Detainees Positive Response, FBI, 2004
Download original document:
Document text
Document text
This text is machine-read, and may contain errors. Check the original document to verify accuracy.
|
Detainees
Positive
Responses
1.
W
.
SUMMARY
CODED
CATEGO
ares
OF JUSTIFICATION
CATEGORIES
INFORMATIONWITHHELI!
S
' l
f
I
INFORlV_1ATION_
Category
Category."b! !
AGENCY
PERSONNEL
RULES AND PRACTICES
b! !-1
Internal
FBITelephone
Numbers.
'
Category h! !
CLEARLY UNWARRANTED
PERSONAL
i g
INVASION OF
PRIVACY
'
'
. b! !-1.
Names
of
FBI SpecialAgentsandSupportPersonnel.
--
. b! !-2
Personal
Infolmation
of
FBI SpecialAgentsandSupport
Personnel,
IncludingDates
of
EntranceonDuty with theFBI
and Other Work-Related
Personal Information.
tb3> -31»
Names
of
Employees
of
OtherGovernment
Agencies,
Including
b 1| ! -4
NamesandIdentifying
Information
of
Foreign
Detainees,
_
Contract
Employees.
'
IncludingDOD DetaineeIdenti cation
Numbers.
l
NamesandIdentifyingInfonnation
of
Individualswhoare
of
tb! I|-5
iIb! I>-6
Investigative
Interest
totheFBI. - . _'
~
C*".°g°I'.Y
b! ! C!
1 l1! _! C!-1
l1! ! C!-2 I
Names
of
Individuals
whoareMerelyMentionedin FBI
Investigative
Records.
UNVVARRANTED INVASION
OF PERSONAL PRIVACY
Names
of
FBI Special
Agents
andSupport
Persoimel.
Personal
Information
of
FBI SpecialAgentsandSupport
Personnel,
IncludingDates
of
EntranceonDuty with theFBI
and Other Work-Related
. |1! !lIC!-3
Personal Information.
Names
of
Employees
of
OtherGovernment
Agencies,Including
_'
Contract
Employees.
b! IIlIC!-4
'
NamesandIdentifyingInformation
of
ForeignDetainees,
Including
DODDetainee
Identi cation
Numbers.
l
b! lHfC!-5
Names andIdentifying Information
of
Individualswho are
of
Investigative
Interest
tothe'FBI.
b! IHIC!-6
_
.
Names
oflndividuals
who
are
Malay
Mentioned
in
FBI
tI11Ys§tigs1i :¢l%@s<>rd§_ -
"I
T
.
"7 T71
CDDED CATEGORIES
ATION
VVITHI-IE
r11wi1fgRM
_LD
-'
__ -
_
coNFl1JENT1AL soURci:
MHAFTERIAL
T ateeolwt __
with!
Names and
Identifying Information
of Foreign
Detainees who
_
b! ! D!-1
were Interviewed
and
Provided
Infomiation
to
the
FBI under
Implied Assurances
of Con dentiality.
Category b! ! F!
ianmw!-1
.
i ENDANGER LIFE
UR PHYSICAL
.-INDIVIDUAL -
Namesand
Identifying
SAFETY OF
ANY
-
Information ofForeignDetainees
who
were Interviewed and
Provided
Information to the FBI, the
Disclosure Which
of
Could
ReasonablyExpected
be
to
Endanger theLives or
Physical Safety ofThese Detainees
of
Their Family
Members.
i i'
W
'
I
.'
1' '
&General
Information
'
:
w-._ -n FJ
|-'
-I
I
memtnewn
_
-
:D .
FEDERAL
' _
Z!
.
BUREAU
OF
Precedence: Peionrrr
. To:
.
JI
INVESTIGATION
.
Director's Office
Date:
Attn:
DD Bruce
09/02/2004
J}
Gebhardt
From: ~Inspection
_
-
-
Office of Inspections
- '
Qaproni_Valerie
_
_
Approved
By:Gebhardt
Bruce
J.?Qr
Drafted
_
By:
Title:
GTMQ
'
'
E.
_ _-
. .,4-I _
_
b6
1
b?C-1
Case
ID #:2.97. HQ-A132'?6.669-A
Pending!;
~' _
''
_
_
COUNTERTERRORI SM
DIVI
INSPECTION SPECIAL
Synopsis:
- Inspection
Request_approval
Division
S ION
CTD]
INQUIRY
I
to designate
INSD! Special
Based upon a request
-_ Details:
_
captioned
matter
from 0GC,_1NSD conducted
of all Bureau personnel who had served in any capacity
since 09/11/2001.
This surveys
which
was disseminated
"
requested
personnel
to
advise
INSD
if
as an
__
-
Inquiry.
they observed
A
a survey
i
at GTMO
via email,
any
_'
aggressive mistreatment,
interrogations
or interview techniques
of GTMOdetainees
by
representatives
of
any
law enforcement,
military
or_Bureau personnel which were not consistent with -. or
"Bureau
guidelines.
Records obtained
by
CTD determined
there
were
'
S32 Bureau employees or contractors who served at GTMOduring
this time frame._ The survey resulted in identifying
nine
employees
who observed
such-treatment
"summaries of what they observed;
and they provided
short
There_were no documented
incidents
involving
any Bureaq personnel.
These
provided to General Counsel Valerie
Caproni,
nine employees be interviewed.
'
I In order
to
requested that
matter
t
summaries
who requested
.'
,
were
these
.
commence
with the interviews, it is
the Deputy Director
as an INSD Special
designate
and approve this
Inquiry.
.
1
4
I
|
>-.
RESPONSES 1
.
J
w92.
.
_
.
_To: Director'sFrom:
Oégace
Inspection
:!
Re; 297-HQ~A13276669-A,
09/02/2004
_
LEADIB!:
Set Lead
1:Action!
DIRECIOR'S OFFIQE
- A'I _DDFO,
DC
That the
' attention
of the
--
request for
designation be
brought to
the
Deputy Director.
¢+
Z
%
~RESPONSES 2
.
_
_______-------n-InnunIuIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
1-
.ej
*
iF :-',-.
7
,
-mwnbmem;
-
I_.
1'
.
FEDERAL
BUREAU
DF INVESTIGATION
_Date:
To: Counterterrorism
AttnDAD
General Counsel
09/23/2004
T. Jw
Attn=
Valerie
'Inspeetion_ "
- _Office
.
,
Precedence: ROUTINE
'
From:
.
io
:> '
gt -
u"
'*" "'"
~-
of ions_
92 , kContact: I
__
_j
Harrington
E. Caproni
'
-i_ '
if b2 ei
ApprovedThompson,
By:
W1
Donald
J ¥&@
92
§jfc"f1
GI-5.1111
137:!
Robert
--
Case ID
'#: -.'g
ii 9_§77'-é.'l:IQ§:j;l_3_-?"!
{Pending}*3_é ,
£aé-7
Title: on-10
_
' .- comrrsnrsnnonrsm
_
DIVISION cam!.
INSPECTION SPECIAL INQUIRY
' Sknopsis: -Provide results
Office of
the General
_Enelosure s!:
.below
.
of captioned
Counsel EOGC!
special inquiry
_Copies
of FD~302s
personnel.
,
-
_
following:
reflecting-interview results
I_*
e
to
the
for review.
.Enclosed_£or OGC and CTD are the
listed FBI
_
of the
II
.
1!
2]
3!
.4! b6 1
5! ,b?C
6}
7! -B!
7
1
7
7.77
Q
'
9
Details: In
July, 2004,
OGC requested INSD to
conduct
into whether
FBI personnel
.
had observed
any mistreatment
an inquiry
or
aggressive behavior
of detainees
at
Guantanamo
Bay, Cuba
GTMO!.
Based upon
this request,
on 7X09/2004,
INSD sent
an email.message
to
all
FBI personnel
who had served in
any capacity
at
GTMO
since
U9/ll/2001. The
email was
detailed as
follows:
_ -'
|
¢
' RESPONSES-3
gI
_~=
.
1"!
.
-
To: Counterterroiggm
From:'_lnspection
:>'
Re:
2'97-HQ-l32'?5669
09/2322004
A,
'
"You have been identified
assignment at
Division
GTMO,
Cuba
since
has been tasked
served in any capacity
with
as having
09/ll/2001.
an
The Inspection
-
contacting
those
employees
at GTMOand obtain
the treatment
of detainees.
to the following:
conducted
information
Employees
should
"
-.-
who have
regarding
immediately
respond
_
1! Employees who observed aggressive
treatment,
interrogations
or interview
techniques
on GTMO detainees
was not consistent
with
should
email
respond
via
Bureau interview
for
the
which
policy/guidelines,
purpose
of a followup
interview.
-2} Employees who served at GTMD and observed
no-'_
aggressive
treatment
of detainees,
should respond via an-EC
documenting
a negative
response.
The'EC
should include
the
employees official
Bureau name, title,
and tenure
of assignment
at
err-10;
.
_
'
Q
The
EC
should be titled
"GTMO,
Inspection
Special Inquiry",
Division,
1327669-A.
The EC should
with a hard copy.
not
_'
.
_
.
I
Counterterrorism
¬'
file
number 297iHQ~
be uploaded,
but
only
serialized,
' ' _ _
CTD provided
a list
containing
the identity
of all
Bureau personnel
and it was determined-493
had served in some
capacity.
This list
was utilized
for the forwarding
of the above
described
email.
_-
INSD'received 434
responses
from
Bureau
personnel.
Some non-responders
included
contractors
no longer
employed by
the FBI and employees who had since retired.y
INSD
received
26
positive
responses
from Bureau personnel.
The majority
of these
employees did not have knowledge of what the "approved"
-interview/interrogation
guidelines
were, but wanted to ensure
INSD was
aware
be noted
that
mistreatment
observed
employees
requested
of
a
of
or
possible
incident
of
mistreatment.
.It
should
the 26 employees who responded did not observe
detainees
rumored
to
of
outside
to provide
a
by
FBI
have
personnel._
occurred,
was
organizations.
brief
allegedly
conducted
These 26 employees
synopsis
any
Any mistreatment
by
were
of what they observed
in
order that OGC could make
a
determination
of whether a follow-up
interview
would.be
required.
The synopsis
provided
by each
personnel
is attached
to their
enclosed
FD 302 in thiscommunication.
'
' -
_
'
The synopsis
of each of-the
26
incidents
was provided
to GGC for review.
Subsequent
to the review,
OGC determined
that
nine of the employees would be required
to.be
interviewed.
The
personnel
are
identified
as
follows:
-
' 2
RESPONSES4
§
_
'
.
-I
'
an
LI1
'
.
To: CounterterroglgmInspection
From;
C:>
Re: 297-Ho-132?6es9-A,
09/23/2004
1!
Boston
.2} -
be _l
_ bn;_1
crnc
3! CIRG
4! Cleveland
Division
'
Division '
.-
Division
S!
- Houston Division
6!
- -TD
Anchorage - Division .' 9!
-CIRG
_
_
7!
The
of the
above personnel
were conducted
8! interviews
durinqfthe first
two weehs-of_September,
2004 with
the exception
_
Los Angelee
9
of| _'_
_to_,amedical "L*Ii
W and
[iswascurrently
on extended
sick '
1 ness
not available.
It should-
b6 '1 leave due
b7°'1
noted
bethatq;:;;;::]had
previously documented
his concerns
of
interrogation ec
1 es
at GTMO and provided
this documentation
to OGC.
h copy
ofEf?i::::]s communication
isattachedto this
report. '
_
The interviews
_
resulted in
a determination
that
no
FBI
'personnel were involved in
any mistreatment
or aggressive
behavior of
detainees at
GTMO. All
incidents observed
by these
employees involved
outside entities,
the majority
of whom could
-
not be identified.; None
of the
incidents were
similar in
nature
to those
reported at
the Abu Ghurayb Prison.
Specifics.regarding_.
~each reported
incident are
detailed in
each of the
enclosed
FD~ '
.3025;
- '
1
- '
' 4
3
RESPONSES5
' -
92.n -
_
I
TO! CO92lD.t8ItE.11'_IC}r;m_
'FI'O'[fl.;
>Bm
I1'1:9
Re: 297-1-IQ 13276669 A,
09,-'23/2004
LE392.D s} -='
.
.J
Set Lead
1:Info!
GENERAL COUNSEL
AT WASHINGTON
,DC
For informat
92
92
Set
'
ion and review . _
' e
Lead Z:
{Info}
COU'NTERf§EEB,OgI §M
I
A'If_l-L11;
wAs_11;Nc;ro1~1, DCVFor
.
information.
0'
n
F
92
I
-_4.
RESPONSES-6
'
if
_
__
o
_
*
_
__
1__
__ _
[Rcv.0I-31-2003}
.
H_
-|
_'
__
"
Z_'___
7_:--
¢
_'
1 -FEDERAL
.-
BUREAU
OF
- - --
_'
*
INVESTIGATION
Precedence: ROUTINE
Date: 09/23/200*!
To =Inspection
From: Inspection
Office of
Insgections
l' Contact: Y
b6 ~1Approved
- .|By::---lI
_'
_I I
--
b2 -1
C1
II
BY
i
Case IIJ#= 29'?-'nQ~A132';ss9-A
[Pend ing!-$56
Title: G'I'MO
--
-
COUNTERTERRORISM DIVISION
[CTD}
INSPECTION SPECIAL
INQUIRY '
Synopsis: Forward-original
the INSD
FD-302s and investigative notes
rotor. '
Enc1osure s!: Enclosecifor
Original FD-302s
interview results
of the
1!
the INSD rotor
are
the following:
and investigative
notes reflecting
below listed
FBI personnel.
'
it =_=.92:-rim-.92i";5 [
i
2} -
M5 Stet-
3}
41
_-r'|a92.'l
J
wi--92
5} 5.=.A-J
b6 -1
31¢ -} b7c
5! __,,|
7!
81 i_i
to
.-
soil-
it
~1
J1&5
'5?-»c'-o~92 5 =L
Detai1s:_ Captioned
special inquiry
FD-3025 and
investigative notes
is
concluded
and the
should be
placed in
file.
RESPONSES-7
original
l5
l
1
I 17
.
_
i-
_: t
7?
i
_
i i
I
T6:297-HQ-13276669-A,
Inapectipn
Igalm:
Inspection
_
09/23/2004
,
.Re:
E LEADIB!:
Set Lead
1: Info!
INSPECTION
AT WASHINGTON[
DC '
.-
92
File the
.1
F
encloséd documentation.
0+ l
92-
2
- RESPONSES-8
_
.
_
,
-
QL
FD-340:1
{Rem11-12-89]
»r92
[Title]
__
___
. _
afI'F~yM»1ma@@
{
?*
*"f*
~
-r7'
"
**
Y1: N
{
1 1
311»
F
92 t
ukil
I
fl?+-
*/L5»-ls=,
,
H
i
P="
1~
{
1"
*
" =
*+
1 1~
i "lg-¢92"
l_ _§_l
:""
+
-T'v. '
lr
: =
_
i ,
*1l%
1/111%.
_
_
_ :I
_
T;
_
4 ._
' _- 77
__.
_
_
..l
I
__
WW W
i
11 7 U g ;* *
.
~ 1
_
'7 ii
i
1:6
we
_
gs -*
92L!¥
'
-1
{ _
92
;;*
r
M5
1'
W
92
Ff
_ F
L
,7?
92 .
I
r»"
,
j -+
T
"1
*1 '
L_
L
__
_
_
if
Q,
P_
.
"7
T?
_p,
_
.~
_
___; ____
<~__
7
1
92
H
1
92
[ .
i
_
__
_
.
_
K
1
___
* f;
_: in-I
-1-
Positive
Response
Number
1
i
U <t.* 1»t.¢.:¢S=&Lg=I-<-'
I
.-2
l_
n
116
"1
- From:
F "=~
we ~1
_| BS_!
FBl}-.._
F
."
':Page'
L -_ -- -_ -. -
-Sent:
_Monclay,
U2. 200410:46
AM
August
12 X
i a/if
'
---Subjieot:
H
RE_:GT _M0-"
-H M
.- _
-
__ I
mc-1=Mr' ~- _Q
_I
.
-.
it |_§-lb _$,_.,,..__
é
._
I
,
I
._
'
requested;
As
hereis
abrief summary of_"what
I observed
at G_TM.Q:_._
.I _I
Jo *-e'¢'ou'piE
5r oc éissiorié,
i".¬nte're?.fi'inte'
detainee
iieWro6ms-to
'cihai|*iec|*|ji'arit_'l
a l1d'fo
nes
o t'3i'n1a f
.-_to.lhe- oor, withno -chair,
too'd, orw_a_ter.'
M ost'time5-ih
urihated
lr had.
or
defacated on
themselves, and-had
'
-. -' been
left there'for_.1B,.24
h_ourso'r'
On one-_occas_sion,
more. the airconditioning-had been
turned down
so farat"-5
the teifhperatufewascold
so intheioom, that-the
barefpoted detainee
was-shaking with
cold.When
'asked-the
I
- MF"s what wasgoing on,[was toldthat interrogators
from the-day
prior had
ordered thistreatment, -and
the -
.-
-detainee was otltohe moved.On ariother
ocoassion. the
NC had-beentunied
off, making
the temperature
in '
the_unventi|a_ted pro_b
room ab|y'we|i
1'00
overdegrees.
"The detainee-was-almost
ohconbjous -the
on oor,
with a
'- pile-'of
next,to'lI1irr_|.
hair apparently
Hehad been
literallyrpulling-oiwn
his hair
olgtth roughoutthe
night. Onanother
.occassioo,not onlywas thetemp'er_ature'unbearablY_hot,
tap 'rr_iusic
_butextre_r_r1e|y_io_ud
was being
played in
the;
' Ttoom,
and had
_ been
since-.th,e_hefore,'with'the
day
ohaii-'iedI_hand
detaineefootin the-feta|.position
and
on thetiie
._ _Ar_|1r-duestions,',feeifree'tocaiI_orask
iria
emai|_':r
In
l I -£3
~
---'
*
.'b7c-1~'
b6_1_;J1
-'Fm'm:
IN5D!. ~ .." '
F31!
'
-~In._. _-. l
5_El lttThl.l -Ju
-29 2004-1o_:sam¢
-_ -
-- we
-
1
.To
" .5
es! FBI! .1
.
:e=t_='
=.__
" '
-;:-.' "'
" '
'
.
:' .11
-9;. -.
-
-settles-tr-E111;=3?-:.6§te2ee.!'@2t1?se
'nsts :i*;*§*f*§:ii%;'" "ti
'-".zgg§.
-
.
_'-
.Could you'piease.provideofiwhatyouqbserved?
a.sh'_ort st|n1_maity
Thanksl.
'
. _V
1
-'
.,..Iii.-Si
L:7?
if
i_ii "ii
.
'
- ..é-4>en*i}ia1Iiéiessa'e. .- '
" - .'
'
_ _
» .is
eelsHt1..<rtt%
-es w¢<te§titzi@;w
&
Frorhi _i__ '
{- | has!-than
I'
i §l 1.:r1Ir:1;tt1*;;:s.t'
-- _ wmr-1
i
»l
e
..._.5°.
-"
" fl Sen't:
ggc
-JulManda
12
20114
AM
10:10i
e" T===|_iltI~
w=Bn
SI-1l2Jest= RE5§TI"lQ,___
_
r. ..t1-t=s.IDS -1
b7C
;i
t;-
_M__ h_ H,
_ _ _M
_
; »r
_
r RESPONSES.-10-i
-1 -
_I
. .'_
i aihrespohding
'tt>.j~,;i;Jii.1i-_f-_EEil1.tES-iufttf
and'inwpro_per
aogressive-treatment
interviewtechniques used
on detainees
at GTMO.
ldid
observe treatment that
wasnot only.-
-
adgressive; personally
but
very
upsettir':g,'
l can t_say
that
although
this
treatment-tiras_ perpetrated
by --
'Bureau'en1ployees;
seemed thatthese
I_ttechniques were
beufig employed
by.the_n'i|l|ta|'y.
;.
'
.
_-
E,
.
_
____
_
_i'_
*7-
i_ _
_ i
_
.II 1 llviessa- 1={'é;
_ _ .
.|
bsl -
. .
' _
. V,
__
L
__
_b1_
_gwemméntcontigctempfcyeest
_J
_.
-
__
_
h--"-h-15":-.1
*_ _;
_My name ISSA Boston-_D1ws|on,EOD
7
_
' '
_
.
.
'
_currenlIyas5|gnedt0Squa_1d1 ._
x
'_ _ "
_ b2
-1-
»'. b6 2
_,b'?C 2_
2.
;' ' _- _
.-fs.-----in---_
:*>
I--1--»
'--I-7
<|Iii..-L-92_..i.-,I-_-5'-1 :
Y J.
T
n'-
*7
.
-
*.- -
_ J
.... _ _ _
.
I
F
92
|
4
'
-
+-
' '-
" '.
? _.
RESPONSES"-11='
~
_ _ _ _.. -.-. ..._
_
1 .
Jytessag "in Hl
»
fl'
r
Page 1tof2
e
I-0.
Caproni Valerie E. OGC! FBI! ."
-
-
o<~~s@»~=B~>
i'
e i- r:.Sent. Monday,AugustU2,_20D41D.5BAM
J
ttéglrleo s§f
t? .e?'atmz
'
t3'm£§
b6
-1
b7C 1'
-.
.5
< 1r _i t
iwiteiigis
to
F»-
T01"
_" Caproni'.
-'
~ FBI!
ValerieE. OGC!
-Subject: FWI
GTMO
"
- ....
..e1=;._@t'$.;ir?tFs.@.ti§T;£1faatiz-ea-
_
_TU
N-
E.
I
,V5
.
i
Here
theissecond
summery./One'rY1*ore
go. /d
to
F~+~=iiBs>@<FB1>
----Ori inal
he ~1
Messa e----- -/"
Sent: Manda Au ust 02, .QD41O:45AM'
r==i_"t i<1~sD> ran
b7C 1
.Subject::_RE: GFMO
_'
-
"'-
i
5-
y1
r
-' '
.
'
--
e r ._
W
__.__'.,1~3_iii?-l'I "
'
-_.;,:L.,L=1;,_-_e+-.~:__ _-
t
@;¥.E'~.E§;§_1.!:@.1.EZ1_1lfL1:1i3;¥3:§L¬
.-
_LI,
.
JI
- b6
-1
b7C *1
As requested,
here isa
brief summarpof
whatlobservedGTMO:
at
_-
- ;
J4
K."
_
J:/1 .._
r
_
I
Onaggup'ie'E:f
oooessions,
entered
I
interview
rooms toi nd
a detaine_e chained
hand and
toot in
afetal position
to the
floor, no
withphair,
food,W8iB@ll,_,OSf
or
urinateid
llf1'lB5,t92'TBy
defaoated
or themselves,
on had and
, _ had
'been
there-for
left 18,24'orhours
more. n oneoowssion, theair conditioning
had beenturfned
down sofar and
.-:I .
the temperature
wassooold
inthe room, thatjhe
baretooted detainee
was shaking
with cold.Whenl askedthe
Ml? s what
was going
on ,'I
w sgin that interrogators
from the
day prior
hadordered
this
treatment. and
the
detainee
not
be
mo92
towas
another
:%On
the"NC
oocassion,
been
off,
had
turned
the
making
l;empera
the unventilated
roor1].p"iot:|a
well
over100 degrees._.
The detainee
was almost
unconcious
the ithon
a-
.pile ofhair
next
to _hii_n.
He hadapparently been
literally pulling
his ownhair outthroughout the
nigh nether.
odcassion, not
only was
the temperature
unbearably hot,
but extremely
loud raprnusio was
being
played
in the - "
'and
room.
h_ad'beer|
since the
day before,
with the
detainee chained
hand and
footin
the feta! position
on-the tile
oor;
'b6
b7C
V. I .
_I.
-'
'
, ,
_
_
_
.
.
.
_"
.
Any questions,
feel to
tree
callor ask
via email.
IL
7_" T
-
.
-- b2"1
'
.it
-----Original Message--»
'_
lI
~I92_ '
,
Fmm= IN$Di FBI!
1Sen
u
_l
'da ul
To: {E-S!
Subject: RE:.GTMO
§@
he -lJ§Qg
be "1
2D041D:58AM
"-
C '1
FBI!
_
re
~
_f_
_
.
-
Co uld
you piease'pro~_vide
ashortsummary
what
of you
observed ? Thanks.
_'
' ---on inal Mesae'----
'
be _1 ,F~m=ih<Bs><»=B1>
s
i
r
_
_
.
,,
,_
_
M835- E135
'
'
_Page
of2
C
~.
r U92--t_;-_;--- b6
-1 '
"
b7C~1 WI]
'
L
L L
I am
responding to yourrequest for
feedback on
aggressive treatment
and improper.'
- intetviewtechniques
usedpn detainees at
GTMO.
-
I did ob,se_rv,e treatment
that was not only
.
aggressive, 'but"personally
very upsetting,
although
Ican tsay thatthis treatment
was perpetrated
by -
'
bl
___ Bureau employees. Itseemed
that
these techniques
were bein employed by
gcwernnient
employeeei
centred
_- the-military,
:33"; --
nameisSA
Boston EODmt:un'enl1y
Division,
- '
aeaig
- _C-9, telephone _
'
.'_
: 92 _
_ _.
"
-"
-b6
- bi T1 '
_etc
.tnnni ég liawggaeanrnaf '*"
"sen _,t
_glee?!
_
' 1aawsHava4a;nueu;aummfna"t*
1
B!@!::t'
_-
_
I
RESPONSES 13
-
-2
-2
-
.
Q .bgiossagel
'
_
'
Papelof-1
,
=2 _
i
ruse!
|_ I
-1 '
b7C -1'-.10;
_| BS!
I FBI!
Subject: RE:
GTMO _
.
FBI!
"
--
._
-
»,
e
»-
_
_ _I.
h.
.
,'
'you.
Thank
witt
t pnnt
outyour response
and once
the responses
are oompteted,
adetermination
be
made
wilt"
reference
the
intewiews.
-Orl
.-
..
InalMessa
e '
__.
.'7
5ub'ject:RE:GTMO "'
' -
'
__
_
Sent:
Mondaf
ME2125
04
10:10
AM
To: mso!
FBI!
b6
-1
b7C l
_'
._
--
.
I
."
sWsn
Ami-°'F7_1=
| .
b6
-1
b7C -1
bl
___
b6
1__
b7C -1
-
I arnresponding to
your
request
for feedbackon aggressive
treatment andimproper . _
interview. techniques
usedon
detainees at GTMO.I didobserve treatment
that was
not onlyaggressitfe,
but personally
very upsetting,
although can't
-I
thatsay
thistreatment was
perpetratedbyBureau
.en1p|oy'ees '
' '
es wenebeing employedby
the
r"*P'=rrr*ir
t"'15!
t
st
_My
name
is
SA -tetephonel
h
92_ .
.' '
t
|
-
military, government contract
.
HBoston Division, EOD]::-{currently
assioned
Squad
toC-19;
I
_ _- , .
92 _ * _'
_
73-
. ' l'
b2
-1
-"
'se|~r'srr|
sslgreo
'
b6
~2
'
b7C -2
_-
'
'
<
-_....
IdHERE'*
°5HUI¬11'
-r.
....
..-_M..o..,..Ji..|.-._.............?¬E'_M.
_..~.-.-..-._..w-Q... =§
.
RESPONSES 14'
IE£ER' ItI-
___
,
_
Q-I.-.'-...'>'.92l
in
_,
mm
' .
IFD-3i Rw,10-6-Q5!
iO
n.r" n-
_
_
Li:
'FEDERA1=BUREALIOFINVESTFGATHHV
i
_Date
was t -elephonically
oftuusnriptiun UQ/U9/2004
contactedzconcerning her
b6 -2
.b7C' - 2
knowledge oany
£§?C'i1 aggressive
treatment, interrogations,or interview techniques at
' Guantanamo Bay, Cuba {GTMOJ . After being
advised as
identity of
the_inte:rviewing Agent
and the purpose of
to the
the
I interview,|'::_|
provided
following.information_to
the
th
specific special
inquiry questions:
V[:|described
as an
'
her two month.TDY assignment
at
GTMO
interrogatorof detainees.
During February
and March
2003, [;|wae.
teamed
withtwo
different
Naval
Criminal '_'
Investiga"
we Service
NCIS] Agents
and severaltontract
translators for
with one
s ent,
noted
during their
detainee interviews.
92:]initially worked
NCIS Agent for roughly
the first
three weeks
then asecond Agent the last five
weeks
of
of her
the TDY.
_
a
slight work overlap
between
two
theNCIS
Agentstraining -transition.
The "primary questioning
b6 -1
b7C -1
interview the
between
Agents.
.also. noted
the interview
responsibility for
the interro
ations was
_. assignment for the
translators
language of
thedetainee. ".
' Shaver
alternated each
varie
daily
'
based on the spoken'
''
'
-
witnessedor
was _aware ofany aggressive
I
policy/ guidelinesr
no knowledge
hador understanding
oftreatment, interrogations,
detainees
at
GTMO
Department of
or interview
in on
istent with
Defense 0
hh/aggressive
techniques employed
FBI or
on
DOJ _
authorization for
interrogation techniques.
_
the permitted.
use
b6 -1.
b'TC -1
.
Furthermore, _.
was- unaware
of DOD
authorized interview
techniques.
'
_Shad
or other-U.S.
conditions or
allegations of
no substantivecontact withMilitary Police
government personnel
at GTMO regarding detaineetreatment and
was unaware
of any
specific
misconduct or
alleged -by interviewees or
mistreatment by
others. |::|
pictures, video,
audio, notes,
depicted or
described aggressive
interview techniques
else
who
was in
employed at
possession of
had n_o
-
or other
docu.mentation_whic1'1
treatment, interrogations
or '
GTMO or knowledge ofanycne
such items.
*.
Invcstignljonou 09/09f2004
U.S. personnel
stated she
b6 -1
b7C -1
._
.
at Washington,
D. Cf.
Filed? 29?-HQ-nl32'?.669_-A
_. Ltelephonically}
naemmea N/A
- .-
1,, SSAL:
*7* _JMW35-E1 l RESPONSES
-This dcwnmcnt
ountains uciihur
recommendations conclusions
not
oftile
FBI. llis the properlyof the FBI andis loaned
to your agcnny;
,o_
w- I
rs
i
_
_,
q_..
- _V 1|.
FD-302a{Rev.
10-6-95!
:
4a'l'b
-
_
'
297 HQ A1327669 A
.
-
.b6
~1
mo -_1
i
Continua1:ionofFD-3020f
'
V
7
- _; J|-1.
_
,Paga
- 2
I -I : W-itnessedtheaa aesuenlces
at ;'='erriap
""7"'
questions
e treatment
The two separate
incidents
trailers
recall
of detainees
occurred
named Delta Camp.
the specific
on twodifferent
occasions.
at the interrogation
'
However,[:|was
dates or provide
detainees
identities.
In both incidents,.
c1'1'ained'hand"a
foot in d
the fetal
position
floor
of the interview
r-ooms-. The
"rooms
rooms were without
evidence
control
the detainees
were
and laying
on the
longer.-
of any food
or water.
of the rooms was regulated
The detainees
had llrinated
-
137:;-1
also recalled the
Furthermore,
to be either
extremely
cold
orhot.Iilnoted oneoccasion
where
.excess
'
loud rap mu-sic p ayed in the detainee"s
interview
room.
I for believed
thedetainees
were
kepthours,
in such
'
conditions
periods of time more than
18-24
and
themselves.
.
b6 _1
I
were without
" furni_shings, to include any chairs.thetemperature
unable to
any knowledge of the two
and/for defecated
'
'
~'
on __
_
J
- '
Shortlyafter the TDYassignment
ended,'l:I
sent a b6-3.-
personal
letter
to the Director
explaining
her desire
to return
to GTMO.
|;:|informed theDirector
shewasin a position
to
1170
-1
- generate s gnificant
intelligence
collection
regarding an investigative
matter, and :'_=1,ddLes5Zthe_issue
relating
to thetreatment
-
of
detainees.
.
~
'b6~
b1'c-
"
'
RESPONSES-16
i
A.
L.
|_
..
92
'
¢
|_______
___
M
_
_
__7___
1
_ W
_ __
__-l-A-#
____
92
J ms-mu
Raw.
s-Mfr!
..
"s92
-n.-
_i ._,. .. ..,.. . ._._ _.. ...
..,_
..
_
.
I
!:
Universal
Case.File
Number
J! -
Q
L
if ? .
-Fie|d Aeqgltlng
O[fice
Evidence
,
iIL.=-92
Seria1,#
=1;.92._f
o:igigi=.%zi'
':"i'?qg_
V
~
-2
_..='*"=.'_'
-'__'
_
>P";
.=
b6 -2
we -2
b6 - I
b?C
Y
'
4:;-|_____-_ ____- :.92zr'r..
.
_§-
92
*7
=
;~f---!;
=I
.,.=@**-' mqn.
_
7' 7
'-_.
f_-;l-. -:,_,-_,.,.;-,'.
_
4 Fri
1
b6 -1
b7C -1
._92
~ -Hétume
U
l
5
Nlo_
§-Fi_ec'aipt___
-1:1, . .'i.ven.
.
P:
-
. .-
I. ._..
.
..
1
; @F**"¢.*1+'"'YIMe=@**@!i£11i§é¢
Pufm
,
f
i' %¢
" 3,-.1ao,Ru|e-,5-'
.-l =i9d_éig§1l::FIl|?léé1fo'f_}Cfiif1i'riiiI"?E5
9.!.
92=-
.'
_-
1
u
--
.»
- d ._
92___.__;l__.'_f_._-.1_
_|
I.
- .
_
'
I
Ii
..':IFl§f9f'e|
f- aoe:__
~
.
_
.
* <<=+?=>I--L-~T=.>=@rI1e'§!=:-=#<%i='r~s"1
Qg§r§|_'I_ptlon.
Original
nr>tef5"'re ilj|tér_92rie92'ra
:1
-r3_
QA
1
92
1
»-
.
| |
-
Egcmi
A,
' '
- L b6 -2
_
b7C *2
LLLLLL@=1@> ~/L»>,v{§@~L
N
Z¢Z>
I
b2 1--L
1; 2% mu ms fP>»1H*¥.&
N127 ml
L LLL.:%J.;L7;§_1_o
II-I
L
Lem wf /wwW>
L
LL
L
LL
_LLL_L___L;L~L_1¢
Mg,Lr"
aruzz
4w
,'
W5 Q4
>9P¢+1L §/
1»£r¬¬LWLLLLL§é1>L
3ii; - AL
l
*1
Tj
N%1'5
, i;iiL_iLL
f
; ;ij;;L;1Li;;;:;L;%;QZ@LL;;L
LL
L
PI Ilillli-Q
ma! -M;
iL%i;1
"L A»»1~:6f%~=@
?L
_L
»_'
msspowses-18 L
_i:
1
- @%
-I fi -
45+/1'?
L L
g»
? é
LLLL1L1>LLLLLL'mg,,L L1:>|JP1a.»921L
L
92.
L
q-q92_92u|
L
7
L
LLL L
LLL
I I
L
F@92:~:~LLLw+//1f>TLfIw
L 7Jm A A~*r4 -l>I
LL1-Q1.
.r'
n '
'
'
-.
.
I
|
92
92
M
92
92
92AP
- -,
H
u. L
V
'
L 3 L_L~
L RESPONSESQQ
Positive
Response
Number
¢
2
Message
..
I
nu-11¢ _. . .
d
._
-
--
Sent
Friday,
.
'
'
.
92
Page
1 of
1_
.-
.
.
ll|.N$D! FB1!
-
.. ._.
.
.
'
_ .
JulyO9,ZUU43:42PM
-,
.__._U_5____;:...
-_ _q», ,,.,..,-, ,,,
.. .,;:,-.21.-3--.'
_._..
.{ -'
"
V' .'
"
To: [NSD!{FBI!
L
-1
-.
'
FBI!
.I
.'
Cc:'
Fedaircyk,
Janice_K.
|R!'
FB;;;
|R!
FBi!_- |R!'
_
_-
'
b6
-
.
Sub]ec1:GTMOE-Ma~'
i LO_bl=BLEQQEJl
.
»/
/'
Perthérecent
F
BIHQe-mail
request,
be
advised fhccfiduringmy
GTMO
Tenure,
I
didwitness,
aggressive
_Tr"ecm inferviiaw
nan r,
interrogafinn
Tac_hniqua s],of'|Jafuinee.s
e.1'c.
by non-Bureau
peréonnel.
-CIR6's
,
11122/2002
Elecf opit
CommunicrTOFBIHQ
ion
65A-MM C991C|2,
serial724!dafoils
some
of Phase.
_'
bbsanrutiuns. -
.' '
'
'
'
'
__-
i
I
»
1
aZ
r
.
,
* /
_.r
.//
_.
l
_
,
=
,I:
1
.4
"
i
.b6
-1
CIR6/'NCA'VC/BAU
"
.
.
Lb2_1
_'
/-
f
i
.
/'
_c Ssr so
S
l
' ._ 'HapeaIl'_s
weII,_.
, "-3
~
'
__ .-
'
k';
¢<
-
._
I
~_
5
RESPONSES-20
"
_
92
.'
..
orca-20112-3-96!" hi
.-
_
!
.
" FEDERAL BUREAU OF
,."_
*"' "r"-'- '
r
_.I
_
XXXXXX
]NVESTIGA.'I ION
.
FOIPA
.DELETED
-
PAGE
INFORMATION
.'Page }- withheld
entirely
at
locationin the
le. One
or more
of the
_fol1owiing where
stateurents,
iridicat
-explain this deletion;
-
_
clica
ted
E-I Deletions
were made
pursuant
to
the exenzlptiom
in
releaseto
you.
below with no segregeblematerial available for
_ .-
'
.
1
Section 552a
§
*
oM11
-
-
U b! !{A!
U ¢1! !
U 1!
E! b! T! B!
U i! !'
U b! !
El b! J C!
U- ¥I! !
-U
U b! l D!
U '
' b! J E!
' .0
T3 b! !
.
03 !
'.D
. El -!9!
U 'b! !'
s ocbm.
hU
U. fb! B!
k! ! -
- 1:1
km.
I {El Irifornnation only
plertainetl
tea
partywith reference
no to
thesubjectorof
_-
a
o-lam!
I
'
request is Listedinthe title
-only-
.
'ou=>e>.
~
U fb! ! F!
' ~
00 !
- .
_'
_
the subject
of your
' |:1
' for
*5
Documents originated
with
Government agenny
Ilreseuoelnnents
es!.
referred
were that
agency esl!
reiriew and
direct response
to you.
' ad'db-rh'FBla
l
_-_'Pages
contain information
l_:!{.another_ Governrnent agency
Yon
ies}.
will
be vise y e
'
..'
-'
to
the - releasahilitythis
of information
following our
consultation with
the other
ageney es!. _-
;,
:1 '_Pagelfs!
'
witl1held'iJ1as'n1uch
analrelease _deterr1'Jination
has not
been
as made.
Youdwillbe advised
as to
the"_
'
"
uispositionatalatet
_
'
'
3'.
__.
'
Pages
bl: not
were
co11side're:i
_for
release
theyasare._i_:Il1pl_ioative
of joke
_2'q"°
'.&
an
' 'Page s!withl1e1d
for thefollowing 1-easou__s!;
'
EThe
l
1 - i __
'
_ __ _
_
_
following number
is to
be used forreference regarding
-these pages:
l tif
'
Posrrwe
_-!'C¬-S,'_#g,1-§$Q.__'1VU
'2__
__r
fs
' £3-ea;
:_
Caeimses maes
2.1- 2.11-J
Km;m,;.,;X,s mmm
X Deleted
Page s!
XNo
Duplication Fee
-X for
this page '
h in
- '
i o0
- U2 Rev, ID-5-95!
._1_
__
FEDERAL BUREAU
OF H'WESTIGATION-
-_ _ -
__
-
EEC 32E .0D:|
,
_
.DarnoftrnnscriptionQgrfl /2-094
__
_
. __r.,
__ _;__~_
I'
_
_Supervisory
Sp_eg,.1.al Agent SSA!
INational Cen'ter'for
Analysis--of
the theViolent " _
m
NCA
V
e Acad my, Q uantico Vir ,
Cri es
C , F BI
regarding his
knowledge of any aggressive
interrogations, or
interview techniques
GTMO! ._ After being
advised of
interviewed
g, inia was
treatment,. '
_
b6 1
byc -1
at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba
the identit
of the
-
interviewing
Agent
and
the purpose
ofthe
interview,
ssab
provided
the |
following information
in response
to thirteen
special inquiry
questions: I
._
_
'
.
nment
to partnered
GTMO'began
09/12/2002on
and
ne n1s TDY
O2. ass-i
|;q]was
with
SSE:
-
,assistance
also to -from
NCAVC,
both
whom
providedbehavioral
_-1_
the intelli
enoe gathering
mission involving
"the b6
- GTI-IO.
detainees. While
|:__E-:never participated
in detainee bvc -1
interrogations, he
'so1Tletimes observed
-them. Also,
when '
requested, he
reviewed background
files of
the detainees
-to
-assist
in the
formation of
interview st-rategiesf
civilian w
'
primary
pointcontact
offor thewas
| in errogation
oa
overall responsibility
the detainees.'. He-directed the"military
reservists who
interrogation met
-
a
of 1,5
_
mc -
conducted
inthe
r ations
of
the-his
detainees.
_he
"did not,'like
because
, attitu
of'
e anadvised
is I '
os.
' I,
.
_
'eoQdid
witness
aggressive
treatment,
interrogations
niques
employed on
detainees at
GTMO
I
_be -1 ;
inconsistent with
FBI or DOJ olicy/ guidelines.
Th-e incident
involved detainee
num}:-erC:F
- -, mt -1,4
or interview
_When arrivedin GTMO,
.numberg|was incarcerat
in'a dar ened
ce
J.l1
the Naval
.Bri
nurnbe i-[was
Sergeant
staff
a .The
lea interrogator
for
reservist from.
|:] requested
he and;observe numberjjand
provide
- b7C
an"
-113
California. About
assessment of
-discussions
two weeks
after
his behav
or.
'
During
arr've in GTMO, _
the following
concerning_integ_'oggtion options
week, '
was
to
evelbp
an
interrogation
enable the, interrogators to elicit
information
Iavestigationoo:
-09/14/2004 at
Quantico, VA
Fa.» 297A-HQ-A1327665i-A
300 b6.-1 _-
_
for number
occurred betweenLd
7 _ ___ ~|.and The
_objective
Vb6
stra egy
w ich
would
from_r1uml_:>erU
-
- Datedictated
N./A '
This document
c0t|ta.|'11s
recommendations
neither
conclusions
nor
of
Lb: FBI. It is the pmparlyof 111:FBI andis loanodin your agency; -
413:4
+
1
so-302 {Rev.11}-6-95!
_O h
e"n
29'?A-HQ A132?669- '
A
_
_
'b61-
'
b7c-
' '
TOn
4 Page
Can 1:nationofF_D-3020
Z
_l I 1'
' , Qggjgzzgg
__
2
l ._ " ""6nt'1n'!0a?2'uo.2,
"rzam"-if:-hej-w
t&
Brig to
Camp Delta,
at which
point he
was fed,
and interrogated
by an interrogation
team,
however
he failed
to provide
an
substantive information
Later that
same evening,
number was
transported to
Camp X Ray where he was placed
in aplywood
ut
and interrogated
by another
military interrogation
team until
the early
L: L-mg
morning hours
observed both
of 10/04/2002
interrogatio adviseotthe
screamed and
yelled at
_,_| ,|c_1
|and
number during
interrogators
both interrogations
At
some
point
during
the
second
:|.nterrogatJ.on,:t;__|a
|E_::|
trned
to their
uarters
During the
late aernoon
ours o
nd
re
uq
10/04,/2004l:|and returned
to- observethe
interrogation. of
number advised
the Koran
placed in front of number '
aptain
_
UnitedQ1"!
States Marine
Corp, began
to -interrogate
point_ during the interrogation
the detainee.
had been
.
b6
-P '. 1,
Captain|:_|squatt_ed over
At some
b7C
the
3,
4
1,3,
.Koran, which incensed
nuJnber|i___|and caused
him to reach for the
-Koran.
Whi1e
did
not observe
the incident,
he was
nearby
when
it
occurre ,
eard theyelling,
-"and wentto -the hut to ---V
1learn--what 'ened.
-ha
|:;|was
then told
what'occurred_.
.,
' -and then re urned
to_ their-quarters.
On
'¥
10 05 2002, aGerman Shepherd was
placed in front of
while h'
dler commanded
the dog
to growl, bark,
and
n1:|_rnber,E
teeth.
- andt;lwere displeased
the with
interrogation
techniques ul ize on number |:|and decided to depart Camp Xshow his
Ra .They were never again
in
the presence o number|:
.:|believed
the interrogation
of number
| concluded on
10/OB/2002. -
_
_
92
- ' Approximately twoweeks afterthe aforementioned
1no1dent,| |and
were at Camp Delta in an
.
observation
room which
was
located Between two interro ation rooms. G
was
observing
one
"interrogation
while
was
observing.
another interrogation--when
entere t
eobservation
room.
.- had
emtaken
somehthingh
|
|accom
.
Iwhil
an1edh
him to
an interrogation
room where
he-o served'
was laughing and he told and
remained in
a. etainee
the observation
with
a full
beard
Ihe wanted to
room. later
b5
b?C l,3l,3
told that
-whose.hea .had.been_'wrapped in duct
tape.
.-Shortly
thereafter,|:land't| GTMO.
departed
-. telephonic
_including
advised he
andl:| corresponded
e mail with
E B IHQ representatives,
at FBIH
and |
and others
nd via
-»
RESPONSES-26_ '
.
be
Q _b7C
1
-1
FD-3l]2a Rcv.lB-6-95!
' 1
QI
0'1'.
tl
. 29'?A l-IQ-A1321-'569 A
_'_
Cnn nua unufm-3020f I .
_
1:6 -1
'
'b7C
11 _
,Qn ,Page
3
regarding
££é5Emé5t""f
the'aéiai
b6
-1
'
ees
ensuredwas
UC£Be
apprized
ofetmGTMO.
theeven
aM0.
s £:::;:;1a1so"
bT<I
-1
b5 *1
|:__|had=no knowledge
or understanding
of Department
11711
'1
of
Defense DoD! authorization for
the permitted
harsh/aggressive interrogation
techniques. He
' any
of the
interrogation techniques
authorized.
_|:
_
tenure at
notes or
use
of
1
was. not sure
if
he observed
were actually
j-'
had nocontact withinterviewees during
his jI
GTMD. He also advised
he -had. no pictures,
audio, other documentation
which depicted
or described.
_116
aggressivetreatment, interrogations
or -interview
detainees at
GTMO.and_ had
no knowled
e "of
_
.,
'1
anyone .
additional information
' GTMO.
-1
techniques 1°76
else was
whopossession
in related tosuch
items.
of :1 had
no
_the_tr.eatmen of
detainees at}
employed on
_
.'
_
'
_Upon his return-from cmo, |:|
along with':|
related the
aforementioned incidents
to SAC Stephen R. Wiley. b5
'1
Also, :|
drafted an ac dated ll/22/20D2,_which_ outlined
the _'
C *1
aforementioned events,
subsequently forwarded
was approved
to CTD
by SAC Wiley, and
Executive Management.
I
I
-RESPONSES-27
-
.%"'
M 5*
'
.mmon;n=-.-.s-1,93!
_.
-z
0
r;'_>:-y-5:-<." "'
'
:'~-:~:*;':,::-92_r1_~_~"
--L =14-Q
. ,2 :
:.--;92
Ȥ,-1
¢
"
I
*1
_Uniyppssjl
Case
File
Nummr
A
2-
@_
'Fiel.Cl'O
Acquiring-Evidence
il::e .
:1.
_$gr_la_l
#pfOrlglgatlng
Document. -_.é
-'
.
H.
. _|_-_'
. .
_.._ 92.
. 31Djtgiieuelvaki"
:.
W
a
..1'
92
-~--~--~
9292
--|92_|
-{;";¥'i
-~-
.
.1,a
...4'
1.
- ';_'.+
.
H,1:
-q.--_
. _1. .;
_
1;:
- - '
.'1
.;
-1
Q-4__
-='<-'>.b6
=.
a
-_
'-
..
..
'5
¢ ='!1 ,H."_=*?"'!'P"!°;!?
»
.- .._..! 1'
;
_ ,. -92.
..:411..
1""?
b7C 1
.1.F_
Hameof'Spac1'E|1ge*
_- "
" F;.__
ToBeRelumed
ElYes
;E11J.o '
'.
.2-'-.
....92
'92
_
X
NK
w
A
F|B0ei'pf+Given
-nYes
i
0 ._
Grland.-JlJ_l'Y
iuiéiei-131'{:bis§§hiii5§i;$_;Qh§
Mule
1
'
b
I_.;;__
jlh -_ .
l."92.'T|.I|B:
h
;_-.'5"1...v-'1'-J.
-.r.."-.
=5
'
..4;
1.92
..w"
.'_'.'-92.
'
1'
I
.|,-
1
1
. 92 '
_Reference:
7
$ -"
i
1
:':i
92
' 1*3i°v'T1iT"4"iF&a1iq[1jl5
, ¢1.9=iFi55!=!=¬ii=J
-- . . .
.-.,.:__
92
Desc pticn:
6;§i}ia|
_
b6 -1
137:: -1
If
92;..92
. £1.
92
T
_
I
.
-_1.'_._
;*FaE§Po192|sEs-'
l_ Is
|
_:.¢..
- -'.
¢
_ -..
- J '
_.. no
d
. __,'_
._
..
.
L *_ i__:.
7
__7_'|,,_j,'_k____
__
_ -
ea
_
-. ..-.
u
_'
}__
..__
-
*W
5 L 7ln-H- * ~iI-
U»m
~
L
41% if
9292
2
j
_
b6 .1
I-
lid
.b7c
-1 _ =1 ~
*Q
1~
~ 5343
56 -2 f~
b7C
. @
7
,
,7
_'
*
j
1i,=__-_
h
~ »» @:~
-2
_
.
"'1
V
i
_ ' j
i Y*- -5*L-h_1:_/'££n_L;
M133-C
j
17 L
__-__ . f 2-;Z_Ii
j-
/"'"k
*
"
-.l._
'
"
_
"
W
Q - 511.2,] 5 QZ,;=._?'{{:Q;W
V _ I;H
Q:
1
i
2r
pg gtgL£2-L
j 92Q92-92f
ééginm
Q ;;_u§¢,;%,
'
J
92_
_-___ P
A
f
L1
,_
1
__,
_Q-
. CL !JfP92!"r-Ax
_f_|Q§>L;t! "ub92-;;|'1|-q1__
__ _ __
r*1~
hi -l 31:ȴy-m ;o
@-*i if?92l:¢4<&
-1»-»J<,
_ -_ Lu?/ W!
B <L
;W j 7'
92
___
Z 1L92"£?
<-Ln}-f xigmnl
LL;-,_/'*
r #"'-#*-4';_ ,7
J
92
.
92 _
_ ; __1 ___
_ __
_. _ '_
____, _, T:
92é_
_ _ ,_~_,_ ___, 1 , ,_ W 1,
Q ______1_7"'
_ _ 1_ J_ ,
;_.:2c-:_5!_L|:|#_'_'-_1'592.
M
NM./.@7.|%L
M,Q,mm_K
| ____
_ _ -M14115;
;~/r- -rȢI.
jj j
'_'
j
j
7*
{ {_-{{-¢m@;».{,-92.a{
an ~92:m~_,?:924R'
Q9"
92;
.___;
_
__
_ q_;1_'_
.___
__0___
_{1~_;§"¢
'
-____
,
%
B-95
-i*@-;~11
?"£n-L1h'r£'h.{.
r.1: .D"#1~'
* _*=-JWJQ
ii1,b§.'C
-i 3,4*- fff»WW2i '1'|f92§
Fu~_
3,4
K
$
-_ ffK-A]
-n r="@§-~
Wm;
1w'
{ _*%
2W
__"
#2
_
I { ]@<.w~
»-_4P
_;
{ -_<_Qm
{ { -[:]2* -Mg;
I.gLt _.-;c--»~?
RESPONSES? 29
¥
>v _
92.
A77-n.-.-u7-7 --..¢.1~_7 7 7-_+
7 77 ;__ 7 4+7- A77-H
'
::~7i7
+7 7 7 ***_ 7_:~:7
:__
7; _ 7
;l
J
"=55
77$
I
'
7u
,511»-Ff
7i
7
7-W
777-7?
Q:92J_1'1-=7
2L+77r?»1
.
7 5 -W-1-*1
125
92
92
1
b'?C -4
-A7-
H779 7
17 777v7u7
77777177773 £7>777~7
_77n.n 74Laa ;L77710~¬u.1ufJ
7-'I1l*77"!¬:J7
1'-7 ,.7¬
A
7,77J¢""717'J7
"~gz~*J3~rn7'*~1
-i'§_777'
4l~Ln5-2.7
7F
l777
T1 777'
-777
7c§1_1_1f|_1~"3'_1"
1"1=r77 79'7>"771
Q17:
w'~"¢
77?<7¢
7. 777 -92
7
r
'. b6 -1
{__.__b?c -1
7~'7 Q1 L P~>U'7
-44
_
/-~.
_
P71
_
_
7
77 7""7 '7 J *5 7§92l""92-2&7 -i!'
0- _--J77
~: %
7 77
s7"@
_
_
mg»;-1n&r
M%rn&
Mb
g
q
77 7juflcgajl VIM/~£!n=/2.m7-72E|:l_
4@
B5 73,4
if
7ii"'_ 'i""- "rm: 3,4
792
77
[
77777_ 7:
_ ~-
*
7
*7 '
_.__l
*
'
*
1
Q7!»
77,17
7-77
1777-77
7
7
77777
7»?
7l:::17@
7
*
.'7
1*
=1 --
92
-7
__ i
"
7
~.AALP
-~7»?'
7...]
- _.. ~w
3
77@i»~~7-» -JI1l J7_|Z_|77~77~~
7
77
1
~b6 -1 7Lmjziz
4f?7_7
7%
b7F
,1
7.1
5+7=
~?%
~'4*5§
7 L*"?}1
77
!?
7>~?
"@
71<
L-_§
MJ
l
92
j*
77
-'
1
92
<=r=;77b;711{
77777-T77»;
77
-77777-7 92-7r5¢"~*
W!: 5711177
Li; 7;7~7-3=~7-7-11
gq g-| 7 7
717171>'*4
I-*1=-* ~
H7777777
7 7t77
57711:»-1.77-7
."$- r9-h'§}l;z7-'
T7
9277
7 ¢L1§»~»7»~u--=- =7
775"
1arn3'~Q7&#
-*"'~:792r7&
r92-7>I~!.7
Y
=** - ~D
7
777
: 1&1 ?-/=7*'~IL
Q7»
A7_ 7 L 7 ii?
77 777
7i7¢[_J¥
Fli b6
-4
.7-/.
_ we -4
L7 77
771%
77 .
E-LHL
chi
H n{map
_-
_
RESPONSES 3O 7 -
_§lrZ9
I
_
___
,__ .. _,.,_.,..,_......_.,,,.,_...,...___.__.____.,....,_;,.,_.._,.,..
,___..._..
.-_............,-a-.-.-..-'--__,---¢_._-_,
____--.._.-.._._,._,__..-92...--..-.-__..-.-I
.
.q
IJW
l.___..-____....--
-
4
b6
.
{Y
i 5,?hif/Q3,»
_"1=r§i»~>r'
|
,~¢,,,m}~.»
?_ ?
l,3,¢1
4,7I 7 -_=mJ.._.
w_/__¬
I ___
_'
9|
i ___
'
92
_
.
.
if __
[ Hi H
jf
%_ ~
F
I
V
TML1-/'
Y
ML?
?_i>J!<?1J-l1@
gin 1 WM ML
591:* v~QI/
Lad,L
/ n WEr
455
-=1
Y
1='~1:>¬
j
j
?_,
:
>
,_
m£dimg}
_17
!;_
i
_ T
.
92 P.
'
92
_ __j___;Lgg__.,-_;
.
I/:m-rim
bi;-Fur¢jl;.
_,-'.
W _._*V
' _v-I/'r'w».'_92792:
_ _ _h_ _'_
_____
_ _ J_
w~
. J11;-1;Y1" ;@_==¢§
40'"
ml U-.1 =5»;-
w
Nl 3 4__
_ _, iIM"cl.
°l13L;¢r?
=L'?F;,_E
92
,'
___
'
______
IT
».__
,
____
L~f g Q
_.
%¢j_»~
2_;-§_3[f;__§»'/
|"J@»»/*?_*1
__:H__WW
-_;___,
_
F _ _'
I_ _____
/*?__l_
'
_:'
_.f!_*1":f"":92_,
1;?
T
W
b6-1,2,»-4
' ~5-I-"5
""/*?*3?
~ i Q "-"'l'3"l
_L"*
gb?°;§'
_ " ;@ l:l;
¢Q,@M__~-&W@;»1m
;=»:w~=-~
1
L
_m~92gJ@
q-35;
if-'31!
_ c f-_£-Ln
_____'
_
__
_;__
L
1
77 _
92Z**
_if-
___
_
__!'~w1::-}l£P
%
"
_?_wl2Jf=_~"-"Li
v:.__¢S?-9::
,_ 5_'°,,_ A* -1§-__
_J
'
._'__
M__7
j _j'_,
__'_
7.___,_
111- 11 h
1 F -|MI'f
J'H.|=~_¢L_L*
r §1£5131?-'L
.r'~
IFE5
;? ! 3
J~9&
5
IW
|
I
kw
~
W *7
1
_ _Z_ _
1
92
W92~~
j
~
f
,énrv92~';s4-1;-/L
f_ ff {4¢"'*/
3/"--J-i. _,
1
.4
*7
if
*
~
~
1I
1
.
.
RESPONSES-31
-
M
1
s
3i
|
_7 {_L!_i}___','____,_6l
WE! M-ff1 -vi" _J:__L
7
_J- f
,
*_
-k , i _* 113'
ZC*'!¬r¢;L
7-"E/s
Lbi ;
£59 _-1 !9*J1~»_"f7'
1
1'21 -M
?_ _~
-
1
pM
¢..4-~.
01,4-@D1§=92_
1
_
.
1
Y
1
1
1
__
.
-IL ,- I _*~92,1:Q--1'11"-*-l~?t1.:1;1_
_Q::sr"~"',|_
£11
if
f c;.1,;-J§¢1--9>;._
H
1 ,
1
17
WW
j
i
TM
11>
1-- i X-. @§L-_
LLH.11 £g*u_L§_F"'
:
m9~1~»;:~i
L
,_W_ WH
, '" '
WW;
,- ,,,,,,,,,,,,,
_
.
.
_
:
_
J_>_::s&_rl92?~
a1;1=§m,_,
1::1l
lag
1
l
'________Tb
c
-1_
_
-92_L_LL
1
_ __Z
_,
Z_
1
71
1
b6 -3
b7C -3
1 l 92
j
1
I
1H {~'-==
~::+W
:~E]L1:1¢m~ rm
i'
l Q,L}§
Lin/I1
_i- W W i
.__
'
1
Q-__1l,,,_é.~.|;-1-M.
§>*i},r92-1
7 C-I-==~@l_,_1
____Z?,'
_J
c-
_
1
1
3
U~Q19 __92r-1 :@92_rrI/rnr'1-.
54 -5C __
1
11..|j
-la
____
r'QQ~1'1rm1L,
W}:-;--1
1/I -~;v~92
*_c,1ul1¢n~J5%->;_&#
V
_-
in-J"
:"}.,~
r-?"_
911°4&?L
92r:
.
1
1
_
?_
j
__
-
_JIl.a--r* 2:1/1:1*1%_1
92'92>_Qtj 1
_L
f Q§;_
*1;1-_ 1f'f'_;_
7 9,1-~s_.;~
w}%w 2/-
71
. _<1:1,.,p1
LQL-__I:CJ"'921"
-, »,=_____§ __.1f_'
-Q 1
,,,,
,_
~ 1 W _i
_.__..b6
-1,3,
b_7C -1,
3
é=1=|:]
r Juu-§92~b~..»}-rw
5;?
}-
41
jr:?§;-g:~:4f==»~;I *=-_
_W
4:
7
1'/-1~=L~2P»»=
n
l
1
1Z
M
- W1 W1 W- =1
» @m,_?1°~<%>:£""b_#
"~rr*<<>1i "+
H11
W
*_W+-»
i""92_1EL1,_,;
j
_
"
I
I
1
'1
-1 l 1___,f'§",;"
1J11
'jL*_'Q
**1
,,_
l
Wk
- W_L
Q
L@?__J=1;
lr-Ls-92
---/ g-Pr~'92.
__
_I!
.ML
_
If
92
_
_
_
_
_
'
4-
1.19
H Mali» Q-Fr%j;F"~ i7_1?Ei
H-J;;__,_
~_
_
_
,__,
W
_
___
,___
,
_
_,,
,§"_9%,, .lLll_
£L92r~q'1§_ ,¥-VLCQ;
__?_W
_
i
ix
b6_4
_,?,Qm*=P'
'E"i§-:1-'I'92i_l£2]:
bY°:L
""
L<,{m/Ȣ:~.=4~_._
¢~~.¢+
Lag. U-
-
"i "
77!W" "
IE!
H rH
W
_'.1
IIIM-M
,92J>s
-4 .
_ _b7c -4
rI
-
Jjri
__
~=>l¢1=>_
_
1:»! N J.
Y
_ _
Y1
7 '
' "'
'
"W"
" _3
__
{_
.__
92
LJ;,.@,m».n;~¢:=:
b
V
MD
_
.-"
N.
L
__
-
?,c_1.<.=::>:,'>$.
_T'ir:*"
»1@ ?Jr*13<-'»
I?=,*-7
¢:".T
"
.
Wi
1
92
I1
__
I
7W7
k '!£lv-Hv -$_r~.»92Q~,q;r,n~j-'
I
_-
,J
92 _: ,
H
Ia
*1
,7
92 _
77 7
§L~£54mNgf%; '4
___Z_b7c
_
____
W
jA
,_-
7 b5
4
77"
'
-
* T
W"
7_
'
if i
H
__
-3
__
_
-_
1
-
7
7% _ _
__
,
f
{
I
92
W
z
Nj,
192
Y
ii
l
~
Positive
Response
Number 3
n
t
1. -.
'5 '
kMesoage
,
* "_
_ '
.
-Page
1of5
.
I
¥ u' $92
Owe»
I I- ,I_ I____i<1'~1'==*
mmmmm
__I__I92»
we #° F
_ ..$3-o-Ht: Thursday,Ju
.bi- CI
C _1
f5,2U04-10:03AM
I To:
I1
_{|NSD!I{FBl!
"t
- --F"It;e.*? _?-:¢§§3;""
V
aw -"-"" " .
ISubject:
R_E:GTMO
.- " __
I SENSlTI92_!§_[3UI_l_.lb|CLASSlFlED
--
.NON-RECORD
I
'
"
,
_
..___:Ih_,;,_
I-"I
b6
~1
CIRG drafted
aletter
to
OGC
at
their
reciueet
to
send
to
the
Depamneghefléetense
regerds
to
the ._
in
WC -1 o servedtreatment GITMO
of
prisoners
while the
Behavioral Ana
sisIUnjt/members were
deployed
to
GITMO. I
' have
enciosed the
eee onsthat
apply
to
my ob's'er'vati0r|s" ."
'
='_
'
M.
---Ori inat Messa e- -
_'
-
~
b6 *1 F==m=i<:~sD><Fs1>at
_'
-Ib7 -1'
; .To Wednesdaff
Sent:
14,
ZUU4
12313
Jlllf
PMI'"
' _-.I
IIR! FBI!
Subject:
RE: GTMO
_se
L! _CL
, nor;-aecono
I-IED j
"
_'
I"II
--
- OK,'
but Ihaveno knowiedgeof
whet they
ere, and
we areaoting
independentlyof
asnow. Could you.I
please, in
bullet format,
email me
someof your
obsenrations.
_
. _I _
_'
"1
I .Fmm= m! Fs13
_'
-3-_0rIlnaiMessae 3-
b6'_1.Sent:
_'
_-
We r1 a u
'-
14,2004 11:52
AM
To: INSD!
FBI!
Subject:_RE:GTMO 1.
j
S_ENS[TlVE BUT
UlJ_QLA$SlF|_El1'
_I
' __, I
~_ -
'_
.be 1.'
.[:11 witness o.eve_ra_|"inoidents
whichal-r_eady_been
have
Witt:
OGC.
documented
1:.~?<:_-1
.-.
_-
.I
_ .I
I
.
--- -Oi'igln§_.92li'92:l8S5aQE.-I---'
."
_'
_' __" -' '
-
From:-MCCRAW, STEVEN
c. mso! FBI! '
-
-Sent:
'
.'_
Frida Jul
D9 2004 2:42 PM
"rd: MM! FBI!;
Iinc
010 com;
rm FBI;
- Hw-IK1E rrm!
-1 * |=e1!_;
[FBI -
FBUEAN FBI!:
~-
1'
FBI ,HO!
.
_I
_
"I11 Cl l
M
F
- LA!
HO! FB -51!
BI!:
F MM
R! FBI!
I-
.-
NY] FBII.
_OGA!
F ;CO!
HO LL rm!
|lu|£AQ!
cJ1s! §FBI!'
BATTLE_*<PBI!- F
FBI!;
on FBI!;
_DL
' FBI!;
MM! FBI!;-
NY! FB - MM! FBI!'
FBI!; H0.FBI!'
. LD! FBI!;
-
MM
FBI!
- FBI!;
" LA!
I-
'
'
NY FB
{N0
.ITD
{FBI} '
'
;
! F5I!;
us! FBI!;
FBI
CG
N FBI!;
CTDHFBI!;
. 'RESPONSES-34
F '
'
.
u
A
In late./Qetober
2002,
Special
FBI .Agmt
was observing
the interrogation
of a_.
.
detainee when
cjnfilian army
contraetor,'who
in 'cha.rgeofthewas ;An'11y's

interrogators, into
came
the
obse1'yation_and_-esked
room SA:to
somesee something.
-be -1, 3
SA :1
then saw
an unknown
bearded, 1ong:hairet1
detainee
another
5.11 inteno
ation room.
.b7 -F3
1e3
The detainee
had gagged
been duet
with
that
covered
tape much
his'head..
of
S ked
&#
Mr.|:|w1.1ether
detainee
spit
at
the
inteI_rogatoI8nee
weed
IvIe._E|-le
that
the detainee
hat-1 been
emmmg the _Kora.1'1
end £¢eu'1d
stop . Mr.
not
did nota siivér when
'
SA|:j askedhowthe duct
tape would
befernovedthe
-from
detainee.
P
I
_In
.
__
_92.
__
, of2002
_
_agents
_
September
or October
FBI
--
e
.that
4a
observed
' go
. d
:|an
canine
u_sed_i'n_::m
was to
intimidate
detainee
aggre_ssive
_'
'
.
_
*
_
.
-
I
_
.
_
.
RESPONSES-35
.
.
"F? -Ev
-.
~ <13
0
FD-302 R1:-v.
18-6-95!
_
o s
_
. _l_
-_
-s
_
FEDERAL BUREAUOF
INVESTIGATION
'
.
" Dale
arm.-awe. 0'!-M15/2004
b6-1,2 .m _ .1
' Superuisory.Special
i
AQent_{§§A!,,_H"j_
b7C-¥h2 EOD:|
|National Center for the Analysis of Violent
Crimes NCAVC!,
FBI Academy,-Quantico,
Virginia, was
interviewed
regarding his
knowledge of
any aggressive
treatment,
interrogations, or
interview techniques
at
Guantanamo
[GTMD}. After
being advised
of the
identit of
Bay, Cuba
the interviewing
Agent
and
thepurpose
th_e__interview,
of
$SA:provided
the bjcfi
following information
in response to thirteen special inquiry
b6 ].
questions:f '
.1. [;;;;::]s TDY
assignment began
to GTMO
the
in middle
of
Septemberand
- ended
in lateOctober 2002.
[:;:;;:|was
teamed with SSA|@UUUUUUUUUUUUU also-from
NCAVC,oof
' wereresponsible for
law enforcement
of detainees.
interrogations, he
requested, he
assist
in . -
providing behavioral
and military
personnel conducting
While[::::::] never
participated in
sometimes observed
reviewed background
the formation
-
~ civilian.contrac
or
-occurred.
b6 -1
b7c--1
to b6-4
interrogations b 3 1
detainee ,
files of
the detainees
to
strategies.
O
__
primary
point
of contact
waswas| '
employed by
the military,-who
often -
_"
_
'a
'
_
at GTMO. [::::::]directed. b5
*1.
the'interrogations of the ' b7c '1
exhibited "bizarre
meaning he
displayed a
range of
emotions and
or.became very
angry when
something insigni icant
.
'
them.' Also, when .'
of interview
. _ -
responsible for
the interrogations
military reservists
who conducted
detainees. '_
SSA |:]
advised |:1
behavior",
"lost it"
analysis assistance
_
whom '
-
.
f E::::::ldid-witness
aggressive.treatment,
interrog
tec nigues
employed on
detainees at
GTMO P
7 '
or interview
inconsistent with
FBI or
DOJ policy/guidelines'on two occasions.
b5 '4
The first incident occurred with detainee number'E:]and the b7C'4
second incident
an unknown
detainee. '
When[:;;::]
arrived
at GTMO,
number was
incarcerated
ct 1
_g.
- b _{
34
in adarkened
planned to
occurred with
n the
have military
Naval Bri
hours in
an attempt
to get
objected to
this technique,
appro ed by
"the Secretary"
personnel interrogate
him to
to
dhe
number for
cooperate. when
said the
technique a_
who understood
to be
Iuws ga.'
m
9/'1
on
/2004
0 ,;4Quantico, VA
24 b7c
-
been
' '
I RESPONSES_36'
. F =# 29'?A HQ
gm_A1327669
be _1 '
A D,,,,_,m,,,, N/A
This donumt coma.-i.ns neither
reconimondations conclusions
:10!
of
the FBI. It is the ]J1'Opéi1}'
of the FBI andis loanedno youragency",
'
_L§,4
i
i____
wt, '
- .. °¢:I._ ,
' .
'
Q
~
y
FD-3028 Rev.I0-6-95] ___
K"
l_
297A HQ A132T669-A
'- -
_b6
-1
b vc
,-1
ContimmtionufFD-3020f |
~"
_ _ W
,On_O9/IJIZQQQ
,Pagc'
,2 H
"' Seoretar
"Rums'fe1'd."A'ft"eI:
-inpi-1 -frem ~- '
-a
the decision
was to
made
provide
number1t:]wit
oo
since e_
ad been on a--self
induced fast
for
afew
days. Number
|:]'did eatthe food, but still
refused to
provide
any
information during
his interrogation.
I-le was subsequently moved
-
X Ray, numbe-r|:|
b6 -1,3,4
to a
plywood interrogation
hut in
was aggre-ssivel
Camp X Ray. . While
in
interrogated by
reservists at
the direction
of: During
Camp
military .
the b7C
-1.3.4
interrogation, the reservists yelledand screamedat
number C]
Additionally,
aGerman Shepard was positioned at
the door
of the
interrogation hut
and made to growl
and bark at the
detainee.
At one po'nt oneof the- interrogators "placed
aKoran
in front
_
of numberJ[:[while
num.ber|:|was seated
ina chair. "The
-interrogator
then straddled
detainee became very angry,
information.
_.
.
'
the Koran,
at which 'point 1_'.'he
but still
refused
to- provide
any
'
-
-Late one evening,:witnessed
a-secondincident
which
involveda
detainee
had
who
been
ductbetween
taped;
|;| and
" -Q-were
in
-an
observation
room,
located
wo '
in errogation
rooms, watching
militar personnel
conduct an
. interrogation. At
some pointyjenteltedtheroom
and told
Ito come with'him
as he
wanted
to sh'ow
something.
him " '
' - accompanied |:|'to
another observationroom,
located
hall,
where
several Military
Police
were
observin an
interrogation.
he
when
entered
the_-observation
room,
down the
observed an
unknown detainee
beard whose
-interrogation
with
a full
head_of
hair an
_a be,
head was wrapped in duct tape
in
the adjacent
room.
There
were two interrogators in
the room
_
-
b7C -
with
the
detainee.
:asked
if iting the
detaineehad
been
_
spitting at
the interrogators
ore:-: J.
belli
ere_nt=behavior
toward
them.
|:|
detainee s head
replied no,
and then
told|t:|the
had been
quoting the
Koran. did
the detainee
and asked
duct
taped
because
not approve
how he
he would
not
of the
planned to
stop
treatment of
remove the
duct
tape,
but[:| never
answered
him.quar
|:'then
exited the
observation room
and_ returned
to his
ers.
Based.--on conversations
with? believed
use of
Department of
Defense authorization
for
e permi
e
harsh/aggressive interrogation
techniques may have
come
Secretary
Rumsfeld. On
several occasions
1-
from
when'|:] questioned
Ib6 -
. approved
by "the
Secretary",_
un'
whobe erstoodt
'
I
|:| about
the techniques utilized said
it had
Secretary Rumsfeld.With the excep ionof|:s comments
RESPONSES-37
been -
me
-
Q ad,
5- H
oo
FD-3Q2a Rev.
I0-$95! '
n"
-
,
Q
29?A- HQ-.A1327669 A ..
'
"
_-~
' b6
-1
1b'?C
-1 .
Cvrr1i11=lH @n@fFl?-3l_>9-of
.0u_Q2LL4/2904
_|
.Pas=__,,_
're
gard'in;g
Secre't'ary,':b-he-d~
the
knowledge
-or--~
--for -Vno
understanding of
Departmento efense
{DOD} authorization
_ '
the permitted
use of
harsh/aggressive interrogation,
Furthermore, SSA|:believed|:|
approve interrogation
techniques, including
tape on
the
unknown detainee.
|:| had
techniques. b6
"
had the authority to
.
the use
_.
WC
no contactwith interviewees
during his
tenure at
GTMO. He also stated
he had no pictures,
audio, notes
'
or
other
documentation which
depicted or
described aggressive
b6 -1
treatment,
interrogations
or interview
techniques employed
on_. 1976
"1 _
_detainees
at GTMO and had
no
knowledge
of anyone
else who
of detainees
at GTMO.
_-_
possession of such items. |:had no
related to
the treatment
was
in
additional information
-
' Upon
his return
from G'I
along
MO,I:|
with '
related the
_311%,:
aforementioned incidents
drafted an
EC
aforementioned events,
t'o SAC
Stephen R
1. ey..
be" _1
dated
11'/22/2002,which outlined the -We _1
was
approved
subsequently forwarded
by SAC Wiley, and
to _CTD Executive Management.
- '
I
n
RESPONSES-38

of t'he'cluc:t
'
' '
92.-
" T'
-F
,
~=.
L V 1% ?*' >_;:,
1=n-a4oa
_
g¢v'.s-1-9
i
'
_
....--_._____#._7.._:,.;T_-..
. IU
__ }
_y
** "';4".i!*.i'
I" ** ..
"'"
"I"
*
92
=s92
'
'
<
_ .
. ?_ '-'"
@$5'?%5'!P'""m°°F
°' .?*'
A
Field
'O[
Z
pe_-Acquifing_-Euigl1§:nce;f
' -'»_; "1
92Seria;j;_i§§i'_Qriginatli1giloé
-'
-'
_mant
_§
__,_,
.
.
|.
_.Date;_;!=ie¢:eivec_l
_,
_-
.
._
_ :__'
.5: __
ij_,;
Fl'DlTl'_
-_ 7_ '.
'
_-
'
'_
r~_j;.
_ . _ .... F|_ame=Fcmm
_
_
bu1un
,
.-
" [Address-oi_Oont|1butor]
_- -.-
_
'_ ~ Byi _
Z '
1-
l:.:_92,f92_:.__
,
_ _
_
.- .r.92.'
J _J
-'- --
b6
_1
"Y:
F:
- 1'u"E'
;'
Q"
'
-;_1
. -.. ~92.-H-
.
§§§""To
Be_Het1m'-Jed
U
YeB_,-- |
.'
r%,.Heceip:Given%.i;%
!1;¥~*@=:»
1 Q46L.
--
-7'.1.
-
I -f§jéter1_'a_['.5;-liis§é&#
.
-~ Til-"T"
-:0Rule
s ejs,
Fedér&|1? g1-¢;_:'¢jj¥=f6n_mma]
Flincadute?
- '
1'
.@j§111
e:
a3
'
.
-.
.:
:
I9292
-.-
.-
-92
»
.
92
P
¢-.-
. -'.
_
4.
_
t eferendezn
.-'
'
,'- _ {_C__Ol1'l-If|'1llF§l§§|i§EI|=!:|
Mab /aJ]_. ,,
>_
'
_ _Dasc
tioh:/l2 6§ginail_lmiegige
i ferxiiqw
=7 M
n":
":41
-r
1
»-
L_
.l
'
" _.
a
=1
-..
:
:
J1
I
l
.
-'
M
.
-
7
.
?_.
_
.4
-"-
*
E
s
i,
-. ¢.
;
w__
j
_3@!,1:
RESPONSES-39'
_
.'
92
0
..--
_1l;gJ
"
1
I
92b6Tc 1i
-1""
/
7i ii *74
7T ft
it W:7?
i
V
77
77 7'
i
_J
1_i 1*
, $24
é is. -'1». _
92
-1-""
7_
i
....___,,.._
H
*"
*
_
I '
~
,
--
..
b1'c -2.
7*
_ _?
.-- _...___.-_..._._.....__-_.__.....--i......._._-_._._-_..._.-_...._.........-..-_--I-_.-_
-_--......_--.... . ._ _.__ .. .
..
_ iI
I
=1
*
-
.
1
if ii ii1
*
*7
=
'
_4i
,92
J
.
'{2,mJ
.%
,1 0;. D513;!
_ _[;_LQjk'7'i
i
/,__.
fgm
~rulL
l-¢:*~?L=..u1u:¢..l
.J_l:m :h_V,_b_f_r
i__._?G;!vu:__|_£EA/J
Wl m::
ll
ff 4* V}_i
.
.
r-
.
1L
1 j j Q ,__{92l%_
r-92,,
_*__?__:_Q_____
__;___l________
i 7 j _g
92.
,1;
F r"u,1Ȥs1L-L
9135
77
7
___
__
I5! _'
jg? :, r.g;Lg*_J'i___
__ _ ___ _'
1; ___
_ _1 ____
_¬4 '-I '
J '*'}3
_F?!"1'.A;-__._
--Jim
§-5_
H
,_ Wjwimi-9¢Q~??*@+~sl,<***li?;L¢g@k_
Qir7w=»s
~ ij
-4
J
_ _. _;. ,:.~r1., ?'=1|.--L3:
7j§Q_L[p
4- ~_
_V_J1
b6
~
-
b7c
r
-lit"
1L92'-"'h'L
@'z.ATig|
f I
fit &:!:'b.L
*a>_L~:'J§ I21-_jQ':!?
i~-*1
ii
Q, __
i i b6-4 7-! l w_1~
K
h
, _b?_c__4
___
_E -~r-I-.{;____jr1__
B7 /l
""
l31$a;'__,,
w4_p.1L=uc
11>
j,1
1
@}1JILJJLQ--@~¢@-}*_
3°|4-'
*""
Ij
W
si -7'92~5~|-=-~<.
l5i2:%i ,
l
~
92
&_§;2~g:}'9l
f--'1f _1:u'_LlL=""}r
";L~'"92
qI1___'
~
+01%__ ,_
_
,_ if ____ __
r
i
-
__
ii H Cir
r
7é_b:}§_h§'L&#
i fr'
f
i iml}:
W 92 1...,
._
-_,@,;:,p;,'5q
9», i
j W . UT
%Jwt
ff ~ nf
b6
-3
b'i'C
?_,__
i_;= lé$'jj llw
~» *1ifak-F
3H}_W_il
I i i Hi
R c.i-n'_b
jj"92r _h¢;L
::L_
,
*i&i}::'*-_*4l92'92'::-£'
_ _-__JLx ¢*- C92_92f'*&#
1 _RESPONSES-40
92
.
x
I
| /Q- I __ .'
. .. .- -...- .-.... ...- |--..... ... ..-.---.
92
W
-».-
1 ~~
'
*#
_
_
7'--..-_
~f
-
4L
'
1-4'_-..--H.-..-......-.....--.......-.._
.
____
'92
_
~ .
'
g "" i r
~ 5;, -p jii
if ?
1
W
1c'?Fi=1f
u.-.:nf925*""~
1]'92A92A.d
3'q"f__
W
{4
Magi;-m¢,W~A
u:3~*=92=r%~r
11¢." {
&.-.¢+g-h .Pw'
j z:;§_g9i%:=L""n_J':
P~<g'92r~:==.7
f=c~
T7 { mm
1~»:{§I:
i _? a'1
Wm~Pw1J:=
j _ _V,_Z -_
plhi:-if
; 92__hr:-»e,,F'?1»'~
T-2:?
§_|§&-92J
,Bbgj
l
l
j f, f
,7
9.»;
, L1,,-m;,gW?§"2-><¢.i,5_L>-f*,H
,_ W , ,_
,_§___
ff ? ¢i '7?,
#1-42. v~Q
*~92_qLh
I
n
/ __
J'
_1 -»
L?
"Ci,--'
' W
-i-i__,1=s
-3_-"__,__,
G l !=*
__
l1»'lI2;
,1.-1-@»-.»?
3n_f__f*:1"*-92_'/K
mi
£.;J:4.
A
j j {ii i _ 7-j--,
"
4-,~@=~
Q
,
j
ol~i i?="'=~?1-}'
Qggs vjg .
lg,
1. |,___ Z1_ ,
92
%
L
L
_
_
j
', _¢Q15:-r*%p;-;9
_,,
-__,_p~@?Ltv*92?
%_
iiah-;.t 1§§~2r-i
M5
7,-WQ'_@i-,*~~cn~$§_s-"_@~?=-+1~@?
iv,_____________b6
-4
I
jaw}
5,I
l-
W
W
__
92"f""jfL.,?,~_,,_»<,,,L».-.b.;=»"-»,{- {{§%@,¢v-»1LJ
{
A
-
1:;
92
_
.-+92_~:1»>_1&#
aha/1.*
"
i l
_,*'L_i
5Jf92r~'*-1'1
°-W91:
f, W __ Low»-".
H
j
if
__
"j
i
RESPONSES-41
__
-
7
l I
I
1
1
..- - .......-.-.--._._._..__-1.-...._..
_-.
92
x
,
.
"ii
JJ ?-'r'H..1df
Z
KZ K 711*iz
_ _
_l_,_:
iii:§3
'"
____
_ _
_ _ b6
_,;_
W
ff
?,j
f __,f ,j '
-1
___,
Z I;"M 1?Z'
F
__*+¢1c|-1 4&Pk*¢}
waif
i __ ,___,_I__fJ_gJ./'92"
I
___
'
92__n_§_.
j I _ __,__,,,
L ji7
1
1.
_ ,_
' _id
,
:77-__
1£n.§_]_1Llr~!
<:*_1
v~~Q'*
" 5_~f____
_»¬92J'*F
Y
/ L5
_111
, |
,__'5:E§> 7'
j
7% _ i W-1|::_l~-s:v:Q-'1~sP
V ,__ ,,J_,{L_w,.,?
L
¢_ W
i~,
92
'
a
92
_ i T?
*l§5§¢"§3
M-. M, 3/
if
'E_
@~:M9:1~~+/*~
'
Emm
j
~V
{ 9- M1 [llM2, 1%
; ;-1'-"
L; L1-i"-<-D
FF
-" W
M hfk im,e:.,_
"l>£~¢=:~
' 7 .1;
?,,
j
ha_'-~ ,g$I_'w~"~»§£
k~'~#*-~'=_
_* v;
, ?""Qyin}- H f*;~>.%L
?L1~" *?kl.1
-3
/!'_ -_
,7 -
92
NE
IL
1::::n'>'_
- 175.,
L1/§t~§{%A¢y@»
,;,,; ¢s<>LT
Ifj
i
,__z
92
2
92
7
___
.;_L__,
~
|
92
4-_;,L->~Ji.r~+
¢"~'§,r>w
»~»;£,_
7 _ 7 *1
_
b6
-3
_
i
,
rix
,
Wib-|"C-3
___
__:
9292
L115
_, '5
**'92*_,__
rm
==J_s..n¢1$-*7:-1
1:
Q { 1'!sH?592M
F
ju -chm"?
ff jj iw;f A
'1
1
b"1c~4_D
i
__
ff
_
92ij _q192- Z_
J;_, h;~,392-_
» $c_E3
1:5
4
H'
-I
ll
'.
.|
-
.
it
.
i_l
.
r
'
I
-1
ri
_
I
i
1
.
' 1
¬
_
j
,-
fj __:;; FY19
:. t?}J"}92*"f*11 fl»T';l:!~-r1-__
Qf "**
fj.
1 W§::-ULl-*~~1'92h1'qy~~
,=~-::*-V
=1!
TI
,5NM [ q" £1 -f A"#;ZZ§
:,L:_1;5jC
j 5:5-=~'hL
}3 }<1=§~_¢<
j
j
Kk ,5
»;i%..@41£
m hi;
tlmr
m,~1,,.
| |
;
_J:~l_!l{@~r~-w"z%-¢__,l¢
92
92
,
92
,, , ,,,_y
1
-J
-. _ *1, jif
4 ¢u~»@Pi_
Q 4927$* E§¢_f4?+.|
HI
L
I
92
I Zsj 92;>~;_!_r *~q=2v-"'19--1[
.Q-.>-'+11<
é
"
=
_H
92
_
____
_
__
____
__
_,_,
___ 7
_____
__.
7_
__
_
___ _
7 __ _ __
b6 -=1
_W
H! -f ¢4*-»c'Gi:_r¢~4n§
%
,4=1»|:|_ Q b1c~1.__
*
- j 7f--,7
7 /??'7-'~3:->'???-"*§
">* 1I""
Pilib
F*j_;?*<.9-;1E
i _:_
_;__] _. i_
Ikfl/9292_jll
**_
-
_
-___
__b6
_3 __
b7C -3
Aj f U19*1/"Liz;
nj @ r~f~<=---=
;c.r l-¢.i-WW,
1-'~~
Jux
92
Z?
4
H/-LLL-""'*'92J"*""
PrQ5-5+
'
'
-
¢ __
.
?f
RESPONSES-43
-
4
I
Positive
1Response
.
%
s
.sNumber 4
1
: Message
'
1. -
_'
_
_H
"
-Page
of 11
,
L
_'I ;[|i§|so!
__. I_itg_
Fe|! -F."m=.I:Il°920:iFB'iI
-sent: Wednesda
106 ~1t'
.1s'142os4~2;1rPM- bic
.- Subject: GTMO '
_-
I
t
-1 '
'
-
I
-
- ' -
' SENSITIVE
BUT UNCLASSIFIED
. NON-RECORD
' .
I
Iwas
TDY to GTMO
from dates
the dune
of 2003
2, to-Juli}
17, 2004.
Duringtime
that
Ididnot observe'
1*
. 39QfBSSiV.&..I;[§ tlJJBIl_i..IHEHOJJEIQDQQEilTl1!%.i'ViEA92i-IlE3§?hl1l§|L1Q$.OD
.2-IMO! detainees
92.-ir.t1.i.r;.i.1.-wa§.!21el Is9.n§i5.isr!i.Wit.
.-
Bureaupolioyfguidellnes
interviewFBI personnel
orby'any
interrogators
the
FT. Belvoir
consisting
fromAirsh
. of
ip
.
-
Force OSI, Naval InvestigativeService and possibly efew other servicesalthough Ican't
recall which
'
_. ones.__However.
Idorecall seeing
some t_eoh_niq_ues
utilized
by
other
interrogators
associated
not
the or
FBI
with
the»Ft. Belvoir
interrogators. ;I-occasionally
sawsleep 'depravat-ion.interviews
with
strobe lights, and
two different
P
'
_kinds of loudmusic. I asked
the
one ofthe interrogators
what theywere doingthey saidthat
i_t would
take
_
approximately four
days tobreak semeene
doing_an'interrogatlon
hours 1-Ei
onwith thelights andmusic andtour hours oil .l'he sleeprdepravation
and thelights
and
£1ItBl'I'l3
of thelIr-tg
musicbeats
would
wear thedetainee down..There was
a-time
period where the interrogationswere obtmsive enough that the interview rooms
for
. treilerwere
not available
if one
of these
techniques
being
wereutilized.
-.
an
entire
- 5- : I I
9
contractor
other!
bragged
or
that
about
doing
aor
lap
dance
Detainee
on-one
1tt:lAnother.inte
ossibly
b
-_
6_44
{notsure
military
if
contractor
or
other!
.about
bragged
Detainee
making
o
biistensa
anic
blackrnetal
we
music for
hour and-hours.
Then the
intenogator dressed
as
_a Catholic "Priest
and baptized
the detainee
in orderto
'
Iheardmany rumors
about thlngelthat
Idid not observe.
1spokewith oneintenogator not
sure ifmilitary or
save him.
- .-
QEHSITNE BUT
.|
s
-.
"
_
_-
_
-'
. _'
UNCLASSIFIED
|
F
RESPONSES-44
-gf, -
_
'
n
-
.
FD-3H2aw. 1O~6'-95!
» _-
-
.
-
-. ..
-
CI--Keir:an.2Wis§..!¢:rrE
s_
=»11~=r111-a-h . ; -1-
.r5m_;;;§1§4'-- .35,-;_
.-
.
V
¥rsns':1e=1"s.i-%' :?#Tc7E
.
+. a.r¢E.a§,xI1r;!.§.1_1=
FEDERAL}
BUREAUor INVESTIGATION -_
-
' -_
1:5-1
MC
-1
-
.
|
DaI=oftransc:ipl1'm'|
05-mggggggug
'
Federal. Bur.eau_...of...lmrs;i1;.i.q§_92;ion
FBI
'
the identit
of the interviewing
.interview.provided
-
his
S__e'c_i_al __A_gent
SA!
ClevelandDivision, EOD
temporary
duty-
wasadvised or
Agent and the
nature
of t-he
h -2
""'
MC 2
thefollowing
infor_mation.in
regard
to
TDYJ assignment; to Guantanamo Bay, Cuba
GTMO!:
.interviewer was
assigned
to
GTMO
in t-he
position
of _
in errogator
for 4'5
daysfroin
06/D2/2003 to 07/17,/2003
115
-1
We"1. as art of a "SpecialProjects"team
which
consistedof FBI
SA[:|
-
[C1'1ElJI_lOttB
Division!
anda task
forceofficerwhose
name
he .
could
b6
not
recall,
-
-1
b- ,6
_1
,
interrogations
Conducted
by
or interview
FBI or other
consistent
with
behavior
by
,
,
.
.
d1.d'I1Owitness
lI.
or observe
aggressive
treatment,
techniques
utilized
on GTMO detainees
law enforcement
personnel
which were not
FBI or DOJ policy/guidelines,
non law
personnel
on at least
personnel
utilizedsleep
enforcement
but did observe
Department
two occasions;
of Defense
On these occasions
depravation
by
playing
load
the DOD
music
for
hours at a time with four hours between sessions.
others brought these instances to attention
of
SSA
was his
-
Acting
Supervisor,
" Atlanta
Division}.
16
and
_b6 _1
who we _3_
at GT
_-
'
was
notfamiliar
with
DOD
policy/guidance
a '
in _erview/interrogation
techniques were authorized.
-
regarding
w
During
conversations
- interview
with
unidentified
DOD employees
techniques, |:::|recalled
bein
up" or"familycompassion"
techniques.
It]
"identities
of
activity.
in
interview
DOD interviewers
in either
interviews
personnel
the
the Yellow,
conducted
by
rooms
would
located
reserve
regarding
regularly
f
l
:|
the
O
|:]witnessed
Brown or
Gold
in
l
O .
trailers
as
i.
-1
didnotknow
the
WC
involved
in
these
areas;
_
occurred
Often
"1
.
Most
_
_
DOD
'
'
,_
E5!
the
occurred at
areas.
and DOD personnel
in
an ent're
'
regarding
asked if he used "fear
b6
detainees
law. enforcement
interview-1'
techniques;
f
or
The aggressive interviews
Camp Delta
bl.
such__ _
DOD!-
_ssive
1.5]
,
_
l
,
hadno substantivecontactwith DOD
personnel
condition
or treatment
held briefings
by
or detai-ne.e's
other
the DOD Commandwhich provided
than
.b6
eneral
updates
of activityandthenumber
ofdetainees
at GTMO.
t]
_
Investigation
on Q9/15./2§_Q4'___=:
7Washington,_lD_.
W i ._W_t*elephon:i._call_yl
:=i|=#_282_-__NEW
5m7.kp. gy 6by
bjc_1_
gamma
0%/1?/2O§1_4
._ _
_
.
.
.
_1 - i
Thisdocumentcontainsneitherrecommendations
nor conclusions
of the FBI. It is the propcrtyof the
FBI
id
'
it and
is contents
are
notInbedistributed
outs
syour
agency.
vr"
*K
or
and is loancdto your agcncgr,
1
'
*1
b7 ?'1
_"7
1i
FD-3'|J2a{Rev.
_
0O
mess!
g
1 .
2B2.- NEW
.
b6
-1
I b7c_-1
_
_
Conn'm1ationofFD-3020f
i___ ____
'
___ ,-on 0_9JL15lf20[}4
_,Psgs_ :2_._
and others
were provided
atour
characterized the
cells as
the detainees
were switched
regular food
the calories
b6 -1
b7C ~l
because the
contained in
- c_ould
of the
cei'l area
at GTHO'
a'nd"he"'
small
but
acceptable,- -He
recalled that
from Meals
Ready to
Eat ~MREs! to
detainee s were
the MREs._-
becoming overweight
'
1
due to
not recall
any allegation
of mistreatment
_
brought to
1S aention
by-detainees, other
than the
detainees
referring to
techniques employed
by DOD personnel as-"games."
|:|ind.ieate<i most
of the interviews conducted
by the his
Special Projects
team were negative. Special
Projects was
tasked
with
interviewing
the most.hardened
detainees. g
_.-F
.'.
'
.
'.
Ego
E1
'
was
not
in
possession
pictures,
cf:
VlCleO,
audio,
_notes
or other documentation which depicted or described
aggressive
treatment. He
contraband each
b6 -1
b7C -1
indicated. the
in_terv_iewers were '-searched for
time they
entered or
exited the
compound. _'
'|:|heard'|many rumors
-about aggressive
-or
inappropriate interrogation
techniques by
DOD which were = "
-unsubstantiated. '-Amongthe rumors he heard were that
a female DOD
interrogator did
alap
dance on adetainee,
that aDOD interrogator.
forced a
detainee to
and that
aDOD interrogate: dressed
listen to
satanic black
metal
as aCatholic
baptized a detainee in order to save him. I: had
hand knowledge" of these
actually occurred.
events and
- '
was unsure
as to
¢
II
' RESPONSES-46
music
for.
Priest and
_
hours,
no first
if.th-ey MC
'_ I
b6 _l
_1
.
_
__
-
92
.
'
.
Q fzr ? . "
V .*E'I.'513"- * ¥_
Ll
_.__ 2-._;.__
ft. ,92,
_»:',_¢_.-__*_!_':.'*'_:._
..._
|_|;.=;_
I
_.
~.
-».-."||;
.-'
11 L
~-=;m~:
4
Q '-1=1>s§iub{nw.s:7-97:!"-_-_
_
i
I
h
.
_ _ .711-
.. .
. gj
I
--1'
'
" l;Jnivei'saI
Caséd-Filg
Nlimbgr
I
{f-gl
Field
omen
Awqul farwg
nsiiaaenw %
' '
-
-I
_if
~;'"1--bate
Fleceiiieuj..-
92
%f
,
-.'_
__1 ---
" .
_ ,
___
hi
,-=_=,9
"Ff
.'
A
7
{Add_ras§bfC-omributorj
*7 *
?.=;;_;?
. __.1.._
..__..,......___.________,
____,_;______________
_I_ _.___.;;_-gt...-
ii-By
fJ» V _ ,
;
.
t_.;,a<¥
-
L
* * **~-1~@W=-1%
';Fr9m"Q_
_
,_H
I5; ."
r
-'
1
3-.$erial#ofO QinatinQ-I
l acument
_-
92
..--r'~
'_.'rl'-'.;}
'
-
_ __ :5;W1"
-1..'
_--
-*1A:
_ _
Rewéd":'LY<=>}'-*.'-@"i"°
'92
V. V
92??§%i¢'m"d-JHW-'@§
°'"*v§Pvrwa"1
?H _
l
92.r!§_*''
_j.;'_
.55.-Q"
.-E1"-"?_-QM
. '
_._. ._
Rule
6 -e§,
Fedbzzil-HdlB1§:of
§{3ri1_'|'iint~i1
Procedure
'
_
Ly,
..'
;1'»q;_;.':"
=
EIYBSN_Q_'.
-El. .r
'
- u_.==2
-" '
-..=;~
'
E3?-;Ti
' e:
'
_-
'
'
. '
val.
-
:1_.r¥§§
H ..
.r in
:5 .
92
.
_ _ ya?
92
.
»=_
,
Fleferer'1qe:_
.'
__ '
'_*_;
L;,
-
.31
r
.L
;. _| {Gumgn_urioalqlatedalj
nnEnclos]ng
.
-1.-
;.-.
.
-Desc
E1
p
n::!1§s
on?
Z
'
i
ii
|
e'i
Z
.b 6 -1
'
,
'
P- '
"§
I.
92>
-92_--.'
92"i.
V
-
-P
92
_
-92.
r
'1"
':
J
92
-
_-_.<
"
'5
4=am:o.r
'
'
L
,
,_Il
-
RESPONSES-47
?
V
i 9// A?
L
L ,;§CL¬2L 9
b?C
|
-13.929
|
'
:57/,~¢3
- r/ '7'1-I"
"7/95 '
b5 -1
I
L
A1
I/*""~.
5
Z
l
..L.
L L.
.
d¢hw2>-.a.¢.'5 ' , ' '
AI
A
5-51-'f&<3¢
_ m,L.-A
L.,.~~.-#4'
Mm
~
!Md
A
P-/ J éi
/ _/=
b'v,:§-'
-"G
/1/'
554/-=
Hz- W -0"
:mm
F-KI
//
L
g7=u_4w
L V56
3! V5/»v»fv:»'>-~..¢-.-»~
-Q1 -0m.
3&
L3,!,L,,,z,,,L;,,,,;L,L VLL,/JiL;a
t
A; Q. I7
92
i;-we
b61-14!;,
.
-
14/
- I-
-:1 0/
'
L
I
E
§=§e?**4 i;L?§L.LLLLLi1*11§§§
I
-
i1*Ea=5:3'92Hf§1@."§.
L
1%
_A7/ /I/0 %a:L1=.L.,LL.L@-'==sL
_
1
,
¥
-
-
L
RESPONSES-48 L
-
L
.
___
.
i-
$1! /fir Q
_ ,,,,%,-.,
é#,w=f- ;@
A
~M/
la/9% 4»
¢*" """ f" "*
**
.
W , ,,,,,,,.
%
V L
"°"/
~r£b<./A_%
I RESPQNSES
I
iii
I1
i
49
-x
Positive
Response
Number
4i
ii
ii
5
i
_
r'
_i
l
-'
'
Rev DI 3]
2003]
i '
c
i|=e_|:|s|=m_L
suneiu OF
luvssfrnsnrlou
_'
,-
_
--
_.r "-
.
.
.
,
-.
..Io: Cotmterterrorism Attn:
' "
I
,
..-
Precedenesi Imnsbists
.- -
_
K
01/09/2oo4_
:
--"1
7
_-Date:
'
Inspection Division
' '
Office of
.'2?E
. _C
Inspections -
Room 7531
'
1
~
1-
Frsm: Los
Angeles
.'Squad
I-2
1'
_'
e_ e_
---
1+
' Contact}
.' ],.L
b6 >1
~
bQ
C __1
I QVB 6- BY 3
. , __jg7
X
.
. I1- ti *1
.'
.
i ",
_'
~-
.
"
,ssisa
,
_rm
.
$ %j§
-
--
'
_-Case
ID #1
297 HQ A1327669
{Pendingft-Eihy
A'Tit1e: Counterterrorism
Division, §§ §%§§%§q§.+-'
srmo, '
i t i-
1zL__2._'-i
~
Inspection Special
Inquiry, §§§ §§%%%§
"'~
i§".§ §*3iiJ°*,l-5.,.5.Z;§»<§%§
=§1E3,:;¥1:'3Z'
B33
. '
2
9'7
HQ -'-1'11
3 276 69A' ' Synopsis: Response
to inquiry,
of_mistreatment of-detainees
concerning potential
knowledge '
at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.
' __-~ -
Details: 5
Writer .coi'np1eted
a 45'
day Ttemporary duty assignment
TDYJ at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba GTMO!, for the
tenure o
May
13, 2003 through June
26, 2003.'.writer was'ta§ked as
an
analyst providing'inyestigative
assistance to
the Military"
Liaison Unit
and
MLUI
in support
of Operation
observe at
any time
during
' detainees
and/er, witness
techniques employed
the Joint
upon_GTMO detainees,
with existing
policy/guidelines.'_ .
'
.
However, although
..lap
in female
Writer
afemale
1
.
of
-"
_
which .wo.u_ld be '
Bnreau interview
I- -
.
did
not
detainees, Writer
does
recall
a male_unsub
detainee was
clothing, make-up
dance by
Force JTTF!,
Enduring Freedom.
Writer did
not
said TDY, aggressive treatment
interr0_gatioI1{s! or
interview
considered inconsistent
maltreatment of
rumor, wherein
Terrorism Task
applied, and
prison-guard, either
-
observe any
-
hearing about
a
purportedly
dressed
involuntarily given
at the
direction or
a
-
.
ersonal
Interrogators
music
an pe_rfcirmancei_of_MiJ;i'tary
tA
1~
erSi J
B1
Writer ur
-
.i,-TTTET
rsessvemetst. as
conveyedas a
-
'
uFisg éi i iiés i
n
iRESPONSES-50
_
i
Ii 1|-|-||i I11 |II|'7
' re i
'__
o
To: Couhterterrorism
From: Los'Angeles
.
fee; 297__-HQ-Ai32?es9 _A,
0?/09,1200:-1
_
JIM"? Q-nmpsnu
tactic which
would result
cooperation of
specific
in.the breakdown
the detainee.--
It should
date,
time;
personls! stating
_'__
_
H_
a d eventual
1U
be
noted,
Writer does
not
recall the
place? and or
the ide tity-of
the
the-aforementioned rumor.
.Writer's
identifying information
fO1lOWS:.
ofgicié-.1 Bureeu__eme
Joh_Title
_<
'
_'Ihvestigative
Analyst
Tenureoof Assignment 05/13/03 - 06/26/0§_.
#0
r
'
f
!.
-vi -:1.
2
~
RESPONSES ,51_
J .
b6 -1
b'TC -1
7T7
1.
..
t
_
,
To: Countérterrorisml From: ,LQBAngeleé Re: 297 HQ Al327669-A,i§jjQ§j§£Q§m
._
.
..
.
h
-
_1
_hm<s>=,' "
;
Set Léad
.
15 Info!
= -.COUNT§ETERBORISM
AI I§SPECTIO11
'
_Read and
,
_=
~
531315 IQN
clear.
§Q
-I"
I
92
F
3 _-
~RESPONSES -52.
1|
Q2
'
I'
---I-2P'
_;.I.
_',
¢h 3Lo-,.__-;_..._L.-..-;..-_-a
D_¢
__
' 0
E5
6
I
FD-3U 2
Rev.we-95;
_
.
.
'
§+'.§E5551EIi?%I3¥$6.5_¥J;9i1iIW.£i;1i5i§E*
=
_1_-
a
,.-_i_:-__.'*£§-.=_;-4,_»;,=_-;;;;?_..5i;.._i=
__,,,,-_
_
a
- FEDERALBUREAU011'
INVESTIGATION
:1
:?
l ,;1~e=.+
.
'
-"
-
__*___
.
5:1. - ITJET-1:;s.19.;:,;i~.1§¢
.'
=.§~;*~;%"F1??2*E'$ _-
b6_
J
_;
Drtsoft|'u.nscr1
[]Q{0',?£'2
pti0n'
]O4
--_0n--B-9f0?~f2Q
-¢_1
--I-NVESTLGAT-IVE
_I
.,I ANALYST
.. q1A![:|
.
, N . .
'
of bJ.rth
SocialSecurityAccount
Number
hm
" Agent
] anddate
was
advised
as
to
the
identity
of
the
interviewingas to the
purpose of the interview
then
-
' -
provided
the following
_IA|4_
__
During
I
.»
IA
-
I!.I'LfOI'Il'I.&tJ.O
|entered_on. dut_ withJ_the Federal
of
,Bureau
-
1,2
_
_
1
we-1'2
Investigation
FBI!
on|
I in
an Investigative
Analys
as
'_
'
e
the approximate
and
isField
currently
employed
as
Office
os
ngeles
time period
of May 13
2003
i
June 26 ,.2003
IA
was
on a tem orar Ydut
.
9
I
!
I
P
be_l assignment
atGuantanamo
ay, u_aGTMO!
insupport
ofOgeration
throu
h
bqc -1
Enduring Freedom. His primary duty during this.assignment
was as a
liaison between the FBI and the U.S. Military,_primarily
with the
'
United States Army. Other than.routine
administrative
support,
IA
presided
themilitarywithinformation
regarding
FBI
i
other
FBI
in erviewsand
investigative
information
as r_equ_ested.
I interrogation
.. _'
IA[:';_'|.:.as
notamember
ofany
interview
or
' _
team,
id not witness any-aggressive
interrogation
b6 -1
hand knowled e of
- any
improper
techniques
being
usedon
detainees.
IA
b?C-1 techniques used on detainees, and has no first
advised
he was not
aware
of Department
of Defense
_
DOD po_1cy
regarding interrogation
techniques, is not aware of any violation
of" DODpolicy, and cannot identify anyone who might be aware of any
violation
of DODor FBI/DOJ interview/interrogation
policy.
b6AI
1
isooumentation
not.
inpossession
ofany
picture-s,
"video,
which depicts or describesaggressive
we '1
notes or other
treatment-,
detainees
possession
$30-31
-"
Military
interrogations
at'GTMO,
and.is
of
such
items.
131:!
Police
or interview
techniques
employed on .
not aware of anyone else who might be in
.
_
--
~-
didnothaveanysubstantive
contact
with
or other
U.S.
government personnel
at GTMO
regarding detainee s condition or treatment, and no allegations
misconduct or mistreatment._by U.S. personnel was formally
to his
attentionby
interviewees.
o
'Irw=stisn!i=m
an 7 O9/Q7/@004 J1!__
7-
W 7.
-7'
'
s_ss§j
j W __
-
_*
'
17
I
. RESPONSES-53
'
_____7_
FM29? HQ Al327669_~A
hefzlp
6 f
_7__ _____
'77
'
''
b
_
_
L
7'
of
brought
. Dmdiomm
09/Q?/2004'
_
_1 -i*
,_
itelgephqnioallyl '
'
b -Io ~1
'
'77
:77
Wn7
_ _
Thisdocument
contains
neither
recommendations
norconclusions
of Lhc:
FBI. It is theproperty
of theI- Blandis loa.ncd'1ao_yo|._|r
agency;
it anditscontents
an:notto ha diptribmcd
outside
yourmommy.
_
.
;__ _
*92
O
.,.-..-
.
_
i0
0
FD 302a. R.ew.
l0'6-95! I
297 HQ-A1327669 A '
- b61
.
- '
Conrinuarimrm-Bvzor
b6 -1
b7C -1.
-._.-
IA
male
about a
is:-F
was a
ib
6 -1 I
b7C l" "'-
K
risen quaxd
tactic
cooperation.
heard the
he i _;,Dn
.
_
Q2L'Q1L2_QD_4_ _.P=
|:Idio' atluiisemhewe-ve"r,
- that.he
heaid 5m mi¢ £"H
detainee being
dressed in
female clothing
with make up
at
the
direction 0f.militar92L
interrogato1_:s ....
Z*
i]The rumor l ioa e
was given
applied, who
i
b7C ~1
an involuntary
lap dance
from a
-'
on
u s ed't0
reek
AI d
rumor. AI
concerning this
is_
*Eh**dEt
e fEee
_a 6own
not
xemember
could provide
and aing
where or
no further
rumor. .
I
1
RESPONSES-54
_ his
from whom he
information
.. '1'
jw
-
é
-
in
L'
-
nu-I
,*_
_ 1
-.
92
_
1
E
. 1
Jrr..
1q
. -;r"
-
e '
.- ,-' e
.
-1
-.
'
. '
u
H-4-_
.__.
-
e
".'-3.1
'-'.
"_"-_- - J11-..'.-I
-_". L
.-_---1-¢_r'-_
._ .-1-_-._-;-92_.
| _..|
0 ""'.- ., -I
..
f 92"4
.
'-I
I _'
-'
-_;-',"
'
;-.'.-..';5»._'-..'.§-_.
;.
'
3 , ~-.-P
-- '~- -- '
-"-~
~_ ~" "4
*-= ,'_4-91¢,-.31.
--92;¢;¢"_§%}
I,,- .:=~--;_;.w
'--1-1--.1
. . .. _r .'. '4
..,»__
-?.1q.'_">
- . 9; - ; _f_'{r_,
'
- '
.'
F?
,..
L
"-
""~" "- "
.- ---=92='
:-='.-:<;.*-.~"--:?~>-f~¢=@¢§:?F.
. .- -,
_
=-':;;=<'-5";-*;;1¢:-,=IA
'
">'T'
'-'- »%1i.1:=F?.I-.'1.<
_
,r-/,.3»g;,'
Universal-O;ise'File.Number
2 1?zn@->-,; 3;§2 ¢1jtI§e
;l'-.&#
.{-._'
,.
-a viz.
§}'»FIeld
'O1f_[c'e
EvidenceV A cjqulrln
I-
senal
#
9f"_'Orlginatinq_
_Dec|.|_ment.
-$3.-.
2:
.,._;
'Date'Reeeqve:_I"-5
9?-j7- qy
W
|
.-'
;§'3'$
. --':=IQ3
_--:5-1;
-»
__k_ aimugmq
.._§:s_
-qnkmm
e i7
'
e
I
92
L.
._.
- --
..-
I -1.-
-
>-git.
. " __'
1
INEIIIWI
Sn dal nentl _I
."
1-3;; _ .;I
;,;:"
_-,-. » er;';5.?=>@ *=E» I
7* .
F
.
"'1-J
_
{AdcIress'ef0o111I1b:.;tnr!
_ _.
-"_.";'>'-'.
114?]
*' ""
ByJig
--
-_
.
b6 -1
1
b'?C
-1
1 =~*;<'*
_
92
.'2
_';"f_;;-1*r".~'§F_
-5?
~§
-j'?i
#5: 3.
<--Ff?
l.'
2--'.
.
'1Tn.Be
Reiumed
"ClYesNo
=Fleceipt=_Given
[3 Ye§Q No
'
._,J.;;|_;,-¢;_'~;;j§l__:.
rand
Jury
Matenhl
- Dzsseminete
92§iFf:_h_
'
I Federal
_'
- i Hules
-'
._
J 'Cfiininal
toflFluie
6
e!,
of
Prmed ig
l? _.-;;=.W
_.1;
.
_l
"NO
D. Yes
N
'~"
'
921.r:.¬:__
I
J
92
31;
E2:-'
Ti
e.fl '"
fiff
5
.-H
-_;i'1;_*;|':%;;_?_._=.s§;_
=W
5*
:4.
1
°
'5.
.. '.'-'.3'
-;~'¢'92
. ,.W
.-...._
,»:
..=:;-ii-5=,'r-%;~
la .-4%,-,-;, i
;_"Ev,
__
Fleferenee:
r92'
E.
_,92
~..
1 ,
!..
0 '1'.
-
_
-'
_
.'
'"
- _ _.,_
1cbmmuhim »n"E1iéiés1néM-=wnéu
*-'=-=-;§¢;Ir:;@r;;;i%;.,
92
..- i5-
_
.
1.
Descrlpglon.
Or:gir_|al
notes
re intennew
of_
~'
e- W
.,
'3".
"T
'
'
-.1 -+.-»
__!-;.'<|-,,§,c.
i"t.: f
b6
-1
._ :J'.,--.w.~;q_:.92
b'?CI
.1
I? .
.1 ?..1 ..;u.
1 ._
,_I- _
_ ..,_:!.
Q;-"f'<>=.:'§:';"". ."'
I _'._:-":-;:.|92-.1
'1.-F!"';.eZ{?f..
. _:T
=:%§.?;"_s,;?;~
5*",
5.. "if-_-_'"'..'*
_j
.
F.. _._'_,._r.
"7
%;'
1-.
_
_
-.<Y'L
1
.l%§
.i
.
-'
RESPONSES-55
..':»"~
- '
-
..
'
"I4
.-J-59- =:"§ - i
- .}L3.--if- .1§*_5;':- ='
r
- rs-.;92..1.
=':'_'.i~.'-1'.
---- .----._
_l__.,.,_,...,,.__.?=.T__..,.._.._._
_ ..._.
.......-.
. .,_ .I
-
~F
Ii
.
.... .5 . 5 .'-r
* F'5
.-. .- _~--w»- 7
U
.'
fins5':-1-"man
§B1f§=§=s1§-g_:.__E
:_>__§_1%I;£r1;-1;__?j_g1IE,__
I g.-35""!
1
. _
7
L
_Q..£..__
._._...
....
77
7
7. 7
_7____
777
_/I
7
-
E1
_:=I;
-3,,-»;-..-I-.__._.:
:1 ,
$1i i a a rfami
92
a
' 7i1%f§7®§I;§#§§I
F§l¥7!@
7;...T;5r§;§.§.H7.s1.§::¥:;
.
;§;:Y::2@:#§.171@
C '1
.
7777
7777
_7_:_'___7.777_.7
7 777i
?7r=-".7
.777 7"
-2 .-______.7
7 7777.
_77 7717
i i *7 '
* "1.---'
b'1'C
_ -7 -1-12F
77
:
:
.£§..*..C._7_77
_Z7
i.
l
-
7 7
_
7
7
71
7,__..7
L
. 7..7..._7_.__.__b__2
76
'
92
5*
v7-77;
..7;_¢.1.=...=¢7
<77
J7
72¢
--¢i4Za77:u§77.-L
b7C--'---.-;27.
75
"'- '
'""
"
'.-'
-'~"'"-:-~'-- --~
-- --'-17...,
7...
i77.7.
,
7»7*'k4:
_7_
7771;
_¢7-r7
~
r "
1@
-
-
-
_
77,5777
-;71-"
7777177.-T
#77 -7- .'
7c7-792,_71~77fr1<!-,L77a.1_
i-* 7<%T'=~
. .
_" 7 ,7
"'
-_-:-~-=7_;¢je;*";92;~=gr.;_".§'-"1
,'.*. -2 ~=_'-,~
L»7~:-*"+7~.77-»~7=;
7-:*-f
794
~7§7:e--77%771¬L:*L1
T1!
"'=7¥7""__E$-Q7:--¢--..7
-95.77,
.77 '
7-.
-§ 777-ii;
77.7-717
7
i
__
'7
1777-'
-"7f
77/"'7"!'f
*"§7"7
77'7"
7::"*"l"1'5E77
""-'9'-57'!
77ll'7l
:92-1.:
777 77 77_7
-é _'
7777 .__7_- _-71"_:;
up-
"£1797-Q7-7.-7"
177-5-""
2-:r7
=77W
&.7 f **=- I=I7-3*~P777'I
7rT 57'3&#
Q->11-&#
?"
H'
92
-
<-'4?
-"1"-""
[777 77
"
77777 7
7
77 7777 7777777777777777
77777 77
1»/=:$777e=277
E
77 !7
7§'
.:..§,_.§
____._
_7.7-__,7.__7_
-7'"
LE17_'-*7!
7.? ¢'=-'51
* i_-777-_.-
""117
'
':_"
7 777
'
@.r
&7777<7~7,~;<'77'7-77
77 -L7=7:7» 7-774.774-71-:-:1
5:-7-=71.-¢.7¢,.@r7_.r-@1474
77775?
_~_~7-7§7¢77..3:-47
7
'-=;;57;<17s7Ij
»<»..1-e777~7'1z
=»>r7.7777*r3_7,.11
7 ¢~.T;7r»-97i77
77 77 75 _7'
77777
'_
7
F I 4"-"'_
d
:7L7':f'_:-4-'92
E
:1-57'
-f_'92_
77, 7
.
.'
I
'
.'
. . -'
_:__
.
7
7 _
7
RESPONSES-55.-~
_ 7 +7777:7-77777777771
7 _
_
.
L
__'__7;_"_'7
_.
_737__-7
77'-7-7777
' .7-.7
77
- "'7-1
"- 4--';~'-=¢_"
'1»-"I-'Z'1
-Z!-7'-T"
_7
7_7_7_
7;_.__
_7E'~$7
7 i""
__7 =I:=={77;¢:~:7~'7
_777_
_7
7 ;;-;5..77;--*¢
77 77
%747.¢77-"ml-;~r2==7'7'»~;---7~:r
Q
.7 7777 7777-777777777
77
'
i1
77
7 777
77
:7-*<'7¢£.4"777-!»492.7sti777¢-~;7_7f17
@177-¢--2
-1-7"r2==~77
'?7~: 1
¢_L:f______J-Q-I177 -7¢¢L'"7779
l-£77
92
H-.92
7 7777777
777;7__7_.77777:7
;77@£:r.777:7=7~77,e7@7773.-.77>-.7777-7»
£777-2;~+77;7,77@.....u1
7774877!
77 1777777777
~7<»
1'
2"}.
7 7-=~= -=&
7
_?
r_ r~
ii-77
f
fi ~;
:i;_:i: f_____P fH___r
7_7
|..¢...,=.._. .._§
}7l-l<7¢».77§77777=E:
7!? -'2"
-'
* 757i:-*
-77"i'
5- 592
'-¢-7777
-7i¢'F=_>T
-9eQ77755*
:~_J77_* .l_¬1=r!l7*
77777
-_..__
_-._
.7._....._T+92
77+
"~7._.:l _§7-=7-77
7<-7 *Tl!§7:;7.,777Q'Pi77l?:7:1170777
7{777
*7-:77=l7
7711:7773
£7F72:-7T7!=-'-Z77'
_r'77*4 4 17
,,,,, 7__77___.._77__l
" 92|
L'
<'l1'==-..e<£.___§:£.__1=7-_.J:£.1=,7-7_ Q..7,
%.
1
92
J
"H;
JKK" W K;
.__.-._~._._,...____.._____
5'1
_
"
u
'
K"K__" -F
"1/
,,_ .,____;,
-=:"==-3'92i ,,
J,, ""V ,
t"___
S,, 5&J-2.!-_'__,Q
"'3
»_ it _£{_
_..___
_
i_
°- '
L
92=_-._
____________:__:-:1iJ§;""""_1
a,[!¢_;_=-.-"T 77¢-%»'92-u_|,2'._'J9g,._/W
, ?,,*____ __
7
92_*........_._.&¢a3,;-:~=-1,!Qt,=ZL=-7-'§,,,j_
f
, _,?,?
_ f
W_
=-~v-P__
J"?-&_,.
-FL?
'L
_
J
. <...._-L-bufW-vie-¬-I;;;:g
s
____._,
_,"";,¢92,g:'r
_
:"f92-1;!"
___ - ~15 *7-_~5:_'
f?J "
,l'"
£7 92-I l in
8. 7;;
- $4.7
92.
'
'i_r'e
.._.-_..-.w___
_ ,___.X.:1!_J:3_;_@H
;c- r--.9;--=92
..»_-3-JQ-_._..j'92'_
c,__
l'92'926-'1:-7
.7I§"F=-c
_a,___
92
E
r -.-.p__T_i
H.
_ _lY'92_,__-ff
e__»~,-¢-_1g
____5|a'T"92-I
_-;{_F_:g~_Q~
_g,,_7___
_, 1?
:__
_
Y y
:
!.: _777_!'
9292'92--4
if
__
- _
.
"
7
='
*-'7"
,I _l'__
__cl&,g_..,L__5'l
!1f=~__,-£"=91..n,.__Q___f1_.¢__1;;,¢_,L
,_,___@!-72-.¢§.1=Z_*'
___
__
_,,_
| ..,_.....,...,____....,._._...--........
____
-bl
__
__.._.
j
.
:|____£'
I__1__~-1-_1_".|1-.1
1
r/q;:L
'
"'
1 W TF5?
_g
" "
*4,k§ *-'-§L.'Z7H-:23 ll ,::_1
1
"":I
=r'»?"~i1-L
'+-=*="1'@-=-"T:@=_<1*
*1»,
,,;_¢1=_-T'Z**-92~'-=s_,_'~*i4@=-zc
=1»--.,
-¢
3?"
h
*r-a*-Hz. 13»-=3,
A.
/¢.._..,_,;,_,.
_n.it_<."._i
:"'4'La 5 ;;_-L-5l 3'e?
§_°-g-irg-_--_1
_
_ -1"__,,________
_ 4,,_'T'=1_r_
Li ! i #1
.
_ 'L'*
hi
Q
"-s_;;?!"_'--'9l_92"1'_*3:-_'§
*5
_@*','5!_-r!1-9 -Xv 5:5»
1
9;-__ 27¢-31
»g.L; F- Tl-éL-1147'-_
Q-a.¢~_-4 14 4:-2 77§._=!192_:"
M;
1-
.
...._._.-.._..._..,...-._.._-.-92..-....
,,,,.._.
-..h___..--.__-.._-¢,-_..-.. ...._,..._.__...
-----.._.._._.__-;:......_lLi:.Z..
.-
.__
n__
'
*iii _
,_
_.. ,
_
..__
?_*,__********___ ___
.______
_ ,_
_,,_,__
=
J-
2:
I';£'
. ':_
_ " .0-i
. '=:'.1'r
EQWH
;."|»-_
_
_
.2» ~11"
RESPONSES-57
92
._
M
i*__r ""'
u- lwu luwl éfr .
92
l
b7C
-1
if
*5-"Tr-as-~p
-
-it
Questions
Conggrning
Activities
atGuantanamo
Bag,
CubsQTMO} .-at an--mi.
Describe
yourroleatGTMO andtheapproximate
timeframe. 1-==~'s
---. §<~'
5* F""'1
'
= s;=.:r=..n-if no
-ae-~-I .
If a memberof aninterview
team,please
explaintherolesof themembers
which
_'
comprised
yourinterviefs-_'
teamr
M.-r"
c _.-i.-s--.-
Describe
anyaggressive
treatment,
interrogations
orinterview
techniques
employed
on
detainees
atGTMQ,whichyouwitnessed
orareaware
o which
was-not
consistent
with
r-. 92.a.
_.
-.*|_-_J_
_-i.-'
B131
Tm;
Dos-poneyi.g92iiceii;;efsf!a~3e1='~esarf*'e*"?1
;a';s_-',§_;
- f-§_§.;---z;-L~e3r
..~. '_.-.
.L
What,
if any,was
your
understanding
ofDepartment
ofDefense
anthonzation
forthe
'
permitted
useof_11ars_i11faggressi!*e_inte1rogation
tech11iques *1-'-=__-----v-3*
_2.»v.-pi'6
10 r-W "r-
Describe
howyoubecame
aware
of
DOD authorized
techniques.
.-'1/I
A;
it
In youropinion,wastheaggressive
treanneiit, -interrogations
orinterview
techniques
employed
on_de_ta.inees
at'G'I
i§vi_i1_1esse_d
i921iQ,"§_iifliich
orareaware
of,consistent
or _
inconsistent
Withyour
understanding
of
DOD authorized
activityLfinconsistent,
?
'how?Identify
anyother
indiiliduals
whosviniessed
thisactivity.
3/; A
'5
_
Doyouknoyr
theidentity
ofeither
thedetainee
orthe
DOD employeer/contractor,
andthe
approximate
datetheincident
occurred?
A--_
o
- ' ' '
l
If youwereawareof anyireatrnent,
interrogation
orinterview
teclniiques.
employed
at
GTMOwhich
wasinconsistent
withFBUDOI
policy
_a_1;i
DOD authorized
r
l
l
techniques,
did-you
document-or
report-it~to-.ar-1yone?'
if so,howandto whomdidyou
report
yourconcerns/I/B
'
?
_-
-
'
'
I
Pleaseidentifywheretheinterviewsoccurredat GTMO whichyoubelievemay have
beenicontrary
topolicyor authorized
techniques.
,1./.-..-s-e
-
Didyouhaveanysubstantive
contact
with
_-
Police
orother government
personnel
at GTTMO
regarding
detainees
condition
ortreatment?
-Describe.
~'92=>
Describeany allegations
of misconduct
or mistreatment
by.U.S.personnelbroughtto
yourattention
by
interviewees
orothers?
-1-'<-M
¢~5-"Jain./'1'»
-I-T1;asrs-Ti.».. Q--
ii
Areyouinpossession
ofanypictures,
video,
aiidio,notes
orother
documentation
which
L
depictsor describes
aggressive
treatment,interrogations
or interviewtechniques
played ondetainees
atGTMO?Areyouawareof anyone
elsewhois in possession
of
suohiterns?/vs,
.I
.»vo"~_¢----<-»'~:..
e--I~:92.-..-,_
.
I
-
l
la
.
i
_
RESPONSES-58
'
7
__
,r
7
I
13! - Do you
have any
additional information
_re1ating'
the treatrnent
of
to detainees
at GTMO I.
which should
be brought
to ourattention? ;.BZ. .'*'¢
1 1%--- ~-9
,cu. 1* rum f 4*"-"" '*
yvl-.1.-Ll
of """~ 5"~.
'
Q5
S
92
u
92
1 RESPONSES-'39
j
3'
Positive
Response
Number 6
n
1
4
N MaSS&g¬
.-
.
°Page
1 0f2
__;'
s9292P§ d;}~5*"
;92
s-
7%; it 1i»s_r33___rFl-;»,5m,,6
Wis? Eh
"
"
r
r-
1;
1
--
Te
l%_i_li¢TD>_<@Il
. RE: ' ' s'
g i*"L"
Subject:GTMO
OK, Iwill oonsideryoua positiveresponse _and
no needfor youto do
the
-.
- U/92
. ,5,»_;t.5,
5...>.I- C
EC. .Qnoewe-get allthe responses,a
detemaination be
willmade
as-19-wl=|o gets interviewed.
-Thanks-again. _.
- . . ---_-0rlginaIMessa_
e-I- '
.
-
'
I
_
be -1r e--»i:: ::|rm>><~=s>
bjrr; -1
__5BI'lt:
Jill?ZUU4
14,
WEGFIESUBE:
2258-PM
5,, I__.¢
To: INSD!
FBI!
--
Subject: -RE;
GTMO
seusmve BUT
UN_CLASSIi'-ED "
_'NN-R on
'
.,
.,
- Yes. There
was-an
incident of
observation aof
detaineeinastressposition". ljhis
was within
the regsof
' military
techniques buigoutside
MIOG No
Bureau personnel
involved]. That
was
the lirnit ofdirect
obsenratioris. Intémts
of
knowledge ofmistreatmentcan
i speakto thatin great-detaiifrom formal
meetings which
Iattendedand informal
discussions with
DoD personnel.
BC _
"
,_
r-
-eh
--
- ~OriinalMessae- --
'
_
_
-- .
.-'
_
.
.
- '
_b6 -'
_1
rm-1~ialrI~$r>><rB1>i
2
Sen_i::Wednesda _July14,20i]4_2:54_PM
..hm. _l. To=l'__i___t'Ll
C-TB! an.
_
'
__
Subject: RE: GTMO
J1", I
_'-
_.
sertsnrgiaaur- i1uci.Ases1.ee
'
Non-Recon-Q .. . --
_'
-OK, l willprint this
out and
retain when
for the
interviews start.
iwiil take
this'as'
anegative
-responsefor Bu auemployees. -Any
observationsother
of agencies
mistreatment detainees?
of
__
-- Ori
lnal Message-m
'
be -1sFmm=E::iUD!
FBI!
'
A
b'r C -1' Sent:
Wednesday, July
14, 20042:38PM
' T:
I_NSD!. FBI!
s
é= F5Ii
is
- -Subject: RE:GTMO __|~| -RCO
~
Or
"1
_.
ttit
.
- _
sausmve am"
uucLAs_stEiEo
~bi
-1
i
-s
WC "1 ' ._
;_i
--
~
_
'
RESPONSES-60
_--
~
..t_=].>¢qa!,_o
oi.ti- "711
l~ l ,92,*;-;.3~¬_Qj
,it~1.sriws_,
a.
_
Hr
»
' "
sIF
At
-that time. itseemed theBureau'swas
focus
identiiyingany iiabiiityin theform ofdirect
involvement. would
I
behappy
to
sit downwith -youand walltyouthrough what!saw asthe
_predictable
onset of aggressive treatment,interrogations or
interview techniques. In short,
the-Bureau personnelthere had no direct particiaiionl But I think I may be able to assist in.
describing thelandscape for
you andgiving youthe detailsabout wheresome thingswent oft
the tracks.ljust-moved to
ITIC [Tyson's
Corner! and
am phone-less,
but l_
have thise-mait
--savanna
.1
_.
.|
Message '
'
6'
_.
. Page
2 of
2'
Q-
.
-
lb6 -4
W "1
up
and
running.-~ --
:
-
»
92
k
CTD!Fly Team
-- "
' SENSJTIVE
BUT _UNBLASSIFlED-
_
You have
been identi ed
as having
conducted an
assignment GTMO,
at
Cuba
since
- 9111101..
The inspection Division hasbeen
tasked
with contacting those
employees
who have
served in
any oapaoltv
at GTMO
and obtain
information regarding
the
_
-
treatment ofdetainees. Employees
should immediately
respond tothe following1
- 1! Employees who
observed aggressive
treatment, interrogations
or interview
_'
- _teohniques on G -{MO
detaineeswhich
was
not oonsistentwlth
Bureau interview
policviguidelines, should
respond viaemail
for
thepurpose ofafoliow-up i|_'| oervie'w.
Positive emailresponses shouldbe directed to: "
'
I -._
_-
_
-
'
--'
,.
- b6
-1 "
- _lnspeot1onDivision_-_
. ' -.
..
1,
-
-
I
2! Employees
who served
at
GTMO andobservedno
aggressive treatn irrt.-of"
' detainees,
should respond
via anEC documenting
anegative response. TheEC
should include
the employee's
of oialBureau
name,
title. andtenure ofassignment at
GTMO. '
' ' -,
_'"
The ECshouldbeti ed Counterterrorism
Division, GTIvlO,_inspectior1
Special _,
. lnquiryt,
.
1 __
.'
s
le #297-HQ A13276S9-A.
The ECshould not-be
uploaded; but
only-serialized, with
_e- '
hard copy
forwarded
to:
.
- ' '
'
'
- ' - I _
_
Inspection Division
Of oe oflns
iii be
. -Roomrear
._
estions '
'1
t' T P7 ? '1
'
1
_'§ENSlT]UE
_U_|iCL_AS_S[F|ED
_B_l..[[
'
SENSITIVE
BUT l._lNCLA§§lFliED
.
.J
SEQJSITIVE-BUTUNCLASSIFIED -
-
5ENS_lTNE B'UT_L!NCLASS1EiED
RESPONSES 61
. t
..
.
-=.
A,_ -;_<._
IG
FD-30.2 Rev.
10-5-95!
. _l_
_
" FEDERAL BUREAU or iNVESTIGA'l ION
I.
. '
136 l
_
_Dale fl -r 41$¢IiPii°11 0311552004
_
-I
Division, ea
quar ers,.EOD:
was contacted
- b6
- regarding
his knowledge
of any
aggres.siv_e'treatment,
'
bf!-C
interrogations, or
interview techni
ques at
Guantanamo Bay,
Cu-be
{GTMOJ After
being advised
as
to
the identit
of
the
interviewing
-2
_2
.Agent
the
andpurpose
of
the
interview,
|:_provided
LI
theb6 ._l
following information
to thirteen
specific
special.
inquiry """
questions: .
--
. Zdescribed
135 "'1
aCase
b? j .-]_his
-of
'
investigator[s},
his 15
Agent tasked
tenure,Z| was
FBI investigatoris!,
. '
to participate
month TDY assignmentat GTMO
in detainee
Department
and atranslator.
as
interviews. During
interview team
part
of-an
' _b7c'1
which consisted
of Defense
'
DoD!
' Investigator {s} representing
DoD,
were
-from Army Criminallnvestigative Division
Force Office
of
Special
Investigations IOSI!
CID!, Air
and Naval Criminal
Q56 -1
-the'E
- B'I
S
b7c ~1
bu,
-
Investigative Service
NCISJ According
to [:l
. usually took the lead role during detainee
interviews. I-iowever, I
DoD
Investigators
occasion took
also participated
the
lead.
I '
'h.I never
interrogations, or
GTMO-inconsistent with
in
detainee
-interviews and
on-
-.
- participatedinany -aggressi_ve"treatment,
ques employed
on detaineesat
DOJ olicy/guidelines.
--However,
walked into
a Camp
Delta
'
"
i
interview techni
FBI or
during the
summer of
2002,
observation room
and noticed
adetainee
in an
interview
rubbing his
leg due to possibly
being placed
in~a stress
The detainee was wearin le
irons
andwas
room
position.
handonffed with cnffs b6
_'1 3
chained
his
to waist
advised
the chains were
adjusted-to_1
b73
force the detainee to stand
in
abaseball catcher position. The C
detainee
was
being
questioned
by
two
military
officers.
|or .
unable to
proved
the
names of
the
military officers
I
or number
§j__the|:|-detainee.
verbally
reportedthis
92in
- was
. -to|
_ *I
-
_| JAG,
usnc Reserve]. [:|did|not have
. any substantive oonfactwith|::|regarding this
matter
ename
-
that
during the
fall
of
2002,
detainee
# was
being advised
held
in the
Navy
Brig
at
Camp
Delta.
According
to b6-1
the
FBI
questioned
detainee
#|:|
for
approximately
x; two
_
- months
with negative
results. The
military then
moved detainee
to Camp X Ray. General
Geoff
Miller
requested permission
Investigation
09;/_3;O/209{1fiia":Vienna,
on
Virginia
i W _Z
. Filc 29,1-no-.A13'27659-A
y o1__"
ii
'1? 935-A
_,
to
no
to
_-
'_dictated
Date _N/A.
WH_
7 '_
be 11 -
__
b7C
This dooummr contains-neitherrecommendations nor
oonolusioos ofthe FBI. 11
it and its contents are not to be distributed outsid: your igoncy.
'
'
RESPONSES-62
isthe pi-upeny
of thoFBI andis loaned
1o_your agency;
._.
3_
.I
is
i
_
-.,, t®
,_
O,
FD-302a um. 1n-6-as!
' :-
23": -so-A13216'69-'A
'
lb6
-1 '
' b7
-1
Gonnhu.-m'o11ofFP-3020?
g
,___|:|
___
,0, _Q_Q/1D/_2[!H !L_,Pag
utilige iésééiéi iheéiregative techniques on detainee~#E:]i.....,,
b6 Q4
with detainee E. once
. V
Corbett stated
the FBI
and DoD investigators had
he
was
transferred to
no further
Camp X-_-ray.
contact mo
-4
Durin December
2002, Lieutenant[:::::::l
Nurse, U;S.'
'"Navy, i-nformed[:|
that detainee
#E|had been
admitted the
to
base hospital
for hypothermia.
During a'daily staff meeting,
' b6
L3,4
|;_] inquiredabout detainee
#l:_|bein admitted
to thehos italb7C l,3
for
ypothermia.
Lieutenant Colonell
' -[advised]
ithatI,<
detainee #[:]was not die nosed_with hypothermia.|
Ito d
|::|that
detainee
#|lg'|
low blood
res.-sure
hadalong
with low
bod coretem erature.
Accordin- to[::i¬::]no add'onal
YP
G
information
was
providedto him
regarding detainee
ii ,
l
-|:| described
his understanding of _DoD'authorization
.
use of harsh/aggressive interrogation
techniques
b7 : '1
--as very'unE:lea'r"'.'
[:1 advised
he becameaware of DoD '
'
b5 1 for
the permitted
.authorized
I'.
techniques'v1a meetingswith General
.-[:::::::]had no
Miller.
substantive contact with Military
Police. d
or
other
U.S. government
personnel at
GTMO regarding
detainee
_
conditions or_treatment
and was unaware oi
any specific
allegations
of misconduct
or
mistreatment
by U.S.
personnel alleged
by '_-
b6 ~l
b7C -1
interviewees
or
others.
[::::::] stated
he had no pictures,
video,'
audio,
notes,
or
otherdocumentation
depicted
which
or
described
aggressive treatment,
interrogations'or interview
employed at
GTMO or
knowledge
of anyone
else who
of such
items. "
techniques"
has in
possession
.
--
1'
92
-'
_
Ii-nn-3-i1$ _*|i
_,
RESPONSES-63
iii
in-is
i*_
__
_
92
.
_ .
-_,__..__.___..__.
. -._. .r__,,J
_ _..=.
, .
.'i'
-,.-__<,- J-J
_ "1-_:.. ..!"T.."]_
-
.
...
-
.
___
:-
Uhlversal
Casa§F|Ie
Number
2i7-#0-Axazmr
.r
-13ate_Hace'ived
=- i_~
1;_V_
FieldOf ceAcquiring
.E_92fide-_.nce_
_
.
I
Serialif-of Originating
Dqcument
.
.
.
r
1.r. _
.
L.
92.'
.:
r'
I
1
92'1
.."'
..92
1'1 ..-
_..
A-
.
r r .<.'¥=!sr.2@=.;=r¢-1»;==;=w=»r~@J'
"
L
. I».": '.
b6
l
'
M
M. i%_
.-
" :~1.
92-
_
.|.'
92.'
From
I.r,54":I
'
>..
1:
._'L -:">:r»:~F:-'-
i ar wlsn
J
-?» 1-W:
W7
b7C
l l aeml *-
*1--'
1
-4
To
Be
Heiurned
Eljigs. -C _r_imhi'r|al
=10
Flulele!,_'.I=.:e:riEi_-r'.2"a.'!-.lEi1.ii:r;:"&
Pkoieééi re
b6 -1*
b'FC
-1
Fiec:aipt'Gi92qen'
Fl,
_Yes_
_'
.
_ .
1..-
._ .
._
_..,
..
C-i:'~an'd.Juiqf.M1éiiqri§j_'¢i§§5i
T
V » T u,§'é?%2:*1i1LNo,...'
. r.
.3.'92'
;:;;T;;,i=le_iarenc:_e.
q-'
l"|t1e:
=
P
.
- .:
i ~ '
. -.i92?°'1""P$=~?*F9Pj5¢=!P§l"q.*!#'
.
9"J.¢.".
-.
.92_"r. . 1»
.1"?
qa
Q
*
. K 1 -_,
I .,--,.-__
; __|-_.=-.__...
1.
,
I
gm
le -':
'
an
.
_»_.
.--
II
92- .
.-.
'
;3.92;-7|
'
.».'.-
..
__
-
_-
~
.
-
1-.:-
r
"I
:=
..
I.
.
I-=._
.
__ ._. ._ . ....
.,
_
-..
-1.
.
.
7_______ 92,,_,|__ _;
____
=
_
Pes'c'ripti0n.'
.m'¬-1§r.§ir.§§i§¢
r
r.¢'
. . /,'<
,
>, .':-_-iv.
'.
'
_
r
L-c'."
' -;.
_
1'...
._.-;
1'1
92
L": I
.__
.
___:.
'
H»-5,
. -.
:.:_;;.,,
i...=
:.-e :
_
_
'
-- .1; - . , a,_'
.- -ii»:-Y,
'.
-
'_.'
_'.J
.. _- r
L-'.
~
v@
__
.
.
:
..5
.
b6
l
b'?C
_-'.|
_______
. .,__,
92
- /9gm
9292K
, ;
:1
' .
b6~1
.
w
K, N me-1 _
_ Cm v<r,,-.,1....=.,
11"»¢»_Z:>72{@/mg»?
JLL;
_
-
fW
Y»-5
i
,-.,
K
Tr»;- .11-T!
.3/I; K
"r
W
11
-
7
In
?-
-
3
7"_ 77+-.:.
- '
?__j
?
i
__#
"1 ~
< .;
"5.
'
. I
_ .-;w>._.:.."_.._ ._"
. _u¬I¢r
|j7Q/r
-:!'%1/afvrrw
- -'
/QT - -'4"
a/:0 __
._ .r1;;;'-*&
r
~
_"
4
*2!'
. ": ."".:":1@"'_».
..*.= +1=
~
4; ,_
4*}!/;'J
AW
H.;? ¢im-iv
ml-:4
" £1522?
___T
7_ .¢;-.5,J-H
25; 5&
1
,
dd
625&
_J1L
Jkf//1'
1-;
;_,'Z9»'|:
- jwws/E;
/ff?l f92;14~§
-.-_i9
¬
l___h
_ ,-
I
_ __
|
hair
-4:
V
'
fr;
'
H.
V
we
K:
f".
I '
g!_T,T_
I
- .__ _ n
Tm-F -1
_
L ' "1 ,'2£@#Eh
i
7
___
A
t»
{ '7
y-J
w
vi, W_-
. H3 j?-=3 .01. W.
___
92
{
K
_,£ ]~4-§= _?-- j;0Z§2v_9;'l~
j
_*_ ' f,. . _.92
' @
_7
@
b7C
-2
__ Q1ACw4,;-/ȴ
;
{
I
..-....1 .-,3.._,92_»_..
- 1...»92
_
_._ f_,__
,, 1 I;;.._.
IW
I
__
vI
| ¢=12=¢¢mlmiéj»
=-Mwa
pv{ 7;3¢//j/_
1; ll!»-v5_*
g-jY!"...@
$"_-"
#"f~~.I .- 1..r.*.*=..1
*_
.._
_;. { _$sE@2.
'7 V;
_Em_{
, »lR';fg;
LR_.7%m
.Q@_;{,m;
b6
92
-4
*
ms -4
L
anwlhlbé
5;m
E
4;-/»
5;
ml?
i f I'¬
lf 5W£;
n
_%l1&#
if|§m
/{__:@
7 :
92
'
r
1-441:
r 7 7I"
._
i
i
7
*7
MW.
.. i
In
_r-"~
7 .-_*
_I'ifJ_
"r
"
if r if
_
W
L2
ow; 4> _;>;4»zW41 AF/3/L
5 Wm14¢, V
T92 a-¢{f"'S<"l
M~r$<Q
53] _-lo IA-M7"
§¬~¬I ii¢rJM=&#
_
L
t
Y mJ1'I>-:»<'
/1,65?
§+w WM<_1;@i
mg 7
' -
4
RESPONSES-65
'
,
.
-'-'1-10"
-""
__. _ _ '-,,--,-_.._--.._.._. .
-'
_,¢-- "-'- u-" *
»---------.-1.----..-.-.-_,_-..
..._.....-..----1-rwu-----an--v
Wm
»~"
W
M
@»~%
l.
E LFTM
% ,4 A1
4
_
_{ zL;cQ _]
1W1 A |M»»/ »=»»<+¢
e
K. 5I_
If ii. Y",1'.hut,I014;
§;1f¬_']['t'
L" if;/man/if/-,-_9¢
.77
3
JWJ
* % /113
fm/p4»W~/'
ii
_1_
i-'927____
'
,7 - __7 .M WW
92
- i _éw
%
' 1":LM"~*l£
F
1'~"
j
j
j
f
1'
7
»/4:
i
Z '
_ W _ SJ5'e:-5,;-1=_f_|7!_/Z
ha!£}§@q~F
_
¢ F vlvSH155-,»
ii
;-
H-;s»1.¢
/La.»
//Ja/W/I
H
i
_'
wag
§J4.-pt-r:A:I»7;;r;&#
2 I'fL
I
J
_ 2"/*'§§92
8/ @254
s1 cm
V
7
1
92
_
M M ~H» ~@¢>~r'*/;»»»*&
1glii fytsj
¢¢5,fé;a;',é
i
.
j 7,;/ '2/in»
~;?»f'~_-s:g/"
, _ j __,. j
Z
@*
$5. "3 4 /,
" * ::"'
-____ ___
V._-____
7_
,
_
__
_ __
.
*"E$@
X
3
_
-
7
___
_ I7
_ _
,
_,
____ _
,
7 :
__ ,
7
92
__ L
, ,
@6191
l"»""'?
@@%*@W#%
%
92
'
*7
92
'
_
M,
Q
-
*
J.
7*'
j WW
-
7 7' - -jm
*1
"
I
_ _
_
I
92
,_._
. @ Jj, GgD * H*/__;§1;[erf!'¢
Jf goM_- I __ ___" ___
T-
Y
.
I
.
-
.
W J5
.. @Lm¢-.3
, 5NJ_92'I$
W ! ¥_
£116
' !%'
>::'__
4;
"
/Ir-'~»~&
I ; _J|
.L {hf 355-
___E$¢_§4 1!
£1 9a";~j1 -'/
1_ ,1%"1
-7
j '1'
1j i
Qa Mme
L
L
@~¢M
1
1
_
;
1
RESPONSES-66
Q
{ __
-
-in
~- -..
.._.<._,-..
.1_-.¢-..'-up-
I
1
J]@~~1 §>~$*+*@@
{~31 5%
K 1<*ir<¢
Q,
"
.*
_1
__
'
**i
I ___
___,__
,fL:::;:;T'_
<T
_ __ H
i
7
j
92
92
i
J
_
7
92
92
_
J7 7
""'7
i
77
"
w
_ ___ _ r
92
_
_ _
_
I
F
E
%
1
RESP6wsEs-57
"*
.
c
Positive-
Response
Number
7
r '
'
Q--
VMesszigc
__ iI
.. "
- Pagelof
.
|~so! |=an_-
i¢~@»s< -=51»
b6_1 it
L
bi-' - - '
-
-° 1 Ii
Subject: RE:
GTMO "
-.1.
--
"
92
' _
Yes.will
I put
you oown
asa positivé
response. ydé.
Thank
--
-
.___.;:,'_'.';.:_4 - _.;;-=-'.
...
:'
."'
.'_l ""..;:|.92'
- .' --Ori
inalMessa
e- -
"
- From:H0! PB?!. .'
- "9'ru=
'1 . "1uéo!
l H FBI! '
b6 "1
Sent Fri a Ju
-
09 2004 5-so PM
-¬_||.l_l:||'-.f
_: :.in
_E"
_u
UNCLASSIFIED
non-gecogg -
-
"
_
1
' _l observed
wl-lat msy
have beén
aggressivéiechniques
byjg-FBI
used
interrogators,
Does
this
still
fall
.s
.
- into what yougrglooking into? ,"
' ''
/' "
b6 -1
.
..1.-
" '
__ . Houston
Dwlsnon-1-"Corpus
-RA
- _r
r - Christi
_.
._.
»/-
RE5|J_Q|92|$E_5-68Jr"
-
.».
.
_..
,_.--:3-':~.'Ir -I *:- _ /
-"----Or|g1nalNle,ssage=~ -__
_|
--
I
seht:.5nuay,_Ju:yo9, "2o041=42PM__
~-
_,- _v_._.
X-' .-P ! -
_-
x I2
~
.
_'
.
FBI
1
HOUFBI'
J! Fl3I!
FBI V
UN!
---92 FB1>;*
7
7NY! FBI!:. _LD
'
BL FBI!;
AN!
_
FBIi:~i.! FB-! FBI
.FB1- CGHFB1!: Ml& l!, FBI!
l H0!
HUHU l- mi
FBI!: Il?~! FB1-
FBI!; AQ! GA!;. LSl_ FBI;
<rH:>1 FB1>; Am- FBI!;
T CID FBI!,
*_ c'm!
FBI i
IWP!
FBI!: NY!
Z PH!
_MM
-
i N0
FBI!; co
!;
FBI!; IR!
FBI!; MM!
;
FBI __] =x!
rs! FBI!;
:-E! FBI!
{NY} FBI} w|=!
FBI
ii
FBI!
con. ;-
V
FBI!;
MM!
"
-i
_NY!.
r
_i~1o!_
- H0.!
Px! BI
CTDUFBI
FBI'!; 'ALHF51; '
' CUHFBI!;
FlF1F92lI92f92f'92J
MM
FBI!
MM!
!!
FBI! -CTD
WP! FBI
FBI! NF!_ I_=BI
FBI!; -
FBI!; * [ s1=! =
1"PX
.
ITD! F51!
FBI!; | s1=!- |=a1
SE!- FBI' IR
FBI nv
NY!
j
FBI!; l
FBI! o
MM
FBI!;
FBI! MM!
-
"
MM FBI!;
~ASD! FBI-MM'! FB1'
cm!;
|<><ran;
{FBI};-CUMMINGS, ARTHUR
M.
cm!
om! FBI!;
- mo!
FBI!;
i .
I
_
mQ_ s=s: MM!
FBI! LA!
HO } FBI!
*
an FE!
ATTLE
FRANI-CI FBI
Ml _ l!£FBI].
LLA!
PB 1
9-"! FBI!.
FBI!; NO! 'FBI!; IR!' FB{ . NY!
b6 -1
b7C -1
-
_
I-
'
.r===|_"i|W
EB1!:|:r
-FBINH0>
|<MM>
FBI!;
{ 10! cMM_i,~
com ,_ MM
FBI
BI»L
I.
929292 -
_-
- --"f> - ;f {-
Frmp: Mq ki ,-STl'E92fEN'C.
'
. -'
INSD! FBI! _'-- _
.
-
.
'
~
FBI!; DE
_
. rw
KKXHFBI!;
or
¥
.e-.'
..
.. _.
- '
-
_.
Message -"
, '
,
QI
Page
of 1
. |""""'"77""
."""'
V| ir~1so;|
FBI! .."'*."""__
- "W""-""""*
- ."""'E
'
' J'_'77"'""*"
"W "*' '"'"'
""'
"
'
'
'
"
"'
-Sent:
Wednesday, August
.1Et,i'gilPM
12:33
'
|i:il~SD»<FB~»l
i
-Subjec:t:__RE:-- GT.
M0
' _
§EN§lI!. J.E E -_UJ_U.N¢J..A§SJFl.E_l.1
.
NON-RECORD
.
,
~
Amilitary iriterrogator arid
I were
interviewing anew arrivalat
GITMO during the__e_venintj'hours
when weheard
what sounded
like thunder.'After hearing-several
"thundero|aps" we
steppedoutside the
interview roomto takea
' break
and see-if the-weather
had madeadrastic change tromJh'e
clear_si<'ies
had witnessed
we
prior
to
the start
of ourinterview. -As
we walkeddown thehallway ofthe temporary
building where
the interviewrooms were
' located,
l glancedin_an*_open- doorway/iilrher_e
new at least twoindividuals dressed
in _BDU's
standing andan .
.----inmate kneeling
on"the»floo'r-with_- lgiaforehead
on theground, The-inmate
was holding"
his nose-and -crying.
There
_was asmell amount--of
blood
on
the floornear the
_inrnate's faoeggiiigslted
the Bl;J.U-c_ladpersonnel what
had-
-1_ happened.
They/explainedthe,in'mate_
that
become-_ups*¬t-w.i'th_them
had
himselftoa'ri__dthe,- ooi,=_.'
I-had //'
threw
.I
heard
previouslyrdhat one ofth_efféFna|e rnilit_a__ry=_persorrhel
would wet
her hands
_alT|li.touol1'_the
as parfof
inmates
their psych-opstomake_th e-i ma'tes i e?e'l3"unclean"
and upsetthemfiThe inmate's
nose appeared
'to__,be
-
.bleedhig.'
of themilitary
One
personnel:_left=thetoroom
retrieve
emedicalkit forthe inmate.I sawngthingr-else to
" con'tradict'the_miIitary
personnel's'__exptanation-ofevents;
-j - _-.-- --
1eel
I.
"-
*2-1|:
Houston
Chr'stiRA
:v|s1on- orpus _l
*
_"
i
_
MC 1'
~'
_-
J
'
'
M
.
_'2.;--Ori inal
Message_-' .--'
- " ,- .'
_. Fmm= rmso! - FBI!
trio -1To:
H0!
FBI! 3. 7
156 -1 S ent:T1'|ursda,-;i'u
2004 9:59
'29
AM
sub e-
~i
:. -: .
-
_
~-
_._- ' _ i
,
*
~
r
''
t sensitive
B_U_T ur~|c:_1_Ass,||=|eo
>.
I
_
"Could Krou
please provide
ashortsummarywhat
of you
obsen.-ed. Thanks.
be ~1i
. ---Uri
inal Nessa'e----'
'
iF~m=iiH@>
=
en
b7C -1
I Sent: Frid ,Jul U9, 2004
5:50 PM
' To:|
| INSD! FBI! '
SulJject:RE:G'l'MO' _--
SENSiIlVE_B_lJT_UNQLASSlFlED
_
_
b6 _1
b2 -1..._
I:
.-
_
Iobserved
whet ma!:
have been
egg ressivetechniques
used 111:;-FBlinten'ogators.
by
Do
still
fall into what
you are
looking into?
Houston |v|s|on-
_
orpus Ct-1ristiRA
_.
_-
' '
_.
.'
_,
'
RESPONSES-59
92-
-
©
51' '2'
.Op
rs-suz {Rsv. lU-6-95!
_
' -1FEDERAL BUREAU
.
OF INVESTIGATION
- Hm f mu m
O9/O7/2OU4
" '
"5PE@ii1~Ag@Ht-i
"'""
li A_W_
FedernlrBQ£§eU
FBI!, who
entered on d ty'wit the FBI on
' 'of
Investi ation
[:::::::::: and arrived at
the Houston
Division of
the FBI,
b2
b6
b7C
Corpus Christi
Resident'Agency CCRA _on or about
01/22/1998,
and
whose
telephone
is
number
[i::::ff::::]
was
advised
ofthethe
identity of
the interviewing
Assistant Inspector
AI! and
purpose ofthe interview. SA,[:::::]then provided the following
information telephonically:
.,
-
_'
' SA.[:::::]was
assigned to an interviewing team at the
detention facility
Sep
"t e
at Guantanamo
mb
t'l
er
un
la
1t
eoveN-mb
Bay, Cuba
enr2002.
The
{GITMO!, from
ite
about
rvi g'ewin team _ .
consistedthree
of sinterviewing
people,
including
S_A aBesides
team inc ue
contract
himself, SA
linguist, whom_
military and
b6 -1
b']"C "1.
A believes
whose 1
en
ity
was contracted
SA
through the
could
not
Army
representative
whose name SA could
either. The
Army representative
was rom
recall,
not recall,
an organization
similar to'the'Air Force's Office of Special
.
an
a nd
.
-".
Investi ations'
1
AFOSI!;?an'investigative
however,entity;
$A[::::::fcould-not
not
recall the.name
of the organization. He
was certain
itwas
a'Inilitary' intelligence
entity
since
the acti'v_itie's
of his
interviewing team,
deemed by officials at
GITMO.to be law»
enforcement activities,
gathering"interviews that
representatives
from
other
most o._f-his stay at
-
were separated
from
intelligence
_ '
military intelligence
personnel and
"
government agencies
performed. For
GITMO, sA|:]
and his team performed
interviews in
the morning.
.The afternoons
and evenings were "4
,reserved.for-interviews
conducted by those who were gathering
_
in't.e.ll.-i.g'ence.
not know
of,-._$A|:921_}-aid
thespecific activities
that occurred
during t
e afternoon
and evening interviews,
4-
-
.
'
N-ea-r
'
end
theof
SA gs tour of
dut atGITMO,
about
to
two
three
weeks.before
anksgiving,
T
was
SA£f:::;j
partnered with
afemale
military intelligence
en
iste
person
b6 ~ 1
b'r'C 1'
identity SA[::::::]could not recall, but whoma have
been
awhose
military-reservist
she
since
indicated
to
5A[::::::Tthat
she
was_a probationofficer in-Los Angeles, Californ1a.J SA.[:::::]
and the
military intelligence
interviewing effort
arrivals at-GITMO, .These
.
soldier were
that focused
on a
detailed
recent group
interviews, unlike
to
an
of detainee
those he
had
-
'
»
hW Mnm- 09/0?/2004
uWashington,
Fuse 297-HQ P=132'7669-A
., 395'- "-
.,, Se/n|
DC
_{telephonicallyj
Datedicmcd N/A
'
.ifia/3:,-11RESPONSES
p
This document
contains neither
recommendations aunclusions
nor
of
the FBI. It is the pmpcrtyof the1- Bl and
is loaned
to
your agency;
q_-.II-IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII____ I_
L
'0;
'
-:
I!I
_
v.
_
HIII_IIIII
_-
_______
___________-
.
_Q
to-am aw.-. 10-e-95!
-11
i.@
-
'
29_'?-HQ Al327669-A_
b6
'1 -'b7C
-1
'
Om mm mFD§
-|
Qof
performed
evenings.
information
'
|_______=on_Q2L01.Lz9_0_4.__
with the other interviewing
team, occurred in the
was to-gain
as much
The purpose of the interviews
as possible from the detainees before they were
exposed to the general
K
detainee population.
'
_ S_A|:heard
.through
theperson
placed
incharge
of
law enforcemen _agency personnel at
GITMO
that other government
agencies were using female military
intelligence
personnel in
psychological
operations-type
activities
a
ainst the detainees.
The person
n 'harge,-whose
F9
identity
SA[::::;:]could
not
recall,
'
toldSA[:::i::Tthat
in.an
effort
todisrup
etainees
who
were
.
b6 -1
b7C -1
praying.during
interrogations,
female military
intelligence.
'
personnel would wet their-hands then
touch
the_detainee's
face,
causing
the detainee
himself unclean.
to stop praying
agency personnel
because he considered
s'b
e for law enforcement;
The person resp
to
SA
emphasized
law enforcement;
-
that
agency
personnel
were
notallows?
pgpee
thistype
ofpractice
detainees.
SA
did not witness this
_
when interviewing
to
it,
technique, or.anything-similar
tactics
or
b6
-1
1
Defense
WC *1
_ materials
-
the
of-interviewing'SA|I|did_not haveknowledge
techniques addressed in any type of Department of
policy
since
he
of
such"a
wetting
the person placed
=
never
describing
technique
.
performed on a detainee.
Sometime
of
received
a briefing
in charge of law enforcement
near
the
end
of
his
tour
at
written
agency personnel.
GITMO-
when
he
During
the
'
interview,
SA[::::;:Land
thesoldier
heard
banging
sounds
similar
to claps
o
hunder, but were perplexed
by
the sounds
-
since there had not been any indication
of rain when they
'
entered the interviewing
facility.
They_decided to exit the"
'
-facility
to investigate
the sounds.
.
AssA|:_|and
thesoldier
were
exiting
the
faci 1y,
they noticed a detainee on the floor
' - interviewing
b6
was
intelligence
soldier,
SA ? and
of_an, raqi _
. ' partnered
with the military
the soldier
were conducting- an evening interview
b6 -1
b?C ~1
detaineewho
had been appreh_ended.in Afghanistan.
-
or
policy.
SA[:::;;:]was
only
aware
of _
the hands from
s conversation with
-1
b7C
-1
another
:|
interviewing
room,
crumpled
over,
and crying..
asked the personnel in the interviewing
room,
appeared
to
may have
res
be militar
'ersonnel
based
hadhappene'd.' snI recalled
onded
that
the
detainee
on their
in
SA
all of whom
uniforms,
what
thatthemilitarypersonnel
had thrown
himself-to
the
floor.SAbserved thatthedetainee*'s
nose
appeared
to
Responses-71
l
1..
11
it
°
FD-302aRev,10-6-95!
-
_
.
2 9?. I-IQ-Al32'7669fA
--
b6 -1
_111,
;
b7C -1
Con1inuatiunofFD-302a!
_| .
|_ __
__,___ __
,Q.,_ng[o7j§z00_4
,Pag:___
__
be
bliegdng.
1'
lsiEsta
not
f§as"sir"hs.g¢'
alnyehn1§*
"sis;
the incident
that
ispu ed the account
offered
by the
mil
personnel present in the room. SA[:::::]+did
note
the
facility,
exited
The lack
-of
b6 1
b7C -1
thunder
there
was no
indication
caused
him to wonder
that w
of thunder
about
the
"asset
itary
hen
he
outside.
noises
he
had
heard.
However, since he did not observe the events that
transpired
in the other interviewing
room, and he did not
receive
other information
contradicting
the
account
of ev ents
provided by those in the room where he
found
.the detainee
bleeding, apparently from the
nose,
SP.I:|-could
not say that
what transpired
in that interview
room fell
outside U.S.
'Department
of
Justice
that
there
DOJ! policy.
was potential
for
However, SA[:::::]stated
the events'occurring in that
interview room to not fall in line with either FBI or
DOJ
policy.
"SA:
emphasized that he did notobserve
any FBI or
DOJ personnel-presentjin_the
room
where
interviewing
he observed
the bleeding detainee.
1_ ;-
-Sh[:_|-did not know
the identify
of
present ~in"the_ intervi-ewingroom
b6 -1
b7C -1
detaihee,_or the identity
of
felt
that
quer in
Slki
determining
the bleeding
the detainee; however, SA.[:::::j
their
logs maintained
the personnel.
where he observed
identities
by
-
would be possible
by the military
at GITMO.
According to
the
date, interviewing
room,
andtheidentities
of
-theinterviewers
and detainees
for each interview
were
maintai-nedby the mi li.'t_ar
at GITMO.
y
SA|:|produced
302 of;his_interview
of
however,
b6 -1
b7C -1
the Iraqi
he did not maintain
detainee
FD
=
soldier on
SA
intelligence
interviewing -teamon the eveninghe observedthe
bleedingdetainee,SA[i::::]receivéd interviewingassistance
from an Army psychologist
or psychiatrist
that this ind'vidual
was
a
SA-|:|stated
could
not-recall
his.name.
SA:
he had observedto this person;
'
-k i-
who was an officer.
major, but that he
made
a comment
about
what
SA[::::::]describedthe_interviewing
facilities
GITMO as temporary structures.
b6 -1
b7C
an
evening;
a copy.
-In addition to-the military
:]s
that
The interviewing
facility
used consisted
of
about 12 interviewing
rooms on either
a hallway.
_There were six rooms in a row on one side
of
hallway
were
and six
rooms on the other
surveillance
interviews
without
evening
when
SA|:|
rooms
that
entering
allowed
side.
Adjacent
other
persons
an interviewing
room.
at
he
of
s ide
the.
to each room
to
obs
?Durin
GIVE
'
the'
saw
thebleeding
detainee,
SA|t|was
RESPONSES-72
-
I92L
L 5.
'-
FID-302a
us-5-95!
Rev.
O
IO
29'?- I-IQ A1327669-A
u.
'
_
Cmmm
@o
b6 -1
JMof
it
occupying an
interviewing room
he observed to detainee
in an
rooms
from
b6. l
b7C1
--
' _'b7C
-1 '
'| ,.QggQ1¢2ggg
his, and
on
the
my
at one end of the faciIit§§
and"
interviewing room
two to three
same side
of the
hallway.
SA.[::::::Lreoeived
tour
of
the
a detention
facilities
not talk
about what
went on at the
.
at GIIMO;
facility with
however,
edid
the military
tour-. -Sasdid
substantive
in
nature.
personnel he
encountered during
the
not consider any of these contacts
-"
_
_.SA[::::::]noted that during
the course
of at
least one
detainee interview,
information he
but possibly
another as
well,
he
documented
received from
the detainee
about abuses
that may
'
have
occurred
in Afghanistan.
SA|UUUgUU stated
the Iraqi
that
he-interviewed the
evening he observe te bleeding detainee
was
b6 l'
b7C -1
one of
the detainees
Af hanistan
whose information
was_specific enough
about possible
to
document
in an
SA
[:fE::]documented
the
information relating topossible detainee
abuse in
a-separate case
file; one
that
was
address possible war crimes. SA[:::::] did
file number
and he
did not
agencies at
GITMO documented
E:::::]believed that
detainee abuse."
maintain a
being set
up to
the FD
302. SA
copy of
not know the case~
representatives from other law
enforcement
information regarding~possible-
".
'
_
,- ' Based on the condition
of the
facilities, and
_
-
having .
were held,
SA[:::f%Ef%%Eff
of systemic
indication
detainee
had teh
b6 -1
b7C 1
abusés_in'
FD 302.
abuse at
tt
oppor uni
tlkowa
GITMO.- SA
and-provided with
He was made aware
costing around
building an
against U.S.
th.
roug .hthe
believed the
essential needs,
of one
detainee
$100,000.00 for
explosive device
soldiers._ ,
detainees
-where
cells
detainees
such as
who
received
werewwell
fed
medical treatment.
medical treatment
an eye injury he
in Afghanistan
sustained while
intended for
_
. RESPONSES-73
use
* '
*
~
+
~
|
g
92
. ._.,_-.,_.___
;_,__
,1..._
v
'-4'°=."""
* * *'" _, .1-w. >. - I
|
' w
.
... -._ .._'
'-1;.
-. - -. 1.-->
-'_,.
.:
'
1&1
--_~
.-.
'
in-.
>-.'r.Q'
'
,@;'>
.'.,-,|
I
.
-.,
..,;_._._,_
'*:
; ..._....~
.
-.
|
.
92._
. -P:. '.:>.
'6 _.--t-.;_;.L" '-;
; T'3
I-'-..92;it'-1.
f
.92'
H
.-'
~-- ."f!"i~".-5
- .
T1
_-,
.
7;.
.r. '.'
_ .___._
__-.,"';_
,.~,_';i3l?-'
_ .--... .-2'
..-_'
.=
- -.92
~"";- -1-. 9292.,-43;:
.,. _.,__.,
. .'
.-_-=-.-_
. .=:£*-r_.._;;;-_?f
-.,:; ,-'-_t.
-= '4'.
- -_|92l__*_':
j:. .'>:..-:'
- -»
'[
. .'5.1--~.'.:;-;
'
-i:*:>.1; --W-"'
1'-'"
92
;'
'-I"
f:- _. __-:'_'..*.,'j-.1?_-E
'
r
:.=<,¥$';=:'-;
~
p
9292
J
._-
.......n
.. .-r...
Fl3_¥34U
'
HB92r.'7-29-_9
''
;_
U}1|versql.Casa
Flla
Number El;-74"'<§Z*Z'
Fig.-Id
Office
Acqu_
_%
lrmg
EvIq!.eng_a[__-a;,%¢.»n,E5.-;=i_
_._r*'
I
_1
Serial_-#_dj'0rlginaIlng_Documé
_ __: __:" ii
.
Data
Received
5;-1""':
'
70215?":/>-w
" .
_ 1
j
ii
~
. ., '" "fr
.'
Fmm.'
="92
%
N
~
-
? _..
_1
"
-
..
~ --
_7 _- ':'::
1:-'-'21 -. -";
"xi"
"
'
-=.|ff--__1:;§-;
"Y-="=*-5 * *'J'?--<b6
-1
--
' -
rI
"I
-.| |-I-I
-Q
'
, -
_
5,
'
°?§
-.
. ..-- __
-_
I'
1;
Receipt
Given El YésQfl lo_-
~- -
Fédaral
RuIéS;gI"
O!'lmir]_at=
Ptlura
.3
,-
-__
"
,
I-
-_
. 92
.'
J! . .d
" . ...;'>
-27
- 1- _§_a,.
. ._.;~.-_
..'_v.
__.}_.:92I92
....-:
:_--.'
f _--1
5-Fifi
:- 92
|L -;7:1ti .-i
1.9. _..'<. 92
. '
'~
i=1-51,-;~;;=;';&#
1
,'
I-:.%;"';-§¥1?
1..-:-.
. . .'¢
"Q;T<;:§-<1;
-7.
1-_|.
.'f$_:-"I- :7?
zs»
".._-..
._ "*5'.."
-,3,.'_
. .-..".3"
__
_.,
|_;._..-.=_..H
0
_-_1";~ ;_.;.|1§§1-7'¢&#
_- I:-'
J ,-_-_1
§j';7_,"92
J92
,_
_L _,- I_.92|-j.
11
_
- _--.~.-.f_-,.-.-;
,
-"I:-1:_..w---_¬+.
_ -_._;_.
__,_*
i
'
.'
'1-':=.'.
L'.'.*";¥..-'-",5"
,l£,'.
-- ¢v-"ti~'
- rs_ =_.
..','
;.{-._-.11-"_
':;-_,;'_>"
'
"M1,
_1 '
..
.-- ._1.-4:-_3n
., .,.
, --...-, ._;'-s
-,1 ,. . '-1=;..;:.E.'.-11*
a,-u-7,1
_.-'1
;-_.__,_"?:j,-.;-;_-if
b6 l
.
TC~;f~
-.1 g;r_=§
- O: : . .12- W
'r?i
b
'
" -,-;-;.._
,5'4 --.-..
¢~~-.
_.-:_.-_r
:_, =_
.
'
I
'1
'1
92
- .
..l';|92-H,
-1-#*5':"'5
__ IQ}--.,'>e:1._---3
-923|
....
F7__|.._|.f._. .
» ~
=.-'-;=.w=: -2*;¢
. .
- -. ,-1:4:-0'»
.§-_i.F-'-=
~- _ _.'2;;~-.,a -__.1
"
V. .
'1
5.1,: :~92
_ _ '
-; '*..:..3-'-_
.
. --1'.
I _.-_>l.an-'.
r?'92_.9292
_
_
,.
_ 1;
.-'
'-;:.u:t.'
:
:*=:
;;
_ _
Q3. ._
¢
.:92-3"
I.
1I
-1
I-|---.-*4!
..
_ ._ W. _ -- -if.-;. =..
. :_;.
;r. H'-::92
_
.
-'-9292
_ 1"
.
. - - _-.-_~;;.,:-;.*-.=;'.~
,_ -.5
.92
-.
92._-.-.---.1I._
.- _,'=
__-31..
:.
.3, ..",-_~92. -f._.,.¢~.- ,,.
_-1'.'_1
' ..
-.'
=."J_-.
:.j-.'-.1 -1
--_'
| Ja$c'|"lpti_p|_1:-_
J2-Clrigi nail"I'1§',i
c_:f_
__l
inié§rein§é§&
.
_"Z:'
,.
A-
.
-
H
= * i;>orr¢11urlicatiti|iEn:l:5§h'|g.|hTgter_ia}_}."
__j3:.
*_~'~f' I
__
|F
'
'
_|-'
.§;.. __.ai
-I
1|
"5?
-=F *7"~:&¥~p
_
.vl
'
_
.
'
.
1
-fl, :_
J
.
'_
_..1_L'
¢
- -Fleference..
.
-
.-.- .
:
."
.1 .-<4
J_
'-"2
. ?"'-H!
--.-G"I'.1.'92
-'»&
~J---T-'-3+
-r"-,
, ..
.
__~
,1-.1
,,'.'._.r=._1<[1.:92
-'
-'
'..:1-=-v-q¬.:-
_-
"I-':tle:'r_.__:T-"
_,;-<- ~,:§-'
. ___.:k__
LY. _§:.
*5."
Z.
92
-Y.-K
-f-1.
L»r;|92<M1%';
1 _
92
>
- '
-1="'~;@?',"=$&
G;a_nd-Jplyf-Dlssamiqqte
lgte alOnly
Pursuant-to
Hujé
6'
_ e!.
s"
_ {'k-.£'1 1~ ¥_
. . --- LIL.|_._'__
,.,_ .-
.
ToBaRetumed
ElYes'
E'§,_|o
I -.
R "-t_.
. 13'- TC
*
B5!
' '
I
_
.'
7»
»-..=_~
.9 Ii ,
_ ," .:i.P_;{92j'- -I -7 71__Has6iE°n mum!
'
.
-
-% _ V
"
%
_
L
c :-1;";_
1. --:.--v
.
.1" .._:921 I
. ..92.__,..
.92|
ll.
~- be
1 ,__
__:.|
K
.I
I
I .
s
:51
.-
REEPONSES.-? .l.
_*_1-_~
W T7
~
_:_I-'._L'_
__.-__._- '
.1
._. -....
- .
92
-I
_.
.¢_.__..
-__.__..92..
I _7__~
Y" .
I
I
92
b6 -1
b'Jc
-1
H // 6/
_'-~;~
_ __
J1?
92
___ _ _ _____
__ _ _
_
__
____
_
-.._--_------------.,.._---- ~
L
y
~11;
0F
{ a:zr¢¢¢_.,.¢l¢-w
-'
I 1-W
rv
b6 -"2
b7C -2
w
_ __ 7
0
r
6T
ii"
dcnm mi
b2
l
W--=-*-=
Em cf OP /11/if
1i
c,..,,..§,
¢5P§»_
r AIL
@- 5'/
@r..;p1»|?!-is-¢4:.?'~./6
=F -£4 -7 _
F
.92
PET
g
/y§mL"E.77 -ll -Z-A. -ti}
..
até .r9~?.-.r'..d?-@@ E
%.=,¢.,,"
J» W» LW H-»-E"!
M ;
*4
__/M
./=i.~.-.
A,
.
we-~L
,=¥~»-J--T5
'
92
4
92
-
_;» _',»¢@,.-.,,,@,1,.
_¢3--¢»~1'".%/
W-w" .
.61
.
/
l,
2
4
....
. ..
I zzmwn
www-
3
1
. ..
. ..-£.<¬.-'.'...5..'.
.13....
.._..¢.@..-ran
-
-...._.-_.... .
_.. _ -
--"
...
£.*=.':_*-Q
l
1
--
i
i
92
J-/. ..-@ <"*-'
/1+ ;.'7
gyu
6
_0iZ- If .£4!'.{.,
,. /Pm. /.r'.f'
/H. L -5'15"/F
-2
P
-..¢/=.. /ram
1
.7" 6-'-W
I-w-_>e..-:1-r ~I !1.'=¢M'_.&#
r% /A-M.¢:¢1'-I1
92
RESPONSES-75
.
I
92.
|un"'*ri_,*,,,;'
'
'
n
---- --~._---.- 1-.._ ,_,Z, ----- »--_
-- -.. .1.-----
92h
1
___ W_ 7'
77 W7" _ W__ :;7___
_
ii,
'
,
__ _:_ _ __ _ -;__--
92
®,
"414-_;
.
1
.
I
@
92
W
_
%
>1
<9|
.
0*
r
rr/57
/:0
/2/¢-AP
Q?-*
/'
-w-¢:»'-v
/rxgr n 7"?/;=.-.
_,
| .l»T
"
ai
¢»=*-W-.
'
F
l
/-'
r??? $77?/'
7"? /QM.
/'?Z?-J
1: /5"-try
-i§.,F5'C-&
*¢/v
_ @»r7»'-'zn-¢//1//1» /$=---~ Mia
4"¢='- F?-f-/B
I
'/ mww K»-1" r» 2;?/r'*£:.-"_7?-qosv.
I
-. fmm
@999-.»-;
Jar Z./41-.
/.eE=:-m .4/I--.
%
,_.£;isr =-=-r2?:»..A-W!
7'"
1." /1"
J1
92
I
-
KI
,
.,
.I
% 1?
/;»"»=4L+»L»<.»:@<L
W /51/=/ ~'-¢- E
1
-
H
'
,.'
/-"
.
....
.
'
.
4
92
if
92
L
92
..,..
.
..
F
___ZI¢11/¢,.;_>J...,__,¢¢e£@;-3.-_._...z?__._£-:.:.,¢|;=.:r._..
W.-. _,__..
92
:
j
1
_
..M..__. -
. _.
"
_ _..
1
7
_ I
- .-...J-._-___.92__.__..._..-._.-....4._-..-.-~_..-.__p»....-.
-. .- -...-_....J-92__
4::-_i-_..._-...-1% .-_-92._-7~_.__<_..-1.
¢; -
* ____
W
a
92
@
52¢. of
n/H» ./75514?
I-V. -'1I.
<'3°
-F? *'-P
mn-¬=-=-*92"/ n 7" ,P- »F_ 1 -"*""-
-=2
/I//////'
."
fl
?%
L
I Q;
J -r/5%»,pa
/M.-:w.=»4-'1
/5,»--,;~_,==..-6-.,,
':H"'
I __/z_M~
am? 6/J*"_/!1'2E""_"
av-L7. ;$5
r
//7.4 //./7'1
,
l P1/1?-.=r_
M-» /awnmnt-fr
-0'9
M7
0:?
.
%
_
~
/.=v,%zw *'J--1-»
~
I -",. <
m/..,./#1-+ /r;'1-mmf.
..
m
<-/I.¢w ».'F.7 /1?? /:*=- ~¢-?¥"E""'
.//1!/?r. ..
<. -Fer-ea.-_
.
"
I
/I-'
.62,
. .-.t.c.m'f,..
..
-_
ia
/4'1?
.. .. I
.In
I
F
E
E
_".._ __,@'¢1,za_-.,2~1:u-¢_;:*'_-'a=.."3:-1":
¢"¢~l?.¢':
7?7@*%_
@
;-.}Zi,<¢<?§..f'I1-.L&
%
i}-;,*,,,¢- %_,
__
.<?f'!<'/.-
of
I
1/4*L".j,,,,.
..
L4 ./? ¥¬'#1
i
§ }, ,¢=.=rm~
A ;-.npm ,w- -I
mr" Orw92
Mm
.,6 .¢¢.¢-¢.-5-4'?"
I?! z_E»=1-/I
-W5 "17/ F"~
I
92
i
.-,
.6'f
/m - II
.r; ,
Y
VI
1-P1
'
.
RESPONSES-?7
z
1F
8
.
-92
%'
7?"
l92N
'
-J
.
-/
'
'
z
Y
//*f > 77.%%3"%519*?»
~. . /J// if .//~~f L-7»
_!
/gw
I
_ _P¢/ti/FRI ,
.
@ /fiiv/r-Lomw Mk ea:/--i fnmr 7%?
¢-"
-,r =~"
1 /Z6/-='
¢' %i'¢»¢-@~@.6?$'>-fe-1*-=*?>'
/4 V//-=i~=-»-»*--A?- f m / rfrfw-=rr/c.
@ 6 =7?=4r'/5? 1%-='=
Auwf m/#4 /4'5 - I #1-~
I45? -
I
,| iL~!_
i
.:.
___ _ iii .
_ . ____
, ,_
ig;
*1-_
_L
I
5
I
. .§.. . -...
1.
_
--
-_
._.--.-......
92
s92
|
A
Mi
W
E
i
:
RES PONSES-78 '
j
i
i
Ti
l
i
1
7T
'g*q
Questions
Concerning
Actigities
at_G_uantanamo
Bay,Quba,_LGTMO1
.-/1!
/2!
Describeyourrole at GTMO andtheapproximate
timeframe.
If a memberof aninterviewteam,pleaseexplaintherolesof themembers
which
comprised
yourinterview
team.
As
/3%
Describeanyaggressive
treatment,
interrogatioris
or interviewtechniques
employedon
detainees
at GTMO, whichyouwitnessed
or areawareof, whichwasnotconsistent
with
FBI or DOJ policy,/guidelines?
What,
if
any,wasyourunderstanding
ofDepartment
ofDefense
authorigation
"forthe
permitted
use
of harshfaggressive
interrogation
techniques?
howyoubecame
aware
ofDODauthorized
techniques.
_
t/ HoDescribe
,/f o
,
In youropinion,wastheaggressive
treatment,
interrogations
or interviewtechniques
employed
ondetainees
atGTMO,whichyouwitnessed
orareawareof,consistent
or ~
inconsistent
withyourunderstanding
of DODauthorized
activity?If inconsistent,
how? Identifyanyotherindividuals
whowitnessed
thisactivity.
-/7!
./8!
Do youknowtheidentityof eitherthedetainee
or theDOD einployeefcontractor,
andthe
approximate
datetheincidentoccurred?
It youwereaware
ofanytreatment,
interrogatioii
orinterview
techniques
employed
at
GTMO which wasinconsistent
withFBUDOI policyandDOD authorized
techniques,
didyoudocument
orreportit toanyone?
If so,howandto
whom didyour
reportyourconcerns ?
0/
to!
-
Pleaseidentifywheretheinterviews
occurred
at
GTMO which youbelievemayhave
beencontraryto policyor authorized
techniques.
Didyouhaveanysubstantive
contact
withMilitaryPoliceorother
U.S.
government
personnel
at GTMO regarding
detaj1iee's
condition
or treatment?Describe.
11!
Describeanyallegations
of misconduct
or mistreatment
by US. personnel
broughtto
yourattentionby interviewees
or others ?
'-
12!
Areyouin possession
of anypictures,
video,audio,notesorotherdocumentation
which
depicts
or describes
aggressive
treatment,
interrogations
orinterview
techniques
employedon detainees
at
GTMO?
Are youawareof anyoneelsewho is in possession
of
such items?
-
RESPONSES-79
_
_
13! D0 y0u have any
additional infdrmation
relating the
to treatment
of detainees
at GTMO
_whi eh shouldbe broughtfo ourattention?
P
RESPONSES-80
_
_ ____
llI
L
Positive
Response
Number 8
_.0
-c
,
l
.'
.
~
v
Q
.
1 Wee/g1§???i7
'
_{Rev.01-31
2003}
_I
.-
f .
~
~|=eoe|=uu_
B_'UFlE.AU
wives-rncgifneou
'
O F
.a
1
'
. IMMEDIATE"
-'
'-.
-~<92£¢¬*
§_92
F~}
6-.
Precedence:
;//agk
Q
Date:
/09/2004
JU0
ta
'
."
-~
To;'Counterterrorism
_a
Jy¥
CK ¢a
Inspection' /EP " ¢" Att >
I'
l"
.4,,»
.I
..
be *1
squad
3
_
_
- Contact:B14
'
I Eryn"
_
__,
,
|
Approved By-
'
'
h?C~1 _
b6_1
_ ..'
'1;-><
C;
Roo
meat:
_
'_
_b?c
__1i&
From:Anchorage_
..-»"
-
.
_ *
'
-3
-§~*f§
-
=b2-1
_
'
-
.11-
.
.'
_
INSPECTION
SPECIAL
.
_
..
iPending]
I
_
.--
came, _
_fN
.
'I i_tle:
-COUNTERTERROR-ISM
DIVISION,
. .
',
-or--awe .,
.T-M
Case
ID'
# :u297
_ HQrAl327669-A"'i
.
-é?
-
_
INQUIRY
.-
.-
._
.
.
./'
,. Synopsis: To provide responseto eemail from steven C._
MeGraw. Inspection.Division
on 0?/09/2004.
Details:_
The purpose of this electronic
provide
a
response
to
an e-mail
f
.
J5
C. McGraw.
. I
-.
Writer,Anchorage
Field--Of
Special ite
"
|:]
-
case_agegt
on the
"Portland-7"
GTMO aor
period-of
Division,
counterterrorism-
_'-
office
Writer
would
into
to
fingers
the
shack,at
from physical
and injuries
cause
assignment
at
the
time.
Camp Xray,
injuries
to his face.
the detainee
to include
possible
When writer
of the detainee'sinjuries,
writer
appeared
broken-
inquired
learned
as to
'
the
'
that
detainee had recently exhibited non eompliance with
a
prison
guard,.and that the rapid reaction team was brought_in to
bring the detainee into compliance.
Writer learned.that
no
Bureau
employees
were involved-in
above incident.
ff
I
.
i
.-
_
add that when the detainee was
brought
the interview
suffer
of
bee
-1
,
approximately 3e4 days and returned_to
his
i
be,-1
detainee
ihqestigationg
While at GIMO,1writer-observed
no
apparently
improper aggressive'treatmentof detaineesme writer visited
Portland
_
.
Agent|:]
briefly visi-ted etmoin o2,-'2-»oo2to. debrief
a
'as
FISA
_
communication is to
from Steven
Inspection Division on 07/D9/2004.
.'
RESPONSES-81
II
'
_"
-
-
_
_
_
_
_Ii
ii -i
iQT
' -n,
92
FD-302
..
' ,
ll
I
or or
[Rem 10-E-95}
I
'
'
l
. _1_
-
¢ FEDERAL
BUREAU OF
INVESTIGATION
'
- Dnteofwnnscripiiun
'
a- I - -| gl
0950952004
-See-C-i-11. ..£nter_ed
» 5sen.1:.. .99".
D1~.1'.t.y...
. .E.<2P..
eep h
one
was i i1 adv'sed
e
'
#9
wener interviewing
|i '-_"
oftn
Off-iCiEll
92
b6 _identity of the
SLIPEIVLSOIY-SPEClal
Agent{SSA%and
b2 _
-.
cu-rrentl assi
MC_that
ned to
the Anchorage
Division, office
the interview concerned" ascertainingany information
- possessedpertaining
to the
treatment and
conditions of
'
d"eta-inees at
Guantanamo Bay,
Cuba GTMO!.
|:| thereafter
provided the
traveled to
b6 detainee
b?C -
following information:
'
'
,GTMO_in FebruarY_2002,
identified as]
case specific
.
_J
W
information on
the*"Port land 7"
to debrief
a
regarding
Counterterrorism
momatter. Qwas not a member
of any
interview team.
As a
HF "Co-case
gen of the Portland 7 case, |::|went to
the sole
purpose of
- case.
conducting one
. -'
. The
to that
-"
interview was
shack used
GTMO for
interview relating
for conducting
"Dog Cages" in Cam
conducted in
_a make shift
-interviews, located
X-Ray. When the detainee
plywood
adjacent to
the '
was brought in -for
|- - the interview, Ijobservectthe detainee
had- black
a'
eye,
-- facial
cuts- around
b6 -1
were taped.
1°70 "1 the effect
_
had
done
| name:
the
nose
area,
and his
fingers on
up. The
-detainee, who
spoke English,
"they", motioning
to the Military Police
this to
him.
A
Colonel in
charge of
both hands
said" words-to
MP! guards,
the MPs,~whose
.
could not recall, advised that the detainee's
injuries were
sustained in
ascuffle
due to the detainee.
. becoming
K1011".-CiOI Clplia1'1t
had toandbe bought into compliance
by a
Rapid Response Team.
The.
detainee also
had acast
on one of his
ankles which
was for -an injury
sustained priorto
the detain_ee s
arrival at
I '
GTMO. -
did
.,
' '
not have
any substantial
dealing with
any
- MP5,
other military
personnel, Department
of Defense
DOD!
civilians, or
any other
contr ctors
at GMTO regarding detainees-
b5 '1
condition and
treatment. did
WC -1
not observe
any aggressive
4
or improper
handling, treatment
or techniques
any of "the detainees
inconsistent with
FBI or
Justice" DOJ!
policy
what type
of harsh
gL1ideline3.- L:
or a
used by. anyone on
Department of
-
had nounderstanding of
ressive interrogation
techniques were
authorizedDOD.
by C did not
ask anyone
what the
DOD
- lrrvcstigationon DBLQB/200_ __Q-,____ tele:phoni,cal],y_} _
no 297;H,O;l&_1_'
__{ieli_b
*1 Dat:d1
32was-A'
g g
i-6
____
-_ .
w 5s,_92|i -iii ;-mgi W,-1 _
__
__
09 092 04
-7 RESPO-*N_$ES 82%
This document
contains neither
recommendations
conclusions
nocr
the
of FBI.It is the pr pulfy
of theFBI andis loaned
to youragency;
-
77 77
'
77
1
I.
___
.
92
|
J
~
Fbéma bul
Ci!
_
_ :!
=' -.
~'29":-so-A1321ss9-A
..
'
'
- --
I
--
b7C--1_-
ewes»-are-sozortt _,_,,
'
_
;§0n'_Q&LQ&L2_0,0i
2 __
policies wara §éiE51n1a§ to the treatnenr"of detainees
as
he-
~
-"
thoughtwas
it beyond
the scope
of hisduty. Since[:::::]was
I
of.
unaware of what-DOD policies were_pertaining to
the treatment
detainees, he was unable to state whether any aggressive
treatment, interrogations
or interview
techniques employed, in _b6_1
his opinion,
were inc0nsistenE:fEE&:iny
DODbeing
policy.
Other
than
bW;_1
"the overall
conditions, which
described as
harsh,
and without
air
conditioning,
including U.S.
but which
military_personnel were
everyone there,
subjected to,
he
did
not
_witness,
or
become
awareany
of,GTMO
unduly"
harsh
treatment.
;| ._
attributed the overall conditions at
in February.2UO , as
being-due to
stages,
the operation
'
.
being in
it s relatively
-_"'
early -
', .;
.
'
' _
1
.|:|w'as
not aware
of any
allegations
mistreatment
ofnot. _ .
of detaineesma_e against
any U.S.personnel; [:::::]did
' have
any pictures,
video, notes or
any
b6-1 documentation
which
depicted
- WC 1 treatment,
interrogations or
.
other
type
of '
' '
or described any aggressive
~u
interview techniques
employed on
detainees atGTM0.Y[::::::]was not
aware of_anyone
else in I
ossession
of,
or the
existence of",
any such
items. ' ' '
-
[E:::::]did nothave any
additional information
relating_to the.
treatment or
detainees at
GTMO.
.
92
o.
-RESPONSES-83
_
- ---IIIIIIIIIIIIiIIIIIIIIIIIIII-IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
-.
__
92
'
77
92
W __*,.__'
_ ;_
..
., ..
-m-a-som.=v.s;:-ay!
_1______
_ _ _____7'_~
J
__
.
92
1
M
.. *-':"'_"'-;.""*?
'
- __ 92"'
.
_
-"
.
H
. -.1
..-~'.-,_
;'-":".@,r
92Universal
Case
Fllé
Num5§r_.-5/9-'-Y
.
L FmOffice
AcquIrhi'g
W
"M
_.E_Vi!i'iB;T1 §e7
V.{Mseriéiiii-drIgiq_atl '§'E!§Eu;
L'%
§;if""
VADaie
n=¢eiv@¢1§,+_.gz2go+i2f:2;@»~54ff
V
92
-1
_'.;.;»_-.-'_,'.--.'_~<
--
92
.¢ ,
Ii..
.,___.
A-'
. .-:j-Jid lamg
iiicbnf
buaugi---»
T- 1¥
- . _{T92§dr'aE;spf
wmn- 7*
"*
-
_
*___
J by
{ 'E';
H
i*?i" f*"
W.
92
'-1?-.'"*{Name=1
R' .
£ ;n wial a="1lJ"
-.,
.
-'
L i'*@'%§é?
5
¢v4'r~§¢*
u .3
-- - "ally?-:__=-""f'§
'
-___
" H.
3_
. .- .
" Héceipf-"Given:
'*
~"
___
_ -?.:::'?;;: -'.'§,;:;i:L?;:i;;_>
.';=:--.
_~1=_"
F1.-,'
;
: _->j;."§_,,'?-5-.'§1
:2
- :'_
_'..
. '3_'T _= ;.__
b6
-1
b7C -1
92
.5tan.é§4umhAa!*;5=i¬®i.5=§minatef
lily~BI1
»"
"L1;
- -'
-
-" ,.
10'
3e%6'
'iE§B§%
eJ-é1@B I§§ i5£¥6*ih?L é¥Er6cadur@@.-.'. I.Liii-@F=?Yi;a}d§ Y~*§?1=??I:-F;-fffgr-'-;'@"3¥. =T
~
v
==
.'
'-5;
'
.Z'E.=I:l'_'*:'
. -'P,7
"73-"<'1."_~
§T l;.'=:'1.'i:="':'7
j- I
J
Ir
. ;_
l¢*~
h_
Fvp
w-
4.
_
.
Y
1
..-
92
92
'@
'-"
, ..
_,
;_
aw
~= ;:;:.
-
.-"
-
5
- . ;>- =¢Y92;~ . K1-._'
__-.'.+.
__.H
11"}
_-
HeIarenoe:'i£1"'11;§3-F¢£?
7.
$:@;'=;%
.=e
_r.
_--p -.
- - ,|-.-~.u%1=1
YF - ..--=
~ -'"7
. 1- _-,-;-_. -- -_...:__i-3:?
-2,,-._-.;_
-_--_-.-_,~---.- _{ .-X-'-_
_;_I-_
--,_..
-,.,D_-;e': s_ §:'r1j5t_J_o|'ii§
of'_=ll
g,
.
g '_'
*;"- I i'
:
_'
4
'
.
92
_
.'
.
I
.
'
.
b6 -1
- '92."
b':'C
-1
J
l
1 .
92l .
n
I92
__
'
92.92-
;92H
.:
Jw
,
_
"I
_;
l
_._
.
__->...
Vi
__ __
_7 ___ _ __
--:14..--,.-
n
-w.
*92
?
1
»
,. -.' .
RESPONSE5 84
I
L1
'
@~/F/:>~
Wm§ @$92r**9l
92. p-
if
_ E1-ca.»,4,-
P5
___?,_ _;
_;
"T
__W_,_ _
___;~
N W §Q¢£-1~$r<-_
j
%@<:---<-1+ *_
A
H #5; W2?
~
2%-f;
;
_
we
;
1;
92
Q52-~~¢<r/&~=;>
w=W~w~~ _ 1
b
4
b7C
1:>7D
* >¬ §,7Q=/5%'-¬4"§ §Q
§i:l
{ +§ % w hM
_
Q
b7E
12%-J]
* / _? '7?
;¢
j ;-é».
~<;*~If
~
. ? /W" C-at
{mé-
__
-
{WYK
§* *L_
+
'I»?'-:;z/-»--~>-;»=1~
{=~K?
1-_K?? »»
~+
____7 7__'__/U56_____-__,__,
_ TW,Q, __
7*?!
ll
9 ¬?i~7F §..¥@
52-JAc¢,%
I Q@;~..~ >vi
___3f=~<f
%> w@~% ?
;@.!/d?W
Q; :,____ i - ___
"jj"_f""
;
,_
_
"; =
' 1
_ ,7,
_
, ;;_,~
H __
. ,_....-._....,,.__.-__.,,._,___,,_,__.......__
, ______..,,
____,__,_,,,__
_
_
I:-A
__;_ __
,
__ -___~
_- _ _'
_ _ __
f
.
-_
i
Positive
Response
Number9
1.L;» .?
Q ,L
n',
>6 f -SS u
bi- C 1
.s1ck
,
L
_
_
-
not interviewéd.
He out
is on
extended
leave due to medlcal 11111655.. -
"
- - _Atta_c11_edi_s
e_-mail
his angidocumentation.
I
_
L-,
1
. if
__._!
r, _.
.
/'
4.5/
4'
,1. _.
,,.'_.
/
,'
-.1
_/ __.-'
.»'
1
.
RESPONSES*86
-'
@-
./'
'
..
_
_
.._
.
' w
C
t
' Message
92_-7! - n
|i
l"
"W"
QPage
'_?
| |nso!
FBI! *b7C
ha_11" """*
.""' *" ';""'
'
~"
W
'*
To: lR! FBl!
' '
Subject:GTMO
RE: ' - -
" --
I
I of
I
t-
* f" '""
- .1
.;_:_-
* '
lri._,;?_Yf!.=_I5"-_i.".¥'.
1
OK, thats
a positilie
response.
leftI you
avoice
mail.
Can you emaillme
the EC
you did?
Thanks.
'
----Ori
lnal
Messa
e---- -
F-'~=m=lil<1Rn0=B11
e3,6_1 '
Sent: Frida Jul 09 2004 3:10
PM ' bqc _1
10:: ms»
Subject: GTMO
tat
-
__
er
-!
m
As you may be -aware, lwasjn GTMO and l did observe aggressiveinterrogation practicesand as
a
"
Behavioral AnalysisAdvisor on
interrogation techniques wasaware of extreme interrogation techniques -
.-:=. that
were planned
end implemented
against certain
detainees. '
' -'
_
.These eventswere
summarized in_
memos
and
anEC
written by
myself and mycolleagues between
Oct. .
- and
May of-2002.
Ihave been
discussing
a2&1 "
._
these eventswith GC
Valerie
' _
Caproni. f
r-
.
_--
,_
s rll s.0,»i
B%.r~_I.cLa§§_lEl.ED_
_
¢;Ko,
of
47'
.
-_ _
Y/FM
40.J -<"N
'
/J o-J"
_e
i" CI*P> 9
Lie
92
I
.-
. .'
~ -u
n
-
-.
t""92:- -.-
'
{Remus-2 -Zing!
K0
"'H l '§
HJT'r'1':I-'#5:""
"92: Hrr>-1a!n*~
f"".,92I 92
-3´l
.'r:;,,;,,
,_
.1;_. L,¢_r=:a*;_H .3:-L
_
v a_ !3»: ...
.._,
;-:.e"-"
}-*'-=-=
I'92.|l+.
r__-;;,.1¢_,~
3;..-.1
4,_f,$
-;;3;,-5"
T51,
_
rb
¢ ...»..;~'
.. E':+
"§=- =.~
ha
a
;J,~:'f1~£'l'*+'-:
_,£92_f
_r-=2
.» - -1.
an¢:"_Ji}£J;;;:_:fL:,¥;J%~'~E
-.I-..>-.f.~_:
,4
éEH_1g5
*~
*e~e
~ ~-*~
'_
we» *§ "WIM
=+»;.E §:=
_F
»~
1 we
_;;§
=-1!»;-FJFf;?24 -r;-if»
P35,
:= =~'--£1-~,;.~.r_j
--r.
.:; '
._'**¢x.r
.qre,
'
.1.-.-.-0»
P
"*1 ... fr , *=r?§L§=%1e:*:"
- m; fn92.;!
,__,__j£- :;~
'3"
1 ~1-|_1
Q",
_A
Precedence
. ROU_.r:-=_ms
2*-.,1 ;,1 §;;:;1;*_-;_»§.,,~;g§:
§ji%,§%,,,
em" »-=r;.,
To
.
Counterterr
-
*"W%§%§%%1§*?§¬§'
Raymond
5
MEY

1?-_~.
-F ?§¬.e'!§¥".'%'£;i92=*
"
J : HP
'3-EE§
;:=;""l"qJ.1q;.n'
ow
:>'-¢__-__
"'l1;Hz
~5r;,|_,;_, ,. =,».. f*s -:2*'r,<v=
~'»*'
-34
* .51:
is*1-9292
1*:~9
Z-1"
1*
.'§§¢
='.1*aj,P
.u=?1?
"'1,-J:
-.rr~5~
ET
- . 5}=r_ -
'
*+
we
11-*
**"~5
* ¢']"{:
'=n="=:"r"L§Z3
" -¢"92"
i -.3
1;1*'§3.~.,:,
»'=
§3
; _;-11%;
we-1
=-9
;£.!'92.L;
-
r*"5; ,;.§_~,il-..g;_;E;;-¢=§¢,,,,~r--~32
-., Bowman,
E § ;~
<;¢%,;F;~§.u
General
Cou
2
***"%="r5* ":~a'Ȣ:~
9 *;"t- .+_'=?
*"3=*"
:3""
$"*~* for
" ?"*
NEHZZLDHBI
'"?
~=-1*
5-_"~¬l1
- ?»
F" '1.-~:.-=¢:,.
.- r i*Counsel
I-r»§_.E.¬"
'1»?!-¢1
Q,._¢u¢t1.~=-..*=¥Jg»:92
"" ..r---P1
-:1 _-31:
: "'
gig ,5.
"'
**at '.=$;Z1§§
1.1;
'
fa
f ?_
*5
g "§
Z"~5~
**
~*-*5
'1
§?.**
my :-I*19**MisEsq-ua
rai¬l=*3"*
M1a.m:|.
_»'§E*
-b-_
1 =,, ;,+,~3I;,
um
G;
§=,~§'#$';
ih
ector
gbpa-rh$§
§ , -,_{9
* %*;;"*"
-'1
3:1-Tum.
»=¢T.._~.1'-..,_
¢ '1
=;o,§i§
iiat""$1nlu_..»
~¥
; 3z4-<
e-.
E*1~W¥*"-.1;<
C Frank
F191l11ZZ11
" ,~
ll;J$.
..:'f
1! n , ~§:i
__rgv__=¬;'*»92- "E ~13-1=+
_l
*1'
""92;-1-r
-w.L_
ff"
M
b
-1
FI.'Oi'|12
. CIRG
I
'
_ Beh-avloral
Analysls
Unlt
BAU}
'
b6
_f*1
bC *1-
.
Contact
SSA
Approved
By:
wlley
.-
_
_
l
Stephen
R
Battle Frankie
Case.ID
#1:{U} 26-SA-MM
99102,} Pend:.ng!
19¢
. Title:
{U}
-
~' '
GTMO IN I EL
GUANTANAMO
_oo
MIAMI
.MAJOR
~
CASE
BAY
CUBA
188
51'{'11Opsis_:I
U! To document
BAU
El.SSJ_5tElI1C.'E
and challenges
TDY assignment 1n Guantanamo Bay G'I MO}
'3»
.7*.
-during
-..ia.r_é¢.1:~;;
.%VHu%$92E%%E
-,1,
-"~'.".- r,-~;~"-:-wQ
Enoloeure s!
_ regarding
issues
1
[U]
2.
_
:'
U!
Enclosed
encountered
.-
documents provide
encountered
by
SSAs|
adds.
|and
:|_n GTMO
_
,~
~n*"~
Referral/Dlrect
[DOD]
P-§Zf§.=i§'i.§';%3;i3@liE
t-_§;_g,_§§
;1_::;1a;a&j;
1:
mo
211B:,:y";g§:f
j§;§;1»?a¥
E|RI'[D.TIO
w @=H= %¥li¥i+z5
'5
1*»...q,,..M,,_,,,.,.
..
.
IS_§fUlI¬EI;AE;
EX
jP§%'§I i 11117§A
$51
5IPm
.H
OPCA-10
R-3-95] ' ' -
l
h_._..__._.:._..._.
in
92 51
l FEDERAL
' XXXXXX
B_T_tREAU
11~WE_sT1GnT10r~r
OF
" FOIPA
-
....__._._..._......s.._.;_-.
.-
.
.
DELETED PAGEJNFORMATION
SEEET
_locationin thele. Oneor
more of thefollowing statements,
where
indicated,
- '
Pagelfs! Iwithheld
entirely at
this
.explain
this deletion.
'_ ' ' _
indicated
El. Deletions were madepursuant to Ithe
exemptions
release to
you.
'
'
'
I ' M-
_.
Section S52
.
cl om!
helow with
no segregable
material availahlelfor
'
."
__
'
_
' Section5522 I
E1 o>o'>oo
-
' '
C1 o-1 ! -
U i! !
cbmtca
_;_ t_§_-_r
' '
El
"U
III wow!
.
U bl !EF!
U b![_6!__ 1
06 !
' U K1015!
_U 0JJ 9!
.-
00 ! '
El
1:. 00 ! '
U 01! !'
00 !
U. K! !
bi 'J E!
E1 0:->'<4>
_
' E! E1! ! .
1:1 b! ! B!.
EI moi E El
&#
-
U 053 !
.
EE
_
-cl new
_Information pertained
lgubjeet
your
of ,
onlyto
11 third
party
with no
referencethto
e b'ect
J y of 0111'
_request
F
_orthe
' |:|
' requestislistediinthe
titleonly.
_
_._
ents werereferred to that agency es!
El Documents
originated
with
anotherGovernment agenoy
Theseies!._
tlocum
' for
review and
direct response
to you. '
.
-
..
_ _
. .
- '
'.Pages
infonnn on fnmished
another
Governnlent a.gency
willhe advised
i-es!. the"F'
by " to the releasability
of thisinfonnation following
on: consultation
with theother
agency ies!.
- eternsination
" '_Page 's!
withhe1d'ines1nu[:h
n nal release
_d
as
' -'
dispositi'on_ats1aterdate.._ __
has notbeen made.
-Youwill
be
_,
_
_- Pages were considered
not
relesse
forthey
asduplicatiwe Of
'
.'-Page s!
withheld for the following reason s!:
_
I
advised as
to the
M-£5 h|o.e2-1&
_
"'
The following
number
t5's="u.§@a
regarcling
forreference
these- Ipages:
I I
- ' - __
_Ro1szTrv¬ tlQo'f>_q;.45e zyumzé-e
t>o,Qu,M9,;lT
l_-sh3,;: Qt;
.
II.
" ;[£'¬$|i
P§G¬5.?Q_'_t"q4'
0v92/595
I
_X Deleted Page s_! X
X" No Duplication Fee _X
_
X forthis
page 'X _
JDDLXXX
XXXXXX
FBUDOI
DPCA-ll! - 2-3-915! - '
- -._
l_
_
P-
-l
-' JQQGDCX-
_.
- FEDERAL
ntnznao OF
INVESTIGATION
."
--
.
'- Form
'
.DELETED PAGE INFORMATION
sneer
- cation
in
the le. Oneor"more
of
the following
statements, where
indicated,
' Page
withheld
s!
entirely
at this
Io
.explain
' El
this deletion.
._ '
Itions
Deletions were
roade pursuant
to
the exemp
release toyou. _
't'
indicated with
below
no
segregable" available
material for
l
_'
_'
"
_'S_ection
.
552
_
_so
b! ! A!
U d! !
ci taxman ,
E01 !
*_--5011 ! ~
io
_
c1»>r2!e -
i o @165 -
Section
"11 o1t?! c>
.El
' 1:1
El b! !
»"
00 !
El k! !
b! ! E!
me;
U £! !
"ff o
U. b! !
III out t
_
l1:1 t1=!c2>:'j
o fb! !' D!
91;,-
552a -
El -oats!
nee!
cl note!
U- KJU!
-E{b! ' !'-_.4|
.
ief withno rerence
I to
thesubject
yourjequest
of
subject
or'tl_1
your
of
'Information
El
pertained
onlytoathird
' teqnest'i_slistedinthetitleonly.'
_ '_'
~_ _
V92U Documentswith another
ts werereferredto
that
Govemment agenc
'Iies!.
l1ese'doc|Jmen
_ sigencyfies!.
-
for
review and direct
response
to
you.
_'
.
T
ies!.
rm;
willbe advised
by no
FBIas.
Gmtenziment
_ agency
_
I - _ I .'
PFigs? contain
-information
.
--
-
consultation
the
to thereleasability this
of information followingour
_
_ with
other agency ies!_
__
'
_Page
'
wit]:|h_eId
s!
inasniuch
as
al nalrelease'_deter1nin_ati
_ made. L-You
on has
not heen
be advised
mtothe
' .disposition at alater date.'
Vit
u
i
L
_i
. .
_be7j4mee§§PAr;és-|1
_Pages.were"
considered
notfor
release
-as they
are duplicatisfe
of _
7 ___
JPagefs} withheld
for
the following :reason
'
s!:'
mi
_____
'The
H.followingnumher
istobe-used
for reference
regaiding
these
pages?
VV
" _s
_i
.
iact!/Lespa/users
PIf66 $ i.5-;|lI!'J
mmve
ssesuvaoem E1
ra bqnv-'¢e-or
1>
'_De1eted Page
- s!
X- No Duplication Fee'
for this
page
_
iotxéoot
.;=ooot'§ot
-Fennel
E-.-T.
.
OPCA-20
-- 2-3-sis!
-
_
__}
e
l'
.
ICXXICXX
- FEDERAL,
BUREAU
on INVESTIGATION
'
FOIPA
'
-
.
.
DELETED
PAGEINFORMATION
_SHEE'_I -
atthis
location
inthefile.One
orrnore
ofthe
foliowilig
statements,
otrhere
indicated
h
'
Page s!withheldentirely
-
_'
explain
this deletion.
'
_
VDDeletions
were
roads
pursuant
to.Lh
e ex
pemtions
. withnosegregable
indicated
he1ow'
material
available
for
releaseto you.
'_
.
I
Q-
_
Siection
552
'
ti coo!
552a
Section
~
ti
lCI bio! H
i orMai i
U 03 !
b! ! A!
b!f7! B!
*
D
U
t
U
-i! !'
Elloo!
00.h!
b! !{C!
o>c?>~<D>
tr b! ?!EEJ
-1:|
' __
_
El b! _7J F!
E1
60 !
1:1 moo!
El. b! !
<1<>t4i
-1:1
El b! ! '
"El
1:1{b! _6!.
..-
.' .
'
El Inforniation
pertained
y
p
onlto_a
"
F
El 010 9!
_ _
clots:
1: _ k! !
arty
with
noreference
tothesubject
ofyo1.u'_request
oriiie
request
isIistedin1_:]1etitleon1y.j
_ _
.
_
92-_
1 El- £!£7! _.
.-
subjectof your
.
E1
'forreview_and
direct
response
to-you-
-
tswerereferred
tothatagency es!
originated
with
another
Govemmen-t
agem:':y
These
docunien
ies}.
" 'Documents
Pages
contain
information
filmished
another
Government
agency
'
'
to thereleasabilityof
this"information
following
ourconsultation
with
the
:
l
ies!:
You
will
headvisedby
ti1e'F
asa _
other agency es!.
'
%_
l on.has
notheen
made.
You
Pag'e
wifoheldinasmucll
s!
asa nalre1ease'_detertoinati
i
ifif
dispositionat a later date
Li
A
_=_
'Pagentithheld
s! forthefollowing
1'BH30I1
_____ _______-_:_
]I'
I
" H-_'1;]2e
following
number
tobeitsed
forreference
regarding
these pages:_ I
V
beadvised
asto't1
be'f,m~ees-ime
not
considered
forrelease
asthey
aredupiicative
of__
_5.... Pageswere
s
_
__
-
_
_
-Po-£LTn/E
R-e.$_EU_tJ~§Q
aivmate i " V1>*>$v/*92'1w
Es
Cztes an/ses
Pass:
H1- :16]
1- .
X '.Deleted
P_age
X
s}
X No Duplication Fee _X
X
for this page
'_X
"
,,,._._.7
. _ _.'."_
..._.....
.-3.. . ._..._. ,.-.. _ ._...._... :;.......;:..._e.........-__e
..._ _._.._................_...-..._
.....;.
_,_
'_
92 _
QPCA-20112-3-95!
"7
'
I'
'
'
It -
_
XFOOQXX
XXXJDLX
- FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
'
JDELETED PAGEINFORMATIONs1=1EE_T
.
_%
'-'
FOIPA
- le.One
re of thefollowing
statements,
whereiridieated,
Pagefs!
veithheld
entirely
atthis
location
in
the
ormo
.I
this deletion.
expam'
_'
"
'_
I tothee_x_etnptions'indi
eated'
below
withnosegregable
material
available
for
E] Deletions
we1 e_'nia:1e
pursuant
_release
to you
1seem552 _" »
"U
-..
-
b! !
El '{b! !
er use!
_
U
III
1'
E
Section
b! ! A!
E1 011 !
-b![7! B!
III 09
-E !
'
E3 fbJ ! C!
__
_ ?_[J
_
552a
-
1: 00 !
l E El
00 !
b><'o@>_
t in a»1o>'c;E!-
n
1:1vets!
_
-I
. _
_1:1 b! ?! F!-
U
|.
1 moss:
-
E3 b! J
-
13 W5!
.11 mtg!
D
!! !
k! !
In _ k! !
E
1, t1.<kJé1>
El 013 !
with
no_reference
ofyourrequest
or subject
ofyour
u .EI Information
pertained
only
toa -'
party
_ _ tothesubj-eet
'
Ieqne-stis]istedin 1etit1eon1y.'
- -_
_ _
1:|
Documents
originated.
withanotlje
- 1:Gevemment
agencyThese
ies!.
tloenments
were
referred
tothat
ageney
'forreview
anddirect
response
toyou.
_
_
_
e
as-orm
ation
sgsneynes!.
by
t11e'FB
as.
Pages
eontajn
_furnished
Iby I _I another
_ Governnaent
_ You
_sinbeadvised
- to thereleasahility
ofthisinformation
following
ourconsultation
withtheotheragency es}.
n'_Page s!'withh
elcl'inasmuch
asa nalreleasedetemiination
hasnotbeenmade- -You
disposition
atalaterdate_'
~'
'
.. __ 2
-_
_
_ .
be advised
astothe
f lease
-they
asare
duplicalive
IA-'19
"H
_ of
I
Pages
were'_not__
considered
orre
_l..
I
_Page
withheld
s] forthe
following
reason%__:
s}':
i _ _.__'-__
E.
EE
_ reference
b 15
to be
used
for
regarding
these
pages
- -
uefollowingnnm er
'
F
_
_ Poscr.-ve
eeiectnsenmvmne -i-rbssnvmenr
3
__E
messesmesu1+usJt
L_
Deleted P2-1ge s!
No Duplication Fee
for this page
JGDOCXX
XX} JC{X
92r'T.'_92f'§¢"'§:""'i'
FBIUDO]
DPCA-2{J'{12-3-96!
H
'
u
- '
ju
_
X13{!DiX
'
FEDERAL
J?-T.1_IR_EAU
OF: nwnsrioarlon
- -FOIPA
s
.
.
.DELEIEDPAGE INFORMATION sonar
' Page
wiihheld
s! entirely
at
thislocationthe
in fle.
l0ne or
more the
of following
statements, indicated,
where
. explain
this deletion.
_ _-
_
D Deletions
were inside
pursnani
the10
exemptions
indicatedwith
beloiv
no
segregablc material
available for
I elcase
toyou. -
'
_
_.'
Iéection
552 I.
"'
~or1=>' >
cltoo!
oiei
-1:1
92
.
' 1:1
o>o><B> l
~'o
bJ ! C!
-1::
b![7} D!
I1 00 ! I
l
_.El
bJ ! -E!
' U.
-U
E]
ct-ago d
=
00 !
l
013 !
E1 rots!
U <! !
Elb! 9!
i
i! -'3! '
e 1:1 00 !
010 ! '
b! ! '
-no
a_
5 010 ! '_
b! J A!
U 'DJE7! '
FJ'
El 010 !
_>
Section 552a
r @121,
.E].
in
.
I,
Lr
.. F - i U- l'i! J_.
hWi l no reference
subjectyonrjequest
of
theorsubject
of your
Information pertained
only toaIparty
_ to the
'
requestislistedin '1et'rtIeon1y.'
__
_ .
I
age1:|::y{ies!_
G-overnment
documents
'I'hese'
referred
were that
Ito agency ie
El
Documentsoriginated
with
an_dtI'1er=
' 1:|
-
for reiriew
anddirect response
to you;
r'tion
inf._furnished
another
agency
advised
ies!-by the
FBI35'.
'____i'Pagesc_o1J1aJ11
orma
__
_ GOVCIIJJJIEEII:
_ -You
_willhe
'to
'
' ofthis
'
'
' fU1lUW1Il.g
'" '
nsultation
_
thereleasablhty
inforrnation
our eo
_ with the other agency ies!.
'Page
'
s!.withheld'inasn1ueh
asla
nal re1ease'_d_ete1111ina1io11
not Been
made. -You
will
be advised
has as
tothe
dispositi'on.at
later date.
a
-L
92
" - H»
- _._
.
d :5lJ'_e_E
PAG'esls?-i2I
'not
esjweren
considered
for release
as
-they
are duplieative
of _b
Q -E-4l
Pag
Page s! withheld-for
ihe followingreason s}: _-
_"
-
number
is tohe
used for
reference regarding
these pages?
_.
Cfollowiiag2|°,0-LII!!/9.
J1-E$_£cJ=J~£?
i --doom
-1
>¢¢v_e@~
=Tr§-
i I2
[ _e&Paal-£2! l2q':|_
Pké-0-5'*Hq "
X Deleted
XNo
X for
Page ! X"
Dupi_ioation- Fee_X
this page ; '
X
'
}Of_X}D{X
' vv-vvvv
FBIIDOI --
.~__.
i. _.WI_
"'
*
OPCA-1:-ll
.--
--
-
,4,-;'~WW _ _L .1
;;
1I
_
- FEDERALBUREAU or INVESHGAIION
FOIPA
'
-
..
DELETEDPAGEINFORMATION
or
.
lion
in thele.One
our
more
ofthefollowing
.s1;aterne_nts,
where
indicated
Page withheld
s!
entirely
atthisIoca
.
explain
thisdeletioli.
- _'
'
_ .I
_
_
n El Deletions
were
niade
pursuant
tothe
exemptions
indicated
below
with
1:10
segregahle
material
available
for
'
release to you.
l
_.
_
section
552i _;
i
our-11_
'
e
"Section S523
-
~
E1 <b'J 'r ! A!
'
El W2!
El
iU
oaola
92
-
l
_
*_
+
;:
.
'
fb3 J C!
om! V_
U 00 !
tlmoatei
13 {1§! }_
- 'El
o.010
!
C- om"
I
onset.
-
L
EJ
-1![4'!
06 !
c 1: oats!
s E-'
ave!
..
em; '
e E! Inca: .
1:1aam<1=1
-
~
U
1::
to o>oJ<D>
'
7_
El
Elitoo!
b! ! B! _- --
aB
_
.
_
-
1::._<1'<!o>
_.
i only
i ton
noreference
tothe
s_ubject
ofyourrequest
or"
_ s1.1h'ect
3 of your
the
Infonieation
pertained
_ I '
_ partywith
lU
-'
requestis1istedin 1et:'n:leon1y.'
_
_'El
Doeurnaen-ts
originated
tauith
atiother
Govemment
'age1icy
These ies!.
- documents
were
referred
tothat
agency es
forreiriew
anddirect
response
-.
,_
toyon.
,
.
.'
_'Pages
eontziiu
iofonzta on another
Goverrlirtenr
-agenCy
Yotr
ies!,'
willbe
advised
bytheFBIas
- .
'to lereleasability
ofthis"infonnation
following
Dotconsultation
withthe
other agency es!. .
'
l " Page{sJ
withheldialasrmlch
asa 1;*e1eas_¢'.determJ.u'
' ation
has
notbeen
made_
"You
Willbe
-advised
as t:o
' 'cliwosition
at a laterdate.
dL
_
i_
V it it
i_
__
_
V_eawhee:»Pacest;t&
Pages.we1 e:1ot_conSidered_
forrelease
they
-are
duplicative
of ____ _ In
_ _P_age
withheld
s!forthe
following
reason{s!:__
' 7'
- __ '___
_ _I
__
II
.
ib
92._
.
dforreference
regarding
these
pages:
= g__T11e
followiognumher5a0t£t;_t-rssef
q
izjboguiueljr
H
KUK
e t fwpaaweraws
I15 -I2-1
1'1
l
'_De1eted
Page[5!
X
X No Dup]i::ationFee _X
'
for thispage
'
X
'}iX}£XJG{
'
. XXXJGZK
'
vvvvvv
FBIIDOI
_
-W-orcs.-20
-_ ." I12-3-say
.
"
_
4-11-7 ._.-......__._.
..;......Z .1-s-If. ..l;_'.:
.1. -.....'.'.._.__
;.
W" ; ._ .Y.i;.I.......
;
*_. {se..:'.i_._;Z1_¥*>37£.-e..-
- 1-
-'
H jm '
"I
: _777
1! XJGUDCX
;gQ.5;;g;
XTDCXQ
' FEDERAL
BUREAU OFDQVESIIGATION
F011»;
. _l nntertsn PAGE
mnonnumon snnnr
I u entirely atm
locationin
- ''
Pagelfs!
.
withheld
. explainthis
deletion.
thele. C-me
ormore
of the following
stateroents,
where
indicated,
_
I - El Deletions
were
rdade
pursuant-to the
exemptions indicated
below with
no segregable
material available
for
releaseto
you.
_.
_
_' Section
552
"
_Section
U fb! !
-¢
obx-21
.
13 £1!- !
I G b! ! A!
.j:|. UX2!
1:1 b! ! B!' -
- In cool
I1 chm!
In
tome!
CI
"D! JfD!
U <! !
B b! ?!fE!.
U <! !
U
U k! !
b! !fFJ
.1
E]
4. -=1Ii!
unis! -
El
.'
l<! !_ .
-_c|
E1 b! !
' III610 !
552.21 - _
-
!
oats!
-Erri-:>cn_.
:1 one
t
-wi lnoreference
1e to
subject
of your_request
or."tI_1eof
subjec
your
Information-pertained
onlyto_a _ party
' El
' requestislistedin leti eonly; _
E1
s"were referred
to that
ageney es!
Docunaents wi
originated
a another
Govemment agencjnfiesj.
These" document
' for
re
and
ew
direct response
to you.
'
''
Pes
furnished
anofner
BE . contain information
agency
ies!.-bewill
advised
by FBIas
- _
.
'
to
the releasahility this
-of information
following our
consllltation wlth
the other
agencjufiesj.
,_
'
_'Page
withhe1d'1nas'
s! as
a nal1release_d_ete1Io1'nation
_n1uch
notheed
made.
-You advisedns
has
to the
' disposition
5.I
at a later
dste.
-
iQ7;-imee:iPsseslc3oI-lacs
Pageswere:
considered
not release
for
as
theyare
dupiicative
'of__b
___
-Pagr-: s! withheld
for the
following reasonfsjz
_'___ '___ V_
_.-
E. -The following
number
is
tobe used
for refermce regarding
these pages:
e
__
Po.s J'r92/9
:~L<e_1dva:1§£/Q
§2.e¢w'92wT
?. __I
Vfruspauses
P/I6-85 I?- ¬i"l3:7-:|
Deleted Page-.[s!
X No Duplication Fee _
for this
page
'
!QD§l'XZ}Q§
'xx;x'Jo<J={
FBIID DI
once.-in
2-3-96! '
L
---
L-
i'
J XJ{XX_XX
FEDERAL BUREA.U_0F
INVESTIGATION
FOII- _A _
-
.
1r
.explain
-'
.
-
XXXJCXX
DELETED PAGE,1192*F0R1vnrnoN
steneti"
Pa_ge s! withheld
entirely at
92
_
this deletion.
t: 1_.
_2
LL
,
_
_
_
this loat'oLn
the leinOneor
more of thefollowing statements,
where indicated,
L El Deletions
were
niade pursuant
thetoexemptions
ntdicatedhelow
no with
sep-cg
release toyou.
&
__
_
" _-
Section 552
L_
in
mum
L~
Er
011 !
able em.-m1available £01-
..
.E1 mats! .
' I:
,"E1@>mm>
"t
ei:I
-~ -
El em!
I3 b!<5>=L
1:1<w _6>.-_._
E!
rn>:1><¢s>__ IIfbJ ! FJ
--1:1
_
-
coats!
.
CI
'1<! LJ
KX5!
.
is 11 mm
_._
the subject
of jlonrreqiiest
ortiie subject
of your
_
., .
These
to thatagency ies!
Documents with
originated
Government agenny
_ _I documents
es!.were 1-Lefenred
' fur
reiwiew and
direct response
to you.
in
00 !
I11 secs!
__.
U
ef to
'
request
listed
istitle
in leOnly.
__-,' I
-92
El
El
lnfonnation pertained
onlyato_Lpa.rt3=
no with
rerence
- El
-
l 1390 ! .
Cl. MB!
|-
i! !L
13 00 !
t
- _
cans!
'f11L! 'f'} C!
__
o
t
Section 552a
a>1m<B>
L
El b! !L - ____
_
--
.
Lanother
L
r
ies!: LY@n
win tie
advised
h~L;'
by .
Pages contain
fnlnished
Govers.men_
agency
to thereleasnbilitythis
of information
following onr
eomnitatron wi
t11eLLother
l
agency ies!.
_
ease__
determination
hes notbeen made.-You will be advisedas 1Z0Lthe
Page s! witbJ1eld'.inasmnchL
as anal 1-_¢1
_
L
L
L
L
L
L
L
Lr
1>e1emee<sLePA¢;
Pages wereL-not
cons_idered'
release
they for
ore
dopiicative
__ ta
disposition at a later date L ' '
.I
Pagefs! withheld
for thefollowing reaso-n'
_s!:
__
-
_-
_-
____
._ E-
The following
number
to be
used reference
for
regarding
these pages:
t
I
-beau/*92¬:O'T'
Ir
_eeqrrtve
J?-¬5_QoA<¬ Nmaart
L LL L .Le.:p¢.q.re.<
Maia; 4:325
133
.mmmm
X '_De1eted
-P3,ge g! X
X No D_np1joation'
.X Fee
X for
XXXXXX
this page
LX
_
UPC.A 1l] 112-3-95!
_
__
',
_______
__ii
-
_
'
_ _ _;__:
-_
_
!..
_ __;:ii
__.
_
_ __1
X?DD{_X.X
'
'
'
FEDERAL BUREAU OF]NVEST_[ IGATION_
-Form
. .DELETED PAGE INFORMA'.I'ION
SHEET
"
' Page
withheld
s! entirely
at location
theinfile.
One
or
moreof the
followingzstatenlents,
indicated,
wher
- explain
this
deletion.
.
_
_
hriicated
below with
no segregable
material. available
for
El Deletions
were roade
pursuant
the
to exemptions
in
release toyou.
__
..
__
_
-Section 5529,
.__I U
_'D!
.E-L
'
1!
too!
ohm
.'
E3
b! ! A!
D
Er
cb><1>@>_
-
U
[II
o matinee:
i
_'
.
_El
i! Z!_'
00 !
00 !
-1:1
M7393!
.7i IE
92
rots!
-D
bJC"! C}
- _
.-
_E|06 !
' oamrlee l
.El
~1! !
1
.T3 b! !
El 1311 !
o one
VEl
El
.
. _
EH9!
.5.
FI
'92
Information -pertained
only toa
'Iequestis1is"tedinfoetit1eonIy.'
_
El
=I! !
E1. W3!.
-- Ci. coco
_
l
63 !
t
-with
no
reference
foeto
of youijrequest
or
the subjectyour
of
Vnlbject
_'
- oliginated
Gemment
Docunlents
with anotlier
ov _ag enc
y
-
_'-
es!;
These ooooments
were refettred
to t.ha1;'-
' forreview anddirect response
to yon-
.
'
infonnation
fumished
"Govemnient
agencyfies!.
be
advised
tl1elFB1
by
as
. . another
.
.
. will You
Pages eontam_,
'to'
thereleasab ity this
of information
following onr
consultation with
the other
age11oy ies!._
_ _
l l'
11'
r made.
-You _wi11
be advieed
as tothe
' '
I PageWiTl1.held'n1as:nu's!l
Joh asanal relea_=;e
_c_1eterro.1n.>1'
as nobeen
tion
disposition elater
at
:iate__'
_
'_ _
-'
4' Pages.were'_11ot|'considered
for release
es they
one dupiieative
of _l_N mimesr :31e__
___ ms
' Fagewitbheltl
e! for
the "following reason s]:
- '
_T,_
'"
The following
no-mber
to is
beused for
reference regarding
tl1ese'pages: -_
L
l
r
~en .
Q.1>! >¢uM¬yJT Kl~
P2 ? B-_1¬_$_E0»1-£Q_zdm8e
or _ __
L[' L'_e$P0nl$eSMae: I31
-If-I-0:]
S
'.De1eted Page s! X -
X No Duplication Fee _X
for this
page
' XXXJDCX
' virvvvv
'
X
FBUD OJ
orcn-20- 2-3-96! -
"
'
--
_"}
'92
' '
XDGQUDK
100055:
_
XXXXXX
'. FEDERAL
BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
-FOIPA
.DELETED
_|
PAGE INFORl92£[A'I'ION
' withheld
Pageentilelyat
this
s!
-location
file.in Oneinore
or following
of
statements,
indicated
where
' -explain this
deletion.
,
i
.
_
_
l
ti onsm
'
dicated
below
withno
segregable
material available
for
El
Deletions were made
pursuant
to exenip
_
92
release
to you.
_
_
_
_'
._
Section 552:1
Section 552
*-
~
IU b! J
[:1
-U b! ! B!
Ub! Z!
.
Ub} !
b! ! -1*-J -
-'
d! } -
Ui! ?-!
-
I1 -oxmc! a
-U
Ub! '7! E! i -El
Ub! !
b! ! F!
.
U'I! !'
.
UE! !
.
U
U. BN3!
k! !
00 ! _
::|'_
|l -E coo! _ with no
referenoe
snhject
of yonrrequest
or the
stfbjectyour
of
_ the_to
Ub! 9!
Ub! !
omo
I
00 !
'
U<! !!
b! ! D!
l
- .
I
Information pertained-only
to_a party
' reqnm
is].iste£liJ1 1etltle0I11jI.'
_
__ '_' _' _
El
1d
ents were
referredthat
to age:icy ies
Docurnents originated
with
another
Government
agencyfies}.ocum
Il1ese'__
I '
'3
' for
reviewand
direct response yon.
to . _'
'
_-
"
Pages information funiished
another-_GovernmenI
ag'ency
_wi]l
ies!.
advised
be Yonthe
byFBI
as -
L"
to thereleasabiljty
this
of information
following onr
consnltation the
withother
agency es!.
'
'
-_
l Page
- withheldinasmnch
s!
a nal
release
as
- -' .dispositi'on
at
a later
dat'e.''
:
In U
J
i
_ has_not_been
Iation
niade. -You
ivi.l.l'beto'the
advised
t1*
_
~
of DETHIMQQS
PAR I3! -F
Pages were
not considered
for release
as they
i-uedup cative
_. . .
_I
- '
-
_
-
~
..'lwithheld
age s! we
forfa11@wngr=mis>=
' -'
efbaeumor was . newts
U U
i-
ab
1'0
-
do
ptsnmpir 1+-r m>e?:=._
wees F23
u EH
_The
following nnmlaer
is to
be used
for reference
regardingpages:
these -
_
Posrrave :Z¢.>5_E¢N$¬
gevmoeé if-1 t>ncgm_eHTL '
l f[ L _'.$£_>oM3_
1'-H]
I. .:>;:x!§:>k
U;e¢XX;QeQ
6
X Deleted
Page s!
X No Duplication Fee . X
X for
this page
IX
;~.JoQQ<;X.-x1_XXXX
XXXXXX
FBIFDOJ
|-ix
:.T.:E'_:i.'.
.7.'_'.'._i';j'_*.*_
.__
*'__i__.__._._..._.._
__,,_;_
__
;:lT:.:
____
__,___
___
- .'I.I.._T-iI;'
UPCA-20112-3-96!
-3
J
_
X!§:X.§fXX
XXXXXX
- FEDER:-ll.
BUREAU
on INVESTIGATION .
" '
.
_
FOIPA
DELETED
PAGE]NFORI92¬[A'I ION
-
.
.
~ Page witliheld
s!
entirely
31thislocation
in
meme.Oneormore
[J f thefollowing
, where
statements
indicated
.
_'
_ -'
- '
explain
thisdeletion.
'
.
bl
'tl1
se
available
for
[II Deletions
were
niade
pursuant
totheexemptions
indicaled
elow
W1
_no
gregablernaterial
releaseto you.
_.
_
Section 552a
-
Section 552
92-
.-[1
' ~
om!
I1 o><m>
Cl only
El
-:1
b! l ; r
'
El k! !
b! '?l C!
El lJ! J D! ' '
1:1aware!
-
lU
El
b! J
CI
53
'
!
El
one .t.
i '
1:1
Ei
U
kl ll
.
'l:l
00 !
n=>o>cF>
.3u<1 _4'>
Ei 00 ! i
D.
mo
'
El. b! !
I
d! !
i! -'3!
i:| '
b! ! Bl
U
'
-
El
1
chats!
i
El- EX-7!
.-
-'
reference
tothesubject
ofyonrjeqnest
orthesubject
ofyour
lnfonnation
pertained
onlyto_a
party
I wi za-no
'reque'stis]istedin 1etitleon1y.'
_
_
- El
Documents
originated
niith
andt1i|er Govemn1ent
agency'_I'hcse
ies!.referred
to§1ocnmen1s
thatagency e
'forreview
anddirect
response
to yon.
.i___
'
P1568.
. _
ifonwillbeadvised
bymeFBIas
inf lI3J1ati0i1
furnished
Governrneni
agency ies!_.
.
_another
" to thereleasability
ofthisinformation
following
onrconsultation
wrththeotheragency es!.
_
You. willbeadvised
asto the
'
Page s!
wiT.b.he1d"inasmuch
-asa nal1;'e1ease'_d_.eter1:oinatio1i
hasnotbeenmade
. '
disposition
ata laterdate.''
'
- _ '
' '
l3
liege}:
were
not
consideretl
for
release
-they duplicative
ail}
. 'l
, 'Page
withlielclfor
s}
the
following-reason
s!:
g
__ __
.____ .__ _;:___
" B_'IlIe.-following
mnnher
tobeused
forreference
regarding
these
ages:
t_ P0-SCEIVE
@;e.s£oM_e_Mvnf4m
=2- >¢5¢_=-mwrjm
_o__
-
I.L1 ~S|9.6'l'~_35¢-5&
P o¬S[41_ .X DeletedPage
'
X
s}
'
_
X No DuplicationFee _X
X
for this page
'
_
X
XXXXXX
!D{XJCXX
DODCXXX
FBUD 03
OPCA 1lU' 2H3'
96! W
'
!
'
|
FEDERAL
BUREAU OF
-
'
'
! _XFDKXXX
INVESTIGATION '
'
FOIPA
'.DELETED
I
,
__-
,
PAGE INFORMXIIDNSHEET "
'
_
.
' Page
withheld
s] entirely
atitislecation
in tllefileOne more
or the
of following
statements;indicated,
where
explain this
deletion.
_ _' _i
' _'
III Deletions
' made
were pursnant
to the
exemptions. indicated
below. no
withsegregable
material available
for '
release to
you. ' _.
I
_
_
_section
552 c_Section
"
ea=! !
~_
[:1 cw!
i
sszai
1
E1 c@!o!rA!
_. 1:1
.E1
cd!<5!
rb!r1!<e! -
El
n=!<3!';
- '
! El
ma!
!n!rh!<?!<c! s
1:! mu!
1:1 <h!c1!rD!
- 1:!
' i:I"a=!<?!rE!
'- in e!<4!-'
:1-o=!<5!"
_
_El 00 !
!_ 1:1
lets!: t
w! 9! ~'
m_a<!c6!
V
'pertained
El
-onlya
i '
1:1 00 !
U " b!E7J
. F!
1:1. tb! 8!
_1:
r:iw!c6!.
00 !
_-
V
1:r~ck!t"r!,
with no reference
'to
subject
the
yourreqoest
of
subject
'
of your
request iS].i5'iBI1iJ1 1BI_iTl6OIJlj'.'
_
l
_ .'
_- '-
__-
D Docllmentsuoriginated
with another
Govemment a_gency
'_I11ese'
ies!.
were refelzred
todocuments
that
agency iec
' tc'!r"reiriew
and direct
responseyou.
to _' _- '
_
"
_-
-
.' _
j_
_'
.
I Pages
co1_1ta.in- fttrltished
information
another'Gove1:cenent
by
You will
be agency
advised
I:1jrthe_PB1.a
e-s!. - _
to thereleasability this
of information
fo owing on:consultation with
the c| 1eragency ies!_.
_
'
_Pagewithhe.1d'i.uas!:!uei1
s!_
a nal-release
a¢¢¢niiiiia1i@n.1i=is
1;
been made-You
not be edvised
asto the.
' disposition
at
a later date' ' -
-
' .- _
_
6 .ftages
wereconsidered.
not release
-they
for-dtrplieativel
lDQIAIMQES
of
Page s]withhe1dforthe f011uwingreason
- -i_ 7 -.s!: ?_
fif
Tl
_'
_I
_
'
'D:|e
-fo owingnumber
to"be used
for reference
re_1jarding'these
- .___
pages:
1
"s
Vi
L"P-o.$r Z'rve
i/teis!@a¢!ss¢_s!~;.@eerL
ft>act;Mjé3;U
ft;
¢;Ni
_
L5t<:wi0se$~
mm :45e-15¢]
e
- '
' -
_'
' §<"&"Y"i?"S?'Y
"
- '
' ._
X Deleted
Page s!
X N'o'Duplieation
Fee .
X for
this page
_
F3]'_;"|_
_ !Q]
!-.;.*. :¬:::a.f.*
1 ores-20- 2-3-sol " __ .
_I
1I
l
.3753955
.
FDDDCXLX
'
FEDERAL
' BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
.
FOIPA '
'_DELETED
PAGE nwsonmimow5.1;-mar
' Page
withheld
s! entirely
at
this locationthe
in le.One or
more of
the following
statements; where
indicated,
explain this
deletion.
_
_
I El Deletions
made
pursuant
were to the
exemptionsbelow
indicated
no
with
segregahle
'm3:g1-i;-11
fg;-_ - 9
1'el$e
you.
to
__
_
,
' _'Section
552 -_'
l.e-
~El
13 b! ! BJ
bl[2!
.U
.
Er oioi.
_
-c__
Section 552a - _l
'
13
._s>1o> A1 _
.
El blfl!
l
-_
_*_:_._
13 d! !
-
U iJ !'
.U
oioicca
- 1:|
-1:1b!f7!' -U}
V" I11.
o om.
El b! ! F!
U 613 !
one
E1 coo!
U b! 9J
U b! !'
00 !
~
.J,
.
'- -U
66 ! '
-U" b! !_ E!
I3 fB!{4J'
EH1!
- 13
'
l-
*1! ! -
III Goo!
;
u-El.Information pertained
only to-_a with
no
referen6e"t0
the subject
of-yourrequest
'tl1e.su
or . your.o
' 0
_
'
_request
is
listed in theti eonly." _-
_' __
.
I originated
u'
Govemment
Docuroents
with another
~'3
' forreview anddirect response
to you.
l-
agency
These"es!.
documents
were
referredto that
agertcy ie
.
inf -ormation
by
ton_ vie.s!.
llbe advised
by the
FB1215-.|
Pages oontain
_ fiirnislled
_ another
_ Governrneiit ag enc:y
_
- to the releasahility
of thisinformation -following
our consultation
with theother agency ies!.I
_ _ _.
_Page virithlieldinasroueli
s!
as
a i1a1'1_'elease_
has not
beendetermination
in
ado.
be advised
as
to the
' 'disposition
at
alatér date.' '
' _
_' -'
_ ._-
_
id
cl for
release
as
they
of be-TAIQJQES
"
f3
25513;!.
LE Pages'
not
were
o_ons'
ere
.are duplioative
'
u .
.'-Page s! withheld
for the
following reason s!:. __
i
_- -
'
-13- The following
number
is
to he used
for reference
regarding
these
pages:
"
;
i
__
.
;P05;7'rvE_ /L6s'P0nJS¬r;Nv/
L - Mcvmen
. 88|7r. It
h Cr_1¬$P0'H5¢S.Pm;.c_$m
|5|-% I53]
Deleted Page s!.
XNo
X
'D L1p1iCationFee _X
_
for this page ' X
}IX.X'J92 §CX
'
7
I
i
_ f.'..'_%_;iI'
'_i7:.'; :i..::Ti-.:£-.'.:il
T
-._f"_
; _'k.7Q?7':.:{iilifI._.ii
_'
_ '.:_".
;.. ;..".._.i:;.
i..._ ._T.f.E.i-;..._
._1..
.... _- .._:_
....i:i;_..:;.;.':1£.;;
__
____
_ ____
___
__
__
;:
E 0PC.A
- 2-1+
2ms} " -
- Xi'
._
-. -:-~ '
XX'XX.!D{
i '- '-"FEDERAL
on nwnsrrtoarxon
BURE
-
.
l
'
VFOIPA
e
u DELETED
PAGE
INFORMATION SHEET
-
__
-
-
I
the
One more
or the
of following
Statements;indicated,_
where
'
'
Pagelfsj
withileld
entirely
at location
_ in le.
explain this deletion.
'
I,
'
_
I.!
I i
tJ:|'
tions
indicated
withsegregable
below
no available
mate
-&
1El
Deletions were
made pursuant
to e exemp
' releaseto you.
__
_' . _
' _I'_
_Fiection
551
Section 5523'
-_
- "'E 11 rm! ~
92-
:1 clonal
El ll?!
' -
5 f1! J
1:1 tomten
- 13
E El moi V"I11-cw-!»:c>
' -
-U '1! !
El fb! !fD!
' U
FIX-'1!
.
'06
13! -
E3 fb} !{EJ
U k! !
E! b! !_ F!
o'e>t4>
L'-
92
E El.
one!
U - lJ! !'
' U k! !
.
' Ul~:! !
El i."b! 9!
Eloato.
J'! !'
t-
.
E1 coo!
E
'
Infonnation
El
pertained
only a
to:third wi no
areference
to the
subjectyouzjrequcsi
of
o1-'t]_1
of your
92
'
request isI.istcd_in
the titleonly.
l'
1
El
_'- _'
_
_-
ents]1ese'__docnJn
were Iefemred
originated
with
ano ierGovemnneni a,gency{ies!.
'_1
_ to -that agene ies!
' for
reiliew and
direct response
to you.
.
I
" _ _l'
Pages contain
infonnation fpmished
anothetGovernment agency
es!. ion@111advised
lrie the
by P121
as
._ _
to thereleasability this
of infortnation
following our
consultation with
the other
agency eg!.
' Page s!withheldinasmuch as
a
_ _
nal telease detennjnation he not been made.-You will be advisedas
to
dispositionat
a later date
the
_
were
considered
for release
as they
are dupljcative
of DQ.'TPu
l| AJQQ§-.
_l_. Pagesnot
' Pagewithheld
s!
the
for following
reason s!: '
--E!-'l hfIl'-'b"'b arr
d' 1. :
.
EB
9 qimgmi
ii_i?5i=§F'io3IéB6§3§3§i%5§eisi»5
1~.~,acur4<?
P_
wwwesenkaci-lt54]sl EXme<m- 7{1$i1QQ{"
xx
E
-'
'
--'X
Deleted Page s}
- '
._ X No'Dup1jcatii;m-Fee
-X
for this page
'.
FEIIPDEJI
_
orcn-202-a-95;
-
"'
u
.
_
i--!
XXX.XX.X
FDOUOCK
.
- FEDERAL
BUREAU
OF11WEsT1o.4.1'1o1~q
norm
"
V
.
.
_DELETED PAGEmsonm.-ufionsnEE:_r
I H entirely
ulo
'lI1
'
ofthefollowing
statements;
where
indicated,
'
Pagefs!
withheld
atthis
cation
. die le Oneor
I more
explain
thisdeletion.__
'_
_'
' _ I _ ' _
i top theexem
tions
indicated
below
no segregable
material
i
available
for
'
E! Deletions
weremadepursuant
. with
Ito.1CIiSE
you.
__
'
__
' '
0°
.
.
Section552
o M1!
_
~
|-
in cw!
Section 552:1
_
_-
E1mare-so
_
U ' ! !
El b! ? !EB!
1:1
oars!E
_
E "E1
smote!
.'
1:1
ant?!- D!
_v
_
_
U
'
b! ! E}
El i! Z!'
- E1 00 !
- E3
1-'3-00
-!
-
F3 '
b! ! F!
E- W4!
-
13
-III b! 9]
n<m<_o,..
I
' i! J
1:1
Mo
-'
.--
.__-51
'
l
' ¢!¬?3_.
'
n momimm
pe1'tein_ed
only
to
a mesparty
with
no reference
OJThe
't
sub'ect
of y0I1I,
'
request
islistediutile
iitleonly.
"
.
»1! }
I
- E- 011
'
_. !
El b! !'
¢!C3! .
_-- _ _'.
-I
'
_1 1 or
=qt1es't
TI_1e.su'bject
of your
i
I IIGovernnaent
documents
were
referred
to
that a_ge.ucy ie
Eli Docllruents
originated
with
mane;
agency These
_es!.
_'
forreview
anddirect
resjionse
to
you.
_' _'
_
'
"Pages
eontziin
informa on byanother
Goveuunent
agene -You
ies!.
willbeadvised
by-t11e'FB
as
- '
tothereleasability
ofthis
iJJ.fo1 foliowing
matio11
ourconstlltation
with
theother
agency es!.__
_Page viithheldinasmuch
s!
asa n:-11
release
determination
hesnot
been made.-You
' '
disposition
at a laterdatef
'
i
LL l
_-
- _i
_
E'
it iit
bernwees-P/teesstsz
S Pages
werenotrconsidered
for
release
es
they
ai-e_duplieative
of
'
_
__
'Page[s!
withheld
forth;
following
reason_- li
willbeadvised
astothe-
'
i __
_ i W__ 
_
__
'
The
following
- number
is
tohe
used
for
reference
regarding
these
pages:
.
.
l
A
_ ___
_'
E E 'f?o:;T_r;{e
__.@f¢es£a@.:seHt~umserL
Q¢ _t1>o¢q;v|e.u
1 fl-%
crtesp¢~sesPs@esrss-M]_
' '
X
_De1eted'P'age
X
_ s!
X No'Duplicatio11
Fee_X
__
X
|-
7- - - I III
XXXFULX
for this page
'
X
.
I
IFBUDOJ
FD-302 R:v.920-6-95! .
-'
1
..,
V -'
.F1'*$5iFm
;31 §55A?§.3>kIIi-1%?-1-1§;ZJ§?;?;
' "
-
P¥1$@H'=
Iii? -- -"£1-?
__--_
I
I &
'.
ht.§a&.$...._..
n:.;.:§.;_z_
. _
l :~L§..-;
. -f;1..@§.J~@
.
<- 1
.
.
."
'
l- J'EJ1:l
- 1I
-. .. .-. ;I1¢1==_:»s:iof1"i1-§-.
---;---mm;
.- -#1---_~.:t
- --2-1...-:
s Ln.
V
Bea-§.¥1!a.§.a1?¢sI-1~n§$_Ir;1a;.;;;
§1'iE2.Ei5H@..I~_'1lEm
sn1:1~§=w'rEsfz:l_cI'A:§&
BTJREAU
o11*
-" varé@r.u-=im1
'o?g19g2oo:-1
p un~
b6 1,3,4
b7c
interviewed
-1,3,4
'
b7D -1
b7F -1
at Guantanamo Bay Naval
Station,
Guantanamo Ba
~-uh .'
Also"
resent
.E1i.1ring
'_'in_t'erv
Speoial
'Agent
.
o onthe
T - was.-192TC'IS_
f;[an<;'L----eont-r-a
asa.L
who*pr5§Iaed5tEe
Pashtu.-a
{
guage-translation.--
-
'p:oVide
t e following iniormation: t:f
IT
- b6 -4
-,h1 j-H
o
t
_ ::_
-
_eTom1'pl_a_:;1f;g<i'
_o_
f_-'be_inq
_.mi_stre'a:.te<:'{_b§{_
_'§1'§____'§
E"
,. q1_eten_t:|..onin"Baqram and "di.1r'in'g;i1i§
3C.rai1s3':.f:.ft.-o_C'amp'
'-i:Jel.ta.
pointed-E
bWI 4;
bTD l_
. b?F -1"
'
arks
on his
wrists
that he d;§i@ed;¢e;
the
I V
@
'
L;':a.1.'1'se_d
,3
<'
he _was |_'1ipse't-13?
jrialm ed ._that
.
_;
_
7
.ha92":i.'n.q_'
Iol
'
5 haekIes'
_ _ AdditionaIlg;1
7 .i
7 _ ._
I
to" _wea§:t.
a hood. wgile- i1'_:.
transzi;-t 'a.m5."
-,1=1=.at
_qIl§l_r§1§__¢j_i§l
not -respon d . to"
a pain
in
smile
in
' told
his ear. ,Fu:ther}|4J
theta
Ialleged that the quards beat him,"
tran_si1:.',_]i|_i:i;L1rrii92_ad_-_tl1e
_f;ra1;.sJ._a.to_:_
tq£, 1~.='.=
_:i".l1_s_a:n._d_wa.s
-.
doo't:or'wo.u1d-seei
himlatzer
. i.<A¢i:-ording
he -is
-toi nhoof.
oent'
ahy-" offsns_e..-__
_£'oro
i-_
; _ came to f2i_is_
-house
w
_1;_e=1i1=-P."
was'_11aving'_
a'
meal with guests.-.__US and
* -Afghan military
'ersonnel
entered his-home and staxted-searching.
t
USA forces
showed.
a-pi-oturefof
hi-s
brother
that--they
had
found
-
b6~431'
. in his houseand askedaQr~it1was..'
|:::|adri1i92=ted
"t-hatit washis
-
brother,andfurther_stated_that
his bjother_was
out]offto
E::::]
n.
b7C -4
b7D '
l
b 7F -1
was to1d_that weaponshad been'found
in his house{'but[:::]i
I :__ Ix
3
_0
n
countered
that
they-were
actually
found'aG.his
brother's
house.
_-'-
'1
'- [;:::1was_e3tremely
upset_that-He_was
detained
idfront_of
the;I '
7 - ema e members of his family and
stated
that he was ihnocent of any;
crime- I-~
5
' -Ilater zod-ified.
his storyregaiding
theweapons-Iannd
.
.
'
admitted
that
only
-two weapons" were. found at
this
'
~'
'these'weapons
was a Kalashnikov and the
other
b6
4
b7C -4
h7D -1
b7F
l
I
that!did1_1ot"_.work.-"
Duringthis
later
;-scant
house."
was a British
one -of _
weapon f
qst'ated
thatthe'-
two-weapons
were.used-£or_bitd
hunting.
[:::;]furt
erstated
that"'
any additional '{-aezaponswnayi
be the property o'
his brother"; and that
-'
_ _
.
if there were any,yeapons@ithey had been_aoquired from a Mujahideen.
eight-"to-'t_eri-years- ago
that 'L¢as"ac-quainted'wi'th
his brother.
-'
'
._ .
_ Ahother
theory
suggested
by[%;:lwas
thattheweapons
may
belong
a __
_ _-___._fy*i_§|l1:__ag'e'__;Le1dea§'-,
a-nd"re'ite1f.f7ate
t at his birqther Wou1d'k'now
the fproirenance of ET_1e-.weéIp67s.*"T'*f _f'f'f7_ -* _'_7" 7 "'ffT
___RE_sP0_NsE$-1'62
_
luvcsfigaticn1_o:1
_- '7-Q3L1Q/
r
='.'
Guesténsms-Ban-s
'
¢u_b§ " ; Iii-
Q
-
'
fuer:
§_55_;';_*1y11§___'§;7-:9f5g_;Q;27
.1;-_$36'_
1'
'
_- _'
'_D:iie
dictatcd
17'[_]_9Z'
'
.I. '
__ __:
___|_ ;|
-_ byui
"'
s
-17 _
_ "
.
_.
_This
document
contains
neither
recommendations
norconclusions
ofthoFQI. 1:
is bu:
propurty
of theFBIand
is loaned
to'3-our
ngmcy;
I
ii andits ::iJmen_tsare not.to be d_i:n_ri b1.:ted
outside
youragmcyf --
_. .
.
pM___,. Z
__L Z
._W*
_
7_V
i
'f }:=n-3o2=+fR'w.1o-5-9;;
.' __
-'
"I _
.2-SSA-MM-9.99102
--
"._b7C -4."b"'D""1 -.
.-
we -1
_
_
__
Con92iny_ationot':F1§-3l12of3
W
,cn_ i1§/.o3_
pf Fag,
1, G;
pi
_Gmmultiple occasions ,
resented to
b6
b7C
b7D
b7F
him According
asked" thathis acouserbe 'u 1._
to
an
enem
of
his family
hac1 "
.
"promulgated"
thali
nadl weapons.
'=
"I-Iowever ..
'
_- "" an'un.sub'stant-iated
- "V
' rumor
g_'
'
. '
'
" '
__ _ _ l "5
brother phonetic!.
"had with phoneti'C
' _
f::|ar1d had
=a"--l.ong_-standing isagreement ower money. ," the basis
for this
_-Further}. was
alle
in
the
ation
was
an
ar
ument
that
Afghan Ann pend used
his
relationship -
with US'"
.s; to_':c_onvinCe
US" thatl _thehad weapons
at -his-_;_
house.
insisted
that he
had-beenwrongly
and
acoilsed
f_
';i.m p].ic:ated- with"-the
we-_apons'.._'
" ' :.' _'
..
_ "'
b6 "
b7C
b7D
h7F
- ,. '|:|;descr-ibedan -added
'dime_ns'-ion
to the conflict "between his
brother and-"enemies.'of'_his
-f_a_mily."_ 'A=_:c;ordi_ng
to I:
amember _
of "onetribe
1. was killed, so
someone--from the
offending -tribe
kil-led
'a member
of"; the.o'p'pos'ing__-group.
This ociourredapp:-oicimatel
eight
.
years ago
and
was afadlfoif
intt-he animosit
held
against.e":
family". ;_:]_sta"t_ec_1_,-.
"_'I his1-"man'
is thepause ...
- _ on
mul't.:i.'p_-le
'oooasioris asked.
"for:p_roof'Ithat
had 'he
committed "some
~-of
n.
opined _that
if -hewere
-a "fighter,_."he ' .
w 'uld
hav'e"ki"lleda1;-1-ien
a: himself |:f;|ins1sued
that-.
b6 4,5,6
b7C 4,5,6
b7D -1
-b7F -1
he.-was asi_
of. _t-hat
"hut
that
su
ested
99
le farmer
and
that
'.i.t_ was-only
the a se
"alle
' one
_
had'draw1f1"attention
the
oi
'the'US _ont'o
'_
_
that his.
-US iorces
hrother would. straighten out
would. not
let
__the"__ situation,
-' 
hJ._m_c_ommun1c:ate w1thhis brother.
"As "an
'additio'nal"
mark _ of,
his inn'ocezf1ce,
|:|opined that
no ireason
to arrest
him
and
asks-d,.
".W-hyme" and
not"
'_1.'.2hE
my ;brothers?"'
-'
- who-- also
werepresent
at
the me__al". '|:%explai'ne
that his-brother
"
had traveled
-about
to speak
an t at
this
with a_
istriot offioial
named
_
aroad that'was_-_t.o
-near
built:|S-'§am|i1Y
¢¢> 1PF>und."_ .-
.was-w-hy..his brot_her._.was
unavailable to corroborate. .
_'
1:] insisted
that
he
kne,i-fnothing" of
the 92i!eapons-Eound-by Us~
forces in"
histhefamily"tompoi.1nd._
s
Fur_thethatthé
-US_
direoted
forces
"to inter92ri'ewpeople ofhis village.
_insistedl
'
_.b6 -4
_m
_b7C 4_
b7D ~1' bTF 1
people of
the village
would support.
hi"s'eto'1ycorroborate
and
that
1iE 1¬.H¬£;f"HEEE3; a'ar*E1i"e"" wea-§@*am*§a~s~4j'.m§c~a
--
statedhethat
only
"commanders
have weapons,
li eople don't,
" _
was asimple;
unedu'<:ated__1'-I:armer.._ -claimed
to be",
and
that
unable to
read-or write
.Pashtu. The
only
ormal
education he
had _
was through re.l'igi.ous- _t1:_ainirig
did admit -to knowi-ng a.
few '
words-of
Dari, but
no
other"
languages;
5 _.
-
-I
-
_
|:| stated"-"that his-family farmed
a'--"plot"
and
grew
together
_
___"RES_PONSES-_163-i _"
.
' I
i-J
§
W__ _
__
_
.
-~ .FD-302a[R|:v.10-6-95!
F
.
.
s.
--
- '
_.
--?"_ -
0 94_'n'~
.-
b6 4
_-
_'
F
_
_b7C -4i
.-"C:r;1tin1iaEi.nnsfFl§-Il' J2uf
l I ,'
i,_..0l,,I:l '¬l9/
"-LP?-SL5 &
-""-
__-
: __b7D
_'
- .-r
265A-M-c99102
b6 -4
b7C
~- -
3 '
1->10
_bu"
_;~
-1
.'_b7F~1-
-
9
4
1 ve§;'e.tables,
onions
specifically
_an_d:pomé<j_ranat'
.'Q'sta
his hands=_were smooth and-_ did not reE1_ec't.hard
manna
labor
beoause
the
"doctors
gave
him
something
to"soften'
them._"'_'
e
lain
To
how
1.-"his hands
,'.c'ould
the rigors
heal
of farm
-from
work,_| stat.ec1_
tha't,f"My-.hands_ -_ju'st,
better" got
and""If
you out me it will heal-in
four months.
-' -
'_ ;.'
_
'
'
_|:-I.'
sfamily-'"_had'
maintained the-.-farmsince 'mo'vi'ng
to-
92
.b7C
q'ill'age
Jalalabad
from approximate-ljr
four ears
-ago. Only
s"brother
|:|remainedinJalalabad.
des.c_:ribedthatto--'
pomegranates were pla1fited"in"the _fall.,
_but aterr
chan ed
this
plantingthisin
spring
thecropharvest
and-.
t__he_
in 1'1a
fa-ll._'
dea
'.of &1ow_lar.g"e
-year-"s
of -pomegranates wou
e. _'
,<':l.a.imed that
1- 'ar,, his family
hartvested 50.man,_ phC=net'J.c
I of-<
-pdmegranates.family
has
also
s
-goats
and
cows.
'
" Q53
family-also grows
"oriions -in one section "and grain
in
ano
er
1b7F
b6
mo -
seonion of
l-and. '
Th'e_-ent_i1_:e- family
works -1:he'
land
and
a1l- of the .
family members
live wi-thin a'compound -together, b t in
-separate houses; The
individual families
' Y
'3
t;'her:'1se1ves-,.--but.-~share.
-"
fa
geesthouse
for'gues_ts_.
Further,.|§L¬_r-ystatied
two-of
hisf
that
not get
along, --but ithat '-the
_o_t_hei_:s__close.
are_
'
brothers -do
" *b6 "
b7C
b?D P
_b7F
returned to
the theme
that certainelements the.
_in_ I -
village werehappy
enemies
are
ve
5
tojsee him
arrested, by U5 foroes"and said," ."My
ha
py
I was captured . They
stab people
in
the
back.
.Again,
" amendedstatement
-_1:hi-s
bydid
=1-ater
saying
_t~ha-t:&
didnit persona
yave
enemies ,_ but that
his brothe-r'
due to.
the
a1.terca1-;ion'_.bet_w'een
brother
md
|:|ea¢plaj.ned-that
his
had afight
approximate y
ten" ays
prior
to
h:i.s._<;a'pture
his brother
-by .US -forces and
imjplied -that
this was
blood betweennhis
brother .a'f1d
I"
be ~
_b7C b7D b7F
somehow'1inked-the.
to bad
._
-1 '
- _.1
_'
"phonetic!
r'
Fi1:i:the:t',_.it
possible the
that
wasweapons
belonged
Q] -to'
awell"-known comrnande-1'. _|::|admitted
that". i'f_
t; e-
weapons found
'in t21'e compound
hadbee-n new , '-he would-b'e
' ilty.
However,
weapons
the
belonged
really
'h-is
to
-brother."
1lQ1;__,_11§;§{E,__1iE_2_!§LI;; _I}§_Q]._lZ1j.§___E§
anyone- because
.6.EQ11.5"once to
- ey- were ~ '
given
a weapon,
they
were1." restorl§iEIe'_¬5
El f*¬'EETrrTnE?IdeT-*w1To
in. '
"--..
-".
.- -. ' ' ' ..
b6 -4
b7C -4
'b7D -1
b7F -1
' |:Idenied beinga lmemberiof
the T_aliban orAl Qaeda. j'
'
Addit-ionally,
Qhad" heard of
the I-IIG,
but heard
it for the first
time aplpro-Jtimate y four months"-a o and did not know anything-about
the organizatic-n._
Eurther,|js:-gatzsd that
the Taliban
did not -
bring peaoef
Only since-the
US arrival has
Afghanistan been
'
-
J'.._
_. _.;§E§¥EjT.
.h.
.'
lH: :!.
.C:D.L
V
. _ L§
F11!-3i}2a{Re92{..lO
_ - i _-93]
'.
I _. .-_ - _V
.¢92
- '-_
I
-
I. -
_-e
_
_. _
1' -F4
'-'-b6
-_b7C -4
_b7D
_
-1j"
-1 2s5A<mM~e991di
gT//?
LT[.anee aofaw
,1_@9,.@;a_-;_.{
-i4
o.'peacefol; e7-'ea1o@
&._-.a_ _f~e=;et- I|=,_
1:_ »j '.
|:lre:.terated
that
the
weapons hacl been
provided eightto-"
ten years ago Further,[::::]cla1med that
he
cold-Us forceswhere '
to
find
fJ.VE
boa-tee
of al'I LI'E11.1f|.J.tl0I'l
|:] s
famlly brought
b-6_ammunltlon " '
Le
from Jalalaloacl
when. they moved'
to
-the
mc »-1 ago._ Oboe_agai_rI,j|:|insieted that
"the
farm four
the "
yeare
_-
-
ax-nmu'r_1it'ion_
not "hie, _
92§&#
p70
*I-=but~belonged.to
his-bfother}
E;:::]stated.that there
were_no
b?Ff1" _ro¢ket-propelled
grenades.foun on the pIEm15ES. _Furt er, the__
.
.'
,
-1
.h'
L"
' recoil1es$_ri£le
found-by Us forces did not work and was rueted..
-_ -'
opined that-_-'
it:..ie'- probably
_"over'
hundred
a
years old, " but ,'
later" modi-fie'd';
this byjeaying
that itwas"frorn._his- !'grandfather s a
time;w'lgmaintained
that-he knew.
nothing any
of ;-éddiI:_ionaI
,="_weapons_t at
may have been_foundon his oompoundf 1'
1_'~
,_ ,_'|i
Z
T'
92
fa
' '
';RESPON5E5d65 "
_- - j.-;_
_'z
W, TZ
_ ..
_'."'FD - 3U2[Rev.15Hi-; !
-
- -""
.'!""~
"
."
.-
'~_;5'
-92 E
i%5$T"'TL7 t;Té
1
?%*
'
-
---r.-a.---:urn1m- -nm1rr1:~m_.
s-¥F;£§2;;.¬;£§Eil-?§i=m¬39
"
..I g".
, -gm -'5
If<':E1i§"'I&
"
FL
P+'i3= ¬5E '!!'.i,§31f?31f¥.=
V'
i
§iZf?.?"_.__,_...._.~_5"
* .
.'
t . 2-
b-
--~
*
1*
1-ii:-;=Q;E*ri.1:-u-:§xza1.§§;.*2.§;;'
"
'
~--==-
.
-
'
''
'
FEDERAL BUREAU.01?mvmsnemnon.
-
-
-"'""""""""""*i"" *
_
_
.
.
--"'De==~'=f'm
.-_"o'e.,g"g
.
v
bqc _
was'.'interviewéa
at
'Ca.1'l'lE
Eff-Isent to-r-~-the
DE1t3..interview were SA . _.'
ms
-"
Ser:v:.ce
"{1jICIS!_,.
Llnqugstl
- '
" Iprovfde
Ci;|.._
.
I__»lfnVestA.§I_592-t_§|.92{e
_
'
IAljiblc
'
"'
' _N
. .
b?D'
FBI,'
N"
sA L,_*
. |_l_92Tav'a1
Cr i'1fni'nal-7
-. 2
I V*=t*+@ 11¢> r1 g~11##~=>@" ?i°11»t
V111
c
I .-:1
*=m¥1~?¥@Fi7°Y
_'
'
_ - -'I W
156-4
[.s'1t,§t§;d
- h§.~_'l1.-a_d.
been/be;éLte1;i
,1.;iiC_O_I'1S'Ci,C&
_1.
'
'
.'
~'
gL_gptQxi,mé.1i_E!
1Z_Q1','
l§!
weeks;'_é.g'o
i'._i@'1jI>_Jf-"i-f'<Z!I.11'.'
f_w_1_i_gn
- g-;Zwas__
.si':_i_Z|.l,
at -Q;;a1_:'_g_11§
__b?c-4 "'-Ray-.7
.Ac-;:érdigg_,__1:gI___
Y
I an,{1mJt:;pwn
n:ir|beL:;__o_§';_gua;_c'|.--,
1:111
-1 _ 1- =i;;j@@.=_¢:I.1-,
unpr@v,6lce; £_;ja.;_=1_s1=,a:tg,;1j'sigiuuinq
'aln'd_-cursing
-at. _1'1,ga,.'_
Thg -'
-
F '1
-gggzgs called--';him_
iI __50nQf a bsttch,"-anda. -"_ba;tta'.j:_c1',j_..then
gold
-
-h'e"=wa's
crazy.
'-
.J
_'
j
-
_|?
'
'
ulIQilE_§1:'O;Ii¬O:.
1 ;,J';._S:-_S_
_.tot- hiréiself
ad:
CC?lJ@i,C1l-;
.'
_
jC
-'
i .1:;§~.c'ausé'
'he'-_.h
receptl
I £641,
st
"Zad_ -_ '
omac]; _s_urqe:1ri
stated a"
gg'ld:_'_eI
11'a.1_m='.d'.-|__
_
_
_on_
h_i_§
_B,a__qk_-;é|=nd'_e;-t'§r.t~3d
.b_eat'i:1"1'
it; _
__ __
-b6L
MC
_ §tat
t-}:1e_
I .ed_t;na_ fa'&:e..
|1':hé_',
.1¢hQ}C-Eg'§'!:1i:i7m
1.u1_1;J;l
-hejpéssed
.ou.t'§_|
waibeatxn
hm becgguse
'
. __ig;'__a"92}§;ug;_:i;_;_;;
-,-j_n
'
b-ID_
b7F -
"
HI!-<; n_|_|_is_;C11: :i.5;i.a.n.
|_-indigaiéd.
t3 ¢_1_e::;e--gays;
a. fem?-'1e
. -. ,_
~ 'gu'a.rd.-n.amed'._L
|whQ;92 also
92:as_
bj§a.t;_i.';_;cLhi:11"an<f1
qralgbgd--h-isThe__a-CI
'_
'
'
ani:1'b
E;éggtt
-
I
:|.'n-tg
;Ke-c.g.l__-£100
i
~
7 r. 7
_
-'
.
. '..- I
_'
.. _U
_,
. .
-_ 5iét§d'
;;hat'_;1l.
't13g__ié,Qldi_ers_wa
_11;i.'
- '
l.'9t_::_|I
P-I ,D__
a_'Cih
E",-¥'T|,--'11.§_ _92§[aS
_Q,_Elél-'~ldt
ZQOt1;1_¢"_1;1_<'::'sB;i.§T§l.§t'§ifQ
..
béa t :'.:1
-'
where
b5 -4
6
§r_e'-ajznliént'_fq_J;T§i§,,lfag-:'L_;.1
. i
w-ard.ei1,.
'f.¢hq'.'5.,s
a_'.'c.a.li'
ll.-£7::.i5;{-.1
"
'
1-92i;iérji_cajL1:;.__
vi-§;it'ed_l;3.';;q'
_m_é.J;e_,
'at_
1:hé_-hé$si c'.a.1_%pd
hold -the giodtors
to
137$
MD
*
' '
inrgediately
:';etu:_r;;
he
ca:n3'J1reDort'ed
-L=-the
'-»
'12
.
-I???._
I
.
he 'r._ecei3§d__an
'1w¬cn;n_<15__._-_ c-laimgé.
thg
.
._
§£oreme_I;!:_i_D11§§,
_J'.r1ci__ide_§1t__'tTg
Ltwc-RadCross re réjsentétives -at C
l.
7 | 5l:;a.ted____-ha?
'
_ _ I_J_@._'1_ta,._w1io
he-'_identi;f_i_e.-'d
-a.g;_|
_did
.
gzpgc.
_dd a-i13k!l:hinci_
to_.cau'.se
._1:_h'e-'
ggarais -to entie -.h"i.sdell.
- and did
-
'
_
_-'
e3rje'r§-'t.§;i_-i1g1:'_1;.e5:;
i'_nsJ:=ruc1:ed."hi_'m
jg do. _'
-Ihad
what
.!__ajgp_e
'
" . _to_bé,a. rec_e11t__wQi1m_;1:on._t_1ze=1;92;-idqe;7_of%_¬;§5nogeZ._ Z.~_
'
f
'
_- _ .
Egctlq
'-' _ ___I s_tal:,ed
't];':,at'_'-L-lye
_wl.'=1spJ.1t_'i_;1;
_a11_.-is_'c:la"c.:Lg::1
dell
'
._
-MD_1 '-After.
he?
wk i;;vclved_.i:g_a--diapute
-:.s_
_é>vé:|.;__£l:>q_g1,__gj..92!en_.tr:___
E
'.
'
- '
_b7F*1
I 7"
- _§tEd;e';1%th&t+h§; i>s uaa-aJ;&,e_-51;p;~eaJ.:_ica;:l:aj.g,;§c=_1;1da.,,___§_n
-pl_=1§;e.Q,
in __:i-sgilation_a.jt.'er.argtui;1é;_
wifghj
uaiilifl; _
"'.
'
.
___
3*
.
*'** :__ _
_ __1'
_ I ;
"
t
__
i
T
__;_;*_'*
tt
_
; _
inveénsn 2'
_"_5]L2
onbn
_. a1'_G;uag=;ta'r';ar-rno
Hal, Cuba__J
.- __
':
Fae»
2'65A--Mmlcé-9102"
'
- _" '
4,6-;_1',3"
'
D= ===rr=:===éi"s
23 6-2-. . .-7
~|
[-Nels
'_
-
'
~
I '
L'
7
_, .
.-
'Fb-soza'
I -R=v. 1o-6-951 '2
., .,_
115-4-. _'___ -'
a-
._b7C -4"-'
_. .gss_A-om-cs"9102
_con&5p=;_n;n=ufFD-iozér
-
'
's
-,"0n
___
. ,¬12g'
;p..;;. I
"b5 _;; ,_. 'j
. ' '
-stated -he
was
an -imam-at .the
'-4_"
_b7¢'Mosq'u_e
in -"
'_ b?D.~1
f foreigners
. b7F -1 '
to
be
audi Arabia..'_
-This mosque
-lI1' Saudi
Arabia for
an imam,
- '
- '
ewployment.- was qualified
because he -'h_ad'-memorized
sections
"two
of'the-Koran.
'
:- has had
-'
no jorrnal-religi-ous_tra.i_ni1ig-.
H '
"
-
_- " ' '
"
5-|____Z
|mE_ '.a Jordanian
male Ila-med
b6 -4,5,6 working atbakery
b?C 4,5,6 intere-sized -in
was"
frequented.
._in|
traveling -to
t-e-
|-
:
'_whi'l
_|t_o1d
he was -,
an
"meeting-a
woman to
'
e't_.UlS.
;
'b7D
c:i'tizer-1'ship.":
-1 U.S., and told
-his'.brother
:|citizenshi ,. so
b7F -1 , moved
-tofthe
i::pta'ine
U.S'.
-
had
_-; "
-
'
1'
'. 'arrar;g'ed
.a meeting
betweei-1| and'| .
II __
- -_- .j
" '''
''
as working
iii-'5a1 1d1_
-'wI.i_en|
Arabia
.i"r1et- him.
av
the
..-.e
__
.
___ rlndia-na
b7C _
name [,__.who
MD'
_Indi_ana_,__
mi '
ave
telephone n1imber'_of
his friend
_'_
'
'-_
11atned'.[
_ __
I -
in '
-. .
.
'
'
'mam"'
-_
worked at" 1'1'e'Is1am-ic-in~ -.
Center
'
-
. thou ht -that
w l1ing_to
elp
called and'.arrange
Islarnic Center.
. '
_- -_
'
rieeded
an
-ima1'nmayan3
wit '
istrip-
_
-to travel to
the
U..S. an_d __teachat
the,
'. "
' " '.
stated that-.'11,e'
was arrestedand .in'carcerated
'
-
I _-_i? _%a%di
Arabia
after b_ein'g;'ass'ociate
withT-whoan
armed robbery.
|:|
'
was
f.ri_end_s- with aman n d
-on-ned - '
'
a.__per:Eume'
st
' where
was.
-a re
'
In addition,
went. out-to" dinner
with
_-basi-s_.
an . __wo ofhis _£.ri'ends-"named-
_b7c_.were
. 1371:»
e
au i_
-ian
involved in"-an armed
ro_
-police .
"mp
_was an associate
of'|_¬
T
- '-
-"
with the
robbery, bu
was
also
en cus_tomer_.'
'
on a, regular 1'
ABE -
ery'arrested
an
by
-arrestedbecause he
'- -.
|statedhe 'h_ad_r'
todo-
_was coerced by torture
'.i_nvolved"'by
Saudi
Arabian .po1ice.the
to
admit
he was - --
'
spent two
years '
' --
in'carcerat'ed'in
apr:'!.son'
in]
year ac-er; he.._was
In. 1" E=leased.,-"he.
s¢t~"92er1"i@='i--'
I- -"1one1'
'
-". I-
-56
-4
.
we __4 | I
hm _1
an -1-;=>'24~Q
lworkea
for mel
..e I 1 c~
f<fo1v1P
Y j92_1s ti'T::uts-i
-a: .| k1{-e-~de-a
passport issues
for foreign
workers and
we'aah-- -¢
_repres"ented- the -company in
_bjlf _1 _-1-_ra£fic_vic_:1a-tionsinvoivi-ng_ foreign drivers. '- ' _
-__j '
'
I- h- '
'
advi_sed-' that
he_ took _a'tri1
3i i3har1is't
ito-. _-
_1989,
Arabian
when
ewas
sixteen years
old. _ At
t_h_e__ time, the
Saudi
,.
'
gove"-r_nment wasoffering-a .759; ;idis<:ou.nt on iairplarie t:i,c_kets'
_u
'
_.92
-RESPONSES 167
. '
.',
..
-
-_,i ||_|_
I
if .
' '-- -1| -
-- '
-"'Fcp3u1a n@v.1u4t9sj
..
..
'1=.'
'
a
.'
.
..
,-be-4'1.
-=1
'
--
. -b7C
-4-.
-_
-11
._265;?1.
M1924-CS{9_l_O2Q _mo "92b"»'F_
-1»
- Con!-tIinualinn.ofFD-302
of I
_I
II
,O11
'5/LZZLQQ
I '
: .P!I$=
_-;3_ Q
,-to Paki-stan-, the
or g$urp'os.e
of traveling
.'1;o'-Afghanistan
H-Flights I
' le_ft_
tlxrice awee1jc,__
and were--a1ways'boo}<:ed. _ '
.__
'. |_. trave1ed
frOm"Is'1ama.bad
Pakistan
to.--Pesha
.
guest housecalled, .B'eit;A1-Ansar.
. _The__
L
.b7C5.]_eader
J1
this
of
-house
was ar1_ex-Mujahid
from
S_a_r._1di_Ara
_b7D.,f
While he
was
at.the house.
ewas 1nfQrmed'there
were
two
military .b6 _45 and stayed in an
Arab
b7F._1 camps
for training-in~Afghanistan;
' 3 xshoirt term
trai-ning_,_
usually limited
_Farowk camp was for longer
training
The A1-Siddeék camp was for to ab ut two? weeks. - The All
_
e
7
-. -
' " "_ "'
-_'
'
_.- was' onabr ak,.'from
school-,'
he
..decid_ed_'
so:
to. attend the sho_rt'ei'_
-A._l Siddee_}c'
1'
'
camp_.
'*
-'
'
The'AL4Siddeek
camp
has
iocated nearKhowst, Kfohanistan.
[:::::::::]-rebeived training on.the KALASHNIKOV
ahd-physical _"'_ '
l
*b5
big _exercise.
He claimed 11:. -1~§as .very'
land
colfii
the camp's well
was - .-
mu~frozen- etat_ed
he
waeobese.
at'_the"and was.
unable.
time
=b7F'~
complete
t
to
e
training.
,He
attended
three
days'oi
" F ;"g_
-.'
_be£.ore".rsquesting
to-be sent- ho_m'e_. _H:|.s_;trainer
was
' 'from-Mecta;'Saudi ArabiaL_ ".-~ .
__.
- -'
J- wd
'.'-_w _'-_¢
- '" . I:I
trave'l'ecI
to Bo'sn_ia
-in 1.995.
3 At.the time.the '
'_wsss;.:rent_ingan aartmelgtwith
.
'- 'He=*.1as.tated
' S_heikI'PhisKwife-land-_strugg1i-ng
Ifr'om[
_I"Sauditi-hanci-ally
_Arabia'o
1_
_§.?C'_
pay
to his" and
rent
hm _if-:he_.would
1315
_
'
-
"
..
.
pro ed Him'_with
I?-[006 tol0,__0O0 __Saudi'_-Riy
_
agree .to journey to
Bosnia to
fight. He
1e£t_.Saudi..'- _-
Ara'b;i_a
withenother :_ 'Lan-_na_r§1ed
__W. ___
-' c-laimed
-his motivation
_pos-sibility
for traveling
to. Bosnia
II
--_-
was money iand t_he._
-.
_0f meeting a-.'woma:.'1.wasLimarried at -the
1;_ime,
"lo but. indicated the
marriage wasnot
working . .
_.
- '
.- tra§e1eH £romI:ISaudi
"to 'Zagreb
r_
.Fronizagreb the twotraveled
'
_. .-. __.'Croatia
p aneby.
on aCroa " V
' addressby/bus
to-Split.
,Croatia.. had
an -_
i
Slitp 1:1
'
- from'
_
Ihis
cousin who'wor_ked
for AL HAI.'A'AL
L=._'EJAMI'
OLYAA
'TABAROA'I'
AL
~- LIMOBADAI MUSLIM1 AL BOSNIA AL_RIYADH}'"The_translationfor this
-»
106 name means.-The'High.
Committee" to -Collect Donations
for the_Mus1ims_- .
...b7C'
___92__'in__Bo'snia'_,.H-_
Rigadh, Saudi. Arabia. ,~Th-is organization was
chaired by -I.
23? I - -SaudiPrince B7iI1f 1EHDEL_'3£ZIZ .. _"Th"e-"two-'s'c
b V-.of the_High Committee
in
SpIitJ[:;;::fi::¥mentioned
the_Haramay
the beach
in'..Spli_t for two_' orthreeda -s. - They
' _or-gani-zation
- Haramayn
was also
the Arab
houses
sugport provided
.'
'
I 7
.
iI 1VDlVEd'J.IIl osniaw ile
organization supp-lied
_
W
in
Bosnia;
he
was
_
_
_
off-ices .-
there. '
The '
supp-l_i'e's,
money-and
to
no_knowledge-of any
_' Haramayn
was chaired
Iand
Shei1cI:I'orI:|
r
_. _
:He had
by Haramayn,
._-
food, medica1-
visited the
military-
by Sheik.
=-
-Haramayzfwas -
' Responses 1/as
.'
-"
_
.
I.
'
_.
r-
-.,
_- .' -
.I1'_;
'.
-'
.
nmmnauvmssn
._ E7
;
-f l_*
J
F"
-
I
265A-MM-cssioz
b6 Q4
b7C -4_
'
.
b?D
L
=
b?F
L___
W
'
Cun nua_;_J
unofFI¥3DiufJ
o,.oi1_51_2;1L02,
1""
_.»_==;=
''4&#
_ headciuartered
in
R'ivadli§-'Sa'uc
Mabia'.'
sta-tedlithis
was
all-common knowledge in-Saudi Arabia _.
.r _ ___ _ - o._~
'
b6 -4
b7C 4
b7D
-1
b7F -1
They'boarded-a-bus
in Split_andtraveledto
me; with1a'grqup
ef-Ara
b
s
f
B
igh t ing_wi":1-1-ean
'Ar"
Th
osnian
f_ Contactinformationfor this group.was_
rovideoib I
group of Arabs were
called
.92__
. . ; . A1-my '-_Th-ey_
traveled to
b6
I
t'
M "'
B
th_
B
'
opera
ions
in osnia_w1 t _'
e OE-_I'J.J."-9.1'l.-
--E
_'s'
headquarters"
in
Zenioaand 92
_c1id.not__li'1-:'e
the
AL-KATEIEBA
"group
staY ed for a few--_da'
Y s_.',
-b7C
because
of the. strict
"e
HYW |. Ihe
stated
group tE3s
AL~KATEEBA.
1'
'
- -_wa5_j_11vc
V_Ed."iI1_
military
.
Zenica,'Bo
-1
'dlSC1P1E
and-harsh
schedule
-'
stated
he
was
forced
to-get
up
every
morning
before
tgeS wi&11|:|
l.lI1IlS6&#
_- '
ra erand Aves
notallowed
to retiirnto Sleep.-IHe_.ple'atie.d.
5'
b7D
b7F
in"
Bosnia
'Al*Zu.bair
H -J_' to go to Q different
__ P Qrou
__P'
|_ called
_'_
.I
-- : -_
l-A1_}Zubair was also involved 1n_mil1tary operations w1th_the.Bosnia =e
' Army,'.but=-was
_not__'as
s_tri'ct wit:h
:ii,scip_le.'_'
Al-Zubair had A-rah
'"
-houses in-Trzavnil-:1,"
_'I
'and.ano1iherqL;ni:1enti.£_ied
u1s__a-,
city_.-|
" otated
..present
Zubair
_-
houses would gen picked
up
the Arabs_at.the
weapons,"
house
-I::|w¢ @
"ts the Travnik Arab
remainder of-his time in Bosnia;
.
by'the.Bosnian-
and taken to fi ht. -There were no weapons :_
heard AL .KA'I and
EEBA_
Al ._
at any of the _hquses._
92l~.'ere'rec'eiving'
..weapons through the Croa.tian mafi_a
from.'_Ii"an.
Army,-. issued
where he spent the I
.
'.
'-'-*1
'-
I'b6
'4
'
cQdk'
[::;%:iff%%;g%g;;g:Looking
and
after
the
Arabs
at_the.ho
was
'b7c
-4 'discovere
j. is .they"
ta1e_nt,_
at
the
Travnik
b7F -1'=
military-operations
he
as
served
the
a"l1owe d-.him'to
[stay '_at_.the.t and.
1'ouse
_
bin-1
" 'pe-rform
Ehe.'coo"king
duties. . |:|
1
house
den-iedinvc>l_ve1'"ne'nt
with<_any
in Bosnia. fQ
,
''
,»_
@*.
Q '..
in Boenia, he learned-'
his wife 15
-
Ego
_
Saudi
_
was
he
pregnant,
BO
was
forced
to
retur
_o
' '
with the leaderof the house
in Travnikname
_
bqn _'
b 15
Arabia
and wes_given pe
'
trave
_ " spent
"
l'
:return to Saudi.
.-
a-Sau¢i'
,
'
'
from '
Jeddah
who had
*_ i
fou,r'months"'
fighting in Bosnia.
|thought__
ed to
Saudi
with
-ii_nm_in,ma_g@Qd*;;§g§l;Qg;E§rtner;beoause
he was not a devout Muslim and.
_
'
"
wasI
' -~'
_enjoyed having agood"E'irr1iéti*****
?-*vé
§1_'Ti1[-=1
l i.n*';;
-" _*.-".'T"':*
-~------ ------_-~---~
---
'
'_
h
k
55
b7c
W77
_-governmen- an
oreign
»"-~
|J5eturned
toSautli
Arabia
and
worked
a-tag];
Contractors
as a liaison between
the Sau
1
workers in.Saudi.
He worked for the com an
b7F
fora roximately
ei htmonths
toone
While
working
atEj%:jY
.-_ _=_'
Contract:ors;,
idecided| year;
totake
ga
trip
toMeceaand
bTD
".-
-'visited
in Je
a_ on
is Way homeifrom Mecca.
RESPONSES-"169.
-
I "1
_I
-e
-17 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIQIIII-IiIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
1
. ,1 ,._
I.-._i.
.' .;-
I- '-f__.
V
__ __ - -__.
__
x ; ::! o
*?"@-3D1= r@=%:1v-bi§si~
f. .- '~-. _n.
:b6 -4
.: '
' b?C-4
-':b?D -1-,
I255A-MM-C99102
-'. .b7?
'
ni
cnnnnun nn nr_F0-302
or .. '
i Al_so_92ir:._I <1 " g the
_l_-_-iiime
,-__
-1 i
L -<>=1§>/2;/91
Y fan
e §_;i_
was -int-roduoed
two
to 'indi§ridoa:ls&
I
,9;
_.
~ 'fr%%,E]fe
Arab Emirates
United
by his,
frien?!
. _ introduced
_
s this owI'1er'of_a_'pe-rfume
in
.He shop
if __'a
dire_'ct.
descendan
nine: nnh'ammna'
and an unidenfifie man
oi Indian
descent
.''
-'
to.
né L
-.took s bhone|'1"1'u11ibe'r
arid' hirn":i.n
qozitacted
1§96 -
b7C
b7D
b7F "
ja trip to the Uni.te'd_- Arab
__jlhernhe
Emirates-.
_ar_r-ived at_E'"
5 hgmé
in
AbuHDhabi
in
the
Emirates,.he.learned the-two'wereo
»
.1 I, j '
'p1.anni__ng
-trip. iio-aChechnya;--"_They. i;1vii:e<i'|
W
[to go"t:_o_'
'
3
Chechn
_
Yg a no fiht
.
mone for the tri
with
them.
- jtoldl
l
i
'
I
Ihe had no
l
.
Itold him not to worry'and
provided =f
" 1-'1'-ir'n.with
Riyals
,S.aucj._':i.
-in addition to
expenses; 3,00-U-'to'4¢,-000
f' _Q_ [
.fh
trave1__
_
,- 3 .1 ._
The -g1joup'_-'f1ew_
to Baku
Azerbai an and-"e'Eayedlat'_ar1_-'.
,_
5
1_1-r|1i<':§enti£i'ed.hot.el_
in
.1_:he
city
-_
|
called
'coi1tac&
a
ah
__
__
-safe" house in
arr -uni-denti'f_ie oca_tJ._o11-_'._and they-were-fdriven
to
- __
- lb6
'b7C
-b7D
.b7F
_
arrived at_.the'
housejU.I1E
he 1cte
me;
_'and'_a.z1ot"ber
Sauc1i_named
-
__
'
.,_
spent the-next
'{:wo'monT_:hs
"the safeat -house» During.
I:bis=_time,. _- ..
they _'went.
on. wa"_l1{S,.r-ode the 'm"erry¢gorr_o u.nd," and=_went
sightseeing. "I .
_.The_<-.'s_afewas
house
'a
eta in
_a,rea=for'Arabs. tr.ave_lirig_-tq.=Che-chi1ya_. _
-'
. ,- .t"¢-if-ight,
when
but-was.
t:,here_'the_
ro te was'_
and 3no c
one was"able" t:o-get -Into
ech-nya. -.After ntwo mo_11"r;'_hs.,~ a1-1d ,._ I
.'-|:]were -boredand returned.home,-_
'
.' _'
- ._.;
%dec1de:1=tc>
we in-51:
parents
-of i
_'
-' "unidentified
"-
92
-
'amount_
time
of 'in_..Saudi
'-Arabia~ '
6. friend-who
" '1led
-in Bosni-a..
They traveled
a"
b6 _4
5 6_1:o 'Bahra_j_;1.a'nd
balked istoan_to 's_'bro_t
The
three
'
I
_fiht g_ .
*wo unteered
- ._'
.'to'-._
'
'
'1
b-;c _4l5,5decided -to-tra've_1
co Ta,
mg _1 mon
_f_inan§:e
tripthe
and;gave'-him
amop.n_t_
.a'n._&
of
e§{'p1L15 -travelinge1-@ense_s.. '
The-Igroup traveled
by vehicle
back :
, '._. to_Saudi Arabia end evehtually be Kuwait -They '_de,airlipe '[
. .'
re-gervatiions to'f1y..to'
Pakistan.
Sa;id a the ; .
b7F *1
. -connecbions
-
necessary to
-----__...._92__._...__.________-_________
'_i .-_-
. -
.
get; them to Ta3.:Lkistan_.
I-_
- -W_hile~t.he'_-group-_was
incident'at'the'Khobar,Towers
b6 b?C b7D " b7F
-
.-
.
group" was
-detained"-by Kuwaiti,
the..;in
erro
ations.
up. returned
the group
Wei 'f1gT 1 h Kt1wai.§t""f or'*a-fiiirghtq---
in
Saudi
Arabia -occurred
Intelligence for
teh days-
was re
ea e"
W]...
ou'
1 'd."t;hth'
_ _jinto Bahra
and|_
gla s until things'_re{turned to
1c ar
and-'_the- "
.Following
e21 atlslit
p
-
!went to -".
Wh e- inr ' '-
for two
normaf.
Qatag,
{and
7
a_|had
a
disagreement
'
"anal
l'*i |[Hepartec1'
or
an 1-lni_ent'i§iec1
,overmone
decided'-"to
~location._
. .Qa1_:a r
' RESPONSES-1'70
'
_
n.
..-
-_
-.-
.
.
_,
-
.
.
.
;
" FD~302a{R:vI.lU~é-953
_
'_ *
'1
.'-
,'
.
_"be
.3'
__,
._ b7C
-' '
-
_.. '
' 1
' '
'
'
-~
.
-4
1
-4 1
-r
b7D -1
'
' 265A-Mlfi-92C99lD-2
'
_
ms -1_
..C='"?1'"" F*""°1'PD-361
9r|'92_'.
POF.
=§:=1_Y_j
"
_retdrn to-Saudi.Arabiai so he
flew
' parehts tQ piCk
him up.f.
to Bahrain-andleailehis '
e 7- h
.;'.»
- _'K _-.5
- -,- -
~b6 4"
-'
H.
_On his way.£rom
Bahrain.to Saudi
ArabiaI [::::::::]ums-b7D'
' arrested-by'
Saudi.'1-ntelligence under suspioion s1:emming
from the
.Khobar_Towers bombing
and his
' prisonin Dammam where he
-was
'_
'
interrbgatiohb
b5 _4 _ aapproximatel-y
b?C -4
579 '1
_
foreign travel.
-Be was sent to -- =' "
beaten for .two_we_eJ1:'sto.pri'0r
his
He was detained by the Saudi government-f0r_;, j_,._
three months and _re'lea-segi.
fl sis passport wa's .r'e_Vok_ec
forfone and-_-a
half:-_year's._.-_-He
,
retizrnedhome
and mfas-1_1J.red_
as an_'
-.
b"- D -1' Imam
in a-
- h' "n H-
local mosque.
' --Two"week
a ter shis
. '
- '"
detained by
-b5 "4
the Sa di
"and interrogated'four
b7C -?
Durin this
,fi?e years.
I
passport 'was,-_returne_c1,'__
he
_wa-is again ,-_
government." He"was
taken to
prison i
times-over_the-next month-and
"¥ELeaSed and returned to|
_b7D L-
time he; -was 1'13-5°
f= FflPlE?yed by. -
iiIblaimed
_I
but his
Jeddah
ahalf.*
He was'.:
passport was revoked for
to be unaware of
the reasons
b7F -1 ' his
apprehension and.passport revocation; _-'
19- "V |
-
behihd ,
'
jt;
." '- ''
.'
'
In- i998 the Bfahr_ain'.gove'rnment
anno92.u1cec_1wasit reissuing
, --
_ Bahraini
ass ort-s to membersof the -
tribe -in, Saudi
_
_ .-
55 _Arabia-.'§..
s father
was originally
from Bahrain and as a '
b7C ' result
'
was
able to receive a.Bahraini'__pas'spor't..
[:1 ''b7D
.ec~:Ee'c!1:e
ooul-d no'lo_hgerflive-in: Saudiiarabia
because of_
eof
overnment
He_p=
lanned
oh oin
to live
b7F *
_e"
pars cot-ion
-_the-_g
I 1.
'
_ _ _in-j '
. _-."-_Kuwa-it
or"-the United-Arab
Emirat-e_s,~
,andbut--met
'
'
'
.
...'.
decided.to.itravel to
the--U.S._ . '
'
¢'
_'
_ _'1
.
' 'trave1ed
visited
to'Bahrjain-and
the-U.S.
-.
a' five"year
tourism visa.
s ather
_ _embassy "an received
be 1:=?c -
.gave him
-- 1
.Bahrair
to
the airport.b
center in
19,000 Saudi Riyals for
h-is trip
ISt&I 1]QJ.1 to] 7and ,,|to| I
_"
'IN.. was
b?D '
'
en a _. W
, __ if
.- .c
to the
ter t
u.s_. jse flew Erorri- was-Ip
icked _up
at
_.
__ '
took_him.to the.Islamic
moved to the Islam-io
_
_'
' .,
_|.'IN'.
-_ 'He
" '
_w
'saud:|..__.Arabia-I to
C,
b"- F '_________h____j_o1q;_ap_pro§imat-e_J.§-;t§{o
months_ before returning to
..
.
' '
visit hissiok fathefT*Z§It¬T eightrmonths*in Saedi+Arab¥
_
_returned_tO
the U.S. hHe'speht aboht'ten
jays in_Wes '
3
--before
he
was transferredthe
tg Iflamio
center
oh
the _
___
__Z
approxfnatelyf -s-ix and.aha
side trips
to Michigan
' Arabia:for two or
threeweel-cs after
_
.
and Buffalo,
three months,
the Trade
..._
months
NY- _He
then retarded
IN.' He spent -
W
-_j
.
|.but,also- made.'.
returned to
Saudi .-.'
to_Buffa1o, NY
until
Center.di'saster. 'I-Ie--£1.-ew
to _Bahra:i.n
RESPONSES-17i____
_
'
.
_
=~
.'T- ~-
.1
1i
-'
-
-
.
.
- _
_
__fb6 *4 al
-- "
.
.
92
. __ _
,
~-
'
'-.
"- .ED=3Uia{R:v.1Qw5-95}
'
.P ~i§¬
.-'.I
_
bvc -4
_
__b.?D __1.
- 2-55A-MM-c9s1o.2
..-
- ;_-'b'»'F
1'92.
__CunLinua..t-ion-nfFD-E-02
of._
-. |
I _ -'
,OrI__5
'22£9g_,&#
H_.Pl§=
_.-7iii
- £01:-two
c'1ays,
to-'Ir'an_w1ie_1;e
th_er;he,met
his
'con'
_»~
' '
_'
_
'
'_for
themosqué_tour.0f
Afghanistan.
1I
- I '
-
""
,;~;
--
b7C
-5
J
-'_U-
1
I
e
It
_I
_I
1
-_........,-.-.-............--....-__._,
_-..__________....,._,.,_,___,_.__._.-.___.,.
..._-__
.._,.... . ._..-,_._
._._-
6 g-
.
L
F
l
1»
_
.
_'.;
'RESPQNSES-"-1Y2
_ ._
.
I
J
I
}
I
Positive
Response
Number10
,I
:-
i"
ii------- -
.
. ._-1
__
-
I 92
_Capi'oni Valerie,-E. OGC}'[F-BI!
I
'
--'
ia 1 _ -I-NSD!tFBl!;
. .
V.~
- -.
.'
J --l-1°
- - ii 'f'R>'
l
I F7e|!'__
we -1 '_ Sent:'
Munday,AuQust02.20042:45.. PM
'
-_'c==j
_ -"
C_§e|'prcni,Valeriei'
_
_",
_._$uPjec!;;i8E;__GTMQ"_
H .. ,_
I
' -"
'
_-
.- .-
I OK,
thanl-ca
foriiie
e|_uick. respie|'i_se.._'
'
F "
" -jiiiiriginal
-
From:
IR!- FBI!,
92_
L ."
_.
0*"; '"
05*!'_:
I
'
l
H -_
_
_* °f'1
_'--Te::=e1!-- . zuse!
_#16
1
JSent:M0nda Au est C|2, 2001i2:40"PM
-
__ '
_5|gb]e :_'
- -- .
-
"
._ I-.was-situated.
in'thé"observatioi1._bcib1;h-in
i_ntew_iew
befWéer'1._.tWo
roems,
-qbservihg intefview
an
whibh
'_
'
-I.
ir.1c|uded-ai.-Ieasi-'dne_FB-i'SA,?and'-pdseibly
bf ti_1e.oa.col|eague.of'his-_fri:r!1&
agencies
th_er
with
-._.. _'
inivesitgatiye. pers'onnel_
agsigneil tl'.ie_r_e'a_t-the_
time.
The
bdoth 92.-.ias_quile
créwded because.
there were
" Iseuerelindivid-uais.
present
who were
obsenging-an "ihter92iiew"
_in' '1e.r0orrg
thenther side
_of'the_
bn
'
booth. .
. th
in a1'rbom',_tl'ie
wae seated
in-'a
detainee
andch_ai_r
was
seciired-in the
game method
as I'd
-seen for
all _of.
' '
_'_:the
ether; detainees,
shackled at
his fee!so -that
he
cquld notIeaxve
t_h'e
r_e-orn_. Hoyveiverk
there _wan1u;:_h'
sn t __'
.
";ta|_k'ing
geing
on,-be'ca'i.:se
thei-|ights'had be_en'tumed~off
and _a
St|'0§:ie7|igiJiwas= ar.1d=0ff.3
ickeririg on .d-"= i
- _1m:i.ud-rock
mus_ic.wa§.being played.
'.l estimate.
that this
went info'r.30
60 minutes.
to I wastold byquite a. ' '__-Jew
FBI-pei'sc1>nr!e_'|
iaétics such-as
this-were
that quite-'comrnpn.theThis_.vi_ras-the'Qnly'
re_attheiime.
.ever_ it thatl.ob$eirveddirei:t|y. '_'- _I
r-
< _.
. be-1
1" ..
-_
_- .
'
. _''_ "_ _ 1-
1
H "_il.'».-;»4:;é1 :}ei.i¢i;=.~=$'=_1a;-_;'
T 'i
.'
LPram-=ik1~s:~»>'<+=B1>-V.-V~V
Sent
'
and
Au ust02,2Cr0411U3AM
- 5u_bect:'_
:_ ..
"-
'
_
;_ q.L'Ji;,____._
"_
,
-
1
_
_' b?c
~1 . |:|-could yc_.=u.piease_prcividi=.=:"ad,ditio|::alinforrnation,-rn'o:e
spet_:i
<': short
si,|rg_|rji1ary!_
_,-- -.
-'"'"' _d1§'I§e ie'd*oT1"tha'i"d"rie*i1'rcidenL"-+~
-*-. --- - *-~------'~
f-.- -r----~
- - ~->4 --
' .-
I._
.. .
_
. _
_ _
._
.
'
'
'.
'
- f_'--3-#O'ri
i'naiMesea'
-
L ~Fmm= IR!
_H -I1
_. 1.
I ll;
' ' '
''
'' '
-FBI! i
. b'i
_-.1.
l'
'Te:
C
;Nm!' Fe1j'
' be
'1
-,
Sent:
Fricla
- --._5lIbJ==t=
J 1 0.92004
4:10
.-
-
PM
j
.II'i'lp_0I'E3._I'lFe:
_
High
.L
Vi
l -Gm-'5I-.r'92A'.
'_ __
»..
..
RE_SPONSES._:173_ . _
u._
-
.'_'
., . -I
I -
._ I
I
-
- _Ret
cm» e'_'-.ma-itmessage
from-Steven C ;-Mci3
mime
rew:rece.ived
oh_Friday,
Joly Def
2oo4..,¢_
I-
~" -
_
:-.
h
As amembefof the
Nationatcerperthe
for'A_naiysie'cf
Violen_t_C me NCAVC!
in-the.
_3
Criticzii _lncidentResponse
Group _ CIRG!,,i
was
assigned to
a.tour_at GTMQ from
Juiy--224,'
2003.1-.Whi|ethe|_-e,
provided
l
inten.§iewlinten'ogation_
adviceto
F Bi. SAswho weretinvolvegi in -
ongoing interactions
with detainees.
_|'dire_ct|y [4
observed
intewiews
with12
detaineee. - _'
'
.DUring one
of theseinterviewsam
I notlsure
which one
at
this time!, I-observed
treatmeiit of _
another detainee
by at
di ereht'interview'team,which
included teptics
tha__t, while
not.ove'rIy _
'
2iggres$ive,'
I
clearly
werenotoonsistentwith Buieau-interview-poIicy!g uide|i|j1es.
To my_'
.
-i '
knowledge, there
were noFBI personnel
invclyed in-thatinterview.
I donot recallat
this time - I
tI
the identities
or agency
af iiations of
those who
were irwolxfed
in that
interview.
" .''
"
-.5!-arting,~ne"_!ct
i92_'ion"dey,-ItiuIyl_'1-2,-fDD4',
will be
ihttevet
statue in Sanblielgo
Ceiifotnia,
.'
arid &
-
..~.- J,- J.1.§':19L89§i
Al.¤!<.El..|..i :'i||
P¢..?E92 M0
?! 5°!
fl1|l'WBB|<5F9.tL1'Ti.i"9
mitt
? T°9.'°"
to.M° daY1 J -"3'?
_'.__'26'."My.direct'té1ephohe'n
g
'
.-_
'
'---SA
-
. .-
._
..=tat-_1|n-._._,
--
---
---_,---- ---¢-.-
-.... - - -
J.b?C
.
-1' -
,
.
;. =.._._..._._._.92.._.;.__4.__
_-_ ._-_._;__...........-.. -.-..'_............:|.-_........-.,......-...-....._.
.._.__
....._
._.
.'
''
I
'
92
.-. __ ______,_
<
_
_"__RES'P_ONSES-1:74
-' '.ti.n:-anri.4-'7
. ,
1-
'
"
_
' '_'.
'. .-
i
.
1
Positive
Response
Number 11
o
______
' **
__
t ,-L
>1'-Meé's_a'ge3
b6 1
Wms.o_
FB|!
W
7. .7:
I __
H
'
--
b-TC--5'1
|: LD!tFB1!
._'Pagé
_
P __ Y-__ ___1_j_I
' ?
if --;__ Vi-_-__ -_.-. -
-
- .lL<?"'v
- -t
.
" =-t Su'5joot:RE;'.";TMO
_.
__'"_v?".%.
t
V¢o
ot
J
_'O|'<_..for
now__W.é-v!riI|_oo_u_r!l
as a_."P0§iti92f§"'
F ponjse.
d_o_'the.
'P}oa§o
anti
you.!
fob.-f|ard.
__
'_
U -_J{-i.
EC Jj92_
_
V~T - +~@ H-'!a=M@1=sa
8--'-t
»
'
L. ~I = V
%1,+
b6 -1.¢F~i |<w>
FBI!
- _ SH_&H,,92
-bqq;
-1
Sent:
Monday,
Jul?200412,
PM
-1:31
---_
ti!-1*- _.
.'
-_
- -To:
W - .- -Sl.Ib.iect_:RE:_G
l M0
Q
I
--
.
_-; -
IN5D! FBQ ~'
.-
r ..-
-.
_'
§E_N$I"r'1yE
am UNCLASSIFIED
..
-
--
;-- ¢ _~¥':j--- ~¥~N N-»RE§ E-B%_:1"_:
_¢j j
b7C -1,
~t-
'_.-,-.@::<'.§iZ3'j?".t;"ieir1
"
.
..,.-1».-.'
.-=.wa;_-l=-='-'."
~ ..'
-
."- L- ,3-e.
-'
1 1'
- '
-'
'
-
__:~>+-j
..¥<" .''
'--~"»-_--_
w---&
H-' %
.any
n'
"' . 1/__o
agpgare
uJ
agjressivé treah'nent-of'det;T
one
déinee
oes.'"_ --
nblodshot
age
_0
__eyes
an
wd hat
'
jagpearsto b'bI
e _0051
tha1"'
congea
ed
to'h|s_e1glashe§4
7I-
I'
_am following thise-mail
up withan
EC and enclosure
that willcontain CD
a _wjth
the original
Raw iesand _.
-irnagoscotwerted
to
the TIFF format
- l'a_n1
aIso'ir|c|udiF.I9'
ranging-from
prints
féce
full to
close ups:'of-the.
_-- _ .'_
dotaineo; s'eyeo!
r
._l_.I__
-.1
'"
'TI V --.
bis .'1'
'
pecra
'
Hotographic
Unitflr
.- _'
.- .'
'
.Lab_orator!¥
'
Div'i5iOH'''
,
.
- --O oi aim-$89? -"
' I
M_cc_RAw-, STEVEN
C.. INSD_!. FBI!. -1
- Fnom:
u|" 12
1Sent:
T0:
_0I
to
-
20041213?
=.-
.- .-_
-"
'
MM!.
FBI.'
co -_ M_M
f_;h6 -1
"b7C -1
'
HO! FBI! . _
MMHFB1!: o
.umFBI
_Ho!_ FB1';
, _sJL FB1~-FBI!; NY!
FBI!; NO!
-
.
FBI!; DL!
FBI! IR!.{FBI
-ll!
=!;
Ktm!'
-15H.
A"-0; _,
FBI!; AN!
-- NY!
"L5-!__ s1-
A o' FB_I!;
1
l l'" FBI!,
-
M!" FB1!
FBI-'
SE!- IR
,--
no
FBI!;
V - F-B
"FBI;_
CUMMINGS
ARTHUR CTD
M; FBI]
mo
_-
=B'I!_; FBI!;
co
FBI.- J: '
- MM!
_
FBQIL ITPX!
.
_
G0!
Est!; w
MY!» ~
_
ow!
MM!.
.Y_ -
'='
{FBI};
_SF. FBI!;
sF!__ Fa1
FBI -~
_
_"
.2-,
-1
Mo!-, * t
Ho!
3
_
»*'- L-"-
MM Fat!;
Fer-!:|++|£N+<!
c%I!QPX! oak!;
V
~
"
RESPONSES-175!."
1.' -?:12k:é004--_.-
-_
.
A50 . -_.l* .1I*'l3' FBI
-t~Y c@GA!: I<><
FBI!; '
FBI~!;
FBI!; MM!
FBI!; MM!
Far!,'
'
,
.I.-D!» F.BI]';'
_
Jow!
._ FBI!; -_ _'Tl'D} FBI HO! _OGAFBI cG! FsI
i_ MM! Fat!! --MM
.
Hom=BI!;
-<IB~1<EB-I!.~
.
FBI!;
FBI!:
lcm!
CF13.-HFBI
NY -FBI
L
@115! FBI
;aAT'n_E,"FR
Cm! -ANIQE
FBI-
oMM!<PB1!!<w~>ctFe1 cw:.c==BI-
92
.
-- ,
31
MM! FBI!
FBI
NYUFBI 7
_Ho!. =BI!;
-
----------------IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
_ I|I|I|u_ _ 7_+
f
_
7
___7
492
a'
'Q
£Révjo1J$1-zone!
Y
'_'
::::j
3
j 3;
a'
_q-"----.J _" :::! *-'
1 '
'
..
ii=£p|:aAL?
"- Pi'ec:édence':
" ROUTINE-'
.'
To*'-Counterterrorism
._'-
"
-
-'
..-
.Attn:
.
- ;Da.'t.e:
0:!/12 2oo4_
' b5*1
.
F#$§;a §abdiab0ty Qiviéianffi"
I Ia :
bjrc _l_
- a '?
:._ '_
" ~[ a - j' __ Photo
.SpeCial
ra.hic
Unit /[:::].__
b2 i. '
a#PPrPvéd'aBY=aaE::l#w
"L
b6 -1
=.b?C
-1
Drafted By:f:
jtb~ a
.-
" _
:.
%
'1
,:'' -
_
ciasa-In -#=-.29.1--HQ-Ai32?6.-69-A-a¢7{Pending!
.
'.,_
__
' -;~'Ti£ia}:aCbah£ar a:;O:ia@_D1§isioh;'§TMb,;fn$@a¢ti0h ép
I ~;Inqui;y@__- 'f
<_q* j =
_ 5synop§is{Happears
;,".:H
I"_a ;. _.
'92§,
U. ,
No bbservafian bf aggreasive treatment of detainéés
_ _Qbut ph@tQg;aphed-one-dapa;nee
who had_blood
to be bIoOd_t at_congeaLed to
shot eyes
Qia eye¥ashes.1-"
and what
~,Q'
"irt~;ae$d'f
La
_:'hr
:'~F§.Enclosure{s}:
Onecontaini
CD
g ga}l§
'
,_; 4; 5"[35
,,"éé;5 '>a.FBj,numbBr[::::::::]';SN
i _numbe;[__
é_ p btographedfgn
1b?C _fMa
ch_I2 2004 at_4;36 PMby {$&T} Phot0§raphEr]_
_|=af?
Fifteen
by
8.5
11
color
print5*of
the
detaanee
age
also
IZ"" ;; ,a[:::§]'
'
lHC
uded
this
in
enclosure..1Photographsfbf[:;§::]are
.
.
'_
'}a#ailable
from tha Special Pha£dgraphicfUnit,. uanticq{| r
Virginia;___.. ";_*.j
- _»,-_-_
_» »'_-_._" '. "a
u
.be_hl E$eta;i_ls:: _.'Ph6tb§fapha'r.'
'ah
Séi_anT;i'fiC
" __
C1 _'
i-' bn;_1 J Téchnicall
of the
Special Photographic
Unit,.Laboratory -.
¢§[''--a.Division,_was
1.
assigned
to tephbtographthe detainee's
far- eQ'
;5'. . - ' ug_sh6t$_o =severaL_days'and twO_travel'assignment5
f;¢m¢ ~_
1'
_'_March.11}to_March
2UO4._'H
I
_i - Durin thé.firat~aasig ment,.dn Mar¢h'lQ]'2004|__§
§- T _if
*
16; during-ZOQ4 ;nd_JunejIQ ta
I1;
-detainae~ FBI
nmmer IS-N
.nur]zber
;- _
;'.':$C*f4-_:1
jI
was photo§ra
bed and
Maan
Case printédat
4:36
H. . _PM,
.' ~- with
__' _
P" *
a;
-_
|.
.-
|
II
.It was
bbserved
that had
Slight.Syel1ing-arqund-his_le£t eye.
;photoq:aphs what
.eyelasnes_was
appears to
be blood
found. -No.observation
'lcod
b s h'
pt eye s
_After reviewing
the
tha;-qongéaled to
qas"madeTa$ ta
hw
his
this
.conditiop'came_about,_agd no
qomment$'whare heard
rom'aQy
**~ * *~ T~+
rmgdetainee.P
pe:s0nai"regardingwaqgréssive<treatment+%@wara&
%ha+
¢ '
'
.. .
' -= 'i'
-_- '
92
1.
_'
7
REsPoNsEs-1_?e._
.i
*-..-_ .' .._,-..|_..._,1:_T"':¬':
11;;
-ii-i" "'-';j-if
E-":1;.;=;;.-._;=i§;;-;-1-.-.':5-.--;::::?i.'fj;>-;:":=-=_;_
.._-.3"-1-:_.1_"
;-""-'_"-_7'_'._.='7
.11-.,.
-= _-..._-.=;.., =»....--;_;._.,-3-.¢._,.__1--=
______';
_
}
. . |.: -.- .. .
...
- --"?i|';'-'-'1'». ..
.-.-|_ -:-;-_-:=I_ ._.
- ._,-_-I.-;<-.r..'-.1
.._...-<- =.--1._.-._
;w:_-L..92_.1_-__
- -.-,_,_
..._h.,_--.;
_ _._.,.1 _i.A_..,l-;':_|-'.'_-_~_.;-*_.
'E.'*"'*'.i=_|,i
'
.!:.',.'F==.I-'.-'.'.-;
-'1E.-=-:=m'.'-;.-.;1-.;
P.-;_
:-¢1él-"';:'.-I.-9
-;.~;---,|-.-E:
..;.
-'.-.--...--:
r.--§:r:£'¥-'-=|'-'.-,;-'é,g§_'4
-=1
. '=-===1*=-:;-=-:.*.-¢'+»-_-. J.-_~'
-at
- H-.l:|;j_-LE
-M--~
-- :-524:
-'
.-.-.=1
- . -._-,
._-.1--,,
'.._01¢.,-,1
.,-1 -.
.-T. . ..,, -_
,_- _.=§¬=':yEt=_Y_;=-...I::;'T'92i_;-:11,£1.--1._-5-,3-,;
_;_"_ q_»
;~,--__--;_1-92=..-1.,_,;;,92,:n__-=u?g._g;;g
-__;_>=:92';>g"
"?~
"
.
. *'~
_ _92|a_-
p
~
_P~@=
.?9Y-HQ=1HI3'27-E'5 §=?WU?/12'!20;04'f"""'
_
.
.
were
observed
.f -',
7N0 other detaineeé
to have sim;lar
'conditiQns,
nor did I personally hear bf any comments
from fihe
jArmy pepsonnelponcérning
their
_
treatmentof the detainees,
hgtéfpénsonaliy
révigwed
my
wdrkfrq bQth-_-
t;T ".? f
assignmehtgtqpd not Seen_any
other
questipnable imagé5. ?
. *_
'~-
--
:I¥Dr.
< -1--Mr-.
5
»
.
a
r
Adams _
.
*
,
_-"-1"'M'1'.'
i _-.hire._1'.
'
.
1 Mr..
I
.
>.
92-
Y
-
_
I
92
_'
-'RE SPONSI_ES-'17_7
F_ _
.r ,
Positive
Response
ANumber 12s
' *92
¢
__
'?i_ |_"'
F-.
nu
l. _-
I
74'-_7
_
7
|-2on31'-- I'
..
"
[Rev.0F§
.. - l- __'.'
_:-|:|194j=bo1.5c§_&
V _ % .BU:RE.Ii1.I__§!_l5' l§iYE§fI-GATIO
V-_
-_
_P'i-écea.eeee.=V __
Date:
RC:-UT11§1E_
_;-07x12/20-0
1
T03; Inspeceion"¢.7'__
;i'j -Attnél
O¬f%de'0f
@6
Infeectio
--
- _
_b7C
- '-
-1
.
'
Rc0m7B37-
_sw
_
.___
_.. _ rm
,_H
__ ___ __ _ Ji 4ail;
.
=.
.-.-.
..- ._-- e;'14{JTTF
Squad'='
" '
'
-¬$fw;$7_
'
f-_.
From:e Denver._,._z
_"
- - - - Contact:
_
_
P~P1=='="= ~-BY"
l
__- _,_ __ I
1:61? ""
b'?C -1-
7-u
r,
_ m2
.h .--
...-
Drain,-=<1
- BY-i"
." "
*:
. e .
.
. -
?-.
V e
_ jLg
e
_:-

-
V
,T'_i ._f~ihF__i i_; _92_fT_
PP-'_1f1~?.=_.§
.?;:
.2.§F-3*
§1~§§§IH
.é§;;-22;_1;1
E=i=*e?t
-=* - .*{§'.§_F_.§-E-i'=
Q_.';.. -
Case 'I:>_'#="_
29?-HQ-A1321-s;_s9'~A-;.'
_. .-I2§§§Je»;
/ Pending-}."
I;1 s¢.@H;§iii2§.;_@
1
"|EEi1 i".92>.:*"1-:
V ~
E
.'I
I.-ceUNT'ea
i .cl e
'mv:s:0m;'_
:Emon1sM , 5
Gfmd
I 'I.N"SPE'CTIONSPECIAL.-INQUl'R1¬_
-" _;_- HERFIP!a;£§,1LTY2I*?I-§§,aIE.I1EI?
'
1
-"
- 5#1¥EB-E.-.§.PlPeh11¢§!2ir;e.&1§.1
-:0: in£6r.ma'c_i<;m.
iri_ _e'-_'ma'i1e
de't|ec1_
-' '
.
_
I
_éynopsis{ Reeponse requeet_
e
-07/O912004=regarding preeementdetainee5.gt'GTMQ
of
fT']
_ -1; " ¢"=
w
W
Details-. From ma --12,_2962-to June- Z-6-,_'_
@003, S-pecielAgent
.
I ,_ I-ISA} |
E EI Den-ve_r,
1served
a. __TDY
a_t: GTMO.'
c-nel
On
occasion during
the final
two weeks
oi thisTDY, SA[:::::1--~
' unknown'bt-erY
;1bs -1
- _b7c
~1
ebeerved=two other
unknewe individuals.from
government agency.t0nducting
utilizing-techniques that
an interview
an
with
adetainee.
.
1'
' "th'FB'
were get consistent-wl
Vi ,1_'
i_nt e'1'
p¢>1_i_
cy/guidelines92ri'e_w
-1 le,
and
w mh éd hi
. bi
éht=;'""fT _
'a5°.
l'
- P resent.
was
=56 -1
Y
'-
.
.
_
.
_
_
'._Ihe'inte;viewin§
techniques that
yere qbser ed
b§ BA.
involved the
two unkngwn-interviewers
from an unknown j,
@ 3'1
_ -otgex
geve£nment'ageney-eitting
a detainee
down
the
on floor
_
-in the
Cen en of
being played
an inperview'reom, while rap'type muslc waej
at.a very.high
player, and
while the
volume using-e
interviewers smdked
portable Radiofcn
cigers and
blew the
_
'
s oke'from these
cigare_towards'the-face of the detainee,-and_',
continueusly laughed at the deeeinee._ ' <.terview ~
' -
.
_
.
geec-hn=_a__q.u;es-ewere ee-en;by
__.._
e
-"
I-"-- room
glass ln 'an.adjacent
'
*' '"
eLneerv
eom "d"
ea
an were" -
b?C -1-
o'::>ser_<re@.fer'
. ew m:-7.nu'ce..s-.P'ri|e::
i_:o aS2- L.51-nd'~_SA
'_
_.'
--.
' '92
.
eRESPONSES-1?-'8."
'..-.
-"
-
i| --q
F
Q
1-___
_f-
j W?
7
_ I ":E§¥§E:EQ T$j_1t
n
15; Ineoection eFromE§'Denvet
_
Re:.'297-HQ Al32756$-A} 0?/12/;0u4_,
~-
H
I1i:¢:>-t I
b6 -l
b7C -1
~
vacating
detainee
the ape aFdue_to
physiqal
jbeing c
their intervie
eeesion.with enothei
tdontact ompleted.
detainee
in-this
_SA|:]d_:'.g1
-i'1ot.'obserire .any. giirect
.One o_
I,
. .
-a_-.._..1
-incident -from en
male, ep roximate
"'1
L77 hair.{_T
the interviewers
jbetween
inCide t
and the
__
the unknown.individuels-involved
unknown other
he other
government agency
in this=|
was a white ' '
;* ;'_
" Baeed
._t
,;i
fon
. .i]3A1
build. brown
f_'
~15? "
Fs_acquéiht3jces'
if
ian "<1 familia -;;y
__jf,
'with;cheL_ Z ®Névy
Criminal'1n¬eL;1genceeAgehcy.TNET3]j1ntervLewe:s; and-.
interviewe itGTMO during-this time.£zame}
.;b1 I?-
_
;_. -bl»
_' .._' T
it_is believed
with
<
-reasonable
certeint'-tnet
the'two'indi¢iduals
in this'
¬S!__
invo
ind iélent
_we
1-e -notlfE:l---N¬
;I~Si-;-----~~o
------r
beiieved that_these
wo in:e:viewe:é_mayYheye been from either -~
the Defense:Humint*Se;vioes,
Br contraoted
the Defense IntelligencéTAgency,."
in'so@E fashion
through-the US
I'
-" *1[::;;]did not
Army.1Q= ;,H
L~f
're¢iously:feport
inci&ent'e
itin not known
ySA[:::;:Twhat
interqiewing
I =-_ . - _
.j.___ =--'§A
b6
"1 .r
b7C -1
92
medium_build;.red
92
unknown other
gov ly 5'8"_to-5'10in height
aq- .
approximately~5'l indiyidual involved'in~thi5,incident.from
efnment agency
was a white-male,*
_ "1
o
;_
hair{eg1 a8Ses.e
1 to.6fl"'in height, large
_b7C
-I
-92-.
_.~-__
.V
;-
guidelineefpolity_£hat
not be_requ;red
to
adhere
ot
er
_*.
- I.
goyefpmept agencies
to. '
.7:
_
_
may or may'_-
92
_L
.
' Ihs
T61;
ection From: 'Denver'
_'f.'£'
_I
=88: 291-HQ-A1327a59 A;
_LEAD sI:
"
07 12/2004 ~:
'
_,_
'.-se£'Lead,1} ,,;£¢!'_.
- ..:Né?sc;;oN}'
;;
_
' w3§g;N@Tbni.nc
_AT
* ._§ .;._"
"_
.-
-
- i-7 _-'
Inquiry.
=' _ _l»_
++
-._
w
3;=.
'.
QFor'info$méti¢ td Cquncértefrorism Di§isio ,jGTM0J_f
Inspection Special
.-
.j
--
_--¢.
- - '_ ~
V ._
_-_-_ "'_'
- _._1'
..
77
7
_
-
-1 L
QWM _.
__...__"'_.-_'__._
.V-_
_
-, ,
4
'_"
7'*
1
"*
'
**
_
'7*" ~
'
'
'74
' '
_
-.
;____.
-92 '
-..._
92 .
"" '"""'r""
--
_REsP0NsEs-1801.
'
_r~
_--
._
77 _if
_
.
W
__
W ___
__|.._.__
7';_____-..._
1
ié
Positive 1
Response »s
Number 13%
If rjf
.-,.l
.
EI
I
__
___
-e
~
7
..
:1ll..:ll of-2. 1
h
.
...1'~?<=>>1Fe'>.r..
~-~_ ie»e.. . eel
e~"_'_
ii; 7 _ran C.
_ ;.,
W '1
Te e{1PJ
itsii" I I
i5:31
J*5
1I
_-
'
7_~1- -- 77-T . ._.e We --'-e
'
.7-7
Subject:_FtE:GTMO .'
Detaineefreatment
. -q__
'
I will putyou
down as
a 'positive
resp'onse.and
will make
OGC
adeterrnination
reference thetreatment
and f
.whether_an in_terview._is
required. _Tl1anl<
you _for
the re'sporise._- 3Ii -_ -
'
I.
.106 -1
..
_etc
-1-
_.'
- '
' '
'.
. --F
Fwmeiili <1P1v<rB1>==
. .
-Sent: Frida Ju U9 2004 5:19 PM '
f
.
I
I
1
¢.=== l<IPl
tFBI! P! FBIl; iP!
ire:.
Tc: NED!
FBI!
Subject: Detaineefreatrnent ._
_ _-'
, _ -
sE_1"us|T n!E"auT
-
BECQBl;L29l;HQ-m_§2?6B9-A '
.-'
"' " -
b7C -1
- _-_ __.;_'___-t_..
'
-
I ._ '
.'
n' .'
_
or
_in
_._
.
FP r
1 .-
a~-__.__ __-___'_..__-___._1__._,.
'
-
'
is"written_
This response
in
to,yo{rrinquiry'cor'1cerning'
tech'niques
on'Guantanamo
used
interview
detai_r_|ees_which.were
consistent
not with-Bureau
interview policylguidelines.
-. .'_ '
_. _.
- z
I -1wasTD- Yin Guantanait1 oiro'rh'Februar§r
to toMarcher,-'2'oq3.
there,
heard
I
th-roilgh
the
While
-_usual
rumor mill-{other
agents; jrnilitary
counterpartsiabout
technique
la
useclmilitary
b'y
iriiterrogators
which was
notallowed tohe Usedby
Agents.
The technique
was toleaveadetainee shacttledliri an
interrogation
roorn
for
an extended
period oftime,
twelve hoursi
or more
and
, either
turn the
"air conditioner
to itslowest '
possible temperature
or off.Supposedly, the
detainees were.
not removed
from theroorns even
to relieve
themselves.- This
was onlyused for
the "ditfcult
detainees who
would not
cooperate._ _'
: . '
_
_'~;One
whiiejn
day,
one
of theinterrogation buildings.
I wasin one
of theobserva_ti_o_n
which
looked
cooms
-at
intotwo-interrogation rooms.
I wasin thisroom because
the-detainee
was
I Interyi
éwing was
in oneof 1'
the
interrogation-roornobsewed from
-this room.
Laying on
the oorof -the
other intenogation
room was
a
detainee. believe_thi_s
I
detainee
was subiect
to theabove-mentionedextended stayin
the interrogation
_
ru0m_ '
-_
'. .'
."_
.
_
' Thedetainee
did notappear 'distresse'd.
The detainee
may possibly
-have been
asleep- t_-le
was"
dressed in
the
normat detainee jum_psuit.-His
leg shackles
were attached
to the
I-bolt lh thecenter of
the.
interrogation roomflodr
as per
SOP. do
I not
recall the
if detainee
was or
__waswearing
not
handcuffs.
I do
not recallobserving any
furniture inthe roornon whiclfthedetainee couldsit.The detainee
didQappear
tohave soiled
himself and
ididnot"0bserve any
uidon
the floor around-the
detainee. =
.
_:
I
J-
-
-I
_ I.
.
-Ido not [chow
how long
the detairieewas
in theroorrl
prior torny viewing
him orhowlong he
remained
there after
I sawhirn.I donot know
what the
temperaturethe
of in'terroga_tlon
room was
or ifthe air _
.__-_~_._i._._ ._..._,__.;,__,.eenditiening»was4;m-or-oil.-I-doindtJ<now+vmo.was.|:espoosibleioethis.detaineelsjniarmgatioo._.Ldo_no1
_
knowwho the
detainee was
nor would
I rebognize'him-as
ldonot recallseeing his
face. '
" J-
I do nohremerrlber anyone
if
was
wlthme-when observed
I
this
or
ifthere was someone.
who that
'
iridividl.la_l_ _l'
was.not remember
do
who lwasiriterviewing the
day thisoccurred. do
I notremember at-
what pointduring rnyTDY thisoccurred orwhat dayit was. This likelyoccurred inthe morningas thiswas
vifhen most
ermy
interrogations
tbok place... " '
.
.-
- _ "b6
Special Agent
- ~ .. r
,.-
1:12./zoom "
_-
I - .
e
_l '
'.
2
'
;
-'
f ,.
-1 "
Iltny full
hureau name
I-bqc
- Position:
_.
I
I
-I
-- ._
f___RESP,Ol ~.|SES
_
1_81
--
'_
.-
1'
'
:Message'
_ -- -'
'_
'3
I
.
'.
*_'
-' I_0'fc.#:
b2-5..
1
nI - I'
' .I Pa'gé20f2 1&
2
-
I
IWillbe O_r1
AL fr 0[I1
July 1310
13.'2004.'
'. 'SEN5ITlV_,E_L.lNCLAS_5_lF]ED
BUT
r
_
I
_____
__..__
_T_._._
'.
92
_._
______
____-
___
_____
__7
._.______ -.._7
.__.._...._?._-.,..__
1
>
...;
.- -----.___ 1
_777..-.92.+.-._____-_.*_____
__-_._»
- --
V;
_'z_/12z2o041_.
____.._ __...._
7
_ _
__._...
__ ._
?RESPONSES-182
7-7
-
..
71_7;...-;_._++ __
7 77_.-_----__ 7 _._! '7
.'._
Positive
Response
Number 14
--.1, ,._,,.
' '
.' " " Page-1'b

.-Meséagn.
1
.
be -1
___
70 ?|;0 i:~i
$0! Fa1!;-.
0 ..0
ee e _
_0-
? 7 ° 07
l°WFB'1i
' " 'Subj_eci:
GTMO
R-E:
'_
_.
_'
'Iwiil
OK,
eonsider en
that
posiihie
respqnse; Once
the fesponées
ere
re0eived.'delerminati0'ns
willbe made
as to .
" "-whuwillbe-irite_n:iewed.
Thanks.
.
1-
--
_: _"
_
92
. a
.'
_
. - -~Ori inEii'Messa .-e-.'
---.-
.
410 0 c':==-><0=>0
;-_-%5a';.Ir'.
/1
_. We_1.. -_Sent:Frida -Jul 002004 +020
PM .-
._'
" " To-: ~50_!' F0r!_
1,-
-- "
' _--'Sub_jer;t:RE:GTl"l0
_jI_- _j.
_SSlFIED_
-'1
'*
séN§i*E1i. ej§. u'r
mic
M
..0
_
1 .,. _
'". , ___._e__Q"-REWRTD
~ =0 .
_b6
_
.
_
. _._
.
.A
.-
; '
--
_I '
.'__
- '
~-
'
=--.;|f~-':-'
._. <.'
--92.::_-,.
I' _
I _'
___-__ _
_ _ _
-..____ _-.-_..--..__,_._
,
-1
b": C 1
,_
..
,.
_
.Whileat
GTMO,
005%.-~L=.=0-.é¢m@
"I
po'lig:'y
non-FBI
wa ; conducted
t'reetmeE|t'vJhi0
By nbri-Burreéuxand
I .
_'
1_nun-CITF per_'s0nne'|_
dsedon one
detainee;
beingdid-nut
obsenje any'ph';"sit:a1
mistreatment
anyof-,
_~_ b6 ~l . -detainee.
-"W
.
--|:l --
-:50-I-0.
._
_-r
_
'
"
- 1'
0 5-.
0 0 01.;
-
' '
.
1"'
"
'
--
0 RESPONSES-1830
b2 -1"---
---_~' E'JriginaI Message--. _
_. '-'
From:
MCCRAW,'S_TEVEI92l_C. IN$DJ_lfEBI'!
-'
__. I _
Ta. --
*'
'
_.--
--._b6
-1
LC
.-
-10 _.
~__-A
.
'Ser|t: 'Fn'day,.July
09', 1:42
Z004PM
MM§_ FB1-' i~1M!' z=0L};
HO} -FBI!;_'
.
o1_0;_.. c0r-1* M|"_!"F8I;
rw |=0r-
0 0_0_
[NY'
|=01- j_ -MM}_
FElI}'j
_0__cm!|'TLE
LA! FBI!_;LL&
T
I-lO!' I_=.BI]; ans;
-FBI -'-'BA
.FRANKIE
{FBI n
[[MM.! FB.I!;01 -C_V!_
.0! f-_ -F_B
. .
-HO!. FBI!; .sg_ F01-.
FBI!
J
.NY!_ FBI!;
' _1=01! r~10! _E0n'.
FE-'51!;
FBI00-00:!;
_ .0
0! F01!;
_" rm
D_L!. FBI!;¬-HC'!
<3P~ CO! Amy
ITD! FBI
-MM->001}; in
- FBI
A' "000
'
1.sJ_ F01-
_____;__I-;:-i.?._..___.-_-¢ ! l_
;_
i
WP! FBI!:
{ENYJ
E- YEA!;
-ASDRFBIJ;
01!; cummm S,-ART1-llJRM@ FBI!;
MM
FBI!;
W
-
0
1F01!;
"1
-rr0!- =01
IR
0' 00 0
-. . _
FBI!;'_ -
001081»;
HQ! F51!;
cr01 FB1>;_
_CIDFBI!; OM! FBI!?
'FBI' 0 om! _
M-f"r! %FB
»~00 _
.
-
=0--
1o<- F01!;
-MM-EBI];3 - -.
PHF
."
.E". ".'l- i
' FBI MM
FBI!;
__
F01!
MM! F01!;
FBI!: co
J
{SE} FBI- __e
"0=0I:= 0
- - =01!,
_IR
T000; 0
F-_ __
" FBI!;
MM!
MM?- FBI!:
1?! FBI
Px! FBI"
0 ><1 0A:;
_HO
MO!
--0
'-
T0! 00:11:];
I090! F011; 0=><,><F0n
{FBI}; IR'!. FEiI!;
Ill
FBI!;
-'
-¢;-.._
._
-.".1-'_.;
.'_'.92_:.=
.._.._<;--_'.-.
.1.-',-.,j._
"'
.¢'-._.'r -:§';',._'-T
-'
-r'.:.:.
='.I: _
-"
:
=.
--.
:,=.-;:_'=".-':--_.
.. g'."_~v.-m
...- - --_5..
-- ,.; _.:-.- -, . .',..9275..
....L
r
_.
§gENS1 1 I_iB_UI__'UhlCLA$1E§Q_."_- .
'.5 _ _ -- _
"b6
-
_. - ..
_
-1
ma: -1_
-WhiieatG'|'M0'f'._obsenEei:'|
game
510"
-F5|IJGHCY
l éatmént
92-vhicuzhh
v- condubfed
Bus by'r1.on'1
"
énc!nun-CITF
pas-rsonnelbg.-ing-useqi
ononedetainee.
-I didnotdbseweany
physical
rr1istri'eati"ne_nt
.
-
fan dtinee
'
0"
fea
.-I
be-1,-1
'
b7C -1
FBlOmaha
-_|
.I
'"
_
--
.
DesMoines
F1.A..I
'-'-'
.- _-
-
__
__ _RESPClNSE_5-18*-1_':
'_:
"'b2~1'
_-¢---<_:>n'_
51Mess'agg~'-i-L
1_
Fran-um" W.5T_._9vEN-C. -Ir450; FBI!@
-Se:-it:Frid, Iv.09 2004_-:
-.
1 42
PM_ ,-
-
~_""T0:
'
H_lg:-1'01
'
_'
'_[MM_!
|_=B1
.!£F !
FBI
MM
_sI
-HO" Fan?
MM! F-BI!,
-92. FBI!
MM[_§F_I
HO :=_s1!--
" .
-'-
015! FBI!, same
cu-!u=s1,
-_ .-
.CV_[FBII;
H<:-!¢1=s.~.:'-FBI!
.- ,-if :-1
_ KLEPHFBIL
N
FBI!
BI _ 92 -DLFBI!;
_
i
Am._¢EaI!;
_
=-'
=-'
~
- - IR:
FemNY!"<FBI}
'FD}-G
-.- FBI!
onoaa
92 c c-nit-_.,_-.
.
w.
-'b6
-1
b7C
1
FBI!{
010"
cow!;
N¥'1{.
_ . 'lIL 2]"[FBI!,
NK1E CTD!{FBI-_
I - I
-
MM!
MM |=sI!,-
FBI!,
N
NYHFBI!;
~
'
-
IRT[|=B
MM!-{Faff
"
-92'
"=" _-
. - _|[Ac;>_}-_gocA!
_j LS!_{£§I
%3-FBI§
_-_
- - 11:10:
11WLASQUF
L MMUFBI1
mo!
%
I} 1sF ><FBnh
-"'
I:
FED
H
i I-[SD
n FBIm
V - _1': -{KX}'
. .MM
J'i_LwF§
FB1}'
-' [!NY}' 'OGA!-*
"
___-[FBIH_ __"F 'PHL{FBIkLQLgMMINGS;.ART
.,
_- _[ -;
|_@q1~@_;FB1
I
|_ OMFBIIIRIJJ
-"
FE-11*1
N.- MM!<FE-I!
_wM><FBI1
7
~.
_ mM"!_qFs1!,-J.
j
_-MM
-j
Mr~T! =aI];
-" -- _
_
|=a1L|_
"
-
E-SFLIFBI-"
_ .
_
. FBI]
IP~!EFBI!'
'
PX!-[FBI
NKMFB1!
kR1_£FBI>:l- F"
- "' |<bs!
* |=si
-..
-"A-I-tr?
-
-
M0 FBI!
!'
HQ
VH1
_
--FBI,
i .
__
-_ _FBI]-"
,1
~
_Y
"
_.
:=Bi
'
ai
-'
1
F
-,
l3 E!_'_[FBI1
NF}_ F=BI!
-,-
V
..
. LFBS-'
uI UK?
iF£3
[x:1"mFan]
|I@mFB1~0!:
_
{SE}" FE!-I!;
_
[NY-saqg
-'
H
-
. - -
AL!_{EB
1,
go!wn$_-,mE.
.*'
m1|f§§!{
BI] 1§1§""
F1
F - ;-
.
Wis
FBI}!
j
. _Ps!os¬g§g. _. NY
B1-FBI?" '
DL cow»
-- .
"
I CON,
1. _ -7 '
_ H;cs!
L
§Fs1J |;-! 1 !; J59
'
_.- :=aI!-1*lg ggiglg-l!
f 55:4
FBI , T
-- I
_ in
7/U117 nnn
I'
:
_
1!; _:2
<'*1W1<FBYlz
LA
FBI!;
-1-
ITD FBI};
@E1- F511;
-
.MM -F "--
~
U. W
' -in
Message
'
'- '
I
{CD-}fFBI!,
'- --
_rm
f
__
_
- 7'Pa§&3o'f6
*»=s:!"|', |'| 1'J':J5
' '
'
'
L[ 'CID Q|'F|'
J11;
- - EYEP:-T
- "==-0&1?!I???_--_
PB &#
DI
j
_
-
HOWE
.FBI
._.
!
sa
wo! r=s1;¢ {o1! Fs1!.?_'
_ _ _{MM}. FE!I]§f'HA_RP.INGTON,TJ.
CTDJ EBI!'; ?'
'
B; SLHFBI!
ME - ' DN
FBI-I
E'_»I!;"N FBIJ_;MM! FBI!.
- '
M FBI!,
--
rm 1'-FBI;
- . . _11"};
'- AN![FBI;
- oea
92
-
- |=B1- grim-Fsnj
-
- -.
.-. .-_
s.
WFJEFBIL
-FBI! Q50
;92
_* _EF!L[FBI.- _
.110- FBI!;
m- N _
_1-
may
,'
_
_92.{cro!n=m!,j
Fs_I!L_
.,
-.
.Q_,_ 1- 2
l_D!{'BI!
fAL'jFB1&
92{1'rn[{
51 FBI, 7K!. Iz~1sDJ.{?BI;-,
. _._ 7
NE F51!?
-V' '_
HA, -Fshj
_Crm_; Fs1 W; "
AL" FBI;
HO! FBI;
K-><![FBI! Mr~1;_gFq:
_ _
CJIS
IIliif
_.
E611" -FBI"
?c
T ; in I _ _R!cm BI
-_
_..
--
IR FBI!
-
" - -*".
92
'_rq
HN! FBI-1
-h~- *~92_I .Nlqggar.3 FBI!,
061 F_BI!f
_{~|-1 Fg_I3_!j___..
,4,-
J co!n=s1;1
-- j
mM;_q:.=s:
-m i
W~11JFIll. I'.
SecD
7
-1~-s1!;=_W?
L
455:1!
SE
.M__ I
."
92-92
FBI!;
L MM} r=5I
FBI!?|
2,-
H!
_u-10! _.
__
_
I!? rm"
, X-. _'
' _.
FBI! |£CG!_4fBI!f
I
-_
u
W_l.D!_ FBI eager!!
-._<rRw=B1!:,
-____
- ?=H= BPH}[E§§]*,.
. L¢s~==cm§?I>;[
- .M;
cmgrar!, ca!
.'92.
1 "'
- _
fL@ML FBI __
:11}!
L -1}- FBI c1n'!u=s1==
_Ml-?}[C!GA};
' '
LVHFBI E!_§FBI-
.
.LA
B
:~w»=a1 wr
cm! FBI!
_§
-
_
_.]B|j TfsI_Z[___
'
7"
' '
FBI
06:»!
|rm
rm om!,
Fszfl
c
._'
?JMP§QGA>,Pa1»
_. .
l"l' *5 ._.92
'
~
.
9
B9? 92
n.4|h..=
_'
'
-FBI]1MM
FBIJI
J. .' -
'-
-
[FBI!,
B'I§BI
.NY
.NY
0 ax
1
,_92
,7
F!_ FBr}}?
__|_ rI!_;Fs1 '
|_ -_
CTD_1_[FBI FE
_ ._!gFa_I!_:[ .BI, .- -,__.3 7* - .L910; FBI!;
{_NY!_ FBf!,
- r=.
-»~
.
X
:~
>;HFBr;;"
'
rrrzawar"
..
2
;
- ; _ _".|=s1 -*1ij
_[@4M. FBI'
.wJ r=sr!*:|Q
j j "_ '
" " T'1
.....;.
Lli -FBI-T
i E-39-E51f-MM
PEIE
;-_
92
.
' -
-j
.
-"
N5!{FBI' -
MM ,
"war, {PX! '3GP< " l lM!'
=. i
{say FBI}mu FBILi cm!
_?
_ i i'
+511
M''
I'
.'
'- r
MM Psi!,
;-___ FB1!f PX!
;_"
_.-
.
_
wsn? "92
{FE-I!_[lE'1~. .-%%-1"
L. 11- an "
GA! '
iLLIWYOGA
_
,- MM!
-_
n=5!_ r=BI _~.
9
5y_ GA!'| |_,M|g92 FBI!?
'[§BA'1_ 7|~BI
7* "'sF'
_
,1;.
.REsPbN'-1a_5-".'f__
1 92""
. :_,-__ MeSSage__
_.
_ __
{==B:§; I
l
., Page4¢
I'1v~r>rq.c'>sA;
l uIsis.!
='sn,&#

NK F51!
CG! FBI -SU] FBI]
FBI =w_v!{Fs1a.
|~1M!':FE>1_!, {Oat}
;
.oey
'
LR FBI 2; -
_'-- {asmsrj
__ _- j sgtf
FBI! ___
;! |r cTD
; U .I;-FBI
E bx
.r
| rw! r=s1!; {NY
I |_ EP} 92 -iggj
_ rr0!<F5r!*
|_
*B
'
_
{.
MP -'51!,
M BI
i _ESL
" -"
W u_§t!
OGF92.
M|
MM§'
,
FBI'
'7
C<'3!
§
'92
F
FBI i
scycorq; __
_
EH FBI!:
-!
_.92
g~¢YeA;fL_ _ , -1=-
=-,
*-
1 , j #50! :1;
,j
'
.
_~ M
" Y92 @zEs1<»1s@>-<»
~
?
.
% ;j j
.L %
j j * FB1>'&&#
, ms
"FBI' H0
1- rm
CELLFBY "
M
_
om! NRFBI;
HO! FB1!
W9 FEW
cm! {FBI},
Ysugaz
] n.= my
Fsl Lgmwy
r
FD ><
FBI
c»
F!;
:- !_ FBI!_;
_-
E.sew
FBI; .ak-
FBI! m}'
" warFBI
!
_
SL
. -LAHFBI
_'
{FBI}?
_NY
In. "'
.-
- : '
Fan cm!
F511? W
-- 'H0-!__gPsI*
LD!_
_
FBI*
_
5
MM
FBI_'
-'
_. ~c.'r_
FBI -FBI -
b6 -1
b7C -1
92'92
_t'
|§'A&#
.j _[ NY!
___ BFMFE -I
Di
U. -J} _
H .'
<3
c<¬;:G
~. '
! _*'
!'
kg-mi
__ :_-lI
.'-
'
_:
____
cT~ay_Fa1
, _92
SD!- FBI!
1
_-
I,
1r
MMFBI?
_
{LDFBI
- ; wF.;_ cow!-;~
~. "
-
j I ~11
oeA!;
_._
FBI!;
MM
."_hglisna
- if- | +<c1
71%!!
*7 |_iBs~;'gFE1
'
_.
Far"
-_n
._ ?;*FB1
_M.!
FBI
_-
___
=,_r-1!u=s1!j rw!_¢0s.=. __I;
-"__=wE!;.:=ax};
;l.s!_
FB1=
W
|_ H01__ Fag;]:|
7 cm!. :_
..
.._[Fsn_;T - j
MM}_[fBI1]
,92_&{-{{5}};
..
"-
W
qwqggsnj
|_g:<;g1=B1W _IR}_@=aI
oar
_c>E}§|.=sI~
.-
-" ?EP!1*"!£FB1!i
_'u:@L£FB1,
- ._; f 1_3y_
--§|="sI! ,=i,~ FBI;
-HOMFBI
W
smssr.
'
FBI
W
NO![FBI
.
J? I _
LL 1.'
h'
- CE!'FBI"' . CTD! FBI!
_
.'
7
_"~
_o1~'Q_{1=B1',
_[s1:!JFB1!';T
.
I-. - -
FBI
i
_
=
c1.A>@ :1
?*
mam
1 --ll"
W
-1=-s}n=s1!; .QTD!{FBI'
I"
-.
w1=!. FB_I-yf
_
_'
-
'FBI!
3 Ase! 1%: BBHFBI!
._~92
*' *
_*
EP
'
"
"--.
*'~
-_
_ ~
.
HO! FBI [ ccg_[Fs1
=*_
----'----~_¢-F
LEW-J;tI§BIJ5|*
-><l!'-;£FBI
i j .0.CJLEBI!.l1,;
g
?_.
_1
NY! __ | w! z=s1j:'E
W "|_fMEJ_ _FBI
.*~
_s0;_gr=a1
"- i._W
___ P<5 Fsr.§|_LL
_* as!__ - , ~
._ _u_=sn-.|%
j
V|__T§W.PBI ] j j
%mE>~%<Fa:rl
' ..aw
- FBI-Fs1! ,'|
if [[MO!JFBI
"
1
__92
ll kl[HO--FBI],
'FBI!;|
'P
7*
"lu_H0!__
X".-
L"<FBI1
u|L"HMfBi1~
I
W
!f:-1&1";
FaFB¥1i
,; ,'H'R'
W '
'
F513?
HRn
MHEQIF
- :1w!u=s: W
|-m1 r=s1;
V..-
." 71:3 0:20:34-
W fHRTUFB
,--
"
'
92 >92
- _ V __LA j. _ .RESPONS'ES
.,-9_
-x '186_.
VL %
.="'-*- -"Ness'
-.
.. .t.,,=¥g6
H
' Ir
' '
- '
"_
'
.-'
.
__
'cre "Fe-I! nij_:.=sr'j
s, LA
F~'BI"" s
ilk L
Q7
-FBI]
|92rY!'_ 7
-FBIl
.
i1.
_1
- FBI
;_
_ _.7
!. FBI'
_L
mm! [FSI!'
DIN]: 5 '
'
. .
Jim FE!
PFBI!
_cro
.
to!_{FeI -AN}
"rFer'!'L.» 1-
FBI
FBI!; . V
s Lien-i __
|£CI'E>}£FB-I!:
_
omen7
Y
i TP
s
Iii
-11
_7Ei"*B i1- BT"'
_ _I_
CTD
-
.
-
l92_'
{LR} FBI!
-1
l
I} BI
- BI
b7C -1.
l .s
Ear
~CTD
Fer;
.Cro
'Ci D L FBI-' FL F=BI'
i
iD EF
j T I .BI}
lTD'
-__
_b6
.11} _¢=_'
,-
Pi-i " Fen
" MM
_NY!i'FBI l;,
_s
FBI]'
MM L{FBI1 rj_
~
LiFBIALI
_
[FBI!"
'IR]_[FBI- is
1=er!;," M
__
I Tilggon '
s ENYUOGA!;
{HO}{FBI *
t.BA.!tEBI!;| is
..__ intre-
iJI;! FBI!
c! r=eI! '1-iii
I LI
_
.3
~__
-.
-
- Pet!»
s_ W9
_
t'_""*Ti~lf5I-
Sut1jecI::GTt"1O'_z
Impo_rj_ta'nc_e:
'.'
-I High_. '
§_EHSiTi.VE BUT
UN'CIJ92S$lElEQ_;
- _._"
'.-
_
:..
You have
beenidenti ed
as
ha92iingoond|.icted_a_n assignment
at
GTMO, Cuba
sin_ee'9!11t01.
The inspectionDivision hasbeen tasked
with contacting
those employees-who
have sewed
in'an'y.cap'acity
at
GTMO end'_obtaih information
regarding the
treatment
of
detainees. - ';
Emntvveeé Shwid.r@sPwd 10-the
fviiowing. 1-- -1-
'
_-- ._
" .-
. .
1! En-ieioyiees
mind
oiziseweud-¬=iQgress
-treatn'ieni,'_-interrogations
ive
or
initer92riew'technic.;u
-.
GTMO detainees
which was
not_c1onsistent_with Bureauintenriew_poiioyifgtiitteiines.
shouid _
respond viaemail f.o_r
thepurposeofa foiiow-up
interview; Positive
email responses
should.
t:"edirectedtq:__
_'
~
." .-.
_ _ ,
~
_ '
'-
'_- Inspection
i92»'|5t92'Jl
._.
i'
_ _
_
2} Employees
who served
'atand
observed
GTMO no
aggressivetreatment-ofdetaineest '
should respond
via enEC documenting
a negative
response. The
EC should
include the
employee'sBureao.nam_e._
official
and
titie,
tenure
of
assignment at
GTMO.
- i-.
-;
The Ecsheuie-'eé
nits: "El0untt-Efierrorietfn
Division; G- i'ME_§,_in_spectio
Soeciai"Inqui_r¢y"i
.'
file #29?-HQ-A132?6j69-A1
EC_should
THE be-uptoeded,
not
only.
but serialized.
with a
herd
COQYJQPQVBTQQG
_, to:
.._
' .'
.
_'
-'
-
I"
_'
' _- I-
Inspection Diirision
l'_ I 3'
"
.'
Of ceof-Insactions
,'
'V'
i'
|
bk; _l
-'.Roon1 B3?
'
- -we
'
'1
sensirive §UTUJ§iC_LA5Sl_E!_§I_2.-
- -r,=s0r:004-
_ _ J'
_
_.
RESPONSES 18?
'
__
s
i
W
i
__
___
_
_
A1
LV l
l __
-
t.9:f 5
'ic§"§roni,vaiékiei§.ieecj'iFsn!'
f'' j
" sefltii
Friday, July-30,
ZQQ4 2143
PM
,-Te; '_Vlalerie
Caprdni,
[OGC}
E_. FB|!"
"
__ _. _
h-Subject:
GTMO
l=_W:
,. _".2..~'_ '
5 -.51
'sEnsi'r|vee._uj unct.Ass1|=u5e_.- .
NO[§'-B§CQBD-.
.
- 1
-
__
Hereone
isof
theupdated nsurnrnaries
I reduested
threeernp_l'oyees.~_
can include.
thiswith
You
package
thei
--.- --
¢ii@Pi5eFi0ff."Two_m'ore t0Qo.
-'
'' -' -'
.0_riinH
-
"ii".
From OMi FBI_!_».
b6 -1
b7C ~1
"
I'
5.
'
"T .'.
'u
i
5.'¬ni:':i
-_1';se"Ps_~a
__ Fi'ii:l¬E'?Jt'i¥ &
FBI!
To: msol
Svubject:
_V
_'
Now-gecogg
mt: -1~
- _
-
_"
'-
*-
.- :"
.~
.
-
'
;_-.-:.
-" "
.-
. - adetainee
"
'
"' ' " '_
-while
'
" leaving
__'_icii'n
-r
_ oiowing
|nterv|_ew_exet_:t
date_unkn0wn,
the'_intenr'_'
iew
bun
g ._at_Carh
p D.eita]a_|t""'
approximately 6-:_3'O
p.m'.
or
later-,- tieard-and"
l
obsenged
in thehallway loud
rh_u sic_ apd flashes
otjight. '-i.-walked
'
from thehaiiliuay. into
the-open d_oo_r
of-ai_..mi_:initorin'g_.rc|or'n
what 'wa's'gtJii1'g
on-._l
tdseeFrom
the rnoi1it0ring.r0t!|'r_1,
l'
looked inside
the adjacent
interview rdcn-i,_.
.1tt.th'attirnei'saw
detaineeanother
sitting.
on the
fioor.of.the interview
room-with an
I5 ;-_aeiidraped-around
ag
him,
idud_.mu'sic_
playedbeing
end
as_trot:|eiighttiashing.left
"i the . __
monitonng room
immediateiyafter seeing
this-activity. did
'i
notlseeany
other persons-in'si_de
th_e_inter92iiew -room
withthe Israeliag draped
detainee, but
suspect that
this was
apracticeused by
the DOD
DHS since
the o_n_iy'
other persons
inside the
hallway near
this particular
intehiiew room
were.dressed_in green
military .'Fatigues,_.
'.
similarto
thecnes worn byDOD_Di'-15- _and
-Urtifo_rr'r_ie_d
the__DC_1'!IJ___ltr1_i=.
At no
time-did'i."dbsen'e
Reservists.
any
physical assaults
take placelef
this d_e_tai|nee"ndr
any;ot ners=wh,iie assigned
to
GTMCJ.I _'_
I'
__. . . :_ '
'
I'un_derst'ood
priorto
d.epio3m1ent
to
GTMO,-.that such
techniques wei_'e_hot_aiiowed.
norapprdved b_1-="FBi'_
polic3;{._ .lNfhiie at'GTi92Ji£li
nusuch techniques
were nev_er_cpnducted»to_
my knowledge
byanyof
the CITF personnel
assigned at'GTMO.
~
_
_. '. - '3
,
J. 3 1. , '
_'
,"'
'
_~'
Approxii1'iatei§i'-oneor
two-days later, DHS,tactics
were discussed
at awee iyheidCITF staff
meeting." Many
of
the-C2-ifi F'Trivestigatorshow~sorr|_e
discussedthe
of_
DHS-tactics,-had
ibeen
counte
roduc1ive'ih rapport
building
with
detainees
who
being
were
intery-ie'w_ed
by
F
§|.T
rn'em_bers."
Acting
FB'l'S
'a'
no"
C_ITF
person_nei.ihciuding_-FBI agentswereto
take artin an such intewiews
dr_'interrog_a
ions
which fell outside'
b6 J'.
the
policy
FBi's
of-inteririewing
detainees.
msA
advised
us
eo"
tha_t
bei_::-ame
if.weoiany aw
similar'instances.-where agressive,DHS
tactics ha ee_n
0served to'r|o.tily_hirn,detaiisiland-"he
provide
.
.b?C
would
sf
make
instances-knot-;n_
to. aopropnate
GTMO
and_D_OJ|
DOD
it shouid.t'
that
officials.
while
at
GTMO, ASS
' acted
in
an--e:-gemplaryniannerand-.represented.-the
F las,-a consumate
. _ ___
profes-sienal. isT summary
detaiisthe only
incident I_'i'tave'to
report regarding
observing arnpn-FBI
approved"
at
GTMO
'_
tactic
. being
used on-a
detainee
I._
-13.6. _.1._
-.
_- || -' .t:..i-.
..
.
ma
a'
Des Moines ELA1 '
-.
-
.
_. _- -*»Ori inaimessa
=- _...-.-.
..
-
- .-_ I__- _ _
-
- '
»
J
I
_" i
t
5
' _
-
" heel _~ -|=r-<>m=_E:jj
] IN-$D}' FBI_!_.
"" we _1 . 5ent::Thursda July29,-.200"4_AM
9:59
...
T=~=i:Q:_i<<>~>.<rBI>~.
i.
i.
'
7
" '2m¢>.nn'4'.
.- .
-I
'
-RESP'ONSES 188_.. '
.
' '
.
F'
92../-" '1
.
'- ._SuE|jéct:RE:'GTMO
U
_
E smveaur
ms
_
t t
.
0.0010ieese
>100 provide
e-_sh0_rt surqmalyidf
yv et 0ba_e-wed.
yoq
- -fhanke.
'--_-on
iha|Messa e ----.
I
I-
-
- 06 -10E~w=i<==~1.cFB1>e
0
.W;
-1 5erit:.l=.rida
-Jul 00 2004 4:20 PM 0 " -0 we INF-11> ! FBI!
_'
'
" 7-5L|bjecl::'RE: G'iT~ 1C_J|
iJj' UNCLAGSIELEQ
SENSITIV
-' _-I..i.~ou-R-E0950 L
1:»-5 -1
."
l
-
' 1
'
-
-
92
."11.
_
-. -- Iwnile"at_GTMO
I"00sehred some
n0n¢FB|'p0|icy treatn en al-_|ich'wes.cdrid
nqnLBure'a_
.
- '
.and_-noh-QITF-pefsonnel'beipg
used on.or_1e
detainee. 1didnotopeerve-anjrphysicelmistreatm
-
' U
-ens 1
._
_. 92 ibjc ___ - 5
-- '
-~ .
ofari detainee
"-
_;
--
__
.
--
-
___
"FBI-Omaha
Des Moinese.-AI P'
_
..
.
-
q _-RESPONSES-189
'-'
_'----'-0:figina'l_r-1'essage¢j-4-4'
.
" '
"|='mm=.Mcc0.:92w,-sTE§.rE;~:»c. IN50!" FBI!"
.1: 00
ZOG41.42PM
r|a"u'
_
':F d
' TO
FBI]
_-
-:_' H
-
MM FBI!
FBI!; ON!;-_
{NY'! FBI_!
gw!. ;|= -U
m!
F01!;
HO
FBI!;
. _FRANKIE-[FBI
;' MM
.B_;
- _-I-Dlt
-
0 FBI!:
~1:!;
i
._-
LHO]
b6 +1 0 0
, FBI!
7c - ..J" "0+0:
._= ;
_b ll
0e
0
IIR! FBI!; .".NY!om!; co!
EWFBIJ 0
- '-
r FBI.
_'
..
___ ~0!_ F01!_| -
;
_
ASD! "F01-!;
' NY! Q55!
_Lt1T0
- FBI!
-
-__
_
RD!
M
-FBIH
| MM!-'
_!lL Mi'W!_-{FBQ1
'
MM}_
~'MM-F
-FBI
~'
FB1,[ s1.= F01
FBI! __F
cIR-1:cFBI>- 0
F3
92
LQRMFBIMI
00
" »-
RNY.]_ FBI.'
.FBI; SE
:P><-3+ < FB'r>-
00
A1
M0
_-
|_[DE1_ §BI-- 501!]?
; i WF! .FBI!;
'
' TD!
FBI!
El:l!; EBI
cm
~-FBIM;
--lr ;fJ.J.BIMlNGS;,ABTI1UR
I
._ TP.!_§_F_BI
__ _?
nmr nha
N0 .FBI!:"; -
F01!;
0 Lm011;rFBI
- ]?. r~10.FB»I>;
l
.-" NK!_{.BI;
0. 01
A0 FBI!?"
0 0MI~0e_:EBIe'
!<EB0;B
.0
~10 ~ W
_-
c:r0 FBI
W 1-
.
:_=B_1;!;0A
U92.!.¬FBI
" '
01!]
92
1'_~1M!. -FBI"!;
<H0!_0¥B11: 0sn'0=a0'=
DWI-FBIJ}
N E511
.
B :
As0!_gFB1
; -E551-El e
VIIHQ
MFWHFBIJ;
FBI!
.'c0!.
'
HCj_{FBI1,
0 0|.
0 0|
U"lY!{I_=BI_!, WF! F-B
NF! FBI!
CTD! FBI
92
FBI!
92
in
N FBI
.FBI!,
-"WF
AL![F_BI!'
KX FBI]
LA FBI!
MM "~s.
FBI!; PGUOGA];
L -s1
j i _;_
FBI!; NY
FBI!;
INY FBI!;_
* CI!FB;.ocm!; as
coN;.
._ -FBI1;|
i§M.O]_
FBI!['DLEFBI.
'
I!'
MIFB%!1:>
FBI!
F2112: _
FIB
.
u ~|{1W!_ FBI" t 7
_-._- FBI!;,
' DLLEFBIJ;
_. .1TD
FBi'
"
;
-'CID]_ FBI
- CTD!
L %
F511; %
<H0><.w~:;|
cm
FBI -%
- FBI!, N03
7Vi
FBI!; I! FBI!;
__._. on {FBI},
_ -
__ FBI!,
e
SL!
FBI!,
MM! ¢LFBI!
=
OGAa;[IR
FBI!,
_W.
NY!_ FBI _[EP!_ FBI
L CON
FBI! LA}_
FBI om!
- H0 FBI
D-
FBI! w1=!
'
< FBI!
;
AN!
rm! g|=a1!j
_-
-I
_,1T;D!:
FBI Rcm
FBI [[m< FBI!,
1-rt: FBI!
l'
' __
Aq!_gfB1j;|
|[CTD!_g|=B1| "
..
.
_ I .E
MM
FBI
J_ n'n!_ |=a1 ;|
- 'V
<.
__
HNJ
.
__.
=_;1i_"_
__
-."
'
'.
'"7
If ..l'
- ~_ _
92_I 1"
U FBI NY!
- b6-1 "
r
SE!_i§BI!; MM
FBI!;TJ.
HARR
' PH
__
:
f>EL Fr's1;
H'
I H0!.
_
1%, w:.>,§;=:;@, <H@,§§F
i;s1u_|=|ia
INSD!
FBI!,
FBI
'
":
~!|
'
' "Y NE
CGUFBIEDLEFBI
MM
FBI MM
FBI
HQ.
BI ,
CJIS]_ FBI! cu!
"
FBI!
AL!_ FBI 1TD!_ FBI
*
_;_ FBI
1!;
.A
cm FBI!,
SecD FBI!
m<!_ §a1 MM
mm $51,»;-~.
.
-
ss -.
_ FB1
W
FBIH
f
[_
FBI!;
MM
_
..._'.
E:|_!
'
|=a1!;_|
2?-][MM].'
_[;§0GC].§.FBI;},_FBI!;[
{ *|;su1_- Fi!i - NH!_ FBI _
-CGUFBI!;
-__
..1~-, ,_[IRL F5I
, -w!;@B;!t
W
_
j
RB-FRFBLEI
_|
_Z mLSI$I!; F}
_
_ _Im
=. I _CG!_ FBI'
j -|=|-q_n=a11;
:0
=_ ;
EPMF'!_
FBI};_C_J §A'!;
-LV! FBI' CID! _ F-BI
92
-"
_ rDE!_-MP
FBI!,
f _ ____
_ __ LvUFBI'
"
-_
__
_|:>r»1-
- FBI
.!';__~
_
{CTl3!!" FBI
Z '
|_{l"1M} FBI
._ F!{FBI!;
LA.
_FBI!;|'u
NY!
FBI!;
SU!_ FBI}_;
-" .
i.n~i~r! ____
FBI; NYHEBI
;-I __; h____|
FBT-' V
_;.M_..|=B
__
-FBI;
'u=B1>:I
LL11?!j <FB_11:<m>
*1 ; ._'
'
.*7 c.11s!_c_r=a11| [~:.~r!_@gg.'
_|<c_
T7
.r.~1Y
FBI!;.N 1
QGA-J; U"--
-- "MP}_[OGA'
1'-113; : F,
_?_ m*!_@+__'-19%!,-J_*
U ;; s1;;<
; %
.'_
~' IR! FBI};
CTD '
FBI"
'
.~<aH><FBn;
.<rrouF.B1-
92
=
j
_HQRFBI
N -131*
? _
- 'cu-n-1nn..4..
k_
_. ..
-SA FBI
.
h{NY}{FBI!,
Y} _F_!,___ _£_! F_!,rm. BI
_ __.
9
y;.
_
_RESPONSES;iE;{ lJ"h%
.- -
.
V ,
_
.
_
..
.
___ ___
7
.-.
_
.
r
. ''_ Messé-gé
'.
_
.'
.
-
.
Pagé4of
6l
I '
VI .- ':_' .Mr~;J_
lf¬MLé§iJ;'
FB1 V .
"F
-
>_< HLc1
--
FBI"|
1:, _.___.-IR
.FBI
,.
92
1
92
_,
Lm
FBI!
?MK
pl?LL
L~
L
"
_WFL[F,BI -L .
L
*' [mm
=F!;
MM FBI!; yBA
=13 j
- W
= _
_Z L PXEBI; ' . _Z
CLTD FBI!;..
.
.
NYIHFJKFA!; w- FBI!;
-L
5:. OGA!
FBI!: MM!
FBI; ;w<sc!cFBn;
C61. ; U! _
N 1_ !' FBI! MP
- FBI
*"IMM
-1=.BIL-
-£56
; DE.! FBl; _=
.
.
_
FBI!; ICTD
'
FBI=
" '
B'5iLEEI! ._
L . _r_»1_92;!_{_|=,B1.¢-'
Lrw '.FBI';_
<1"w:L-cFBn;923
1
1-l"
-U;L
"
-_|§5E cnrsa
LMM!
l] FBI__
L :c@>cFBI_!
EP 551-
L1
..*
i
M
FB'
|'
_MLLi|}
BI.!'
_ 7'
Lu92L
1!; <L1R!cFBn;
_L
~m0@A- "
L"
.
|=s1!;_- "L
FBI!;
'
L<~Y;"<@@A!:[_
????
W
"
FBI;
' '
rm! FBI - IR!
BI!; FD
'
-L
MM!
FBI!
SA! FBI!
FBI!;
L"
"-
FBI!;
MM! FBI?
PX! {OHM
L..
92
L
FBI;_![_
MM L..[
NE! FBI!; .L
a
.MM
FBI
i IR! 'FBI!';
L _ __
IR.!'_[FBI .L
-Bi-I
- FBI!;
.
_.SC .:CON]_; L
. ITD! FBIJ;
7
.- L_
L
.- if|~m_{osA!";|
I[Px!_
W
s1_ ,A§g!_ |=:ar.
RHOEEBI! iL
"_Lb6 -1
.' 'LR
FBI"
Ib7C -1'.'
L'
jL 1
L1Tr=L<FBI!|L
_._
,,
j _o=sm<F,B11;
' 1[lTD! FBI!|
wm sn
%
|§ %|[HG}{FBI!
|?|§muEI 1s!_ |=a1;
L -'
'
Sei:Dj_
-cm!;
FBI!;
FB1!-E
J
L"
' L *' .n! r=s_1!_;j
- . -LMM
PsL="":_ I
_'
Lcm
FBI! j
'1T1>! F,B1!;
'; '
'
- MW!. FBI!;'
.L ' 1=z!L F_,B_I!;.
MM!.- FBI -- SI-! FBn_:L"..
-SE! FBI'!; I.-AHFBI!
'
._'_-_,_
Lmr ~FBI!_;_
.'-_' _,
L
.[WW
J1NYLQG5
M ; - E L ._ _'
-L
_'Aso!_[|=B1
L FBI -; .j
. .[gigs
MM Lr=ar!;[ij
"
-SD!-_'
W FBI
*.LD_EFB_I
-w_
-cow L " _j
_'
_Z _BFE_FBIm_k
_Wsm;
L '
.-L
Lk1~!_
r=BIL:;l
J
L2w!
k
L
L
L
1c1=B:_.
CG_CON;
' HO-FBI!; _-an I
,
Fa1~!;
'
%
PG!
FB1!:|
,
kmM>.:L
-_.
- '
|.| KC]§0GA!;
AN FBI!;
MML
,L
.* "FBIJ
"" 1L FBI'
B5-H551!; :
' WE!. FBI!;]
_?__
'"
Est! -;l ,_ _i '
|_ NY}_f0GA if _- "_
|.sL'
' +10%
FBI ~1=B11j_|
_ _ILQTD-!LL1 _
~
mar L<wE;_ FBIL1,-1 ?
' I'
__
VF
2Jr
I=n :R!_ §g_i!,;|
_I. TB_
J..
x
_
_L m'.L
A;-EBU1
LT_
L. sw>;<@@51
FBI;-| MMHFBI!_
L{FZl smuF
;I
'
ASDn.FBITI;
U_E.A!.L
_ cow
.
1m=»uFBI~
_ _$s!é
M
>1BI :=jj_j
Lr l'
FEm;
1*-1¢Tv
? <:E
UK
L-.
FBI
, ! Lc0¢Tn=Bn.|
av FBI
-"II'
HO FBI
L
?
*-" L
??
-j
L,
- _:@M><FBI!:|
? '
-- '
.-cu-92!"n':92'n.q,,
I
.'
I
-'1-_
SI FBI
=;
L
1-L1er
?L
LL
Hrrw==uEaLLf-
2
|-csc!:FBI!: ?
L Responses-'191-1
I
W
-
*"
__
_L n'7"ii
NY:- FBI!;
w L"
"
L"
I
r rif
?
at
r
7
~
V
! Fs1!;! J'[;co!_-{|=s1Vl
-- ., PX!__
_rw!_
FBI
|=|._v!_
__
; _. f_§B1[-_
_.
- '
"
NY!_i
F:?j
|_
ME
FBI
l_
__
_
so!"_§|.=sIW
F
PGL FBI
l
1d
__
Wiw /nirszgl
,
;-L
_., /j |_ J|92|!_
,1 anEe1 [gsu Fag
FBI M0-.51- Ho]
V_
".-'r~1Y}-_gFaI!j
_'
FBI!; u Mb]_EBI!;
_NHI!_f-FBI'
iw "-. '
.F
1-lug-FBI.
."
1"
'
1-um"! FBI!_|
ji HR
"
I-lR~"l'.
FBI -. - _
HRT!_gl=sI!,-j
T FBI!;
LA!_
-F8111
"~ .
_.
_
-. b6
cT01_ FBI!i,
, -I-=~-cosrxl
-FBI =TFD!_g1=e1
K. ,-
,
V|§cr0z:|=Bn
f W
' F
_
~"
:
F CF01
WF
1.
f
.
18*gm! ,_g _ C113 we
_
or "
i
H11
FBI!
i - B.5>tFBI!;|i|*&
i §MM!U
_1L
.-_
cro BI!_,_ F !
.__ b"ic- 1_ '
,
..
i- "F-.51-!i.U.i..FBI!;
-NY!_[FBI ,
.'
--
F
_
.
GIID-; EQI-!;
!
= -NH]_ FBI];-_
"
_ _'-Tl-R3§l .BI!_ ..
.
.- , Ml921!" FBI}; IP
_
_:
FBI! C1D!. 'FBI!;
~-
l.iIRLR1,-i!;|
FBIl:|
LLl w! PBIA~!<F_B1!
.jF_ _[_[§i'D!_
W FBI'
,__,
MM!_[FBI'
~
-d
|_ FDL[FB-I |- TF.*!" i=e1~!;|
c."ro!_. l=sI1jW
' ATHFBQ;
l .~
d
.
cro FBI!
PH FBI!,
.- Fa:-!_
_MM FBI-}; '
TP!_ CONE| -
'_ HO-J
._-
' KC!
FBI '
{ FBI!;
jmmoony
LA!- FBI '
.
__ __
HR
FBI!;
an.» -FB[]_;_L___,, . Ho! =s1!
, Ias->FBI!
V
Sl.Ib]BCtI._
-_
1|-qpiir-t§ance:_lfiigh
_'
__
_'
'
'92 ..__
*1
1RL[fBI
p
.l
.
_____
cr~1M1 FB_I!
.F
F
_-
_
' '
.
'§5|gs_|];_
su"ru_n'c:::Ass|F1eo
we
'"_
'_ .'.BON-B'EC'OBi2I
j"
2-_
..-
.
_1
__
2
2
'
You have
been identi ed-as
ha'vihg'
ahassignment
oondubied
at
GTMO, Cuba isinoe
9i :1!U1..- TheInspection Division
ha § been
tasked
with
oontaotirlg those
employees-who 'have
.'se_rved
in any
capacity at
GTMO and obtain
information regarding
the treatment
of detainees;
I -'
-'
Embioyees-should"imrnediatelg to
respond
thefollowing: _'.
'
- .
-_ _
.1} Employees who
obse ved aggressive
treatment, interrogations
or interviewjeohniques
on
G. i'MO.detainees
was
not yv_hio'h
consistent with
Bureau interview
polioyiguidelines, should
' respo d via-email
for. _the
purpose of
'a'fol|_o'w-up
emailresponses
should
interview._Positive
'5?-ii?T?"!5fF¢i't'5T "-_*"'
""'."i'
"'.'*'T__
'-""."'"'.-1"
* " " _""..'
'.TY"
"..
Fu
' '
-. .,
s
.
.I
,-
_
_
_ _ _ -'" -mo -1
-lnspect1onD|92{1s|on I __.
.
2} Employees
who
sewed
g't'GT:MCl
and
obeer_vedno
-aggressive-lirestmen
of
detainees
'
an ECocumentinga"
negative response.The'EC
should
inoiuoe the "
,_ ._
shouldrespond
via
-ernployeefs of oial Elureau
name.
1itle._B d'tehureof assignment
atrGTMO.
'.
_'
' '
_ The EIC:
should titled
"Coun 0el'_terrorism
GTMO-, irispepiien
Division,
Special inquiry",
.'
"RESPONSES*192_
_ .
- ".0Mhnn,-I.
.
I
.
.
_-
- .''
1.
_'
x ~
._
F-
=_
V
_ .
__
--
" le#'
2-9.7-HQ.-_A
1
32?The S69-EC
A..
shpuid
not
be |Jpi:';1_aded_,_bu-t
only
serialized,
with
a .I'Iarn&
"
e-
-wpvfvmardedw.
-e
'
'
g '
--
A
~ 1~
.J
Inspection
DivisIdn_-
_-
Of ce.ofl'ns
ec cins I
er-R0c_:m7837
'
_'
' -
L b6
-1
.'- b7c
-1
'
-
fseusmve BIUT
UNCLASSIFIED
_'
_ ISENSITIIVE
eujrm_1Q|¢.ss:FIEn
'
.
..,
_
._ : . .
.'.'
_
||-
"-
.I -._
...?_
Q
I __
_ _
_
ve BUTUN
9.5 SS_1I_-=l;IE];'
5,EJ~|s|f|'|-_'
_
_ Tj§é1~is1-TNE
e'Bl;_1T"Ul§l.C
u
L._'-k'. £"»_§_IFLEIJh
-- ; !.5ENs|T|vE|3gJurqq_Ag§s|F|E_g~
"
.
-
-1
r
x
_|-
_._... ........._,._-._'._
.. .. - _
_ -
..
.._
_ .__----1....--.-;....__...-¢-.-.--92-_-r--...-.-..I......-..-....-._...
_ I- _ _.__ ,_ _.,___
__
__ __,_,____;_,
~
3
_
?,
-. er"-1r':r'.1m|..-".
;
-
|
.
'RE$PO_NSES'j
j
&
_
- . _f'
_'
.-
.
--'
_
___"_
-
_
»'
.I
z
_
W_
,..
W
A-
.
§$c }1
':_ _,,i_::_
_v
__
.
I II
I
_.
7_
1'
'
I'
- V- .
| msD!i¢ti=Br!"
'
'___ '<
- __
___..
,_
W
_...:-1
-1
_
.
.-.
c ____ ____._~r~~
_ W __
Ii
P
'
I . -Fron;1:'._
Caprcni;Ve1!e'rie'E.._
_I Oi;3§I}
-._»_'
-I FB_l!"'.:-i
'
f _"Sent:"--_M0}1day',Au'gu5t_16,
2004-1-o1'PM
b6i-i1itTh-i=>
ii|:|i*'1I @P1ifFBi*?tii
i
'
$ensIII£§;BlQ:
u.m;_t,A8$IE§2;'
1
-ON-_RECO
. .
-
.
.
-_ -
Nofurth'er.ihterview
necessary.
Loud
mtlsic
aridstrobe
light
would hewithin'the
ncticn'0f"_e'nvii'c
down"
__
that
isana'p'prcved
technique
forDbD.'.'|The
Israeli- ag;.though
ocgncxious,
doesn't
seem
to
changethe
basic _:|
technique
intocriethat_uii0'u1d
beunlawfuiiy
abp si~.=e.P
V. '_
'__
_
'*_?1"""
:".:"i'
r
_.
._~_. "'
_ : _'
I
--
ii'1E|.
¬".""1":~";
:MEhS5'
-.t _1
, tFr=.=mi¢1~sD>rF@1>
'_
197$
-1
-5ent:'Mon
BY,1"-92.Ug':LlSf_1§,
ZQQ4
2:49
PM _t
_
'
__. lTb_:
Caproni,
92»'alerie'E..
FBI!_92
- .-j §JGC!
t ~ ___'sahje_ct:"F*N;GTM1.>
_
A
~.._'_'gEM'sr"rNE..BLITiJw.¢|.A§_gi|?|eQ.*
5 This"-éiiBu{d.lbe
£r__1é_.|§st
one..':Let-me_kh'ct§:'fciIcv.+
'
--".1-_i
'f
9- _'
,_
5.-H--'O'ri
ihal'MeSsé
e--.--5 .-u
'
'
_'
be_1< .tFwmi: l M>-<w1>t
.
L r@=t;__ t"1<1~sv><FBnw
-_ WC *1 .'
$e_n1::_F|,July
ida30, 20041:_-$5_FfM
'_':
.-
-
'Sul;ect:"RE:GTMO,
.
1
.
92
_
_' --sg i@|s[['1vé-1é:u
c;_i-g§5;1E]'5|;
r'1,@'
'.
.- _ ,
.
IHQb;_RE_f;gBQ..__;'____
;:_t_ - 2
_I
'.
_
:
--?°
1
° __ Fuliowin'g.a'detaineeinterview'exact'date&
_a c.Carnp
Delta
at
.- - 'ab[:rr0xir
8230-,'p._r'n.
ate!y prlétei,
I
hz_~2et'r_d1a
observers!
inthe
nd
hallway
ioud r|_ju§ic'_and
qfiight .iashes
'"
_ "
-waikedfrom'the-hallway
in tO
the'ope1j_d,o1:!r.qfa
i'r|onitoring_
roamtoeee whét'was
goingon. --From
the -'
_'
-t
. monitdring
room,--I
icokedinside
theadjacent
intengiew
room."
Attl-iattimel
savg.-an;>the_t_det:§inee;sitting
'
_
_'
op _ti_'1e
ccr pf the
interviey-;'
rpcmvv_riti1
an is_raeii¢qlfaped
a_g'
around
hir_n',
ioudi m.|5ic'_
being"
p_l_éy'ed
anda _'
etrobe_iightf{aéhir'1_g;
I
leitther'nc'nibcri'r_-iglrobm'irhmedi?ate|y'ia
ec uity:
__'.I
djd_n_ot_"s'e"e-ényi
.
er&
otherbersons
ihsitie
theintewiewjregm
withth_e@_iS_r_aeli_'
d_repe_:_i,detqinee;
];92.pt
ag
_§u5pe'ct't
was
a ~_
" _
§t:th
'
practice
uS'ed-icy
-theDODDHSéince-the"
un_iy='otif|er
perso_r:s'ir_15id_e'tI'ié
haili_vya!P-|jiear,this_parti¢ular:,._ . 1-
- iritérview
room-were
dressed
ingreenn_'1ii_i_t_ari.1"fatigues,sifniigrtctthe-cajesrwqrn
by'E_DO_D-OHS
'and
theDOD
_--MP4Jnifé1i'med#Ré5eqvisb5=:..At;hoTtinie-tiid»i-Qtieeir-tie;nyupIf:Qisical-H$53
_
'-eqyf6tHéis vi?Hilé'-ééé-igrieb]tci
"
_
.'
_ .-'
. . ..|.understi:1c'>c'i;
p_rip_r'.-to
deploy
rn_er|_t_t_o
GT_MO92.-_.'
thatetichjtechniqties
vqere"n0t'e1II_o92qq|,=§_d,_riqrex
byFBI_
-pc_|icy;.
_W}:|i|e
'at
GTMO no_suc'h
techniques
were;-never
co'r_|_ductedmy.kncwi_etigé.by
to anyiof
the,-GITF
'.
92
personnel
assigned
a_tGTMO.:.'
'j - 1-'.___
Y ._ - I"? _1;-."
-.
" Abprsximételyfche
or
twodays-later,
._Di_'jiS
tactics
werediecu5s'ed1at.a
w'ee|heldICITF
y} Btaffmeeting.
--
- _;
';ru_'iariy
oftheCITFi'r192_»e§tigatdrs"discuasedlhpw-s_omé.of
theDHStectics'_ha'gi_
beeh-cbunterprqdin-'.
ctive
b_ui|din
ra
crtwith-detainees
whowere_be'ii I_§1-i['1_t_er92|i'_j92§_~weciby.-CITE
merriberé»
"Acting-FBI. .- -
_.b6
Q1_"
'$S
advisec_i_tha_t
no
CiTF_Qérscn13_e|
incI_l.|tf.iirig-EB-1_éige|:|ts=w
pfart'ih
such.
~ ainees;
b-JG_]_. - interviews
orinterrogations.-.-which.fellputs|tietj:1e'EB|
qf'int_e|'ir1ia92iiin_g"§iet.
s-'po|i_cy
-P_tSSA_
- 1-. '
aiso
'
snaxz-004 -.
apI_vised,us
that
ifwebecame
au_iajre5of"any
_s| miIar
instances
where:-ag
ressive
DHS
--
5
'-
77
-'* Mesesagén
:13" _'
"
'I
--
I
- I.
" Pa
V0
3Ie2o'f.?
.
'nz;d:%§een'c->bs§éw'ed'ta
"téc c$
IPhF0v'id'er1.etaiIs,'anȤ
rnakelihene
nb 7}".himinstances
méwiwm"-- '
Q h~§
"
_.
appropriate GTMQDOD
._-1m1.o'oJ
should0f
noted
be
ciaIs'."It
that
while _at'GTMO-,
ASS/ *5
1
actec_1__in_anmanner
exemplary
and
represented thé"FBJ
as aconsunn'ate'profes$iona|.
summary MC-1 _Th
I -det_aiis'
only incidentl
the have to repert
regarding nbserving
anon-FBI-'approvec,i
beingiused
tactic on
a'
_
92
-det_ain_eeatG'TMO._-"-" .'
- - __ I
_' _'-_.1_
'_.
-
.-
_I136
1
_
I-ma
_'
I' -¢--'
3'-Des Moinés-R.A.-.- 1"
-.92
V
J-
-
~b5
-"l_-¢C_!|'"i'
Nessa E:-'-'
" . . inal _ -"
rF'°m= IN.5°>. @I>ln
b7C -1 _.-
_
-Se
V>T|-if
_c:;
ntThursaJu
9
:.
. 2.
OM! FBI!
¢
|-
1
2[II_04l-9:59-AM
_
..-92 "--Subjeqct:_RE:G_IT92*[O_"_
I
92
'"
92
9
"* ~§ENSlT'|§!E92l§lr;
'|,: 55315'
l-'_=
|g1;; _
"N95-ggcg_3m»;
9
"- - _,
'
*'-C"
-1 Iané
uidl
n§v'iné..3.5
brt|sufnn1aIY
'|'_h;=1nk$.
~ofwhatYbu czibsi-I :
F .Y°- Fe -P. -. ..
. ..
.
. '-Ori
inaiMeSsa
e-.
n
_b6
. _ '-
. Fr@m=i:@~><FB1>.n
-1
-u
_;-Sent. Fri a,.J
~n- _C-1 'tin
.16.:
us,:2o0+4.2u PM-'._
92{-
L <
--
mso! FBI} ..
~
1 'jS.E.I-:lSl_
GUI. g ggg?
5§|E|
l']92.{.E
gD_3
9
H- "
-_-be -1
1-b?c_¢1
VI
'
WhiteGTMO
at
|,obsewedlson1e-nnn-FBI
pbligy téafnneniiwhich
'.-"as nonco.n'd
f
-
'
B.U.reau_
and r'1on-'ClTF.
personnel being
used on |q~n|;.detaineeI did-_no
gbslerve
t
any
physicat '
b6 -1
-1 -- .mistre'atmentofany detainee.-""'.
. -"
'
rna.a~
;
-- D'e5'.MoiheS
- '
R.Ai'
'
-
-
-
_- I-- -'-Ojiginal
Mes§age'7--1-
IFrum:--MccP.Aw;s*|"EvEu:c.{1Nso! F51!.
."
Ser|t'Fnda
09 Ju
2004
1:42.PM
.-
.
J
'-
_-
it- _- .Hoi!"_@a1;!;]
. 'OID!'.
|_ MM"L'
FEiI;C0N
_[EN¬..¥FBi!;
wr -F51;
MM '{|=BI!;|
. I MM!-.{FBI!,=|
4
~-
_ - be
1
"CJIS
; W1
-.1
_£EBIJ.: -f-JJ.!~!_ E5I.!"
- - F51*
11,BATH . ----1.1.
.._h an
. -_ ' h.
-
_
..
.
LA Fan
3 L:
. ;.-
H0!" ":_
.. - FBI
--{Fan
_; MM"
-wu=.aI.>;
|-
.. .
SJ FBIH l_'D"FBI;
V<-
1+0!Y%L
wan
0N 1FBI
1] J92f"."'L
R TL
_ _- FB
Q
% ml
- n - kNYm=BI-n
- <mn>cwI> n
I"" H. AN! -FBI;
.-
fNO.
.1:=1.- -. .
FBI; c:,";. IR
--
FBI .-
n :T |:i<£*'M5TFBlFL
WMEMMMPBIM
TKH0!
I
_
_;
_mYY{EBI_;_
-H'QL§O'GA
W
i i COM-F_BIj
J _.-
CG!_ FBI
- ."
- ...____ |=B1}, _ _
92
.
SE16./200'4§
'
"
REsPqmsES4195 .
I%_.
MaS'sage
' r
-" -,*
O» %
.j.l.- f ~P».g=s.<>r1
W
" I 'C'l'D!
I ;FBI!
V A
_ ;
~
'
B
-N
BI; _.
._
I . __
.|_ cTm_p=a1lL
.j +{M| f4}__{FBI&#
IIDJJFBI
.[FBI!;|
_MM!_
- W_FBIF;{
w§!_¢[_|=B1g;|_
- ff
- N! !_ GAJi|
_|<xEBI!_;_|'
_*__W
__. a_|-1! FBI!;
'qu%x_om.rFBIf;
_
IL
F
%
MM!
_{FBI!;_|
MIMFBI!,-j
tM!]FBI!;_|
M
mes, ARTHURM.- C170 FBI!;
- MM
Fan
- ...|j MM!_;EB_I
V_s:_=_!
.
FBI {NY} Fan}j_.[MM!_ |=s1
C?_!_
_ FBI
'
3H5
'
.B
Q
.
_ IRL FBI- _ _ - _'Px!_._ FB1i j 1 MojjFEQ;j
-92.
."-
[ -
-
=>.- --
FBI; m!_ |=s-'' 11
. _'
____ .PXL FB ' 7
. i
.
=_
- __
H0 --
l -I I17
0F
W1_:!; EBI'
_._EmB
-
-
NYFB _ _M___"
'
l'_ F92L!_
7_ '¢1:>uFB1>
FBI ':o<>;FBr|
9<PBn;.
j war!:
'
N O FBI];
L UWF PGL
FBILIEMM
|
l.'|:'
FBIEi|_
"'N_Y!_
U.
I.
[[DL!_&#
OG#!_;_
=B1
U
' con
"j
i s1! ccm;
-£1 FBI Iv
MP FBI-;
- '
*1
.j lL|_{CG}_[FBI,k[R&
.
L
L92lY
E
r
ssi_{
DGA
.
j uni, . t.FL!_'EFB_I};-|§_
b6 -1
-mc ~1
__ '
- MD
FBI '
-- -'[ [IIH
I[Mm-_g|=B1y|_'L'=
CWHFBIMW
UCEUFBLEG
|' M92ijj1
'FBI
'.
UUDMFBI
'D'
LIA!,_I.'DtuFBni.
|I=;I 1:51;
_
_cro>_ FB1;
_ CTD}jF'=-BI;
_
_
-|-|0!-_{00w-
W_P:-+gFB1-; ' WLmo!--
I
FBI!%
_~c0n. FBI!;-I
i<SEa
F5131
|
_
.
=
]'§sL.|=a'I!j
-. .|_{ME*!]jFBI!_;|Z
W
1-mm '
FBI-'HARRINGTON_,TJ.
c'r|:>1_L=a1-_
N?1'_!.'
"
MP¥i!.
.EBI-fl
|J=_
MM=!;
-E51!;
I
q I-FBI
U1.- |£WFl"WFBI!
LE
Fe: _l Iil!i=I9H
AI
@;_¢sa;1,'J
?__
W
AN FaI! rm!- -|=.B;!;_
IR!'_ FBI _.u!_- cow;
- r-ro!. _or5A!;
ma!
y-
-FBI '[DN!{FB1'
'] cr0 |_=a1"
|q_p=a'n;LLi '
|_ TlI1]__ I-=EI'
_'
1
HO!_' F_B
_l_ AQ_!_
-.
.FaI!;_|
?,*__ *_ -
J
.-
FBI -__ j
-Ag1F*Bijj _|_q[-no
cc [1=BI§;|-
[T+0q_@r-=B1;|j MM
- -HO-!- -FBI! - _Q21-1s=
,1-;| 7-
cn! _;.|=a1 ; -
Pam- "
FBI!;-_ -.
EBI~
_
_1.'t>q-_QF'gt=
_ _AL};
" .1112.
FBI *-
* .-SI*,-Z-FBI
-
.
|'L_
_INSD!_{FBI.*
E
|' -__MER1fs1
1'] | c
FBI
- FBI
MM! FIH_HU.L§FBI&
.| 
. MM
F I.-'
-_, CTDHFBI} ., .__=._I
;_7 UB
-IRD--~_
FBI'_ - NK}__{"FBI h-I
__
I I]_ sg!_;
;__
W
_rro
Fs1]
~
8/"16¢ 2O¬l4' I
i DLHFBI!
.MM}_ r=BI'
__
FBI-'
H _.M
.;_ .
V- =RESPONSES-196"
-
.. _.
_-_,,
_
. ....1
_
_Pé,c4[.!f.7
.
__
_
occ 'FBI'
WW _5U]_[FBI'
ce};;1=s11,-_| - W _LDL FBI;
-:3 i§'
"
:-
.
NH-!_{FBI1;
1__
--
V
.
;
LTD FBI ;
_ _-CTD!; FBI
V
1
- CG]_[FBI' WW PH!__[FBI!j_FW W -OM FBI!;7' 1
W .EP!_§EBI
__LV
c10! |=a1! MP
1.=ar!;"
.0GA'!"
. :
=-
Y
CTb!'
-II*
i!'11
FBI.|
i
§F!FB1|__11i
FBIJE
.I
j
_ LAL{f_BI W
"~~rLg5s1.W W
su _g=s1»
- ._;
DE}_{FBI MP
FBI!
. NY! FBI!; .
.92"_ NY}_ §BI
.
j
|._
_[DN!_.[FBI
LA}_ FBI]_,_|
...
!_§4,_|
W _
krw]_- FBI I;_ NY}_[OGA
,
§LA1~§FBI1;|
_
_
1R!_
|=a1E|_|__
W
|.Ajj?EI1,-W
. _;
cg;s!_ |=s1 NY!
oszx!
' -
--
-
..-
|<c;_ |=Es1!_,-_|__ W
=Mlmgsn-;
- .'CE
.
3j
FBI B-- '
___
F ~
FBI!;
I M
1!
-
{H6!_ FBI,
SA]_[FBl
_
-.W
.'
1 ;'
1'l'DJ_
FBI [ MM! FBI!
EMM!, '
FBI!;
lIR FBI!|ENXUFBIEMM
'
ICIUFBI
'FBI]
'1!|9
I1
156 -1
bjc -1
MM
|'!92LQ,-§0GaRf FBI_
.9!,.
' --I£_-
W
HF- BI
NY FBI}
W.
-MM FBI"
92 ;
'
-
-
..4
.
1_
l]:L|_''
.MM!_{FBI'_
. _ LL|_ MM]_'
FBI-{
.OGA'
MM!W@{!j
' ..AiI FBI!:..1Es: - _rm
FBI!
_- .- W -R .F
W
LLB!
.&#
W _, np}_.;FB:w FBI
=
._[ sA
MML{FBI1{
_.-!.,;__
FBI"'
W WWW
WWJI-um
A
*
_ W .~92q_{-cam]
-N
.-1Rm,
'
:=a1!,'_|
-
- L'L'|
WIISLEQGA.
Jn|-!_
Fe-1!;]
W
"MM!__
FBI
_td;MM_!_
Fa1.;,-L
__W BHQFBI
'
~-"--- .
_W
5§!_ _FB1
_mjpx!-_
=.5I!;_
_.'
_gc1-011551
-TPE =B1
_-- m'1 o@A!;
.
SL]_-_ FBI!_J |_'{m<'
."
= _g.M*réi!;{FB1.
L Gc]_-gal-I
.I_ rm-1l|a:1j;- ~
% su1tFBI!i Li
DE-HFB1-J; %<~Y>W<FB%1n:
"=
|_qMP;_ -F511] '
LR"- FBII
=:$m=B1T1
._. W -'
11=
11:21:11
rm
FBI!;WW_
NYFBI
_W ..:H
L
_EPf|a_s-!n=aI!
EBI":*7*
l MM!|
'
érm
-:=an;%
. sn
esp.! N} FBI!,
LL? se
OGA! MMRFBI
I FBI
-
--
.
-1
j
CG!;
'---CON '
J1 -LP
'
!:
- FBI!
1W
IR IR!_[FBI
BH FBI
rm FBI
NY!_ Q§A' W V _.-
__
"_
~-- -A-s|aq- =|_=a1-!7 W
-W .El"=Ri{E5I____]_:
+|e-@552!;'
<;m
FBI
Ice.
-FBI
W '
_,. ;
-rm. FBI. -1'ro1 |=a1!;| -
ASD! FBI!; HQ
W . .'MW]_ FBI; _
r=sr-'
W.W
Ili=!
WW .
rm ;_
;
-cm 'FBI'.CJI5"'FBI'- CTD
! FBI-J;_|_A!_g55n;| .W -
_W
Se¢D!-{FBI}
HO! F31!
'W,-_
._
*- 81 16f20U4.
-
FBI!:
..
-FBI -* '
IR 'r=a1
W
L _» s|.1!;. -'
1II-
%V
1-D! F5111
__N *_|=s1~
RESPONSES,
-- _'
-_197
?
MM! .
'
_
..-
.Més~§;g¢
. Vi
_-.
_.
'»7?L" §% HI!;{M5-i!.l=a:A
i_ Asn,
'ff|' r<:xf
.
FBI
FBI
_
rm osa
__
I
1W
1
Br=!_g|=a1
.JN}_g=a1
_'BF!_[FBI'
_q2vvLq.0c-1A!:1'
LM
]_ FBI],|
:__
._ .;~1=s1y|*i w5_ c0N,
-MM~!_ FB{;
-
_I
!_ FBI' j
?_
"
>1-I
-j
cs!_ ::or~n,
1
-.-
»
'1
FBI-'
F'G'
kH0}_'
_
j
FB
FBnI-'
V
A!;|i_-&#
--[Ll
|gAr~1 .1?-BI
15
_
-
__ BMM!_'_
Hi NL? '
as!{|=a
._i we!FB
-L~|__
FBI F511
_l[MM!_[FBI
D h'NY!_
GA}
|_s"I' H-_FBI
__ l __
'
__." -CTD FBI ' ;MM]
-T
FBI '
CG
NY! FBI '
_
WE!~ FB1_' .
FBI"IR FBI
'.WF.FB!!
M '
|i~»;>§A*
j
A
= -
:
"DE FBI
LES Fan]1
IIu~1M;>= Fsn" - L' C0 !" FBIJ;? ».
[-Li __ ; 'B5.}.' FB_I!;
-
.'
I[_LA!_{CO
_1TD'L
__: 'A
FB1
[MM . II
~cm!_ F.s1!,-J
o! cFBI->; H
=
.
-b6
*-L-1--_- "%
%LL|'@'
_ccE>rFBIg|
FB .
P.
CTD}-L:@¢1_!FBI'
FBI1;]- l- mFBI'
_'- -
I b7c -1.
=1
"-
MW '-FBI-
- .- _"" |'?G!- FBI!. i
"'3 , _-
kM
HG
FBI
--
_. ow
f| m0--
.[f-tjTD1_§FBI-
"gar»-n FBr!;
Cj {FBI!;|,___
_ll lfllliillil
NYMFBI I30:
FE!
[{c0!_@l!_J PX}_[f,B£L
FBI} :.v Fs1,
| SD!__ FBI' -
- '
I
.
|_ su FBI!;
-
.-f
__
_
11>;
HN -FBI
I!
'HR;:I'-!_§F-BI
._ _"|_lIFFRT .EBr
HRMFBIJ
1" 7
~ ,7
_[1_-AEFB1--
NYUFBIJ,
_
i M§Lg|=a1
.
W_ _PG}_ FBI.-
- | r~.|Y}_ |=Bj_
.~:
5W'Jr=1gFs1
r1m=aI1,
_~.'
j
-'
__
MO
'-FBI
-i_HOuFBI_L|_E
__
_? _
;-. -->- " _Mo. Es;£|
UI.
F211;" "
FB
UFBI
l
* _kNYL |'- BL W
7
0 FBI FCTD!_ FBI
---_@cm1_{r=a1
i:sA!._=.:92|r§!;gFs1-'
jI-?'-rr|::!i<?i=a1
"~ _.V
",__
FBI! ?
rrrr>1 FE-I!
*
F-TD! F5113
_ |_w{! EFB1!;
CF-D! FBI!
- "1'|'D.!_
FBI
- Lf Fs1
as FBI
*MM
EBI;
L
FU" NY!;_ fBI!_;]
_u
{as}-g0G_A,
I;'
"I
. 2' V_-_ .1 1- *'-"_&
_;
b6
1
. @@A>';<a¢><FaI>
;
L to i "
.-
= '
--=b'7C
- - -. ~
"
._ . KC'E]=BI
_--
1
_
_'
1 I1!! H
_
Subj_.ect:_'_.
.- ~
1mp_c_vrtH"11ne:_
High : -
_
MM!
?iaI!_-
'!H
., - - 7
' ._-'
_'
|-11:1
!.
~-
'
-
-
_
-'
_;
'__1
_92
'
'
' '
.-
sensrrrve _gJTUNC_2L .Sf..i_[Fl_lE_l,1_-_-
-"NON-RECORQ"
.-'
1-
_'
Q
. _
_,-
.
"- hou.i"|e
identiiiuqsidnes
aoing
|'ve'be'e1r|
odri-duotied
ejssignnientliét
GTMO_,'Ci&
'
' i
' '
s'
9111101
. The
Inspection Division
hasbeen-tasked
with
contacilng-tiwose
employees .
_who havesewedin
anyoapaciiy
at_GTMO-and
obtain
information
regarding
the
-"
.- _tre'atrr|'er|t_
of
d'e_tainees.
Employees
should
immedigtgig
resp'ond
to
the
following :
aQ§re§é.i*el-Ireeirnent.
inierr.qe.?a1:I§3ns
_ - or.inten
.
''
i'¬ChT]iqU92=§S
GTMU
U"éia'iiTe'i-ES
¬5I1
Wi iii:!'fW§5
n0i't§O'n5iSté i'Wiih-Eliiféi. policyfguidelines,
should
respond
v'ia-email
forthepu_r_p'ose
of
a follow-up
intervieyv,
' _ .
'_
F osit_ive'e|_naiiresponsesshould
be_dire'.c :ed-to;
_
-_ --r. _
.'
.
--
_-
.
b6 ~1
-
_
~_
_ nspeotion,_ lVI$||DT_92
_.
-
__ . _. _
.
_.
2!-'_Er_1f|plo3?ees
whosenieoatGTMOendobserveq
noaggressive
lreatrrienl
of.
'_ _-__
--.. 'detair1ees,'shouId
respond
viaéln'EC do_cumenting-a.negative
response,
Tr|_e'E_c.
'
'
'
- .T shoijld
inolude'|e'emplojreeTs
o c_ial'Bureau
name itlel
and£_en'ure.'_ofa$sigi1
'
_.'
-TheECshoilrld
betitled"'C'ounterterrorism
Divi5io_n;'G
rnspe¢:ran;spe¢ia;_.._
FN|Q_-,
_ ,
" -file#!'29_7'-HQ-A13276_69-AEC
shouldnotbe
_up| 5ade_d.'butonly-s&#
The
hardcopyfonvvarded'1o:_._.
'
-_
'
'.
4 _
92
'.
.r. _- -
'
' '
-
I
r
.
_
_
_ .. - ,_i
I-
- '1n's_p1ection'Di92iisiqn
'
-'
T
L '."0 i<:eoilr92
ec ons
_b6'_1
i
_b7c:
-1
SENSiTNE_BUTU_NEI:ASSIE1EB
~
.--'_.'
-Rm
__
-'
'; -'
-.s,g1:is'|T'1y:iz_13yi
UN ,i7.b;S5l_E|Eg.'h .
_'.
'
.~'-
.
-
" '_""_
P
_ '
- T '"."'j;'"'f
1
if " .""T"7":':
'f-_"
" ** '
" f'j"" '
".'_"j*"§','"
" 1 -7 _&#
- §_ENSITl}1
EBUT_!JNCL_ASSlF
IE D
-
_:_gsns1'hyé
B_L_i'-j|'L_LJl:l_!.f.?LA$SJ,i=iEl':p'
.'V'i
_ . _- 8/15.12004.- _
.RE5|5cjNsEs-199.- '
;; ,
_
..
___
___
._ _|._r§§_s_
'
s§.ge.''_
_'
T - P5gé._&#
4-
' -§_l§5I;SlTNE_BUTiU -CLA§SlFl_ED
" -SEus|T1vEBu1'uNc1'.Ass||'=|,
I
¢
I
1
.1
J
r
92
J
.in1
.
-92.
92
,
".-
.
'
L -
sx16x2oo4~- -
%%
RESPONSES-200..
.
--
>
Positive
Response
Number
¢
15
a
'~.
_n|cLIN$B>
FBI!n1P ' %
»%
'4"
B¢4
7
--
..
i:;*|~~ss>w=B»>
L ?n
W1 _-1 Se-r_1t:' Wednesda
,July14,2D04.3:5QPM
.
. -
_
."
-
-'
- -.:..,
5ubj¢¢+;R1;;eTMc_;y-'_" -
UNCLASSIEIED " .
,
"°"-RCRD
,
.-
1
*
'
'.
Until
'OK-,
decidelwlhal
we
i:c$rr_1;':iif=
was
1nt,'li:=::i|jisidert1"|'isn
no n_ee;_!
to do
an
n
92 _ _
.-InaiMes;5'a
e--n V I
h;I
in
J
AIn{me -1-:xL~-.-===r-=i
"11?
F
.="-S'¢I__1i::>TueSda'-"3'u|
-1-3:2 04-*9=s2-AM;
i~
L
_
"
VFm
1~
_Ns|3!
-
~- I
.
'
*'
'
* '
j~-- . -
-
'b7c
M"'l;|'
-1. -'
' a 0nayear.TDY.-_
- - _'
92
._. --'
- .|have_ een assigneoG_TMQ-slnca-Oct0t1er20lJ3
-.to
on
I-- " -. r
be -1
'--
'_-.
.I
-. --
-
--
.
.
.
I hzlave
ubéewéd interview
iechniques not
consistent with
Bureau intervievi
poiicy, but
in compliance
with
Department qf-Qéfense.
"DOD policy.
Ih;'ve-npt_taken_
any interyiew
partjn
uyhere these enhniques
wegrg
allqwed .bL;thaye or'1lyo_bserveq|.._
.-;_
_
'.
-
~'.
_ __'
7 _Thé Eletaiiéuof
tnéss; i-r'1tér~:i
-n jcu-rt'sha§c_|'<|in§
e_92}v§'coi1:*;ist-c
ner, Edld
tenn§er;h4ré5,'I§uB
:_f,td- -'
the
'
mln
-st1fqbe_|igl1t§|énd.féf92interr0ga u_m_-o'dm
in Igngpefiods
tinge,
for
or __p|92ga_ir_1,
this ~_¢_vas=conststé|'nt
with
U00. , 92
-pq|ic_yn0t_F-Blpoiicy-
I ,-
..-
-" _
-' __v
-_
1-_ _
_'.-f
-
__'._Fo'r
5% |h§pe<=mm
0j_visicn,":
infnrmatidn
be_of['GTMO
.-.-miIfx si mnbmtq
sno*"._
rrém
cén
Contact
me
if '
..
necessarqyi
" -_¥
- - -'_-
-i bvc -1? -
_ ..=
.
.I
-92.-_ -...__. __....._.:._..---_
,-_._
',
|§n:L.g§s|F1g'Q" _.
[
_ ."_
"
.-
,'-
_1
.
_ _A 7:_..._ _' ..'...:;_.
...__
_..____,_
,.._._._'__._'._,___4_,._,_._....._.'
.__'______,___,-__
__._.
________,_.,___.__.,'
L1,___,.........~_
_-_,____
____';_
__..__
____
,,..
' 1
-. -=_-* R iESPQN§ES-.2.01".:
" -71412004 .
|
_
__
--
_. __ _
.-
.
92.
n
»-
'
Positive
Response
Number
_,
*
16
.
'
*7
mi
_
'
-'_
_- '
__I Mosls
1 gel
-H _-
Pagelof2
hi6i I-1;_____
__,._,
_e i,__,
_msD!
Q ___
______j__,,__,
_ ,
-
'.Subject:l§EiGTMO. :-
..
-
.
l-
'_
thie
_a
l-.ivill.olassify
as
fesponae;
oosi needito
ve anThanks."
No
EC.-T
do
_i
'
-
--J-¢"'a<;i¥*
-
i _--'--on
lnal'Me
-_ .ssa e---"
'
'
"
.- - " Fron'92: | i0<!- FBI! ._
§§c"11'Sent:
uesd
zoo»;
4:25 PM»
~
- -_T° _ INso! Fa1!_
-s
.____uJ"_1._
ct:RE: MO. _
.
-
;."
5..
__ -- .'
_'
"h
's_E.L4S|Tjve'_e1'L1j,1_|gQAssiF1EQ
'~ __
-i
.
'b7C
i
_'
,
-'
"i'
'
justatom-ed
' ;in|1i_1a|.lea§ie
fmm
read_the_be|ow
and
repiy_e-ntail.
reouested
.'-1wasioyioomormmsizsioa-1ir11rn3j
;
-. -
'
.
-"I- he only-rhatterwhioh
may berelevantthatlol1seriied.t1vas':':__-_
_- -- .
-
-. 115
"1 l.{DateL'ln'known,_possilqi3i' -3-ctl'No~ttime
at'Campi_l2elta,
:- iamej
-'71
MC
'
Gold'Trai1er,'"l_
believe! lnlewiewllntenogation
treiler.-We heard
loud musiocoming
from, the
right fa'r_near
'.
-_ .'of oneofthe"interikiewiinterrogatlon roomsfand
proceeded
to
enter the observation
hoothin bet_wee_n-.
'I -- -_rooms,'
1ig'l_-its
The
the-lnteniiewllnterrogation
werje_off'in
butthere
room was
a strobe
light onwith loud .
e - _music
_.
inside anda clotheddetainee sitting
on the oor, noone elsewas inthe roorn.An unknown
white '
=
_be _1 " -- 'm'ale
civilian clothing
ente:ed the'obaeniation
room
we werein. and
toldus we
should notoe
there._ SA'f
.. .
an-fc _1
-_|':_lE]andn1yselte:dted
- _ ._.
1eroonj.'
'
~ 1-~_" I_,
. -
.-i
.
_
_
.
5
.'
: ._I Doesthis constitutelaggneesiyejeatment
and wafranta
follow-up-linteriview-by
?'
if not,
you
should" I .
_.'-c'_.ornp_letereply
a'negat_ive
ECstating
I
did- not
observe anji
other uhusuoliaggressive
treatment ? '_
_. '
_
-1 - _- _.. -_. ___
' .-
b7C 1 --'3A' FB|= _'
. K
'
"on,
..'-_- . ..-~
-
1
.
'
.. .
"'3 '
Johnson-city RA
" _o2 -"1__
_'
.1..-~.--OI'ig_ina_ll'/le'.;5agt=;
_.
- -.---'
_Fi'om:'
MCCRAW, SFEVEN
c. NSD! FBI! l
_ sent: Friday,July 09, 20042:42
PM
--
- -.
" supject:errM0_ -- " - "
..1mpor.ta_r|ce:..t-li'gh_.
...-.
.= _.
-'
_
_-
.. _ _ _ A _
' SENS]J'iVEEiIi'UNCL555SlFlEQ
". t"
-
You havebeen identi edas'hav'jr|g
an conducted
assignment
at GTMO.Cubasince
9!11l01;
The_
inspectionDivision
has
beer|.iaslced_ with
contacting those
employeesguho havesewed
in any
' capacity
at GTMO
and obtaininformation
r_eg'arding
treatment
the detainees.
of
Employees
should
1 immegiatelg
respond to
the following
:l
M
l . I' - _" T .. .. I '
'-
'
|__ 92
'
___
t
_I
;:
___
_
|<Ii~ev_>t¢FB!>
- t:§¬~ 55i,&#
Sent: Tuesday,
Ju|y2?',
1:25 PM
2004
'_b7°
-H
_1
__
"
_ _-
_
., Subject:"GTMO-'
'..'
T
.
.. .
. SEN-SlIlVE-__B._UJ'
u1§ICLAs§:F|E0_1&#
_'
- -'
..IQON-RECORD .- "
.',
''
'
b6 l
_
r:5-1-_-_
- hewiidght'it
remembem1e-ter|ing'-him
:~~--- -~:;-:-- '<-.|'can
r-:.=-2=1-"--j
--Atthe-time, i th:5uWes
SA|; _|uitr1_me_fdr_we
ii- ere paired
tbgether mest_cf 1e_tjme_L
n0t.recalt.'
Bdtq sA|:|regeming_mi's
.."
'b?C
|j _|_5tte|k'
-1
matter.advised
He
he'_v92fas
not"wi_t_h_
oh the
d;1y'i_n,ques
r_rie
dn
-'uwhoitwasthatwaswithmel;. -"
i
- -_
_;-;.
-"
1
- 1 Knoxville Division,
-.}ohnson.City'RA
_1-b6
b-1
--_-e--O_ri Ina!-Messa
e'---"_ .'
= . ~r.r==m=ei<i<><>-<FB1>
e-VV .
lb7c_ -1_-___ j-q=
'_
NSD5__
EBI'!
b5 '1Sent'Tuesda Ju13 2004425
'
Sub'
::G-TMO.-'~
.
_ - NONiR5QQ_ 31:1,"
-_._Q__;
- '
PM
= '
b6 -1
. J§-"
'
w
Iljust_rét11'i'|1ed.frorn'anr:1_u'alIeéive-add
h_eiew? 'féc|_ue5ted-reply
éfmgilf__i_read'-the
|__weeTDY tb'emo
:mm"'sr251ds-11:11x0a...
~- - 3_ _._ _
The o_nty_-mafteriavhieh
m§y?ui=; reieirant-that!
dbsewe_~i:I
I _west_
:._ ='.
_:-'
_l; _I" '_
'
'
" '
.
-{Date U_ni<no~.-in,
Oct!Nov
-poslsibty
timefragnej
SA ar|d n -zyseif were
at
Camb
Betta;
in the Goid
EEC E1
' Treiier,
I believe]
interview- lnterrtugaticn trailer.
heard-ie_ud_.
music comiftg
fr0r1|1 the fat
right
rearof one-of
the -.-
_.'
intewjewlinten'ugatio_n
roomsand
proceeded tq
enter the oI:iser92__r§ti_on_bodth
in -betweeri
roqms. Thelights were''
C|ff_in
-.
the Intewiewfl terregation
room but'there'wes
astrobe light-on withlaud rijusic_inSi_dé-and_
eéibthadf _" '
j ' _
'
_ detainee
_' sit_ting'c:n
oor, no
the
cine else
was inthe teem.A _Ll k D92'f ~WhitB
in ciyilian
male
dlothingi entered'_the3,5 -1 '
_;_-- #e|::serVBtien reerr|?we>we_n=$'iq% "and:tatd'~E|s-»ye1shQu|d
C_1
" Dge_e.this
deqstitdte-ag_gree$i1;e~treatn'rent
inzémew
and-warrants
youby ?" '|rnfd:,.sn@uia
Retina»;-up
cm -npreée-a
'
-_ "
'
_negative
_
reply EC
stating !
.I
did
not
.
i-..$A|:]FBi-
observe anyether unusuavaggressive treatment? _
. .
_1
.
'
-ma
_-_
92
I _.-
-1 .'
- -' '
I
- Q_ _
. ' :_ , ,
'D'iviiI
K D§ Vl||B.'
o|*-1.
-- '
.'
I Johnson-City'_RA
-I
-
;"- '- b2 -1
._?/2?x200¢_
*
7
_117
__ _
.
- _ 92RESPONS_ES 2Q3
__
_-
_
i 4|
II_
i
._ t
-&_
_
-'
w
__
,-
-
Positive
Response
Number 17
.
92 »
i '
I§f1'3s§a.Ee
I
:.'Pa.ge1
-be -'1'
Hif ulN5D.!{F5
'_
"_'
t!~ T
1°" ".1!
sear;-.'
-'1Nednesqa7y,July14:-2004-7:59AM
_. -1
_ ___7._f_? f'- .2
H
--
Ii ~T==e=
|:irsE>»<EB*>f
P"
~L
éubge-;i:.ee;sj~_1o-.
V,
'.
'
-7
_SEt~1S1 |_ iv-E
u_Mci..==.s§IE1§_I;_r
BUT
.,
__
M017:-gggggn3-
_-
__.
_
i
it/ ,»~'
.
.
'_" -
-
-_ _-
~I
._ "Q1
- .-_ . .
-.
-
OK, I-'wi_|I
COi1SideE__thi5
apbsitixie
'resp|_:|r'1se._
d_o-an
No req1_.1irementfory0u
Thank;
EC.. the
fer respgnse. te
_,
~
.b6
inal l?*ie§Sa
_.
5. _-" :
*1 "
FP9m= 5E-ll-@I!---
iti b?° 61'T0i §5D1 F5I!,
'
.
i
sent: Tuesday,"-Juiy21304
13, 2-1;-4'
PM_
__-
.Subje¢t:G- l'M_0..
..
_-
'
'
'
I -'
I -:'
"I '
- '-
WHt t t
"
I
r
.SEN_SlTI U'E Bl[l'.UNC_LASS_IE1§Q
_-[gem-Rscogn 5 ..
9292
-'
-
_,_
.- -.
._
-u _|i-1.-:respe_;1sé'
_tc:_'t_h-e'recjuest-for
t-_reet1T92_er|t_efd_eta_i1I'|
¥nf_0.rrT_1_atidn'g"eg
et
GTMQ:
I. _ __ _' "|"s_é5F@u_;LT;iY"51_I_errMoTfrqm
ear1y :.I1.]|'*ie
'rr;|idLJu|y.-20$-.
one
id .-ncaassipn
|witiiessed
O_ri
ziitemiéw. 9
.techniqué.s thetibetieve
werenot cons,ist_e'nt
with F;Bl_'iF1lENiB_W_pQ|ipy
or gpidelinee.
Sometimemid
in tqi1...
-_ léte JuneIviewedan |'hter_rogatio_n'th'rough
one way'glass_beh'|g
conducted an
in actiaeent
interview room.
_'1
--I witnessed cteta,ir1iae=seetect-in
"a
middle
theof
the ¢_er'while
lqudlrap crheaw
metal music
was eeir;g_
'
,-- _.
...-pfgye from
a porteble
CD_ player.
Two intértogatbrs
were standikig
above__tha detairiee
end continuously;
' laughing
and blowing
ci ar 5I I_1O|<8
in thedetéir;ee_'s'fai;e;'
identi es ofthe
interrogators
Wl ilethe
_92
is __ _
-unknqwn,Ibelievethat
they were_assnqiatetI.wit|¢i'Defense
_S'ewices'0r
Hu_n_1int by theUS-Army.
cpntragted
_
__ l.1 "_ .'
-'_,:¢1ir1
éC'v92_aitl:_be
|ore -detailed
se:jt'reg'ari:ijhg
.5 :'
._:' '_
7'
ltj'1is
lj
Ab?C.b6 1- i _1i-2 s lii
~ '
'.
1
"-FBiS.eattle
._ .' -_b2
V
"i
-_
'
' '
-1 .-
.
_.
-gezisiriveeu1iuuc§L2§§iFiEn_~
_.'
"
_-i_L-.emeeere-s1nite_e.u1u.ttc1.»issIEIEL._. ittt;.?.t,i,_..__.._;._,.;;._-_.--t+;._.-=..__i-;___.__i,i.: _i._-.;.;_ _-_
'
-RESPONSES 204
.--
71-'14."z004
. -'
"
.:
r
Positive
Response
Number 18
.i,
il é
.
92
'
_' -
-92
Message." W
-
.
_
-
."
.Pagelofl
;F_ at r ,' T{e1N$v!
=~ FBI!J
ea dd
rp
b7C -1 _Sent: Monday, July 26,'-200-42:52
PM _'
[_71%-=r
|j|<%'~$.D>r<FBeI1e
_
Suh§ect:GTMOlnquiry .__.
"
._-
§ENSIT1VE_BUT_lJ N-Q1-&§$lFLE._E_J_'
'.
,
be -'1
Fnr.liet-reeoneilie on
8Apurposes.
Albuquerque wision,did not
inerscrnélly abusive
obleerve
b?c -1 -behavior towards
detainees while
at GTMO.
As indicated
in my._5C,,instar1ces
reported
of
abuse
by detainees
- were
reported viainterview FD-3025;
_ _'
_. _-
'
'
'
'
_.
_d emsJ1, ILEBur UNCLASSIFIED
I
¢
F
*1
-2
92-
:-
J
-' RESPONSESQO5
1126:2004 ~-
-
_-_
-*
.
F J77
77
*7
*
7
W
'7
7
7
7 _ 7
77
___
j
e'
'FEDEFlAL_BUREA_U
OF
lNvE$T|aATioN
- H,i
l_.II. I
v_ _5H._.hl
'Precede::ice.:' -RQUTI1-12.}
__
-.
_'Da._3c'.e:-'
- 0'7./231
-'
_ '
. __
IIi1spec921:io'n'
o_:
l ' Attn':i92__T;_Tnit
:Chief.&#
115L. 
-=. Room ?837'.-b7C
IiiFru 5- ,
Rlbuquerq éi '" "'
T1"-@
i.; - '
,.'
_j_u'
""lJ f' .'
"
' '
..'Squad.6XLCRA '
-- _._Cr:»n_tact::
-132
I
' b61 -
'-- "!1,._
-mc: ~1 APPIQVE5
31" llh
-___
-1 .
-,_
5 -" §/'
-3 '
I-'
'_
- __I-_ -.--
' _ -=_'_ i ._
'
' .-§g,_
+e
e_:-¢§§y§1
P
=
M
_"-
_I
;
11 »
i Case -:1: #= '23"?- H'Q-A1jgvss;9iA _-ipem-ring!".
'
'1~it1é=-..-" ',cou:41T
.
<
-
-
_'"'i.c;'rr~1o;~
_
.- .;_
INSPECTION -SPECIAL INQUIRY
-
i
.--
,
~-3-_
_
.
_-
.'._'sy£=@psi-'5;
if cfl. --Res-iaonse
'.;L¢1;ing',ssRA|:|:
of
G"l"1'*10f'ee
y
_I
|_ -;-_in|t;eI 1;Qgat|iC_JI'1s
_'_ .-_
l
II
: _
1-.
ll -__ _
.?C-1
_:bé-ta:i.-ié="
--~ Z0133
sA was 'r1:iY-ro_
jermei
bégi';1
l_.-b64- .ning
Tl " '28. for
45_daY$'&i1'iin_Pa-rti-=:'iPat'eQ.
interrbat'i.-0ne'-3

_-
bl - ."_ i1almds
Z
..
e';<'¢1.us_i_»-eg
U-1'8-.
withCID--of-fic
Army
er -
"Ig5; Véi
-//
b6 -1
_3.'
the outset, 2.. NC
'_
7At
5
[and*6f éf'E ?EE pETe6 e1natJGIMQ
ETTIV1 we;e_'
__ e
.-instructed;in=e
clbsed-door orientation
to abide
by
Bureau ;.-
be giveqs iranaa
.-_
policy.= and
guidelines
inconducting
inte:r0gaLionsr'with
~_ ~Hthe
.-. __..
....
-,..
.<
_
b7c _1'
Bxcepeion that
detainees were
net to
l_
- '
warnings. QBureeu.personne1
yere;¢1ear1y{told-that theaFBI¥did'.i
"
'~'
-not condq
e-dz
participate in,
sbme mili¬ary_interrogatiqn
I techniques
jThis
referenpe was
made_specifically td.
I
-iI1'ter1 C:gatiOn -te_C_h:1iq1.1'ésI
militaryofilfite-1],-igerice
officers,
.| not
to other
milita membere
of the_CriminaL"Investigetive
,
-
_- _;
_
. ,
11$
'_
'1_
Ta_._ak
,_Force
-Slx
dic1'rIbt
any,ab'1.1sive-1;r&#
'witn'e'
_.
11¢ -L
detainees during
interrqgations or
othepwise. '
-_§'_-_'-'
i e§'
"_ Qdeasiqhaiif, during interview seesiqne}-Qeteiheee
_-
complained 0f_ineppropriete
beha ior by
military;pereDnneL.=
.
Such Qpmplaints
were'inc¢rporaced intd interYiew.FD-3Q2s~per
~
,
_ins¬ructions of
Bureau management _'An example-of
sueh.e.__
_ _
"" ""-'
repéfrt
"
- déin -'}':>'ef_ft: 1Td "i fi 3'l"51iI'? F[MIC9'9T0F2TA1?1£
--.-.--~; ------1-- _4"
" .and.
zwhich
e detainee
alleged.a female.guard_removed.her_b
*, /h ? ¢¥,
while
pressing her'body against a
shackled and
restrained ,.~ +-__
detainee from
5.for
menetrual blood
behind, '
handled. his
on his
lack of_Cooperation,
head and
genitalia a.nd_'wiped
face as
a ford
of punishment
.TheHdetaihee.stated ;his'persen
"P¥T5;=%1?..¬E¥33.2
':_
WB6_ 1
Tf .
_
-
'
_
'1 _
'
'
Ji
5':'i1w.$IFI
RESPONSES- Z06.
'
..
,__...
c.......$
.. ..;_.._e
.,_...
,_. ., -~ -r
.-- néiiféBii.?.2E9.m*-z{'2.L§.i=.~;!.a§'
_
tEmwm§ @§@H_n ._'~ __
._=_
' _-F,ee i,,»%mi;T- M
PELCZIAS$lFY;i£!i§§.1 Z ;l?§l5§?_D_3.l?
. - - »-1.-- E15???"-=_?§?T¥--5--ZlF?-E155
": i ; -I-"---$9= =»
.-----
.*
-
- .,
_
_§I3LEi§3'§§!§§!111i°¬ U'm-E_.§
--
;.
%
G *1
Ir1spectionH'P1 OT =' 'A1buquer_§nie
'
.
Re:.
291-HQ"*A13'2?"a59-A,
01/23/2_oo4. "
_ . '
_
.
92 ..:
.re§ur gd'fr0m
ché interrogation'with
bldod 9i$iblE @H-his92f@¢E
.- "and head;
=
-"
' ..'.-"--3*-
n n'-
.
. 1--
,- "7
-
"' '@
.'
- .Q5=
' ..-
7
_
6
I.
I
I
_
92
.
,
.-,:
-'
J
.
.- '-
.
.
."
- RESPONSES+207-
.
.':
_.
a
0
92
,
.
.
-
' Albuquefque.
-"
To:
''insp__eC_tiTon
_From
Rei-
.
'
_I .q?{g3/2004 *
297fHQzA1327669< 2;
.
.1
.
.I
_ -
L33D sJ: .- "QY'
.
Sgt Le_.a'd
.l:'.
_{II1fO!-.Z_:
INSPECTION
_ _
_
_
'
= :hAT'WASH;NGTON'
Dc;"
_
Q-;For_in
onlyl
orma;iQn
I
J
I
9
1
'
-
.'
_
_ -_ I
_
I1
_;
an
.
--
.
' :-
-_
'
'J 1
....__.,_
. - ----I--__._._-.-.~.._
-I-.----.--3-_-1-L-----_---71-----i_...-___.T_..._..-._-_-.-._..L-_.__.T_._._.._._._|___,___,___,,,.
._,_.,._...
-
;
:1
.-
_-
_
-F
1
' I
_
r
r
?RESPONSE_S
fi
20
a_'"'
.
FDM2mwJW&%!
'
.
_
5
; -
-
.
1." FZEIiERAL'BU1¬1§AU
or INVESTIGATION"
"_
__ISN}
Delta,
United
b6 r
b7C
b TD _
DTF "'
=
-internment Serial-Numberi
.
an Egyptian male, was interviewed-at
CampNayal Base Guantanamo Bay,
Cuba,
by Special
States
Agents|
[of the Federal Bureau of Investigation
l,__
eDivision
, _l-eflthé
9% Contract nité
._ -i'
'
Investigations
linguist
ates
A
d
._
I}~]
The'first
fifteen
minhtés'of
the interview
-
ocburred
__ ,
interpreted
between-Arabic and-English. The iollowing
during the'oonrse
of the_teo¢hour;interviey;i_:
-_._.,
English,
[:::::::]
and
Criminal
7
:
occurred
in
said'he
learnedwhatEnglish he knowsat the '
University
of Cairo, Egypt. ;He appeared to heYé.appr0ximately a 2
level commandof.English on.a
5
scale
He'smiled
frequently and.
_b6 ~4
1::-TC-11
1:3-TD
-1
..b'?E
-1
-
ed
madesome-attempts
at humor-E:::::::]eaid he hadbeeninterview
1by_a man this
mqrning._ The interviewer
would not say what agency
--he-repreee
nted..
garuer-small,-t'a_lk,
|:|
requested"
the"-interviEW
'oontinue'dn
Arabic.1
-b6
-4
b?C -4
-
i .'
'
[:1-beoan e""se_rio'ns='and
saidhe -learnedafter coniingt
to Camp Delta
_b7D
-1
that
the-Egyptian
government has accused him of
being
part of'ai1955
plot to assassinate President Mubarak _They also
b7F -1;
I
_;'e*_]'-'
Q}?
,_
qq- _l"-=
say he is part'of
an.organization
called Al Wa!ad;- He then said he
wanted~to describe_what the Egyptian government-is like._ He said
in'i9E1,
a law was passed-in Egypt_which'says
he can be tried in
.Egypt
.
without
anyxrights:andfwithont
a lawyer,
and that
the death
penalty_oan_be imposed
on.him.';T%is
lam plaoes'oi%i1ians
uneer-~
military
law,.THe.believes'peopleshould be tried'by
civilian
,
-courts,
"ts
-4
"
b?C -4'
b?D -1,
'b?F
-1
not military
courts.
He also
said
the Egyptian'government
conducts operations
such
as bombings-and blames'them
on Islamic
groups to justify
their actions against
snch
groups,-This happensd
-under past,administrations,in
Egypt also_
Q ;~l
'*
_ t» lE::::::::]said
t
the accusationsof the Egyptian goeernmen
against
him,
are.not
such as his.alleged part in the assassination-plot,
true '-He
reasoned that, if
these things were true, he';
Egypt.
After
Egyptl
Yet -he wee able to - f'ly'~out'
e-F "E"a ff6"T1§iEf1TfvafLjir1-p~a*e'ep~
would have been arrested
all,
by Egyptian
he said,
it
authorities
was_not as
if
1in_-iQ_@haEnhelhad iQbbed_a;QaQg,;it;yas
a_plot to kill
. in his true name.
It was only after
while
he was in-
the allegation
he traveled
were
the-President of
to Afghanistan
and
*,,5Ee,'
e,9 ~
"- ""5 §= 104.42
*°"'
112093.!
" -El§i1enteI sme;_Eie>s,,,,¢,ube
, h-
J
"
- _; .Fi ;g55__5_h1g;]g1_~[399j'j;g2.
||:#
$l;_3L_,r§A_§=1_0_.-_
*' -I>*1==
di'=I51==d
D'4J __
1.'/_20
_._
_
b6-1 "b
'
b7C
1
_?_
_
'
_ _.
.'
__'
'ii,,,_;
, oi _"1
'f
. T_
,"
1 i_:
'
-__ii~_,ii,
.
This
doc njsnt
contains
nsilther
recs-rninunda
not§:'on_::|usinns
uns of-u:-FB].;"
it
isthepmpea1'y
of
'-ih:
andisieaned'_tn
!r:mir
agency;
-1t and its cuntznti are not tn be distributedoutsideyouragency.
'
' '
-'
.
._ , . .
.
1
,
All
I -. ED-3n2aG%¢v.I04a5j
- "_ GZ:?-*'___
'-'
--; _ _*
:;:1
J
_
_.
'
92
"b6 -4
265A=MM _C'99lO2. SUB.AA
40 .-_
- '
.= '-_t
_me
__;;'
-4" _
I -b7D
-1 =-
,
_. I
:@mMwc @JMOf';;i ";'__ ,@1Q§Zg;K2DU3
-1? oh;
was arrested
that the
allegations were
made; -He believes he.is
one
of many who were arrested ae
a I E.S_p0I1SE
to the Septefnber 11, "2'_0Ol'
attacks.in order
to show that.the United
States was doing something
about the-attacksL ._
.. .--.
"- --7
-- "__3r
1-_
b6
_-4
-=b7C -4_-_
-b?D -1"
-b7F -1-
.liars.J_He.
't-"
[;;::::::]said'he
found
all has
the interrogators
to_be'
oes not
trust
any of them;1-Heigeve an
example o£_the
behavior of
-with blood
on
Americans. A
his-face and
detainee returned £rom.anfinterrogation'
;
head. ,He said a female_interrogator,j j
after'not getting'cooperation fromYhimq1called.f0dr guards
into the
room.,.While the
guards held_him,-she
removed her blouse, embraced
the detainee_froo.behind and
put her hand on his genitaIs.
The _
interrogate: es
on
her_menstrual
period and
she wiped_blood £rom'her body on
his
face and head? He said he asked one guard, "Why_do
you hate me?"_The guard
reeponded;fPI£-I:oould¢
'-b6 -4 "
b7C 4;
.'b7D -1
' b7F-1
I would kill you."'
T -:'
_ . co p1ained'-. o_.one-"i 1as'-I-t'o1d
him what
he is. _accueed_o doing.
He is_ready
to he
against him.
He offered
that there
him:-i.'I.. Y*'~' _' 1.; -,.
1.
2A."
He wi1i face_a
He will
tried-if there
are three
_..-1. .
is evidence
q '-".
military'tribuhal '_a -"_ "'_ -='
be-returned'to'Egypt, wherehe will
_"imprisonment
Iv 3:
_He will-be
" ' political
qi
poseib1e_outcom
and torture
_. ;- _
1"
released to.a
co ntry where
asylum-i _.
":__ _"
-H.
face life
'
i
e '
he can claim-;'; i "
-i ¢ "¥'isaid
he hennderstands the'imoact'of'the*Seo
ill
-attaokspn But
he complained about the treatment_he has
received '_
during_his arrest,
traneport,'and detention.
_He said the prisons"
in
Egypt
are better-than
here. But
he declined
to say'how
he knewthe difference.
He denied ever telling
previous interrogators
that-
b6' 4'.'
he had-been-tort
b7C -4
- '
.b7D *1
'b7F -1";
believed
red before by_Egyptienauthorities;
-. ;_ -92 According
t before;
in
the
humane treatment
J'
»
he wa's'arrested,'
he
-
of prisoners
in
the
United States,
Fof'EH1ewreaeo T*when"he wae% irse~in£
ihterrogators.
Bet he
found
his assumptions-about~treatme
in
the
U.S. system
no-rights to
honest with
to;be-incorrect Helbelieves
Arabs. He
doubts anyone
who
him. .He-believes
override decisions
control _-the
of the
American media.
the United.States
interviews him
extendswill be
the.D,S.-inte11igence'agencies 1-
U SJ military and
"
.
that Jewish
people
- '
-- ~RESPONSES<2 1'U
"-
j
_-
'
- 5-50mi-.10-s-95;
_-_.. '_
1. _-
"
.
. ._
-_ -_
__
_I
_106-4
I-
1 '2.ssA~ M_M-cs91o2-'suB_AA
40 l"
' iiEgg
.
'
'5
.- ~'b7E 1"
'-'r::@"ri:s:1u=u192an¢'.r'1=:»ani=5rNL
'_', ,P_=:=h_._
;.0h§ iéC2i/-.
..
~.-
.
-.
-
' - hThe ihteitj riewers e;@Ilained'-to
that"'he
i'
was"
b6 -4
_detained during
atime
of war
'and- that
he falls
under
amilitary"
b7C -4
b7D -1
b7F -1
1 rights
as people-who
face civil
tribunalsl |-asked
what_ 
' "System
of justice;
'- wouldbe done
'- 'II
is why Ihis
he is-not
with him.
"He was told he
_bein afforded
wi].-_ - either
the -same
be tried
or
_" released-'- -He""s,aid-he.
believes he
will he returnedto Egypt.
He
- .-'_wa's t_:o_ld'i;he
'U_i'iite'd."Stai:es
-not followingis
the 'dictates"o-fthe W
Egyptian]-government, "that
the. possibility
of political
asyliim was.
. ment_ion_ed in his
fi- 1'e..-that
and _his'fate was not certain .
Iinterviewers
are-_t-rying to
determine
--' ancllto Al'*Q_ae|_:1a.
_
'_.
b6
'4
-'
_'
H.
- '
| w
'37 :"'4."
MD _1.. _Ioperate.
bu. _1
He o_
.The-_
the Tal_iban'
_-- .
.
said-"he__know's
both" Cilia
the
the
and
how
FEI'-'
"do 't1'1i
s' a'nd'how
the tr
to
obtain
how e
sI
t_Ih
'
:LnforImatioh.___._He
would not
=. .
who is linked to
'-._.
~
. "_
y._
_'ng
,__
yI
I
yI
s_ay-,how 'he'.knows
these things".
=
I-Ie then. asked", 'ii'.the'
int-enticn--is .1:_c.-turn.-hin1_back't'cI
I Egypt,
why-'just.
not turn
h-irrr ove:r:I'n'o'w?.
.'IHetold
-was
t_.here-- are it-cc
_- manyunanswe-iced 'questions{
tc}'him
let--go. immed-i-ately. _.I'-Le
said. he
I belie'vesfrom the
intervi-"ewe r_s_' ,.po'int
,-of view, -.he is .eithe'r
'
_asscciatfed with
the Taliban
and -Al-Qaeda, or
he was just -caught in
:I
the 'net,so
why
II
b6 -1
brc -1
not get
as rriuch "ir1Itell'igence"_'from
as possiblel
him
As-vsoon "as the interrogators
get all
they can
. hand him over to. Egypt "cr-1'
apl-ate
.- -.
-I
__',. _.
- trust
_- I
_I
-
- -'_'Iconversation
hie
was--'followed by
_..
could -be. developed betwe'e'n"
SA -Jw
De1.ta'lon
E1
=3 --enou hto;
from him,
I. I
..t.hey= will:
I
II
II -_
_.
-a '_dis_cussion
of . how '
have repeated -meetings,
e" at Camp
and
-
' -'
- - ' offerwasmade
to'hc1d'moi
f"req1.1eIit'inI:Er92.'iews.
e
this way, '
~-In
ggcfq
- perhaps some tr.ust_could-be_ c1e'v
and-[:|
e 1oped
wou1d-
feel- =" _b7D _1
acculdhelp
h-i'm1con;_p'1ete
process
Guantanamo
at
-w at-timethe
Bay.
seemed willing
to address
this piopcsal
'
thenHe
asked
- 92
comfortable opening-_up
it"was _ar1d
.
ended with
asked if
and -providing
he." could
sayhis
the understanding.
his complete
histo ',which '
1375- _1
prayers. The
that another
interviewwas
iritervi-ew' would
occur irI1_;
-
two weeks, at which time -this pioposal could be'Id:i._sc1is-sed
.I again.
I
I-I
.-_-._..-_._.-____._..._.._._..-__._._i.-_.__;___,..__._92
__ ________'
___
.
j- "RESPONSES-.211
_
.I
-
Positive
Response
Number
19
O
7
-
_ Message
____
l_
ha
7
'- I
'1=-_"
1 ofl
T<1~S@HF§n11,_
-1 " -» L
_-3u'bject:FlE:GTMQ...
._ -._ _1 __
. I
-I
OKf0rnow'weWi||
positiveéountthisasja
response.-No
need-todo
EC.-jan[ nanks.'-.= . ,,w,_
- -Ori'ina|-Messa-_:
e-=-;--- .-e
. - _-I
~ _Fr=mj=|gIil.tI<><>2L- _" FBI:
-L
.'
-b6 -1
- _Sent:Tu$da' 1.3-2004912B"AM-_
Jul
_-
. _--
A-I 1-'
1~s:=-ml»
, ,S_u_bject':G'1'
- M0
'
-
.-
- - '»
_-1sg;gs[1j|i{Eeu-T"u'Mg_1,.A§'s1E|Eo
-"b6 l
.
-
'
.-
-
mb":c 1'-'--.MF-|:[ '
2.
._
"'
.:
_'-_
"
--'_
_'_--_-I wofked.-at~GTMO
from June-through
Augustof2U02.'-Durin_g
time penodl_ob§eweo
that
one incidenf'''1in aninterrogation roornwhich
waacontraryto Bureau
interview p'ol'icy!guide|ines.
|Ob5e|.'Ued3d_et_3ir1e
.
.in aderkened interrogation
roofn
shackie
to
the bolton
the in
oor _a
kneeiingposiiiori.Theroom
was
- ,
~ COIT1ple_t&ly92dark
and there ;- eas
a_ as|-ring Frtdbe
.|igh_t plecedin
frontof
the detainee and
aStereo was '
-_
'
playing loudfnusic
in-Vthe
foom.
looeewed
a maleintefrogator outsiqe
theroom during
the time. '3met|'
.
' -loheerved
tl-iis activity;
_Theinterrogate? vJas'wea_rin_g_
a BDUunifo_rm_w|'th no-unft_patc11es._or-heme
page on"
.the uniform am
haveno idea-'wf1a_t
agency
he
worked for; "howeyrerfl
never
obsemed any FEE!
pen-sone!
-I.involyedinrthisjnterrogatiori._l11atIcieecribeo.
'
r -"
- T
'
_ -- '__
-- -"sensrrIvE;eu1f,o§|ii,LAss|FJEn
'~
-
',s-"
1
-
.-I __ ? 3;2004
:'RESP.ONSES-212'_
_.. 92 _
_
_
Positive
Response
Number
20
"- Wl ssaaé
-" l1 l
ll alli et
liitwr ii
1 Li |:lf5E>IFB*i
bi? _-1
Pae¢_&#
l
l
.,
.Sent: _Mon;day,Juty12,20El4B;46__AM
--
'
-SlJb]6C !RE GTMO
b
92'_ "'..'5EN~
-- ,LlT1V_E-_E'JT uwCLA§§l E.Q
»_
. lT'h'ank_
you forthe
responae.»_l will'print.your
response outaridttadetenninationisrnade
whether this'prao_
.'
.; . __
wasnotappropn'ate,_youwillbejntervieweej
_ __
1
_ _._
_l
.-,. :or.iinairmessa e.~ 4:-...
o._,-Fwm='
§Ei-_- .FBIi-:'
Jul 11
2oo4'3:_z9
PM
b6 -1 .- sent: Sunda
_ _ _ ._
bt
._
-1
'__To=
IN5DJ
FBI!
'
-Cc: {_SE!_{FBI!"
"U,
r. - . _
-5
_3!; ~;
.gt
_I_-" '
e.
=
-
_ -§ubje'<_it:__RE:G
_ F- l'MO'
,
._ t.-
..§§ns|31|ve1eU*r,un§LA§§J §l2...
- -NON-R§CORQ'
_
-1564
._
g
-
_' .
__
,
.
' .-I'm
responding '_uiale4l11ail
becausewas
I aware
of
apractice of
irxterrogating';letainee_s_
which
l
did-not
feel?
was
appropriate.
_
Duringmy
short TOY atGTMO inJuly 2002,!took partin _some|discussioJ-|s'abouta
._
- - practice-whjich
hadbeen utilized
in which
the
detainee
would
be
placed in
the interview
room approximately
..6-By
_-'or=to
the schedglgd.inte{92iiew'.
The 'air"conditionir|g_in_
the roomwould
beturijied
down
to
as -
-
' 55 de§'rees_ltwas
comm0n.practice_to-have-thedetatnees restricted
frommovementwith ' '
hand lego
room,
whit:
_ff5, end
a_ chair-1-bolted
to thetloor,- which
would
prei/er. it'tl_1em
from moving
around
the
t t-hiscase would -prevent
them from
adjusting theair
cohditioning temperature."
_'
'
.Myinteriiiewteam not
did parttc-ipate
in this
practice; but
l vaguely
recall seeing
detaineesrooms
by
in
themselves inconditiolns which!
believedincluded
un_comfortabl5r
_were
octzasionsfwhen ourinterview team"
would
show
'
was
uncomfortabtycotd.
up
l°or'an
interview and
the
temperature inthe room
'.
However. the'd.etainee'was
rarely inthe-roomior anylength of-time
before the __
Yinterview aridwewould
immediately
_the
- -not
-
cold
environmen_ts.. There '_
_ I-
torn The
air conditioning
temperaturea.com_fortab|e-level.
to
brought
t -'
topicup
to the
Marine Corps
JAG
assigned to
us-and they
actually-lziegaridiscourage
to
this
practice, 92
neceesarity because
of my
efforts, but_othe_r_sagreed
that with
my
vyeiwsas well. .'
' ;'
--
._ -1
.__t>2
If
fee to
heed
ecintaot
me
a_beut
thiehe
mate},
i-eeizhed
at t-.-5m.a'i[_:[
tat
my
cell
hpmné,|:|
H
h-__b?<_=
, -1 _-_
" .----0riginalt4essage- -
I
_REsP0r»i$|_5s-,213~
'
.
_
_
" From:MCC RAW,.STEVEN-C.'[INSD![FBI!
_
-_ l_ _-_
- '
Sent:
Frida'
Jul oe, 2004
1.1-:42AM_'
. .
_._
."
,
b6 l 1To: tM tMM>cFa1 Ho>u=s1
t
_.
_.b7c
-1
1
.-.
"_1w12r2004
_[O10]
.--
_V .
_ii _ N t'.UFBI. i MM!ti=a1>;l
|<i.¢i; -i=a1
cowl [MM
eat" j
HO! i=_eI!;92_____| cJIs_!_t1=en,BA
I-
'
hm F81;
_
" FBI!;
.-
Pesitive
Response
Number
21
._M-essage
_ "' ~.
I I
" _'
- _.
- .,.
-.- '
l."3.gBl.0ID
- Wll'"f*°ll_ E."l>.;~
~l ~~
be -1"ie==fm=.l:li<*~s5>i iFB*>ii e»
MC -1.Sent:_'- Monday,-July1'2,2Oi_
' I.'
B:31AM
_ _ __
.sl:|<@e1¢PB':esis i
r?. &; ~*~.
--
. .'~@ %mW;@H;a
Subject:GTMO
RE: .',
rm
_'
-I . __=-,_='E¢*,'<
etc --i
UNCI:A§§lFlED
_ _'_
-
_. NON-BE-COBQ
..
- _"
v N92
"
_
._ '_|
will put
izou down
as positive
_a
response,
so no
need todo
an-EC. !'wil|'p:rintoutt|1ele
'
Q 
. - ascertain
ifihe
treatment
is beyond the scope. ,'Thank_-"you-for
response.
y.oi|r -
_- -
-_
_
_
----0ri?ma1Messa?e----.- .- "-FE1I].- ..
'F|*n_m. cs!
July U9,2004 5:32
PM3I
_'b6
'
-1Sent : _F|'.iday,
_b?C
To: mso!
5ubje_ct:F'-E:
-1:
FBI!
_.
_
..
_-
'
' _---.
_-
I"an:_i i¢i;ig'.ie
e1r_.oi1'the:sid_e
c_auti0i1_her_e,:so'tl_1ese
of my or
may fen
111;-i in
W
.92_-. .wit.hii:i
the parameters
you-are using.
I have
been repeatedly
assured tl1 at,'a1tlio_ugh
some the
of . _
techiiiqties titilized;-by
some of
the non-FBI
interrogators here
are we]l'outsid_.e
what would_"
-
generallybe . coi/isidered proeediire
-standard for-a
CONUS'__FBI
_al1
interview,
the
of techniques.
t--iised have
beeo'_ap'proved
the Se'eDe_f.
_H-owei-Yer
by personally
I
feel
about these
techniques; Lhave
been-.assured'
DOD had
permission.
that
further
I
iiot'h'eli_e_vedo
al<in",toaetivities
the
anything
at
.;
Plbu Ghareb
in Iraqhave talteii
place here.-~_ _
Eitiiationz
Ifwas
told
" .
.
~'I' _
on
or about_Th11i'sday,'
April ZQQ4
by member
a 22 DOD's_North
of
I A '
Eiirspe NA'E!'
team
sia:|:|
whom
he
d,ebriefs,_
had provided
the 'foi1oWi11g:
_S_oi'netime.iJ1
' -1
'secon_d_or
week of
'l1l'l.
Fehniary 20U_4,|:
of
l.1'Cl
was _tak_eri
to reservation
i:}was on
both FBI '
and NABhold_!- He
did notrecognize the'-interviewers.
anew-hen he
told
he__didn t want
to -,- _
speéik an
to
one unless they
were ii_1t_-roduoed
by ]ii.is=ri=.-_g1;i1a'r
interrogators;wasyelledj
he
at
for 25 '
e
inintL'1es.|iLlwa.'s
the rooni.'_tempe_ratore
was short.-shackled,
sigiii cantly.-lowered
"stro'b&
3b6
'
1170
were used,
and possibly
loud niusio._
There were
two maleinterrogators; one
stood behind
'
-4
-4' '
alnd.t];ie-
other
in :ont. The yelled athim and'to.ld_
he was
him
never leaviiig_l1ere..
The ' _'
iiiterrogator
to gr-=i|jis
ti-led
identify photos.
Afteriiiitia1'25
me
or yeHing,|:|was,
iniiiiites
left
alone inthe 1'OOIIl
in thiscondition for
eppfoxiniately hotilrs.
1'-2
1At onepoint,-the'interr'ogato
'-
ceme.haok in-theefternoon
to rnsl-re
_sure'he
's_til1'
was
Diiring the
12 there.
how.-1rs,|jwas
not '
._
permitted to
'ea.t,'j:ii<ay,
use the
bathroom.
or One
'
ofthe inteiro
gators was
desc:_ribed_as olclflate
;
50's,
and
grey
black
hair, -mustache
with nohe;1rd,_short,'
aridslciiiriy,
wore
a Bluesh_irt._.-'
--_
'
-
My actions:
I verbally
iliforrned
my
GTMO SSA_wl:ien
received
I
the
information ,._1later'
__- i
"-ii1fonn'ed tlierG1°MO~{9n Scerie-¬~on;im-ander~via e-mail eiH95il95?'20EI4s»---§ ---------=--&#
Note: Itisirny nnderstanding
all ofthese techniques
were,at
thatttime,_permitte_dDOD.
per We
believe theinterviewers may
have been
with CTCbased iipon
the physicaldespription and"tlie
fact
mats wastaken an
to
interviewroom without
-appearing
the
on-schedule.
.. Ibelieve-theythe
are
I b6
- bTC
~4
-4
only entityherethatcandothat.
ell!
»
'_ »" - -1.
92.'.
'. . -
r
_'
t-_ .
.
v1 .
b6 -4
b7C -4.
hm app¢,@at.;1y
15 hsmgby
NAB. T tbughout
st s¢s5;¢n;|:|pe55¢@11y
t rew-ujs
a?'
-in
_= trashcan; Atthe time;
Ifvyaé told
he-had
anulcer
-and that the
stress was-irritating
it. I was later.
._
'
. advised he
hadastcmachvirus.Iwas toldhéhad been.g i92'ren'
ashbt of Motrin or soriiething
like
-.that!b3rthe.medica1staff. '
-"
_'.
b6 3,4
b7C 3,4
'
actigns:
My Dile
in part
to the
fact that
LTC |:wa_-s_pres¢'nt
anH.did not-object
ti! the-'
I - situation,"and Ithat
nav_e1'
hbard|:|ask t6bG'1'BU.Il
his cell0r'_requ¢S1'n1cdica1
¢d to
I Y
a
. '
tbcpk ho
arztion- stzbsequently
I
reported
this td-the
GT-MO O11:-Sceni:Co;nm:1_nd~';i"via_e-i
on _j_
-05/osrzood. -
I- .
b6 #4
-_
. --
.1
t
,..
-.
_-
I
Situat1on:._I b_ri;
- observedfOll0jari11g'i1-1_-{early
the
'A'n¢m;_1rs-were
Apt il_0f20 _inade
:
by
bein
b7c ~-1
NAE'tb.
|i_|[::|refu.sed
debrief
-spaak
i.t'1teract'w1't
to or itlterrogatqrs-it;
Ibelieve
anywa
. _&
|:]was kaptin
an i11tc1 r0g;_ti0n
ro'0m.for-aj:proxi1natc1y_1_5
:sho;'t-sha¢_k1ed;_vrith
hours,
___
.'
-lights andpossibly niusic. .. _l_
'_- '
- _--. ''
._
.
-_ '_
" Mylacticms:Becausewas
it mynndergtmding that,"-at
that"ti1:[1é,ofall_these tech1:|iques
I,
- ?pernj:itt§:dpe:rDC:}D-,1did-.notrcpoi<t'this.:
_'
1» ..'
'
.
_~_ '
-'
Fi-nm.:MC§CRAW,STEVENC={1'NSD!
~_ FBI}
.h
.
_- Tu: cwncmn;
..
Sent:Fri?:'9i'20042-:42PM"" -
'FBI!; -
._
aw!
._
_
MM! FB11;_-
-" -
I 01~I!; MM!u=1a
~t<N*nrEB11-
- - _--
:_-'- ~"
-
"
w
';
1
FB1- MM!-z-1=B11;
'_
'.
I.-.A!{FBI!;
t
O!_ FBI!_CHS! FB1!;.BATI'LE,
'.~
-.~cm F.B1- :1~m>_<FB
-<
§w '1:-.
0 ml
. S
B]
Z_ ;-
_ I
BI;
. ~-D
. A'N! FB1!f
."
-.fFBI!_ t
-rNY!t<EB11;
" <c0>r1=P»1>-
.
-.-
mo: 1_
<Ho><@GA>;
<c@>u=Bn= t
?_ - !_ FB ;'
Era!-1;
LD!- FBI!; 1
10;.
1
FBI-1;. BL
- 0!~ FBI!; 1>.; =1a1!;
0;
FBI!; A
0;
_
1 OGA]-'
B1! :-,!
_CTg]JD
FB
=_BI!%:!_
'~
ASD!
._
_FBU
~' '
rm
BI!;
_- t -c-rivv]. .PR1!; ".DJ:1=tBn;
9_
MM
B
WP
PB
J
NY!
OGA}
V><Fn;[
1urr
;
WC ~15|@H! FBI!;ctn~/11~'.-nlqqes
ARTHURM.
- -" 01"-13!_g1=Bn;l
_ W
win an
*" 0 .mn
_
- be-
1
t
FBI]
-1
1!: iFBI!
- ~;
'! FBI!. FBI!
- FBI!
. 'F1" FBIJ;
" IRJCFBI
.F
.92
FBI] FBI!
_.
_
- i
PX!- PB 0
P 0;-.1;
..[RL FB cmlgrs
[ Ink.
'
'
HQ FB1-1
us FBI!;
1'5 Ili
-
;| fl
I
'
I-A FBI!;
-'
j
S ;
FBI N}f;____
.
MPH = .I"
__ i
s1_=!Q='B1 PG!
FBI!; D1-] C'9N]i
_. $D. C0N]
N"1. ! OGA} P-$}' .F13l!;
" I
' rm
t
FED
P FBI! ~_{a=*_-
IJI .
- _"
' YOGA!;
C0 FBI!;
SEHFBI!
?_ |_[qpB-
BI cm
92
92
.
I HFBI!;
_.
. ._
CI! F13
1311;"
MJJJFB -
1
CG! FBI!;
. _-
MO [FBI];
: -
T.
"
_ _.]_ -PB
om _1!
I
__ _.
MW]_[FE5_. _
-
___
' 1!;.
-
_~
-
.<F_Br>;]
t i.<c"rm'a=BI>;l
_1 - _|u:>L! FBIn;
_ I.L
- "
_
t '
' 2"
?/f1'2/2004In
Q:
I'---RESPONSES-'215
.
I
'
l
-.'
-'
.
__
Positive
Response
Numbers22
I_ -pg
_
l
_,v
.
._<
-I
.._
nF °m=.-i|::<d1"$°><FB
'_
>dn
- .'
V
V.;
b6 -1'
b7C -1
.Sent:
'-Monday, July_12,
2004 9:09 AM .
.T='=
|:|I°TD> FB >d¢in '
_'SnIhject:
G'|'M_O_u. -1 _"
..
d II
Vnr.
"
ssjgsrnvs au1uJ~n':Lgs§|F1En_
- '
. -hi5 !-_
;
Nb Eflhnaquihred,
I willhandIé.. Th'anks.'
- -_
"b6 1 +
b7C -1
-J ,
_i.
__,_
..¢:-:~
.I _I I. ~
E>_,92l
'92 .~_ _
u'..51
-I :--
_- '
.
.
. V
.
.~. -' -4-§'1§JrIginai'i'_P'_1essage--_e-'-"
-.
.-
F@m Cm! F5I!
56 ti
-__. _l1_ona
"- T1==
M Cl
'
h'
''
-]U| '1.-2
2004' 9:93-AM
I
_l
I!
|l *i |1~===» FBI |.
l
_
__
g-5i.|bjeCt:'RE':GTMO
~.
b6 1
b7C -1
-
i.
_
-- ' |:|Iha'vej11§:ver
beérjGTMO-,
to ymifstill
do an
nédd
EC?_|:lI
.
' -. . --~'--'-Ori
' Messa
e---- '
Fffom :
_
b6 -1
'
- '
'_
-- '
'
{I192lSD} FB"I!'
'-
' -Sént:Mbn-7: 12z'2004
8:21 '
.1
we ~1 1 r@=|::|1¢w>@Bn
L
.-'.- -Sub]ei:t:RE:GTMEO_-__- L1 '-
1-uucLA§'§|E|g-0
-ngn-gscggn
.
_-
-
._
_
.
_
_
'
Piease respdnd
via EC'thét
you did
n<§t'.d|:>serIve
treatment
agg_'__re:
GTMO.
zit willI put
your»-sixie
.- - _name'd.own_§_f'a
Afghanistan
subsequent
rgeuirgw
is. required._
'"_I'
' -'
;'
'
__
"-'---0rfina|iMes5a
'-~-
i-
-I '
.' --
. -'
'
_
be
-1" _FT9m= 12 2UU4'_3:1'6AM_
U-:BI!'
'"
IRESPUNSESQ216:
.;
byc _1'_5ent:M0nd'a'.JuI
- -_,L.
- _ .1~==|i|<:e=.s@><FB1>
Ȣ
Sub3ect:-F g1l:GTrg1GJ _'.
I'-.Importance:g-Ugh
b6 "1
b7C -1
5|:]_I
.
_,
1
'_
..__-
did nOt'obs'crve
tréatlncntGTIN-EEU,
-at
however,
I didobsérveteafrnent_ dud
-_sDm¢ procedures in
Af anistan. _I willrsspljgid ifrequired.Iam cilrrqntly '[_
to DY
- '- _,.I_,egat'Riya_dh._Thanl<s§,
__
-._'_
..__.
.1.-..-._
1
'
_From:-MCCRAW,STEV'EI~T_.C. D92ISD!
FBI! '.
-I _'
. -
~-1 _V. l _-
195 1
-'
we-
..
_ .
_
.
_' '
--'
.
~
- I|_ H0}_
FBl1;_|_
¢d d B11;-I
,l¢1WuPB1 _I____ ism}-cPBd~6
' .'
II
-
....
......__...:_..-.:_.....-.i..--3
--v --.-.__..
.....'... n._ I.-
I. _ _ .- .Sent:'Fri
H9!-ZIJIIJ4
PM 2:42
'
__
'
- '
- ,.
-
~_ _
Togli
,,
7__'
_![F_-Bf
|_1M1.92rI__
'
.
'
'_
_
|I!,
M1vILEBI!_;_| | LAJ.£FBI]i|
mum
TI
_
|_ CHS1jFBl2.;J:3A;'gII_!.¥
BB.
" _
I=.1 I1 52210!
F211 <s
El 1"_>u,~'
,-
- m2z2o0¢
'
'
"
--
'
92
Positive
Response
Number
23
_,i, i|| L*-I
__
.-_-I
ilvfessagen
.-i
'1
_l '
@I
pi
_| I. _ F'a
lznfi 1
'II1@>
V
117° "1
.Monday,
July12,20D4
PM'
12;5s
_§
_.- - sass;
'
53>;
:;;:;1:»'--'
- .- '
s'uEjss:-he- GTMQ-'
"'
' -
'
§§!j'§5lTlVE_BUT
- pg
_, _~92
-f'é
UN§LASS
*'
'|s
D~Ywco
- -_-Count
. vé:
'
.
'W
'
n/J Fz'i&
'
-;
Y
l; £C'E13
_ as eenwn¢ep_
is in
dje_pr_ca::'e§s
approved.of-péing
_:
_'
" '
- '
_- _-'7. -O{ igi'na|
_'
;Message---»
' .- -
"'_Frdfn':
STE92!_EN'C.
MCCRQW,
[N5Q}. FBI}
- Sent : |YIo_r1_d3y,
July .12_-QZQU4
12:13 PM.
-"'Tfo:.
;_
I
.-
_S!-'b.ie_¢_t:.G, I'P- 1'E>'_ s
"Impd__r-tance:'High
_
. V
_s.|sz~:"s'17r|i/15
BUT U_NCLé;§§lPlEQ
3- "__.NDN-REORD
i
;
"
-.
_
_-_
.-.56 -_1 -"_ Rafgrence
pr;eviouss_"e-mail
captiongdre
T¥10's'92=_;_i'r.it1i92
ma ér.
hég ve rapliess
and svhlo
-3-'
'_b7C
_1
V __-
sgswere previou_sl1,r~
instructsfd to subrfi_ft
an to the{fnsp_ECti0n
Divi§i_qn,_Attentj'on:'
Chief
.Unit
3s.-s_:,1ss|s
senq
i snort.
a
neqauvs
e-mall-to Un|t
Chj1f3f|:|t_o assist
in redunoilialiqh
ef'thé <51.-Mo
-'
-_C2i:Jl'as3cicinsLfegardingthis'r1?|
bé_dire'cted_t§"lEi nitCHief|:]at|
_b2si11e1f&#
-1]
"-
' - 1'
b6 -1
_ §ENS|TlVE_
BUTUNCL!k§SlFl§;Q _;__ _we
.'
_1_
'
5sE;us1Tjv1
Bu'r"_;JfgE:-L,-=92's:s'|g=lE1:>'
i
-
:
.
.
1'
'
RESPONSES-21'?
'_
.'FD-302{Rev.1 -6-95}-- _
--_
.
.
-Ll-:1-.
.
3 -FEDERALBUREAU OF
INVESTIGATION
92
_
_ _'_ __.
_
be -,'
l
'
-' l
Dareefuanscz-i1m'cn' OjL[29"g2!1§
lSN:' was'iiite_rviewed-at
De1ta,'Guanta
Y
bio~
_.BaCuba
" by
Special
Agent
ederal
b7 E
. was
Bureau oflnvestigation
FBI! maj
b-7D_N'av_a]
C_I'iII1iI1a'1
er:/ice
_CIS!-_'
The was
illterviiew
conduoted
English
Inves

__
_.
advised the
of reason
for the1I1_lZ81'V'l.BW-.
__
i
_ __ ___
_. __.
_.
__
ea" -4
_. '
.'
_qttesti.o11-edabout
his
speci
Icaphire
ogjjgi byithe
l92lortIjlern_ llliance
.215 '4
'
Kondoz, Afghanistan
and his
subsequentto
transfer
Mazar-'e-Sharif.
. _ '_ -'
-
. b7F
-1,. - j___
'
'
. Aroilnd
-'
" Neeemear
205% Noveniber
2.001 d his
tweets
l;
mg
were
to
. get
out ofKozidoz. |::|and'others
jitmpedinthe beds oftmc
s. '
etrucks .drovefor awhile,
then
_'
-" -came to a river, _where'
they wereforcedto getout ofthe trucks-Their planwas tos1-11-render
United
to
_b5'
I~Iati onsforces.
a_0190
At
opt toZ_020Q,_mgre.t1-ucks
appeared. mg
to into
get ofone
these
_.
33°
trucks"-buthis friend
- _.
_ I£5151-:[
_..
had failedto
put his
shoes -L -
Mg :
ori.He
. WE-1.i'I'3d_fU1f
and _while_wait_ii1g,
tlte-tifucigsthey _wcre_go1__ng'to
get in-to,
drofve -Some
_oi_ f.
-~ -planes flewoverhea . 'it_mce
wasdark hecoiild notfsee
the tnatlciiztgs
on
the planes; .'I'1:te
p1e;nest1sed' &
;- _ __ . _some
type of ho or
'
cendiary device
and proceeded
toblew
1_1p l1lZ[6_thatg
E[1lClC$
was initially -.
7-goingto
getmt 'saw'm@y
orgetsevercly--1_11Jured.
peopledic
i
_- . _
Lr._
is Jsid]
and sweet
s-1e1e, s1i= I:l.
- started
wallciiig. Theycould heargunfire i11t]1c
distance. .'_ey
so ear'
elicopters. Themed
walked" b6- bat-'k"towards'-the
river
and
observed women
crying. Thewomen
werelocals
whose homes-hadbeen
.
1°79 -
hm _pegplg
destroyed by-the.
pl_anes.|:| estimatedthat eight
tonine
truclts were
d_estroyed..They were
full of
to
surrender. Hebclieifesathat between
390 a_t_1d
4-DOeo
le
were-killed wl1en.tl:le
trucks
t.-;We
-e
eblew
-up; Hadfr_iend,|:|been_ready;with_hi_s
his .'- -. - _ - on |:|wouldhave':shoes
- ___dicdoI1'one-ofthe'tr'ucks;i
I
-
'
--Pakistani
H
-'
"'
'
'l:_l'saw"TaI'i'b
by
indifferent
yelaioi-es.
- He
inan
attempt
truck
t'o|gc ot-I1
The thearea.
trLLck
away
d1'ove
was
andevent_
- b6 _4
stopped by
tlie__l92_ljortheri1
Allialice. -and
t1'1e'
in thetruck
others
wereforced toget out_. -The
157:; -4-i Nor 1en1'A1liance
soldiers tooktheir jackets
,1 money,
and shoes.The- Northern Alliance
soldiei-swere
mo _1.
_- tootinany type-O=f uniform.
-They did
not have
glms atthis time.Theyloolced
like
civilians. _ _. .
..
_NF
-' ,
._
'
|:|and'his
-group
were forced
to w throiighavalicy, between
two high
hills. He.
. I'_
c sepeople
on the
hills-with
and
guns
camcorders.
They--were'_
the
videotaping
group
of
walkers.
=
_ __was
Searched a-gain
and l1l5_l1il1.Il.Cl5
were tiedbehind hisback. _ _.. __
"
- _-_
b6 "Q " '--'
- - On
the second dayafterhis-capu1reil::|i-aas
put into
a_ ditch
by
the Northern Alliigmc
b-,92C
_so'1'diers.l;:|desoribed
-'trucksthe
Northern
Alliance
as_"'Ch.1Iiese'
people.
spent
I-lo
night
all
intheditch.
1579 '
- On
the thir day
showed
up
andthe
prisonerawere
tojutrtp
allowed
ll'_lB_ti'
into
1:>?a-
'
".
|' lpmrisnti
on 01-Z'L'9f2i303___Z
n
' allQC-ua1f1tane:mo_Ba-92LL__Cuba_
'
. __:'
'
I-"i|=# 255;a_;MM;"¢99_102w-i
. J
I'-_ Deladictated Q1-.-L29 _gg37
3,,iQAE _
Wb7C :1
i._/p
-
"_
W
- '
-"F15-snzatasvr
to-5-95! e
.
' -
_ .
-
.>.
_
- b6
zs=5n-1viM-c991__o2-_
-_
_
__-
..
_.
"-
bl ? "4 _
.__
.
;
-4
b?D -1
we
-1
_'
_,
_
. .Culitirlhntion
q1'm-3q25r1'
. _ .
' -
.'
116-
b7CI
me -
'
' .1
__|
i *'
land
"
V _
_
1
. ._--0;
0.1/:9/200,3
u'
_;Ps
--
.
___
._'
...,,
'
.
_
_,_
_
Jgotmto
onetrnck,'and[:|got1_nto=anoth
fuJ1ofA.fghan1
' '
='
b7F
'
" _-_
I'he'tr|.ieks
awhile -andstopped
drovelfor
at
ari'tir1,k;nov_m.-loc_ation.
'ta1-1, caueasian,
Anieriizan loolci.ng :nan
who was.w
0the trucksand theoccupants; -The
man-then left
an did
__ej_ea_11_s_
rnan_was.talc.u1g
. The
pictures
cfnotisee himagai1i.' Thetrucks
started
.- hp agai11_.a,r_1d
drove At
off.night
they arrived
at Mazar-e-Sharif.
;;]saw -lines
of people
h0ld'
guns, The
truck m %
in hacked
up t_o'a
large container
an It eoocupantspf
the bed'Qf&#
truck-were-forced.-i_nto'1the container-.;
-_ -Q_.;
a
'
-4
b6 -4b7C
_b7D -1
are -1
p.
.-;- 1 ,-
'_
_, :'
.-__ . I
- ._
;'_
92
__'.;6detain_ee_
descnb.ed
the
container
as cells-at
being
red
color,
in
like-a
looking
shipping
containe
-It
was
about'_
size
o
e
Camp
but
Delta,
-wider.
.
|
windows
only
and
smal
holes nearthetop
"for ventilation. Thecontainer was
made ofinotal. estimated
thatat
least 100
rnen wereforced into"-the
container. Thecontainer-was -then
closed. P_eop1e.inside_b.egan
to screarn"
and
'
hang-on the
outside-of .contain_er;
the
noone
-but opened
it. -|_:[blaoked; out
¬1l1_e .to
of 1ack_
airwhile
'it v_v.-asstill
outside.
darkHe-carneto_Whenit'-=qas.1ightand-noticed
that itappeared there
were newholes
in the outside-wall
of
the container.
.-He-noti ed that
the 1':neta]'
was pushed
inward, .t_owards
the people
inside" the_conta"i1_1er-,.a
sonlethirig
s if
had
pugnctured the
container 'orn
the outside.
- He said.he
hada
g:razi.ug'
we
un¬lon right
his
typewliieh
elbow _he'.thou_g_ht
mayhave
.from.a-bullet.
been
thou-
the _.punctL1resin themetal container
rnay hat-'e'o'ome'from.
gun re". I-I_[e'
tfloesnot be1i'e92_ze_
t. ep'unetu_re_
'-he-sawerepnorto
present
hisblanking ont.'_j
._ .|"E-'- -- - ...
,_ -'j
.2 ,-i ; =
.
'
. _--|:noticed-the-tn-an
.'next.tc'_hi1n
dead.
lie Hesaw
-wasstill
-green;-fo.am
c_on:u'
thewas
Inan.?s'n1otith'.
nothad
eatenor El.t'3I1l fortwo
-3J1},f1.l1.i.t1_g
days..=
not given anything
to eater;The
men-~i.n'-thetoolesloths
container and-rnhbed-them
against the
ceiling of~the'container
water. 1-
_:
to
get the condensation
that had
_ac_cun1ulated_:_there. the
'The3cloths"
out so
-rung
they coulddrink the
. _
-"
'
!_- l: helieves he
_only
about 20
people
survivedthe
"
. '
--' .
eontainerlforiapproitirnately
-I-Iezeshtirnatedlthat
ordeal._'
''
.
--
.
_
. -
''_
- theWhen
contained
was nally
opene'd;I:|no
peopl'e
opened
ced thewh
th
14:70
4 . '" '
put
the
mincontainer
at
Mazar-e-Sharif
and
when
it was
opened
were
they
Sabergaan
at ail.
j
iii?
:i
hdbeenmoved92whilehewasinit.~
'
_' " '
_b -4
- container wore the same typeof civilian clothes hehadseen earier on the NorthernAlliance soldiers.
e COIHEIIIISI
a
A.-.d0<=tnr;1T=atsdhiS. attI1W1;th.i9§§ins-aftst.ttis.rslsss==
._
_.. .. ..
=-
_.; -.
a
.:j:ould not say why
-he was
put into
the container.
He thought
it might.
have been-
bee -he
ause
looked.more
like
an
Afghani
than
aPakistani.
Lgdid not
see happened
whatto
the
_. deceased,
but "later
heard that
the captures
had gone
through;_err poo etsand taken
money and_perso_nal
items. Thedead were
put intoIa bighole and
buried. Healso heard
that some
of themen whowere too
weak to-getout of the container
on theirown wereput intothe holealso. .
._-.
iU
The soldiers
U.S. 31a1TiV¢d_
StlbergaanF111
ahe
released
w&
?-bt1ut:oneh
front the
container|:|s initial_capture
and placement
into the
container-weret
et 'ee
days
worst
his
of life.
.
--
as-spouses-219' _ =_
-1
.
--;'-
'
L
Positive
s
Response
Number 24
.-
i
iii
1
-Megsage
'-
I
b6 -1
b7C -1
-
_-_".'_P§"
1ofl
_|<i
$F I§1TF"3'T
t
£1
|-'
{{{{
it
t
~|_i|:¢T@={FB->it
Q-. ~, 1
-'s@m&'_
3:22_PMh
'Mo_r|day,_Ju|y12,2C|D4
_ '
-.
Q=1
-'
fsubjecu
:.~
'
~_
GTMO,
I'
'
_'
' '
Q;
_SENSlT1VE UNQLASSIFIED
agr
you-ggconn-:
- ..
Y
4
--'
--
Fositivefesponse perourcohyersatioh
. - c:n'O7I12I2_0t'J4!I_
-_
.
.
rwas"TDY
GH11/10
at 0TI1i3»
from 2l!-0;!--'09_f1J'2!2iIfi03
1'0i2 a12ob3'-11n_aI2
théarid
pig a:.<_:;&
odlof
[W16 -093032003, on
one
occasion Iwitnessed a detainee inan interview rdorn whowas, sub]et:t_ed'
to loud 'V'
.mu$5;;.a§1;|,-gtrgiqe_-I-witnessed
lights-.
.tt;is_.whi_le:wa_[kin'g1_paSt
the r2DOIT!.0__r1=£T1!'?
wayt'0=
another interview. do'not_
I
-'__
'

.racal| the
exact dateor theti_m'e
oqcurred-.-The_re
-this
_no,FB|
wéré pEl'50|'ll1é|_in
th_e room
thé io'ud.i_'riusic a
étrobelights. '-|'
""
'_.:;¢ _; -.'-_-__..
- --
i._ i
J
-' b5 -1
.'
bYC_ 1
.-TFOS/RFFIUYI/Roam1.5223
..
.-
T
b.2.'1"
SEBlSLi1;N&B:_lJT'UNCLA$.. iSlI$lE_I5 "
J
r
92
I
r
_
t
m2:2oo4
.l
I
RESPO'N'SES=220
*
-
"
V
_.
-
Positive
Response
Number25
i-
.
J
' 1.-
_i "' Ji
i
i
i
_.
fl
7
__;
Y7
._Me'ssaLgc""
1-'
'.
'
ll'
'
2'
HY: -.
_
_ _7_:_
__
'_
."_Pa5e1_
0 ,,
- L
_ ___;__
__ _
_, __,__rI~§v>i <=?B{11
~,7;
; _ _
92:i1<@r@>"<rB'>
Li *- 6*- 1Vi
-,
Subject: RE:
RE: GTMO
mreavusws 1"
_
_
OK thanks.
vvillkeep as
thisa_poeitive_resporise,'
gthlerihave same.
statecneeci
hue
Nd y0u'to_dcfur EC,
" an
.h'_'
e-L--I
-. -h£3'I
-'
I- -ih_inaii
"
'ies'sa
,'
' I -._ *-
r==r=m=F_
;Q |<<:w><rB1>
~ 4 _,
Ju 13 2004 11:06
AM.-'
_ _
WC
~1.
Tm
<1~$@1<FB11
e
". 1- "i
'
~-I '
Suhjec1:_:RE:G1'i"1E!I|
._ {1'ER92flE92-'ifS_:_
. _'
..
r -1:6-1 _'
_ Sent:
Tuesda
_
.'
.1
bvc 1
- '
.
- .
=
' _
__-
_'
- -'deployed
was
rc->"c;n}10"
$11 thefoiinwingviaie-as
listen}; o2;_1s:ea_1D"o3:1ar63;
crumbs
09102103,
10'
1" -
' -,
USIS1 I04
tg GU02/04'-;.ponduci
in_crde_r't0
interviews
of nancial
operatives
of
Al-Qaedaand _U1e
Taliban. I
" did not witness
any aggresaive
behavior or
interview techniques
being_used GTMD
on
detainees
that isnot
' ./consistent
with Bureau
poiicy. However,
during the
éecnnd depinyment;
0111730309.92'0?J03_,
10
ubsehred
v'
i
-- a detaineebeingvexposaci loud
to n1usic~,and
a;$i.rqbe. iight=during_
an interrogailon.I dono; rec_aiI
thedate--,
1that this tookplace, the_Idetain'eenam_e,.or swho"
was interrqgating
the_det_ainee. I"-saw
wha; was
going on'
.
'
approximateiy
_.a1
10:00am
and Ibeliev_a'tne-qetainee
refenedwas
in
as.-the poisifan
man'dL1e
_1 tcvhis
_
_knowledge-_o_fchan'1ical
&'b_io|ogiq.a|_weépo'né._"
- - -_ T ..
,3
.
- _'b7C -1'
_
_-
' 5Eli1$lT192,f__E_-_l3I._I_|"Li N.CLASSiFIEQ92
2
1
- -
- ---- -- "v--- - --- -
---;--+---
--_ '--- _ -._
_----- --_--_--'..--i_',-.__--_--_-_-.._-92---_ ----.---._.._..__ ---__
_...___.....______ _.. ___ --_.
_.. ..
.¢
x
"-
2r;3xzo04 -
_"
'_
..
RESPON-SE5-221"
.-
_
Positive es
Response
Number
,
.
.
26
I
i
'.
RESPONSE-S-222
1
L
.
City
Opaall92'M92'
1- 1'
'
1| Gander
'Las92_'IN
-arno F92l's92_Na'ma
Tm='a1'qr
92
92
Operalibn
Enduring
FreedomGuantanamoay
Operation
En_d|_1ring
F:e_ad_<_:-m
Guanranamnay-_
OperationEnduring
'Fre;-:dpn1'
Guantanamo
Ba?Mr._ Cub
-Tm:
'
lrmu
dfrléé
Mr.-_I. Cuba'_ péralinn
Ertdunng
F_ree4on92'Guar921§marr_92_r:_
Bay Jab
5__
,
.
.
0
_Cui_1a'
~
_'@M~»
'Gu_antanan_m:92
Hay0P'QI'a1i0n
_Ef ldurinQ
Fr_eac|o_m
Ms.- -- Cuban -" CubaMr, .- _.- Cuba
ML."
Cuba -Mr. ~ I uba
Mr.
- Cuba .Mr.-_¥ Cuba .
Mr. " Cuba."
Mr.
b6
1:7
. _'
Ballla
"-
F
__
Frankie
'
.'
me. . cum
'
Ms; -_ Cuba
»- -1
92
+'w
OperationEnduring
Freedom Guanlahamn
Bay 3
Dperalinn:
Enduring
FrB_Bd0m
Guanlanamn
Bay
'
_-Drieratiun
Enduring
Fraiaclorri
.G|_ranlanar1iu
_Bay
opeisriun
§ndLi Frcgdum
_ng-
_-
r
IMM 1
gno-
- 5B3.
GU§|nta'namd'Bay
If §n M_-"
Gut-.inl_ana
Bay -- ";.H@
mn
{Mm
l_II{1eraliun'E
Fraadpnn
1;lLrrirl1g
,0pqra|iun
Enduring'Fregdu'm
.
DpéraliunEnquring
Freedgm
-'
I
Vj'_NY
'
-.'
Guah'tarqan'1n
Bay
Operauon
Enduring
Fre|_§dorn__'
Cuba-
Guanlénarnu
Bay
Opagatfun
Er1durin'g.FrB_ed0rn
Mr_
. Cuba "' Operatidn
Bay
-Enduring
Fraedorn Guantanamu
Mr.
"Cuba .O e athn
_Erldurirng
Fraadorn
_ _ {NY
Mr, . ._Quba
'
.
MM
Qlperalidn
Enduring
Fréeriur-n
'LA
Up r lidnEnduring
Freedom
Mr..'
.'
Quna.
Mr.
CubaOperéllun-Ellduring
Fr'eadom_
ML
-_.Cuba
Ba;
Operation
Endunng
Fraédom Guantanarncr
Bay
Mr-. '_
.". I Cuba _' Dperaliun_Em:luring
1
Freedom-Guanlan mn
1 4*!"
' '
Bay
DperaliunEnduring
Freéciomc ar.1rar'1'am@'
Mr; V_ Cuba:Mr. . .Cuha
Guantanamo
Bay
Dpérallbn
Enduring
r=|-ee_d_6_m
1 E110 _
Guanlaharnp
Bai
Mr. ._ t_';uba'
0para1iE|n.Endur'ir1g
FrGedum
.'_,
-FIR
-- - -Ciper}|tion Endunng
Freedom
G'u
an_lunam0_
Bay
M5; . 'r'3ul:ra'_
Guanlahuniu
Buy
Mr.'_
r _Cuba
Opararicm
Eridilrlng
Freedom
Mr.
' 'Cuba"
Guanianarno
ay
OperalionEnduring-Frnaplom
Qua
'
Guanlanamul ay A
Mr,
Cuba
operation
Freedom
Mr,
'
Cuba
_'Gua|_1lanamo
Bay
Operation
Enduring
I-fniedom
Mr.
Cuba .Bay
OparaliqnEnduring
Fraédom Guantanamo
.;'H0_"Mr. cuna
qpmauén
'EI'|c'Iuring_
freedomGuanlanamoBay "A
A
ss
My
-Cuba"_" .Qnafél92ar_§
Endu;ing'-F.réadom
Guantanamo
Bay
_Mr.
' _Cuba ' _C|peri-Minn
Enduring
Freédom
Bay
Dperaiiqri
Enduring
FreedbmGuantanamo
Mr.-" cups.
_
.
Cuba
'
Guantanamo
El-ay. A
Mr. -'
Operation
Enduj Fréédom
ng
.Guanlanarm'
Hay
Guarilanamu'Bay
Gu_antanarrn:
Bag?
" V195
._
R-1.-.-_E'<1~'
Guanlanamp
Bayi
Guanianamn
Bay
Guantanamo
Bay
_A,
A in
~
-
.
I? "-
r W
-.
;NY"
.ir::>1_
_.
Lr4r=;-Ir-M.
"- --.1e'a"m
.-
J
92
______
L5»: Namé
-L
m.
r
0
Mr. Cuba
Mr. Cuba
Mr.
Mr.
.4-
1
g
Cuba"
Cuba
- Ms.
Mr.
_-Mr;
MI.
.Mr.
Pi-- t -ii
_,7
First Hams '-oar.
"- Mi .
.- Mr.
.Mr. der'
_.Thoat
-Mr.
' MI.
'. Mra"I'
OI
i
no -1
b7C -1
_
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba.
coup
Cuba
Cuba
.Ml .
"_ rm.
Ms.
Cuba
.Mr.
' Ms.Cuba
C.ub-a M5,,
Cuba.
-Mr.
' Cuba
_Ml .
' Ms.
- Ma.
.Mr.
'
Mr. '
'--"!IMF;
2;
.Mr._
' Mr.
Mr.
'
Mr. MS.
.Mr.
Cuba '
Cuba
Euba
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba
|::5§ -**%"
Citpaalion-;_-II_'
_
operation Erfdunng
Ereadom
Opa-ra1ioh'End_urin§; I -readom_
1
Dpargtion Enduring
Freedom
Qperation Enduring
Fraaolum."
1
Operation Enduring
Ereadorrg
.Upofation _Eiiu_a-ring
Eréédoni
Operation Enduring
Freedom
Operation Endur_in_g_Freadom
_'
Operation Enduring
FréadomCity
Operation Enduring"
FreedomGuantanamo Bay
Quantanamo Bay
Dporation nduring-Froédom
Guaotanaino any
Jab Title
Guantanamo Eiay
0peration.Enduring
Freédorn
Guantanamo Bay 6
§rrq|d orr1_c_e'
'
Guantanamo-aay_inn "Unara92ion_Endusi.r92g
Froaoam
-
0pe_ration_Enduring Freedom
-_Gu anianan1o_
Bay A.
Cuba'
Operation
l_Enduring'F_reo_d|:ifn'-'
i"°»
0pa_rat_ionEnd_uri_n'g
Freedom
<$uantana_mo'Bay
Freedom
Cuba Qperatipn Enouring
NY .
Guantanamo
Bay
Cfuba
Cuba
Cubs
4Z1oeration_End92nin923 ftéaidorn
Guantanamo Bay
Dperat1'on:EndurIng'Freedom
Operation Endunng-Freedom
Gunntanarno Bay
Cuba
CubaCuba
Oparation Enduririg
Fréadom- Guantanamo ay
'-DparationFreedom
_Enduring
Guantananio Ba»;
Ut>B'Iation.Enourihg
Froedom Bay
Guantanamo
-_Ope_ration Enduririg_Froedo'|"n
Gujanta'narno Bay
Operation Enduring
Freedom Guantanamo Bay'
Operation-Enduring Freedom
Guantanamo Bay
0oerat_ton Erhduring.
Fre_edorn
Gua tariamo Bay
Oparation En f FreedomGuantanamo Boy:
.=r_P "
[H0
co
iQT.-
EHCI
}CG
Guantanamo Bay
Guantanamo Bay
'
. '
{MM -
iHO
Erw-.
4=01
Cu_.|i:|EI
Cuba
Freedom
Enduring
Cuba01ior_a'tion'h
Guani-anam_o.Bay
Guantanamo Bay
ouauaaam Bay
°
Guantanamo Bay
'
GuantanamoBay
Guantanamo Bay
Guantanamo Bay
--D|: eratiE?7'1T!'3.I:|;iu'rin'g"
Eiaedom
§LS '
Operation Enduring
Freedom
=on
Endtt
Freedom
ng Guan|anarr1o_Bay.
Cuba _Oporat_ion
Dparation Endurtng
figgtiiorn
'
F.
Guantanamo Bay A..
.
._Op}iration
Enduring
Etlaadom
HQ .
tin
Cuba Operation Enduring
GU_3I'i928I"i6_i'i"lO
_
=
I B81
Frééiziom
Ii-NO
Guantanamo Bay
G118-.11'i===!11Bi"11.='
Bar
MM
...
2_of'1
Guantanamo Bay
Gutin92anat11O B181
an
'
-|R- '
ERF '
LAB -
HE].
=_
.Last Name 'First Name
Gémtor.
'- TheaterMr. '
_Cuba
Mr. Cuba
Mr. _
_Cuba "op q'aiibn_..- _-Ms!-.~:Cuba_'l" '
Operation
Mr. .qutia _. " '.Ur1 r.ali_on
Mr. Cuba
-
..
Opqration
Cuba
Cuba] D|}eratio_n
Cuba
Operation
Cuba
'
Operation
Guantanamo-Bay
turn;-:-izi.=@=
Mrj. - .-Cuba-_
Mr: -I.- Cuba
Mr. Mr.
_U|Tll'I'92'I'lQ3 hi5 1
b'i|'C
-1
lti'ir.__
Mr.
M9, '
_Cuba
City
Mrs 1'
' '1
-cuts: '
Mr. "_'Cuba
"r
'
Guantanamo BayEnduring Freédom
Enduring Freedom"
Enoiii1{1g_Fiééimm'
Guantqnamci- Bay
Ms. ._. Cuba
'End'urir1g Fraedom
Cuba _
"Enduring Freedom
t;uba:'-{I255,t?.z*m%
;3Ei%ii%
Guantanamo Bay Job Tllto
Eriduring 'Free'dorn
Mr. - ' -Cuba
Guantanamo Bay
Mr.__
-Cuba.
Mr." Cuba
'
O
Operation
Guanlonarno BayO
Operation
iiiiatiirt §?Rr é éiiBiiiT§§t;oan|eiijar§io,B;ir
A
A
Ope|"a tio'|_1-Enduring__Froedom
Ms. Cuba
'
.Endi._iring Freedom
Mi. .-El.lb3'
Endu ring
Ereédom
Mr...
__
'
Opératioh Enduring
Freedom Guantanamo Hair
Cuba
Mr. -.
Guantanamo Bay
Cuba I
~Mr.
Ms. - _Cuba
Guantanamo Bay
Ms.
Mr.. =
j '
gona-
Fioid Ol éo
Bay
Qparrition
EnduringGuantanamo
lfraadoin
Cuba
Guantanarno Bay
. CLIDG .
Of>eration.'_£ndurtng Freedom
Guantanamo Bay
cube
A
Fréedom
Mr. Cuba
' Opia'ration'-Enduring
Guantanamo
Bay
Operation Enduring
Fré_odon"i
Guantanamo Bajr O
Mr, Cuba.
Opt-:'ra1io|i_Freedom
Enduring Guantanamo Bay
Ms. Cuba
....0peralton_Enduring
Freedom
.t_'3uanlanamo Bay
Ms.
"Cuba'Operation Endu rlgFraadorr! 'Guar1tan_amo'Bay
Mr._-,_Cuba-
D|I|'eFatioE i]§?idii §_=_uantana'mojElay='..-gr
g. i_=.'r'_'oa1i:iii._=-}
Gua_nt*anamo~Bay
Oiaerétlon _Eno'1_.iring
Freg d'orri_
PH"_
| MM. .
no
G'u3nlanaI'I10
Bay Ho_Endurii1g
Freédom
Operation Enduring
_Fre'a;li:m
Guantanamo Bay
Operalicin End_uril1g .Fr_oedom
Guantanamo Bay
Cip_aral1on
S
S
Operation Enduring
Freédon-iGuantanamo Bay
Operation Endurin
FreedomGuantanamo Bay"-h
oiiartition Enduring
Fraadb t Guantanamo H_ay.
-_
Opéralion Enduring
Freociom_
Guantanamo Boy
Oporation Enduring
FreedomG'u_antan'amo Bay
Buantanamo'Bay
Bay
Dperatiorl Enduring
FroedomGuantanamo
Operation Enduring
Freedom
Operation Enduring
Freedom
Opération Enduring
Freedom
Guantanamo Bay
Opgratlnn Enduring
Frégdori-i
tjooraiion _Ei'1uiiiriii;i
Ff§§a_iiom
Guant rganuo Bay
A l'- '
Opétraliunl E duF:rée:_i'or1"i
ng
-Guantanamo Bay S.
't?iuantanarno_Bay
Guantanamo Bay
MM
sr= '
-NY
CD '
HQ
A.
-'3of1Ei '
|
>
-RESPONSES-224
.
P
,_.j_.-i-i-an---_
f' Last
Name First
F"
"T
Name
.-
Gander-
Theatei . 1
"Cuba
Cuba=
*,5I:'|ii1r"§;?. g!Y>I-5;3"E='. §="fCi.t1i '."
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba
'
i
i T
.MS. .1_arc
b6
-1 -1
i
CUIJG
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba_
.
6
Cuba
Ct.Iba=
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba
'<*_~~:-=,:.=:-as-r_:
i
'
I Lrr]
L- ii
Cut:a£.., 1 ' -
2
Cuba"
onun
Cuba:
CubaCuba
City
-- Ctpeélliio
"
Operation Eriquilng
Freedom
'GUS[liB[l3F_i1D B87
Jdp Title
_.Operation EnduringFreedom
A .
~canrraropnrniian"=En_a isn @T¢?ae=inm:->
auamananinraay.
I .
Guantanamo
§Jij'i:r'atia'n
Freedom
Enduring
IN Ba"? A._. _' .-
--
.'0perat'|on Enduringfrefad m
92
1
hm
Gander." .Th-aali
-- -'
r
D_lJBB
"_" 1
" 1- "V '.
. =;Il.'v"Mr. ._ Cuba
-
..
Dpara_tion Enduring
FréadomGuonlanarno Bay
Operation Endurlng_Fraettom
I _Guantana'ma
Ba?
Mr._'Cuba
tt.rtr1- -I Cuba
Ms.'_
. -"Cuba".-
Ogeratloijl Er_idurIrig'Froadom._
Guantanamo Bay
0|;-aratton Endurlng
Fre_edom
Guantanamo
._
ayi
- 3; M r.2» ours ;"=92iifwi?_'L'-':'I*i1i=i-3??
iieiiaitorr
l_§iiout_tt1§?I§_ri§
Elnj
i§?;'Gtianta_naijng;.§ay=;
Mr. 1 ' Cuba Opa'rotio_n Enduring
Freédom
Mr. 1.Cuba
Opato on Endu nq
Freéaom
Mr. "
' Cuba
Operation Endur1'r'|g
Freedom Guantanamo Bay
Operation. Enduring
FraedomGuanlananio B;92,r_
Mr.
_Quh
Ms.
Cuba"
Mr; - ._ .Cuba
Field Clftrca
AL
Guantanamo_Bay
Guantanamo
Bay
Oporati-on Enduring
Freedom
Operation Endur|'in'g
Eréiedom
no
5 .I
'
Enduring
Fraeoom
Mr. V _ _Cuba 'Operation
K§tt:Mr. - '-Cuba '
Operation Enduring
Fraedom
92.
f.
Mr. '
-_ _Cuba"
Guantanamo Bay
Operation Enduring
Frao'd:in'I
MP"
Mr.. ".-"t:uoa__ Operation Enduring-!fra'ga'do1'1i
Guantanamo Bay
Mr. Cuba
It-tr. ._ .-Cuba
-
Mn
Operation Endurtng
FreedomGuantanamo Bay
-'
' EndL|n'r|g'
Oporation
FréedomGuantanamo
Bay
MM
Guan1ariarrio_Bay
SF
WF
Guantanamo
Bay
i
Operation Enduring
Free_dorn
-'
.Oporation_.Endurlr_'ig Freedom
Operation,-Entiuring Frae,d_om
ti- Ir.._ '_
'Cub'a
Mr. - -Cuba .
' 0pora1ion_.Enclurtr|g
Eraaoom
Cuba t
Mr. _Cuba
Mr. Cuba-'
Ms.- -'
Cuba
Mr."" .'
Cuba -M5.92.
"_
Cuba
Mr.
_-Cuba
Mr-. Cuba .
Opgration Enduring
FreedomGuantanamo Bay
Operation Enduring
Frozydqmwnwhamo Bay
NY
St
Guantanamo-Bay
cur -_
Guantanamo
Bay
"CG Fréedom
OparatioI1'_E|iour§ng
Operation Enduring
Fraadom
Dporalion~Endur|ng Frea oon'|
Mr .= .Cuba 1-1Oparatton_Endu'rir_1g
FreedomGu_antar1amo Bay
Guantanamo Bay
MI.-_ _f
_Cuba
Opérat_|o'I1
Enduring Freedom
'BS.'
ooinrgnamd Bag}
ML '.
Cuba'Ms.- l_ Cuba ' D|Ji:|' El_t%1Jl1'En_:1uFing
Guantanamo
Hay
Freudorrfi
Mr.
'_ V_uba-_ Operation Enduring
Freactorn Guantanamo Bay
Guantanamo
Bay
ML. - .'C|.rtJ'a'
_O|J'era1i_ori'Er1duiing
Frieaqoi-ri
'.Dpéra1ion
I"
Fraaoom
E_nd1i_ring
'
Mr. g ' Cuba'Guantanamo Bay
Bay
Mr. ;__-_
'
Cuba
'
_'°P°.m"='i92
Fi§§s1°i
E 'Guanta'r1amo
w".'
g
1'31~
Guantanamo Bay
Operation-Enduring Frpadom
-Guantanamo Bay
Operation [Enduring
Frébdom
Guantdnarno Bay
MM
MM
DL.
gm-16.-.
gt
, Gi.la_ntanamo
'_RESPOl92iSE_Erf!
i-A.
Bay
Guantanamo Bay" '
Quantafnarno Bay
Guan lé1ri£l_m'D
Bay
Guantanamo Bay
ERF
o92__
ERF
LA"
1
4
A
'
Gender
Laet___1'~|ama
F|rst_Nar|1e_
_-
_'
'2
__
' '
".
-1
_
_.._
M"
._
_.
'
Theater
Cuba
-" _Mr.- . '_Du_baUoerati_on'Eridu1'irig
_ BayS
Fraadorrr
Guantanamo
i-'-*<:r.=a=:;:.~",f=*-Y~i:uriaa:t*~.'C'¢' aiifua-aaaivriénli
tho T
I -Ms, _'Cuba
" __O|:ierat|onE_r1dur|i1g'Freédorn
G|.ian_lanamoBa§r
'
--[MM
_,PH
-
Harrington
Op-aationli.
_'ii
City"
.
Bay
OparatlonEnduring
Freedom Guantanamo
Mr.-'
l :;Cub:a':.
0p_era_iiun
Enduring
Fraecium'"_'Guanta'nan'92o
aay
,'Mr.'
. __Cui::a
.''_Oparaiion'E|1during
Freedom Guantanamo
Bay
JobTmii
Ms. ": Cuba
Bay '
EField
Difica
Qgieraiion
Enduring
lfreadoinGuantanamo
Ms.
' Cuba
iH=e'
Bay
_Operation
Enduring
Freadpm Gua tariarrip
.iHCl "
-_Mr.-'
'_
-Cuba
OoeraiionEnduring
Freedom Guantanamo
Bay
'
Mr.
i
92
Thurjnas
Cuba
Mr.Mr.
-Cuba
'
'uu._
..cuu.='
Ms.
' __.CuI:ia
Mr,
=
- Cuba
-
Qparalion
Enduring
Fr;-{edom
Ms.- --Cuba
_
Guantanamo
Bay
Operatihn
Enduring_F=readam._
Bay
0peratio|1.|_Endur|ng
Fréadmn Gualnlalnamo
1:5 -1
]:>'?C
-1.
Operation
Enduring
Fre_ei:|orr_|
iEmaiiira-iFi§aa ni.
_.i.N9
EH0-.
Operation
Enduring
Freedom Guaritanarnq
Bay
Oparalion
En iiring
F_reeclon'i_
Guanlainarno
Bay
Qparaiion
Enduring
FreedomGuanlanaino
Bay
inc:
f~ oi~t_
Mr.
' Cuba
Mr. 1'
-Cuba .
Bay:"
ME.
Operation
Enduring
FreedbrnGuanta'narn0
Mr.'.
_. .: Cuba
Ciparaiion
Enduring
FréedomGuantanamo
Bay
Mr.
Cuba
-Operation
Enduring
Freedorn
Guanianqrio
B31;
Mr. _'
-'
CU'ba'
'
BayOpgratlon
Enduring
FraedfzrnGoant_ana|'rio_
Mr. '.
|- . outta
Gu nianamo
Bay
CiIpe'ra1ion'Enouririg_
Fratj.-oorn
Guantanamo
Bay
Mr.'_'
.'
Cuba_
Ofaaralion
Er'icIu'ririg_
Freedpm_
Mr. __
_ CubaBay
Op;-:ratio_n
-,Endurin_g
"Freedom-iii-Iuantanamo
Mr.»
Cuba
Opérailon"Endtiring
FreadornGuantanamo
Bay
Mr; -_. _..Cubti. OperationEncluring-Freadorn
Guantanamo
Bay A.
_- -'_EFtF
' Ms.
_Cuba"
Guantar1a
'
rno_Bajl-'
Operation
Enduring
l_?reed0rr1
Mr . . _.Cuba
'
Opératio'n'Endu_r|ng
FreedomGuanlan
a'r92"|i':|'_Ba5t
:.u~r
Mr." - Cuba
Bay
Operating
En|:iu_rinj;|
FreedomGuantanamo
'='
EP.
Mr.
'
Cuba
Operation.
Enduring_Fre'e'dciri'1
Gulanianamb
Bay
|'irir._.
-Cuba
Operation
Endy'rin_g
Freedom
_ BuantanamoBay
Mr,
' CubaGuantanamo
Bay
Oparalion
Enduring
Fraegiorri
Ms. ."- Cuba
- ERF
-Guantanamo
Bay
Mr,
' '
Cuba
Ag -.1
Mr.
Cuba "
§'
|R
Mr. h . Cuba
.s.-
C5
_Oparati_onYEnduring'Freeci0rn
Guanianamo ay
opayaisan
Erlouring}
Fl:-igaclom
Guantanamo
Bay
operation"
Enuu_rmii'Fj§§aum
[Mi
G_ua'n92a_r_1arno
Bay
Oparaiion
E_r|ou'r|ng'Freedum
§'CG'.
Guantanamo
Bay
Guantanamo
Bay
- '-"ti
oi'1B_
j
5' ;
..A __
:I-[Q
-
_ RESPONSES-222
_'
c
'-
i
in
_f=:T'/"9""
l -_ - .
:;
"""-T -
..Firbtl92-lama
I
_ IGander",T_l1B'nl
--
st__Na1'no .
|t-r
ML:
.
Mr. -.'
- Ms. '.
.ca.-ha
--_Mr.
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba
'
Mr. I-.- --
- -Mr. '. Mr'. .=f
r
'
: -r:2?;". :;i.irr"r1;;;:_;:--_;.
__'
ME. II.
K3
-'
Mr.
-
Mr.
1-
r
i
t-
I
Ml'.'_
__
.-Mutt
Mr. -I __
b6 -1.
bTC -1
i
M5_ '
'
-'
,Mfs.-.-'.
.-
t,
Ms. _Mr. 1_
. Mr.
'
. Ms:
ltrtr .
"- Mr...._f
: _'
Mr.
t
r
ir
.
{$1
. Mr .
Mr.
..
Mr. .
Mr.
- '
.I
r
1
_l -1r_.»-"
Mr"
I.
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba
Cub8::
j tm!
/-.rJa..-'92.-
.
Last Narne
7 I
J
Elrat
.P_
candor ..ThdateI"
Mr. ,.'-Cubaf
Namb
Mo. '
'
Cuba
-I
Q
"O|?iaa_{i0n_- _'_- . '
Oporation Enduring
Freadbm
Operation Enduring
Fraédol
Mr.
-' Cuba '
'
'
Oporation_Endtirinb
FreedomMr. . 'Guba'
G paralion_ Enduring
_Fraedo'm
Cll§|
:_.
Ms.
Cuba
.Operation Enduring
Fr'ead1:im
guantanamu
B_ay_
: '
Fraadom_GuantanamoBay
X"
_' Cut-B Operation Enduringi
' "0p_araU6n
¬r_|duiingTFrendom
X_ - ,Cuba-'
Guen'ta'narno Bay
Mr.
-_
' Cuba
"
Oparaiion_En_du||ng Freedom
Ms- - "-Cuba" ' Operation Enduring
Fratadbrn
Mr.
Cuba "
Mr. "_ - Cuba
92
'- G'uanlar3_alno_B
Operatiori'Enduring_F_maddm
£3-u Hay
anlaftamo
"'_Guantana|'nq-Ba
nn.- '_j3uba'
Guantanamo Bay
Operation
_Enduring
Fraedofn
Mr.
- CopaGuantanamo
_Bay
.-Gua'rita_namo"_é!ay
Mr.
__
f.C!.tbEl_ .
O'p'Br_a1i'on
Freaqun
Endu
Guantanamo
ay ng
Mr. '-Cuba __
Operation Enduring
Fréadntn
i=_|;i=i'
Oparaiiulfl Enduring
Fri-iadom
oi; -_.
Oi:n;raLion'Enduring
Freadorn ay
Mr. __'
__Cul:ial
WGuantanamo
Opératton Enduring
Freedom.Guantanamo
'Oparation_Endu|1ng Fraed-om
Guantanamo Bay
Ms.- -- j Quba
Cuba '
Mr.
.
.Op'eraE|on
Freedom
Enduring
Guan|anan1oBay_'
_._Guantaharuo
Bay
Mr. '
- Cuba;
b
1.
$1 Ir;-§
ulna;
Mr.
Cu_ba' '
. ==35"g?+:g;;;q;g;;jggooo.w;§;-gag;§3paraijon:_E_nit
i| "§ $%i*i§ ?{"nii f; 3ii'ant'i|i5'é
-Guantanamp'_B_ay
nu.
pupa ' Operation Er1_du_r'ing
Freedom Guantanamo Bay
Mr. '
Cuba
Ma.- ..Cuba
I
Mr. -"Cuba
ML. _"
Mr. .
"
tjperallun Enduring
Frdtaljiiirn
'Ci..|bB'
Qperalinn Enduring
FreedomGuantanamo Etay
Cuba-Operation Enduring
Freedom Guantanamo Bay
Mr. _Cuba".
Ms._ Cu_ba'
Mr.
' . Cuba .-.
Ms.
-=:
Opqrdllgbn Enduring
FreedomGuantanamo Bay
Operation Endurlrig
'Fre_¢dorr|
E:-Cuba
Qpération Enduring
Fraadonji
WED _
LAB .
BF '
IF! - .
GiIantanamp_Bay
..=ERFOperation Enduring
§=roadon1Guantanamo
Spy
HQ '
Operation Enduring
Freedom
Operation Enduring
Freedom
Operation En_durIn'g
Fmadom
Mr. Cuba
Mr.
Cuba '~ Operation Endunrig
.g
H0
Eraeiiorn
Mr.
.
C|.fha' '
_OporBliI:Jr92 EI_1dI.I
Freedom
r_1g
r.is';:s"-:t*.i¥=.I3¥-''
- PI-I
Mr. .'
Cubasvwrartwi Endurlné
F.r=?;==9'=m
Operation Enduring
Fr édornGt.ian!an_arnp Bay
Operation gndurmg
Frébuum
.H° 1w.
no --
_Guar1tanamo-Bay
Guantanamo
Bay
-.-.---a
=- '-'
.l::'ra}-
a--- -_ --
= -antsj I
GU'&nl£_m'at't&
Guantanamo
Bay
'
_RESPO'iiSE5¢229-.'
G'uantanamo' Bay L92it- -_
Guantanamo Bay-'
-.
Gu'ant.a_na:_-no BayDE
EMF "
Guaritanaipu Bay-
-Guanlanamolbay
GuantanamoBait.
Guantanamo Bay
w
Ho"-.
'92.
i
.
._ Last Name '
First Name
Gnradar
Thealfar-1 Opeetion
Mr. '
3 "Cuba
Mr." _- Cuber Mr. -Cuba
Mr.
Cube. Mn ..
Cuba?
Cuba
1
'_
Oparailpn EndilrlngFreedom
Uperajiun Er-|duri'rig'
Freedhm any -
Ii
.
G'1.i$ntanamq
Bay
OpEri;l|dr_r_E|'|_du'rin'g
Freédrairl
U1!_£+I8_llr_§i'| Endur|ng_Fre_ed0l r1
C-§uantanamu_B ay
-_.J;.r§b'TilIe
l§uan92ai1amu_Bay
'3 '2 uu ii I-?l l;'iacl|
1:°r?.1J ii?E .i¬l~.{ '#-.i= »f§rT :ri?§i1i§i§r*i§,a-r3§;i_i_§;;:_"_Q;iér;iis¢ihE
Fluid 0f cb- Operation Enduring
F_rea'do'n'_|
O'parat ||:_ii'|
FrqeddmEnduring
- - Operation Edduring
__Guarilan'emn
Bay
MT:
Freelduin
Guentanemo Bay"
Mr. 'Cuba ' ,Opera_llor_1 Enduring
'su_ 1 ..
G_Lfe|f|tan_amo_-A
Bay
.Fr_eadom'
Me. I.- Cuba T
Guentanamu BayFA
Mr. 0
Cuba
._A- ..;
Mr. Cuba
'%i'=.1?
."E:-'-.'i*»
Mr.- .'
Cuba
K
bu
Upqrdriqn Enduring
Freédom
Md. __ G_uha",'_-
Ojie_ralidn:'Endurihg'-Freedom
Dpqralion
EndurinigG_uantanamo._Bay
Freedom
Be
-1-92
i
b'?C
1
O
_r&
_i._A_"'
Upere.l un_Endi.|ring Freedom
Mr. -'_
C_ulJj: a"'
Guantanamo
Bay
1
Mr.
Cuba
Ms." '.-Cuber
Operalldn Enduring
Fre|:_d_orri
Oparariqn Enduring
Freedom Eiuénianéme Bey
Giranienai b Say
- _Operation
Enduring] Freedom
Mr.'_ "t>£|ua'_
' .Gu;1n1ar'rerm
Bay
Mr. '-lCuba'
'- O'|:|eratirfmFreedom
Enduring
. 92 Operation Enduring
Freedom Guantan mp Bdy
Mr.
Cuha_
-_
Mr. "
Cuba .
Gui-1'ntanar'ru:r Bay
0pBr§I1io jEnduri'r1_§Fr§gédqm
Gualjlarreme Bey
Mr.
.Cuba
_0pera_lion Endu Freedom
ng
Gdarnlenemp
Bay
HT;
.Cuba
Opereiibn_'Endufin5';
Freedom
i
Dperajiuri Enduring
FréedomGuantanamo Bay0". .'
Mr; __
urina_GLlanlanaTno Bey
_Eni1urlng_F.teedr_5'rn
Mr..'_
I Cui:|e_ .-Operation
MS. DUDE!
Operatidn Enduring
Freedcrm Guantanamo Béiy
-1
.
Opératibn Enduring
FréedbmGuantanamo Bay
Mr_- _-_Cuba
Guanlenamn
Bey
Mr." '.
Cuba
Ode.-ration _Endurin'g
Freedom
Operation Enduring
Freedom Guenianamd Bay
Mr._-.: _Cuha'_
i§ueirrtaii_smn' Bay
Mr.
-Cuba ' _DpEIdi}dn Enduring
.F_r'e'edom
Guanlanamo Bay;
Mr. '.
1; Cuba
Operetlon Enduring
Fraedarh
Ms. .Cuba ' Ugerdiien Enduring
FreedomGuénlenamo Bay;
- A ."
Operalinii Enduring
FreedomGuégnianarnd _Bay
Mr. ,Cuba
.Sj_'- 'Guantanamo
Bay
Dileraiion Er'1_duri
__ ng'Fréedcri'|
Ms. __ Cuba-.
Gueinianarm
Bay
Mr, Cuba'
Oué qiim EF?*='*!'F!Frééd m
E! .-A_ _.
,-
i
i
9'- *
5
Guanfanamo Bay
Opérellbn Ehduring'Fré_§dum'
_
1
Bay 8"}?
[Jpqratian Enduring
FreedomGua_nt_a'n
Gueniariamu Bay
Gua_n_l'anarnq Hay
-GLi-3-l1|Bi'lBT |'1O'BB!
'_Guankan:irr_1d Baymu: ..
Ho -.lr
1'fa'=>r1e
I "RESPONSES-230
" 1
1
NY '
_;
SA '
NY, .
ERF .
I'l'l'l
_ I
Z
_
r
5
I.
.
_ l'_l..'aat_NarneName
-'-First
_ Gander . Theater 'Dpeatiun - '
3"!" .
.
Ms; '
-Cuba Guantanamo Bay
0p_era92§qn gqdumgfregoom
. I
Ms..' _'CUba'
Oparaiion Enduring;
Freédoni -Gu_a_nt_anamo Bay
.i'ul.r'.- =-'[1uba
Oparaiion Enduring
F_lje'ad0i'11'
_G_[_1a'ntanamc| Bay
Operation Enduring
Freedorn
Ms. ._-._ Cuba
'
Qperaiion
Enduring-.Fraadorn'
MS. .-CL|l:|i!_
MF:___ , -cUb_a'
Operation Enduring
Freedorn
ii
.GuanIanamo_
Guan_iar_92arr_1o
Ba?Job
..-_qr_,.,_..
F-:---:--i-=:
G_uanlanamo Bay
M3- H5-;¥3.;@'=:,¬
:
'1
M11611"
oi:can-=;
ari1ji1rrn'§iFra'ao6iri<r=-ti
u am
air:-air ia"|§5§ 1
Mn cuoa .
Mr. -.Cuba
.
.'Gua'nlE'|namo Ba§*'.
Freedom.
Mr_._ . Cuba '- Operation Enduring
Operalion
Enduring
Freedoln
Guantanamo Bay S .
Mr.
Cuizra _'
Enduring .Freadqm
Guantanamo Bay
-Mr.
Mr. "-- .--Cuba I ' .'_Dparali0n
-15?
Ms.
Cuba "
Operation Enduring
Freedom Guariianamo Bay
- '
'._Operaiion-Enduriruj Freedom
5.-_-;92g'.;:_~
1
an
Guantanamo Barf
Tllla
A
We
' ' '1q-Eil
-1115' -1 - 1':TC -1
u
Qperaiion Enduring
Freedom-_ouah£a nanio.aay"
mi.-'
.'.cuoa-.._
'. '
Cuba-_
Freedom=Guaritan_an"|o'Bay
~1r_.=,-_Cuba
'Uperaiion Enduring
Guantanamo Bay
Map -. Cuba'- Ops:-aiicn E'ndu'ring'Fr.aeEi'cm
Oparaiion 'Enduring
Fr'E:edori1
Guanlanarno Ba?
Ms-.. - Cuba
Operation Enduring
Freedom
.Mr. "
,Guba-.
Ereadorn
m;.'._. Cuba.-- Operation Enduring
Flelclf flioia
Oparaiibi] _Enduring'
Freedom
Ms.__ .'Cuha
,MM _Opemrion Enduring
Fr-e_edorn'
Ml'_CIUD3
.
"
Freedom '_Guia'nta_nar_nd Bay."
Mn
'coha ,- 0para_l|o'n Enduring
-Guanianamo
Bay
Oped-aIIon'En'durh92g
Freedom
Mr.
£IL!B '.'Dpara on En'dl'.Irin_g
FreedomGuan|anamo- Bay
Mr. Cuba
Guanlanamo Bay
Operation Qnduifing
Freadurn
.IMs.' --Gubja
.Guan'ianamo Bay
Oparaiion
Enduring.
Freedom
Cuba _
-Uperaiion Enduring
FreedomQuanianamo Bay
Bay
Mr.
Oper'a_i_ic_:r_1
FreedpiGuantanamo
l Enduring
'
r. M
Opaijaiion Enduring
FreedomGuantanamo Bay
.i92iis.
Operaiion Encluiing
Eraadom _Guantanamc_| Bay
Guantanamo Bay
Mr._ -E-_'
Cuba Clpération lgnduring
Fraadorn
Ms. .Cuba
Operation Enduring
Freedom 'Guan|animo Bay
M5.
-Cuba'- . OperationEnduring Fraadom
SA .
"Mr. _'
ERF '
I Cuba
°Pa.H"Pn Endurrig
Ffaaibm
Mrl.-'
HCuba *'
-'O|:fér_atIuii
F[_e'étlcirn
Enduring
IF! r
Mr. ,.
Cuba
Opai'_atic':n
Fr.a'edori1'
Enduring
Guantanamo -Bay
.Guantanam'o Bay
Gua'nlanarnb_Bajr
O
Guanianamo
Bay
S
A.
-Cuba.
CLiba_
Guanianamo_Bay
Guantanamo
Bay
i i '
_ h ii
1
1
Guantanamo Bay
Guantanamo Bay
i.
.
_.
s
.i
.°
i
"WP .
i
i
MM '.
--
'PH -=1".-I
,6 R'EsPons'E.S-231
D,
NY - _
3
A.
.-
IA
r
a¢
4
I
HQ
IR.
-92
<
,
Flrsl Hams
.0-M 0-Iv
Gender
[heal'a_r_
"Cuba
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba" '
CulJa_;
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba
Cuba
Ollba
l';1.|1-.ia
Cuba
Cuba
Cub?
Cuba
Guba
W ? nh§=a¢?;;m
Cuba
Cuba
.D|;:e-allon -.-'
- T"
" _'
City
__
v
1
---.Firsl-.Name
'
Last Nama-
'
Gender
'
-Theater _.
'_
_Mr. .
Cuba
.-Ms. 1 '
Cuba
- .Mr.
I
_ , Cuba
Mr.-'
/Cuiia
- . Mr.
'
Mr.
- Cuba"
Cube
3E.in=.=Iii=ii"
.- .'
r
City
-_
Drieraiion
Enduring
Heédoni GuanlanarlioBay
Operaiion-Enduring
Freedorrl_Guanlar-amo
Bay
E.U3 l,Bl5 iEI l;lU-EB?
Ci'p_i_3raiion
Enduring
Freedorn
Guantanamo-Bay
Operation
EnduringFroedom
Dperaiiun
Enduring
Freedom
OperationEnduringF92'oai1oi"ri '
_'
Mr. '_"r.Cuba Ciperaiiori
_Endur|ng
FreedomGuantanamoBey
Guia_ntsnp|;i1o
_Bay
GuarjianarrioBay
_ _M1'_.'-Cuba"''
Operaiinn
E|'li3Ll'l'|ng'Fl
Guanlanarrio
Bay
8B¬|D|'1;l
-_.-..C_uba
._ .
.=r Mr. _-.__Cuba
Mr.
' Cuba
cub;
Mr_ "'
_
i _Mr'.'
' cube
-1
h'.|'C
-1
C1 i
_ 'Mr..
'- Cuba
My.
; -"C_uba_
Mr._
"Cuba
'
Mr.
Mr. . I Cuba
.'
r_I -- Cuba
_ Mr.. '
' - Cuba
-
iiiriti
-
-Jo!!Tilla
l
Guantanamo
Bay TA
Operation
Enduring
-Freedonii
OperationE_ndurir_rg
Freedom GuantanamoBay
QperaiionEnduringFreedom Guanlé amo
Cay
Dpofraiiun
Enduring
FreedomGugnianerrlo
Bey
Operolion
-Enduring
Freedom
Operation
Enduring
Freedom
EJpe|'a'
Enduring
Fraédom
un
i=.D'perallon"EnduringFraedom
Guantanamo
Bay
Operation
Endur_ing_Freedom_"
_Guarii_ar|'arno,Bay
Guarilanarno
Bay I R Pxu
ll-{Q '
'
'
Mr' -" ._Op_eraiion.Enduring
Frogqdo
' '
i '
S "
--
. -.
I/Cuba
GuantanamoBay
Mr
Gllientanerno
Bey
'_4'*i-'L ;i*;';
-l§'1E§:!'-:'§!E'
FRF
Oiioroiioii
Enduring
FreedomGuantanaino
pay._.A
Mr.»
__fCuba
_.S
ii»
'
Mr
-"
"aim;
Operaiion
Enduring
Freodorn
Gua_nl'anarno.Bay
_Cube
Qperallon
Endurhg'Fr_eedo1_'_h
ERF- '
Mr..'_h-Qulia _.'
OperaiionEnduringFraadom'
Guantanamo
Bay
'Mr;»
._ Cuba
Oparalion_l-Qnduring
Freadom
1
Guan_ianar|'[o_B
ERR.
innV gy
i§'i?%*33|5§'5
Ui§ii=-'§!iE'HFF19FE9955Ri1'
Guanianerrioq
Guanianamo
Bay PL
_
Mr.. *Cu'ha'
OperleiEnduring
on Freedom
- _ ':.rzrr.!
_i
1
H0'
_
', ""'_:" 1:|i|
2"5""°:
;.:"§PouSEs-2.3a-'
ho.
; 6~?'*" jm
'
.-=
Mr.
Cuba
1- Ms. " _Cuba
Mr. J _'
Cuba
_. Ml . _ Cuba
. -Mr;
-Cube :Z£
1
GuantanamoBay
-Mr.
Cuba
" -.Mr.' - >.Cuha
OperaiionEnduringFreedom
OperationEnduringFreedom
d Office"
Operation
"Enduring
Froedom
D|:|ei'atI'c_inEnduring-Freedom:
Operation
.E_nduring
Freedom
C'para'iion
EriduririgFreedom
OpéralionEnduringFreedom
'
0i>or§1lkin_Endurinu
FIFQQQW
Guanianamo
Bay
i
E.
Operation.
E_nduring_
FreedomGuanianajmoBay
GuanlanamoBay
GuanlanamoBay.
Guan_ia r|an io Bay
G'ua_ni_an:irno
Bay
Guarilanamh
Bay"
in. _,
'§.-3_u'a;nlanamo
Bay
GuantanamoBay
_'A
ERF
MM.
'
EL:
r
.
be.
i_A.
iii -
r~irr-HQ..
I
I
."°
~
HO
l
|
l
k
i
92
First
Narnia!.'.Garider
"_THg'al'ér:
-7
LastNew
'
- '
Mr
.
Cum;
'
Cuba
O|aeatlgS}92-
1
"
Ms Cuba
0p'e|jalinn
Enduring
Fpaédqm
|.
- "
O'peraliun"_E_ndurir|g
Freedom City ..
1-X -I----.._cu|=a'
Ms.
. ._Cuha
Bay
Qparuinn
Enduring
FnaeddrGuz_a_n_lanai1'|o
-
-Operation
.EndurIng
Fréedom Guanla ambBay
Qper 6rg_Endui'_ing
Freadb Guanlériéino
Bay
Bay
Operation
'Endu:-trig
FrqédomGuanianamo
Guzinlanarnu
Bay
Oaerétidn
Emurmg'FmBd§;T|
.- Ms.
.- Cuba
-.|'u'|s."
1
. rm.-
C
M13-
Guanlanarnu
_E!ay'_
Opem dn
Enduring
Frea'dbr_n
'
jznr
.JobTitle"
i=1¢|'a
0{II|:a'
Bay -s
Ope1é|t§on'Er'1dur'|ng
Fljbed mGuantanamd
_'_f~A_:
lJiM_'
_'_C-iuaplanarnc:
Gay
O'p_ai'$l§on
Eriduring
Fre'eU0m'
/.Mr-. _.<,3uha-.
5 '-1.
Ha".
Baj;-'Mr.',
"Cuba.
Dparalior|'E'nduring
'Fr Guar
ae|:lDmqmc
-.
B.-_'Mr.
. '.'_Cu_l§a
.'OperationEnduring
Bay
Freed i Guénljanamo
Mé;
Cuba
Mr.-"
--Guba-
-
a
'3ua'r|{1anamo_Ba§
Guanianamo
Bay
Guanlanafnb
Bay
.'
Mr.- --.'@*1l=é.-_
_0Qeralin;1Endurmg
Fiiaedorn
92 ~'_
; " Cuba
- Mr.
_-
.O
Gua 1 921_ana'1'rlo
Bay
DperalipnEnduring
.Fl'¬IBl2iDlT!
Dpération
Ehdurjng
Ereeqarn
_Cuba
Dpé_raI,ia_r92
Endu{L_ng
Fyéednm
_'Mr.
'
'
_Cub_B'
O'para'liuf>
Eijduri Freadpm
g
" Mr.,__ ._Cuba_
_Opera1ic|n
Enduring
;Fl'QBd_l3!'I_ l
*
i
l .0péra'1it>n
En u ng
FrpedunG|.ia_f|I_anarm_:|
Baj
Guantanamo
Bay
_Opqrali_o:_:
_En|:lui'ir1-3
Fraqdnm
__ Mr.
Cuba
'_Mr.'
Cuba-:
'
Mr,
Cuba
Mrf " Cuba
b -1
25,1
Y
-1
.r
_
-
Ms. . Cuba
'
ME. _ Gubti
"Ms.'Cuba I
Mr."
Cuba
-~Mr'_
"Cuba
Mr. t _Cuba
Mr.
Cuba .-
Guantanamp
Bay
TRu1'='|fRT_éb|=
'
_'
.
0pef3lIr.ih;EndlH'i'92g'FrBed
Guanlanamo
Bay. s
'1.EBF..
Opera
Eiiduri
nn
Freedom
gGuanlanamuj ay
ogerarian
Endu Fréadnm
g
Guantanamo
Bag
Operaiiup
-E_riquri_1g
Fre'édo1j|1
.
Q.
Guanlanamo-Bay
Op-iafatlbn
Enduring
Fraud-um
Ope'ralinri'
Enduring
Eraadnaa
OperationEnglurlng
'FrB¬I:Idn]
_'-_
MI._ '-_C|'.|ba
Guan1ar|an'|o
Bay
_V
92.P
'
Cuba
Q Egg1,._
= g=s__-]_ -_
Mr. -"¢;"Cuba
. ~*@%~'ai92_4f<i;-;j=g1@_=;~;_.!;uban?92z§§ . ¥§%
="::$?-.??;
L*_1;.
~ jDn§r lI§ ,'Eng
-
K-
_.
Ii
Operafion
Endu ng
Ereedom
Guantanamo
Bay
Operation
Ehdu Ffeadom
i]
Guaniailafno
Billy
Mr___
_
__
_.
0piaral1onEndunjngFreedom
_
, y_;
..
Cu§'=l_
Guahfanarno
Bay. ..
.
Guanianamo"
Bay
Mr '
Fraaqparn_
Guantanamo
Bay-.___.;
_
~_Mr.
"_Cuh_1a.'lperaliun udurlrjg
Guania amoBay
Mr.
' - Cuba
G_ua_nIai'!amo
Bay
Guanianamé
Bay
Guarlfanamo
ea .
."{ ""}-'.
1
term
Qpgrgiitm
Englu ng
{-4.
j
. 3.
- A
'
E
;-_im|u_
.'
0pe}a1kgn.E
5u n§_E§aéi{6m
Guania_r1é1'noBay
'
'
Dpar
qn-_ Endu|'ir_1g
Fmacfom
Guanlzanamcr-Ba' E
;~ -_1;;;DH5._-'NJ:
-1 M
- .
GuE |I'lTa'!'laITllO
Bay .5
-,wE-"
yA
r_.;¢+i.-,1
._
"
LS
5ReSPQu_sEs=z33__'
'
1
1
PF
~'
Last_l92_lama
r FirstNarria
- ' Mr.-
.Ga'nda'r"
__'Th_aater'
- .Dpm_llior|'
_ .'
-'
_ '-ciw
'E;ub
'
T a Oparatlon
End_u'rin'g
Freédorn'Guanlom_:|mo
Bay:
.. . Cuba
Bar
m<>
.Operation
._ Enduri
noFtbedorn
,
. -.Bu== 92§*9»
Cuba
'_§lparati'oI'i
Ms
Bay Enduring
Frée om"Guantanamo
'
Mr.
- Cuba -'
'
'_
"Guantanamo
§a3r
OpBr892io _'Ehduring
Pqaéunm
.- Mr.
-'
Ma
puba'
. Mr.. . . Cuba
.
Cuba
',.G§1a'f1§anamo&#
I;-lqiantanarno
Ba?
Oparaiion
Enduring
Fraédom
Operation
Enduring
Fraadorn;
__Mr. . . __'§3ubaOperation
Enduring
Fraaoom
Cuba '_
Operallon
Erich.i|'ing
FroeQ'om"Mr;
Cuba
"
Guantanamo
Bay
Oparallon.
Enduring
Frae_ddr_n_
Mr.
O1iaration'|E_hc|uring
FteodomI _Guar1l_an_ama'Bay
Cuban;
. ,'
92__.
'
Ci
.Ms-92
Qpe'n_atior_|
Endurinh
Freedom _G_uanlanamo-Bay
|
I
. 92
-
I I :Mr.. .Cuba
'
Mr' Cuba
92
Mr
-
~ "Ms
3 !
b5 -1
b7C -1
_
-.
'
' Mr
Mr.
92
f
Mr
r
Mr.
Mr.
Dilatation-':Ei_92du'ring
Fréadonl
Operation
E|'1du|'i:_1g'lf-'r£:E¢.d0_n_'1
.1oh Ti é .
Upe}ation'
Er||:lu_ring
Freadom
Guar|@'an_amr5"Bay
Guanianamo
BayA
Gqaniooamo'Bay
Gu5I3'|I§;I1amo'
Bay*9.
Guantanai-no
Bay
s
Cuba" " Opr3}ratioriE|1d|,rrinQ'92-=r=1_e'odom'
Guaniar1eimo.|§_&1r
[E|a|u
Dillte
Cuba
opuamn E-ndunng
Frgedom
...Cuba
-.' Oparalron
S
Enduring
Fr9§dom-an 1 .
Cuba _-_
DpBf3UlI_ll l.El'_'l
freedom
Uri g
:"° ..
r *""=
n
Oparallon-Endurlhg_FrBe,dom
- cum:
Cuba
Y Oparatiorj
Enduring
Fraador-n_'
Cuba ' Operation
_Gi:ar11.ana'nu:|
Bay
Enduring
Fréadorn
co 'Cuba "
Guaniarramo
Bay
Opera on
EntfUrIng'Ereadom
Cuba '1
Bay A
Operation
Enduring
Freedom Guanranomo
Cuba -'
.' ,Opara_Iion
E_i1o_urir'1g'FlfBédom'
A
A
-wi: _
Goanianarnnf ajr
Guantanamo
Bay A
CubaJAIg'hani_s
Enduring
0pé_ration
Freedom
Cuba
-'
Cuba
Guba_'_
.
92
4HR"
_
.
_GuanIarjamo.Ba3i
w|=0
-0
anna.
-'
Enr!_u1-ing'?robdom_
Bay . 1_..
Cuba Operaiion"
U|:|'ara'1ror_92
Enduring"
FreedomGuantanamo
92
.
'iF§ .--é'
#<'%, |?!¬Ji--Guantanamo
Bay
Clperalion
Enouri
Ff?Bdon1g
'=ramr:;;aE;2%§5.b§ra=:@r"rr4»:z§;iiE?n§3?§
Mr " Cuba
"'
'
'
-Guanifanarruo
-'"'
i_'
Guan_lanarn'o
Bay A1ay
0per'_a1Ion
Ehguring
Fraadriwm
MM
.Gu'an92anamn
Bay A.
Opararion
Enouring'Free_dom'AIghanisIa_n
Gu_a_I'nl_ariamo_
Ba}
'
ino
Operation
Enduring
_F_n;§:dr>m
Guantanarno
Bay
oneran
.En<1urin9'Fr¢i=dvm
.
Afghapislan
Guantanamo
Bay A
-'G_|5aralIo_n_
Enduring
Fréedom
.._.iHQ . _
I.
sr:--3
Cuba_j.
'
. K_
Mr. .
Mr.
Mr. .
Mr, .
Mr.
Mr.
- Mr.
-
-Cuba1- .
Bay
Opiaralion
Enduring
fréedom Guanlanam-o
_Afgl1_arif5lan
Guantanamo
Bay
.-
1_dof16.
'
'
E1 . _ his-'
-
Inurrnr.
-g-,1 .
$;.ERF-
imam
.
- REs'P0'|~rsEs-2'35
QC. 5'
"1
IPGJ_l-IQ
in»-.
r
-PB"
92
92
1
Last Name
Ge r| '|_"i-'|_'a'aI|'rr
itlor
--
_ -First Name
Mr. . - '.
-Afghanistan
.'Cit5r
-_
'
_'
_ _ 1:"
'
Mr. ;-.
'
Afghélniétan Or_!nat|on_
'
Iixfg énistan
OperationEnduring
Fregadom
'N'ir.
-'
Enduring
_F| e'edci_m
Mr. -,.'
V ifghaniqlan operation
Oporation
'EnduriI'IQ'
Freedom
Mr. - _Afghan_is'ian
i
i <3
4.
-.
.1-§i3114_1%|$"'
'
A . f_,EieldOftl=é
1cG.'HQ.'
-
_iQM
'
is ..
OperationEnduring
Freedom
Mr. -_ A_fghanistan'
P . --r
92..
i1'i°.
I-i. .
ii» O
Operation
Enduring
F|'BBdOi'[|
i . --Mr. A.- IAfghanista_nOparation
Oporr-rtii;v
Enduring
r3Freedorn
Enduring
Freedom
Mr; -- . Nghalntstan
5
Mr. '
- - AfghdnisiénOperation
Enduring
F_r_e9_ciom
Mr.
IjEn|':_iui1ng
FraBd§:||*|1
AfghanistanOperation;
Operation
Enduringj
Ffeodom
Mrfl "J5.fgha_r|is|an
Operpilon
Endurlnq.Fread_orn
r
'|iN_Y
:
Mr. _.. Afghanttan
Opar iipnEnduring
Freedom
Mr.
' _"Afgi'i£ir|islsI1
b6 1
pm: -1
OC-
INY
_. '
A--
LV
'
Operation
En'dL1i1'|_1g
Freedom
Mr.."
_Afghlar'|islan
_Opé ation'Enduring
F_-reédorn
Mr.'Afghanisién
Mr. Ng pnisian
Mr.
Opéra_tion_'E|_1dui1ng
Frgédorri
OperationEnduring
Freedom
j_"'Aighanistan
'-Pi
Operétion
Endu_r_ing_Freecidm
ii-1r. __Argha_n|_sr_an
Q
iMrL'
.
i
i
Operation
EnduringFreedom
Mr. '
-Q Ahghanislan
-Mr. I ArghaniaténOperation
Enduring
Freédom
Mr. - 7 " Aighairiislan
OperationEnduring
Freedom"
Operation
Enduring
Freedom_<'
Mr. . _'Afghanislan
.,
.',Aigha|1iston-Dpara qnEnduringFreedom
Operation
E_riduring'
Fro:-1_dorri"
Dperbiiqn
Enduring
Fr'eBd :r|'i
Operation
Enduring
Freedcirn
.Mr.
"
'
_'Afgl-_|ani5i8n
Operatipij
Enduring
Freddorn
"
_Mr. -_
'
-_Afgi92anfs_Ia_n'
Oppraiiog
Enduring
"Freedom
r
[_o~|_.'
.
11=
92
_'=Aighq;92'r'5i1an
Operation
Enduring
Frgedom
_Mr.'
'_
JPifghanldlpn Operation
Enduring
'Froadom
Afghanistan
,
Endurirrg
FreB_d0m_
.Mr..'_
'
"
' Operation
oiohanisi "-Qii.@rii.tii>n
§i'"3iiT!! Q'FT-°9d°{"
Enduring
Fraa-dm-ri
_
_ Afghaniélan_Clperation
Mr.-.
Afghanistan _O|J§2IE[itIlI'i
Enduring
Fraodpm
RESPONSES-236
.- _';
_1'sqr_1a_'
"line
13!?
_.'-.&#
iB3.
'
Y-1
'
.ME .- .:JN :l
'SU
Mr
Mr.
I -Afg anlsi n
.Mr;
_
i
Enduring
'Frea-dom
Mr. -- AfghanistanOperation
Mrj '
_ *_Ai ghar|i5ian
" Doorman
Enduring
Fre_e_d'orr1
.M_r. '
:'iafghonisiah
r
iuo=
no'IPX
'iro F
IMO .
ifNH_"
NY. _-
rm
lunr .-
urn
lint
I
'HRT
liu=.1"
'
mar
1
.
Last Name
FIrst_N ama
Gander Theater .
Afghanistan
Afghanistan
Afghanistan
Afghanistan" '
Afghanistan
Afghanistan
Afghanistan I
diQfl l|::a
Afghgrnisian |l5l_oI
|l;A >
Afghélhist tl
Afghanistan_ .
i.'
.
to
.0
Opeiliinn -Lt?
.
Operalion Enduring
Freedom
Operelion Endurirgg
Free_dom
.. ..Y
Operation Enduring
Freedom"
_ 1-_
'D|5e'rot[on
Fifaedoln
Enduring" -fur
Operation EhdLl_l'|l'1Q'FfEéd0l'r1
'
__Opara1to_n
Enduring _Freed|om
""-1H0 '
'
;
Operation -Enduring
Freedom
Operation Ehdut-Ind
Freedom
Operation Enduring
Freedom
Operation
Freedom
OperationElidurifig
Endgflng
Freedom"l'
Afghapislon -.
Afghanistan Operéliun nduring .f-Ieedom
Endunhg Freedom
Afg anIs_tar|- j peration
nrgnqntslunQpBrE|liun'ErIi1u 1 |g Freedom
-Ew.-'
.
f".@{HO '
l
QHQ.-.
"" lwm
'
:"r'r1.1
'
'
-pr.
<n.ngnan|st;tn,; ;'£3r;ittr1Jtt13ti;¬rij!l§ itt9..Fre§dnmt§é:¢§§.'
Afghanlsiarw .0pe_ration
Enduring F_r,aedom.-
.-
_ _
;Hm=Iy réarn
iHD-Fly Téam
Aigheinlgdafl 'o;;.=;rattut1_'t5'i|u92'1_r1ngFieit<1r>m-__
'_
_
'_
"
Afghanistan .O_parattn'n_l§.n'durIng
Freedom
,
.-
i-_lO¢F|y Téam
1'
ICRU.
.-
!LR_ -'
1.-
1
_92 -
..
' RE5PONSES 237'
'- 1'anr1e
1
.;-.
1
1
Response
Which
Are
Not Purely
Negative
I
Resp0nse'A
1
.'
o
Rev. 01-31-200:1--
o
i FEDERAL eunenu
or
INVESTIGATION
?
:==-maenw PRIORITY
Date 0 7/12/ 20 04
To :»-"'Countedr;t'error
tn:
ism>
Z *1
'92 ,_
.-
_-
.Inspec
_
_
ion Special
Inquiry
ion
Division
._ Inspec
..___._.._...
_____._i.6 g._. .._bé_ _
_ ..
~1'-c
From: Boston_
'
Hudson
b6 -1
b7C l
RA '
~
Contact:
I SA
Approved By: I Z
- Title:
Synop si
To report
92
_
Pending] '
negative response
_
from captioned
writer.
. b6
Details: 0
Bureau
name: 1;? l:l
ff-lC'iEl
1 Special
' Title:
Agent
-'
Tenure of
Assignment at
' 2002}
_
;With
/
b2 -1
GTMO SPECIALINQUIRY '
s:
ext:
,E
'
a= /W
#: 297-HQ-B13276-69-A
'
_I N
_I
ma-ta
o By}
a jat
Case ID
*1
C
-.
'
-
GTMD: 45
days _[July 'Auguet
t1 -1e exception
of fluctuations in
room temperature
controls by
military personnel,
any aggressive
treatment towards
duty. -'
-
captioned writer
detainees during
did not
his tour
.¢'§
Ir
&
RESPONSES 238
observe
of
-
1
-1
-
Response B
Ihglessagq;' '_'
- :P_ag6 1
l______J
9~8=>>»<PB=>
a'°'f
. August 02,2094
- H
1!, 5:22 PM
5I5
. l¢3f12
.
-'
MC
-l .i- .a .-51%-TE:,;12
U
----
sent; Monday.
S_u_bject: GTMO
RE: - _I
a
|a
. _-I
-
__i§£~NCN-R RD
'- '
. . ."
_'
-- '
- 'b6
-1_ '
1 ii;l*i§'§ifIr:*'1 5%Bi? 'é&#
a aE;~§a@aa@§a>aa§
~a a -
_;,.__
g
_£§___ ,..
.. ,
_M..-
_
- "'§ .._¢I-ms
r 1~'r"=
H1;?1?.?.éi
.§L-.a.=" 1_-3;
_
_-
_-
92
-. i;1I?%I1&-FmP.m:ai I0§??E
- dTTi .iE1iiEE
-§ERE_II1I:'§§I;§§%I.TlJIlI1-.L15$iJIA
_';___-._a:.......; __,..._........,_.,1.:192..:..§.:.;.,-_:,--~, _..,
_...._
,5,,_,,_-_,,__
_
I-was MaatETml!12!tI2I2lilIM1f1Iil2BIIii
and aaa
not aI:rsnnally'ullsar1e
anu_mislram|.1=_m
nl
J~
Hi-aiainaas.
wan!!!
I aa
um sllmiaad_ii.aI1!nl1i||9;sir':1_iIar
in
-311111
iif iil uccanadat Sauna
_;l!ei!a'
arinr
in
orll i W I'M
at '"iTg
Imm:annat
_i_EI..
ha aue
that anabsiws astiuinl
wauiui mam
auaumain
the --_
iIrBsaan'a-aihureaunlsaanaa.
- -J ._ -- i. '_=" I I _"11
.'
~_.
bi
<~
.
3li il!flIliI 3 '92 lil$_II_!;9 Ei!§i:_lI saaa;l
aalaa,-aai_11un.aau
-.'
_ :2
r__:au|nagu1a:.§:u _all
imas_aaia!!aua;n.1iaa1m uarspnnal
were-Y -
b7C
mv aiiagaligns-_ragarainn
harsh
lraammnt
are
inalunaliin
ma
aarauraun
!a'
me
$- if allegalimlsat
_can
AI/|u_n§'|si_cai"§st|*_a
usau lm
at Bilraib.-.a!J: ai!_aaatiaasara_;;ma
_-.b7D
_
302. -allaaiaa
iin llllslll is aaraaanv asaggressive as
ma mannlnuesailsaaa-as have
Man - =
I-aeaame am
o'i';~.rai!aIniaamatianmaj:
.'at6TM1i.
amalnea
ha.
mialnianal
item
mamas Saaaiaiis!
inlanI1an'af2!3II3.- = , ~.;
a a- a
V?
.k
4
b6
b7F
11
[1$i|:[lhaaaiuiilunumansiatar-listingmqTBY..
IiiEast
ar1raas:anar,1§|:_|naa.
asnI&#
~1
Tim
1!i1g¥nursIa§'¢f"|aa
uwnn-aaznauian
Ta__rkasma,w!_1in:n
e'!'aaa1
taaamamu
aa avlizr-'lI1
ma-alllnesa
mfafs
regular
Wl_EiI
aamact
'a!_l_uI_il:a_a:_1n_ra1&
mm aaiainaas."
jgaur
-lSama
92ai_1
.flin
and ranama
ma1tiniianu'|Imvinna-ui.-unlna.
'wara-uljnrau
I'l1e_iIi!B.l!rs
! a:1_||1in
anler
l_1imanistan
In_
amt imrsanelauiiasinu iihinaaa
uII|1ression._-were
amen
Tim Inspired-by-Ba ;_iu,frea
man
ma.
£8_
b _gwasjairmerill
1
l:rua|1aa5£erinr.
a
tnalnsaluas
Tns lliqhu_rs.éahsi
ha glmng
tar
to;1._. are
aamncranv; and
may iuulizell-ihr:
llnimn Stains.
llliluugn melliululrs ara_-Muslim
their agaua-|Ii:i nut-
auaaar ianciuna
ill
lSi3Illi_!}
raniualism; may
ciimesl inam an anlitiaal -t:ung|e|:1iuu"ia
Islamic - - ;
zarrariats me
ur
Taiiiuan. Huweuemlair camu
in iuhanistan-was
l1umne:_|,_a_riuI
an!in
.Pai{ist_an.
may
'
_
'mc'lIiu8iars
Imus
weracaumraaj
PiIIii$liilll5,WiHl
halt ileiniramerfatl In-I15
l:il$ lmi!l.iIi1Ii l1ali_IIn":iI!
."
ramapmeal airaa v-ta__
.ui ::iais._
ninasa Il_I._-.pa_s
aiiauell that
ma liiulmrs
who alara.-lraiusiena -aireivlixltn
ma ilinasaHan: immaaiatalu
axaaulaa.M
ma iimaoi
my 1'M,.lIS'
ware aaa_si_:3arinu
tli cials wllallier _
Ia Maram-1 igim rs'ta
&:l|inasa;aussilm1
aim
gaintosalunura-far
an cinatan I15.
actian in
Ilia mmaaa
iasi. maiiiglwr aalainaas
at amawere-cumzinaanmay
matwaula
he
immamamlyaxa|:utaa.it_meu_
wereramma}|ml:nilia._..'_ '
';.
.'_ 3 -j 1- -
-"
- 1'
'
b1
__
r
'
'
h MeBB2=;ge___
~-.
cs: F
F
- I
I BF B
_ _
_L
I|||L_
Palgc-:2o
&#
l
FF
-F " ~
F! %
B
i
E¬'H$
-I
"|17_
Ii!2ElIl2.!%J_§ar
1§,
j
linclnnen
that
~
nr|:1at;B_mn.ii:e a_raBraBi11ali§nema1u aa!|B2.Iiuiavaiiaisqiasnatlling-1
owing-a5!ysiBa!a1i_usaB
bl
_
_
_
- i E'i'_l' _lI;lllliit- $16585§ll!lI!Il!~!§l§IIl!i'5'SiI1li1;ilIIIill£11373
_=
.,
'_-- hm
-1
_..-BTBB
Uighur steal!:-is _:;sa:3n_at!I_l
uniuawBreur.u|a:-mm
linglwas
.a§!||1is1l:B
dowin:
harsh
{mammal
=
- '
awatalnees;--Hal auantlu
a-"smukina {%l!n'.'
reggnliug allusaui
min-uamiuaas. Hawauggji-.!I1e.lilgl1urs&#
-"
an
aratrua
1 .-.mBrBwBsaaamu.atGIr , ::i_tw_as
ismzpmlazi-uriarm|||uIIIY.an|l,1l1|lilnmllriuriu [lIB.!} |lS1I&
~ .._s_ii=am1|'_
I-1:|:IiBvBit'Baa:sBalI_Bli
eI1B.
iHfii 'i!lli_l$B
am -Bay.iiIi]Ti'I1]I.1l92
nncurresl
J!lli]lI'l
.-_ - have
nsnurye margasm
as liiaiy min
iiiIiillU0iilBlIl!?il ll_I1l}l'SlllI!jl!i,
."_
_._
.. ~_
FF 'Ih':_1;t- B-a1?li_i'i:aia'|_n,:_'
F
' 'nhse|' £'a m'Bssiuet
' '
arei -3l!25':ayai'I!il|
aa nant l elaineé
i 33;?
ulienriaws
llmhursl
~'
- , ._ inma
.ll
Ii: Ii
I.
,
.1, b7D
. _
-
b?F
_§.§C*}1l $n|:|Ba:zgsiBmB:np.mBwBm
1::-:!nln::e:B:imes§B1z_;u;:_u
~
--
.
_-'_
¢_'
'_
_-'
_i.- .-'-Ma-ssag'e-I--I?
Crr1gina|_'
- - __
-.
1-
Fwm.=Mc<:RAw,FFEvE~ <3- INSDHFBII
~"F F
_'
I .- .. 9
J F '-:
I
,
,_
B
'1-B:
l' r~1§~4!.
' gMM!
F_B_t!FB1
'
Ho! .FBi!&#
Sent
Frida
-
Jul" 09 2004 1-42 PM '.
'
'
.- "
--
.-
'
."'
'
I-
-._, [o1o!, c,0~-
Ml ¢Jl_!_]FBI'
t ~:&_gFB1!;
,
H0
FBILE
NY!_'
=
MM!
FBI'
FBI]
mu?
g
L|]iu92!_-{5B1Hr!
|. "-.~_
-_ '
QB
____!
Ls FB;!,LBATrLE,'
FRAN ,B1;
@@F
~FBI
.
,
7B
_
1U-A!
"wm=B1!,]
._ FBI!
;
F 1-.10FBI!;
_-.
NY!
_,|cu
F15! i<n1.!.FH1~
am! FBI!_
B A.NlFB1'
.j
-
!<FB1!;-
'
|
. _" _- - H0H%g FBr- ; FBI'
Kcs!_-_[gB1j ]Fr[|:=!_gFBI!_
~ _
.CO--FBI
-b6 -1'
MM"!'FFBI
~M!cFB1!U<Ho!<FE11;J
B
I~
-
'-bin: ~1n1B>FBI- NYHEBI!;
! -F
92 9 1FBI!;
92
FBI
. Fen
Fm! FBI!
{CID! F MM! FBI- FBI
FQ!<o<:-M Ls!
.
<As1:>!<FBI- mo!
F
ITD]
FBI!;
ASD!_[FBI MM!
'
FBI!;| _| |w! QOGAJL! B|I| 9_9_{FBl!;
_
[PH} EBI!; cummwss ART!-I.UR"M. cmFBI MM! FBI!;
~
_T l _MP-1>£FBI°M FB1 IRD!
MM
FBI!;
MMFBI'
FBI~92 MM!{EBI!{U
. i
-. '_
|F511;!
MM!
lJsF! sF!
FB1NY!
FB[!;
-_
CO!- FBI-!_; B B B
FB1!
_ss!
FBI-!
i .j
--
BF"=
1
- WF!
A
IR!_ FBI' Fm-FB1!;[
*.£PX OG§~;_ J
mo FBI
QFBI]
$ éE? ?
NK! FBI};
_! HIR! FB1!;-
am?!
-
F
i l*§%cFE11n
F wE>
Jj~FuFBn,'1
B.NY
" F<FB1>-FALUFBI
Wi
CII{J F_BI! _ J<><! FBI! LAWBI!;
_' "'
"
l
VV
jF
MP! FBI!;
"_
'
BESF0N'sEs'-24
V
'
"
Response C
aemnunlnni
u£2;
- <:>
Fensnnn. Bunenu or INVESTIGATION
A
Precedence: ROUTINE
Date: 07114/2004
To: Counterterrorism
.Attn: 'MDLU
Inspection 1 =*==
- From: Counterterrorism
_
UC |:|
£?<: 31
Divsion '
FA/RDTU<~
[W
Contact: SA
Approved By:
Bald Gary M 9292
Harrington T
J b2
-Battle
Frankie 1'
|
.
-I - '
| b6
Drafted IBy:
iald
I
,,_ b7C
- Case ID #:
297-HQ-l327569 A
Title: COUNTERTERRORISM
tenure at
-1 I
~1
_
_Pending!
DIVISION
GTMO, INSPECTION
Synopsis: To
_1
advise of
GTMO. -
SPECIAL INQUIRY
observations of
Details:' Special
Agent| '
treatment during
"
Iwas assigned TD!
to Guantanamo Bay, Cuba [GTMO from 1 March 2004 through 27 b6_1
April 2004.
While
there SA witnessed interviews MC
_l
However,
SA
did not
observeaggressive
any that were treatment
or the
use
oin
erview/interrogation techniques
which
could
inconsistent with
be characterized
as
adversarial
Bureau interview
in nature.
policy/guidelines.
O0
' b6
-1
S:92CTD92E ly Team92 Gtmo.ee.wpd
137;: -1
RESPONSES-241
i
_92-
Resp0nseD
__ ___
I:
Message
l
'
If
_
_'
Page
of4 1
_lilwsgurslw_I
_Cc:
777 7
77
7T2:qV:;7j;V
77
IR! FBI!
|'
' Subject:
RE-'_:GTrv1O
- .Since you
did notpersonally observe
any mistreatment,
we
will classify this
asanegativeresponse. Thanks.
r----Ori "
--- '
,From:
~
-I
IR! FBI!
Sent Tuesda
=-
b6 -1
'
-
. Cc
| Subject;
Jul 13
2004
9
AM
'
1 20
{IR]{FBI!
-
uncr_Ass||=:so
_
RE: GTMO
1 ssns|1ivs_s_u;r
'
NON-RECORD -
-I
was assigned-to
GTMO fromJuly 1?,2003
August ?,2003.
l'mamember of CIFEC-is
Behavioral _
' Analysis Unit andour function
was toobserve interviews
of detainees
and provideinterview strategies
as .
heeded. Duringmy
tenure there, Inever
personally
witnessed agressive
treatment, interrogations
or
interview techniques
on GTMOdetainees. Idid hearloud musicbeing played
and peopleyelling loudly
from behindclosed doorsof interviewrooms butI could
not
say theywere yellingat detainees.I also
observed strobe
lights ininterview rooms
on anumber of oooasions
but neverobserved those
being used
on detainees.
_.
' -'
i- -'_'
Thereweremany
comments
made
by
investigators during
my
tenure at GTMO
that every
time theFBI
' established
arapport witha detainee, the militarywould
step
in and the detaineewould
stop
being
_
cooperative. There
were alsoaccusations that
the Militarywould
present
themselves as
FBI Agents
to
detaineesand harrass
thern butthat wasnever personally
observed byme.
~
_I
etc
lfyou any
havequestions,
pleaseme
acontest - __
'
b2_1
agile
or I
-1
'
.-
1CR6!
CA
C
' '-.
.
_FBI Academy '
' _-_
Quantiedvirginia
'
22135
--_-Original Message--.
,
From: MCCRAW STEVENC.INSD!
."
_Sent:
.-'
RESPONSE;
'
242
FBI!
-.
Monday; July
12, -2004
12:13
P
N_Y!_ FBI!;
'
-_t
HO!- FBI!;
- MM
_HO! FBI!;
FBI!; NY!
- - FBI!;
FBI!; no!
FBI -
FBI!; HQ!
FBI'
MM! tn:-11!;
'
_1 . 136MM!B m!
FBI!;
Fs1
-no! =s1!;
-7/1312004
'
Te=EP'11 |J FBI!; MM! FBIl'
" o1o! c'on-
we *1
" "
_NY
um 1. Q
FBI-
cu!__FBI
' CllI5! FBI - earns F_RANl IE CTD! -FBI
s1!_gFs1!;_ to
FBI : I31-HFB1!;
0! FBI;
IR! FBI- NY!
FBI i-lO! OGA'
__
cs!
FBI MM!
FBI!; no! FBI!;
us! _ FBI!'
OGAJ; _1-5!'iFBI!;'
'
FBI; en;
I **
co!
FBI!;
NY!
Rev. or-31-zoos!
'
"
FEDERAL
BUREAU
OF
INVESTIGATION
.
1,
-
Precedence: ROUTINE
__ Date:
-
-To: Inspection
' .FI. OIl1i.
_' "
-
b?C
-1
.b6
Approved
l
ssA|
By: Tidwell
.
_WWWW
..
--
|_'
b2
-1
J Stephen id? / W __
_Fedarc
_
,
-
BAU 3
. ctintact:
b7C -1'
b6
-1
Attn: .
CIRG. .
pNCAVC,
_
0'? 3/2004
-
k Janice.
'
'
Drafted
By:
_
Case ID#: 29 ? HQ A132'?669-A
Pending!i',?5"2-*
- Title:
COUNTERTERRORISM DIVISION,
en-10, '
- INSPECTION
-
' .
_
SPECIAL INQUIRY - ' .
Synopsis: SSA
interrogations or
GTMO detainees.
Administrative:, Reference
interview techniques
July 9
Analysis Unit
on
_-
electronic mailings
McCraw, Inspection_Division;
Details: SSA
__
did notpersonally witness
any 1;$C_El
aggressive treatment,
- CIRGJ , Behavioral
_
and 12,
of AD'Steven
C.
_
2004. -
Critical Incident
3 saw-3}
'
_
Response Group b6 '1
wasdeployed to
stmo we
'1
from July
17, 2003
- August
7, 2003.
Members of
the BAU Unite
were regularly
deployed to
GTMO to observe interviews
of -detainees and
provide interview
strategies and
other behavioral
"
assistance as
needed. During
my tenure
at GTMO, I never
_'
personally witnessed
any aggressive
treatment, interrogations
or
interview techniques
on GTMO detainees.
'
"I On
several occasions,
I did
hear loud
music being
played and
people
yelling
loudly from
behind closed
doors of
interview rooms
but I
could not
say that
detainees were
present
in those
rooms. I
also observed
strobe lights
in interview
rooms
on several
occasions
but
never
observed those
being used
on
detainees.
' There
-.
.
were many
my tenure at GTMO that every
with adetainee,
the military
would stbp
being cooperative.
_
comments made
by investigators
during
time the
FBI established
a rapport
would step
in and the detainee
'
The military
did not
stop the
'
I interviews
whilewere
they
progress
inbut
routinely
took contro
V.
.
RESPONSES-243
92
.
-
.
»
|
_0 From: CIRG
To: Inspection
Re: 297-HQ-P11327669-A,
of the
detainee when
Q'
01/13/2004
the interview
was completed.
The next
that detainee
was interviewed,
his level
of cooperation
diminished. .There
were also
accusations made
by differentinvestigators that
Military interrogators
would present
themselves as
FBI Agents to detainees
was
time '
J
'
and harass them but that be
was neverpersonally observedby SSA[::::::]
_'
..-.
r-
1
4
1
1'
.2 -
_i
'
b7C_q
RESPONSES-244 '
*
Q Re:
0
?91'
Toi IDS-Pectipn
?i5om-. CIRG
"297-HQ-A1327669-A, 0?/13/2004
_
.
LEADKB!:
Bet Lead
1: Info!
' INSPECTQQQ
.
AT WQSHINGTON,
Read and
DC
cléar.
+6
I
3
RESPONSES-245
Response E
Q!
Rev. OI-31-2003!
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence :
- sate: /2004
_ROQTINE
To: Inspection
b6 -1
b'?C
-l
Division Attn:
".'£Q§-ffi¢_é:
§?'F&#
S-1;
??}§: 5F3. <'?5.§,.@-.111.
ot-'i;;ofn
it e
,'
From: New
I CD~30
b6 -1
Contact: SS
I
_If
_
_]_.
92
r edY
B
-1
§?3T;_-..§.E-..12i.1f~=;:zq@
Approved By:
D
"3
York
_
if/TC "1
r"
:|-'.---_-_--2-»=-g
Sfz
. -L3 95_§j¥E,{l3{ff_:i.§','
Ing
PE-AS Q;-1*
011-==4F4%
_=m-:-.- ,.'._'
Case ID
#: -;t29
¬HQ§Ai32§6¬§e§71;
Pending1"fqB1*E7
.- __92-',-.||,-__..',,
.-.._'_'
..'
.1
..1-..-q
_;_.
921..-.sf.=._-- ----- . .-
'1 :i. tle:
wGTMD
COUNTERTERRORI SH DIVISION
--
. INSPECTION
Details:
§i;E:nF0sHATIOHscnwrrrurs
~~*'~~
=@r.rar.M tn-
seesiisiu ti=1ef'EIE 1;.s;.><&#
SPECIAL INQUIRY
Synopsis:
-To
at the Us Military
~
@§E %gmm m mE$ e__-
report writers
two !
tours of
assignment
Base i_n_ Guantanamo Bay Cuba G'I'1'-10}
.
_
- Ti!
I Writer conducted two '{2! assignments
at G'IfMO,
Cuba in aFBI/Interrogator
capacity. The
first tour
commenced on
O4[3'0/2002 and
ended 05/ 30/2002.
The second tour r:ommeric_ed on
07/17/2002" and
ended oa-/1'?/2002.
IHQ At
the time,
writer was
I.
a New York City
Department INYCPD} Detective assigned
Police
to-the Joint
Terrorism Task
Force {JTTF!
within-theFBI/%fySquar-I-as.
Kg;g_Qffice,
_
|..
'
ipsorscra
A555 i;* U1 During
the periods
great many of the
conducted jointly
time did
or was
writer observe
aggressive treatment
was noted.
of
A few
of the
the interrogators,
some wanted
language.
i.e.
to be
moved
these
issues
All
noted above,
writer interrogated
detainees at
GTMO. These
interrogations
with US military intelligence
officers. At
persona
the detainees
11 yldith
invo
ve w
and in
detainees directed
certain concerns
however minor
were forwarded
e-
,-'
cxf
p'_. -m92a_,,._
1.___.
MT:-h
. T_.
_ e§ =_|-92;,|' .'i;"r_:;=..
._.
=_":'
I
to
_the
e_----cc:
1_,!@5»;..'.1§.-'1.
. _BEAR§HEn_" 1.?
; TTC
to
minor medical
issues, food
complaints and
closer
to
others.that
spoke the
same
OO
-
Vaha !,
opposite
RESPONSES-246.
7.
|
a
any
fact the
proper officials.
I
were
no
b6 1_
am-H@~"Prl3;17éb?-/
**ma:1> _
sanmzs: r|
_U
LED
Q
_
-- niiv '
mm:
I
'*
v.
Response F
'
'
?§y-
Q2; Qg;
Rev. Ol-I1-2003!
_J
_
FEDERAL
BUREAU
OF
INVESTIGATION
92
.
Precedence: ROUTINE
Date: U7/l
To:- Inspection
IAttna
/2004
V Steven C. raw
' .
Room 783
Erm: Memphis
| Squad
7/Nashville RA
-
~e, -5
_
I 1
'?C
App
aved,
_
_
Con :SA
b6 1
b
1:36 -1
h7C -1
Unit Chief
" Ie*
' I
I' I _bg -1
====-We l:lBr
ICaseID '29?-no-A132?6s9-A
#=
{Pen
-Title: CONTERTERRORISM
~GTMO;
DIVISION;
-
INSPECTION SPECIAL
Synopsis: Response
of detainees
INQUIRY
to request
at Guantanamo
-Administrative:
This EC
from FBIHQ regarding treatment.
Bay, Cuba
GTMO!.
is in
response
_
to email
from.AD
I
Steven C.
McCraw, Inspection
Division, dated
July 9,
2004, .
requesting responses
from employees
who served
assignments at
GTMO. The
email requested
that employees
who observed
a -ressive
treatment -immediately email
Unit
_ I
Chief[:|
and that thosedid
who
not
observe
treatment
such
b6
-1-
'
sou
that the
submit an
EC stating
EC should
not be
such. The
uploaded, but
email further
should be
requested. b?C-1
serialized,
withahard copy
directed to unitChief
b6 1
' Details:
"
-Respondent's official Bureau name and title
Eas ALAT,
-I?
e ective
of GTMO
detainees. "I
gP
Secial - '-A ent
endin
August 15,
Q9.
transfer to
2004}._ Tenure
is S.
Le at
Rabat
of assignment
at
GTMO was
March 3,2003 through
April 15, 2003?,
Iobserved
interview techniques
no
aggressive
did not
which
were
interview'policyfguidelines. '
'0n two
or three
in an
did
interrogations
Iobserve
not consistent
the use
with Bureau
of
-
occasions,_during regularly
. scheduled
interviews, detainees
subjected to
loud music
to keep
pornographic photos
treatment or
use nor
advised me
that
they had
been
them awake
and had been shown
effort to
upset them.
I have
_RESPONSES -247
no
I
' u
Q
To:
Inspection
From:
RE:
297 HQ A1327669-A,
knowledge that
these
was under
activities
that
sometimes
that
Defense
DOD!
common knowledge
reoall
O7/12/2004:
the impression
Department
of
Q
Memphis~ _
were done by FBI employees and
these
interviewers.
among FBI employees
was_disoussed at staff
detrimental
used
by
were techniques
contract
and it
This was
meetings because it
to our efforts
of
as
I
was a topic
attempting
r
was
to
establish rapport with detainees:""i"aiso reCall"thatm""""m
translators
who worked with both FBI and DOD_interviewers}
also
sleep
confirmed
the allegations
of
the detainees
physical
No detainees
mistreatment
of
or translators
advised me
of
any
'
detainees
by any interrogators,
guards, or any other employees, civilian
M
regarding
,'
deprivation.
or military,
at_GTMO.
I
-..
r
z_
z
RESPONSES-248
"
u
.
61?
92-..|Inspection From:
.I
, To:
.
Memph_1s-
Re: 297-HQ-Al327669-A,
_
Q1
U ?/12/2004
I-EAD s!:
Set Lead
1: [Info].
INSPECTION '
AT EQSHINQIQN,
DQ
For information.
§§_
1
¥
-3
<
RESPQNSES-249
'7 41*
W" '7:__
_
____
7" lI_
_7
i
Response G
_k
-. -
-If it
-El ,--|, }
___ _
__
.4__..
--
_**'_I_?_| r~rso!
W--Fs|!.
__jT _____..
__;
.
__ '
rs»-=si:irs~>»<rr»i
1
_ .
_-
r
'1.
}Q§,C_§1 Sent:
M@ncia',.1uiy.1s,2uo45;2r PM.
Tu:
" Subject:
GTMO92
"
.
l lNSD! FBl! '
ll
" '
.
§§_hlSlTI1EuM<;1_As_stFIEni
s'uT
'
_ N'N-.RECORD_ --~
_
.
_-
-
b6 -1
lnspect0rQjust lreturned
to
theof ce after
toda'
gone
being
two
weeks,
for so
that
is why
this response
is
1217C
_a
Ia
week
-1
e.
y-official
Bu
name
is
Special
Agent,
and
tenure
of
assignment
at.GTMQ
of
3i 4I03to
#18203. I observed
no aggressive
traatrnen
,interrogations,
or interview
techniques on
GTMO . '
detainees which
was notcor|_sjstent with
Bureau interview
policy orguidelines. lfthad; Iwouid
have
' such
abuse
immediately.
reported
If anything,-thedetainees weretreated withprofessionalism. aswell as extreme '
' restraint,
considering some
of theiraotions against
the guards.
Most
detaineesi interviewed were
asked
by
- __
myself, or
the other
CITF interrogat_or,.how?tl1ey
were being
treated. The
onlycomplaints
recall
I dealtwith
rriail
.
not being
rreceived, dental
issues not
being
g|92_ren-immediate attention,
and other
non-abusive ISSUES.
The senior._
CITF of cialI wasteamed withwouldfoliow
u
on thesecomplaints as
soon
as
the interviewiinterrogation
was
completed.follow.
An'EC,will
gou_
Thani_<
'_SLC,
Rf-92,
Boise -_
sbsnsijws BL1T_UNCl._i}92$§IFlED
'_155 _1
-
-
.me
_'
_.~
-1 '1->2
_ _
_
-1_
1
_
."In omnna -
RESPONSES-250 '
_
_-
_-
1-: 1--_77_
_-L
r
_
_
_-1
G! .
'0113
rev.?-zoos!
FEDERAL
r.
BUREAU
OF
Q
INVESTIGATION
Precedence: ROUTINEDate:
-0%9/2004
be 1
To: Inspection
ittml p_
__.
C
'1
. Room7&7 92_.
,.
- -- --From: Sal-1: -La-I ;-e~-C-it-y!"
-
I
b6 ~1
-B
Q3.'8
E
RA
2
_'
Contact:
SAf liI
' .
' E 7 9
b2
/'
_
-1
'
The Boise
HA
ls a
W? -1
APP °"°d _BYDEUJ
e
rJ
um:
mall
once
'
Hmadmt lm lm:
I=raf=e=1BY= l:|='dek
an
92
CaseID #=
29'7 HQ-Al32'?669.-A
."
&#
Title: Counterterrorism
Division,
". GTMO,
'
'- .Inspection
Specia-1 Inquiry
Synopsis: Provide
.
negative response to abuse inquiry.
Details: Special
Agent!
_,
I an
a45-day
TDY as
-Boise RA, served
during the
period
March 3,
2003,
-
Salt Lake
City,
92
'
interrogator/interviewer '
to April
17, 2003.
Actual days
at GTMO,
were March
4 April 16, 2-003. March
3 andApril 17 were
}k:§;C :l
travel days
between Boise,
Idaho and
Ft. Lauderdale,
Florida.
During
TDY
this period,
SA_ didor interview
not observe
any .
aggressive. treatment,
interroga ions
techniques on
GTMO detainees
which
was
ot
cnsistent
with Bureau
interview
92
policy/guidelinesf
SA
would
have
reported
such treatment immediately
had _she observed it.
-__
_
'
The
detainees interviewed
by
SA and
her be-1:11:-1
Task: Force
partners were
-1
various _CI'I F Criminal Investigation
asked if
they had
any complaints
about their
complaints that
were made concerned lack
dental appointments
not being
made,
not
their hair/beards
to desired
length, etc.
concerning mail
and
dental appointments
the investigators.
'
'
I
n!
treatment. The
of mail/delay
in mail,
being allowed
to grow
The complaints
were followed
up
on
by
a
{"
_ C
_-
_
.&0:
Inspection ggig:
Salt
Lake
City Z!
Re: 297-I-IQ Al327659 A,
0'?/19/2004
LEAD B!:
Set Lead
1: Action!
' IN§PECTIQN
AT WASHINGIQE,
Read and
QC
Clear.
n
2
RESPONSES-252
_-
Response H
1|
1
r
it
be -1[see
iii _-7*»
____ 77_
_ ;| lHsDHFB.I!
'i
_
_
.
_
_Z. '
'
"
'*
irg7""
iiw-q nwhrq 7""'_ iW'_""-_
7 i" 7in Vi 7*
ivi 7".Fri 7'
W7*'
" " '
T"'
'i7*7"**:'
fa
'1'
.
_5ubject: RE: GT_MOlnspection
Special inquiry
. -I
_I
__
__
_QK thanl<sL i~iad'a
couple ofthe
same 'resporisesi,ob_servationst
idonot beieive
it tsthe criteria
of the
inquiry, so
- we will consider
itanegativeresponse. Thanksagain.
"__
.
_ - _---'-ifJri'?'inalMessa?e-:-_- " "'
, _From.
[CG![FBI! -
g cfl Ser|t:Tuesi:la
Jul 13
2ou4'2;17
' 1PM
. .To:
zi~iso! FB1!
'- ., Cc:
.-BI!
,.~_
Subject: GTM0 nspectionSpecial -Inquiry
'SI NSITN
UT
_RECQ_BQ.29I-HQ-A13ZT_669
.
- i
;_ 1
I _
__| did
HQIIOUSEFVB
physically
any
aggressive
treatment GTMO
of
detainees
but, asthe email-was '92
'
written requesting
iniomnation regarding
the observation
oi "aggressive'treatment,
interrogations or"
_interview
techniques dn
GTMO detainees
which wasnot consistent
with Bureauinterview -_ .- -
-
'
policy-iguideiines"
.I willinclude the
following obsewations
andiallow the
inspeotion Division
to dete_rrnine_if
itfalls under the
desired criteria:
'
__._
-_ -
'
-
" .-
.5
_
-A detaineelwas
into
ledan
interview roorn
by hooded
MPs. The
detainee was
alsohooded
and
the hood
-'
was _|'B'i
by theMP511OVEi.T
for
theinterview. This
procedure-was under
not ourtdireotion.
This happened
on
two occasions.'
'»
'
;
'
' I1'-"
_-_
,"
_ _Inan interview
trailer,
observed
i
interviewroorn
an
ashing
with lights
and loud
rock music
coming through
' under
and adoor. I didnotobserve anyindividuals
inside as
the solid
door was
closed. observed
I
this-'
'onlyon§:e._;
I' _"
"'
"
'
' . .-.
_. -,
'
7An EC wiii.follow reporting
the above. _-
-- -_
--
~ i$Al:|
'
__cT-1- _-
I
,
' _- D6 -1
_
_
.
_'
T'
--»w<: -1
.-
"
-
__sEi~is|TivE _BU;-U_N§_LASSIEi§Q
- _
_'
h
-.
.w14:2o04
'.RESPONSES 253
__
;
_
J
Response I
,i
it F
i 156 1 ll Front
|i*~*"@F>>rFBi>
LA! FB|!.l
'
.'"
Kt
"
__
K
C 1 .Sent: Wednesday, 2'00-41:2?
.Ju|§1-1',
r5M-
i
I::i~~e>e->
_ fSi._|b_iect:GTl'MO'
_-. .
~_SEIilSIT E*BUT_LJ|'iiCLA SSlFiED
'
-- QQN-B§CORD
b6 1 -
-=
. ~
.-
.
';
I eawjone inter.view_where
the detainee
was interviewed
while sitting
on theoor. Thefoiiowing _mqming
'»during theail
handsbrie ng there
was direction
given on
the proper
treatment detainees
of
during
an interview.
'|
-'
.qnly assume this
dieeussion was
e_ result
of thedetainee beirig
interyiew white
sitting on
the oor.-'
_._.
'
Any ':
further
qniestion orcornmente
please coritact
the @ direot line.
Lbi -1 '
--
.- SENSIIIYEBUTUNCLAS§lF|ElQ ;
"92-
.. - - _
__
t
' 1r14i2oo4'*7
'
'
"i'ii*
"-
RESPONSES 254 .,
-
-r
-_
;
-
Response J
i'
Message -
"
'.
_"
_" '
I'
_Page l|_of"3
p
°e
ll:I<P><=<FlB'I>l
I~
Subject: RE:GTMO. _-
' ' _
_
I w lclassify that
as
a negative. Thanks
fer_ the
response.
--¥0rl'
Mesinai
e-'--_-_
==~=~=h<P><»<e:>
L _
_Sent:
Wednesda%'
Jul?ZUO4
14, 1Z:23'AM"
_.
b _1
To: INSD!- FBI! _
Subject: RE:GTMO -
.,_ I
'
.._
_._'_
I ,.
' 92
-_ ._ .
_
-
O11 one
morning parmer
my
em
OSI went
hito the
ohsetfvatibn accross
roem_ hall
the from
our -'
interogation roomto
get achaii . While
in the'r'e
he
called me in.In-_ one
of theether mte1-og_ati'on
.
reotns was
a detainee
sittirig in
echairalone in
the 1_'o_0n:|.
-The g1
assI2.way mirror
was very
waim '
to thetouch,as
-if the room
teII;p.__wa.s92
the interfiogatibn
room-._ The-detainee
appeered-be
to
s1eepingit1thechai1'.'
'_
i
-1
- __
'. I
The next
day vathilen
getting achair
irt the
ebserttatieij teem
I ebserved'wha't
appearedbetothe
same detainee
the san1e'i'oom-..
window felt
very
Thecoolthat-moming,
as
if the room
temp.
was lowAgain
.
the
detainee was
aloneattd appearedtc
be sleeping
in thero'om.'
_'
'_
I do
not kpe-w
_wl{at'lSN
the detainee
number
I.1OI"'_92_PV-hi!
hadthe detainee
in-the roont.
I_clid_not
go -into
the interoga roan;
en and
do_n_'t1c;1~;>w
the ream
felt.how
_'
3'
.'
_'
- -.- - '
_
A er making
tl1ese'ohserva
left ithe
0bsem1ttion_re0m
0ns we
subseqtiently
and
conducted
bur _'
inter~rie}r_facross-.thehall._'
'_
'
'
-'
.'
I wouldeppreeiate
any-input you.'.l:'1ave
_regardiiig_obse1_vat1'0ns."
these
.
_=
-_---O'ina.1'Messa
_" -=--"
.t, _
b _eFroa?ht<n<sD>
Sent: Tue'Hl3l2D04-7:41
AM .-_
'
T°=I::|lPX1rFBI>
7Cc:
' -
:
re-1:L
"
. .-
,"
Subject: RE:_GTMO _-
'
-UNCLASSIEJED . F
_u;uaec;uuf'-- _.--l;
._-.
_
l _
.-
b __
- -If
youlceuldprovide-rhelan
just
a
emailtwith
short
syhopsis
of you
observed
and
we will. ma'determina1:'on
he
whether
it should
classt
he
as
rrhstreatnwent
edwhat
Thanks.
of
-
b_1'
- '
-'-----Ori ina|Messa
l-1-'" --.
b-t
'
.
m4r2004
W
_
-'
_'
LF1-»=h<1=><><FB1> 1
__ _
'
' .'= .
'"
_
'
'
-RESPONSES Z55
."
.+~.
.
-'
" _:'
sol
b6 -1
b7C -1
h
s
Message
V
h
l .:.~Pae='~*-<=.w
Sent:92'l13
u_esda
2Dt'J412:48
jut
AM
u-
To: INSD! FBI!
Sub
: .'_
'
Import:ance:High-_
'
-
_-
.-
.
.
' While
at GTMOI observedsomething that
may or'may_:'not
-consistent with
beour
policy because
my infcnnationis veryl.i1iu'ted_-'-I
like todiscuss
wouldthis
to -
- determine
how I-should
r'espon'd.
I-_am
c11rrej;itly'I
in Isianiabad,
-DY
Pakistan until
V2.1 end-.wi1l
return tothe officein PhoenixDivision, TucsonRA onW26. .
_
- .- ," 'YOILIliIl3YC01 1I$.Ciattbv
8_ii.lIiilB.ISi.8J1121iJ3.Ci
to Tucson
- '
b2 __1-.
~Maynun1ber,inTucson_is
3e-mail
-or wheuifetum
. .g'"
____ ,_Le
- Thanks,
' i
1' -
._b6 -1
b?c ~1
'
.---Ol ig;inalI92fIessage----
_From:
_'
_-' " ,, .
-
_ .-
--
MCCRAW, STEVEN
C. LINED!FBIJL '
__
_- "- '
Sen:F ?i'i '
---
7"
-
' '
" estiiiiieeieta
' Subject:GWU_'.-'
_'
. _.
.'_
.'
ia
'
i
'
.
SENSITIVE BUl_UNClugSS'IFiE_E.
g_
_
. --
_,
_. ,
1
_.
_
i Youhave been
identi as
ed
having
conducted
an
essignrn_er'it
at
C-§ |'IvlO,'
Cuba since
'
-. _9t1i,1U1.The inspection
Divisionhas
been
tasked withco_r_"|t_acting thoseernployees
'
_
.who have
served in anycapacity
at
GTMO and'o_btaininforn1ation
theregarding
treatment detainees.gmploveesshould
of
immediately;
respond to
the toilmving
:-
'1! Employees
_who observed
aggressive treatment,
interrogations
interview
or
'
- teehniques
on GTMOdetainees which
was notconsistent with
Bureau intervi_ew_-
~.polieyiguidelinesi,
should respond
via ernaitfor
the purpose
of atoilow-up
'iriter_view_:_
- _Positive ernail responses
should be
directed to:-'
- .- -~
5
L
'
.' '
._
_
;
. .-
_
__
~-
b6 -J.
-'
inspection Division .'
.1 I- .
.
t -2! Employees whoserved
at
GTMO-andobserved no
aggressive treatment
of '
' detainees.
should-respond via
an'EC documenting
a negativeresponse. The
EC
.sh uld ineiude theemployee'sBureau
o iciai name.
title. and
tenure of assignmentat '
'G.TMO._ ,
__
.-_
_
_-
- - The EC
should betitled
"Quuntenerronsni Divlision}
GTMO. Inspection
Soecial _"
'" |nqui|'y",- .'-
--
H-I ' -
.
_-1
.
I
. ..
I -il|B #29?-HQ-A31
32-17559-A.EC
TheShlitlid
FIOI b¬'UD|OEdEd.
iJl.li only
§EliE|iZBd, -|'ii'
E.
'
. hard
copy idniizarded to:
' .. '
' t - -' _
' '
.
_-
' inspection
Division '
__,
- Of ce of Ins ectionls '" ';
Rizsponsas-25's.t
_m4g2@04
,
_14!
]
_-P -1
Messagej. '
- '.
' '
SENS-ITE!E.BUl
.' - , 1.1 §i=A§SlFlED_
.
"
Pa_gc.3o
Room 7'83?"
'.
H
I
'_
' RESPONSES-2_57_.
m4r2004'._in
'-
_
_
_
[
i
l
.
Response K
.MBSS&ge.__*_*
%
7.
?Page
_1C;f1"f
l.
__ Ml..Eh;e:.E;.|._ilE...._!.__.-.}
_
_-I
.
Prl5_'_,=_~3=¢11>><FB'>e
1
, YI-|1
b6 ~1
b7C -1
Sent: '|=neey;'Ju|yo_e,20043159-PM
-.
Te |:|<1~S@>
FEW
Subject: GTMO
aeeignment --- . '- I
' - . '
"r
-QNGLASSIF-IED _bl -.
151 .-
-- l
Non-gggoen
--
".
"
-
eeef
.l
-
u
_'
PEA'$°.lT;57§1'- §4'?§l -l§ - - -
*.
:~ ..
_
' '
_'- -
. l5?
=likeii2i.iiIefi.:t*§-§éE=f%'f§eie.I.
- -
-
~.
~-
".
L
-"
_
_
'
1
was
assigned
GTM
to
pIf} _?!2_3
- become
8122102.
While
eiener
1 eny
observe
elielreetmen
detaineesand
did
not pa c|pa eInany
ewiews,I did
aware thatthe interviewrooms werekept pretty '
coldand
that
interviewees were
kept in'those
rcerns forextended perlods
of time. _ '
, if
.
7_i
-N
_
Additienallyl
7__
in
the cell in
|so|'¬
foron
an
extended per1od3f'Tin'|e,
up toSl ays.
1-i lnli
__
I
'
_ ne
detainee
wast-cept
-' .-'
' -
Are these
considered violations
of f'Bureau interview,poiicylguidelines?
' - _I,
e
-
' .
" . - -"
' r ;- .-
?§ii Im§unIE:RIii;I 512? ' '
__
:
" L
l
it
_m_2/2004'. -
Vl
L.
--
Jaeseonses-zse l
"-.
-.
_.
Response L
' '
- '
>,
Message
_- I l ;
_
b6 ~i
b7C
92-
'
From;-L V 1
Sent: TuesdaJul
13
-1
--
.
__
-V}-I-agg
_
_ *[ s|::-! 'r=e|!
--
2004 :24
PM
'
_-
_
_-
_
-
"5ubje¢t m'garding
GTMO
treatment
of
Detainees
Forthcoming
from
LJC '
- '
.LLlilQ.LA§5.l.E|§Q
.
-
NON-RECORD
b6 1
b7C -1
-'Hei'IoMrl:|"
'_
'.'
"
_ H"
Per
email
-
f
instructions
fromStevenC. McCraw,-I
arnsending
thisemailto yopto advise-Iwi be submitting
an _
email-and
did_n0t'personaily
obsenreaggressive
treatment
ofdeiainees.
'
-
-'"
_
I--arln
eware
however,
that
cletalinees
could
beidentitobe
ed
niaced
on
a Iiet-for
a sperii
' cinterrbgaticrt
techn-iqué-involving
interruption
ofsleeppattern,-callled frequent
yerprograrri.
I
was,TOYtoQTMO 91.1103.
"1rough11-!11J03._
._ .
-"
_-'
'_
_ _, _ '
' -- 1_
__ I
'_-b6
1
" nitC |e
SAAPU '
-
-'
_
' I I-'
'
-
iggat t
. _
'1_
1
_.,,
|
I-.
L
~
"
?ri4r2n04
_RE$PONSES-259'
'
.-
-
i-
I
. Rev.01-3
e -."r
l-1003!
®
.=
1.
FEDERAL
BUREQU
OF
INVESTIGATION
Precedence: ROUTINE
To! Inspection
Date: 7*./15/2004
Division Attn:
b6 -1
me -
92
|
. b6
"
'
'
I
_
_Office
;Room
From: Administrative
Services
' SAAPU, Room 10130
I
Contac:t.|
ii
Approved By:l
-1
pections blc-J
_
37
'
"
'_
Z ILl:
--'
_ J.
f'
kid}? _ '
E JM51
t
Case #=_
ID 297-HQ-A132'7669 A
Drafted. By:|p
_
Tit1e:' COUNTERTERRORISM
DIVISION, GTMO,
INSPECTION SPECIAL
INQUIRY
FOR SPECIAL AGENT SA! APPLIC}NTS' '
Synopsis: Report
of negative
interrogations or
conducted
observation of
aggressive treatment,
response to
email
of
individuals identified
July 9,
2004 from
as
having
interview techniques
Details: This
EC is
in
Steven C.
McCraw
to all
an
assignment
I was
on GTMO detainees.
at GTMO, Cuba since
on TDY assignment to
Detainee-Liaison Unit
.
09/11/2001.
_
_
GTMO, Cuba for the.Military
IMDLU! from September 1,
2U03.through .
November ll,
2003. During
this time
frame I
was assigned
to
participate in
interviews-of the
detainees being
held at
GTMO.
During my
assignment I
did not
observe any
aggressive treatment
or aggressive
interrogation or
interview techniques
of detainees
at
GTMO.
During my
the military
assignment at
personnel aseigned_to
cooperative detainees
could be
GTMO.I received
operations at
placed
on alist
abriefing
from
GTMO, that
for
aspecific
interrogation.technique involving
interruption of
sleep
pattern,
called the
"frequent flyer
program."
With this
particulartechnique, identified
block to
cell block
or every
two hours
military pereonnel
along with
all of
detainees were
moved frequently
at intervals
that appeared
to be
depending on
the_shifts and
"""""' 7*
$?
' ,.
from cell
every hour
availability-of
to
move
the detainee.
Detainees were
their personal
belongings. Due
to the
RES PONSES-260
non-
_
moved
movement
I
~
To:
fnspection
Divieion
From:
Administrativg;Services
Re: 297-HQ A1327669-A,
07/15/2004
-'
_ to different
cells
throughout
a
particular
the detainees
24 hour
detainees
period.
seemed
had
their
sleep
"The duration
to
depend
of
the
interrupted
program
for
on the,cooperativeness
of
the detainee.
I did not participate
in this
program
and do not
know of any participation
of FBI personnel
in recommending
detainees
to this program.
I did observe on the detaineemovement-databaee,-some-detainees
moving
approximately
recall
the
names
every
of
these
were
hour
or
on the
every
_
movement-records,
two hours.'I do not
detainees.
'
'
1
2
.
RESPONSES-261
9
_
.:
_
_""92
_
_To:297
Inspection
Didieion
From: Administrativgggervicee
Re:
HQ~Al327669<A, O7/15/2004
_
-
.J
,
LEAD{s!:
Set Lead
1: Info!
£1! -?1"1I1ET,I5Te13 £¥T1,*92"E ,§ERi
AT AGENT
- For
PRQCES5ING, no
information only.
Set Lead
2: Action!
INSPECTION DIVISION
' Bring
attention of
the information
-
in this
appropriate personnel.
communication to
_'_
Q9
. 3
'
RESPONSES-262
'
the
