Bags

Power Trunk/Gate Release

Dual Mirrors

RADIO

Head/Curtain Air Bags

8/26/2016 9:33:22 AM

002479

Page 1

..

Preliminary Estimate

Customer: New York State Police #140554

Job Number:

2014 DODG CHARGER POUCE AWD 4D SED 8-5.ll·FI Blue

Line

Oper

Desaiption

Part Number

Qty

Extended

Labor

Paint

Price$

1

FRONT BUMPER

2

#

3

#

Add for push bar
R&l

0.2

0/H front bumper

5

Repl

2.6

Bumper cover w/auto cruise

6

68092597AA

1

345.00

Ind.

5182372AA

1

24.25

Ind.

24.20

Ind.

279.00

0.3

Repl

1.3

RT Bezel w/auto cruise

LT Bezel w/auto cruise
68092614AA
---- - ---Repl
--· - ---- --- ·-·------------------- ------ ------

8

10

Repl

RT Headlamp assy w/o HID

57010410AE

1

- - -------

0.5

14

Repl

Front shield 3.6 & 5.7 liter

15

Repl

Splash shield w/AWD

16

Repl

Front shield pin

6506132AA

-----------

--

-- -

Crossmember

.

COOLING

18

Repl

-

-- --- --

5065240AG

-· -

-- -

---

Radiator

19

-·

. --

1

197.00

0.5

57010338AD

1

123.00

Ind.

4806075AB

1

82.20

0.2

---

--

---

-

6

--

-- ---28.20
--- .

68050126AB

1

••

22

Repl

Lower seal

Repl

A/M Coolant

68050130AB

1

54.60

1

36.95

Repl

Fan assy

0.8

-·-- ------·-

364.00 m

Deduct for Overlap

20

2.3
-0;5

68050129AA

1

270.00 m

Ind.

68085784AA

1

542.00 m

1.5

AIR CONDmONER & HEATER

24

Condenser assy

Repl

25

AC Service evacuate & recharge

m

1.4

26

AC Service refrigerant recovery

m

0.4

27

Deduct for Overlap

28

••

Repl

29

#

Repl Transmission Huid

30

HOOD

31

•

Rpr

32

Repl

1

36.95

1

12.50

2.l!

Hood w/o scoop (ALU)
Add for Clear Coat

- -- -

34

·1.0

A/M R134 Freon/PAG 150 oil

- -----------------~·--·--.
33
FRONT SUSPENSION

35

.

RADIATOR SUPPORT

Repl

23

---------- -- - -----

Aim headlamps

13

21

1

FRONT LAMPS

11

17

3.2

Add for Oear Coat

7

12

1.0

License plate

4

9

1

------------- -~----·--

Wheel alignment align four
wheels

-----~--- ------1

m

-- --- - -

3.0
1.2

1.7

FENDER

36

Repl

RT Fender

55113584AB

1

264.00

1.6

20

37

Overlap Major Adj. Panel

·0.4

38

Add for aear Coat

0.3

39

Add for Edging

0.5

40

Add for aear Coat

0.1

41

R&l

RT Fender liner

Ind.

42

R&l

LT Fender liner

0.3

8/26/2016 9:33:22 AM

002479

Page2

Preliminary Estimate

Customer: New York State Police #140554

lob Number:

2014 DODG CHARGER POUCE AWD 4D SED 8-5.7L-FI Blue
43

Repl

RT Fender liner retainer

6506132AA

5

23.50

44

Rep\

LT Fender liner retainer

6506132AA

5

23.50

R&J

RT Washer nozzle

0.2

R&J

LT Washer nozzle

0.2

Bind

RT Door shell (HSS)

45

WINDSHIELD

46
47
48

FRONT DOOR

49
50
51
52

•
•

53
54

#

55

REAR LAMPS

1.1

R&J

RT Applique

0.2

R&J

RI eower milIDr

0.5

R&I

RI tfandle

0.4

01 rtside

R&J

RT R&I trim panel

0.5

Rpr

RT Frt door decals

1.0

56

0/H rear bumper

57
58

2.0

Rep\

RT Side mart.er lamp

68039504M

Repl

LT Side mart.er lamp

1

28.25

Ind.

68039505M

1

28.10

Ind.

59

••

Repl NM RT Mart.er lamp bulb

L0000168

1

60

••

U5.

Ind.

Repl

NM LT Mart.er lamp bulb

L0000168

1

2.35

Ind.

61

REAR BODY & FLOOR

62
63

*

Rpr

Add for Gear Coai
Repl

67

0.2

Bumper cover w/rev sensor

68092609AB

1

354.00

Ind.

Add lbr Gear Coat

#

70
•

0.3

Add for auxiliary lights
Repl
Repl

72

Rear valance
Reverse sensor

1

0.6

68092615M

1

217.00

Ind.

1EW63lZZAA

4

436.00

ll1

Add lbr Gear coat
Repl

RT Side support

57010288AD

1

15.85

0.1

74

Rep!

LT Side support

57010289AD

1

15.45

0.1

RT Side bracket

5182268AD

1

18.95

0.2

75

Rep!

76

Rep!

LT Side bracket

518ll69AD

1

18.95

0.2

77

Repl

RT Outer support

57010614AF

1

6.70

78

Rep\ LT OUter support

57010615AF

1

6.70

0.1
0.1

79

Rep!

Retainer ling

4806474M

4

46.40

80

Repl

Energy absorber

57010467AB

1

48.95

68092616M

1

329.00

1

79.89

Repl

Wire harness

82

#

Repl

Rear bumper heatshields

83

#

R&I

License plate

B4

#

Rpr

Clean mud/deblis from bottnm of
vehide

85

#

Rep!

Install rear bumper and RT/Frt
decals

8/26/2016 9:33:ll AM

Ll
0.2

73

81

3.2
1.3

Add for reverse sens

68

71

Ll
-0.2

REAR BUMPER

66

69

1.5:

Overtap Major Non-Adj. Panel

64

65

Rear body panel

Ind.

0.2
0.2
3.0

1

002479

1.5

Page 3

,

'

...

• _'_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _P_r_el_i_m_i_na_ry_Esti_._m_a_te
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
Customer: New York State Police #140554

lob Number:

2014 DODG CHARGER POLICE AWD 4D SED 8·5.7L·FI Blue
86

#

Rpr

87

#

88

#

89

#

90

#

91

De Nib & Polish

1.0

Rpr

Disable SRS

0.5

Rpr

TmtColor

Rep!

Corrosion Protection

1

Repl

Flex addilive

2

25.00

#

Car Cover

1

8.00

92

#

Hazardous Waste

1

3.50

93

#

Paint and materials as per
Mitx:llell RMC

1

749.42

Rep!

0.5

SUBTOTALS

0.5

5,171.66

0.3

30.3

21.2

NOTES
Estimate Notes:
8/26/16 @ 8:15 faxed to Donny

ESTIMATE TOTALS
-Basis

category

Rate

Parts

C05t'$

5,171.66

Body Labor

30.3 hrs

@

$ 52.00 /hr

1,575.60

Paint Labor

21.2 hrs

@

$ 52.00 /hr

1,102.40

SUbtotal

7,849.66

Grand Total

7,849.66

Deductible
CUSTOMER PAY

0.00

0.00
7,849.66

INSURANCE PAY

ANY PERSON WHO KNOWINGLY AND WITH INTENT TO DEFRAUD ANY INSURANCE COMPANY OR OTHER PERSON
FILES AN APPLICATION FOR COMMERCIAL INSURANCE OR A STATEMENT OF CLAIM FOR ANY COMMERCIAL OR
PERSONAL INSURANCE BENEFITS CONTAINING ANY MATERIALLY FALSE INFORMATION. OR CONCEALS FOR THE
PURPOSE OF MISLEADING, INFORMATION CONCERNING ANY FACT MATERIAL THERETO, AND ANY PERSON WHO,
IN CONNECTION WITH SUCH APPLICATION OR CLAIM, KNOWINGLY MAKES OR KNOWINGLY ASSISTS, ABETS,
SOLICITS OR CONSPIRES WITH ANOTHER TO MAKE A FALSE REPORT OF THE THEFT, DESTRUCTION, DAMAGE OR
CONVERSION OF ANY MOTOR VEHICLE TO A LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCY, THE DEPARTMENT OF MOTOR
VEHICLES OR AN INSURANCE COMPANY, COMMITS A FRAUDULENT INSURANCE ACT, WHICH IS A CRIME, AND
SHALL ALSO BE SUBJECT TO A CIVIL PENALTY NOT TO EXCEED FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS AND THE VALUE OF
THE SUBJECT MOTOR VEHICLE OR STATED CLAIM FOR EACH VIOLATION.
You are entitled to the return of all replaced parts, except warranty and exchange parts, but you must ask for them
in writing before any work is done. If you authorize work by phone, the shop must keep any replaced parts, and
make them available when you pick up the vehicle.

8/26/2016 9:33:22 AM

002479

Page4

 

 

The Habeas Citebook Ineffective Counsel Side
Advertise Here 3rd Ad
The Habeas Citebook Ineffective Counsel Side