Innocence Project of Tx Junk Science Dog Scent Lineups 2009

The Habeas Citebook: Prosecutorial Misconduct - Header
Innocence Project of Tx Junk Science Dog Scent Lineups 2009

• Topics: Sentencing, Wrongful Conviction
Download original document:
Brief thumbnail
This text is machine-read, and may contain errors. Check the original document to verify accuracy.
!
!

"#$!%&'()!*+(',-%!
!"#$%&"'()*%(*"+%,$-.)(*"

"
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!

"!#$%&'()!*%$+*,!-.!,/%!011+&%1&%!2*+3%&,!+4!5%6(#!
7+18(.9!:%$,%;-%*!<=9!<>>?!

!"#$%&'()*(+($,-..
!

#$%%!&'()*+,-./!01"$%!02,.3$'!2%!41$!5..2)$.)$!6-27$)4!2%!8$9(3!:56;8</!=-24$!
41"3!-$>2-4?!!56;8!"3!(!.2.@>-2%"4!2-A(."B(4"2.!)2C>-"3$D!2%!E2',.4$$-!'(=F$-3!(.D!
34,D$.43!=12!%".D!(.D!%-$$!"..2)$.4!>$-32.3!=-2.A%,''F!)2.E")4$D!2%!)-"C$!".!8$9(3?!
!
!
81"3!-$>2-4!"3!+(3$D!2.!-$3$(-)1!D2.$!+F!(!4$(C!2%!>$2>'$!=12!3>$.4!
1,.D-$D3!2%!12,-3!'2)(4".A!(.D!-$E"$=".A!4-(.3)-">43/!(-4")'$3/!(.D!4$)1.")('!-$>2-43?!
G(4('"$!H2$4B$'/!I9$),4"E$!J"-$)42-!2%!56;8/!(.D!G")*!K"'+(3/!(!41"-D!F$(-!'(=!34,D$.4!
(4!8$9(3!8$)1!L."E$-3"4F/!1$(D$D!41"3!$%%2-4?!!;41$-!4$(C!C$C+$-3!".)',D$D!34,D$.43!
M")1($'!N)1.$"D$-/!&-(.D2.!M2,.4/!O-"34".!O(C".3*"/!0(41$-".$!P1"4=2-41!(.D!
HF(.!&-2=.?!
!
!
N>$)"('!41(.*3!A2!42!(442-.$F3!H$9!I(3'$F/!=123$!'(=3,"4!(A(".34!6"*$44!(.D!
241$-3!1(3!>(E$D!41$!=(F!%2-!(!.$=!>,+'")!,.D$-34(.D".A!2%!D2A@3)$.4!'".$,>3/!(.D!
J$-$*!NC"41/!=12!D"D!(.!$.2-C2,3!(C2,.4!2%!-$3$(-)1!".42!41"3!(-$(!".!(.!$%%2-4!42!
$D,)(4$!D$%$.3$!'(=F$-3!2.!12=!42!%"A14!41"3!7,.*!3)"$.)$!".!)2,-4?!!J-?!Q(--F!MF$-3/!
(.!$D,)(42-!(.D!-$3$(-)1$-!%-2C!R,+,-.!L."E$-3"4F/!('32!D$3$-E$3!3>$)"('!41(.*3!
%2-!1"3!".3"A14!(.D!A,"D(.)$!D,-".A!41$!>-$>(-(4"2.!2%!41"3!-$>2-4?!
!
!
81"3!-$>2-4!=2,'D!.24!1(E$!+$$.!>233"+'$!="412,4!41$!34$-'".A!)2.4-"+,4"2.3!
2%!4123$!'(=F$-3!=12!1(E$!B$('2,3'F!-$>-$3$.4$D!41$"-!)'"$.43!(.D!(AA-$33"E$'F!
)1(''$.A$D!41$!,3$!2%!D2A@3)$.4!'".$,>3!".!41$!)2,-43?!!81$3$!'(=F$-3!".)',D$!N1"-'$F!
&()),3@Q2+$'/!N4$E$.!S"'+$-4/!&"''F!H(E*".D/!(.D!I-")!N,.D$?!81$-$!(-$!,.D2,+4$D'F!
241$-!(442-.$F3!%"A14".A!41"3!A22D!%"A14?!!M(.F!41(.*3!(-$!2=$D!42!41$C!(3!=$''?!
!
!
81$!8$9(3!0-"C".('!J$%$.3$!Q(=F$-3!R332)"(4"2./!41-2,A1!"43!6-$3"D$.4!
N4(.'$F!N)1.$"D$-/!1(3!3,>>2-4$D!(.D!$.)2,-(A$D!56;8T3!$%%2-43!%-2C!41$!+$A"..".A?!!
81$!8$9(3!0-"C".('!J$%$.3$!Q(=F$-3!R332)"(4"2.!"3!D$$>'F!)2CC"44$D!42!-$342-".A!
>,+'")!)2.%"D$.)$!".!41$!8$9(3!)-"C".('!7,34")$!3F34$C?!54!3,>>2-43!41"3!-$>2-4!(.D!(''!
$%%2-43!42!+-".A!3)"$.4"%")!E('"D"4F!42!%2-$.3")!$E"D$.)$!,3$D!+F!>2'")$!(.D!
>-23$),42-3?!

!

"!

!"#$%&'(&)'*!%*!+&
&
&
&
",-./01234252.67!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#
&
&
8'9&+)%*!&$:*%;<+=&!"#$%&"'()*%(*"+%,$-.)(*"
"
"
$%&'()*+&"(%#,%)#-./'."/0!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1!2#
#
#
34,&#"5#6*%7#8+"/%+/911111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111112#
#
#
6*%7#8+"/%+/:#;/<,5#8&=>/!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11?#
#
#
@(A#8+/%&#B.")/%+/#,%)#C8+/%&#D"%/*E5F!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!G#
#
#
;4/#8+"/%+/#(H#8+/%&#D"%/*E5!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1I#
#
#
;4/#6*%7#(H#8+/%&#D"%/*E5!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!J#
#
#
;4/#8&',%A/#,%)#K0H*>#L,'//'#(H#M/"&4#N"7/&&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1O#
#
#
8(P/#L(%+>*5"(%5#KQ(*&#8+/%&#B.")/%+/!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!2G#
#
#
34,&#R,5#&(#S/#@(%/!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1112I#
#
#
#
#
#
">>2.3?,27&
&
&
">>2.3?@&"=&B<E/'&#T/E('&5#,%)#KHH"),."&5!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11;,Q#K&
&
&
">>2.3?@&#=&N"7/&&#B)*+,&"(%,>#S,+7A'(*%)!!!!!!!!!!!!!!111;,Q#S&
&
&
">>2.3?@&)=&KHH"),."&#(H#U"+&('#3"5%/'!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!;,Q#L&
&

!"#$%&'()$*+(',-%.$!"#$%&"'()*%(*"+%,$-.)(*$
$
+()/"!,&)+"($0(!$"1'/1+'2$
!
!
#$%!&'%!()!*+&,-!'./%,.%0!12!3(4/.%!5,6!37('%.&8(7'!/,!#%95'!/'!5,!(,:(/,:!
/,+&'8/.%;!!<(=$%7%!/'!8$/'!>(7%!(1?/(&'!8$5,!/,!8$%!:(?%7,>%,8@'!&'%!()!*'.%,8!
4/,%&3'0A5!375.8/.%!8$58!/'!$533%,/,:!8(652!8$7(&:$(&8!8$%!'858%;!!
!
!
#$%!3&73('%!()!8$/'!7%3(78!/'!8(!'&>>57/B%!8$%!7%'&48'!()!(&7!/,?%'8/:58/(,!
/,8(!8$%!&'%!()!8$/'!*'./%,8/)/.!%?/6%,.%;0!!C(7!7%5'(,'!8$58!=/44!1%!%9345/,%6!1%4(=D!
8$%!&'%!()!8$/'!8%'8/>(,2D!3578/.&45742!12!8$%!E858%@'!'857!%93%78!F%3&82!G%/8$!H/-%88D!
$5'!4%6!8(!=7(,:)&4!577%'8'D!/,6/.8>%,8'!5,6!.(,?/.8/(,';!!I8!=/44!.(,8/,&%!8(!6(!'(!
&,4%''!/8!/'!'8(33%6;!!J&7!5/>!/,!3&14/'$/,:!8$/'!7%3(78!/'!8(!$%43!>5-%!8$58!$533%,;!
!
!
#$%!)(44(=/,:!8(3/.'!57%!.(?%7%6!/,!8$/'!7%3(78K!
"; L$58!I'!*M&,-!E./%,.%0N!
O; M&,-!E./%,.%!/,!#%95'!
P; F(:!E.%,8!Q?/6%,.%!
R; F(:!E.%,8!Q?/6%,.%S!#$%!E./%,.%!
T; F(:!E.%,8!Q?/6%,.%S#$%!M&,-!
U; #$%!E875,:%!5,6!V=)&4!W57%%7!()!F%3&82!G%/8$!H/-%88!
X; L$58!Y5'!8(!Z%!F(,%!
!
!!
230)$+%$45,(6$%&+'(&'78$
!
!
Q?%,!1%)(7%!8$%!8%4%?/'/(,!'$(=!*WEI0!1%.5>%!3(3&457D!+&7/%'!5,6!+&6:%'!$5?%!
8%,6%6!8(!1%4/%?%!=$58!*'./%,8/)/.!%93%78'0!'52!/,!.7/>/,54!.5'%'A%'3%./5442!/)!8$%'%!
*%93%78'0!57%!3(4/.%!())/.%7'!(7!37('%.&8/(,!=/8,%''%';!!J,%!'8&62!)(&,6!8$58!*51(&8!
(,%![&578%7!()!+&7(7'!=$(!=%7%!37%'%,8%6!=/8$!'./%,8/)/.!%?/6%,.%!1%4/%?%6!8$58!$56!
'&.$!%?/6%,.%!1%%,!51'%,8D!8$%2!=(&46!$5?%!.$5,:%6!8$%/7!?%76/.8'A)7(>!:&/482!8(!
,(8!:&/482;0"!!I,!8$%!$5,6'!()!5!'-/44%6!37('%.&8(7D!'./%,8/)/.S'(&,6/,:!8%'8/>(,2!)7(>!
5,2!'(&7.%D!,(!>588%7!$(=!)75&6&4%,8D!.5,!1%!3452%6!8(!:7%58!675>58/.!%))%.8!5,6!
=/,!.(,?/.8/(,';!
!
!
H7('%.&8(7'!$5?%!85-%,!)&44!56?5,85:%!()!8$%!:&44/1/4/82!()!+&7(7'!5,6!8$%!
=/44/,:,%''!()!.(&78'!8(!544(=!8$%!&'%!()!8$%'%!8%.$,/[&%';!!I,!.5'%!5)8%7!.5'%D!
37('%.&8(7'!$5?%!&'%6!3$(,2!*%93%78'0!=/8$!4/884%!(7!,(!875/,/,:!(7!%6&.58/(,D!)54'%!
7%'&48'!)7(>!'$(662!451'!5,6!6&1/(&'!*8$%(7/%'0!=/8$!,(!15'/'!/,!)5.8!8(!:%8!
.(,?/.8/(,';!!#5-%,!8(:%8$%7D!8$%'%!51&'/?%!375.8/.%'!$5?%!.(>%!8(!1%!-,(=,!5'!8$%!
&'%!()!*+&,-!'./%,.%;0!!#$%!&'%!()!8$/'!*%?/6%,.%0!/'!,(8!4/>/8%6!8(!8$%!.(&787((>K!45=!
%,)(7.%>%,8!5:%,./%'!$5?%!.(>%!>(7%!5,6!>(7%!8(!7%42!(,!/8!/,!>5-/,:!577%'8'!5,6!
:%88/,:!/,6/.8>%,8';!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

"!GQ\\]!^;!H]_QGD!CJ_Q<EIW!EWIQ<WQ!`<FQ_!EIQaQK!#YQ!WYV\\Q<aQE!JC!CJ_Q<EIW!\VZJ_V#J_IQE!V<F!#YQ!

^QFIWJS\QaV\!I<bQE#IaV#IJ<!E]E#Q^!R"R!cQ4'%?/%7!V.56%>/.!H7%''d!cOeeXd;!

!

"!

!
!
^5,2!3%(34%!'%,8!8(!37/'(,!1%.5&'%!()!+&,-!'./%,.%!$5?%!1%%,!/,,(.%,8K!()!
8$%!)/7'8!Oee!6%)%,65,8'!%9(,%758%6!8$7(&:$!F<V!/,!8$/'!.(&,872D!*UTf!=%7%!
.(,?/.8%6!58!4%5'8!/,!3578!(,!)75&6&4%,8D!&,7%4/514%D!(7!4/>/8%6!)(7%,'/.!'./%,.%;0O!!I,!
,%5742!544!()!8$('%!.5'%'!8$%!7%54!.7/>/,54!:(8!8$%!.$5,.%!8(!.(>>/8!>(7%!.7/>%'!
=$/4%!5,!/,,(.%,8!./8/B%,!=5'!4(.-%6!&3;!!#$/'!/'!=$2!8$%!&'%!()!3$(,2!'./%,8/)/.!
%?/6%,.%!37%'%,8'!5!7%54!8$7%58!8(!+&'8/.%!5,6!5!7/'-!8(!3&14/.!'5)%82!)(7!%?%72!./8/B%,;!
!
!
I,!OeegD!8$%!<58/(,54!_%'%57.$!W(&,./4!3&14/'$%6!5,!%9$5&'8/?%!7%3(78!51(&8!
8$%!&'%!()!)(7%,'/.!'./%,.%!5,6!%93%78!8%'8/>(,2!/,!.7/>/,54!.5'%';!!#$%!1((-S4%,:8$!
7%3(78D!>5,658%6!12!W(,:7%''D!/'!%,8/84%6!*E87%,:8$%,/,:!C(7%,'/.!E./%,.%!/,!8$%!
`,/8%6!E858%'K!V!H58$!C(7=576;0!!#$/'!45,6>57-!'8&62!=%,8!'(!)57!5'!8(!'858%!8$58!
%95::%758%6!5,6!/,5..&758%!8%'8/>(,2!12!%93%78'!$5'!*.(,87/1&8%6!8(!8$%!56>/''/(,!
()!%77(,%(&'!(7!>/'4%56/,:!%?/6%,.%;0P!!#$%!7%3(78!54'(!6%6/.58%'!5,!%,8/7%!.$538%7!
8(!*'87%,:8$%,/,:!(?%7'/:$8!()!)(7%,'/.!'./%,.%!375.8/.%0R!5,6!.(,.4&6%'!*8$58!%?%72!
%))(78!>&'8!1%!>56%!8(!4/>/8!8$%!7/'-!()!$5?/,:!8$%!7%4/51/4/82!()!.%785/,!)(7%,'/.!
'./%,.%!>%8$(6(4(:/%'!+&6/./5442!.%78/)/%6!1%)(7%!8$%!8%.$,/[&%'!$5?%!1%%,!37(3%742!
'8&6/%6!5,6!8$%/7!5..&75.2!?%7/)/%6;0T!!!
!
!
5,(6$%&+'(&'9$)':0%$%);*'$
!
!
C%=!'&.$!'8%3'!$5?%!1%%,!85-%,!/,!#%95'D!5,6!8$%!'/8&58/(,!$%7%!/'!%'3%./5442!
156;!!#5-%D!)(7!%95>34%D!8$%!.5'%!()!W5>%7(,!#(66!L/44/,:$5>D!=$(!=5'!%9%.&8%6!/,!
OeeR;U!!Y/'!.(,?/.8/(,!=5'!15'%6!(,!8$%!8$%(7/%'!()!5,!&,%6&.58%6!57'(,!*%93%780!
=$('%!/6%5'D!5..(76/,:!8(!5!7%54!)/7%!'./%,8/'8D!=%7%!>(7%!*.$575.8%7/'8/.!()!>2'8/.'!
(7!3'2.$/.'0!8$5,!8$('%!()!5!758/(,54!8$/,-%7;X!!a(?%7,>%,8!&'%!()!+&,-!'./%,.%!/,!
#%95'!$5'!,(8!1%%,!4/>/8%6!8(!1(:&'!57'(,!%93%78'K!%?%728$/,:!)7(>!)54'%!5&8(3'/%'h!
8(!/,5..&758%!$5/7!5,6!)/1%7!%?/6%,.%g!$5'!1%%,!&'%6!8(!.(,?/.8!3%(34%!/,!8$/'!'858%;!!
#$%!'.5,654!()!8$%!Y(&'8(,!.7/>%!451!/'!'857-!37(()!()!$(=!*:7(''42!>/'4%56/,:0!
7%3(78'!/,!8$%!57%5'!()!'%7(4(:2!5,6!F<V!8%'8/,:!$5?%!54'(!1%%,!&'%6!8/>%!5,6!8/>%!
5:5/,!8(!=/,!.(,?/.8/(,'!/,!#%95';"e!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
O!#YQ!I<<JWQ<WQ!H_JMQW#D!Oee!QiJ<Q_V#QFK!#JJ!^V<]!L_J<aC`\\]!WJ<bIW#QF!OOSOP!cOeeXd;!
P!<58/(,54!_%'%57.$!W(&,./4!()!8$%!<58/(,54!V.56%>/%'D!E#_Q<a#YQ<I<a!CJ_Q<EIW!EWIQ<WQ!I<!#YQ!`<I#QF!

E#V#QEK!V!HV#Y!CJ_LV_F!R!c#$%!<58/(,54!V.56%>/%'!H7%''d!cOeegd;!!!
R!!"#$58!"gPSO"U;!
T!!"#$58!hU;!
U!F5?/6!a75,,D!%&'()$*+$,'&-.$/'"$%-0(1$20-345-$(6$!6673-65$8(69D!#YQ!<QL!]J_GQ_D!E%38;!XD!Oeeg;!
X!!"#$
h!E%%!_(1%78(!E&7(D!:';;)-1$7<$($=(5>7)7?'15@1$8'1376"435$'6$A&(B-1$(6"$C74&51$7<$D-15$%-0(1D!<;];!
#I^QED!<(?;!OOD!"ggO;!
g!E%%!MI^!CIEYQ_D!CJ_Q<EIWE!`<FQ_!CI_QK!V_Q!ZVF!EWIQ<WQ!V<F!F`Q\I<a!QiHQ_#E!WJ__`H#I<a!W_I^I<V\!
M`E#IWQN!OOhSOg!c_&8:%7'!`,/?%7'/82!H7%''d!cOeehd;!
"e!E%%!I<FQHQ<FQ<#!I<bQE#IaV#J_!IEE`QE!CIC#Y!_QHJ_#!J<!YJ`E#J<!HJ\IWQ!FQHV_#^Q<#!W_I^Q!\VZ!cOeeUdD!
(B(')(E)-$(5!$883Kjj$36451/,?%'8/:58/(,;(7:j37%''7%4%5'%jeUeT""37%''7%4%5'%;36)!

!

O!

!
#(652D!3(4/.%!5,6!37('%.&8(7'!57%!&'/,:!2%8!5,(8$%7!-/,6!()!+&,-!'./%,.%!8(!
=/,!.5'%';!!#$/'!*'./%,.%0!/,?(4?%'!6(:!$5,64%7'!=$(!8%'8/)2!8$58!5!6(:!*8(460!8$%>!
=$(!=5'!37%'%,8!58!5!.7/>%!'.%,%!(7!=$('%!'%,8!=5'!(,!5!3/%.%!()!%?/6%,.%!12!
>5-/,:!'/:,54'!8(!8$%!$5,64%7!6&7/,:!5!*'.%,8!4/,%&3;0!!#$%!&'%!()!8$/'!*6(:!
=$/'3%7/,:0!$5'!1%.(>%!>(7%!5,6!>(7%!.(>>(,;!!H7('%.&8(7'!$5?%!8(&8%6!8$%!
*%?/6%,.%0!:5/,%6!)7(>!8$/'!375.8/.%!5'!1%/,:!!*5'!3(=%7)&4!5'!F<V!%?/6%,.%!8(!
'&33(78!5!.(,?/.8/(,;0""!!
!
!
L%!6%./6%6!8(!/,?%'8/:58%!8$%!&'%!()!8$/'!8%.$,/[&%!12!#%95'!())/./54';!!L%!
854-%6!=/8$!45=2%7'!=$(!$5?%!$5,64%6!.5'%'!/,!=$/.$!/8!$5'!1%%,!&'%6;!!!L%!
/,8%7?/%=%6!./8/B%,'!=$(!$5?%!1%%,!=7(,:)&442!5..&'%6!1%.5&'%!()!/8;!!L%!'8&6/%6!
8$%!'./%,8/)/.!4/8%758&7%;!!L%!5,542B%6!6(B%,'!()!875,'.7/38'!)7(>!.(&78!37(.%%6/,:';!!!
!
!
L$58!=%!4%57,%6!/'!'%8!(&8!1%4(=;!
!
!
!"#$%&'()$'1+!'(&'$0(!$4%&'()$*+(',-%7$
!
!
b/78&5442!544!6(:'!$5?%!5!$%/:$8%,%6!'%,'%!()!'>%44;"O!!#$/'!/'!=$2!8$%2!$5?%!
37(?%,!8(!1%!?%72!&'%)&4!/,!/6%,8/)2/,:!6/'8/,.8!(6(7'!4/-%!1(>1'!(7!67&:';"P!!V!6(:!
'>%44'!5!'.%,8D!157-'!(7!>5-%'!5!'/:,54!8$58!/8!$5'!6(,%!'(D!5,6!$/'!$5,64%7!,(8/.%'!/8;!!!
F(:'!.5,!54'(!1%!&'%6!8(!875/4!'.%,8'!)7(>!(,%!4(.58/(,!8(!5,(8$%7;"R!!#$%!*%?/6%,.%0!
/,!'&.$!.5'%'!/'!5!'/>34%!54%78!12!8$%!6(:!(7!8$%!358$!8$%!6(:!85-%'!8(!:%8!)7(>!(,%!
345.%!8(!5,(8$%7;!
!
!
V48$(&:$!8$58!-/,6!()!15'/.!/6%,8/)/.58/(,!.5,!1%!5))%.8%6!12!5!$('8!()!$5,64%7!
5,6!6(:!%77(7'D!8$58!/'!,(8!=$58!=%!57%!%95>/,/,:!$%7%;!!L$58!=%!57%!4((-/,:!58!57%!
.5'%'!/,!=$/.$!6(:!$5,64%7'!.45/>!8$58!8$%/7!6(:'!$5?%!6/'8/,:&/'$%6!1%8=%%,!
6/))%7%,8!(6(7'!5>(,:!3%(34%D!/6%,8/)/%6!(,%D!5,6!>58.$%6!/8!8(!%?/6%,.%!)7(>!5!
.7/>%!'.%,%;!!#$/'!/'!=$58!/'!()8%,!7%)%77%6!8(!5'!5!*'.%,8!4/,%&30!/,!8$%!)/%46!()!
*.7/>/,54!(6(7(4(:2;0!!I8!/'!5!>&.$!>(7%!.(>34%9!37(.%''!8$5,!3/.-/,:!(&8!5!35.-5:%!
()!67&:'!(7!)(44(=/,:!5!'.%,8;!!_%'%57.$!$5'!37(?%,!8$58!/8!7%[&/7%'!8$%!&'%!()!
[&54/)/%6!$5,64%7'!5,6!8$%!(1'%7?5,.%!()!,&>%7(&'!'5)%:&576'!/)!/8!/'!8(!37(6&.%!
%?%,!>57:/,54!7%'&48';"T!
!
!
V!*'.%,8!4/,%&30!'8578'!=/8$!8$%!6(:!1%/,:!/,87(6&.%6!8(!5!'.%,8!'5>34%!8$58!
$5'!1%%,!.(44%.8%6!)7(>!5!.7/>%!'.%,%!(7!5!3/%.%!()!%?/6%,.%;!!V)8%7!*:%88/,:0!8$58!
'.%,8D!8$%!6(:!/'!8$%,!37%'%,8%6!=/8$!5!'%7/%'!()!.(,85/,%7'!=/8$!'/>/457!'.%,8'!/,!
8$%>;!!#$%'%!'.%,8'!$5?%!()8%,!1%%,!85-%,!6/7%.842!)7(>!5!'&'3%.8!5,6!)7(>!(8$%7'!
>58.$/,:!8$%!:%,%754!6%'.7/38/(,!()!8$%!'&'3%.8;!!#$%!/6%5!/'!8$58!8$%!6(:!=/44!8$%,!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
""!E%%!D'6<&-+$,746"$A4')5+D!EV<!MVWI<#J!<QLE!#I^QED!F%.;!OeeX;!
"O!Z(1!W((8%!Q93%78!L/8,%''!_%3(78;!!E%%!V33%,6/9!V;!

"P!E%%$E57/!Y(7=/8B!5,6!\2,6'%2!\528(,D!F7$,(&G$/7?1$(&-$F5'))$*-15$/-5-357&1$7<$*7HE1D!LVEY;!HJE#D!

M&42!"gD!OeeT;!
"R!Z(1!W((8%!Q93%78!L/8,%''!_%3(78;!!E%%!V33%,6/9!V;!
"T!E%%!^57-!F%77D!D'5>$/7?$/-5-35'B-1G$8'15(I-1$C(6$J(;;-6D!<;];!#I^QED!F%.;!ORD!OeeO;!

!

P!

.(>>&,/.58%!8(!/8'!$5,64%7j(1'%7?%7!/)!8$%!'.%,8!8$58!/8!*:(80!8$%!)/7'8!8/>%!>58.$%'!
5!'.%,8!/,!(,%!()!8$%!.(,85/,%7';!!#$%!$5,64%7j(1'%7?%7D!'(!8$%!8$%(72!:(%'D!.5,!8$%,!
8%'8/)2!8$58!$/'!6(:!$5'!5..&758%42!3/.-%6!(&8!8$%!'.%,8!()!5!3578/.&457!3%7'(,!(7!
'&'3%.8;!!#$/'!8%'8/>(,2!/'!8$%,!37%'%,8%6!5'!5!*'./%,8/)/.!/6%,8/)/.58/(,0!/,!#%95'!
.(&78';!!I8!/'!.544%6!5!*'.%,8!4/,%&30!1%.5&'%!()!/8'!'/>/457/82!8(!5,!%2%=/8,%''!4/,%&3;!
!
!
#$%!&'%!()!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!$5'!1%.(>%!=/6%'37%56!/,!#%95';!!J,%!$5,64%7!/,!
3578/.&457D!F%3&82!G%/8$!H/-%88D!$5'!1%%,!7%'3(,'/14%!)(7!&,8(46!577%'8'!5,6!
.(,?/.8/(,'!8$7(&:$(&8!8$%!'858%;"U!!Y/'!=(7-!$5'!1%%,!375/'%6!5,6!'3(,'(7%6!12!
37('%.&8(7'!5,6!3(4/.%!)(7!2%57';!!#$%!#%95'!V88(7,%2!a%,%754@'!())/.%!$5'!
7%.(>>%,6%6!8$58!$%!1%!&'%6!=/6%42;!!V'!=/44!1%!'%%,D!$(=%?%7D!H/-%88@'!=(7-!/'!
'%7/(&'42!)45=%6!5,6!$/'!8%'8/>(,2!/'!$/:$42!'&'3%.8;!!
!
!
)3'$%&+'(&'$"<$%&'()$*+(',-%$
!
!
Y&>5,'!$5?%!1%%,!&'/,:!8$%!'&3%7/(7!'.%,8!51/4/8/%'!()!6(:'!)(7!8$(&'5,6'!()!
2%57';"X!!#$%!)&,65>%,854!37(14%>!/'!8$58!6(:'!5,6!8$%/7!$5,64%7'!57%!,(8!54=52'!
7%4/514%!=$%,!/8!.(>%'!8(!>5-/,:!.(>34/.58%6!6/'8/,.8/(,'!1%8=%%,!$&>5,!'.%,8'A
8((!>&.$!:&%''=(7-D!'&::%'8/(,D!5,6!'&1+%.8/?/82!.5,!.(>%!/,8(!3452;!!V48$(&:$!5!
7(&:$!:&%''!>52!1%!:((6!%,(&:$!/,!'(>%!'/8&58/(,'D!/8!/'!.4%5742!,(8!%,(&:$!8(!
+&'8/)2!5!.(,.4&'/(,!8$58!5!3%7'(,!=5'!58!5!3578/.&457!4(.58/(,!58!5!:/?%,!8/>%!5,6!
8$&'!.(>>/88%6!5!.7/>%;!
!
!
I,!7%.%,8!6%.56%'D!5!=$(4%!1(62!()!'./%,.%!$5'!%?(4?%6!8$58!6%54'!=/8$!$(=!
5,6!&,6%7!=$58!.(,6/8/(,'!5!875/,%6!6(:!5,6!$5,64%7!.5,!>5-%!'&.$!.(,.4&'/(,';!! !!
!
!
H(4/.%!5:%,./%'!/,!8$%!<%8$%745,6'!$5?%!4%6!8$%!=52!/,!6%?%4(3/,:!8$/'!
'./%,.%;!!V)8%7!>5,2!2%57'!()!87/54D!%77(7D!5,6!8$%!5334/.58/(,!()!'./%,8/)/.!>%8$(6'!
8$%2!$5?%!.(>%!&3!=/8$!5!=(7-/,:!'%8!()!7&4%'!8$58!:(?%7,!8$%!&'%!()!'.%,8!4/,%&3';"h!!!
!
!
#$%'%!7&4%'!:(?%7,!8$%!=52!8$58!8$%!/,/8/54!'.%,8!/'!.(44%.8%6!5,6!$(=!/8!/'!
'8(7%6D!$(=!8$%!'.%,8'!/,!8$%!4/,%S&3!57%!.(44%.8%6!5,6!'8(7%6D!$(=!8$%!4/,%S&3!'.%,8'!
57%!45/6!(&8!)(7!8$%!6(:D!=$(!.5,!$5,64%!8$%!6(:!58!?57/(&'!+&,.8&7%'D!=$58!-/,6!()!
7%5.8/(,!'$(&46!1%!(1'%7?%6!)7(>!8$%!6(:D!5,6!'(!)(78$;"g!!#$%!7&4%'!57%!15'%6!(,!
2%57'!()!>%8$(6/.54!(1'%7?58/(,!5,6!7%'%57.$;!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

"U!E%%!#75,'.7/38!()!H7%87/54!Y%57/,:!58!PX!cb(4&>%!"dD!E858%!?;!M5'(,!E>/8$!cOeeXdk!\%'4/%!L/41%7D!

J(6")-&1@$C&-"'E')'5+$K4-15'76-"$'6$C74&5D!bIW#J_IV!VFbJWV#QD!M&42!"OD!Oeeg;!!V..(76/,:!8(!5!Gb`Q!,%='!
'8(72!(,!G%/8$!H/-%88!5,6!$/'!6(:'D!*H/-%88!$5'!%'8/>58%6!8$58!$/'!35.-!()!14((6$(&,6'!$5'!/,6/.8%6!
(?%7!"Deee!'&'3%.8'!/,.4&6/,:!1&7:457'D!753/'8'!5,6!-/44%7';0!/-;45+$/7?1$J-);$F7)B-$J46"&-"1$7<$
84&"-&1D!Gb`Q;.(>D!M5,&572!XD!Oeeg;!
"X!W$574%'!^%'4($D!F3-65$(1$,7&-61'3$2B'"-63-$(6"$'51$:-)(5'761>';$57$5>-$L(M$26<7&3-H-65$C(6'6-!58!OD!
`,/?%7'/82!()!W%,8754!C4(7/65D!<(?;!OD!Oeee;!
"h!E%%!^57-!F%77D!D'5>$/7?$/-5-35'B-1G$8'15(I-1$C(6$J(;;-6D!<;];!#I^QED!F%.;!ORD!OeeO;!
"g!E%%$'"#!

!

R!

!
J,%!()!8$%!3&73('%'!()!8$%'%!7&4%'!/'!8(!/,'&7%!8$58!8$%!7%5.8/(,'!()!8$%!6(:!
57%!(1+%.8/?%!5,6!,(8!/,)4&%,.%6!/,!5,2!=52!12!8$%!$5,64%7;Oe!!I,!>5,2!7%'3%.8'D!8$%2!
57%!'/>/457!8(!8$%!1(62!()!7&4%'!8$58!=%!,(=!-,(=!'$(&46!1%!&'%6!8(!37%?%,8!&,)5/7!
%2%=/8,%''!/6%,8/)/.58/(,';!!
!
!
Q?%,!=$%,!8$%'%!7&4%'!57%!'.7&3&4(&'42!)(44(=%6!8$%!7%'&48'!.5,!,%?%7!1%!
.(,'/6%7%6!.(,.4&'/?%;!!V)8%7!>5,2!2%57'!()!7%'%57.$!5,6!$576!%93%7/%,.%D!8$%!F&8.$!
$5?%!.(,.4&6%6!8$58!8$/'!'(78!()!%?/6%,.%!$5'!4/>/8%6!?54&%!5,6!.5,!(,42!1%!&'%6!/,!
.(,+&,.8/(,!=/8$!(8$%7!'./%,8/)/.!37(()!4/-%!F<V!/,!5!.7/>/,54!.5'%;O"!!I,!8$%!`;E;D!
?57/(&'!5''(./58/(,'!5,6!%93%78'!$5?%!54'(!1%:&,!8(!)(7>&458%!7&4%'!5,6!37(8(.(4'!
)(7!8$%!4/>/8%6!&'%!()!8$%!8%.$,/[&%;OO!!
!
!
I)!8$%7%!/'!5!6%?%4(3/,:!.(,'%,'&'!51(&8!8$%!&'%!()!'.%,8!4/,%&3'D!/8!.(>%'!
6(=,!8(!8$/'K!!
!
"; E./%,8/)/.!>%8$(6'!$5?%!8(!1%!&'%6k!
!
O; _&4%'!15'%6!(,!8$('%!>%8$(6'!$5?%!8(!1%!37%./'%42!)(44(=%6k!
!
P; !Q?%,!/)!37(3%7!>%8$(6'!5,6!7&4%'!57%!&'%6!8$%!'.%,8!4/,%&3!$5'!?%72!
4/>/8%6!?54&%!5'!*'./%,8/)/.!%?/6%,.%0!5,6!.5,,(8!1%!'(4%42!7%4/%6!&3(,;!!
!
!
)3'$5,(6$"<$%&'()$*+(',-%$
!
!
E.%,8!4/,%&3'D!%?%,!/)!6(,%!.(77%.842D!57%!()!(,42!>57:/,54!?54&%;!!E.%,8!
4/,%&3'!6(,%!/,.(77%.842!(7!7%4/%6!&3(,!5'!.(,.4&'/?%!37(()!7%'&48!/,!6/'5'8%7;!!
!
!
V8!4%5'8!8=(!(8$%7!+&7/'6/.8/(,'!1%'/6%'!#%95'!$5?%!7(&8/,%42!7%4/%6!(,!
&,'./%,8/)/.!'.%,8!4/,%&3';!!
!
!!
I,!C4(7/65D!5!6(:!$5,64%7!,5>%6!M($,!H7%'8(,!=5'!&'%6!(?%7!5,6!(?%7!5:5/,!
12!3(4/.%!5,6!37('%.&8(7'!8(!:5/,!.(,?/.8/(,';OP!!V48$(&:$!$/'!=(7-!=5'!15'%6!(,!
:&%''%'!5,6!%95::%758/(,'!/8!=5'!37%'%,8%6!5'!*'./%,.%0!8(!6(B%,'!()!+&7/%';!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Oe!*Y5,64%7'!.5,!.7%58%!%77(7'!12!3&44/,:!8$%/7!6(:'!5=52!)7(>!8$/,:'!8$%2!57%!/,?%'8/:58/,:D!12!

4%88/,:!8$%>!'%57.$!8((!4(,:!/,!5!'/,:4%!345.%!(7!12!/,./8/,:!8$%!6(:!8$7(&:$!'(>%!:%'8&7%D!:45,.%!(7!
%>(8/(,D!%?%,!&,.(,'./(&';!#75/,%7'!'52!8$%!>%''5:%!l875?%4'!7/:$8!6(=,!8$%!4%5'$;@!!^5/,42!)(7!8$58!
7%5'(,D!8$%!)%=!'8&6/%'!()!6(:!3%7)(7>5,.%!8$58!$5?%!1%%,!6(,%!'&::%'8!8$58!6(:'!3%7)(7>!1%'8!())!
8$%/7!4%5'$%';0!!"#!
O"!E%%!a&2!Y57:7%5?%'D!F3-65$L'6-4;$N&5'3)-$O$=7)'3-$=&(35'3-$/-5-35'76$/7?$L'6-4;D!H(4/.%\/,-D!

(B(')(E)-$(5!$883Kjj===;3(4/.%4/,-;.(>j875/,/,:j578/.4%'j"XgXS'.%,8S4/,%&3S578/.4%SSS3(4/.%S
375.8/.%S6%8%.8/(,S6(:S4/,%&3;!!
OO!E%%!E8%?%!#24%7D!A4-15$37)4H6.$!6673-651$=)(3-"$(5$:'1I$D'5>$P6&-)'(E)-$F3-65$/7?1D!bIW#J_IV!
VFbJWV#QD!M&42!"hD!Oeeg;!
OP!M%))!E.$=%%7'D!QR$C(1-1$8'&-"$'6$/7?$J(6")-&@1$,&(4"D!C\J_IFV#JFV];WJ^D!V&:;!PeD!Oeeg;!

!

T!

V48$(&:$!/8!$5'!85-%,!6%.56%'D!F<V!%?/6%,.%!5,6!37(()!8$58!H7%'8(,!4/%6!&,6%7!(58$!
$5?%!,(=!6/'.7%6/8%6!$/'!*%93%780!8%'8/>(,2;!!V'!()!%574/%7!8$/'!2%57D!"U!.5'%'!/,!
=$/.$!H7%'8(,!3578/./358%6!$5?%!1%%,!'.7&8/,/B%6D!=/8$!,%5742!5!$&,67%6!>(7%!8(!
)(44(=;OR!!#$7%%!>%,!$5?%!1%%,!%9(,%758%6!'(!)57;OT!!#5-%,!8(:%8$%7D!8$%'%!/,,(.%,8!
>%,!'3%,8!>(7%!8$5,!Te!2%57'!()!8$%/7!4/?%'!/,!37/'(,;!!
!
!
J,%!(8$%7!:(?%7,>%,8!%,8/82!/'!53357%,842!7%42/,:!(,!'.%,8!4/,%&3'K!8$%!
.(>>&,/'8!7%:/>%!/,!W&15;!!#$%7%D!8$%!'%.7%8!3(4/.%!$5?%!5>5''%6!8$(&'5,6'!()!
1(884%'!()!'.%,8'!85-%,!)7(>!5,8/SW5'87(!'4(:5,'!35/,8%6!(,!=544'!5,6!(8$%7!'&.$!
*.7/>%!'.%,%'0!5,6!57%!&'/,:!8$%>!5'!*37(()0!5:5/,'8!6/''/6%,8';OU!!
!
!
#$%!4%56/,:!*%93%780!/,!#%95'!(,!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!/'!5!6(:S$5,64/,:!6%3&82!)7(>!
C(78!Z%,6!W(&,82!,5>%6!G%/8$!H/-%88;!!Y%!$5'!1%.(>%!)5>(&'!12!875?%4/,:!
8$7(&:$(&8!8$%!'858%!5,6!8%'8/)2/,:!)(7!37('%.&8(7';!!Y%!$5'!:57,%7%6!)5?(7514%!
3&14/./82D!5=576'D!5,6!(33(78&,/8/%'!)(7!56?5,.%>%,8!)(7!$/>'%4)!54(,:!8$%!=52;!
Z%.5&'%!$%!$5'!.(>%!8(!6(>/,58%!8$/'!)/%46!/,!#%95'!$/'!$/'8(72!5,6!>%8$(6'!
6%'%7?%!8(!1%!.57%)&442!%95>/,%6;!!#$/'!/'!6(,%!1%4(=;!
!!!
!
)3'$%)/0(#'$0(!$02<,*$&0/''/$"<$6'+)3$-+6'))$
!
!
G%/8$!H/-%88!:7%=!&3!/,!&3'858%!<%=!](7-;!!V)8%7!:756&58/,:!)7(>!$/:$!'.$((4!
/,!"gUTD!$%!%,4/'8%6!/,!8$%!`;E;!<5?2;!!Y%!'%7?%6!'/9!2%57';!!Y%!8$%,!8((-!5!+(1!58!8$%!
I,:544!E$/3!]576!/,!^(1/4%D!V4515>5;!!Y%!=%,8!8(!.(44%:%D!:756&58/,:!=/8$!5!6%:7%%!/,!
.$%>/'872!)7(>!8$%!`,/?%7'/82!()!E(&8$!V4515>5;OX!!Y%!458%7!588%,6%6!5,(8$%7!
V4515>5!/,'8/8&8/(,!.544%6!8$%!`,/8%6!E858%'!E3(78'!V.56%>2D!=$%7%!$%!7%.%/?%6!5!
>5'8%7@'!6%:7%%!/,!*E3(78!E./%,.%0!/,!"ghR;Oh!
!
!
V8!'(>%!3(/,8!5)8%7!8$58D!H/-%88!>(?%6!8(!#%95';!!Y%!5,6!$/'!=/)%!1(&:$8!5!
14((6$(&,6!5'!5!3%8;!!V)8%7!3452/,:!=/8$!8$%!6(:!8$%2!6%./6%6!8(!875/,!/8!8(!1%!5!
3(4/.%!6(:;!!#$%2!6/6!8$/'!(,!8$%/7!(=,!=/8$(&8!&'/,:!5,2!-,(=,!(7!%'8514/'$%6!
37(:75>;Og!!
!
!
H/-%88!8$%,!1%:5,!?(4&,8%%7/,:!$/>'%4)!5,6!8$%!6(:!)(7!&'%!12!6/))%7%,8!45=!
%,)(7.%>%,8!5:%,./%';!!I,!"ggeD!8$%!^(,8:(>%72!W(&,82!E$%7/))@'!J))/.%!1%:5,!&'/,:!
8$%>!(,!'%57.$!5,6!7%'.&%!>/''/(,';Pe!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
OR!!"#$

OT!M($,!V;!#(77%'!m!M%))!E.$=%%7'D!/7?$J(6")-&$L-"$57$*("$2B'"-63-D!C\J_IFV#JFV];WJ^D!M&,%!O"D!Oeeg;!!
OU!M&5,!J;!#5>52(D!C4E(@1$F6'<<-&S/7?$=&7?&(H$%&(3I1$/7M6$C&77I1G$/'11'"-651D!#YQ!^IV^I!YQ_V\FD!

E%38;!gD!Oeeg;!
OX!G%/8$!H/-%88!`,6%7:756&58%!F%:7%%;!!E%%!V33%,6/9!Z;!
Oh!G%/8$!H/-%88!a756&58%!F%:7%%;!!E%%!V33%,6/9!Z;!
Og!E8%?%,!\(,:D!T75>'6@$*45$($JUPT/$/UA$%&(3I'6@$N))$5>-$%'H-D!YJ`E#J<!WY_J<IW\QD!^57;!""D!"ggR;!
Pe!#75,'.7/38!()!H7%87/54!Y%57/,:!58!Oh!cb(4;!P!()!"XdD!#%95'!?;!^57.&'!J>57!L/,'8(,!cOeeed;!

!

U!

!
I,!"ggOD!H/-%88!1(&:$8!5,(8$%7!14((6$(&,6!8$58!$%!,5>%6!*W(4&>1(;0P"!!Z2!
"ggR!$%!=5'!.45/>/,:!8$58!8$%!6(:!.(&46!,(8!(,42!6(!875/4/,:!5,6!(8$%7!15'/.!85'-'!
1&8!.(&46!54'(!6(!'.%,8!4/,%&3';PO!!#$%'%!.45/>'!1%:5,!8(!58875.8!8$%!588%,8/(,!()!4(.54!
,%='353%7'!5,6!>5-%!H/-%88!=%44!-,(=,;!!
!
!
I,!8$%!%5742!"gge'D!H/-%88!1%:5,!=(7-/,:!=/8$!8$%!C(78!Z%,6!W(&,82!E$%7/))@'!
J))/.%;PP!!#$/'!,%=!'858&'!%,514%6!$/>!8(!=(7-!(,!.7/>/,54!.5'%'!5,6!8(&8!$/'!
%93%78/'%!=/8$!6(:';!!J,%!()!$/'!)/7'8!1/:!.5'%'!/,?(4?%6!5!6%)%,65,8!,5>%6!^57.&'!
W(88(,;!!H/-%88!8%'8/)/%6!/,!W(88(,@'!)/7'8!87/54!8$58!$%!$56!.(,6&.8%6!5!'.%,8!4/,%&3!
5,6!8$58!$/'!6(:!$56!>58.$%6!5!'.%,8!85-%,!)7(>!.7/>%!'.%,%!%?/6%,.%!8(!^57.&'!
W(88(,;PR!!I,!5,!53357%,8!%))(78!8(!>5-%!$/>'%4)!'%%>!/>3(785,8D!$%!54'(!8%'8/)/%6!
8$58!$%!$56!5!Z5.$%4(7!()!E./%,.%!/,!W$%>/'872!6%:7%%!)7(>!E275.&'%!`,/?%7'/82!5,6!
5!^5'8%7@'!6%:7%%!/,!W$%>/'872!)7(>!8$%!`,/?%7'/82!()!Y(&'8(,;PT!!#$/'!=5'!5!4/%K!
H/-%88!$5'!,%?%7!7%.%/?%6!6%:7%%'!)7(>!%/8$%7!/,'8/8&8/(,;PU!!#$%!6%)%,'%!/,!W(88(,@'!
.5'%!,%?%7![&%'8/(,%6!H/-%88!(,!8$/'D!5,6!$/'!8%'8/>(,2!=5'!544(=%6!8(!'85,6;!!
W(88(,!%?%,8&5442!7%.%/?%6!5,(8$%7!87/54;!!#$%!E858%!6/6!,(8!&'%!H/-%88!/,!8$/'!'%.(,6!
87/54;!
!
!
Y/'!.57%%7!5'!5!'.%,8!4/,%&3!*%93%780!8((-!())!5)8%7!8$%!C75576$.5'%;!!Y%!
5.[&/7%6!>(7%!6(:'!5,6!:5?%!8$%>!,5>%'!4/-%!*M5>%'!Z(,60!5,6!*W4&%;0!!Y%!1%.5>%!
5!)&44S8/>%!45=!%,)(7.%>%,8!())/.%7;PX!!Y%!875?%4%6!5.7(''!8$%!E858%!&'/,:!8$%!6(:'!8(!
/6%,8/)2!'&'3%.8'!5,6!37(?/6%!*%?/6%,.%0!8(!3(4/.%!5,6!37('%.&8(7'!/,!5!$('8!()!
/>3(785,8!.5'%';!!
!
!
#$%!8%'8/>(,2!$%!:5?%!8(!+&7/%'!$5'!1%%,!6%'.7/1%6!5'!%,8$&'%6D!*6(=,S
$(>%0D!5,6!.$57>/,:;!!V'!$%!3%7)%.8%6!$/'!7(&8/,%D!$%!1%:5,!8(!>5-%!=/46!5''%78/(,'!
/,!87/54';!!
!
!
Y%!$5'!8%'8/)/%6!&,6%7!(58$D!)(7!%95>34%D!8$58!%?%,!8$(&:$!$%!6(%'!,(8!-%%3!
6%85/4%6!7%.(76'!()!$/'!5.8/?/8/%'Ph!$%!-,(='!8$58!$/'!6(:'!$5?%!54>('8!,%?%7!1%%,!
=7(,:;!!V..(76/,:!8(!H/-%88D!5'!()!Oeeg!$/'!6(:!*W4&%0!$56!1%%,!=7(,:!(,.%!(&8!()!
"DUTg!4/,%&3';Pg!!*M5>%'!Z(,60!$56!1%%,!=7(,:!(,.%!(&8!()!ODOUU!8/>%';Re!!*n&/,.20!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

P"!#75,'.7/38!()!H7%87/54!$%57/,:!58!O"!cb(4&>%!PdD!#%95'!?;!^57.&'!J>57!L/,'8(,!cOeeed;!
PO!#75,'.7/38!()!H7%87/54!Y%57/,:!58!"P!cb(4&>%!OdD!#%95'!?;!M&'8/,!V4%95,6%7!cOeegd;!
PP!#75,'.7/38!()!H7%87/54!Y%57/,:!58!Oh!cb(4&>%!PdD!#%95'!?;!^57.&'!J>57!L/,'8(,!cOeeed;!
PR!#75,'.7/38!()!#7/54!_%.(76!58!RU"!cb(4&>%!XdD!#%95'!?;!^57.&'!W(88(,D!c"ggXd;!
PT!#75,'.7/38!()!#7/54!_%.(76!58!RRT!cb(4&>%!XdD!#%95'!?;!^57.&'!W(88(,D!c"ggXd;!
PU!\%88%7'!)7(>!E275.&'%!`,/?%7'/82!5,6!8$%!`,/?%7'/82!()!Y(&'8(,;!!V33%,6/9!Z;!

PX!#75,'.7/38!()!H7%87/54!Y%57/,:!58!"O!cb(4&>%!"dD!#%95'!?;!M&'8/,!V4%95,6%7!cOeegd;!
Ph!L$%,!5'-%6!51(&8!=$%8$%7!$%!875.-'!8$%!'&..%''!()!$/'!6(:'!5,6!8$%!(&8.(>%'!()!8$%!.5'%'!8$%2!

=(7-D!H/-%88!'858%'!*<(;!!Q?%721(62!/,!8$%!.(&,872!.544'!>%D!'(!I!:&%''!8$58@'!'(>%8$/,:;0!!E%%!
#75,'.7/38!()!H7%87/54!$%57/,:!58!"OgSP"!cb(4&>%!"dD!#%95'!?;!M5'(,!E>/8$!cOeeXd;!!\/-%=/'%D!=$%,!
5'-%6!51(&8!8$%!8(854!,&>1%7!()!875/4'!5,6!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!$%!5,6!$/'!6(:'!$5?%!.(,6&.8%6D!H/-%88!
56>/8'!8$58!*o$%p!.(&46,@8!-%%3!&3!=/8$!/80!5,6!5.-,(=4%6:%'!8$58!8$%!,&>1%7!.(&46!1%!/,!8$%!Reee!8(!
Teee!75,:%;!!!"#$58!PX;!
Pg!#75,'.7/38!()!H7%87/54!Y%57/,:!58!PU!cb(4&>%!OdD!#%95'!?;!M&'8/,!V4%95,6%7!cOeegd;!
Re!#75,'.7/38!()!H7%87/54!Y%57/,:!58!PT!cb(4&>%!OdD!#%95'!?;!M&'8/,!V4%95,6%7!cOeegd;!

!

X!

$56!(,42!1%%,!37(?%,!=7(,:!8$7%%!8/>%'!/,!ODhP"!4/,%&3';R"!!V..(76/,:!8(!8$%!
7%'%57.$!6(,%!12!8$%!F&8.$!3(4/.%!5,6!(8$%7!%93%78'!/,!8$%!)/%46D!8$/'!/'!51'&76;!!Q?%,!
&'/,:!7/:(7(&'!875/,/,:!>%8$(6'D!%93%78'!1%4/%?%!8$58!8$%!1%'8!6(:'!=(7-%6!/,!
3%7)%.842!.(,87(44%6!.(,6/8/(,'!.5,!(,42!1%!7/:$8!5337(9/>58%42!hTf!()!8$%!8/>%;RO!
!
!
H/-%88!$5'!/,6/.58%6!8$58!/8!/'!,(8!/>3(785,8!)(7!$/>!8(!7%.%/?%!5,2!)(7>54!
875/,/,:D!8$58!$%!6(%'!,(8!,%%6!8(!)(44(=!5,2!7&4%'!(7!37(8(.(4'!%'8514/'$%6!12!
'./%,8/'8'!/,!8$%!)/%46D!5,6!8$58!$%!7%+%.8'!8$%!/>3(785,.%!()!'./%,8/)/.!'8&6/%'!
.(,.%7,/,:!'.%,8!4/,%&3'RP;!!H/-%88!$5'!54'(!.45/>%6!8$58!$/'!6(:'!.5,!/6%,8/)2!'.%,8'!
>(7%!8$5,!5!6%.56%!(46RR!5,6!8$58!8$%2!.5,!)(44(=!'.%,8'!4%)8!1%$/,6!12!.57'RTA
.45/>'!=$/.$!$5?%!1%%,!.7/8/./B%6!12!%93%78'!/,!8$/'!)/%46RU;!!
!
!
!
!
J,%!.5'%D!F5(5-$B#$D'61576D!.%>%,8%6!H/-%88@'!7%3&858/(,!5'!8$%!4%56/,:!#%95'!
%93%78!/,!'.%,8!4/,%&3';!!I,!8$58!.5'%!$%!7%3%58%6!8$%!4/%!8$58!$%!$56!5!>5'8%7@'!
6%:7%%!/,!.$%>/'872D!8$/'!8/>%!)7(>!8$%!`,/?%7'/82!()!E(&8$!V4515>5;RX!!Y%!=5'!
37(.45/>%6!5,!%93%78!=/8,%''!12!8$%!37('%.&8(7D!5,6!8$%,!8%'8/)/%6!/,!8$%!&'&54!
>5,,%7!8$58!$/'!6(:'!$56!.(,.4&'/?%42!/6%,8/)/%6!8$%!6%)%,65,8@'!'.%,8!(,!8$%!.7/>%!
'.%,%!%?/6%,.%;Rh!!#$/'!8%'8/>(,2!=5'!,(8!.(,8756/.8%6!12!5,!%93%78!)(7!8$%!6%)%,'%D!
,(7!=5'!/8!%))%.8/?%42!.$544%,:%6!8$7(&:$!.7(''S%95>/,58/(,;!!L/,'8(,!=5'!
.(,?/.8%6;!!J,!^57.$!OhD!OeeO!8$%!"R8$!W(&78!()!V33%54'!=7(8%!5,!(3/,/(,!5))/7>/,:!
8$%!.(,?/.8/(,!5,6!$%46!8$58!H/-%88!=5'!5![&54/)/%6!%93%78;Rg!!#$/'!6%./'/(,!>56%!/8!
())/./54K!/,!#%95'!.(&78'!H/-%88!=(&46!1%!544(=%6!8(!37%'%,8!$/'!4/,%&3'!5'!*'./%,8/)/.!
%?/6%,.%;0!
!
!
I,!8$%!=5-%!()!8$/'!/44S/,)(7>%6!6%./'/(,!H/-%88@'!'857!7('%!)&78$%7;!!Y%!
.(,8/,&%6!8(!8%'8/)2!/,!87/54';!!L$%,!.(,)7(,8%6!=/8$!8$%!/''&%!()!$/'!7%4/51/4/82!5,6!
8$%!?54/6/82!()!'.%,8!4/,%&3'D!533%4458%!.(&78'!'/>342!7%4/%6!(,!8$%!%574/%7!6%./'/(,!/,!
D'61576!5,6!5))/7>%6!8$%!6%)%,65,8'@!.(,?/.8/(,';Te!!<(!'%7/(&'!'.7&8/,2!=5'!:/?%,!
8(!H/-%88@'!8%'8/>(,2;!!
!
!
Y%!1%.5>%!/>>%,'%42!3(3&457!=/8$!37('%.&8(7'D!=$(!'8578%6!&'/,:!$/>!
7(&8/,%42;!!#$%!51/4/82!()!$/'!6(:'!8(!*.(,)/7>0!=$58!8$%2!=5,8%6!8(!-,(=!/,!5!.5'%D!
.(&34%6!=/8$!$/'!.$57>!=/8$!+&7/%'D!>56%!$/>!5!)/98&7%!/,!.7/>/,54!.5'%'!544!(?%7!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

R"!#75,'.7/38!()!H7%87/54!Y%57/,:!58!PRSPT!cb(4&>%!OdD!#%95'!?;!M&'8/,!V4%95,6%7!cOeegd;!
RO!W$574%'!^%'4($D!F3-65$(1$,7&-61'3$2B'"-63-$(6"$'51$:-)(5'761>';$57$5>-$L(M$26<7&3-H-65$C(6'6-!58!UD!

`,/?%7'/82!()!W%,8754!C4(7/65D!<(?;!OD!Oeee;!
RP!E%%!#75,'.7/38!()!G%/8$!H/-%88!#%'8/>(,2!58!hhShgD!#%95'!?;!_/.$576!L/,)7%2D!M7;!cOeegd;!
RR!#75,'.7/38!()!H7%87/54!Y%57/,:!58!RUSRX!cb(4&>%!"dD!#%95'!?;!M5'(,!E>/8$!cOeeXd;!
RT!G;!H/-%88!F%3(;!58!XRSXT!m!"R"D!Z&.$5,%-!?;!W/82!()!b/.8(7/5D!%8;!54D!UKOeeh.?eeeeh!cE;F;!#%9;!)/4%6!
M5,;!OgD!Oeehd!S!!F%3('/8/(,!85-%,!(,!M5,;!OOD!Oeeg;!
RU!E%%!W$574%'!^%'4($D!F3-65$(1$,7&-61'3$2B'"-63-$(6"$'51$:-)(5'761>';$57$5>-$L(M$26<7&3-H-65$C(6'6-!
58!UD!`,/?%7'/82!()!W%,8754!C4(7/65D!<(?;!OD!Oeeek!V))/65?/8!()!F(&:45'!Y;!\(=72!58!P;!!V33%,6/9!V;!
RX!#75,'.7/38!()!H7%87/54!Y%57/,:!58!"T!m!OX!cb(4&>%!PdD!#%95'!?;!^57.&'!L/,'8(,!cOeeed;!
Rh!#75,'.7/38!()!#7/54!_%.(76!58!OeU!cb(4&>%!"edD!#%95'!?;!^57.&'!L/,'8(,!cOeeed;!
Rg!L/,'8(,!?;!E858%D!Xh!ELP6!TOOD!TOg!c#%9;!V33;AY(&'8(,!o"R8$!F/'8;p!OeeOD!3%8;!7%)@6d;!
Te!E%%!%;:;!_(1/,'(,!?;!E858%D!OeeU!L\!PRPheXU!58!qP!c#%9;!V33;AZ%5&>(,8dk!L/,)7%2!?;!E858%D!Oeeg!
L\!"UPUhRg!58!qU!c#%9;!V33;AQ5'845,6d;!

!

h!

#%95';!!V'!458%!5'!V37/4!()!8$/'!2%57D!(,%!37('%.&8(7!=/8$!8$%!V88(7,%2!a%,%754@'!())/.%!
'5/6!()!H/-%88K!*Y%!$5'!$%43%6!&'!=/8$!'%?%754!.5'%'!(?%7!8$%!35'8!)%=!2%57'!=/8$!
:7%58!7%'&48';!!I@>!5!1/:!)5,r;0T"!\58%7D!7%3(78/,:!(,!5!?/'/8!1%8=%%,!5,!/,?%'8/:58(7!
5,6!H/-%88D!8$/'!37('%.&8(7!%9.45/>%6K!0L((S$((s!M&'8!:(8!=(76!8$58!G%/8$@'!6(:'!
&,5,/>(&'42!$/8!(,!>2!%?/6%,.%!8(652D!+&'8!5'!=%@6!$(3%60!5,6!533%,6%6!5!*'>/4%2S
)5.%0!'2>1(4!8(!$%7!>%''5:%;TO!!
!
!
H/-%88!54'(!1%.5>%!'(>%8$/,:!()!5!)(4-!$%7(!/,!45=!%,)(7.%>%,8!./7.4%';!!J,%!
()!$/'!6(:'!=5'!/,6&.8%6!/,8(!8$%!#%95'!b%8%7/,572!Y544!()!C5>%!/,!OeeO;TP!!#$58!
'5>%!2%57D!H/-%88!=5'!,5>%6!*J))/.%7!()!8$%!]%570!12!5!3(4/.%!'&33(78!:7(&3!/,!
Y(&'8(,;TR!!
!
!
V'!H/-%88!$5,64%6!>(7%!5,6!>(7%!.5'%'D!$(=%?%7D!8$%!)75&6&4%,8!5,6!'$(662!
,58&7%!()!$/'!=(7-!1%:5,!8(!1%!7%?%54%6;!
!
!
I,!OeeUD!H/-%88!=%,8!8(!b/.8(7/5!8(!3%7)(7>!5!'.%,8!4/,%&3!/,!5!,(8(7/(&'!
>&76%7!.5'%;TT!!#$%!4(.54!5&8$(7/8/%'!/6%,8/)/%6!^/.$5%4!Z&.$5,%-D!5!7%8/7%6!3(4/.%!
.5385/,D!5'!5!3%7'(,!()!/,8%7%'8!/,!8$%!.5'%;TU!!H7%6/.85142D!H/-%88!6/6!5!'.%,8!4/,%!&3!
=$/.$!.5>%!(&8!8$%!=52!8$%!3(4/.%!=5,8%6;!!^7;!Z&.$5,%-!=5'![&%'8/(,%6D!$575''%6D!
5,6!/6%,8/)/%6!/,!8$%!>%6/5!5'!5!37/>%!'&'3%.8A54>('8!%,8/7%42!(,!8$%!15'/'!()!
H/-%88@'!*%93%78!%?/6%,.%;0!!E%?%754!>(,8$'!5)8%7!8$%!>&76%7!5,(8$%7!>5,!.(,)%''%6!
8(!8$%!.7/>%!5,6!34%6!:&/482;TX!!
!
!
I,!V&:&'8!OeeXD!H/-%88!=5'!.544%6!/,!8(!3%7)(7>!(,%!()!$/'!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!/,!5!
'87/,:!()!Y(&'8(,!1&7:4572!.5'%';!!V:5/,'8!8$%!+&6:>%,8!()!8$%!())/.%7'!=(7-/,:!8$%!
.5'%D!8=(!6%8%.8/?%'!$56!5!$&,.$!51(&8!=$(!8$%!7%54!'&'3%.8!=5';!!#$%'%!6%8%.8/?%'!
.(,85.8%6!H/-%88D!=$(!$56!$/'!6(:'!6(!5!'.%,8!4/,%&3;!!H7%6/.85142D!H/-%88!8(46!8$%>!
=$58!8$%2!=5,8%6!8(!$%57;!!#$%!6%8%.8/?%'!8$%,!>56%!5,!577%'8!(,!8$%!15'/'!()!8$%!
'.%,8!4/,%&3;!!#$%2!$56!:(88%,!8$%!=7(,:!>5,;!!#$%!7%54!.7/>/,54!=5'!577%'8%6!12!
(8$%7!())/.%7'!7/:$8!5)8%7!.(>>/88/,:!5,(8$%7!1&7:4572;!!V)8%7!$%57/,:!()!8$/'D!b/.!
L/',%7D!5!OR!S2%57!?%8%75,!37('%.&8(7!/,!.$57:%!()!8$%!.5'%D!(76%7%6!8$%!>5,!H/-%88!
$56!5..&'%6!7%4%5'%6;!!^7;!L/',%7!8$%,!'%,8!5,!%S>5/4!8(!544!Y577/'!W(&,82!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
T"!H('8/,:!()!\/'5!#5,,%7!8(!!

$883Kjj86.55;/,)(3(3;,%8jOjJ3%,#(3/.N5t83.m'tPRXeghgUTm)t"TXeghgUTm>tOXh"eOUhh"m7tPe
g"eOUhh"uPeg"eOUhh"!cV37;!"D!Oeegd;!
TO!H('8/,:!()!\/'5!#5,,%7!8(!
$883Kjj86.55;/,)(3(3;,%8jOjJ3%,#(3/.N5t83.m'tPRXeghgUTm)t"TXeghgUTm>tOXh"eOUhh"m7tPe
g"eOUhh"uPeg"eOUhh"!cV37;!PD!Oeegd;!
TP!#%95'!b%8%7/,572!^%6/.54!V''(./58/(,K!#%95'!V,/>54!Y544!()!C5>%D!n&/,.2D!
$883Kjj===;8?>5;(7:jH%8vJ=,%7'jehv$()v[&/,.2;3$8>4!c45'8!?/'/8%6!E%38;!"TD!Oeegd;!
TR!!"#$
TT!#%77/!\5,:)(76D!K4-15'761$NE745$C=F$U<<'3'()@1$/-(5>$J(465$J-&$C7HH46'5+$V$D'5>$T7$N&&-151G$
C763-&61$NH76?$,&'-6"1$(6"$,(H')+$(&-$A&7M'6?D!YJ`E#J<!WY_J<IW\QD!M&42!PD!OeeU;!
TU!!"#$
TX!#%'8/>(,2!()!M%))7%2!C75,-!a7/>'/,:%7!w!H4%5!()!a&/482!58!RSTD!#%95'!?;!M%))7%2!a7/>'/,:%7!cOeehd;!

!

g!

37('%.&8(7'!%9345/,/,:!=$58!$56!$533%,%6!5,6!=57,/,:!8$%>!51(&8!H/-%88;!#$/'!
/,)(7>58/(,!/'!'%8!(&8!/,!^7;!L/',%7@'!5))/65?/8D!=$/.$!/'!5885.$%6!8(!8$/'!7%3(78;Th!
!
!
I,!458%!OeeXD!Y(&'8(,!3(4/.%!=%7%!.544%6!8(!8$%!'.%,%!()!5!87/34%!$(>/./6%;Tg!!
V3357%,842!&,87(&14%6!12!$/'!37%?/(&'!)54'%!5..&'58/(,'D!3(4/.%!5'-%6!H/-%88!8(!$%43!
8$%>!5:5/,;Ue!!#$%/7!$&,.$!=5'!8$58!W%67/.!M($,'(,!$56!.(>>/88%6!8$%!.7/>%D!1&8!
8$%2!,%%6%6!.(,.7%8%!%?/6%,.%!8(!8/%!$/>!5,6!458%7!5,(8$%7!/,6/?/6&54D!W&7?/'!
Z/.-$5>D!8(!8$%!'.%,%;!!H/-%88!=5'!5'-%6!8(!5''/'8!8$%>!/,!$/'!8/>%S$(,(7%6!)5'$/(,;!!
Y%!6/6!5!'.%,8!4/,%&3!5,6!6&42!7%3(78%6!8$58!$/'!6(:'!$56!345.%6!8$%!'&'3%.8'@!'.%,8'!
(,!3/%.%'!()!%?/6%,.%!:58$%7%6!)7(>!8$%!.7/>%!'.%,%;!!Z(8$!>%,!=%7%!577%'8%6!)(7!
.53/854!>&76%7D!5!6%58$!3%,5482!.7/>%D!5,6!$%46!/,!+5/4;U"!!^(,8$'!458%7!8$%2!=%7%!
7%4%5'%6!5,6!544!.$57:%'!5:5/,'8!8$%>!=%7%!67(33%6;!
!
!
I,!M5,&572!OeegD!5!](5-&>!W(&,82!7%'/6%,8!,5>%6!W54?/,!^/44%7!.5>%!&,6%7!
'&'3/./(,!)(7!753%!5,6!7(11%72;!H/-%88!3%7)(7>%6!5!'.%,8!4/,%&3!5,6!(,.%!5:5/,!
37(?/6%6!*%?/6%,.%0!8(!15.-!3(4/.%!:&%''=(7-;!!^(,8$'!458%7D!5)8%7!F<V!5,6!5!)5/4%6!
%2%=/8,%''!/6%,8/)/.58/(,!.4%57%6!$/>D!](5-&>!3(4/.%!)/,5442!7%4%5'%6!^7;!^/44%7;UO!!
!
!
!
L%!$5?%!,(!=52!()!-,(=/,:!$(=!>5,2!>(7%!.5'%'!4/-%!8$/'!$5?%!$533%,%6;!
L%!6(!-,(=!8$58!%5.$!()!8$%'%!>%,!=%7%!)54'%42!5..&'%6!()!'%7/(&'!.7/>%'!1%.5&'%!
()!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!5,6!=%7%!4&.-2!%,(&:$!8(!$5?%!(8$%7!%?/6%,.%!8$58!.4%57%6!8$%>;!!
Y(=!>5,2!3%(34%!$5?%!,(8!1%%,!'(!4&.-2N!!Y(=!>5,2!3%(34%!57%!/,!37/'(,!1%.5&'%!
()!H/-%88!5,6!$/'!'.%,8!4/,%&3'N!!L%!$5?%!,(!=52!8(!5,'=%7!8$%'%![&%'8/(,';!!
!
!
#$%!:(?%7,>%,8!6(%';!!I8!.(&46!$5?%!.$('%,!58!5,2!8/>%!8(!'8(3!&'/,:!'.%,8!
4/,%&3'!5'!%?/6%,.%;!!I8!.(&46!$5?%!.$('%,!8(!/,?%'8/:58%!(46!.5'%'!/,!=$/.$!8$%2!
=%7%!&'%6;!!I8!.(&46!$5?%!>56%!5,!%))(78!8(!/,'&7%!8$58!(&7!.7/>/,54!+&'8/.%!'2'8%>!
=(7-%6;!!I,'8%56D!/8!$5'!.$('%,!8(!.(,8/,&%!7%42/,:!(,!8$/'!)75&6&4%,8!8%.$,/[&%;!!
H(4/.%!5,6!37('%.&8(7'!57%!'8/44!&'/,:!H/-%88!5,6!$/'!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!6%'3/8%!$/'!7%.(76!
()!3%7+&72!5,6!)54'%!5..&'58/(,';!!
!
!
C(78&,58%42D!5!$5,6)&4!()!37/?58%!45=2%7'!$5?%!'8%33%6!)(7=576!8(!.$544%,:%!
8$%!&'%!()!8$/'!8%.$,/[&%!/,!#%95';!!H/-%88!5,6!$/'!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!$5?%!.(>%!&,6%7!
/,.7%5'/,:!5885.-!/,!1(8$!./?/4!5,6!.7/>/,54!.5'%'!/,!8$%!45'8!)%=!>(,8$';!!
!
!
\5='&/8'!$5?%!1%%,!7%.%,842!)/4%6!5:5/,'8!H/-%88!5,6!8$%!45=!%,)(7.%>%,8!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Th!b/.!L/',%7!V))/6?5/8;!!E%%!V33%,6/9!W;!
Tg!E%%!M%7%>2!F%'%4D!8(6$C)('H1$J-$M(1$D&76?)+$N3341-"$7<$84&"-&D!GYJ`;WJ^D!M&,%!"UD!Oeeg;!
Ue!E%%$'"#$
U"!W/82!()!Y(&'8(,D!T#Y!`HFV#Q!J<!I<WIFQ<#!V#!U"OO!ZQ\W_QE#!cOeeXdD!(B(')(E)-$(5!

$883Kjj===;$(&'8(,89;:(?j3(4/.%j,7jOeeXj6%.j,7"OOReXSO;$8>k!W/82!()!Y(&'8(,D!EQWJ<F!E`EHQW#!
V__QE#QF!I<!OeeX!^`_FQ_!WVEQ!cOeehdD!(B(')(E)-$(5!!
$883Kjj===;$(&'8(,89;:(?j3(4/.%j,7jOeehj(.8j,7"eeUehSh;$8>;$
UO!\%'4/%!L/41%7D!/7-1$'5$=(11$5>-$FH-))$%-159D!bIW#J_IV!VFbJWV#QD!M&42;!"OD!Oeegk!^/44%7!?;!W/82!()!
](5-&>!OSRD!%8;!54D!UKOeeg.?eeePT!cE;F;!#%9!)/4%6!^52!"OD!Oeegd;!

!

"e!

())/./54'!=$(!'3(,'(7%6!$/>!12!_%9!Q5'4%2D!5,!514%!45=2%7!)7(>!b/.8(7/5;UP!!I,!8$%!
.(&7'%!()!8$%'%!3%,6/,:!45='&/8'!5!:7%58!6%54!()!/,)(7>58/(,!$5'!.(>%!8(!4/:$8!51(&8!
H/-%88!5,6!$/'!=(7-;!!^7;!Q5'4%2!4(.58%6!'%?%754!%93%78'!8(!5,542B%D!7%?/%=!5,6!
%?54&58%!H/-%88@'!=(7-;!!
!
!
Q5.$!()!8$%'%!37()%''/(,54'!/'!5!=%44S-,(=,!4%56%7!/,!8$%!)/%46!()!'.%,8!
4/,%&3';!!#$%2!.57%)&442!7%?/%=%6!6(.&>%,8'D!?/6%('D!5,6!8%'8/>(,2!8(!6%8%7>/,%!
=$%8$%7!H/-%88!=5'!&'/,:!37()%''/(,54!>%8$(6'!5,6!=$%8$%7!$/'!7%'&48'!=%7%!
7%4/514%;!!Q5.$!()!8$%'%!>%,!'&1>/88%6!4%,:8$2!5))/65?/8'!'%88/,:!)(78$!8$%/7!)/,6/,:';!
#$%'%!5))/65?/8'!57%!5885.$%6!8(!8$/'!7%3(78!/,!8$%/7!%,8/7%82;!!V!17/%)!'&>>572!()!
=$58!8$%'%!%93%78'!$5?%!8(!'52!51(&8!H/-%88!5,6!$/'!4/,%&3'!/'!'%8!)(78$!1%4(=;!
!
_(1%78!W((8%D!5!37()%''/(,54!'.%,8S6(:!$5,64%7!)7(>!8$%!`,/8%6!G/,:6(>!5,6!
8$%!)(7>%7!$%56!()!5,!544SZ7/8/'$!.5,/,%!3(4/.%!&,/8D!'5/6!()!H/-%88@'!>%8$(6'!5)8%7!
=58.$/,:!5!?/6%(853%!()!$/>!3%7)(7>/,:!5!'.%,8!4/,%&3K!*#$/'!/'!8$%!>('8!37/>/8/?%!
%?/6%,8/54!3(4/.%!37(.%6&7%!I!$5?%!%?%7!=/8,%''%6;!!I)!/8!=5'!,(8!)(7!8$%!)5.8!8$58!/8!/'!
5!'%7/(&'!>588%7!I!.(&46!$5?%!1%%,!=58.$/,:!5!.(>%62;0UR!!^7;!W((8%!=%,8!(,!8(!'52!
8$58!*/,!544!o$/'p!%93%7/%,.%!=(7-/,:!6(:'D!o$%!$5'p!,%?%7D!%?%7!$%576!()!(7!'%%,!'&.$!
5,!(3%758/(,;!!I8!:(%'!5:5/,'8!544!8$%!37/,./34%'!()!875.-/,:!5,6!875/4/,:;0UT!!
!
F(&:45'!\(=72D!5!7%8/7%6!^57245,6!E858%!H(4/.%!())/.%7!5,6!8$%!.&77%,8!
37%'/6%,8!()!8$%!<58/(,54!H(4/.%!Z4((6$(&,6!V''(./58/(,!c<HZVdD!8%'8/)/%6!
%98%,'/?%42!51(&8!H/-%88@'!'.%,8!4/,%&3!37(.%6&7%';!!V48$(&:$!/,!$/'!^(8/(,!)(7!
E&>>572!M&6:>%,8!/,!8$%!Z&.$5,%-!.5'%D!H/-%88!.45/>%6!8$58!$/'!375.8/.%'!=%7%!
>(6%4%6!5)8%7!8$('%!()!8$%!<HZVD!^7;!\(=72!3(/,8'!(&8!/,!$/'!5))/65?/8!8$58!8$%!<HZV!
6%./6%6!'%?%754!2%57'!5:(!8(!6(!5=52!=/8$!8$%!875/,/,:!()!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!58!8$%/7!
875/,/,:!'.$((4'!5,6!'%>/,57'!1%.5&'%!*?%72!)%=!14((6$(&,6!8%5>'!=%7%!)(&,6!8(!
1%!.(,'/'8%,842!37()/./%,8!/,!=(7-/,:!'.%,8!4/,%S&3';0!!Y%!=%,8!(,!8(!%9345/,!8$58!
8$%7%!57%!*8((!>5,2!?57/514%'!/,?(4?%6!=/8$!8$/'!823%!()!'.%,8!=(7-!5,6!&,4%''!5!
$5,64%7!.(&46!'$(=!8$7(&:$!6(.&>%,8%6!875/,/,:!7%.(76'!8$58!8$%/7!14((6$(&,6!
=5'!=(7-/,:!58!5!.(,'/'8%,8!"eef!=/8$(&8!5!>/''D!/8!=5'!6/))/.&48!8(!$5?%!8$/'!'.%,8!
/6%,8/)/.58/(,!>%8$(6!5..%38%6!12!+&6:%'!5,6!8$%!.(&78!'2'8%>;0!Z5'%6!(,!$/'!
7%?/%=!()!8$%!)5.8'!()!^7;!Z&.$5,%-@'!.5'%D!^7;!\(=72!'5/6!8$58!8$%!'.%,8!4/,%&3!
37(.%6&7%'!*.(,6&.8%6!(,!^57.$!"TD!OeeU!5,6!5:5/,!(,!^57.$!O"D!OeeU!12!F%3&82!
H/-%88!5,6!$/'!14((6$(&,6'!=%7%!,(8!.(,'/'8%,8!=/8$!8$%!>%8$(6!37%?/(&'42!
6%'.7/1%6!5,6!85&:$8!12!/,'87&.8(7'!()!#$%!<58/(,54!H(4/.%!Z4((6$(&,6!V''(./58/(,D!
I,.;!58!875/,/,:!'.$((4'!5,6!'%>/,57';0!!Y%!=%,8!(,!8(!'52!()!H/-%88@'!=(7-K!*I!6(!,(8!
1%4/%?%!(7!)%%4!8$58!%/8$%7!'.%,8!4/,%S&3!%9%7./'%!/'!.7%6/14%!(7!7%4/514%0D!,(8/,:!8$58!/8!
4((-%6!5'!/)!H/-%88!=5'!.&%/,:!$/'!6(:!8$7(&:$(&8!(,%!%9%7./'%;!!Y%!.(,.4&6%6!$/'!
7%3(78!12!'52/,:K$
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
UP!Z&.$5,%-!?;!W/82!()!b/.8(7/5D!%8;!54D!UKOeeh.?eeeeh!cE;F;!#%9;!)/4%6!M5,;!OgD!Oeehdk!^/44%7!?;!W/82!()!

](5-&>D!%8;!54D!UKOeeg.?eeePT!cE;F;!#%9!)/4%6!^52!"OD!Oeegd;!
UR!\%'4/%!L/41%7D!/7-1$'5$=(11$5>-$FH-))$%-159D!bIW#J_IV!VFbJWV#Q!cM&42!"OD!Oeegd;!
UT!E%%!Z(1!W((8%!Q93%78!L/8,%''!_%3(78;!!V33%,6/9!V;!

!

""!

*I8! /'! >2! (3/,/(,! 8$58! F%3&82! G%/8$! V;! H/-%88! /'! 6(/,:! 5! 6/''%7?/.%! 8(!
3(4/.%! 14((6$(&,6! 8%5>'! 8$7(&:$(&8! 8$%! .(&,872! 8$58! 57%! .7%6/14%!
5,6!7%4/514%!/,!8$%/7!=(7-!%8$/.'!5,6!$51/8';!!I8!/'!>2!1%4/%)!8$58!F%3&82!
H/-%88r/,8%,8/(,5442! >/''3(-%! .(,.%7,/,:! 8$%! .5351/4/8/%'! 5,6!
%93%78/'%! ()! $/'! '.%,8! 6/'.7/>/,58/,:! 14((6$(&,6'! /,! :/?%,!
'/8&58/(,';0UU!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!
V,(8$%7!%93%78!.(,'&48%6!12!^7;!Q5'4%2!=5'!E8%?%,!</.%42D!5!37()%''/(,54!
3(4/.%!6(:!875/,%7!5,6!/,'87&.8(7;!!^7;!</.%42!'5/6D!*V'!5!37()%''/(,54!3(4/.%!'%7?/.%!
6(:!875/,%7!5,6!/,'87&.8(7!I!.5,!'52!=/8$!7%5'(,514%!.%785/,82!E:8;!H/-%88!/'!,(8!
5.8/,:!/,!:((6S)5/8$!8(!5?(/6!/,.(77%.842!/6%,8/)2/,:!'(>%(,%!5'!5!3(8%,8/54!'&'3%.8;0!
I,!7%:576!8(!5!?/6%(853%!()!5!'.%,8!4/,%&3!$%!?/%=%6!$%!$56!8$/'!8(!'52K!*L$%,!8$%!
8$%(72!()!(6(7!5,6!/8'!875,')%7!57%!7%?/%=%6D!5,6!8$%,!.(&34%6!=/8$!8$%!.45/>%6!
51/4/8/%'!()!E:8;!H/-%88@'!6(:'D!E:8;!H/-%88!-,(=/,:!8$%!4(.58/(,!()!8$%!857:%8'!/,!8$/'!
4/,%S&3!/'!8$%!>('8!4(:/.54!.(,.4&'/(,!(7!6%6&.8/(,;0!V)8%7!5,!%98%,'/?%!7%?/%=!5,6!
5,542'/'!()!H/-%88@'!37(.%6&7%'!5,6!5.8/(,'D!^7;!</.%42!.(,.4&6%6!8$58K!*I8!/'!>2!
(3/,/(,!E:8;!H/-%88!5'!5!875/,%7!5,6!$5,64%7!/'!5,!&,37()%''/(,54!.$574585,r;o$%p!/'!
/,.(>3%8%,8!5'!5!3(4/.%!'%7?/.%!6(:!875/,%7;0UX! !
!
!
H/-%88!$5'!,(=!.(>%!&,6%7!5885.-!)7(>!(8$%7![&578%7';!!V'!8$%!45='&/8'!
.(,8/,&%!8(!%93('%!$/'!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!)(7!=$58!8$%2!57%D!5!'>544!:7(&3!()!'-/44%6!
45=2%7'!$5?%!>(&,8%6!/,.7%5'/,:42!'&..%'')&4!5885.-'!(,!8$/'!+&,-!'./%,.%!/,!
/,6/?/6&54!.(&78!.5'%';!!
!
!
I,!E5,!M5./,8(!W(&,82A$(>%!()!8$%!37('%.&8(7!=$(!$23%6!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!5'!
1%/,:!*5'!7%4/514%!5'!F<V0A588(7,%2'!E$/74%2!Z5..&'S\(1%4!5,6!Z/442!_5?-/,6!87/%6!5!
>&76%7!.5'%!/,!M&,%!()!8$/'!2%57;!!#$%!.5'%!5:5/,'8!8$%/7!.4/%,8!=5'!15'%6!(,!5!'.%,8!
4/,%&3!3%7)(7>%6!12!H/-%88!5,6!$/'!6(:';!!V)8%7!5,!/,./'/?%!5,6!=%44S%6&.58%6!.7(''S
%95>/,58/(,!()!H/-%88!12!^';!Z5..&'S\(1%4!8$%!+&72!7%8&7,%6!=/8$!5!?%76/.8!()!*<(8!
a&/4820!/,!8$/78%%,!>/,&8%';Uh!
!
!
F52'!458%7D!(,!M&,%!"UD!OeegD!588(7,%2!E8%?%,!a/41%78!'&..%%6%6!/,!37%?%,8/,:!
H/-%88!)7(>!8%'8/)2/,:!/,!5!.5'%!/,!$/'!$(>%!.(&,82;!!V)8%7!5!8$(7(&:$!37%'%,858/(,!12!
^7;!a/41%78D!8$%!C(78!Z%,6!.(&,82!6/'87/.8!+&6:%!7&4%6!8$58!H/-%88!=5'!,(8![&54/)/%6!8(!
8%'8/)2!5'!5,!%93%78!1%.5&'%!H/-%88@'!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!45.-%6!7%4/51/4/82;Ug!
!
!
J8$%7!45=2%7'D!4/-%!Q7/.!E&,6%!/,!Y(&'8(,D!$5?%!54'(!1%%,!'&..%'')&4!/,!
37%?%,8/,:!8$%!&'%!()!'.%,8!4/,%&3!%?/6%,.%!/,!.(&78!.5'%';Xe!
!
!
V,!514%!45=2%7!)7(>!C(78!Z%,6!W(&,82D!F%7%-!E>/8$D!$5'!5>5''%6!5!$&:%!
5>(&,8!()!/,)(7>58/(,!(,!H/-%88!5,6!$/'!*'./%,.%;0!!^7;!E>/8$!$5'!.57%)&442!37%357%6!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
UU!E%%!V))/65?/8!()!F(&:45'!Y;!\(=72;!!V33%,6/9!V;!
UX!V))/65?/8!()!E8%?%,!F;!</.%42;!!V33%,6/9!V;!

Uh!V4%9!L&->5,D!W4&+$F(+1$D'6<&-+$T75$A4')5+$7<$XYYZ$84&"-&D!QVE#Qi!VFbJWV#QD!M&,%!"TD!Oeeg;
Ug!#75,'.7/38!()!H7%87/54!Y%57/,:!58!"UPSUT!cb(4&>%!OdD!#%95'!?;!M&'8/,!V4%95,6%7!cOeegd;!

!

Xe!V))/65?/8!()!Q7/.!E&,6%!cV&:&'8!"TD!Oeegd;!

!

"O!

5!'((,S8(S3&14/'$%6!353%7!)(7!6%)%,'%!588(7,%2'!8$7(&:$(&8!8$%!'858%!8(!&'%!/,!
5885.-/,:!'.%,8!4/,%&3';!!
!
!
!
!
%"='$&"(&*,%+"(%$0>",)$%&'()$'1+!'(&'$
!
!
I'!8$%!%?/6%,.%!6%7/?%6!)7(>!5,2!'.%,8!4/,%&3!7%4/514%N!I'!/8!'./%,8/)/.N!E$(&46!
/8!1%!&'%6!/,!#%95'!.7/>/,54!.5'%'N!!
!
!
#$%!5,'=%7!8(!8$%'%![&%'8/(,'!/'!*,(;0!
!
!
!
I,!/8'!7%3(78!8(!W(,:7%''D!8$%!<58/(,54!_%'%57.$!W(&,./4!'5/6!8$58K!
!
*#$%7%! 57%! 8=(! ?%72! />3(785,8! [&%'8/(,'! 8$58! '$(&46! &,6%74/%! 8$%! 45=@'!
56>/''/(,! ()! 5,6! 7%4/5,.%! &3(,! )(7%,'/.! %?/6%,.%! /,! .7/>/,54! 87/54'K! c"d! 8$%!
%98%,8! 8(! =$/.$! 5! 3578/.&457! )(7%,'/.! 6/'./34/,%! /'! )(&,6%6! (,! 5! 7%4/514%!
'./%,8/)/.! >%8$(6(4(:2! 8$58! :/?%'! /8! 8$%! .535./82! 8(! 5..&758%42! 5,542B%!
%?/6%,.%! 5,6! 7%3(78! )/,6/,:'! 5,6! cOd! 8$%! %98%,8! 8(! =$/.$! 375.8/8/(,%7'! /,! 5!
3578/.&457! )(7%,'/.! 6/'./34/,%! 7%42! (,! $&>5,! /,8%737%858/(,! 8$58! .(&46! 1%!
85/,8%6! 12! %77(7D! 8$%! 8$7%58! ()! 1/5'D! (7! 8$%! 51'%,.%! ()! '(&,6! (3%758/(,54!
37(.%6&7%'! 5,6! 7(1&'8! 3%7)(7>5,.%! '85,6576';! #$%'%! [&%'8/(,'! 57%!
'/:,/)/.5,8r!E(!/8!>588%7'!5!:7%58!6%54!=$%8$%7!5,!%93%78!/'![&54/)/%6!8(!8%'8/)2!
51(&8! )(7%,'/.! %?/6%,.%! 5,6! =$%8$%7! 8$%! %?/6%,.%! /'! '&))/./%,842! 7%4/514%! 8(!
>%7/8!5!)5.8!)/,6%7@'!7%4/5,.%!(,!8$%!87&8$!8$58!/8!3&73(78'!8(!'&33(78;0X"!
!
!
E.%,8!4/,%&3'!)5/4!%?%72!8%'8!'%8!(&8!51(?%;!!#$%2!57%!,(8!)(&,6%6!(,!5!7%4/514%!
'./%,8/)/.!>%8$(6(4(:2;!!H75.8/8/(,%7'!4/-%!H/-%88!7%42!%,8/7%42!(,!8$%/7!(,!8$%/7!(=,!
/,8%737%858/(,'A/,8%737%858/(,'!8$58D!5'!=%!$5?%!'%%,D!57%!7/664%6!=/8$!%77(7'!5,6!
12!8$%!6%'/7%!8(!34%5'%!3(4/.%!5,6!37('%.&8(7';!!#$%!!*'./%,.%0!()!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!/,!
#%95'!$5'!,(!7&4%'D!37(.%6&7%'!(7!3%7)(7>5,.%!'85,6576';!!I8!/'!1%/,:!375.8/.%6!12!
*%93%78'0!=/8$(&8!%93%78/'%!5..(76/,:!8(!,(!7&4%'!%9.%38!8$%/7!(=,;!!
!
!
V,'=%7/,:!8$%![&%'8/(,!()!=$2!8$/'!*'./%,.%0!%?%7!.5>%!8(!1%!&'%6!/,!8$%!
.(&787((>'!()!8$/'!'858%!/'!1%2(,6!8$%!'.(3%!()!8$/'!7%3(78;!!E5642D!8$%!&'%!()!8$%'%!
3$(,2!8%.$,/[&%'!+(/,'!5!4(,:!4/'8!()!(8$%7!45=!%,)(7.%>%,8!)75&6'!&'%6!8(!.(,?/.8!
8$%!/,,(.%,8;!!V'!&'&54D!8$%!:(?%7,>%,8!$5'!3%7'/'8%6!/,!&'/,:!8$/'!+&,-!5,6!/8!$5'!
1%%,!&3!8(!5!)%=!1(46!45=2%7'!8(!872!8(!'(4?%!8$%!37(14%>;!!
!
!
#$%'%!%))(78'D!,(!>588%7!$(=!,(14%!(7!'87(,:!/,!/,6/?/6&54!.5'%'D!57%!,(8!
%,(&:$!8(!3&8!5,!%,6!8(!8$/'!375.8/.%;!!
!
!
H7('%.&8(7'!5,6!3(4/.%!57%!.(,8/,&/,:!8(!&'%!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!8$7(&:$(&8!8$%!
'858%;!!#$%2!57%!53357%,842!$(3/,:!8$58!8$%!.(,87(?%7'2!(?%7!8$%!&'%!()!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!
=/44!'(>%$(=!:(!5=52!5,6!8$%2!.5,!:%8!15.-!8(!1&'/,%''!5'!&'&54;!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
X"!E#_Q<a#YQ<I<a!CJ_Q<EIW!EWIQ<WQ!I<!#YQ!`<I#QF!E#V#QEK!V!HV#Y!CJ_LV_FD!14;&($,(8%!PD!58!hX;$
!

"P!

!
!
#$%/7!8$/,-/,:!/'!37(15142!7/:$8K!8$%!%))(78'!()!45=2%7'!/,!5!)%=!.5'%'!=/44!
,%?%7!1%!%,(&:$!8(!%756/.58%!8$%!=/6%'37%56!&'%!()!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!/,!#%95';!!V'!4(,:!
5'!8$%!:(?%7,>%,8!()!8$/'!'858%!)5/4'!8(!5.8!>(7%!3%(34%!=/44!1%!5..&'%6!5,6!
.(,?/.8%6!(,!8$%!15'/'!()!8$/'!&,'./%,8/)/.!5,6!3$(,2!*%?/6%,.%;0!
!
!
230)$30%$)"$>'$!"('$
!
!
#$%!533%4458%!.(&78'!()!8$/'!'858%!$5?%!)5/4%6!8(!37%?%,8!3(4/.%!5,6!
37('%.&8(7'!)7(>!&'/,:!+&,-!'./%,.%!4/-%!'.%,8!4/,%&3';!!#$%!)5.8!8$58!H/-%88!5,6!
(8$%7'!()!$/'!/4-!57%!'8/44!1%/,:!&'%6!/,!.7/>/,54!.5'%'!5,6!:/?%,!)7%%!7%/,!8(!?/.8/>/B%!
8$%!/,,(.%,8!/'!5!'56!.(>>%,8!(,!8$%![&54/82!()!8$%!#%95'!.7/>/,54!+&'8/.%!'2'8%>;!
!
!
!
V.8/(,!=/44!$5?%!8(!1%!85-%,!12!8$%!4%:/'458/?%!5,6!%9%.&8/?%!175,.$%'!()!
:(?%7,>%,8!8(!37%?%,8!8$%!)&78$%7!&'%!()!8$/'!*'./%,.%;0!!L%!.544!(,!8$('%!175,.$%'!
()!:(?%7,>%,8!8(!6(!8$%!)(44(=/,:K!
!
!
!
";!
L%!.544!(,!8$%!C(7%,'/.!E./%,.%!W(>>/''/(,!()!8$%!E858%!()!#%95'!8(!
.(,6&.8!5!)&44!/,?%'8/:58/(,!/,8(!8$%!&'%!()!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!5,6!8(!37($/1/8!
8$%>!)7(>!1%/,:!&'%6k!
!
O;!
L%!.544!(,!8$%!#/>(8$2!W(4%!V6?/'(72!H5,%4!(,!L7(,:)&4!W(,?/.8/(,'!
8(!/,?%'8/:58%!8$%!7(4%!8$58!+&,-!'./%,.%!$5'!3452%6!/,!#%95'@'!:7(=/,:!
,&>1%7!()!)54'%!.(,?/.8/(,'!5,6!8(!7%3(78!8$%/7!)/,6/,:'!8(!8$%!4%:/'458&7%k!!
!
P;!
L%!.544!(,!8$%!a(?%7,(7@'!J))/.%!8(!/>>%6/58%42!'&'3%,6!8$%!:/?/,:!()!
:75,8!>(,%2!8(!5,2!3(4/.%!5:%,.2!&'/,:!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!5,6!8(!/''&%!5,!
%9%.&8/?%!(76%7!)(71/66/,:!8$%!&'%!()!8$/'!3$(,2!*'./%,.%0!12!45=!
%,)(7.%>%,8k!
!
R;!
L%!.544!(,!8$%!37('%.&8(7'!()!8$/'!'858%!8(!7%?%7'%!8$%/7!&,+&'8!.(&7'%!
5,6!/>>%6/58%42!.%5'%!5,6!6%'/'8!)7(>!5,2!)&78$%7!&'%!()!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!/,!
.7/>/,54!.5'%'k!!
!
T;!! L%!.544!(,!544!3(4/.%!5:%,./%'!/,!8$/'!'858%!8(!'8(3!&'/,:!'.%,8!4/,%&3'!
/>>%6/58%42k!
!
U;!
L%!.544!(,!8$%!V88(7,%2!a%,%754!()!#%95'!8(!'8(3!&'/,:!'.%,8!4/,%&3'D!
8(!.(,6&.8!5!)&44!5,6!.(>34%8%!/,?%'8/:58/(,!/,8(!%?%72!.5'%!/,!=$/.$!'.%,8!
4/,%&3'!$5?%!1%%,!&'%6D!5,6!8(!5/6!/,!8$%!7%4%5'%!()!5,2!3%7'(,!.(,?/.8%6!(,!
'&.$!8%'8/>(,2k!
!
X;!
C/,5442D!=%!.544!(,!8$%!4%:/'458&7%!8(!35''!>%5,/,:)&4!45='!37($/1/8/,:!
8$%!&'%!()!+&,-!'./%,.%!/,!8$%!.(&787((>'!()!8$/'!'858%!5,6!8(!544(=!)(7!8$%!
7%4%5'%!()!./8/B%,'!=$(!$5?%!1%%,!?/.8/>/B%6!12!/8;!
!

"R!
The Habeas Citebook: Prosecutorial Misconduct Side
The Habeas Citebook Ineffective Counsel Side