IDAHO DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION
«Protecting YOII alld YOllr Commlwlly"
C L. "13UTCH" OTTER
Governor
_::s::::::::::;z_~-...... ....__ k~-....

BRENT D. REINKE

e::,::aee_.. .

..ea:e:ie:Z5Z__

~_

•

Dileclo,

---.-.-

I

j_;:C;;._,",-~

28 August 2008
Pg1

Phillip Valdez, Warden
Idaho Correctional Center
P.O Box 70010
Boise. Idaho 83707
Dear Warden Valdez
This letter is in regard to our meeting held on 22 August 2008 with you, myself, and
Lieutenant Tim Higgins, IDOC Gang coordinator and 100C Investigator.
The intent of this letter is to outline the issues we discussed resulting from an initial analysis
of violence at ICC, speak to follow on actions, and address future expectations and
planning.
My concern relates to in"mate safety at ICC resulting from the increased violence in recent
months.
Since the beginning of 2008, incidents of violence at the Idaho Correctional Center has
steadily increased to the point that there are four Incidents for every one that occurs in the
rest of the Idaho state operated facilities combined. During the month of July 2008 alone
there were 17 batteries at ICC.
Information has been compiled from alii 05 Incident/Exercise Notification Report forms sent
from ICC reporting any act of viole"nee for the period of January 1, 2008 to August 5, 2008.
Investigation files available concerning these incidents have been reviewed at length by Lt.
Higgins. Using the IDOC Offender Tracking System and the IDOC Corrections Integrated
System, He took a look at what had been done by ICC to modify this inappropriate behavior.
He reviewed any evidence of gang involvement and the preVious disciplinary histories of the
assailants. He also reviewed complaint letters sent to departmental administrators
concerning the violence at ICC. Finally, he interviewed several of .the offenders that were
involved in these incidents, as well as the staff directly involved in the investigation and
disciplinary process.
'

EXHIBIT

"

.

CONFIDENTIALIATTY·EYES ON I.. Y

.!

. CCA RlGGS006483
,.1

-

•

•

·:
Pg2~

The reported incidents of violence were grouped into four categories. These included:
1. Extortion for Rent (15 Reported Incidents)
2. Extortion to Force Inmates to Assault Other Inmates (5 Reported Incidents)
3. Aggravated Bat1ery (18 Reported Incident)
4. Simple Bat1ery (34 Reported Incidents)

I
.r

The contributing factors to these assaults are summarized as follows:
Criminal Referrals: Major crimes that are being committed at ICC are not being referred to
the Ada County Sheriffs Office for investigation and prosecuHon. Ada County Sheriffs
Office confirmed that no crimes that occurred at ICC in 2008 have been referred. Criminal
prosecution is a major deterrent against commission of violent crimes and is a common
practice in all state operated facilities.
Disciplinary Offense Codes: When disciplinary action was taken against the inmates
involved in these incidents of violence, they were found guilty of "Simple Battery",
"Intentional Injury" or "Horseplay". No one was found gUilty of "Aggravated Assault" or
"Aggravated Battery", This issue greatly affects classification and accountability issues.
Classification Exceptions: Inmates were being retained In medium custody that should have
been moved to close custody
Poor Qua!i!y Video Cameras: The quality of the video recordings of the incidents using the
facilities close circuit sUNeillance system is poor.
Not All Incidents are Fully Investigated: No investigation reports were located for eight
incidents of violence in 2008 that were brought to the attention of the investigation staff
Protective Custody Investigations: The Investigator reportedly does not see Protective
Custody Investigations that are normally written by the Unit Managers and submitted directly
to the administration.
Investigation Office Staffing: All of the investigative staff operate independently from each
other with their own chain of command and areas of responsibility.
Investigation Office Organization: The filing system used for investigations is very difficult to
locate specific investigation case files.
Lack of Vigilance/Complacency: Gang members have been able to operate openly with little
.
fear of being held accountable.
Following the last assault at ICC the Virtual Prison Program Deputy Warden, Jeff Henry
notified Ada County. Ada County responded to ICC and filed a report. Subsequently the
detective involved also arranged a meeting with IDOC and reviewed the report. The
follOWing referrals were made during that meeting whioh were not previously referred for
prosecution by ICC.

CCA.-RIGGS006484
. 3'1
·'1

'CONFIDENTIALlATTY EYES ONLY

•

Pg3

The cases that should be reviewed for potential robbery charges (I.e. 18-6501) include:
Offender-an-Offender Assault, 3/22/08, involving Mour 85306, Peko 84109 and Lay
80221,
Offender-an-Offender Assault, 4/13/08, involving Traylor 77314, Lewis 67529, Bashale
67199, Price 66757 and Schmidt 81591.
Offender-an-Offender Assault, 4/20108, involving Cheever27031, Boyle 41355 and
Boyle 49018.
Offender-an-Offender Assault, 4/23/08, involving Auperlee'47551, Ward 82368, Pickens
87382, Hausner 65723 and Dunn 66064.
•
•

Offender-on-Offender Assault, 5/10/08, involving Riggs 37783, Hausner 65723 and
Schnoebelen 81050.
Offender-on-Offender Assault, 5/25/08, involving Bradley 68370 and Ellison 82685.

One case should be reviewed for potential witness intimidation charges (I.C.
•

18~2604).

It is:

Offender-on-Offender Assault, 3/05/08, involving Knappenberger 87530, Stropkai 87621,
Oshea 72566 and Dunn 66064.

Based on the thresholds and criteria defined by Ada County, no cases should be reviewed
for potential aggravated assault or aggravated battery charges (I.C. 18-905 and 18-907).

(

ICC has submitted a Facility Lockdown plan to address future assaults in the facility and that
plan is being reviewed. While this plan does attempt to address individual assault's as they
occur, I believe it does not properly address causal and systemic factors.

Therefore I am in agreement with the recommendations made in the report. I have listed
them below, and have added my comments as well. I believe that these systemic
procedures will be more effective in the long term than reactive lockdowns which also
punish inmates that are not involved with the violence.

1. All major crimes should be immedIately reported to Ada County so that they can be
properly investigated and prosecuted. Referrals send a clear message to the inmate
popUlation that the facility is taking violence seriously and that new charges may result
with longer sentences.
2. The facility should develop an effective method of behaviormodifioatlon in order to
reduce the incidents of violence. The disciplinary process needs to ensure that inmates
are held accountable at the level commensurate with the offense they committed~ When
simple battery is predominate as the charge to violent offences if sends a message of
complacency and allows the inmates to sustain a violent culture without commensurate
consequences. Contractually ICC is required to follow IDOC policy 318 (Disciplinary
Procedures) . IDOC'sexpectation is that ICC correctly and consistently apply the correct
category of offence,

----_.---,

...

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTY EYESONLY .

CCA_RIGGS006485

,"
Pg4

3. Investigations need to be more thorough and better documented. The investigator
should review all protective custody investigations and will need 10 develop a better
investigation file system. Investigations should be consistently formatted and an
administrative review should take place that includes follow up action such as criminal
referrals, follow on investigations that dig deeper into problem areas, and violent inmates
identified and dealt with.
4. A number of operational changes will be necessary to get staff to pay more attention to
what is going on in the unit and to make it more difficult for inmates to commit acts of
violence with out being immediate detected. Frequent tier checks, follow up on
information reports, cell searches increased by quantity and quality,supervisor
accountability in high violence units to name a few.

It is our desire that these systemic issues be addressed in addition with security procedures
that address specific acts of Violence.

of

IOOC and ICC have had several meetings over the last couple months regarding this
issue. The specific contractual areas that apply are 02.20.01: "At all times which inmates
are in its custody, the contractor shall provide security and control of inmates, and 02.06.00:
"Contractor shall develop and implement safety...procedures".
Contractually ICC is reqUired to follow policy number 309 "Conduct of Inmates", which says
in part that inmate behavior in violation of local and state laws may be reported to legal
authorities for jUdicial action.
Please prOVide a written, formal response to this letter by 15 September 2008 regElrding
how Ice plans to fully apply implementation of policy 309 by including a proper legal review
. of crimes. How ICC plans to insure the correct offence category is applied in disciplinary
offence reports as required in policy 318. And a detailed plan to reduce alf acts of violence.
A consistent plan to as correctly as possible Identify and hold perpetrators of violence
accountable. A movement plan that works with other 100C facilities to keep STG members
from organizing.
Be advised that looe will be tracking future assault reports, and acts of violence. The
contract monitors will be folloWing up with ICC on Ada County referrals utilizing a
documentation trail that Elisa follows up on OOR offence codes and outcomes.

Cc: Steve Conry, Executive Vice President Prisons
Andrea Mihm, Senior Director of Business Development
Corrections Corporation of America
10 Burton Hills Blvd
Nashville, Tennessee 37215

CON.FIDENTIALIATTY EYES ONLY.

"'.

CCA_RfGGS006486
0.

.

,.; ..-

'IDAHO DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION
"Protecting Idaho through Safety, Accountability,
·Parfnershlps-And Opportumties for Offender Change"
;

C,L "Butch" Otter
. ". ~.J~:O:Yo~m·p.r:."....
........ •..
":."--

.

... " Plt~ptot'.. .
,-.... ,. - •• ' ._'.........__.•.

';'::-."

Date

August7,2008

To:

Randy Blades
Warden of the Virtual Prison

.;

Brent D Remke
. .. '." ...•:'

TIm Higgins
Investigation and Intelligence Coordinator

j,'

. ..
~

Re,

Imbal AnalysIs of Violence at the IdE!h'o Correctional Center
.•. ....,.~_ ... '~ ":,.::..::.~: ".~--.' '-.", ':..~":'

'.

';"

...

".... ....

. .,

OVERV!.§\'}!

,

..

Since the beginning of 2008, IncIdents of VIolence atthe Idaho Correctional Center has steadily Increased to
the pOlOt that there are four incidents for every one that occurs In the rest of the Idaho state operated facilities
combined. Dunng the month of July 2008 alone there were 17 batteries at ICC. I was asked to review the
inCidents of Violence that have occurred at ICC In 2008 and try to detenmne some of the causal factors
I compiled information from all 105 Incident/Exercise Notification Reportforrns sentfrom ICC reporting any·act
of Violence for the penod of January 1, 2008 to August 5, 2008 I then went to the Idaho Correctional Center
where I reViewed all investigation files available concerning these Incidents and determined who was Identified
as being Involved Using the IDOC Offender Tracking System and the IDOC Corrections Integrated System, I
took a look at what had been dona by ICC to modify this Inappropriate behavIor I reVIewed any evidence of
gang IOvolvement and thaprevlous dIsciplinary hlstones of the assailants, I also reViewed complaint letters
sent to departmental administrators concerning the violence at ICC Finally, I interviewedseveral of the
offenders that were Involved In these InCIdents, as well as the staff directly involved in the investigation and
disciplinary process
DEFINITIONS.•
illS important to first understand the definitions for the types of cnmes I will be describing
include.

In

thIS report They
'

Aggravated Batterv. Acts of violence where weapons were used, where there were multiple assailants
attackmg a lone Victim, and/or where the VictIm was seriously injured. The force used was likely to produce
great bodIly harm
Extortion' The crime of oblalnlng something sUch as money, Information or services from somebody by using
force, threats, or other Illegal methods
Simple Battery The willful and unlawful use of force or Violence upon the person of another, or actual,
intentional and unlawfullouchlng or striking of another person against the WIll of the other, or unlawfully and
intentionally causing bodIly harm to an individual.
Simple Assault· An Inlentlonal, unlawful threat by word or act to do violence to the person of another, coupled
With an apparent abllily to do so; and commllbng an act that creates a well-founded fear In another person that
Violence is Imminent

ICC ASSAULTS REPORT DOC

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

PAGE

1

-.. EXHIBIT
lI!

I-Ltlt,
CCA_KELLY020569

~

f

.~ .
'.1'
.\

l'

FINDINGS·
It IS Important to understand that what Is being reflected In this report are only those incidents that we were
made aware of and II does not Include those Incidents that the victims decided not to report It IS faIr to
estimate that for everyone incident we know of, there may be two that we do not ThiS IS especially true where
the victim was not seriously Injured and was able to conceal any injury Additionally, what was reported as
mutual combat may have actually been attempted extortion In one form or another The findings are based on
wItness and victim stalements found 10 the Investigation reports, video recording of the mCldent. an olher
eVidence col/ected during the investigation Inlo the inCident.
Attachment one to thiS report contains a summary for each inCident that was obtained from the 105 Incident
Reports followed by the results of the ICC Investigation. It also contains comments about each incident by the
assessor (Tim HigginS) and the diSCiplinary acllon taken for each Incident. The attachment provides the
specific Information about the IncIdents referenced below
The reported inCidents orvlolence were grouped Into four categories These Included:
1. ExtortIon for Rent (15 Reported Incidents)
,
Extortion to Force Inmates to Assault Other Inmates (5 Reported Incidents)
3 Aggravated Battery (18 Reported Incident)
4 Simple Battery (34 Reported InCidents)
2

ExtortIon for Rent (15 RePorted InCidents)
Weaker Inmates (predominately sex offenders) were 1),
:~,~,(~:rl§I!~J¥!~C,9:n.,liq
taken. Sometimes thiS Included teleVisions, radiOS, a 'i ,',p#s9n?llitbp~m"Vlg ,
they had to eilher get moved out of the housIng unltot, "", AO;'p'ay:::,a':mphtl:\ly'f~~,'" l$;~~,
~'(tP.~p
month but sexual acts were reportedly ac;cepted E1§,a $U~.&l;Jtu[~;df.f:!11.. '~g~~tO',tijlsWSQ
,rnultip.1~djeati~ii~:JliitIHh~t ml;ite.~~y'gJ1J~~JJ5n~pmp',Ued The as~~fI.~~k'lii, :~~t.~Ji,~:~:B;":W~S, rr.q'
'ffrn~irtiilir'
, B.:Qt¥6m~J?)J$:~'e.li!S:~
,~'C9lJ)rriWtO$,.#6~\bYjl:i:e,:,gang. This practice was usecfpredoffiiilately' by-the Aryan
,~mil~,!>j, "~ry,~,~;@n~C~,,;,\
:~;W~i~;'l~pi;cafW,pJesent dunng these beatings to ensure they were do~e as
;JO~ttUct$q !:iuts'ellaom;;JPlnediitthltlitfaJiM: FYt>"p!f.gps were turned over to the gang leaders who diVided them
among members These mCldents Included:
, ' 0

in '

. ,'_.

1 02/04/08, J·pod Extortion/Simple Battery (Single Assailant for Rent-No Known Gang Ties)
2. 02104/06, L-Pod Extortion/Simple Battery (Smgle Assailant for Rent-No Known Gang Ties)
3. 02/06/06, A-Pod: Extortion/SImple Assault (Smgle Assailant for Rent-Aryan)
4. 02106/06, A-Pod Extortion/Simple Battery (Single Assailant for Rent-Aryan)
5 03/10/08, L-Pod· Extortion/Aggravated Battery (MUltiple Assailants for Rent-Aryan)
6 03/22/06, J·Pod. Extortion/Simple Battery (Single Assailant for Rent-Sure/'io)
7 04/13/08, J·Pod: ExtortIon/Aggravated Battery (Multiple Assailants for Rent-Folks & Aryan)
B. 04/20/08, J·Pod ExtortlonlAggravated Battery (Multiple Assailants for Rent.Crlps)
9. 04122/08, A-Pod ExtortlonlAggravated Battery (Multiple Assailants for Rent-Unknown)
iDA 04/23/08, L-Ped' ExtortionlAggravated Battery (Multiple Assailants for Rent.Aryan)
11 05/10/08, L-Ped: Extortion/Simple Battery (Single Assailant for Rent-Aryan)
12 OS/25108, G-Pod. ExtortionlSimple Battery (Single Assailant for Rent':Aryan RWB)
13 OS/25/08, K-Pod ExtortionlAggravated Battery (Multiple Assailants for Rent-Unknown)
14 07/01/08, J-Pod: Extortlon/Group Aggravated Battery (MUltiple Assailants for Rent-Aryan)
15 07/29/08, C-Pod' Extortion/Simple Battery.(Single Assailant for Rent-No Known Gang Ties)
. ",Ext6djdtiitCli:For.ce"Ih"m."al~~"~~:"Ass~UII;Oth~nJima{es f(§'~ef!b~sd; lucia-en

ist

An Inmate was normally approached by several Aryan gang members and told he would either beat up an
Inmate that they Identified and take all hiS property or the gang would beat him up and take all ofhis property..

ICC ASSAULTS REPORT. DOC

PAGE 2

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020570

j..

"','

If he refused. he was Immediately attack,ed and all his consumable commIssary taken, If he told staff, the gang
would eventually retaliate agamst the Inmate through fellow gang members located In almost every facility
They were sometimes beaten several times until they agreed to follow instructions. ThIs practice appears to
have been done exclusively by Aryan Gang members. In some Instances this resulted In forced gang
recruitment The mmate Inltlally forced to participate later begms to receive part of the proceeds from others
and Willingly jOins the gang. These incidents included,
1, 03/05/08, Dining Hall' ExtortionlSimple Battery (Force to Assault ISlngle Aryan)
.2. 05/09/08, L·Pod. Extortion/Simple Battery (Force to Assault/Single Aryan)
3 06/01/08. Dlmng Hall' Extortion/SImple Battery (Force to Assault/Smgle Aryan)
4. 06/29/06, J·Pod. Extortion/Group Aggravated Battery (Force to AssaulVMulbpla Aryans)
5 07/11108, L·Pod· ExtortlonlGroup Aggravated Battery (Force to AssaUlt/Multiple Aryans)

Aggravated BatteN (18 InCIdents)
Known gang members nearly always committed the Incidents of aggravated battery, especially those by
multiple assailants agaInst a lone Victim Causes for these Incldimts vary on a case-by-case baSIS The
primary reasons reported included'

..

Retaliation for prOVIding mformatlOn to staff,
Retaliation for not dOing as Instructed by the gang,
Bemg a Nortel\o assIgned to live In an area dominated by Sure no, and
Vanous Intemal gang diSCipline Issues.

Th~

reported incidents Included'

11
11
11

i ~~~;' "., ::~~a:JJ~~~d.f~Vat~~\~~~~(}~~~~~:'

.'- ~i\:W~I;~~

:~)f~~)

3. :93/0", '~i.:,Ad~cdfA 'Bart~ry; i'!l!iplS't sS,ai apts~Sjl"rei\6L" r _''
,
4:g:~lQ,$!@lH~oq:'" ',"'.
J~~ifart~ :e," :_,.- ::':¢kmRiii~SHUi,Q,9!X~~",N~~~~91,W~~P'?I:!~1).;.5. ;O~I1,11.Qa ,,:l~:eQd~ l~lg9_

:l;}.f!tt.~f-Y.{(MU{tlpl!,-~,

6

J~$.L1r~n\'lmIY~J.NV~:aRQp:,~):'

7

14. iP6/26l081/U-P-o.d~-'-h;9~r.av.ate,g: eSltt!'lfY-(Muilip/tf M,f?~!I~Ol~gtl:ln.9)
15. J>:tA11108:j L:J;lQ~.r.:, fl;ggraYi;J!$!:l; ~~ff~ni,;(MWIj»a.Assi:dli:)lits"A{y~61

~~. :&f.f~~!~:~!'_ t:~~~l ~~~~t.~l:~·~~~:~I~&~t~;~~;\~;~l~~~~y~~ri.:'~~i~;~~~J~~~?',

18 !06/0310.8~,:A'iPP'r;f,.Aggi'ilvated Battery){MutuaLCpmbatIWe~p:o.Jis~NQA<noWn~Giintnffis >.
.'

",

•

• -. "_:_. ••

."....

_..

.: • '.'

•

.'.

"'.

• ,.

• ".

• ".

~

•

,.,' - .

• ••• ~

. -•• " ',,"

•••• " ••" -"

"=.•• _-" •• ' .

'.:

•

.:

SImple Battery (34 InCIdents)
While the vast majority of these Incldenls were SImple dIsagreements between two Inmates, some may have
been retaliation by a gang member and may have Invt!lved an mmate being forced to commit the act of .
Violence by a gang The reported Incidents Included:

1. 01/03/08, X-Pod Simple Battery (Mutual Combat)
2 01/13/08, I-Pod. Simple Battery (Mutuel Combat, Aryan Participant)
3. 01/15/08, Q-Pod. Simple Battery (Mutual Combat)

ICC ASSAULTS

REPORT DOC

PAGE 3

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

CCA_KELLY020571

4. 01/23/08, G-Pod. Simple Battery (Mutual Combat, Bureno Participant)
5 02/07/08, Medical' Simple Battery (Mutual Combat)
6 02/06/08, N-Pod: Simple Battery (Mutual Combat, Aryan Participant)
7 02/11/08, Education' Simple Battery (Suretlo Assailant)
8. 02/20/08, J-Pod' Simple. Battery
9. 02/21/08, M-Pod. Simple Battery (Mutual Combat)
10 02/22/08, K·Pod. SImple Battery
11. 03/06/08, West Wing Hallway: Simple Battery
12. 03/21/08, M·Pod: Simple Battery (Mutual Combat, Aryan Participant)
13. 03/22/08, X-Pod: Simple Battery (Mutual Combat)
14 03/26/06, DInning; Simple Battery (Mutual Combat, Blood vs Aryan)
15. 04/02/06, T-Pod: Simple Battery (Aryan Assailant)
16 04/02/08, ABC Foyer SImple Battery (Aryan Assailant)
17. 05/16/06, A-Pod Simple Battery (Aryan Assailant)
18. 06/19/08, Location Unknown' Simple Battery (Unknown Assailant)
19. 06/09/08, N-Pod' Simple Battery (Mutual Combat)
20 06/14/0Bi GHI Hall: SImple Battery (Mutual Combat)
21. 06/15/08, DIning Hall. Simple Battery (ArYfl,n A13~~lIant)
22, 06/28/08, !J:\~POd!SJi'trle;
llfal-::e:b.tilbaf), .,
23 07/06/0B,~)
.,jv~n:¢:~m~~ff JU~JI§llo Participant)
24. 07/09/08.;G,
'
25. 07l11/0B,'.
26 07116/06/
27. 07/17/06,t.
26 07/21/08,';,'.
29. 07/25/08,
30 07/26/08,.
31 07/27/08,
32 07/2a/OB,C
33 07/30/08/
34 08/01/08,':L

.";

CONTRIBUTING FACTORS
DUrIng the course of thIS reView, several factors that may have contributed to the Increase In vIolence were
noted.
Criminal Referrals' Major crimes that are bemg commJ~tratJQb:aW,rl~(~:er.ngJ~t~m~# to the Ada County
Sheriff's Office for investigatIon and prosecution Ada:Q9YQ.
.I(t'~:Offip¥::qqOmFti$.dJhat no crimes that
occurred at ICC In 2008 have been referred CTlmlnal;ft~q~~Q",
IS'? maJ:i>f'diHei'fenHigainst commiSSion of
violent cnmes and IS a common practice 10 all state operated facilities '
DiSCiplinary Offense Codes' When diSCiplinary action;W:a-~,tak@,@MlsnJ:lWiiimal~$'iQvolVed ihtlli!f,s'e
InCidents of VIolence, they were found gUilty of ·Slmpl'~,f:l,~tt~i)tt?~lht~Ii~,9f.f~nQNIY~;:[jr':,11.p.r$,~P!.?1Y.' ,;m~tPm=
was found guilty of "Aggravated Assault" or "Aggr~v:~t~g'li}£l~,~&.:,~~y,~n.t~QI..l9h.':m!=):t,jy;;tln\~s'We.¥pqi)'e!'W~r~;
involved, the victim had to be taken to the hospltal,aM@iflj;ii:(~e<:i,tlj1~;\\,~,~'~Iv.:eltb:y. mtilt\ple.r~$.$alh;\ri'f$::ao.q,;
was likely to produce great bodily harm The Issue of eldoHibi:i wa(f.iio.tadt!r.e~~~$'dnhi§j~~y.!te,t,f Ir:Lr~\l'!t.i~!'l.ly
mInor pUnishment for major offenses.
ClassifIcation Excegtlons: Inmates were being retained In medIum custody that should have been moved to
close custody Reasons for this Included
• Incorrect dlscJplinary offense codes beIng used resulting In lower points bemg assessed.
• NumeroU!llnCldents lnwhloh the disciplinary offense reports were dismissed and never rewntten. In some
cases, staff was reportedly told not to resubmit disciplinary offense reports that had been dismissed,
.......... ::::- .....

ICC ASSAULTS REPORT DOC

PAGE

4

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020572

.

~:'~~7

-!!.~

•

~\~~;~~~~~~~~~":~~~'~l'd~'

....

.:''''''f: .:;;"~'

!':

:;'.i

The practice of only holding the offender, who actually' committed the violence, accountable and not
everyone Involved in the extortIon
-

r~~ii.jitt:;;;::rii!!!~~J!tiii;~

/g.aitle·tfiStete1opeiiih3pf~QiljQij.$if.w1i.~r~:-ij).~Y:El.r.~JostaIiBd, In qUickly determming exactly who was

J..

.

"involved With specific mCldents and what tool< pface

..•

In~._~,. ;~~.II·~~ii~'ill~ ~ .~J~~I~t~~!~,u\\q~
Internal reportmg system. All but one of these InCidents W~.t~J~
.s.0.n·'1 Q
"
.. s".
The remaining inCident was reported to them via emall.Jn:1tH.~JL . '.: l)'rfh.c!!
.... I~iedJ)eiow;. the,ass~ilaiJlt{
were Idenllfled by Informants and several suspects spenf1S'(jays',ri:restri6 IVEd1ousmg'but no formal
mvesUgation report was compiled or disclplmaryoffense report written In the other SIX Incidents, the victim
was interviewed and no further action was taken They Included'
.
1 02106/06, A-Pod, Extortion/Slmple Battery (Demotte 66673)
2. 02/06/06, A-Pod, Extortlon/Slmple Battery (Gasper 70721)
3. 02/20/08, J-Pod, Simple Battery (Dye 59305)
4 02/22/08, K·Pod, Simple Battery (Berry 79626)
5 03/07/08, A Pod Group Aggravated Battery (Soto 82317)
6 03/11/08, L-Pod Group Aggravaled Battery (Ramirez 87186)
7. 05/06/0B, L-Pod Group Aggravated Battery (Young 14130)
B. 05119/08, Location Unknown, Simple Battery (Nelson 72449)

:j

.·n9r~~fi;Pt~W.~fl~~:.q9.~~QdY::.J(lYJ.!,~!i9.~}p.~~

-.

;;~:~~~k~n~;::a:ling$~;:.t~~~ .y.:1t~~~~~~~1~~W'~

':lo'tl)e admml$tta~IQtn·1h.edli .' - .

. . .~~y,!f~~B:?r:C6$.:::~~~~:'~~J.~:

.'

:0.0'

;lnfl:lrm~lioltaool.j' .. :o.6:'/s' beh'fnd~th'e:act5:orfiJisp.eti.i:h.lct:in the facility arid could be used to solve other cases.
•••

_

M

'

••

_"

••••••••••••

j!l\!"~19¥t1tlli;.~~I~a:~1a.ffln?rf';i,j:·~fu1b~·;Wy.~,~11~:~lN~::$.(~.tt~:i?:W~te:i.rid'ep.etide!\tl'itr.Qitt:eii~ti·:o.ih.~t~Wi.Jh;:lli~J.f!9,WB)

;'. _

,J~pmm~nqi!ilni;l:l3.rn!i\!f 9f;J51~9n$Jbl"tY;•. TIi~:.IC.G.;.lnY~.s.tlgmQr·f)O'!TP.~IJy.!hl:lr:t~I~?;a.lj 11)v,"\n~t1g~JI9n~:~p~;!~

~:i":1i::~iii!!~lWfiil~i~~i:~1

;jiTi~slble-fQflj!h.t.·to.m~:¢fi~_t).9~~T;~~l,IllS:111:Jn:v..e_~tig§lijl?.ti:s:bel~j::l\brie:f·ahd,lacKlng;detall
'.Ellb')~t~.QJlfl3.IYi~ia.i~~9!if~.Ij:g~(~ifM~!.l.l:i$e.m~otnnodEt:

. '. - ... -.

...

Ttie,offi~e.;(~:QP.J~[i;lJ~!i.!

..

ri!:Tne!fihng system used for invesbgallons IS confupJng ~t 1:l~!31 and It was very
Case numbers are not used and:lnvesli'gationfiles are
organlzeifby either the assaiiaries"or fhe vlcllm,I\'!~(n~rt\.~Jn
," e·'. :\~PTl~,~Y;th~:sft~;lijlir9'iIiatqdjiff.rt()f
placed Into an investigation file but are only being f<~f~iil,e,tirf!i.,
.. i]J@;c9Ji.rRut~r;iWnrBMb:e:pliffiWWi .'
Investlgator cannot access The Invesllgallon flle\$y~Wiiils' ctjllca.; ."t'r.ei.l~a('¢hahd ·tf.~D·q '~·H.<i.l~.~J§.",Wh!bn;;~t¢.
the mam components of intelligence collection. ;Addi~lii.n_~liYAI1~;~IG-PbQr8IhEi!or: ;:;;:lrt::l;'~:~'Gr.ea.te&a;ri:u:mp~b~(
gang files that he could nollocate when I requestedjh.l~tD;: I~a]jlpe,a:r.s:lhat:tb:as:t:i fiI~s areJjfifog((emov..E@:!tqiiJ':
the office without his knowledge. Staffs access to the .lnvesti~atJoi"s·offlce should be tightly controlled

Jov 'm)'

::d

' aT,

,; . . .

.~i'atil:jn;caseflles

Lack of Vigiiance/Complacency' Gang members have been able to operate openly With little fear of being
caught. This was evident by the fact that many of the Victims were attacked by large groups of offenders
~.".":'

'. , ..

ICC ASSAULTS REPORT DOC

PAGE 5

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020573

..
~

.~.

,

almost Immediately after pelng moved onto the Unit After beallng the offender, they commonly walked out of
the cell carrying the victim's teleVIsion, radio, shoes and a pillowcase containing all of the Individuals
commissary. The staff In the housing units reportedly does not observe this happemng In almost every case,
the victim or another Inmate brings the Incldenlto the attenllon of staff. Additionally, several of the victims
reportedly notified staff they dId not feel safe being moved Into the JKL area, which IS beIng used to house the
more problematic general population inmates 8taff reportedly Ignored these warnIngs.
As an example, Inmate Pitchford 85665 was assigned to A-Pod, which IS normally used to house 'weaker'
offenders who may need to be 'sheltered' so as not to be VIctimized On 7/18/06 he was told he was being
moved and reportedly warned staff In the gym three or four limes of times lhat If he was moved to J-Pod h~
was going to be assaulted This unit contains a lot of predators who are known to vlcllmlze seX offenders,and
he knew the other Inmates were aware of his crime. Staff told him that If anything happened, he would be
moved Once in J-Pod, as he entered the tier, he agam lold the officer that he did not feel comfortable going
on the tier and agam was told he would be moved If anything happened While at his cell door. he had to walt
approximately 5 minutes for the officer to open the door. He was secured In hiS cell With his cellmate for
approximately 30 mmules when Ihe cell door was unsecured. 4-5 offenders enleredand told hiS cellmate to
leave. They then began to beat him and took all hiS consumable commissary. The reported acllons of the
assailants were very bold Once the cell door was unsecured, II was a very short period of time before the
group entered, acted, and eXiled wllh no fear or concern with gettIng caught

;

.!.

CONCLUSION
I would recommend the followmg steps be taken to reduce the violence In the facility:

1. All major crimes should be I""mediately reported to Ada County so that they can be properly investigated
and prosecuted. Ada County should be made aware of the crimes of violence that have occurred at ICC so
far In 2008, but It IS doubtful that eVidence has been handle at a level were prosecution IS sllll possible.
2. The faclhty will need to develop an effective method of behaVior modification In order to reduce the
inCidents of Violence The diSCiplinary process needs to ensure that mmates are held accountable at the
level commensurate with the offense they committed.
' .
3. Investigations need 10 be more thorough and better documented. The Investigator should review all
protective custody investigations and will need to develop a better investigation file system.
4 A number of operational changes Will be necessary to get staff to pay more attention to what IS gOing on In
1he unit and to make It more difficult for inmates to commit acts of Violence With out being Immediate
detected
.
.~.

~.

ICC ASSAULTS REPORT DOC

PAGES

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

CCA_KELLY020574

,Iit"--: "'·~·':"~~,t",-':"~=·: ..r'~:.. r,:.,r:~l'~ "~~.r.

~.,

.:~:':=i!~~;

Idaho Correctional Center
Incidents of Violenc~
January 2008 - August 2008
Thefollowln9 are the acts of violence involving tnmates housed at the Idaho CorrectIonal Cenler that
were reported to the Idaho Department of Correction thaI look place between January 1, 2008 and
August 5,2008 Following color code was used.
.

'I'

;

- :'

Summary obtained from the 105 IncIdent Reports

j' Results of the ICC Invesllgatlon

1;

Comments about the IOcident by the Assessor (Tim Higgins)

'. _." ..! Gang Affiliation, Disciplinary Action Taken, and Time In Restrictive Housing

_01/03/08,1627 hrs. X-Pod

'tYPe: Assault Offenaei"riii offender
Involved: Scott 19845 and Rulz 86892
Summary: Inmate Scott and Inmate Ru)z engaged In mutual combat In X-pod. Both Inmates were laken
to medical for evaluation and both were placed In segregation Only superficial injuries aXlst on both
partlcipants
ICC Investigation Findings Fight over tOilet paper ownershIp Both Inmates received OaRs (Archibald)
Mutual Combat! Simple Battery ~ based on only minor inJuries, no weapons were used, and the one·onone combat reported
'

01/13/08, 1450 hrs. 1- Poo, Cell 118
Type: AssaUlt: Offender on offender
Involved: Cunningham 83211 and Robinett 32518
Summary: Inmate Cunningham 83211was assaulted by his cellmate Robmett 32518 In 1~118 Inmale
CunnIngham stated that he attempled to defend hImself during the assault. Cunningham was treated by
on-Slle medical staff. no further treatment was needed Both mmates were restrained, taken to Medical for
evaluation, then Segregation pending Investigation.
.

ICC Investigation Findings ThiS fight was over a loaned radiO Both

Inma~es

received OaRs (Archibald)

Mutual Combat/Simple Battery - based on only mmor inJuries, no weapons were used, and the one-on~
one combat reported.

.01/15/06, 1321 hrs, Q-Pod
Type: Assault Offender on offender, Use Of Force. Physical Reactive
Involved: Woodhall 68399 and Riley 25586
Summary: Inmale Riley 25586 entered Q-Pod from Intake and engaged in a physica/altercabon With
InlT)a~e Woodh,all 68399 who was reSiding In Q-Pod. Staff was presen~ on lhe pod and was able to stop
the;iight,·B6th·lrJmaias.w~re.es.bo.rted;outorthe urut W.hlJe.:P.ffic.rit. H.uJJ.W1;!~.·l;Jscortmg Inmate Riley out of
lhs'pod, R.II~y' a~gt~ssi\iei)ni.Jf.h.~cf5ackto.wa!ds i!i~. p-q9}lf1~.;Wfiiigo~?f4~.rnore Inmales in the pod
Offfc~r Hull phY$lc,l,llly re.~tr<jine:d ..t.h:El';r~f'lf.\~ ftom~d~a.h()I~:Q.:.10Wfi:\"d~)~e·6lher inmates on the pod. Both
Inmat~s were tal<~n'I(} medlG.!31 for ElyalU~llQn and_pJaced,m se,gr.egallpn

Altachmenll

-Page I -

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020575

:".~.

;'

.~

ICC Investigation Findings. ThIs fJght resulted from a conflict from several years earlier After being
released from pnson, Inmate Woodhall moved In wIth Inmate Riley's wife Problems developed and when
she eventually forced him to move out, Inmate WooghaJi threatened her and actually "put his hand on
her" Both Inmates receIVed DORs (ArchIbald)
Mutual Combat/SImple Battery - based on only minor InJunes, no weapons were used, and the one-onone combat reported

01/23/06. 0646 hrs, G-pod. Dayroom
Type: Assault. Offender on offender
Involved: inmates(s)' Fuentes 26509 and Corte~ 79754
Summary: Inmates Fuentes Bnd Cortes (Sex OJJelJder) were Involved In a physical altercation Inmates
were given several verbal commands to stop TIgJJfiQg Upon amval of ERT, they both Jay on the floor and
were restrained,' Inmates were escorted to medfcalfor evaluation. Both Inmates were then escorted to
segregallon.
ICC InvestigatIon Findings ThIs fight was over simple disrespect Both Inmates received DORs
(Archibald)
Mutual Combat! SImple Batterv - based on only minor InJunes, no weapons were used, and the one-onone combat reported.
.

JifS\.1:p&L C

f%JQN~d;'l~9g~~Z~~~ti~~·~~Je!>.(~r
82990
Summary: Inmate Roberts exited J Pod and reported to Counselor Rose that he had been hit He stCited
that It was Inmate Lester that had hit him while to Cell 216. He was then placed Into hand restraints and
escorted to Medical for evaluation and then Segregation. After fInishing the feeding of JKL umtlnmate
lester was questioned by Counselor Ashcroft and Office(Guiterrez, At which time he admitted to being In
Cell 216 attemptmg to take Inmate Roberts' commissary. He said that when Roberts went to stop him that
IS when he hit Roberts.

'C~ Investigation Findings Inmate Hansen 61926, Fu"er;7~~~'1:?nJ:!~w6.tt~t?.9A~'fp'~Jj ." JI!1~9;;P~M,',_
uSing Inmate Roberts' cell for tattooing for several weeks'3 119 R9l;left~ Cl;)rnpl~lnep.;ta .
,1Ima.te;,lnmSlt~.,
White 73648 told the victim he had to get off the tier and·fiil'nded'fiim:aJljlfoW¢'~s:e'l9:;NIIWt!!if9.!?rr,I"J.l~~~lJY
or he would be asseulted. When Inmate Roberts refused;JD,q.WL'j~{~Jt~:q~~];fJ.Q.5IJp)11,at~~~~l'f,lr·e~g~o~
(Archibald)
. ..
"ExloJ1lon/Slml?le Battery.- based on personal property taken by force, only minor Injuries, no weapons
were used, fhere was only one assailant and the victim did not fight back It could be argued this was
robbery

: Noilii'KnoWij . .

ANochment J

-Page 2-

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020576

1

..:.:....,.

:.

.. 02/04/08, 2000 hrs,. Ld?od, Cell 205
Type: Assault' Offender on offender
Involved: Stropka187621. Rhodes3B209

_.~ii\f~:ti!!i!~!f!f;;r*1i~:1iE~tdlOa
:I0"-~$U9:a!!tlJ:A.t¢.Ii).f:j~.IgJM1.n~'W~~Jn.Y9Jv.~~ItJ:;a:{!glH:wit.fj!J~iJ)~~e::Efi.·g~~~1.it9~flJlt

...20S'

ICC InvestrgalloQ Flndrngs.lnmate Stropkal 67621 told Inmate Rhodes to give him his commissary and
agree "lci·pa{$10 !3"monttY"ln rent or to get off the tier When Rhodes refused he was attacked by Inmate
Stropkal Since Rhodes admitted to defending himself both offenders receIved DORs for mutual combat,.
(Archibald)

Extortlon/Slmple Batterv • based on personal property taken by force, only minor Injunes, no weapons
were used, there was only one ai~saJfant and the victIm did not fight back. It could be argued this was
robbery.

,.It!~"-.M_"
~
..
L

"

02/06/08, 102Q hrs, A-Pod, A-Cell 117

Type: AssaUlt: Offender on offender
Involved: Demotte 86673
Summary: Inmate Demotte was discovered by staff to have mUltiple bruises and an abraSion on hiS body
as well as a healing black eye. Inmate Demotte was restrained and escorted to Medical for further
observation While In Medical I asked inmate Demotte what had occurred and he stated "I can no longer
live at thiS FaCility, there are too many of those kind around",lnmate Demotte was escorted to
Segregation Pending an Investigation of iii pOSSible Assault

:t
•. ~

ICC Investigation FIndings. No investigation report was located

On 2/8/08 Inmate Maine 57375 told Unit Manager Rodnguez that Inmate Corley 84202 and Moore 78203
assaulted Inmate Demotte, He also Identified Inmate Hausner 65723 and Inmate Hemmmg 73253 are
the Aryan Kmght Leaders calling the shots. ThiS information was sent to Investigations and the ICC
administration via email on 2/13/08 at1 023 AM,
Extortlon/Slmple Battery· based on personal property taken by force, only mmor inJuries, no weapons
were used, there was only one assailant and the victim did .not fight back It could be argued thiS was
robbery
: ~.

02/06/08, A-Pod,

D~li§ifs4i~ffiiii~I'!!~1~t~~d

';?,?nt J9 rnvest~9.ah(;ln.-s..a_nd ~tt)~: ICO:admlriislr.aIIPn';iI.la,e!r.i1~lJ _9.l1k~11WPE! .a!1 Q~3:AM:·:
ICC Investigation FindIngs, No investigation report located

Attachmentl

-Page 3 -

CONFIDENTIALlATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020577

·

.~;.

ExtortlonlSlmple Assault· based on personal property taken by threats of violence, lack of InJunes, no
weapons were used, there was only one asssilant and the victim did not fight back It could be argued this
was robbery

02/07/06. 1110 hrs, M-R/M10
Type: Assault' Offender on offender
Involved: Hernandez 45325, Walker 74902
Summary: These offenders were Involved In a physical altercahon Both Inmates sustained superficial
InJunesOffenders were both evalual~d by MedIcal and then escorte.d to SMU In restraints.
ICC Investigation Findings Inmate Hernandez failed to sand off Inmate Walker's (Sex Offender) name
from a radiO he was given that was later confiscated by staff Because of this security staff were able to
trac~ the radiO back to Walker On 2/06/0B Inmate Walker was angry with thiS and punched Inmate
Hernandez In the face and mutual combat developed. (BergqUist)
Mutual CombaU Simple Battery - based on only minor InJunes, no weapons were used, and the one-on·
one combat reported
'A8_I111"--'=-~--------="'"

04lo6/0B, 1400hrs,

N.~

.,c- - ,,----.----~- .... ~-- -.

...

..-.--.._ ......., ..... 11.11~

pod.

'type: Assault: blfende(on offender
Involved: Bedke 85B77 and Joe21540
Summary: Inmate Bedke and Inmate Joe admitted that they had been fist fighting at 0630 hours that
morning. Inmate Badke and Inmate Joe were both evaluated to medical and escorted to segregation
ICC Investigation Findmgs What started as horseplay turned IOta a fight Inmate Bedke made racially
demeaning comments to Inmate Joe calling him a "Squaw" and the fight was on Both Inmates admitted
to Involvement with the fight. (Captain Melody)
Mutual CombaU Simple Battery - based on only minor inJuries, no weapons were used, and the one-onone combat reported.

....

-, . '.:'

-:. ..

.. :::..-:::..:":-.

.-:.~::.~~

'

'

.'

.

02/10/06,1830 hrs, J-110

Type: Assault: Offender on offender
Involved: Williams 38901
Summary: Inmate Williams approached the pod control In unit JKL OffIcer Danforth noticed blood on
inmate Williams 8ms and face Inmate Williams olalms he wes assaulted In hiS cell but refused to proVIde
any addltlonallnformahonabout his assailant or assailants He was evaluated by on-site medical staff
and placed In segregation pendm9 investigation
ICC Investigation Findings, Several offenders beat him because he snored Inmate Hamilton 75910 was
hiS cellmate and this appears to be a paid hit Two members of the Psycho Soldiers gang, Inmate Trent

Attachment I

~Page

4-

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020578

,

•.

'.!

>'.

•

.':,.

60338 and Inmate Brannon 66056 told the victim he had to get off the tier When he refused he was
beaten Both AssaIlants received a DOR No action was taken on the cellmate (Archibald)

Aggravated Batterv - based on there being mUltiple assailants attacking one vlcllm making serious injury
highly likely
.

.

.~

02(.11/08, 0721. hrs, Education Room # 3
'type: AssaUlt"Offehdefon offender·······,·
Involved: Archunde 61477 and Ray 79612
Summary: Inmate Ray assaulted Inmate Archunde In Education Room # 3 Both Inmates were placed In
wflsl restraints, escorted to medical for evaluation and then to Segregation wlthoLitlncldent

ICC Invesllqatlon Findings, Inmate Ray attacked:.lntjjate;Af¢f®:n~if~w6,~tq.{~ not fight back. Inmate
Archunde knew thet Inmale Ray had testified ag~ln:§tf.lq.m.:~;ptb~r!m:na.t~s.\and had been telling other
offenders Inmate Ray was a "Rat". Only Inmate Ray r,(;(9~!V~~;'~nt):OR~ ~.~ergqUlst)

'!:

Simple Battery - based on only minor inJuries, no weapons were used, there was only one as~allant and
the victim did not- fight back

02/14/08, 1355 hrs, A·Pod.
'Ty'pe:Assaiilf'Offenaefoii offender
.
. , ....'
',' .''''''.'''~
Involved: Riggs 78722, Burns 73304, Castro 7293gd:!a~:e$.al~)~~tidi~~ii~iI{Q~Ji11@2
.
Summary: Inmate Benavidez reported to staff Ihall1~;ni:ld .I:~~~r.(~!l~:~Ul!~l;j:~Y;:S.4f~h9;;gi!pgJ@'~fup'~f~:,and'
told to move off the Pod. An Immediate InvestigatJqf'!''W~$;p.rC:iih~tech·.bY; lJi.ljtMi:iij·eg.efRoQng!JeZ;~,'A.lL· .
Inmales In A-Pod were secured to theIr cells and s~tT~~6'1IrCom~plat~)up.p~l'tq:(~-g:,$.J;it.t~t1v~@r:Q~e,ci~~
Al approximately 1645 hours, review of the recorded vld~9;;rQQI§t!\'.W.?~i~·9m.P.!~J~.,J.W~~~.BPo.P'lpg"~~JQ~J:£i
Inmates were Involved In the assault Four out of the five inmates were Identified These mmates are '.
known or aSSOCiated With the SIG Surefios Inmates were escorted to MedIcal for further observation and
then proceeded Inlo Segregation pending DIsciplinary charges.

.le{;}.Ji'iveSilgahdnt'ElhdIT\9srti:)!J!7 $ureno gang menj·~:~&. !i!nJ~[.e~ h.·,s c;eU:a"!ld attacked Inmate Benavidez

··s.)tTiPW:~~~.i.i.~W:h~·

.···'.a}f:ij~flMq:·gang member

H~;'!~fiJ~:@J~~(fc!ei:itJf9,Jh!?~,e Involved Video was
e.ddhatJnffiate Riggs 78722, J~4.11)$.:7339.4}9ElRttQ:7?938, and Paz 63812 were the
assailants and all four were written DORs (BergqUist)
r~Vl~i#~d'I!!ljli;~$ta·

Aggravated Battery· based on there being multiple assailants attacking one VIctim making serious Injury
hIghly likely.
.
•

••

•

•

•

..... ~,>.,: ..-. ..•.. :.'

..• -.':'

.....

02120106, 1'540: hrs; J~Porf.J:&09'
Type: Assault.' Offender on offender
Involved: Dye 59305

Attachment I

-Page 5·

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020579

.~

"

·.

~

:..

t'

~:

SummalY~ijnm~f~ ~

(S~~tOJf~naer)was observed by Officer Alumbaugh to be In distress Officer
_ 1i:iJ]jc~)~·PY,l3;·ii'1 r~ferenoe to his behavIor at whloh pOint, he stated he had been
assaulted:in hls;celblJimal~(was';lil!'COi:t~dJo Medical for further observation and then proceeded to
Segregation pending Investigation of a possible Assault. Upon completion of this Invesltgatlon a 105
Notification follow-up will be mailed If It'IS concluded that an Assault has'occurred
Alumbaug:~g'u;~lrt1.

ICC Investigation Findings' No investigation report located
Simple Bettery • based on only minor InJunes, no weapons were used, there was only one assailant and
the victim did not fight back.

:

-

-,.":.,"

02/2.1/08; 1310 hrs; M-Pod.

Type: Aifsaulr-offeliaer"oii offender
Involved: Plokens 87382 and Noms 7683B

.

~mi'~=!~~~"~~ff~~"~?~i!1!:'M:=1i!t:~:t
to
Eb

ihO:iata-s.Wat~

.'.::eyalui:lt~..

d; p!~ge9.J.!'l\l?~g.~g~Jj9,Ji,

ICC Investigation Fmdmgs. This fight was over a card game Both reoeived DORs (Archibald)
Mutual CombaU Simple Batterv - based on only minor inJuries, no weapons were used, and the one-onone combat reported..
~--

-;;"-

...

,

.:'-~

:

.:

_.

--..:

02/22/08. 1423 hrs, K-Pod, K·204
Type: Assault Offender on offender
'11i'VQ/Ved-; B:ei~ 19626

.

:'$u;Mfit~~N:nrtm~I.~;~~rry.w.~9.,~i.~R~y'er~~·:~Yi~ffi~t Fry with fresh contusIons and brUISing to the face

In ., . ':stated;hifllad1)een:9ss'aulff,jd WMother Inmate and would not disclose any further
'.

.rrim?WB~·r[Y:was::.'rfjsfrath~d,::~:o~.~li~¢.O'rted
to Medical for further observation and then

.etfed:ii.iitfS~gtegatJpri
for-:lnve~tl9~tI9n·.Qf:f;~sault
-."
.
~

ICC Investigation Findings No investigation report located

;Blmple Batterx - based on only minor InJunes, no weapons were used, there was only one assailant and
lMliictimCJidl10t fight back
-

•

....

•

•

'

*'

..' .....•.

~""

.. I,
".., ..""

,:.

,..:.--.;:.:

""-

.

. 03105/0B, 1121 hrs, DIOIng Hall

7t.;J!:~~J;~W:~:~~~;;~n~~g~B~ld:}~frQ.p.f<i~::~15~n

;.,

...

!

.<.

•

$UmrnatY:)ntn$.($;}<ntip'p.enburgerWEjs:/livqlyedJrt~·p'.I'iY.~r~liIl'l'l't~r~aijon with Inmate Stropkla In the

Din'j'~·ii:H.all.the·.allerga;flP:n',W<ls.inLi~Q"!I;'bgtt.J 1f)m.~Je!? lj.t~.()~ #pc'~JW~ same time and started sWinging at

igacI:iQtl:jer-Wtlh:cJo~ep·flsl~)3p!hlhmEitEis

o.b_s'y\3l;iV$'r!:1l3I:Cfirediii.eIHo.stoP fighting and lay down on the
floor, Both Inmates were then restraimid, escorted to Medical for evaluation, and then to Segregation.
ICC Inveslrgalron Findings Inmate Knappenberg 87530 said Ihat Inmate Dunn 66064 and Oshea 72566
took hiS commissary and property (radio, lamp, envelopes) and ordered him 10 beat up Inmate Slopkia

At1achment I

. -Page 6 •

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020580

67621 or be beat up himself Inmate Slopkla had testified against Inmate Wixson 87523 and Inmate
Wardlaw 87624 dUring an armed robbery case. Inmate Stopkal and Inmate Knappenberger receIved
DORs for mutual combat (ArchIbald)
Extortion/Simple Battery - based on personal property taken by force, only rillnor InJunes, no weapons
were used, there was only one assailant and the victim did not fight back It could be argued this was
robbery

.••,.•. .:..';"T.,,,!:r:•..-•.'"'.,.,.• .•."--'-: ..,.", ...
~

~~[.

. .'

'- ..'-::;:;:, .....

·~f~,(!jff~~'··-~ rff~~:~;~:::'

hivolviJa: 'Boiittiei"'1l3389 ang Tlm.1O 59552
.'
... '.. ,
'Summary: During In.!;H~Y.~!JJ(i:
.. jj~nhijl_e~~)?Qul;ti~'a:$5aulr~~~lfjfua.te:Jrri:iiC:$jr.fiQ:~;W~j:\t
Wing Hallway. Inm~l!il?:¢Mi:tr~r '.
·jl1!i'fip.l~JUti'~':I?i:1.tj)1!hm~t.~,S;P9.trfQ!t~q,Jimfl;·:gffi9~(S.~ verbal
directives to cease,:frQJ:jl!Nfi3n.if:;I!~f!\:,trn~Jh.:~'sl!.~t¢nJ~q~l.11t>q'9,gitl:ie~~!3,I~.)Diir~t§~~9~m.e.r,':·~M:TJi1'ri-o::were
then restrained with vmst restraints and taken to Mei;l!Q8.Jif§r"i:!V?!.tii~tjoiH:lhd thetj.[d.th~S~g(¢:9~tIQ.rt
Management Unit for housing Neither'rnmate had any'suoshiilfial j'oJuTles," .'

.i 'atiotrikdih s;jom~t~·j!=lrelTly,W~bf:l~h 64577 (AK) wrote Inmate Tlnno a letter saying the

." .... ' .~::w'Q-m~:~~~,~!i~l~m.@J:M!Mffl.~~li~(~.Tinno requested protective custody but was denied

~~u.s,~ ~~'J~f.tj~$9'Jd:p.roijjdiftiarrie$;:I{~p.:tiitgqtt this was a staged fight In an effort to keep Inmate
Tmno from being assaulted by others Inmate Bolilier was his friend and pretended to beat him up hoping
It would sallsfy the Aryans. (Archibald)

Simple Battery - based on only minor inJuries, no weapons were used, there was only one assailant and
the victim did not fIght back
•• _.... '~::.' _._.

,':"., •.•• _.. -::..'-_ ....._.:• • • .,_..... '" ••_..

_'J••','

03/07/0B, 0533 hrs, A Pod
Type: Assault. Offender on offender
,!lJvolved: S~to ~2~.E. .", ..... .'.' .... ".
'Summ;:Il:y:::lnmale,Uiibe.'744.61:ti:>JdOffjcer.-:Lopez, Danny that Inmate Soto (Nortello) had been assaulted
'Irl'Arp.()~ 'll:i~ i.l19.h~::~~tQt~ :M~~!~tiiv~lua~bn;' revealed numerous scratches, abrasions and brUIses on
lO'mate,sot6's:iJack..:A6Jnv·a.&tlg~tr.onjbti::ftb;~;assault IS ongoing. Inmate Soto IS not cooperating and
refUSing to give a.statement. A-pod was celled up, a knuckle and hand check was conducted, with
negative results Inmates from A -Pod were then escorted one at a time to A -Pod counselor office for
mterviews Resulls of the interviews mdlcated that the assault could have been STG related. All matenal
from the Interviews has been tumed over to the STG officer for further Investigatfon.

ICC Investigation Findings No investigation report located

Aggravated .Battery - based on there being multiple assailants attacking one victim makmg serious Injury
hIghly likely ... . .
.

:l)3109/08; 1413 hts, cH.jibd.Daymom
Type:. Assc!,ufb Dffende'r,qooffen"t~(

Involved: Fox 70553, Martinez 71869, Lopez 72129, Mcleod 70912, Valdez 63761 and Torres 76972

Attachment]

·Page? -

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020581

,

.~

·

.~.:

.~

'! .-'

Summary: An Inmate on Inmate fIght broke out In H-pod Dayroom between approximately 7 mmates. A
response team arnved on scene at 1415, at that pOint the fighting had ceased and all the Inmate were
secured in their cells Unit staff was then able to Identify six of the approximate seven Inmates as
combatants. and STG affiliates The seventh Inmate was Identified as a non-combatant, and Is not known
to be an STG affiliate at this time The SIX known combatants were evaluated by Medical and housed in
SMU Inmate Valdez, DaVid 63761 was taken to Saint Lukes Regional Medical Center, per order of Dr.
Garrett for additional medical treatment Per order of Chief of Security Villarreal GHI was place on Lock
Down pending an Jnvesbgabon Into the fight. Addilional mformation will be senI as it becomes available
ICC Investtgatron Findings Inmate Valdez 63761 (Surano) told Inmate McLeod 70912 (Nortei'lo) that all
the Nortenos had to leave the NorthWlOg or they would be attacked Inmate McLeod gathered a number
of Nortenos together in the chapel (Fox 70553, Martinez 71869, Lopez 72129, an Johnston 78202) and
they went together to H·Pod to confront Valdez IrjJi1iate McLeod pulled Inmate Valdez out of hiS cell and
all five Norte~os began to beat him Inmate Torres 76972 (Sureno) came out to help Valdez and half of
the Nortenos turned on him and beat him up as well (Archibald)

.. 0:3/10/06,·1349 hrs, Lopod, cell 202

'"tYi)s·fMsaulf Offelicel' on 'offehaer
Involved: Hoek 17808. and Dalbec 82220
Summary: Inmate Hoak was assaulted In L·202 by Inmate Dalbec Inmate Hoak stated that he did
attempt to defend hImself and that Inmate Dalbec was not alone In the assault Both Inmates were
restrained, escorted to Medical for evaluation and then to Segregation L-Pod remained on lockdown
pending the result.s of an Investigation Into the assault
ICC Investigation Findings' According to a CI I lntn~lel{p~*:was::atta.q~eQj~fjj:l::b.~J;ltj;ijj·!:!YA_nmate Dalbec
82220, Inmate Hausner 65723, and Inmate Ha'mlm6n.JS~:tQ~Ii'iroa.je!.f!~i$.KW,q4!:9~1}9n)r.o':i!lde information
about the assailants Only Dalbec received a DORJ;ia.~!}dt9l;1 p..h:y5I.q?r,,~:v.j~e~8.~9i?IJ¥~t~'~ (Archibald)
Extortionl Aggravated Battery - based on personal propertY taken by force and there were multiple
assailants making serious Injury highly likely It coul!j)e argued thiS was robbery

03/11108,1925 hrs. Lopod L-210
Type: Assault. Offender on offender
Involved: Ramirez 67166
Summary: Staff were notified to check on condillon of IOmate Ramirez (Nortet'lo), Staff discovered Inmate
Ramirez had been assaulted In his cell. Inmate Ramirez did not provide any information concermng the
identity of hiS attackers He was exammed In medical and then placed in segregation pending reView of
facility VIdeotape InJUries appear 10 be in the shapes of a combination lock.

ICC InvesbgalJon Findings No investigation report located

Attachment I

-Page 8 •

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020582

Aggravated Battery - based on there being multiple assailants attackmg one victim making serious Injury
hIghly likely
.

":'('

......... "~""" ;,
::.r,:

03/21/08,.2048 brs"MEod

Type: Assault· Offender on offender
Involved: Parton 80478 and Hueth 67427
Summary: While preparing to exit M Pod, Correcbonal OffIcer Dominique Juarez witnessed Inmate
Parton stnke Inmate Hueth two tImes In the face and then push him baqk mto the bunk area A "Code
Blue" (Inmate on IOmate) was called'and Officer Juarez ordered all the mmates to cell up, then separated
the involved inmates Into the multipurpose room. The Emergency Response Team and ascorted the
Inmates to Medical for·evaluallon and on to the Segregation Management Umt.

:~1,9~J~!~._

lid
dkw~ir;f!~eth 67427 testif!~~~,Q~Iti~frrtJn~,f.i:i!J)j9~gherty 59336 who shot up
j·nJ.s:.fjfW?o~;'~~~.r,
~L
,~IJ',1p'~,~J~mlOe debt. Inqlat~'P~I1Qn'BO!\rit(ft~9~erwood/AK) called Inmate
Hueth a rat and mutua combat took place. Both 0.ffen~~titX~:Q~N.~.!t;t;J?11U~·j (Archibald)

,_''.

Mutual Combat! SImple Battery - based on only mmor inJuries, no weapons were used, and the one-onone combat reported
••

-

II-

1

03/22/08,...1730 hrs, J-Pod. J.•.110..
Type: Assault Offender on.offender
Involved: Mour 85306 and Peko 84109
Summary: Inmate Mour alleged he had baen assaUlted In his cell Inmate Mour was escorted to Medical
for further evaluation and then escorted to Segregation Pendmg an Investigation, On Monday, March 24,
2008, Investlgatton was concluded and revealed that Inmate Mour was involved in an Assault on
Saturday, March 22, 2008.
ICC Investigation Findings Peko 84109 punched Mour 10 the back of the head when he refused to give
up hIs property Inmate Floyd Lay 80221 wh~ was also present stole Inmate Mour's shoes Lay and Peko
both received DORs (Archibald)
Extortlon/SlmpleoSatterv.- based on personal property taken by force, only minor Injunes, no weapons
th'erewas only one assaIlant and the victim did nol fight back It could be argued this was
robbery.

Wefe'Ljsed~

::o.~/2~·itf. :.~·:,.O~.·,~~_._~~rs·: . ~~~~.~:: _. " .:J~,
''tYlili; AS5ail'~oQ{fetidet 011"0. bdec'

Invoi'vei:f: 'Gafbrclith 19921 and Hogan 72580
,
Summary: Officer McCellan gave Inmate Galbraith (Sex Offender) and Inmate Hogan (Sex Offender) a
verbal directive to stop frghtlng In whIch they complied Emergency Response Team formed and enlered
X-Pod Dayroom at 0923 hours Inmates GalbraIth and Hogan were restrained by Emergency Response
Team Without mCldent Both Inmates Galbraith and Hogan were then taken to Medical and Segregation
without force or further inCIdent.

ICC Investlgallon Findings The fight took place over one mmate usmg the other Inmate's razor. Both
inmates received OORs. (Archibald)

Attachment I

-Page 9-

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020583

H

J

',:'.

·f

.:~

of:

Mutual Combat! Simole Battery· based on only minor InJunes, no weapons were used, and the one-onone combat reported
.

,

N1A'::::~ ~::~.

"

:,,:,...;~::;: ".':. NII(:~':-'~~' .... .",

..03/zelOS, 0535 hrs,. Dmnmg Hall
Type: Assauit, offEindar offender
Involved: Stinson 69870 and Huckaby 69665
Summary: Inmates Stinson and Huokaby were Involved In a mutual mmate on mmate assault. Verbal
dlrecllves were given, both Inmates were compliant and submitted to Wrist restraints without the use of
Oleoresin CapSicum Inmates Stinson, and Huckaby were escorted to Medical for an evaluation and then
to SMU without further incident

on

ICC Investigation Flndlngs'lnmate Stinson testified against one of Inmate Huckaby's associates named
'SlefdsoenffmafeHOcKao}thad previously went to Inmate Stlnsons house and threatened his mother in an
effort to try and get him not to testIfy. Inmate Stinson attacked Inmate Huckaby In retaliation and mutual
combat took place. Only Inmate Stinson received a DOR (Archibald)
.Mutual CombatlSlmpleB"~tl,e'X ..• based on only minor inJuries, no weapons were used, and the one-onone combat reported;

.03

. 035.hrs

H~Pod.,

..

~rll~i~d~~~~%~~~~iiP~t;Qlj'o~~:~;if?~~i ~n~:topez 52286
.~!.IJ1'!m~t-¥
p',ti~;~~~Q.~

....: '. ..

·9,~~ii;MIi\11.~fj~r Hi:lnsaker that Inmate sturgis was assaulted In hiS cell

.. pptoxiiiJafu/y{11:$O;;tjQUf.S; Rtl.rthi3r investigation revealed that a fight between Inmate

In

Siurgls" aifd Inmate Lopez cell'H·216. After the fight, Inmate Lopez left the cell and returned to his cell
H·209. A few minutes later, Inmate Bonham entered H·216 and assaulted mmate Sturgis All three
Inmates were restrained, escorledto MedIcal for examination, and then to Segregation.
ICC Investlgallon Findings Inmate Sturgis 29933 beaten in hiS cell by Inmate Lopez 52286 and Inmate
Hansen 61926. After the other two had left, Inm.i3te Bonham 67297 entered later and also beat SturgiS
Both the three assailants and the Victim received DORs for mutual combat (Archibald)
Aggravated Battery - based on there being multiple assailants attackmg one victim making serious Injury
highly likely

04/02/08, 1839 hrs, T-Pod
Type: Assault Offender on offender
Involved: Ison 67986 and ColuccI 79193
Summary: Inmate Ison and Inmate Colucci engaged In physical combat In T-Pod. Both Inmates
suslaIned superficlallnJunes Both have been exa'mlned by medical and both are In segregation pending
an Invesllgatlon

Attachment 1

·Page 10-

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020584

,.

":

;,lccifnvesiJ ··atioii#i·ndln·:'s~ in.m~r~:·!s.qi((~~:(;)ffen~er) worked as Porter (tnmata worker) In the
:Sl!!gt· .....ritfi1lt1;li;-dferilsetHb:hnhl;t~6iitr.a1)ahdJ~: Insane Outlaw and Aryan Knight gang members 10
\r~if.

.J~;.tiQ.~&iiig.,:fnit($·ta~.CPcI~i:;i:?J.Ja~g~~~n(~r;l,~Ji;T';Pod

without authonzatlon and attacked Inmate Ison

67986; Only Coilicci received a DOR (Archibald)

i

·f:

Simple Battery - based on only minor InJunes, no weapons were used, there was only one assaIlant and
the vICtIm did not fight back.

04/02/08. 1938 hrs. ABC Foyer
Type: Assault. Offender on offender
Involved: Case 85603 and Hooker 82963
Summary: InIliallnvestlgation reveals mmate Case assaulted Inmate Hooker In the foyer of hOUSIng umt
ABC Inmates were oompllant when given verbal directives by staff and laid face down on the floor. Both
Inmates were restrained and given medical evaluations and placed in Segregation. Inmate Case received
no inJunes . Inmate Hooker had minor Injuries
ICC Investigation fmdlngs Inmate Hooker called Inmate Case a "punk" so Inmate Case beat him up
Since Inmate Hooker did not fight back, only Inmate Case received a DOR
Simple Battery - based on only minor injuries, no weapons were used, there was only one assailant and
the vlctrm did not ft9ht back

04/08/08,,"1 B4Rt.lrs.. K~pod.,CeIl21"3. 6,

"Type: Assault-Offender on offender·
Involved: Cisco 55060
Summary: Emergency Response Team responded to a medical emergency In K-Pod Inmate CiSCO was
discovered lying on the floor of cell 213 Offender shows signs of haVing been assaulted Contusions to
the face and back, Small laceration on nose. EVidence of shoe pnnts to the face and rear of the head
Pod locked down, Staff conducting Imtlal checks of Inmates on pod.
ICC Investigation Findings Inmate CISCO was beaten by Inmate Sanders 62639, Inmate Fortin 72953,
Inmate Thompson 51260 and Inmate Lee 66268. VIdeo confirmed all but Lee (Bergquist)
.Aggra.vat~9.Batte!¥;-

basad on there being multiple assailants attacking one Victim making SBrlOUS mjury

highly likely

04/13/08, J-pod, cell #108
Type: Assault: Offender on offender
Involved: Traylor 77314
Summary: Inmate Traylor was allegedly assaulted In hiS cell J-108.lnmaleTraylor has red marks and
brUises consistent With his claims. Inmate Traylor was examined by on-sIte medical staff and escorted to
Segregation pendIng an investigation Into the assault.

ICC Investigation Findings Inmate Traylor was first beat up by Inmate Bashale 67199 (BGO) while
Inmate Lewis 67529 (Sureno) stole hiS property Later he was beaten by Inmate Pnce 66757 (AK) and

Attachment I

.Page il •

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020585

.'

..,.:

~'.~

Inmate Schmidt 81591 (AK) who then took his television. He was told he had to start paying rent or he
would be beaten up every day All four assailants received DORs (Archibald)
ExtortIOn' Aggravated Battery· based on personal property taken by force and there were multiple
assBllants makmg serious injury highly likely It CQ~ld be argued thiS was two separate Incidents of
robbery
..
: .•... ~

_.~.;=.--:':.~.-.-

.: "' __ •

_.t:•• :~.".~:::

::",.

~:;~~t:;.:, ::;,.~;:'
Senmidl";:·

04'16/08, .1252 hrs: C~Pod.
'Type: AssaulbOffend"er 6ii offender
.Involved: Mercado 84119, Colungo 81084, Chacon 55033, Barajas 81752, and Luna 83609
Summary: Officer Wilhams called a Code Blue (Inmate on Inmate Fight) In C-Pod Via the radiO. A total of
5 Inmates were restrained and escorted to MedIcal for further observation and then preceded Into
Segregation Pending an Investigation. Inmates Involved In the mCldent are members of rival gangs
SecurrtyThreat Group (Nortei"lo and Sureno)
IctnnVestfcialioi'l' Findings- fnm~j~·~e.·a.r:~Ja.s: B1752 (Norteno) saId he W-~~';lor~;.pWS:iii'~nq'gs.l1g)i'iern\j$ts
iMeicado'8W1,19·:·Colu~"
tiifH)B~.'
··f1o.CHacon
1-,;
-.·,.,.,
, ~ .•..."..Q!t·,~.-,.-.,.-,·
..-.,.3.
, ;. 55033) he had to g ef''-'~~'ed::off,'tffEf.·;·IH(r;tliEiieW!!ia1ifbeat
Jnov.. .,., U I . J .' <1'._ . " .. ,•••..•, •...
hlm;)~mat~'a'aiciJ~$;I;rn52douna;liimale;Lu.na B~609 (Nortano) and Jgg~U:I.e:r.tIJ.~y;!=!pm~wpf.).e..gia.i.ti:~JH~­
6oiltalruii!l'three Surerlo gang 1nl:inj'.' '19'~lYri@#J resolveJhe proble.m:.1~~·i~iitifu#fir~~v.eI9#~ ilotHhei'
three Sureno gang members j~mp"..
:.);U~d.:;R~-]i the two Norterlos with chairs, flstsatid feet
The Surerlos claimed they we~)p~.tni:llT)~;.'
, s All fIve offenders receIved DORs (Archibald)
Group Combat/Aggravated BatteD' - based on there being mUltIple assailants and weapons being used
making seriOus Injury highly likely
...: : - .....:.;.;,;,...:.,.. -~~ ....

__.....__..

',.:-'."'" ..

;;..

~

..... ..... -.
;

.

.'

04/20/08,2030 hrs, J-105B
Type: Assault. Offender on offender
Involved: Cheever 27031, Smith 49018 and Boyle 41355
Summ~.ry.: I WEill? .made aware of a possible assaulton Inmate Cheever Upon further inquirY of the
Ji;l~lP.~:hn~;~p,.9tkt~eJEl'c()r.9;~~:~aoll!tyviCiiilD.:f66~~a,r~\iealed that at approXImately 2030 hours Inmates
J?9YJ~'·~6W9m.ltti eDj~r)On)~~eCh~evet's;cellilnof:clqa~ithe door A few mmutes later Boyle and Smith eXit
;t6irc(iIl~WJtW~a:~a·9.;(ti'th~jrh$iJQ. Il1tngl~fC.h:~E!.y~r r~pQ.Ji~d his alleged assault to staff on ine Untt at
;~ppr.o~jiTJ~i~iy:Qg§pZbgWl;;.lrn:n~t~Jihe,av~r·w~~,.i.a;stfaJhad and escorted to Segregation pending further
Ihv.e~tig~Mn'..~"tI~:pra.~~cjed·t(;)':~aQri')lialtOi1;~eiidlmj' Investigation of Assault

:ICC:Ii:lVeSfI~atioi1FIj,dings· j~lJlt=!te:Gh:e~v.er2JP$:1;W~~:tJeEi:t~#.in hiS cell by Inmate Smith 49018 and

l/Tmatei:Boyla4t355 b~f6tfl1hey·i:;to'fe hiS propettY tnm·ate.EJiiYl~ told him that they were taking all of hiS

~.9m.mfs.§.$iYaocrchBrglrjj:i hlffi,$10 p~rmPhtf( (eti(IDiP.?I~qh$ever said he put a lock in a pillowcase and

iWas'gpiog. togq:Elft~nhe.Tti

b!Jt'Qn~'QJ

the olhe(lnrnates took II away from him Inmate Smith heard about

~nis:~n.~AaQ'l~;b?~k:8nd ~"~at up'~ri:la:t!'! ;CQeei)er:.a~econd time Both Inmate Smith and Inmate Soyle

received DORs (Archibald).

Attachment 1

-Page 12·

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020586

1

;

1

:~

• :4'.

.".~ ..~;,~ '"

."

Extortlonl Aggravated Battery - based on personal property taken by force, weapons bemg used and
there were mUltiple assailants making serious Injury highly likely It could be argued this was robbery

04/22(08, 1600 hrs, A-pod
Type: Assault: Offender on offender

.rt,~::~. .(;!~=~g~~~~;~~.i~~tfflf, .•nl~~~~rl~p

approached by three Inmates (1 HispaniC and 2 WKiJa~t~tc;il'shOWfI11S::R~-' ". 00: .Qt~;a.Dd;'v.;;'heh' 1i~~;~fU,~i)lp.J; he
was struck in the nbs and face with a closed fist A~RQ!t~~tm,!:g;~!l
o. ·c..O)Tlli!~,!ljl,d'~pp.J~(.'9..Q~Y'ii?r~9:
and knuckle checks Inmate Gentry was escorted to Medical for further evaluation and preceded Into'
Segregation Pending Investigation of ari Assault:

ICC InvestigatIon Findings, Three Inmates (1' HlspaOlc arid 2 Whites) approached Inmate Gentry and
demanded to see hiS paperwork to verify hIS cnme, When he refused they beat him and told him to get
out of the Unit No phySical eVidence was found dunng knuckle checks The Video was reViewed but the
quality was so poor that they were unable to Idenbfy the assailants. (Archibald)

,

:;

1

Aggravated Battery - based 6n there being muillple assailants attacking one victim making senous Injury
highly likely
.

,04/23/08, 1530 hrs. L-Pod

Type:-Ass'aulf:°'(:>ffe-nlfefo'n offender
Involved: Auperlee 47551
.
Summary: I was notified by staff of a possible Assault occurring on Inmate Auperlee Upon further inqUirY
of the IOformabon receIved, .Umt Manager Rodnguez dIscovered Inmate Auperlee with injUries to the face
consistent to the allegabons made, Inmate Auperlee, stated he was assaulted 10 hIS cell by two mmates
Inmate Auperlee Was escorted to MedIcal for further evaluation and then preceded to Segregation
Pending Investigation of an Assault
~l'tC·inve

-,Co"

$fidfn'nj'

"'f\'Pln'dii'j':'s; Jnm~te-A4p:erl.i;j~Mj;p&1,'\'\Iif~Reat up Inside hiS cell by Inmate Pickens 87382

)l8Z3.~!rT:Q·~~jh(:ip:${Qlel1j~f9o.mrm~.s~.ry,and some of hiS property and told him to get off

r ·.J~~9:~l,l~9U.h~Qentli.~·.:~.;j\Yq other Aryan Knights SItting at a table (Inmate
tla,~~p~r., .. ",,;r.. . . ' nT:@~~pynl'r66i)i34rafi'd:
.M lhe stolen commIssary with them (Archibald)

'tpe.Jj()~A

Extortlonl Aggravated Battery - based on personal property taken by force and there were multiple
assailants makIng serious injUry hIghly likely It could be argued thIS was robbery

:,~..

~.

.05/06/08,.06,10 hrs. L·Pod.
Type: Assault. Offender on offender
Involved: Young 14130
Summary: I was approached by Inmate Young. Inmate Young told me that he was not going to go back
to hIS housing UnIt and that I would have to put him In Segregation. I questIoned Inmale Young as to why

Attachment I

-Page 13 -

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

CCA_KELLY020587

he would not return to hIS cell, he stated that he had been assaulted by the Arian Knights on 5-5-08
Inmate Young went on to say that he dId nor want protective custody but that he was refusing to return to
L-Pod Inmate Young was. taken to Medical for an evaluation and was then placed In Segregation pending
the results of an Investigation
ICC InvestigatIon Findings No investIgation report located
Follow-on 105 was sent Indlcatmg Inmate Young refused to cooperate wIth the investlgatron a'nd no
eVIdence was dIscovered to substantrate his claim of an assault
Agqravated Battery - based on there bemg mUltiple assailants attacking one vIctim making serious Injury
highly likely .

.05/09/08,1730 "rs.

L- 213.

tYpe: 'ASsault" Offender on offender

Involved: Snodgrass 65760 and Brannan 66056
Summary: Inmate Snodgrass reported to Ms Rodnguez that he needed to be moved off of L-Pod due to
being pressured by the "white boys" into haraSSIng and IOtlmJdatlng newly arrtved Inmates Into the Pod
with sex crimes to leave the Pod Inmate Snodgrass stated he was nQt gorng. to partici ate In their games
Inmate Snodgrass stated that on Wednesday. May 7th, at:'il·p'p'r.9li;lr:o.!!t~!~!'1~~9.·
,;w.~s assaulteQ in
hiS cell by whom he believes to be Inmate Brannan for refuslli~{titrifn;olO'ejf'fiJ
() ,UWiI:·Pod. Inmate
was escorted to Medical for further evaluation and prececl~q,10f(r:s~gf~~lIar.( ,
.I1~i"~c.o:tnpletlon of
Investigation for a possible Assault.
.... ., - . .....
:
ICC Investigation Findings Inmate snQcl9.r~1?§:tt&1~it~·~I~f@'w.:~~:Q[i[ft~fI~b,Yifu:errlbeJsofthe Aryan
Knights to determine If newly arnved:l~mJit£$.)w~re~seX:Qff.eii.ifv'~"···~:i:Fffi'llf~y:w_~rg:lj~~W~~f,to order them to
leave the tier and take all of their prq~ef.t:Yi:w1ii¢.lth~;;W~\i,t.lg:Br:i.
~f.J!~'·fif:Y.:~.[J<i~@ft~:~~was ~rdered to
beat them up If they refused any of hIS Inslructlons,·WI)~!l,:ij~.....)t'!HgplhJ!fh~iwasdieat up inside his
cell by Inma.te Brannan 66056 (Archibald)
, ,.
.' ..

Extortion/Simple Battery - based only minor IOJunes, no weapons were used, there was only one assailant
and the victim dId not fight back and the victim was being forced to use violence against others as part of
an extortion scheme.

.' Srannalr'"

OS'pioioli 13'b"'6d=
17YPf*A . . tt~~. ... ~Kcih.::$taff

JtJyp.lv~~i Rlgg~\,.;·;J~~nc;! Schnoebelen 81050
Summary: Officer Dean called a Code Blue, IOmate on IOmata assault 10 L-pod via the radiO,
Inmate RIggs and Inmate Schnoebelen were IOvolved In a mutual combat assault Both Inmates
separated and obeyed all verbal commands once staff were on site Both IOmates were restrained and
taken to onslte medIcal for evaluations Neither IOmate needed offsite medical treatment.

'j CCJ.ilnve§i!gtiUbi1'Findin'gs; I'1il'l?f~/Hal,l.t>n€lr ·6.'5:7?:3; toI,d':lrimat~,'Iliggs::S7'7a'ftha~ hith$d"lq"i~;;lveritHfunit

'~~~;~i~'~~iu7~~~w~l:f'~~:~~~si~~~~~~~~':~f~:'~:~:fry1;~r;eV:~%~~~~.i~~~X~::'i~·;Wtfuem~e

Jnmate(;fai:lsiieEl<~ptWi;!tlf.h.iH~t.citd hlrn:h.e.IJE:l~~!3i:l to.\:l~t9.fnhe unit o(he;W~iUrd:be· b.ei3Jup)~.Y$Jy,.Qay.

(Archibald)

Attachment I

,

','

-Page 14-

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

CCA_KELLY020588

:1'

i.

~;;.
~~ .
. ';"'..:!.~ ..:"1" ~~'/:""':s~:

ExtortIOn/Simple Battery - based on personal property taken by forcB, only minor InJunes, no weapons
were used, there was only one apsailanl and the vicllm did not fight back It could be argued this was
robbery

O.6/1·2t68i·.j245,hrs;'J~P-od,

Typif: :'Assault· Offenaefon offender
Involved: Waller 78402
Summary: Sergeant Chaney discovered mmate Waller from J-202 A wIth fresh injuries to the face I
Interviewed mmate Waller In regards to a possible Assault. Inmate Waller slated he had been hit several
times In the face and body by the "white boys" AlIlnmales In J-Pod were secured to their cells In order to
allow staff 10 complete an upper body torso and knuckle check. Inmate Waller was escorted to Medical for
further evaluation and then preceded to Segregation for Investigation of a Possible Assault,

:T0eJil'

!Pt¢W.re.(

Jnm~te.:

~bii-:i'nd"
jtl((--" .

.'1.~

film ",', e682B8 told Inmate Waller 78402 that he had to take down the

@:ur

W~s not white and It could not be displayed In the Unit Later that day

'ate;t;,3'rnmey 76861 and Inmate Lee 68288 beat him inSide his cell and told him

to gel off t e unit. All three assailants 'received DORs. (Archibald)

.Aggravated Battery ~ based on there being multiple assailants attacking one Victim making serious injury
'hlglily likely"
.. -

, 05/-15/08,. 15.35 hrs,"J. Pod,
TyPo: Assault. Offender on offender
Involved: Ray 72981
Summary: Officer Bollenberg noticed Inmate Ray bringing hiS property down from the lop ller In J pod
Inmate Ray stated that he needed to leave the pod . Officer Bollenberg could see marks on Inmate Rays
face and head. Inmale Ray stated that he slipped in 1))1e shower causmg the marks on hiS head and face.
Inmate Ray was restrained escorted to medical and then segregation pending investlga~lon
ICC Investigation Findings' The Video showed thai Inmate Esquibel 63328 and Inmate Payne 70189 beat
him up ~ihsiae his cell" B9lfl assailants received DORs (Archibald)

Aggravated Battery - based on there being multiple assailants attacking one victim makmg senous Injury
highly likely
.

J)S/1610tk2G"4{j'hfsj AiPodJ3i3VI6ofir

'T:fJ~:g~'~4~~~}i~~,~~~~t~t(a$~,21'_

,_-,; .

.S~:m!Jl.a:n(:;Ttim~\edVldCtaiY;(S~x.:Qrreftd,f!t]JQI(t9J:fi9.er Danny Lopez that Inmate York slapped him in the
:fac%l!hApod~l:';,PaY(PQ.m af:~ppro~mat~ly:·~q49' lntnate York denies any knowledge of the InCident. 80th
inmates were restrained and taken to Medical for evaluation then to the Special Management Unit for
hOUSing pending an Investlgabon for assault.

At1achmenll

-Page 15-

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020589

"0:'

'.:..
,:'.• ~

'..:' ;',

~.

'.,

"'

~~ ~. ,~ ~',"':'·i.;i.

;"....Jo<f ...

..:

:~",.i

;.:

,i.'
';';~I

o;,,"~:

.'.

~}..

.:,;,"

'~."

ICC Investigation Findings Incident started as horseplay and escalated Into a flghl. Inmate York 86027
slapped Inmate McCrary 88489 No DORs Issued (ArchIbald)
Simple Battery - based on only mInor inJuries, no weapons were used, there was only one assailant and
the victim did not fight back
;

'0';1-1'8
;';"'.i'l:""
':!'Yt'!'If.

I·t;:;:-P\f·
r·..·
, y. Ie

..

,,:~.:.:.:.

....

,.,.

'""

~ff' "".~' '.
,... :.0
en14er

Involved: Fergus'on·614.42
Summary: Inmate Ferguson (Sex Offender) walked Into the JKL counselors office and staff saw that he
had both his eyes bruised and several brUises and scratches on hiS head and arms. Inmate Ferguson
claimed that he was assaulted on 05-17-08, at approximately 1600 hours, but he refused to state which
Inmates assaulted him
.ICC lovestl!;lation Findings. Inmate Ferguson 61442 sad he was attacked by several offenders because
'nels'a'sex'-offencfer Dlifwould not assist In Identifying who they were Video showed 5 to 6 offenders
enlenng the cell dunng Ihe assault but the quality of the Video did not allow for identification. Three of the
offenders are believed 10 have been Castro 72938, Inmate Powell 73B16 and Inmate Schmidt 81591
based on whIch cells the assailants went to after the assault No DORs Issued (ArchIbald)
Aggravaled Battery· based on there being mUltiple assailants attacking one vlc!lm making senoU;3 injury

·nighlylikely-······

05/19/08.0930 hrs, exact location unknown
Type: Assault Offender on offender
Involved' Nelson 72449
Summary: Counselor Hunsaker received an anonymous concern form stating that Inmate Nelson had
been assaulted Counselor Hunsaker went to Inmate Nelson's cell and saw that he had abraSions on
each Side of his head and on hiS forehead. Inmate Nelson refused 10 answer any question regardmg the
abrasions on his head, and refused segregation placement
ICC InvestIgation Fmdlngs No investigation report located.
SImple Batlery - based on only mmor InJunes, no weapons were used, there appears to have been only
one assailant and the vIctim dId not fight back.

Q51.19/08;-1 045.hrs,;K.Pod;·
'Type: A·ssault: Offeridi3l' on offender
Involved: Wallis 72~!3 aDd~oPJ:lz 66433 ,

.'. .

slimmaiY;Pfftc~tWtiitE!rMU~"tqJ~~C)~e.r~:Q!!nm",l~·.wallis In hiS cell with InJunes to the face Upon

.

qqe.l!tJl;inlogJ.nT:milt~ w~nts Qfa:1:i9.~.sI61~:as.~~uJfQhhl~ person, he stated Inmate Lopez, slruck him in the

f~¢i\!Md b~'aYWjln. cI9~'e(ffl~ts:arii:ftffeh;stai'fed kicking him and later proceeded In attacking him with a

i(i6klihi·sbck.:;abfffJnti"E!.t~s\we.r'.Ei"¢s-P9rl~,Q:¥o;"M§'9lgClJ for further evaluatIon and Inmate Lopez-Vasquez
was escorted from Medical to Segregation pending Invesltgation. Inmate Wallis was moved to another
area of the Facility forapproprrate hOUSing.

At1achment I

-Page 16-

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020590

·

'-I

,
..

ICC, Investlgahon,.Eindlngs Video showel;llnmate Lopez 66433 Involved In a fight with his cellmate
Inmate WalliS 72973 Inmate Lopez can be seen sWinging a pillowcase containing a small heavy object
and hlttrng Inmate Wan,s several limes with it Only Inmate Lopez received a DOR. (Archibald)
Aggravated Battery· based on weapons beIng used making serious Injury highly likely;

:OS/25/0B F 2030hrs, G"Rod, Cell·1.17
':fype:'AssaOlt"Offeride"(o'ri: offender
Ir,vo)ved: Bradley 66370
Summary: Inmate Bradley (Sex Offender) was allegedly assaulted in G·117A Inmate 8radl~y refused to
cooperate with the millallnvesllgatlon by providing names of the aggressor. Inmate Bradley was
evaluated bycn site medical and escorted to segregation pending further investJg~tJon

ICC Investigation Findings Inmate Ellison 62685 told Inmate Bradley he had to give up all hiS
commissary and get off the tier, Inmate Ellison then pulled Inmate Bradley off hiS bunk and beat him up,
Inmate Ellison recelv~d; a DOR (Archibald)
EXlortlon'Slmple Batterv· based on personal property taken by force, only minor injuries, no weapons
were used, there wBsonly one assailant and the victim did not fight back It could be argued thiS was
robbery

·05'25108,"0151 hrs, Ko.Pod, Cell 105..
Type: AS'saU!t Offender on offender
InVolved: Bernard 31015
Summary: Staff discovered Inmate Bernard during count In his cell after an assault Inmate 8.ernard had
swelling and abraSIons on hiS cheekbones, nose and the side of hIS face. The mmate reported that two
Inmates came Into hiS cell pnor to count and hit him with closed fists, however he was not able to Identify
Ihe Inmates
ICC Investigation Fmdmgs Inmate Bernard refused 10 identify the two assaIlants. These two mmates
reportedly beat him up and took his commissary (Archibald)
"

Extortion' Aggravated Battery - based on personal property taken by force and there were multiple
assallanls making serious Injury highly likely, It coVld be argued thiS was robbery
,.,::.

06101/08, 1752 hrs, Dining Hall
?F~J'!~rA!!~'3.~lt.:qfflfl]:s!~r-:on offender
.il.~y'Q;'v~~.~ Rayp"e.~5Z.QZ.';and Brushears 77948
.. . " '" . . . .
;StifumarY:Inmate&,Payne and Brushears (Sex Offender) engagedarltiit)tu~\{Qtppf¥.Hfdlie dining hall
:·h:eanh~.:~xJt;dQ;O.r.Bo.\H 'inmates were given verbal dlrecllve to stop :~lghiing:;'DufWefe'i1rir~$pbnSIVe to
dIrectives Both were contamInated with OleoreSin Capsicum. Both:1I1iljat~5:w~r.~)re~tta,m,13,t:i and escorted
dIrectly to segregation, decontaminated, and given.medical evaluBt~oJ;l~J;)y qiJ~,~i~e:mepI~I:staff

:'ICG.invBstiga6oriiFmdiligs'The two inmates were observed In mutual combat. Inmate Brushearswastold
'IWth~AiYl;iin(ni9ht5'Jo: b~:af someone up but refused resuillng In him being allacked by Inmate Payne
.RP.t02 B:othi.iiiiiat~$ rei;J~J\'!:lp;DORs for mutual combat (Archibald)

Attachment I

-Page 17-

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020591

J

.100",7-·

...

~; ~;' .~:/:

Extortion/Simple Battery - based on only minor Inlunes, no weapons were used, there was only one
assailant, the vIctim did not fight back and It was an attempt to force an Inmate to commit violence 8gamst
hIs will as part of an extortion scheme

06/03JOB, 0650 hrs, A·pod Dayroom
Type: Assault' Offender on offender
Involved: Luckado 82376 and Williams 51314
Summary: Inmate Luckado reported to staff that he had Just been assaulted In A-pod. The Inmate had
Injuries that were consIstent wIth' that of being Involved In an assault Inmate Luckado Informed staff that
.IQrTla.te WIlliams from A 122-A assaulted him by the ShliW~l~~~fte:Mfi~ih!1l"
.. PIJ.ftQI'JJation by the
.~r~y.';~J~~Q!i0:~O\~lnm;3fEfsW(iie}eYaluated by medical' .. ··':ip..m$}$(:~
"'fU9iSMU cell # 36.
Hailij'ai),tf.(jj;jj:l~ft.~:&~Htts.p.~C~Q:n~)Nf.~[.e conducted qn;: ~.,;~i~i1pj~t!3ft;·'Q:')·p'O
Qv.?~Q~r{jib~hlng of
~1~nm~.~!JQa)'I..~Sj':;'·'
. , ~p'g'Y~Jdez was notified.f.li~f:a:di:litl~!'rEjlli1fQ@i=!).Q'O'if9.n9WIrrg;an
v:,,

IIJW~Ni~~91J~:w.ilr

...

' 1:lIjl:catl~if.;i .

..,

.

,'n'i1=lOaih sHN!!hams 51314 told Luckado.82376 (Sex Offender) to take hiS feet off the

J@/VI~~,o:ij'~fri~~ When he Ignored him, Inmate Williams poured coffee on his head and
:tiJ.tl!1!l!atall:lt:Ki,do.lln:tfta:fa.p~lnmate WIlliams claimed tliat Inmate Luckado hit him wIth a chair Only

:Q!'j"lf

Williams-received a DOR (Archibald) .

Mutual CombatJAggravated Battery - based on inJuries, weapons beIng inVolved, and the one-on-one
combat reported
.
:,:

:.: .:, ..

-.

.

,.

'.:.:.

.•.•-

..

i06/0910ih'19Sb: ilr~N~P.oo

,' ~;;"~~~~1~d1M~f~b:!32a:a~1 '.' ,.,

!;~lifija

:£f""": ""~ry~:1iilpn;Wijs.:
,
afor.::
·'a,<iR'toi!rat·

";':~p~,§.t~f.i;~DlIh~a.re had been a fight In N·Pod earher today
i:litfrcl1eak:bn all inmates from N-Pod He discovered Inmates
'.. ;f}tit
",. ;rti.J~tfmt:
'...,'.;".". "-·.:·:t~!a phySical altercation. Both mmates verbally
cS ~ n;fJt~'
J:11;lm9,hlydIV .
Iff:
'" ...' t,moh' eventually escalated Into a phYSical altercation
, 8.othl/lmatesrefou$:eifto·providewritteh s:t~l~metil~; Both were given medical evaluations and then
housed In segregation pending further mveshgail6n.
,c'.' '.

ICC Investigation Findings. ThiS was horseplay that got out of hand and turned Into a fight. Both inmates'
received DORs (Archibald)

.' . . . . . . .,

Mutual Combat! SImple Battery - based on only minor lnJunes, no weapons were used, and the one-onone combat reported
...... ·• •"'~~.N~il~I1~B:"~Kn~O~WIT~7~''''''''''''''
.~~.~~~~~"··~····."··I'·~-_~.~~,~~~.~·"~,,···~··_-, ~,·····;'~··!'Il--f! · ·l Ii il· · ~.·•

. No'iie:"Kiiowif.

.

1245::11fs.:G:· f~t:omoi';

·1~VPly:'J.:'~'¢~i~J.~~£Z:t1~;!C.~~Gd~ton:ir;2D~(3~:

..

.~:UJlJmil.t:Y.{d.rflcar-~o.w.f1r q~lI~d;,a;Qo.d"e:~!y'~·:(!ql'1i.~J~-pf:1lnmate assault) In the GHI mElln corridor

The
the Unit both Inmale ChIppewa from I 107- A
f!ll.'lcl:!nm:aJe;·Slol1e frotnfl214 S·w.erecoiTiplalnf.with;}J\tqjl'e·c.lives given to them by staff. Both Inmates
eme.r~etidy,tespOils(lla~.i'!~ fesp~n:cJ~d;t()!.GHI';JmQn ~I]tetjrig

Attachment I

-Page 18·

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020592

• ~

.~ .~,

'.~.:"

_.__.; ....;,_~~:.:.

~;,

~.

.~

<r:".......":'

....

.....-:'

•... ·r.) ._. ~;-:'';';~::''';'.

were placed In wrist restraints and escorteq to medical for evaluation followed by placement Into SMU
where they were signed In under PHS status.
ICC Investloatlon Findings This started as an argument that turned Into a fight. Both Inmates received
DORs (Archibald)

'fII1ut~al CombatlSlmole Batter:v.,- based on only minor inJuries, no weapons were used, and the one-ononecorTIoafi'eponea"" -_.-.'--""
.~

,
r

06/15108,1808 hrs,.Dining Hall
Type: Assault Offender on offender

'I

Involved: Colut::c1791Q3 and RodrJgue;Z21066
.
Summary: Dunng the evening meal, Inmate Colucci hit Inmate Rodriguez In the face multiple times with
a closed fist When Inmate ColUCCi fall to comply with lieutenant Flemming .Greene's directives to cease
fighting, LIeutenant Greene deployed a one s.econd burst of Oleoresin Capsicum to t.he neck and head
areas. of the Inmates. The inmates then complied witt;r;the direotives given by the officers Both Inmates
were restrained and escorted to the Special Management Unit where they were decontaminated,
evaluated by medical staff, and SUbsequently housed

,i,
.~

i

ICC Investigation Findings Inmate Colucel79193 attacked Inmate Rodriguez 21066 Who did not fIght
back Three weeks earher Inmate Rodrigues had been moved when Investigation heard a hit was ordered
on him by Inmate Lee 68288 (AK).lnmale Rodrigues was a Porter (Inmate Worker) In the segregation
Unit who refused to smuggle contraband Into Inmate Lee while he was In restrlcltve hOUSing. According to
case file, Inmate ColUCCI beat up two other Porters previously for the same reason Inmate ColUCCI
received a DOR (Archibald)
Simple Battery. based on only minor inJuries, no weapons were used, there was only one assailant and
the victim did not fight back
:~.

:f'; }
:".;.;

.... ~':..'-'"

06/26/2008 , 1433 J·Pod Cell 202

Type: Assault' Offender on offender
Involved: Alvarez, Philhp #84494

'..

r.l~i~ii\iii!i~'f!'1!l'i~;flSI
transport "nmate Alvarez was escorted to Medical forf.l:!rib~r;o~sl;lP,~JJ9.il/a.i:!cfi)j~r{(O.S~fjregatI6h

pendin~ an Investlgahon Any additional information follovlIr;g an Ilwestigah6'ri\iiill bEl'communicated.

ICC Investigation Findings. Inmal$'AIV<:!t¢tX$llr~6;Q.$~.~ Qff!:.(I1~~rfw~s'f:ePQi:ti;iQh ...ilBeat Out" of the gang
by seven Surei'o gang members'1I:iep~l.!.~ifi~,:w~~'6oi:l\'.fQ.I~:Q~1.'f~:~x;offen~'1;I':.':i1)e beating took place In
hiS cell and was performed by AgUJ.i~;SQa54;~'lnm~(~·pena;;n:i31'~j:'lri:rMtl,tM.af.lm~?i74515,
Inmate Lay
80221. Inmate QUlntanna 87191, Ihii:fEife:-P.i3·lma:6.b.:846\. andll:m'i~W:;Sali:r.z;~r i2~$fJ All seven 6ssallants
receIved a DOR. (Archibald)
.
Aggravated Battery - based on there being multIple assailants attackIng one vlclim making serious Injury
highly likely.
I'

Attachment I

-Page 19·

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

CCA_KELLY020593

...,

'!:.:~.r::~.::~

I:.

6·27·2008. 1425; Mpod

Type:'PREA-"""'" . .
Involved: Ward Joseph #54087, Richardson, Ronald #61357, Vigil, Victor #37149
.
Summary: On th~above deJe and tIme Correctional Oo.unselor Renteria received information that an

_

~u~:~ ~ iitit!i!Wl.&liOQ~.'~C~!I:-;~~1;!:i:.r

inves Igallon Is being conducted. A follow up report will be generaled and forwarded upon completion of
the investigation

ICC Investigation Findings

Inmate Ward 54087 reportedly sexually louched and fondled Inmale

Rlchar~son 61357 and Inmate Vigil 37149 The ·SART" determined theallegallons were unsubstantiated

and was In fact horseplay Inmale Ward was Issued a DOR for Horseplay (Archibald)
Horseplay - based on account of Ihe inCIdent by those Involved

...,~

.,

",". 19j,9;~ ours" p;;r=6tl

<,. :'BrAS~-i.iJtn):ffel:\o~l:Qjfoffender

irivo.(~Qd:::j}idkmal'li;;Sj~~¢'it#B7681 an d Spracklen, Jonathan #89413
Summary: Inmates Spracklen #89413 (Sex Offender) and Jackman #67661 were inVolved In a phySical
altercation Correctional Officer Owmgs Issued sever.al verbal dIrectives to stop' fighting but both Inmates
were non-compliant The Emergency Response Team arrived and Correctional Counselor Rentena
dispersed a one second burst of oleoresin capsicum Correctional OfficerElxenberger also Issued a one
second burst of oleoreSin capsicum Both inmates stopped fighting and were escorted 10 Segregation for
decontamination and sUbsequently housed in Segregation Both Inmates were evaluated by medical with
no further mCldents
.

ICC Investigation Findings. Both involved In the fight Both Inmates issued DORs (Archibald)
Mutual-Combat/Simple Battery- based on only minor InJunes, no weapons were used, and Ihe one·on·
one combat reported. .
.

.. '''.''':-'''-''- .,..

<O'ri't29ii-··'2tt'·
:T~p:~lA,

'.

j{i~. ,.

'iL

o'Celt:2-16;

.,f ,...,. ,fjP:d¢:r:

Invo!Ye.Qf·Wo)f,Nlc!pr:#,84040·'

.

Summary: On MO@~y';,~9.ne~3Ptiii20b~:'BfPipfj(QXfma~tiW:1130 hours, Inmate Wolf, Victor #84040
reported to staff tfi~flia;;liad:b~eri'.a.s'sa.ult~~':;:lt-E!PRr9?!ilm~lely 2045 hours on Sunday, June 29th, 2006,
Inmate Wolf has Ji@'n(l~gqT:lSI.st!3JJi,.w!!h i.h~for~iiAs~.lilPR( Inmate Wolf Identified Inmates Lee, James
#68288; Schmldtl..:~e,[em.la.~#B:15gtraii&8.ow.en:i:,J.ej-ry #73816 as the aggressors In hiS incident. Inmate
Wolf has stated thai this inCident occurred because he has refused to put in any work for the Security
. ~hreat Group known as the (Aryan Knights) However, this has not been confirmed and any new

Attachment)

-Page 20-

CONFIDENTIALfATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020594

.~

,,~

-ri.";;'':;'". ::-:-:

.........:-.
.~

..

~":t.~~ •.~".:.... :~3~:"!'

;<;0

.~:;!'

~...,

:-

~ ,~:~.:

...

:!~7:;~~~\~~~' i.~' l ·j7.~-1.:;f:··.".i.'H....~./! . .~!f. ~;~!'·'~·+f*~t~~#:'-

Information gathered through the Investigation WIll be communicated Inmate'WolfwBs escorted to
Medical for further evaluatIon,
ICC Investigation Fmdlngs Three members of the Aryan Knights (Lee 68288, Schmidt and Powell) told
inmate Wolf that if he did not beat up the new sex offenders, steal theIr commissary and fOfce them to
pay rent they were gOing to beat him up When he refused, these same three gang members along with
Inmale RIggs 78722 and Inmate Baxter 50119 followed through on thelf threat and beat him up All fIve of
the assailants received DORs (Archibald)
EXlortlon/Aggravated Battery- based on there being mUltIple assallanls making senous Injury highly likely
and It was an attempt to force an mmate to commIt violence against his Will as part of an extortion
scheme

07101/2008, 1615. J-Pod Cell 222

"Type: As'sauICOfferider'on 'offender
Involved: DavIs, J e n s # 3 7 5 8 9 . •.... " .
Summary: l~wa~~;'O~v.is:;a1:5.ag:.(~WOJf~!}~i3fXt~p.Q'deJ~t.t~':$t~Jfafi~;h¥!:~~giii.~.trA~·M.~
"... rtm.~~~,
Davis stale{,l;ti6Wij:s.~apprQ~o.li~d':l.ttn1~::c;t3l\~by.J6.I1fIQmfl~e$:\'{.1l9mJ~'t{i,"ested lq:~i;l~ \1u;;-"'Ij(;:ppon

:~~~I~~~O~ll:. :'~~~ .. " l~%~~~~..

-~~6~~r~~~:;;I~J~~~~~:~~~~~6~·:t~:::;~:ZJ()~~~r.Jf,

Davis was escorted to edlcalfor further evaluation r'ac' edlcaJ,staffdetiWriinedA\1rn-atildiavl~
needed to be transported off-site to Sl, Lukes HospltaHor...\ig~an&po~sf6i({t)i6kef(rJb$sMtU1m~t~s·1n
J-Pod were secured to thelf cells end the Pod was placed' Dn 'lock aown until further rnvestlgatlon
Administrative Duty Officer Warden Valdez, notlfled'Vlrtual Prison Warden R?ndy Blades of the inCident.
Any new InformatIon gathered durIng the investigation pertainIng to this inCIdent Will be forwarded. After
an assault on J-pod on 7·1-0B the pod was locked down A search of the unit will be conducted on 7-2-08
at approximately 0830 The search Will concentrate on eVidence from the assault and slolen property that
was taken from the victim
-~.

ICC Investigation Findings' Accordmg to Inmate DaVIS, four Inmates demandedlo see hIS incarceration
paperwork so they could determine if he was a sex offender When he refused they beat hlmup The
Video showed these were Inmate Trent 61338, Inm<!!e Noms 76838.., and Inmate Castle 63417 No fourth
Inmate was observed. FollOWing the beating these inmates went and sat at a table With other Aryan gang
members who Included Inmale Brown 66468, Inmate Hoffman 34748, and Inmale Baxter 50119. The
three Inmales Involved In the beating received DORs. (Archibald)
Extortion! Aggravated·~at1er'l- based on personal property taken by force and there were multiple
"assailants makmg'se'ii6iis"'lhjury highly likely It could be argued thiS was robbery

..~

.',., -;:' w...,..::..•,..... ~ ••._....,_... ;~ .•

Name

JDOC

Gan[l Affiliation

DOR'"

Findings

"". .Offense Code

" . .
BroW!!·.·

Hil.llinliiY"

: 11l:l'!6ff:.: :.AfVi!I}:l<nji'llillf.. ·..

.....

~74B:"

'NVii·o·KOiQfils:"

·',~: . No"':"":':':JN1A
~.: No...;:.;, NlA...'.

.. .

tiliA' .

8:Dav5.,,::..

N!A· . ·. ....... '
'NlA"

Restricllve HOllsli'ig

NttAC\lol1;N.oled·~· ..

. NtfACbO;;:Ni!led

:07io6)OB;.1B46+-fbiIrs, bi?lingiHaU:

'-'type:" Assaulforre!ide,t6'n'off'e'nder,

Jnvolvep:'18m~t~~(I,!)~ ~.ap;1ml.'Wd:~prey # 76851, Ferguson, Gregol)' # 86693

Attachment I

·Page21-

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

CCA_KELLY020595

.'.,
.;

,

'.

i-,!~~.i~;i··f·'

\!t ~~~

:f

..:-<

~.;;..;..

.. i

'\.;;. .f. "':. ...:.f

~

.:..a ......... A" . .,!.-::

... :~;
:.:.; 4'

Summary: Oqae··!:3Ju.'~lTrlfrlale" oh ii1mati3;qitJtie.;ifihl.O'9}~C!fj"lnm~te;t:~.mmgYW5's':the:-aggr¢$~or In
thIS incident [Pfficei{Sh#1.P~ttg~y'~,jp\ld~;:I!~ ,.'. ' 'c,I).r.~J,v,~~;'to.At9P}i!l~tf~g·~6~i9:~i:;d.9W.6·t?~,dawi1' on the
floor Inmate~~t!mm~~:,C:9,P~~Uy~};fj hls~,~,~YI,I;p'i'!' Wtl~~~f~t~P.~·~f1' ;SBt9.¢Bht.S.chaR.p~rt;Cl:!:tjtai:t!i.r.r~ted both
Inmates with .~JiM: ~l:i¢,~l1.gJ!iqt$.t 9f·QI~.Q.;f.e·sii;;C.a.pSli:iUiit.Jrolh:lril)i}~t{fEfb,e¢:i:lJ:t[~::qq.tf!li1,'M~:i;lflg)aJd down
on the floor Officer Blrk 'pliilced'lland- restraints on Inmate Lammey and escorted him 10 the dining hall eXit
door Inmale Ferguson was placed In hand restraints by Sergeant Schapper and then escorted to the eXit
door. Both mmales were escorted tosegregabon where they were decontaminated, given medICal
examInations. Both mmates are housed In segregation pending further Investigation and discIplinary
actions
ICC Investigation Ftndmgs Both Inmates particIpated In the fIght and both received OORs (Archibald)
Mutual CombaV 81111ple Batlery - based on only minor InJunes, no weapons were used, and the one-anone combat reported.

7/09/0B, 2056 hoUrs. G pod
Type: Ass~o.'tdjffehd~t;:ijn~sJaff
InvolveddW( ,. ""ji.~~~.?1!#38260,
.".
SummaryrJnm
~~r§~I~Wi:!S escorted to medical for a p.t~is~g$g.atlb.:tL.$.'J.i'!J@ti91iX!:i~~r? mInor
allercatlon1?.!1ij[
19,VfjS'q~ez # 84555 in G Pod. While W?UjQ'91f9N~:~,r;n~.q!~I'~¥a!l:ift,VR.il)t1mate
P.earsall altempled.l15 ruJi alit off the examination room. Off,c~r;9.Wi:og~'(3tl;iQ'i?d.'1i'lmate4:"elarsall and.
J~b
. ~@hl!rtjf.9.IJd~Rf.,lct!hg; p.~~fs~\r.~uf·"'J~~l f!i~)iilng aroung towards Offlc~r OWmgs Officer
.
," '··JQ:iPt~·.S.@3:~qtnrgoMfoHacfl~~;
. liotlnrnate. ~~!3~alJ: H.~, appfiec ~r.essure to the

;~::t::i!M!;~~!&ii!::;.ti.:i.

several mmates on the tier APREA Investigatloi1has'bB'eii(
.;.IntO:his}jn~£f~.u~m$·ltl'tti§w{p~W~Fm
was gIVen a medIcal examination and claims he had a severe headache from being struck In the head by
inmate Vasquez. He has self-inflicted minor scrapes and lacerations to both forearms

l.nm'~f~ .R6

.

:·:.~;~~4,wll~!hI~a:~~~:~~~::,~~~~~~:~~j~~~~~~~:'~~f\~m6~¥MuOf~~~7'§.Jw~d

b,Qtt?\ H~:9J~Jm~fJJ,i:!!:n.~'¢'.

fIQ!:~~.9.r.§lJ:i9,~gifj(s'~~tn:fnMQ' oocaslons Witp'SssBf3-'saW, Inm'~*~! Pe~.~~alr5p)t
on Inmate Vasquez which resulted In mutual combat Tt\:~;;s.eXiJ.~I.E!I!~J;i~,t1.qns·.w~f!3:#~tgr!IIIj:I.e.:9.:l.~.~~.,
unfounded. (Archibald)

Simple Battery - based on only mmor Injuries, no weapons were used, there was only one assailant and
the vIctim dId not fight back.

••

•

•

•

:".l.Oliy,., ...,.,.,....._..... ,.
2'O:aY.i;·
'50'liys'

No'ACliili'l'N6Iild·'" '

'orf11J.08;'0903:liOiJts,,'i:P.od

T· :e"Of'liic!if'ribAsS'aiilt/OtrkHider-;on offender

:!/.~'VJ:d~~I($.rr~YPJV.~d'fWrria.t~s(sj':.J~ramiild, J3.4i'i~~lupe #40743 Pearsall, .Roger #38260

·BrlilfSomrrialY.o,f- IO~lq~lJ.v.J;x~n:l.s~.~J'\q

~ctlglJT~ken:
P$llle.ifcalJed·~.e.b.de'bIUe,"'(liJma\I'f.Onlnm~fe,fJsSl;1ult) ERT

At apprOXimately 0903 on July 11, 2008 officer
team responded to I pod. The assault was
over when they arnved. They res'tralned inmates Jaramillo and Pearsall and escorted them to medical for

Attachment I

-Page 22 -

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020596

~.

.
:

·~~"4

l~

:..it

-!-i.·~:~

=:i.:i:· 1

:~~~*

,."':

evaluation. Inmate Jaramillo was placed PHS for assault In segregation at this time mmate Pearsall Is stili
.

10 medical awaiting mental evaluation and proper placement

ICC Investigation Fmdlngs After Pearsall was returned to general population Inmate Jaramillo 40743
made a comment about Inmate Pearsall spitting on hIs fnend Inmate Vasquez Inmate Pearsall made
some comment Inmate Jaramillo felt was disrespectfully and Inmate Jaramillo began punching him
repeatedly as he knocked him all the way down a flight of stairs (Archibald)
SImple Battery - based on only mmor InJUrieS, no weapons were used, there was only one assailant and
the 91ctlm did not fight back

07/11/08.1430. L-Pod

Type: Assault Offender on offender
Involved: McCormick, Dwayne #75137
,summary: Inmate McCormick 75137 reported to staff In JKL that he had been assaulted Inmate
McCormick has fresh InJunes to the face that are consIstent With an assaulVbattery. Inmate McCormick
stated he was assaUlted by 3 or 4 Caucasian Inmates whom are associated with the Secunty Thr.eat
Group known as the "Aryan nights", Inmate McCormick stated he was unaWare as to whom the
Aggressors were In hiS assault Inmate McCormick was escorted to Medical for further evaluation and
then proceeded to Se' .. .trQfHQriJnv.~~ljg~tlonpurposes and for his safety Staff secured all Inmates, In
L-Pod, to theIr cells I .
.'·J~ta.I)9.W~.t~ffa§~;conduct upper body and knuckle Inspections. At
approximately 1629 h~!.m~i:Mi:nliil~tratlv.j;rQiJty Officer (A.W. Prado) placed L·Podon lackdown until
further notice

J&G:hi~

': . .

.~

j:t5:,r~t~m9~rs ofthe Aryan Kmghts ordered Inmate McCormick 75137 to beat up

;fomji{(L ,.. J!.. ~Y.~g6. '~'M~e.ij';~~lailed to carry out thiS order, he was beat up by Inmate Bailey 67816
(AK) and Inmate Miller 74986 ·(AK). Both assailants received DORs; (Archibald)

Extortlon/Aggravated Battery - based on there being multiple assailants making serious injury hIghly likely
and It was an attempt to force an Inmate to commit Violence agamst hIS will as part of an extortion
scheme.
.;

:07111/080"'1450, LPod,

Type' dflncldent: Assault Sexual
Involved: NOrriS, Joe #76838
Summary; Inmate Noms 76838 reported that he had been assaUlted 10 the Pod. Inmate Norns has
Injunes to the face and body consistent with an assaUlt/battery Inmate Noms stated he had been
assaulted by two or three Caucasian Inmates who are associated With the Security Threat Group known
as the Aryan Knights. Inmate NOrriS would not give any addlbonallnformallon about the assailants
Inmate Norns was transported to St Lukes Hospital for treatment K-Pod was locked down while the
inCident was investigated Inmata Noms was found to have contusions, swelling, and a hematoma of the
upper left quadrant of the facial area Upon return from the transport the IOmate was taken to Segregation
for hOUSing pending an investigation mto the assault
,lBcfnvesttgatiomFlJid'lngs: Inmate Norrls is a self-admitted Shoshone Outlaw/Native Gangster Blood

;:g~b.g.nI~in~~r! Jhi~;'~~i]l)*;by the Aryan Knights is believed to be over an issue of dIsrespect, He would

'. r1P.\ IdiHitlfY:th~a.$sailari1~r (Archibald)

At1achment 1

-Page 23 •

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CC~KELLY020597

.~

~'..~

.~.' ;;~~~;r
,~~

.

Aggravated Battery - based' on there being multIple assailants attackmg 9ns vIctim makmg seTious Injury
highly likely

,,7/16108•..1949 hrs. "'.Pod. CelLA10t
Type: Assault Offender on offende'r
Involved: Bautista-Aguayo 84566, Sandoval 87716
Summary: Inmate Sandoval entered Inmate Buatlsta's cell and started hitting him repeatedly. Inmate
Sandoval admits being the aggressor In the incident. Both Inmates were restrained, taken to Medical for
evaluation, and then to Segregation for housmg.
.
ICC Invesbgalion Pendmg
Simple Battery - based on only minor InJunes, no weapons were used, there was only one assailant and
the victim dId not fIght back
"-.""'-_._.._._.. ,, ....."'..... _- ..:: ... ,.... _...• '._._--_ ....

7-17-08. 0645. Dining Hall
Type of In~ldent: Assault: Offender on offender
Indlvldual(s) Involved: Cantleld, Tommy#B6856, Coronado, Ruflno#B4483
Summary: Inmate Canfield # 8B856 assaulted mmate Coronado #84483 In the dmlng hall lieutenant
Greene administered a,one secpnd burst of OleoreSin Capsicum aUnmate Canfield to gam compliance to
orders to sI9p:~ffgJj~i)jg{'rti1J.~l~,fQQt9M.d.i:iwas comphant"and was not contaminated with Oleoresin
Capsicum. liJ:m~,~!f'" n~9~W~§.~~~~!t~y medical and placed In segregabon PHS. Inmate Canfield
refused me:Cljcaf'.:'qr.}'i:ind.Wi:i$;taK~iJ dIrectly to segregation for decontamination and placement
PHS for fighting . _. , ... . ' ..",.
ICC Investigation Pending
Simple Batterv ~ based on only minor InJunes, no weapons were used,
the VictIm did not fight back.

then.~

was only one assailant and

07/18/2008,1330 hrs J·Pod Cell 114A
Type of Incident: Assault: Offender on offender
Involved: Pitchford, Brandon 85665
Summary: 1'!.r.Tf$.X~;PIJCiliJplCr89'Q~~5i.l~~X::dffe·ild'e.r) reported to JKL Unit staff that he had been battered In
hIS cell J-114' "Ii}li'iaiEfPil¢lifOfQ·li~~JnJu.tiiflfc.:pi;l~J~tent with a battery/assault Inmate Pitchford stated he
was battered iiJth!sc;~JI. b.tfq!-1M.rJlv~~G~I,J®,~!"Jn)nmates Inmate Pitchford could not Identify the alleged
Assailants. Inmate Pitchford was escorted to Medical for further evaluation and then will proceed into
Segregation pending Investigation for hIs safety

ICC Investigation Pending
Aggravated Battery. based on there being multiple assaIlants attacking one victim making serious injury
highly likely
,

Attachment I

·Page 24-

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY.

CCA_KELLY020598

.'

'"!..~

.~.

:,~ :~'. \-(~:
:;.

ai.·..~~~::. ..·~>1

.:!.::

.

• ~.~; •. ~r.

"t ..

ISi"~d. SUT" . ·iii%.-ff' ··k4$:jfriiT5i1.1~··
(uF~~ow~':iX~)L~rUE.~~~.~j~o&i >:> . . .:

:.. :.':.~ :~ _~.:._
·.ilIil :.i. !ijij;.:•". ~
.r.'.... . . Dm!I
r::=~". . .~;"";.;,~'=";,,J;.- ~4~H"'"..::;:;;=.:::t=---_·· ....·]

,_.,..

l.·.:..·.: j..i.:l...:.§ •.:.<.:j.:;m._:.:
.• ..

j_'.
. • • • '. •:•••••.
• ••

IM.·.Ii.

ll.·l;...•...',·.

07/21/08, bPod

Type: Assault Offender on offender
Involved: Luoma, Scott =#62609 (V), McCllnn, Mlcheal #87323 (S)
Summary: On the above date and approximate time, Inmate Luoma #62809 was assaulted by an unknown number of inmates on l-Pod An investigatIon was Initiated and It was discovered that Inmate
McCllnn #87323 was Involved In the assault on Inmate Luoma At this time It 15 not known whether or not
Inmate McChnn acted alone, t.he Investigation 15 on-gOIng, more Information will reported as it becomes
available. On 7·22-06, upon further investigation It was determined that Inmate McChnn did not act alona
In the assault He was aSSisted by three other Inmates. Inmate Collingwood #59683, Inmate Albin
#76165, and Inmate Hudson #73440.

~

.,r

ICC Investigation Pendmg
Aggravated Battery- based on tlie number of assailants It Was high likely that serious Injury would occur.)
:~

.,
07/21/0B, 2013 hours, X-Pod

Type: Assault. Offender on offender
Involved: Conlon # 77033, Ramirez # 85394
.
Summary: Emergency Response Team was summoned to x-pod for a disturbance with Inmate Conlon #
77033 and Counselor Martynack Inmate Conlon was escorted to medical for a pre-segregation medical
evaluation. After becommg verbally agitated and abUSIve With security and medIcal staff he was escorted
straight to the speCial management unit where he was housed in oe1l203. Inmate Conlon alleged that he
was assaulted by Inmate Ramirez #- 85394 while on X-Pod lieutenant Watts and Counselor Martynack
conducted an interview with mmate Conlon concerning hiS allegations. An mvestlgatlon Into the validity of
inmate Conlon's allegation has been Initiated. No externallnJunes are apparent at this time, however
medical staff Will attempt to re-examine Inmate Conlon at 2200 hours
ICC InvestigatIOn Pending
Simple Battery· based on only minor inJuries, no weapons were used, there Was orily one assailant and
the Victim did not fight back

,07/25/08. 1535 hours, I-Pod, 1-213
fy'p'e: Assault COffendefoii Offender
Involved: Inmates(s) Waterhouse, Qumcey #77780, Lund, Layne #58320
Summary: Inmate Lund 58320 (Sex Offender) was g1lscovered by staff In cell 1213 With a laceration on
hiS IIp He was escorted to medical. Inmate Lund stated that hiS cellmate Inmate Waterhouse had
assaUlted hIm 10 his cell at approxImately 1530 hours. Inmate Waterhouse was questioned and blood was
discovered on hiS left arm. Inmate Waterhouse had no Injuries that would cause there to be blood on his
arm. 80th Inmates were evaluated by medicsI staff. Inmate Waterhouse was placed In SegregatIon
Inmate Lund was taRen offsite to the hospital as hiS injuries reqUIred him to be taken to the emergency
room for treatment.

Attachment I

-Page 25 -

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020599

,
:J

'.

'.,

,

..

:;'.

ICC Investigation Pending
Simple Battery. based on only minor Injunes, no weapons were used, there was only one assailant and
the victim did not fight back

.07126/081_1-840 hours, DjnlJ)g Hall:
Type: Assault. Offender on offender
Involved: Inmates(s) Karns, Cole #60343, GarCia, Joseph #89298
"
Summary: On 7/26/08 at 1840 afight broke out pe\YIeen Inmates Karns and GarcIa in the dlmng hall.
When the mmates failed to comply with verbal dIrectives to cease fighting, lieutenant Aaron Gleason
deployed a short burst of Oleoresin Capsicum to their faCial area, The mmates stili continued to fight and
Correctional Counselor Michael Kerr1hen deployed another burst of Oleorelj!n CapSicum The Inmates
then qUit fighting and assumed a prone position on the floor Both Inmates were restrained and taken
dIrectly to the SpeCial Management Unit where they were decontammated In the shower. They-were then
led to their cells for housmg
,

ICC Investigation Pending
Mutual Combat/Simple Battery - based on only minor injUrieS, no weapons were used, and the one-onone combat reported

01127/0B, 1133.houTS, M-R F.oyer"

TYp'e: Assault' Offender on offender
Involved: Inmates it Caldwell, Clay #75701, Stopka I, Aaron # 87621,
Summary: On July 27th,2008 at 1133 hours Inmates Caldwell (Sex Offender) and StopkaI became
mutually combatIve in M-R Foyer as they were returning from chow. Initially both Inmates were noncompliant to staff directives to stop fIghting Once the Emergency Response Team entered the Unit both
Inmates complied with directives and submitted 10 restraints. The Inmates were escorted to MedIcal for an
evaluation and then to Se'gregatlon without further InCident 80th mmates received superflclallnjunes to
the face not needing addillonal outSide medical treatment
ICC Investigation Pending
Mutual Combat/Simple Battery· based on only minor injUries, no weapons were used, and the one-onone combat reported,

07/28/08, 0530 hours, B-Pod, 13·205
Type: Assault. Offender on offender
.., ,_,
Involved: Inmates(s). Coates, Michael #62899, Taylor, Jam~J?Jl~Mo.1
Summary: On 7-28-07 at 1430 hours Inmate CoalEW;#62899 (S~x:·,QWnJI.~r);,~lre,ije.~,that he had been
assaulted by Inmate Taylor #85801 In B·205b at 0530 hours ~:A.Fter :ar-Hni,;e5tig~tioli ItWas concluded that
Inmate Taylor struck Inmate Coates m the face with a closed':f{~.t; [3,o\/}Jorn~.t§~:w!,!r.e. escorted to medical
for evalualions and subsequently placed In Segregation No further Incidents occurred.

Attachment I

·Page 26·

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020600

,..

"

.' ,,;....
.~

,.........

~:.

ICC lnvestlgabon Pending

.
i

Simple Battery - based on only mrnor InJunes, no weapons were used, there was only one assailant and
the vIctim did not fIght back

~:

07/29/08,1903 hours, C-Pod Cell 107
Type: Assault Offender on offender

Involved: Doglc, Dzemal #85442, Velasquez, Sergio'#64865
Summary: On July 29,2008 at 1903 Inmate Doglc.#85442 notified Correctional Officer Knight, via his
cell call box, that he had Just beenassa.t:mer;t .The ,~i)1.~rgenoy R.~~P£n~.~ Team was deployed to C pod;
Upon there ai1'W~.Iithm&t~.,l1o;glq:~!lell.~I:fJ/j~rr
" ~N~J~~q4Ji~~~~6.§g;had tned to extort hIm for
commissary, :eP9;Whenr~~gljf;t~,~9~~~Hv,w...
.... ':;~e~!~;:M~r:l~:mm with a closed fist Inmate
Dolgle did sh9.W;:~
;m~:n::J~l?J~:t!ll;.Qllh).(i.
. :", K.B.o.tb:filffil;lte.s;were restrained and escorted to

Segre9atlon\~p;e(id

.';

-;

.~

li.edtiM~StrS.at1~n;;:W1._tJ.:rt.b~!, Jm~J.~~nl.;,

ICC Investigation Pending
ExtortIon/SImple Battery - based on personal property taken by force, only mmor InJunes, no weapons
were used, there was only one assailant and the victim did not fight back. It could be argued thIs was
robbery

,.01l30l0B,,1.52Q.. hours,JCC,_ M~F'od_
'Type: Assault. bffenderon offender
_
Involved: Gutierrez-Gallegos, Abel #76723, Ramirez, Adam #76147
Summary: On JUly 3D, 2008 Case Manager Rosendau!. rE.!celved info~r:nat!ol1 t~1:lt ~o offenders,
$y'~¥.£i.~z~,"~.IJ#.g~#llt
""O:~e~
··ff~,(R~:mir~i~:j4~r($i:i)(~~~p:~~.r}t;~W:~J~,sfbeen Involved 10 a
p!.1y,steal:alt¢Icat!o.r;t.
.~d· G.
ll~gg§.ftQmt.h~:p~d.:a.!1~ fOllmt~l;Ip..~rtI9Ial wounds to hIS
!~ft:ey~'al)~~f9rs~ :G
_ " Msgo$:a~irt.e) Q: Qeiiig;iii:aip.fiisJcaraltar'Catlo~ wltJiOffender Ramirez.
:$fa.lf·~.afi1e(e:[t~\ai~me.n. siti'om Q}))er r6sj~ehlS,~ot:M.;po.Qj-rfdAw.o~ti\it~m~lit~·ld~njiTi~~. RamIrez as the
:liftfier~ssa1IanFRa'riJlte.i''WEls:.ihtetvieWEid,a.i:l_~~w.C!~Jpund with superfIcial wounds Both inmates were
taken to medical and segregation

"..

ICC Investigation Pending
Mutual CombaV SImple Battery - based on only minor InJunes, no weapons were used, and the one-onone combat reported

08/01/2008, 1710 hours, L Pod Cell 113
Type: Assault. Offender on offender
Involved: Colucci, Timothy # 79193

Summary: On August 1, 2008 at 1710 hours Inmate ColUCCI #79193 notified Correctional Officer
Woycenko via call box that he had been assaulted Officer Drake made physical contact with Inmate
Colucci and venfled that he had Injuries that substantialed the assault had occurred Inmate ColUCCI was

At1achment I

·Page 27-

CONFIDENTIAL/ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020601

·r

.

.;, .,;...,

.....

';

.......

"

taken to medIcal for an onslte medical evaluation and then placed In Segregation pending further
Investigation.
ICC Invesligalion Pending
SImple Battery - based on only mmor inJuries, no weapons were used, there was, only one assailant and
the vIctim did not fight back
'

OB/O,4lO8;=1BD4"hours. -DIOIng, Hall

Typ'o: Assault Offender on offender
Involved: John, Mlcheal # 87221, Ross, Richard 4f. 85308, Larsen, James # 82664
Summary: Al1804 Hours a code Blue( inmate on mmate fight) was declared In the dimng hall Three
inmates John# 8722,1, Ross # 8530B, and Larsen # 82684 were Involved In a physical altercation 10 the
rear left corner of the dining hall. Captain Welbye responded from within the dining hall'and began gIVIng
lOUd verbal dlrecllves for the combatants to cease fighting and lay face down on the floor wllh thelf hands
out and palms up All three Inmates were compliant. All three Inmates were restrained by staff InSide the
dining hail. All three mmates were gIven medical evaluattons and housed In segregation pending
investigation and dlsclpl/na/)' charges
ICC Investigation Pendlllg
Group Combat! SImple Battery - based on only minor InJuries, no weapons were used, and number of
combatants, If It IS determined that there were two mmates attacking one or that there actually was a
weapon Involved then It would appear to be aggravated assault based on the probability of causing
serious injury

Allachment I

·Page 28 -

CONFIDENTJAUATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
CCA_KELLY020602