ATTACHMENTB

UNITED STATES p:STRICr COURT
rOR

~Hi D~STRIC=

OF COLUMBIA

•

--------MARTHA WRIGH'!. e c a1.
P1.aintif!s,

Civil Accioll

v.

No. 00-293
r.O~~!ONS

CORTCP~TION

A..'BRICk.... ~

a1.,

et.

:-~is

FILED

(GKl

Of

AUG 2 ~ 2~Dl

rr.at.ter i.s be:cre che

COUI'!.

en the

~-tc:i-:.r.s

tG

D!.S:r.':"5S

!=la:':::';":!s'

JE;fenda::.:

C:)I::-:: ::io::$

C~r~·ol:at

ior:.

0:

Arner iea

\ "':CA" ~ .

I. !!AC'ltGRCUND

ra~es

a~d

t~r:..!;

ll!"isi::;

f:-c~

the 10:19 dist:a:-.ce

te:et:'h~!"".e

se!',.':.ce

Tr.e ·::'.:::'t s!.~::e!"el!· apt==e-:;.ate£ :he l:'l:.:;.~a.~~·;e and
:. :-:..:n.,;ghc !"..l: .: 0::::' ii:ut io:: ':: ror:-. .:(';:::: E. Er.S les. :.c-s;u: r A5S~'C i3:e
C.·e::~=5: =o~nse:.
;'~de=al C:::r.-.mU:1! =02 t io::,S COTTm..:.ss icr.. d!.!!" lng ':h~
tI.lJt '!.c·r-.s Hea r l::3 .

~ay

Plai::,cl.ffs

be clvi:ie-: i..:r:: :;"'0 9!'.ouPS: (1) :.::mates
.:.. .

: ani:.ly ,r.'=:Tbers .

." !

re~ipients

cf

i!'1!!".at.~

::al:s.

and

faCl~:::'e9

to

:~a~

faci2i~y'E

!n=ar~e=a:ed

inma~E9:

in

re~ur~,

C~

~eceives

a commission

The excl'.. sive dec.ling

te:-:pho:-.e

~s t.~rcugh

con":~'a:;ts

a co::ec: ca:l·only !eat-.;re. wh:.c:: :::herses tht!
In:nat;s can:1ot !"E·:ei·...e cal:!

f!"cn :n,:-:s.i:ie

:~e

:c::::li:y. a:1C !:£:;'ther

:r.mot.eSl ~OT

!e=ip:.e~,:s ,j~

~:~A 1.5 a ~r;.~:ate for-p::::::.: :;·:"!'I=.:>ra::"c·:1 "th~::h o?e:.·aCE3 e:.s:-::.y
p~:Ec·r:s

.=tat.e

a.:1C :3:.1; .;.r.

a:::t

!;::;a:

:..r:5":i:utlO:-.~
Ce:1':~:-

t:-te

.:

tw·e~:.y-=:.x.

ho~sing

eel,.

?ri~::!'.e~s:

._- ..
. . --····1

D.C.

:,cr::-a::ce

!\'ort. . . . ~as:. •

sta:es

~C'·le=:1ne::.:s.

.--.,

f

:~eN

:)1.:'=S~a.;1:'

Cer.t:-al.
~'2X~CO.

a:-::i

:.;'1 a9!.e=~en::s Tid::.!:'
c;:e~a.t.e9
~cu:·
A~i'Z='=-~·3 C~te:-.:ic:l

~:-.d

=W;I,s

Ceter..t;.:.;:

Dis:!"ic:

of

:e:::e=i
C~lcl":"':::':'4

reft:r.dar.~

:elep:.one c::-r:-,pa::ies are =>.~e~clji.1 Inc. : '\Ev~[=om··l .
a:-.d Te~eS1"ap~ :cmpc.·.:, {"AT;'!"":
~cr:cc:)!t
C::'"':'.r\U:1.i ::c.t; ~:·:a:
: ... _.
:. "M·::", ,
?:'oneer
:-elepho~.e
CCl'po:-a:;. ve
~\'?:c:l~e!""
ar.': ,::c:-al ':'e:ec=~:'\iJ.!'".. i=~:icr..s :'l~:t ('\:1::=5.: Tel :..ink") .

Ame:-i::..:-:,

• P!.a-.:::::f::; al:~ge, :~= exa:"':F~!!
=aii. a ?!a1~t~~f ~~$t pay ~~
~hen $.!S ;er ~~~ute tte=ea~:~r.

diita~:~
a~d

T~:e:;r.~nE

I

t:iat :0::i~~~i3~

3.

:--:'::

t:'I;,ical

surcna:ge

or

:C:1g·
54.00.

!:ut",ate :a1.1&

;;er.nittec to use c:.her :ong-d=.star.ce

~!'"e

ca=!":.~rs

c:'

•
i~ltia:ed

calla. s
a~lege

Pla.:n:if!s

tt:ac

:~ese

exclus:.v€ 'ieal:.r.g

':C:-a::-~C~S

ha .... e

! :tT::' ~y :--:embe!"'s 2:r.d cC'..!r.se:.
t~~se

c~n~ra~~s.

cover: ':19
a:a

::~~

=o~~

: r:.vo 1 ved i!'! prov icing p:'lone sE:!"Vice

?ri~aril: :~sign~=

rat-ea anc :'lg:t

Ccf~ndar.t8

tc en:ich

:c::::niss~cn

fees;

a~

(:~rou9h

the eXFense

c:

_..I

irr..ateE,

the infla:ed

th'! !'"ecipi.e!1:s

:~

jnmia:e ·:a::'s.

la..,l'.

~ r::i:t" e.'{e.::!Fle, ?~al:1tif:s a~:ege :hat t~1ey Gre p:-c::i::ir:::ed fr:rr~
\;'sir.g calli:1g :-=a:u:-es st.:c~ as cl,:·e.:-t. aciia: d1a: a:-::..::::::!, a::.d : ..;::: ..
I

-;=

IJ;-'.i:::r. \o.'c:~:d :-~$:.;l:. in r=t~.!! c.::ns!-jer-a~:y =~eap'!:r
t~"".-1.r. :hoe ':::l::==: =3.J.:-oor.:/ :-a:es ,.,c:.r.da::~-:! l:::l t!1e cx::'·.s!'\'e :!'2.a!~~5
~cn:r:l';:!I.
;.e~ ?:'S.' 0;p':-, !.': Li c::;:~~:. ~f\ 9-~5, ,~ ':;~~-t:.,
;!. ..
7,.
7h-e"l alit: ~:lege t!"-.at :::eb.;. card!: a=~ r~:..t. i=<e=~:.~ted ir.. ~.oS':.

C!)L!.E:C:-, a:l

'1.

C;A !~~l!:t:ies. e,,'oer: tI:.ou;h de:':.: ·::ar'::s are ~-e:;'.,;.:'a!!.::lJ ',;sed· ~n
F-r:sons ,j~·e:·~,:p:~ by t~e :!ceral E'J:-eau of P=ise·:ts.
£'!e P!s.
(!p~ r:1. !x. A {":ec~=~l 3\.:rea'J of Priso:-.s Me:-:v::ran=l.... ri..,)
I

3

..

_-_

A

relh~:.

of

:he

..

- - - - - - - - - - - - - _..

:·~~r13:..:l:

_--_ - - - - - - - - - - ..

.

sh:uld :'.:: De c,:,sr.";:ssed !cr !!"i:'..:.re t~ S~4:e a

"

:::orr.pla~:::

:n'Jst

:,e ;;:resuor.ed

to be

true

and !ibera::y

III. :C:SC'C1SSZ0Jl:

:r,f:

,~er:'I:S

c:

::,:8 case.' );.meng other

things. they -..Irge tha: :he

ref~~da~t~

~:oba!.
AT&~,
a..,C: P~cne"r assert :ha: ~::I';
s11~·.:.lQ =e ~i~:nissed for l!lci< 0: pe=so;:al : l.!ris:i.:.ctlofu
:eir;:;da":",::. A~5e-: l:SC ass€r:s -=:.Clt the ;,c::()r. si;c.uld !)e di!'lrrissed
!lg.1i~a!.: :t fer iad.:.l..re :~ joi!'> 3r.. :~dia?ensable p3r~y.

(:'~~:a:':.-.~

4

.

'

si:u~:iC:"l:9

",·:-.e:e a

::;:-:.sd~cti:-·:t O'ler

has

CO'.J:::-t

We5te=~

See
55.

c.;

j·.!!':s~':c:icn

co :eta:.::

disad~an:aged.
~~.

507

:~

~.S.

No :-igid

t~

Referra:

::956:.

or:

dis~iss

.

~he

~

t~e

a ::la!.::"'. ::- ::ase !:iut

F3C::ic R.R.

:c ..

352

ase!1=:~

adr..in!s:.=-ati ve

':'ce.s ::'::

un~.airly

:he pa=ties would r-.=:: :,e
case

w!~~out pre~~~!c~.

~.S.

Reit~::-

v.

258. 268 (1952).

f~=.ula

e;xisu fer a;lply::'r.g the

dcc~:-ir.e

c!

p:-~lf.a:y,

ju:-is:iice::':::l.
tr.e
a~d

a;ivan~a;:s

..

~r

~

0: allo\J,.'ing a:-. age::::y :::: apply its expart

a.

C~rnmu~ication'

f:lr
S~rv:ce.

bss;;pation. !n ... , %5 F.2d

ld.

-!\t

v.
l~:B

Exc!:ance

:n.':.

Ci:-. 1392).

'';3.+:-1 ~'=

!xpen; j:.:d;;men:

1l2C.
~,.,-­
...... :'2 ...

A.

j~d~ent

Ad.,an~.ge.

P~a:::::ffs'

cl3.:"7:.3

are

be:s":

of Agency Ex;>ertille

5

.

--.----_._---------------

·--.~

...

--~

....

--~

...

a:e

•

::a.:es.

u.s.c.
:!",Jst

See

~.c~,

!!1C". V. t".s"

325

: :-"..lrir.g t!"i.e to:ctic;:s li~ar.:.n9. tl:e ,:C~=~ as;'.ed ;':a.:r.t!.f:5'
c-:-·J.nsel :~ ~:c·p:;se a. r€~dy t:ha~ ~1cl.,;~d =e,:i!'es~ -:he i:-<~r:..=; 1.n t::.!.~
caSl!.
ieg ';~9·...i.s~ 5 t 2C~: ,~c"::.c::s :ie3r::.r.:; :-rans.c~:.;: ~":.lO:':lC'!':.!

=.:

Hea~i:'1; Tr."')
at 7.4!17~2E::i.
!'he !n.!.~tll.~)~
,::c"..:::1se!
.. t..I
a~:::.c\.!:a:e !l rerr;!cy ':hat. :r.:.s :"o\.:.:;c :-::c..:!d e!"~te~ de::".c:':s':r!.:es ,:!':.e
-:t\~l-!!xit:c" cf ':he ~ssUo!.i in-,r:;"J'e:o !.nd :ne :1'!ec !c= :-:: ,;',,!!.e.anr:e. -::t'~
he',,- bes: t~ reso:v~ :i19 ma::'!r.

•

or

:c,r:.t.r~r:~
~·:?cen~

~lai'("J':i:f.e·
=~:r:ter:t:o:1.
~he
;~-::r!d:::~nt ;~-£. v, FTC. 20~
~O;;3 ::0: a:!ec:: :!;.e ~c,:·s ju:::,s":.ict..!on

~£:::is.l::;n

::,:'-. 11.:':";,.
:'~::s
::f

roo

:r.

~C':

-::-.'!:

!J.e. C:rc',,::':'g

F'.::: '750 i!:i.C.
::: ::'e=~:ate :::-:I!

:o:-~3 .. :i:.!,:a.r.c!t ~a=:!!r'
O.C. ~irc"':l.t :i-=:::u;ier:.
;=ch!~:ted :~e ~~:i~; ~: :ariffs ;~r lc~;-d~$~a~ce c~r~ler!f ~~t !~
!'\:
~~:~:e:! ,:i"'.~ FCC" I s:.a':olto:-y ~',;~r t:o e:-.st.:::e t!:a.t ::h.e rates. e!
c:.b.cae ~.a::=lr.:::; ~=e reas:'>nac~e !.:-.d ::.::;n-:h.scrlr;~!". atcry. S'!@ ~:~t:'C'::.s

Wi;·

Hear~~~

=~.

ac

~:9-2C:

1:::~12.

s.. cor.:L

5~rvi=e.

i:--.:::'..::i:.:-.g

cor:rec,::,cl~al
cc~!.:':'n:.1~s
t!;,:

to ,::'::,s.l.:ier the"

t~at;,.;

Qf $;,:1=4

F.e.C.

b!l:eo

!:o~ice

R:d.

pa:t~

;274

1es~.;,~ Q~

~a.r;v

~;.llerna;'dn9,

(-=el~

£~

Jt.:n~

~t:ket

~C!ecjlni=19

1996)

:he

priscr. coctexc

::>ef.

A7&T'

:~

= M;:,t.

S~c~r.d

Report end Order, CC

Oc=ke~

,:~e::efo:::·.:

!'-.as ;t::..ready

deve:O~£od

'_r.c.e:.'j.;f:'::'9 :.e:ephcne

Econom.;.ca-~

f:~!ic:ices

:.he

:;.eces~ar!

tcchno~cs:n,~.

a:1d rll::;;?S,.

an~

::h'!

S\?' ;n

Nc .. S:!-7? t
':!)

fo~

re~..;ire

s.~~~~ty

to :;:'ism.;:.ss); :r; ;hl
Cll;'lg~

13 F.C.C.

No. 92-71 ire!. Jana
bench!!"." r kll

:0

'Or.. ~he

CC

of "811:(100 Part-,' fre:eren;;e rcr :r.teb!a.:i 0-

Red 6:22,

iti

p. ;a114.

For !=1:=,ll;a

of Prcpoeed

rr~fe~er.ee

s~y; . . . .:.C'e

irE.ate ca.lling s~r.~::':~s.

?r=!er-r,ce

reascn;i: ~.\t:tac:-.ed as ~x. 18 t'J
~a;,:er

:.e:ep:-_on~

of ir:.r."\6t't

!nc.$ed, t:te F:C h.:as co:,.. s;':lerec a:lo

:.::s:i~w:,:,o:'lo.~:.

Sec::nd Further
:1

~\:;,e prc".~::'sion

or

::ate

s:;>e:ial:ted s-xr,e::"Z.:'se

!:l:e te:ephon,e
feas:.h111~Y

;";'ldUS:.=y';3

c! .a.lce:"'::'H!ti-.;e

t:hc'ne $j",s:e"!':s !.:"Ult p::oV'!.de adequate S~C\!:,:.,:y r:"Ieas"..::res.
:~:..::ci.

t~~e

TCC

r.as

:~e

expli=it

8

$tati.!~ory

authc::.ti~

to

~~--

- - - - - - - - - - - - - ...- - - ....

-.~.-

....-

- - ... - - - ....- - - - ... - ..- -

•

ac:icr.,.

10 the Mata: of

Reclass~;ica:icn

l~ F.~.C.

the

:he

D;.V

Con:pensltion

this caae-

the reaacnacleness

l-Se: calls, or dire:::t

• :-he. F::-: has
::or.:.e~:s
·:i~tertr'.:"ni!:j ::ta':

:"!"'.!"'..l.':e

0:

r .. !e;h;mc

of

"hID
, tUI

Red. 706S

~~e~jings i~

oet2t cards,

!"'t:leJrent;at~Q'

exe-:~ige1

t;,:,s

0:

:nrr~te

:e:erh;ne

:Ual serv:C'iSS .

!iL:t~O::-lt~l

!!"!

ana ::.g~'.ls.

~.:::l'"

:::r se'J'eral. c\!caa!cns,
Fo:' exi,!""'':; ... 'ti. ::ll!
AT&.":" s prac';;.ice of ;:,vl~ii v::::-..;;r.e -;isco'.!!"'.,:;s

s.!.:.~le

::ust!)'rl!::! ~'::o have !.):ge ='=·'r...~;J..'1i~a::.cns :-~.ee::!s t:u! rl.:;,t:
;:,::up :Jf Cus:.=rners who t'!'.is~t pe able :'c ?QCl ::he:.r t:~~cs
?::-::.!-l:'l:itf!cL S,e M::·tic:'l8 Hea::=..:li :'=. a: 2:-: 2-1~,

,I

FC~

.. _

~c !i
~'3.S

..

o!

?r~s.,ners

Friends

t:!-.e

•

~a:es

ha~~·e

already

re!2~red

S\.!C:l

:ha!le:".ges ':0
Se~

dCt:t.rine c-f pr:;r.ary jurisdict:ion.

In
ra~es;.

£ll.:...d

i;'t

A

t~e

Fe.:

-9 .• t.rsbe:r-y

:ietermi~i:lg

V.

:.~e

I: :;;,;-qis.

fairness

pe.;t go ;:th:: srcJ"';is, Ars:;..;rry ..... :1" ir..;;s~ 244

fer

=.1:

the

r \.'-the ::cre

'..:.nder

=~sc: "6

~ S::'..l€S

::' ":'hf! U:i::.ty :c~sume=s' .~ct:..:n Ne:. ....cr~ ;"C'-:J'\.o~', also :l.l~c
::ornme:-:.ts in ~,he FCC's proceedlr:s anj 3dv:5~d tr.e F':C ti:at .:.t
";:;::e:-.::ly ur.der:':;·:Jjc a ceta:':~d SlX r:tor.:.r:. lr~Ve5tig3.:i:-n L~:: ::-.e
c:.l;:;lg c:r3::::.ces o! c:::l:lec: calls t!:,st ':l=igi:-,a:~ fret': ::::!.'!':!:'ct::'-::-.a:
fa:.il:!.::es. '"';:.A...'l se'.:ks ~o 3h~=~ "::'9 ::"::0:':-193 ~':''':,:.~ c'::e [FCC} anc
t.c ed';.:at':! 'tne :~::: staff a9 to pa=a;:ic'.lr.t. :,sS'Jes a:. =r:a:~e i:'. tr.:.s
?:.:·-:eed:'ng,·
cc

:>c.~ite:.

Nc.

:~!

!je!s.'

9€·:i.29

?e~:y.

·:f:l~:::

Ex

7 i"Cper.in;

':une 21, 19-;:;)'.

10

C'ol'!"mer:~s

=.! "J:J.t:'."

•
II.

U:l~fonnity

t:!:a: apF·l"i

=0

::,:!lect ::alls made ';)'f inrr.e.tes. 47 :I.S.C.

expla!.::.ed

en

~~e ra~e3 a~d te~.$

!!.

=is.~

a::ove.

pa~ties

As

t::a:. ar..y

jc:.::Eng

c:

de~:si=n

tr.~!ie ::,~':ter=.

ref=eSe:lti:lg inr..ates

JE:~~cian:s'

~

2C3

~a;

.

are prese;-.:l:,

arrange~ent~

'folo'w!:-: be ::lCC:":..Slster.t wi:h t.he decis:'c:ls

SeE Je:E.· ?eFly, Ex. S ·,C'.etcher ';06, 2::'10

CO~I: obse:-·ies th3:' ':)';.her non-~~ ~rison :a~l:it:ies haole
di:~ercr..: :a:llng .:.rr;:ige~~r::$ tr.,at pro~/:d~ :~r hotI-. l:·'l:er
r!:!.:-e5 a:-~d. ~deq1..a":e sec-"::-lty :..-=as"":'::-1i!9,
See e. ~"
~is.' ':fP·:n .• ~x.
-. r... F~ceral ~·.!rea'.l of ?::-iS~:l Me:nc"; ;::ha!'ge :'::>r de!:i: ..:a:"C5 ir..
?'ede::-al 2u:"eau :f :risc'::'s !s S.!5 ~cr rr..i:1uce,\. The Court exp~·.:ts

;: 7be

"..!s£d

snd ?:".::icipates that :he ?C: ·.... ill exa:;:ine -=his clspa=ity in :he
=~~r~e ~f

i~s ~=~senc

?roc~e~!~g.

1\

~.~corC::.:-:s~i"

:n !avor

~!

~

t::e Ccurt cC!"lcL"::Jes ·t:h3t u::i :orrn: -:'1' .:c::cc.:-ns C'cur.se!

F:C

referra:~

CC~8tituticna!

•
Issues

-=

geek

:':.c,:::- .:ne

-" :..lrlSc.:.c:. i. or.
=~:-.~t:

co;:)

i"C '.JC i

,:,~.al

~"bsc:·...::e

e":en a

te:ephone

argt.:ins

t.t:~ t

s

:ho".J.j,d

~c=

has

the':"::-

::·e

reec·:ved

:~9·..11a~·~rj· :::cnt~xt

';9:4:-S~:5.

~ast..

~

Second. all cf P:a:ntif:s'

bott',

ins iCE

..........

C-"_'"

~h .. s

};y

"i~::ial

cons~it~~ic~a:

ir. the

:-a;.se.£

~:..:.r;'s:j':'ction.

isst.:e :nay '.... arrant an

cor.s:dered

;.:r:a::e~;e

~~a~

!:ar tc i:\voki':"'.9 pri:nal'il'

'.:~~st:t"..!~ion31

the

at

.:..s:s~e

by

aoc

~akeM

~ssues

Hot.:'o:-.S

by the

Heari:-;,~

cor.sci:uti~nal

CI.!t

s:'de

t~e

':"n

5im:.lar

Tr.

clai~

::~:.son

faci::..:ies.
·.:::'arge,

an.:' i !

?rih:ar~i

::.1:-:sdic:ian of the

ex~c::y

t~.e

:i-pe

c:

--- an::
t' ,_,,-

=!.alri: t !"la,

fa~:Sf

s:ate r=Sl.::a-::r-::.

wi '::-.:.::
s~!'

".

:h~
~.,

~

11

--------,--------------------

•
"The FCC'S

:;.~
cla!~,

Fel

eX3:"",p~et

?:a!ntiffs

in o:-ce!; to p:revai:'

first

O~ thei~ F~=s~

ce~onstrace

that

j;f!".enciment

ex~lus:ve
b~twee.-:;. >-~e!"'...da:lts ,!,~9'';':t, :":l ~a':.es
which are 110 ex,:rbicant that reaso!'lab:e acce!<s :0 ;t:e ~ele;;:t:cne is
:ie~iee. ~ J9h1j';m "I, c:,:ifo"';»ia, 20"': r .3d l!SO; 656
\3;:!" ::..:.
20G~;· (=:stes :'lC~ "s:> exc,rb:.'::a!"!t d to de:'1Y ;laintj,:f pbon;: access!;
St~&~dr,.c v. >i~y
He:foa, 791 F.2d i~4# 7~' (9: A :ir. l~BS! (as
l:::H:S as 1 irr.i ~a~i~r:3 O-:'l phcne acceSA are !"c:asona~le, t~er-:! is' ':'::l

d~alir.S9 CC':'lt:-a,C~3

~ust

ch~

en':e:red in:Q

0:

?i-rst ,~:m~r...:itr.e::':.t. "tlo::'aC::'on)j W~shi;;ctor; v. (:.enQ, 3: :.~:i lC;:;~t 1:';~
.6t:: :!:-. 1':1S4) \i!".rr.~t:e has ::..: ::!.9ht ~o '..!n.i.imicco ~e:"!F:;cr:.e \:s-! and
:ele?!:c::'le ,;::.::ess ~s s1.:."JeC':' to ::"b.tlonal l:.n'::'ta-:.;'cr'!s ir. ~~:::'!' ~f
s~ct.:::-:ti~ i~ttrt's:.:

!=

F!ai:;tt~;s wer"!! t:o :.ake such a ;:-lo·,dr.:g 1 :h!9
:r.$.:,,"~ hs;~s. to eva:uste whet: ..... e:- :.he: ct..:-::rer:: arr!\n,;er:-,an.:.

Cou!"t w~u1d
rl!$'.Jlt:'r:.g In
~he: ='\:'Cde'!'li;~; o! phor:1! a.C-:~SI i9 reasonably :e:a!':':~c :0 a legi:;:.-na!:e
?e-!':~l">iica! in:trest.
~ '!\;;':ter "'/. SAflev, ",02 t,T.:::. 75 ~1~5'!.

The F:: ~as ,::c::s~~ered and c::ntir:t;.es '=0 ·:or.sid.;r :actt:al .:.ss~es·
zea:-i:-.S "'n :~!.S gt:.esticr.. , suer. ~s ttle costs aS$j':i.;,tec w~th se::"'.f:'t'.s
it"lr.ate fil=_l.lt:lis. the lEV'e: o! bad deb: aS5:,cla:.e: \lji~h :.r:~..i~e
pa:·F:':~'r.e se:-vice Fro""tl~e="9. !actcrs prch;.:>i r. ing ;.!"'.e '..i..ee cf ~:::b!::
::.11-:--::'5.

hi _::. ~~

::'::e ::'..!~~en
~::~icn~.

C':'l

r~te~;::ayl!ret

and t:}-Ie

-:-!:lsi.:::::'=y o~

:,:~~!!r

.'

Afe!!!' the FCC :loes so, :c the ex:e::" :111::' c!:l::'

:he a:aency' S

ex;:,~rt

findings ir. ad:lresslng them.
$tates/

EllIS:

zoe:jt:ir: 1:9

u.s,

the exer::ise of adm.:.ni stratlve discre:! =!l.

Therefo:::-e. :.n

9r~se~ted

342

by

Yi~w

Fla:~~lff$'

of t::'e

fac~

cla~~&.

IJ

age:'lcies

that tr.e Court 'dc'.;ld bene!it

IV. C;:!NCl.!1SION

".

':nady9 Kess: ~
Jni:ed 5:~te~Jtis:=ict J~d3e

:!

.... as

:!":e c;:·::.:::
stay:ng :~~ =ase ~r ~:sm~5s~~; i: ~:t~~~:
:i.3ce:-n.s !'".:' :=rej".!di=--= t::- t::e ;:?r,;:'~s 1:":

ATTACHMENT C

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
MARTHA WRIGHT, et al.

Plaintiffs,
v.

Civil Action

.I

No.

00-293

(GK)

CORRECTIONS CORPORATION OP

FILED

AMERICA, et al.,
Defendants.

AUG 2 2 2001
NANCY MAYER WHITIlNG10N, CLERK

o

US DISTRICT COURT

R D Iii R

This matter is before the Court on the Motions to Dismiss
Plaintiffs'
Defendant

Complaint
Corrections

co~sideration

by

Defendant

Corporation

of the motions,

of

telephone
America

oppositions,

companies
("CCAN).

replies,

and
Upon

the Motions

Hearing held on August 9, 200!, and the entire record herein, for
the reasons stated in the accompanying Memorandum Opinion, it is
hereby
ORDERED, that the Motions to Dismiss the Con-plaint under the
doctrine of primary Jurisdict:on are granted; it is further
ORDERED, that this case is

diB~Bsed

without prejudice; it is

further
ORDERED,

that parties are directed to file the appropriate

pleadings with the FCC to

ens~re

lawsuit are presented to the FCC.

that the issues raised in this

G'~~~.

a~,P; ~1J1I j

Gladys Kess . r
•
United States District Judge

Date
COPIES TO:

Marie-Ann Sennett
D.C. Prisoners' Legal Services Project
1400 20 th Street, NW
Suite 117
Washington, D.C. 20036
Frank R. Volpe
Sidley & Austin
1722 Eye Street. NW
Washington, D.C. 20006

I

17

-

---_._----,----_.

-------------

,

ATTACHMENT D

r

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA .

)
)
)

MARTHA WRlGHT el 01.,
Plaintiffs,

l

CORRECTIONS CORPORATION OF
AMERlCA el al..

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

v.
,/
-'

DefendCJnts

Civil Action No.:
1:OOCV00293 (GK)

fiLED
NOV

5 ZOOI

1lANt:Y MAYfR WHlT1IHGION, CIBlI'
u.s. DISTRICT COURT

ORDER
This matter comes before the Court on Plaintiffs' Motion to Reconsider the Court's
decision dismissing this case with prejudice. Upon consideration of the Motion, it is by
the Court on

th~ay of ,N~¥ri~OOI' hereby

ORDERED, that the Motion be, and hereby is, GRANTED. The Court stays this
aclion and requests tlutthe paf1ies file a report with the Court on

!t{J (; .:;7c:"t: 1--

informing the Court oflhe status of proceedings before the Federal Communications
Commission.

.'

-_.

__ - _-,-_._------------------...

..

•
Copies To:
Marie-Ann Sennett (D.C. Bar No.'462200)
Eric R. Lotke (D.C. Bar No. 446706 )

D.C. PRISONERS' LEGAL SERVICES PROJECT
1400 20th Street. N. W., Suite 117

Washington. DC 20036
(202) 775-0323
Local Counsel for Plaintiffs

FranJc R. Volpe, Esq
Sidely" Austin
1722 Eye Street, N.W.
Washington, DC 20006
(202) 736-8366
Accepting Coun Orders on behalf of Defendants

2

- - - - - - - - _... _ - _....

-

ATTACHMENT E

--.~

..-

Public Correctional Policy on Inmate/Juvenile Offender Access to Telephones

Policy Stlltement:
Recognizing that \here is no constitutional right for inmates/juvenile offenders to ha....e ac,.~ss to
telephones. nonetheless consistent v,ith the requirements of sound conectional management,
inmates/juvenile offenders should have access to a range of reasonably priced telecommunications
services. Correctional agencies should ensure that:
A Contracts invo}vinglelecommunications services for inmatesljuvenile offenders comply with

all applicable SUIte and federal regulations;
B. Conaacts are based on rates and surcharges that arc comrnensUlllte \\ilb those charged to the
genenll public for like semces. AIiy deviation from ordinary consumer rates should reflect
actual costs associated with the prOvision of seme<>s in a correctional sening; and
C. Contracts for inmate/juvenile Qffender te!':communications services provide the broadest
range of calling options determined to be consistent with the requirements of sound
correctional manaiement.

Thi$ Public Corrt'Ctional Policy 1III-J,S unanimously OI.uLt:d by me Amcric3!l Con;ctional N::Ioc:iation Dc!~g1teAssembl)' ilt dlC Wimer
Conferonce in Nash,ille. DI .. ]:m. 24.2001.

P-24