Department'of J~s,ti~,e In~pector Gener,ar ~u~s~ionnaire'Re9ar.di~g. ~etain,ees
Dol-01G INVESTIGATIVE QUESTIONNAIRE

FOIt ,R:EVIEW' AtH:> USE ONL-Y BYIN[)'x'VlDUAL FBI ~ESPONDENTS

.,

.. ,.

Q'O NQT FORWARD ¢R' DI,s.sEMir~rATE" .'

"

.

QUESTIONNAIRE 10,: teSt-O,O,OO:l:t41
AS'-af tf:1.~ la,st time thi.s·q~~t1onnair~w~s ~a\(~dr ~pme r!,!qIJi,re.d liel~s" h.av~ n9t"~elJ- C;:9~pleted.
Plea~.r,e.v,iew

your r~sp·ons~.

_:·~ijsi,~/::::.:'.:;,:.-:' ~:.:: '::

A.

P'~r~on~1

"..:, . . .

.:··'·'::;}«:~?:;:·'~·:').·~\;.:\f::·i?~;:·:·!~;·Y· ',' '.' .'

InfprmaJ;ion

Please provide:the following ii'lFormatiQn:'
1. Fir.st liarTi¢'

§ ~,7C FER AqREE/YIFNT
;~. MI~qJe 1 l ) ! t l ? l r : 6J.'7C PER AGREEMEN·"
:3~. Last

Ii ~ 7.C PER AGREEMENT
.6 &, 7C
f; ~:7C
$peelp,l .Ag,~[1t
6 &; 7C. PER. AGREEMENT
fi ~.7(;. PERl\(~8EE1V1.cNi
.~ ~.'!e,pE.RAGFEi:.M!=Nr:
6'& rCPER.A'GREEJViENT

name:

4. Eliter.ed bn nuw" Date (EO!:>}:
'~;. Curr.ebt 'Di'{isi'qrVFielp Office:
,6. 9~rre!)t Job title:
]; Direct-dial office,telephone nU'mber:
8_,fBI c~1l pnorie' nlJri1l:jer:
. 9~ fBI p,agenlUtQber:

io.

Bes~

cQn.taet nUlJ1berfor'You'~

B. Background of S'pecifi'C D.eploynie'r1ts'oi' Assig'nm'ents
11. At'any time aft.er:5eptember 11.( 2'001, aid :Y0u'sefVe' a~,a meml)er',oftlie U.-S. MmtarY, or' as i:lh
emplo¥ee ,or .contractor Of the FBI,or any otheqjovemment agency.( at Gua ntanamo Bay, 'ClJ ba; Iraq;

·Afgh~nls'?!,IT;'or'J.n .areq~rq:m~roll~ ~y tt)'e
.g'I.!:>!jal yIl'!ir on je(ro11,

1'2. !=nter·,the

V.S'.

o Yes

0

No,

number:o't time'.s:y.ou, wg![e,depIQy.ed o.r:ilss.\gn~d to each 'of the-.failowing i<iGa.t!.9lis;

.(Guantanainb Bay~ CiJba·;..1raq;,AfghcHlistan; of in any areas confrolled
j!1t~lIige~e

by ffie-U.s,

MJlitary.,oF'a:u.S~

seriif,:e).;1, '

For,each deployment or
Location- 'select- one)
... ,,, ...: :,_'..".

:

Mjl!tc)ry -qr:a U.S. int~lIig~n~e's~r¥!~.e llr~~!JQe.c~ion,-wit~ \/:le'

..

assl~.nrf1e'rit,complete

.

tile followi~~ section.

Dei!)0Y.m,~ntor ~!pigiJrrtent'~egjm j:iil,~(
abo.u.t

~ep,~~e6~ pt:'5~igm;i'll!iJt:~n:dei! qil .

or i1~ut

;Afganis1atl
02/09/20:02
0.3/12/2002
....... - ... :'. "...
.
l~a. What Wa,!? j:/ie ;ger'tera:l nattJf'~ ~,M p:u.rp·o~¢. ~fYQur ,aSsigrimen.~ ~in<;f ,a¢t.iYitj¢:s?
Investig'ator, i'nterviewiiig· -d.etaiij'ees( \col[e¢!:i ng eyjdeht~
12'b. Please provide. the' names cif the, speCific,camps, basest or facilities where you worked.
~

~.

Ba,gram, Afg't@nistal1,;Kabu.l

:
:abP.V~ SECRE1,
plea~.:che¢'k her.e 0, 'in.c1ude In 'yo~r answer that you' hav.:e ·1lC!l:l:Oi~.i9nal information dassllled -'above
'SECRET/~' and, if ,yo'U know, 'id.entlfy 'the:c1assiflcatlon.lev..el, llcket, ;compart'rT\I:~nt, prograrrvor·.0ther
desIgnation .th?~,ap'p'lIe~ !9·t~e. !nforrnatlon, po n9t In.c!uqe,the ,adq I~jol')~l clqsslfied fnfprf1Jjltfon. II) -your

ric;.

NQ~;

.

It lnfqrmj3jipn: ~bput a ~p'e,cifiJ:'.camp", ba,se" Qrfacilit;tis.dqs~ifjed

OIGQ-005271

questionnaire re,spbnses. DIG personnel with ,the necess~ry clearance Will cQntact yo'u to rec~ive it.
Position

Name

L--------------- _~s..!Y~~1i - -- - --'- -- - - - - --'- - - - -- - -~ ---

I

'~1?¢'. Pid YQ!.J joint I\,,' illt¢rYiew Qr il1l¢rrbgate any de~irje~ Vlith h,9(l-F~l pers(>tirJel?
~

~

........

'

"'"

....'

__

... ~ _ _

....

_

0~

.....

" __

O~

.......

0.-

• _ _ . _ .....

'

_"

.....

.....

_

....

b6
b7C

:,

:

_0-. _":'"

- With what 'kinds 'of l1on-F~J personnel 019 YQI,.! workjoi.ntly?'

: D.cITF

'

;: &1 'Other U.S. MiIi~ary

: 0 ',Ll,;s, iO!eliigetl!=e: ag'ei'i~

:~

0: Fprelg'n -rnJlltary or intelUgenc,e.agel1CY

;: 0 O.ther

'

",

~-------------------------'-------~--~---------------'--------~-------~-,:

:;fif DId'y;uj~~iiv piaii :"any. det-aln~ ini:~rvie;:'or-I nterr~giti0ri,"St~teg V;' objectlY-e;;.·-or ia""ctlGs-w~~ n;n--,
~F~I per.s.onn~l?

.i
0~

..

O~

.~

.'
~

::W~h~~t ki~ds~;f-~6n:Feil;~r~;;n""e'i did :Y~U:W~;kj~jntiY? -- --'.~ - -~- -- _.. - - ~'- ----.- ---'- -'-'- --',
: 0 CITF'

': 0
;0

:0

•

'

'

,.

,Other U.S. Military
U.,.S: lntelfjg~n~~. agem:y'
·For~ig'n·.m.i!lt.alY:.pr Ini:elilgenc~ a,genyy

,~ 0 o.th¢r
~

.•- ..... - '- - - - -' - - - ..... - - '7 - ... - - - .... - - - - - ' - - ,., ..... - _ .....

:129. ~Were Y6,U ~~er-6therWl$einVblveli

':'

"

"=" -

-

~ -

:-

- -

-

-.- -

...r -

-

-

-

-

-

-

-, -

- ' .. -

-

-

-

-

-

..... -

1'"' -

-

.

..... '.-, , ;

In-:detalil~,e,lntirVleW$Or Intiri6gatiorl$~~ith- nO~:::FBI -pers7>nnir?" -:.

o Yes

0Nd'

.

---~~-------------'---'---'------~-~-'------'-'-~-----_._--_._--~~-~--~~._-----

.

A. Trainin.g Prior t;o'Qv~,r~e~s~eplQyment'orAss.ignm~nt

l~.

Did 'loti reGeive ~lny, tr:ainin-g~ iii,sti'.iJctio.n, 'o"rguidan<ie ·speeificall.y in"prepaiatiprr for ariy,6fyour
overseas.deployments or assi~nilients?

Ddo

Not

Recall

14. In pC~Paratidri for anY ofyout ,overs.eas deploy.mElits pI' ,assighme,hts"did you' receive 'any training,
in·sfriktiori,.-.OI<!jllidanee ,d:mcer'nlhg Jh"e.sta ridatas. 6fcon.du€t·a pp Iicable to the treatoieiit~
..
interv.ie1ll!" or interrog.atiomor"detainees by FBI personnel?

'bYes

ado Not;,Reca.1I

OIGQ-005272

15. In preparation for any of your overseas dep loyments ,or assignments, did you receive any training;
Instrug:lon, or guTdam:e wocemlng the.standards 9f cqnd!Jct-applicabl{} to ~he.tre<ltm~.r!ti
i'nterview{ pr jhter.rQ~atjQn of-detainees by non-FBI pers,onn~l?

'OYes

, 0No

DDQ NQt Recall

16. In preparation rqr any of'yOU( overs~?!~ QeplQYlT1erJtsor q~sigm:nents, dfd yOl:! recei,ve,?!ny train!ng r
instruction, ()r'guldcmce cbn~emlng WhClt 'lOp wer~ :S,UPP9sed. to do if you obs~rved or llecfr9 ag,out
the''treatni¢nt, interview,> 9r iriten'bg!"itipn,of aetaine,es bY FBI pei"SbhneJ, which YQU I5elieyeUJo
be lnapproprialel' iYnJ:>rofes'siohal, coercive! ·abuSiV€t or urilawn.lI?

'

0Do Not,Recall

iT. In prepar;:itip)l fQr ~nY;Q(Y6ur overseas (J,ep!trym:ents or ~!::s.lgnl'nents, did Yb,LJ' reCeiVe ,any training,

ibstruCtion, 6r:guidance cdntemhig what 'you W,er.e'supposed, to do if you obserVed 'or' heard abci,ut
the treatment, interview;, or i1'lterrhgati6il.of detainees by non-FBI personnel"Which y.ou 'believed:
to b~ inapl?rapriate;,:ul)prof~,stoflal,
-werdve, ,abusive, er unlawfuf?'

,I

lB. Training During ',Over-seas tieploy'nl'ents orJ1:ssi9 nmen'ls

18. During any of your,ov.erseas deployments or assignments" did y.ou receive any'training~ ihstructiolT;
,qrg.\.Jlqance !=onc:~rn\n.g the ?tC;lnda.r4s oT,condup: ~ppIiG.al:)le:ta the,tr-eatm~ntJ lnterv!~w;: '?[
Int!9rrogatio,n .Qf !iet:i3in~:n)y FBI ~~so.l)n~l7.
'

i~, 04rinJji-qn.v:9f ;Y0\.lr Q\I;e.r$e?,s'depl,oym~nt~ ,or aS~ignfller:!tsr. d.ld you receiv~ ?lnY t@il]ing, instr[,lctign,
Qrlli.liQ.<:m~e'qjnt~rning the, sta:ndard~ qf'cQndu<;;i: '9PplitC),Qle to th¢'treS'ltmer:Jt ]{lt~rvi~wr Qr
'int~rrdga~jQn ofd,~tain:e~s b,y h'Qn-FBI p,e'tsi:)hn¢"?

OY¢'S,
'2Q. I?4rtng ,FlllY qrYQlJ.r~o\f.er~eC\$'deploYIl1-en!,? qr ass!g:.nmen~id!t;! yqu, r~celye ;:;l1')Y'tl:a)lllpg, fnstn.lctlon,
Qr~,!-!i!:t9rice,'q;>nGe.rn·ing WIl:aPtQu W~r~ ~upp:Q$e:d tg; dp if ¥,Qu :Qb:~erve.d 'pt he51r.tJ .ab,out the..
,
treatment] jnt~rvl¢Wl,'Qf ,1r:i~rJogatidn ofP.etaiMes by fB:I: pe~l:'inell which you believed to be',
ina;l?propflate~ i.l'nptofessioilal~ cee'rGilie" abusive,: or hlaWfu I?:
.
,

u

eNo

OD.o Not Recall

z1. D~rj!1g

a,ny gf YOur Qy¢r$eq's"Cl~pJqYr:n~nt~ Pt q:S$'lgrimeiit~~ pi~ y'QI,J r~c~iV~ ~ny t!'ai!1ifl9, Insti1icj:ion',
,
treatment, interviewr , ,or lnterwg,ation ofdetainees by non-FBI 'personnel, which )':OU believed to
.IJe'.inapprop,rfa~~l".mp:ror~~~iqn?i~,:co@'r9iV'er,ab.usfv~]·9r'.!J!1laWful.?
'

or:,9 ~ IdanCe.concernirig 'What 'yb'tr were ,sLlppoSed .tQ do, if \Iou .o,bserv-ed p rhea rd ,abo.u f t h¢

OIGQ-005273

dyes

,00'0 Not Recal.l

Ie. Ad~quacy' Q'fTrai.ning

,., ~YIfi :Y6.~~ opi~brt; d--'rd:'yd~- (~eiv~ :ad~qya~e trainirii~. lr;·;tru-cti6t),-6~g~d,a7~~~·~~I~tln~ t¢,st~hci~·~d~·
of condUct by FBLahd non-FBI pers6nnel relating to treatment, inteIVieWr or lriterrogatlon,of
'detainees prior to your deployment ',or assignment?
.

OYes
'0 No ... _ .... _ ....
.. _ ..... _ '" ... .... _ ... ,..., _
... _ .- ._ .... ..... _ ""
i2i\, pfease des.cdb:e the w:aVs-in whidi YOl,! b:elie.v:e tn~ .tt~ining, jnstructic!i'l qr gUid,an~e w~,s

'*' ... _ .,. __ """ _ "'"' ..... _

~

.... -. ... '" _. _ ....

.... _

,A

'r

'*' ...",..

~

~

• _ ..... , .....

~

i natle<fu:ate:
'
I,don"t remember having any tr.aining or instrudi011. I had beendepJoyed ;overseas 'on sevefcil prior
'oC()C!$i<?ns~and had interyie~~d p~ople being inwstigi;lt~d forterrO[iSI11' Still, I~don't· ~1}i.!1.k 1 haq artY
., :5p'.ec!~iqt~a}n.iry~ !e[.atep1;~ t~},S~ d~pl~Yl11:e!:1t..._... ' _ ,. . •. " ~ ...'
~..
<

"

"

"

.... ",

_',

.

'.

'

,

•

,

•

~

' ••

~2~. In yqur opiniop, ,did yoq rece!v.e',ac;!.eguate traifling( iqstruq1911r"9r gL!iqC!flce rela~jng·t0 standarqs
'of «lndUct by F~I,qnd non-FBI p~r!?Qnnel r~lq~ing. to tre;:ltlTlent/,ihtervi~w,..orir:rt:errogation.6f
:d~taln¢~s,.di.Jrlng

-

.~

..- ,.

~

,~

- - .......... - .........

~/

...

~.

yOJJt'

l;Iepl(jym~nt

- ... - ..... - .

-~.

'" .....

-

or a~slglin'jEmt7

.,,~

- - ... - - - . - - .... - - - -- .... - - -...."

~..

~

-

-

,

'- .

--

'"

~

-..-

2~9, PI~qse descr.lbe,~he \:\lays :In wJllclT you, believe the tri'lin.lng" Ipstr.!jc~10ni'0r .gul<;l~rJc~ wa~

- -- --

~

-'

...

:

: jrii;l.dequa.le :
,.
,
, .Ld ~m'nh'lrik we, I:!a!t alw~ra In I~y 111 Ulls ;ar~~, :spe1:lflc l<Hhe:se. detal.n~,E;s·. How~v~r~ ql,lr rn lJ1d,set!lQIt)9
in ,i'nd througho.Ut .toe .intervieW'S- was that these .detai.hees should be inter:\liewed and interrogated liKe
~_ .?!1y.~!h~~ !~~O!LslJl:..s~~p.e .. ~n_~~!~"!.ti?~:.CLn ..t~~ y§ ~or 2~~s~d~)b~ y§): _ .. , ...... " .... "" _ .. :.. .. ~ .. ~ _ , ~-\

<1

24. In )'0Ur',opinib'J1, ;dld you receiVe :adequate: traiiiirig( iri'strUttioh, :or.gUidarice:t6nce~hih~· wtiat yoll
were su pposeO to.:do- if-you, obse'rYed or heard about the treatment, interview ,:0r interrogation' of '
:q~t~in~r by f~I 'Of n9n-F~I ~'ers(>nn~.Ir. that YQ,ul.Jelieve.~.wa~ inappr,opriate,; ~!,!p'rbfes~fon?ll;'
,q)en:::i'ye~ abusive; or u:nlawfu.l? '

0!\1o

Q'¥e?

-

24a. prease describe the.ways, in-which you believe the training f, Instruction or- g.uidance was
inadequate:
'W~hatl ri9 trplnlng .sp~Clflc~IIy::de$!gn~d on th'e(prqp:~p!1r~s: InJh'l~ ;qrea.
,
-'-'-

..... -

-

- , _ .... -

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

- - - -- -

-

-

-

' - ... -

<- -

-

-'- -

-~- -

.... -

--- -

-

-

-

-

_

.... _

... - ' -

-,..

-

-

'

-

-

-

-

-

_.- -

~

2$. (O'ptj9nal) In :yvha~way? c::al'1 th~F~I improve:tra1fl!nQ. Or) t~l~ ~ubjelrt for fytur~ QeplC?yments:or
~ssig nmen~s!

'

~ hav.e. f1~!:lrcl that 1h~ FB~ has~' mUch improVe.9 t)'Ah1ing p:r;qgranl f9f pgopl~'belhg:d~ployecf Gurrently. As
long as M.enls. know wliat tlie Bureau' policy is r~iirding occeptii'ble standa'ids'and pra,otices-, !'think

Agents 'wlll be· fine, secondly{ as an A~ent deployed overseas" r n~ed .to ·know·who, n:itn reportIng' to ahd'
w~o nw "!i.nk!· is with th~' FBI :at HQ. Thj? was 1J0t'fujly dev~.Ioped.puring ~b,e time .of my d.eploYlTIenf to'
.
Afgha,oistan.

10. C~ri1ment~
26. Please provide:aii'y' additional il1formation ,concerning 'train'fhg for overseas deploymehtS or

OIGQ-005274

9ssignfnents of FBI p'ersbhliel yOlJ

IntrQ,du~t~9n tQ

belieV~

is

relevah~<

Part III: Jil t/1i~ s:eC,tiQ,n·,we,.ar:eseeking in~oniiati9.Ji

regcrr~Hng i;l:wid'e r~'mge:9f
to have occurr.ed.
You sliourd not as,sume; just because' we are asking about a parliclilartechnique or-ji(actice t thatwe',hav~
'C9l)cIuqeq th~t it. in fa<;t' ,occ;urr.ed'. We .recqg,n:iz~ that §ome of these ~fechnique~ '0(' 'practtces: D;lFlY at tit1T~
'~e:n.~c~~~ry fClr:$f€!tY f1n,d's~ur'ity rn 9:~f¢.t¢ntiQ.n s,e~,tjng~ rrc<:tdgij:iptJ',:W~ rec9g:ni.?~ tJ1gt'~9rTieQft~~~.e
.illt~rview

0.1' .int~rrog,atfo.n'

J:et:hlliq\J.~?' ,ana Qthet type.s bf _d~taiJ1J:~e.treatment .all~ged

lechn'lqu~s pr'pra,c~iges,mav; '119V~Q~el1' qUlhWlzg~ fgr',u~~

by mlli~i?~Qr'Qther

~~v~rnm~tt~ perS9!1n.~I.

W!th re~peet to each identlfied'technique; practice{ or- type ,of conductdescribed below/weare seeking
jl'Jfo,om~.tjQn abpu} It§ .Qc,l!4r~encedl,lri~gorjnq::ill'n~GtiQf..I wi~~ th~ inte,rvi~v\",o,rint~rrogatio,n 9f ,Cl
:d~t~jn,e¢l ~r duri~g, th~ ,d~~~h,ti.9.n pf a' qetaiti!'!& b~YQntl ;\iVha1: is'n~~!Jetl 'fqi' ~af¢tv ang :seclfri~y.,
In: thal: :J;:"Ontext:lIVe 'Will. as.k yi;>u 'tq .tell u~ WhE;~h~r ,Qn~ 0'1" more :Qfth~ following .,stat~m~ji~S are: HUI;:!,:,

.

-

, 1.. I personally 'observed thls'conduct.
I:l?1>s~ryed, ~detain.~(s) in a 'con.Pjt(olJ.·thClt leq' m~r~9.,b~lieve tha~ .thl~; con..duet.lJad Q~G~r~ed..
':? De~.iIJ~,e(~l to.lQ J.n~ thqt .th.is~ cCl..ndl19t h~d ~ccl,lrr~q,.
4. Qtners'WhQ ohs,ervect,.this cQO'dDl:ldescrib:edit to me.
5i, Lhave':r~lev.ant: iiifb'rriJatioll classified OoY,e:"SECR6P .
,6'. I never observed this conduct nor heard aIJout'it-rrom,someone:who:dld.

·z.

a

a~

~b~
G;

d.
'~,

q r perSeiially obse-rved this conaucl.
0 ~pbserv.ed detairiee(s) In c3.C'0,hditioh that led me t6, bellevethatlh'ls conduct had ,oecutrecl
0 , Oetainee(s) -told me that this: conduct. had :occurr.ed.
0 others who observed this conduct'described it to me.
0 f. have releyan~ jnformatiOn c1a~sjff~d~bove I~SEC~EJ:\

t 0 I

never observed, thJ~ -cond,uct nor heard ;abq~t it ff0rn solJ1e9f1ewho did.

2&.·'Oeprivj,ng:a getair1~ ~ftloth'iri.!},
a.
b',c.'

_

o II p'ersonally oliserVed this coiiduct.
0, lLobserYed

detafnee(s) in a cona ition that led

me to, believe 'that this conduct had :occurred.

o \Oetaihee(s) told me that this conduCt had :6ccurred.

0 Others who observed ,this conduct described it to me.
~'. D. I I}av.e re~va,J)t,lt'lforn)ati.on ch:l':?sifiej:l pb9V~ "S:I;CREr".
T: ltI r neyer o~?e,rved thls·copciuct (lor hearp :a~8uq~ from:so~eone~~o
..

d.

,.

'.

"

-

---

c;I.I,d.

..

OIGQ-005275

:2:9', Depriving a·,detaine.eof steep, Qf interrupting ,sleep by fr.eejuentJ':ell re(b¢ati!:>ns,or'other methods

a., 0 I personally

obs~rv~d (his cqnauct.

I ;Qbse('(~d. d.etqinee(s) in ~'cqndftiqn thqt

led .me to' b~!ieye that thi,s <:o)ld4Q: !lad o'ccurred.

d,.

0
0
0

e.

0 I have relevi3nt iriformatioh' .cIa'ssifie:d 'aboVe, "SEdREf".

b.
,c\

D~.ta'ine~{s) tol~ m!= .that

this, t9ndu~t hapo<;curred.

Others' who observ~p 'this ~pnd1Jct d~sl;:rll:!ed it

to me,

'3Q'. 'Beatiijg a ,detainee

0 I p~~soryC!ljy' ~,b~ryed ~h!s~conduct.
~. 0 I-a!;lser,ved det;.ain~~rs) in :a:«;"C:H19 itJol1:th?i~ t~ me to' b~fje.ye lhgt this cQfTdu<:t'haq 'Qq~lJrr:ed.
c~ D. De~a,in~.(s) t91~ :r:ne tnClt thJs: ,t.oru:!:u.c.t hp',d :O,e;;cur:r:~:
,g. 0 Others wl)p. 'ob~etY.ed this, GQng u~t. ~:es'crib~ inl1m~.

·a!

0 I have rele'\lant i(lforf1J~tion r;lassified ~bove 1~S.~t,~".
f. M I, ri~y.¢t'6D5er\ied this:cQnduc.t flQr h~r'd ':abp_ul it f!:q{n'SQIn-eone whq tHd.

'e',

:31. UsIng' w:ater to. preve'nt breathing

by.a 'detarnee<ort.o. cr.eate :tile seosatlbii pfdrownlri:g

.
a. 0 r p,ersonafly oQserved this :<;(?flclu~t.
b', 0 Lobs~rv~ddetq'[nee.<s).lna:conc;rltl.9rrthat led me to believe thaUhis c:ondu,ct, had occurred.
,Co 0 E>e,~aJnee(sHo]~ m~ that this conduct had o:q::urrec!.
d. o IQtne~ whp ob$erv~eJ :tITTs, GQndl1ct des,criQe9 i,t t<t me,
e: 0 t ha)'{e relevant lbfbrmation i;:1!'issitJed 'abOVe' "'$Ec'I:~ET".
1'. 0 t- fieve:r ob~ell(ed' this:co.riduct npr h!'!dl'.d ,abtiu.t'it from so'r'n'e:bn¢ Whq ~ifl,.
"

,32" W;ih9 hands, rape, of'-ahylhirig else

00 \rpersonafly

to thOk~ of strangle a detaihee

observed,this,;coni:luct.

OIGQ-005276

,-

0
c. 0
d. 0
e:. 0
f. 0'
b,

I observed detainee(s) In a condition th at led me to believe that this conduct had 'occurred.

Detainee(s) to'id me 'that this conduct ha d 'occurred.
O~hers w.ho observed this CQIldu9t descri

I haV~ releyant ihformation c1a!?sifled gb oV~. ".SEC~".

I n!=v.er'ob~rve'9 th,is 'cpnd I]Gt nor ,hear51 abqut it frorT! ~meo'lewho did.

33. 'Ttlt.eat~hing other s:lction to c~use

eh:t:sj~al

a.

0- r personally o,bserved thiscondtiet.

b.,

0

[observed detainee(s} In a'condition th at led me to' believe that tllis C0nduct had :occurred.

,c, [J Detalnee(s)'told me that this Gond uct had occu rr.ed.
cf. 0 01hers who Qbser,v~d t~is condu(;t~e~cr il:!e9 it to me.

0 I. ha.Y;~.relevalit rnfor~atjon G!a!?~iti~ !3~
t 0 r n~y~r o~s.er.v.e~L th~$.'c<?np\lpt n9f ,h~.r9

~:

,

'

34. 'Other tr¢atOient qr a~fi9n;cqusing signlfitant phy.siqll p:airi or injury, .Qr !=?iu"~Jrig pisflg\Jtemeii,t or
9.~~,(b...,,,_,_.,,_,.__,~_,. _:_ ...__.~, __.....__
a; 0 I. personal!y,observed this_condu.ct.
. led me to' b~,l.leve tbc;lnni$ copduC;.t )la~ 'occ:;urrec::1.
~" 0 f ob,served. c;I.~t.a.lnee($') 1!1 a .cond \tion th a~
9; 0 bet-ainee(s) tQld me th:~t this QQn9uct ha~ 'occo-rree!.

0
e. 0

cj,

f.

l;Jthef?' ~hQ bq'~erv~d 'tl1i?: 'Ggn~ uC:t Q,~!?!3[ tbeq it to. m~
I.liav~ rele~ant InfQrma}l~n~Jassifjed a~

0' t n!=Ver qJiservep this ·cQnctu.ct hdr heard 'qqouf it frptn.sq,hiebne:w!:ip. did.

.
35. p:rat"iilg. a ri'etainee on a hot sutfat~ of l:iurni "9. .a deta,iriee,

a. 0', I, personally observed' this 'conduct.
b. 0 ~,ob~~rve9.· d~tC!.if.1ee{!,»' il'! :a :c0l'!9J):\on t.tl a~. ied

~~ t9 belie"'~t!lSlt;'thisc::on:du~ had 'G~~urrep:

~. 0 De~C!!nee(s) tr;>ld me tb.a~ th~s t;;On(jw::t h,a.d .Qccu rred .
d, 0 pthers whp o~':?enl~d thiS Ggnd)1<;:t, d.~scr. Ibed it ~o m~!,
. 0... I hav~ rel~yant il)f(;mlJatio:n...da?~ined.. i'l~ ove "SEem";
. ~.......
~

• .. "

¥.~

••••

••

_

•••••••••

_

.w• • • _

,

OIGQ-O052,7?
-.

[!]]Ilr never observed this conduct nor heard about It from someone who dId.

~6. \.}sing -sh9 skles or other' rest ra.i nts

in Ci prolonged manner

0 r per.sonally observed ,this condoct.
0 I obs~rVed . detciinee(s) ill acond itidn th~t led me to belieye that. this conduct had 'occurred.
c. 0 Detainee:(s) told me th-at this condlict nad:o,cturred.
d. 0 Others who .obselited thls ednd ud described it to me.
e. 0- r bave relevant i'nformation Classified 'above "SECRET".
f: ~ I, never ebserved'this:conduct nor heard about It from someone who did,
a.
b.

,37', Requiring, a detain~~'10 m,aintain, 'or restlOirjing a ,detainee (n, a ,stressful 'or paInful po~ition

0 i· p:e:rsOilally ,O:b~erv.et:l ,thls.:cq.n,d,lict.
b. 0 r obse'rYed d:etaine.e(s) in :a ',cbhd itibn that led me t6: beUeve .that this conduct had :occurred'..
c, 0 Defain~(s) told ,me that this conduc,t hild ,occiJrrea.

;a.

'd.

o lQtherS' who observ~d thiS' tend'Uc! described It tb me',

"e:

D

I have releyarit inmrtnation c1assiTied aboye "S'ECRET" .

f. ~ I neV'er 'o.bserv.ea. this 'c6'Mud nor' heard a biut: it fr'om'"someone Wh0 did,

38.

Fqrdn9 a '9~tall)ee to p~rfQf!TI,d~m<;lndrngp,-h-,Y,-s_lc_a_l'e_x~~~~c,"",!..i..~e..:....

_

,a. D I p~r.s6r'1aliy 6pserve:d' this condu.ct.

0e. 0
d. D
e. D
b.

f.
~

0'
"

r observeldetaltiee.(~y In ia cc>ndition that Ii='d me tb beUevi=' that this

ton.du,cr had ,occurred.,

D.etainee(s:) told m~ ihat this c,ond,uet had 'occurr.ed.
OtherS' who observed 'thiS conduct d'escril5~ it
r hatte 'releva'nt'lrfforriiatlbn classified

to me.

~ boye "SECRET",

I........
neVer
obserVed this ,conduct
Iior heara :about it from sori'iebhe:whb did,
., .......
...,.
• ..... A . .

_ .

___ ...........

..,~v_

~~,.

....... _

.-.........,.,_._

. . . . . . ,. ... .,.,..,..

..- .....

;,. _

_

'

.............. _

.............. "' . . . _ _ . . . .

01

..

"

...

~,.

~""-"-

-- ....

:39, Using' ,eleetri,G.'aJ s,hock,0n a Qetalnee

OIGQ-005278

I

I

,

a:

i----

b.
c.

0

'

I personally observed this conduct.

o h,'observed detainee(s) in a'cond itiot) that <I~ me to believe that this c6nduct had occurred.
o iD~~ainee(s) told !'De th,at thi? condLJd: ~ad 'occyrred.

,g, Olathe!'$- vtho 'ot?,served this cqnduct'g:e~qibeq It to me:

D I hav~ relevant information c1assifi¢p ,a,bove, "SEC,RET":.
t: 0' r ne,ver ~b~eryed thi~ ,ton,cfu<;t nor. hE$ni 'abol!t it from.sqrneon~ Whq ,qid.

e.

40. Thr.eatening to use,electrical sh6c\(on a detainee

a:

q

L personally observed thls,conduct.

b. D I 'observer:!' de'talnee(s) In 'a <::ond itlon that led me to belleY'e that this conduct nad ,oclZurred.
e; D 'Detai,nee(s) tqlcj rn~ that this <i:onduct h:ad 'Qc<.;qrred..
q~

e.,

f.

0 Otl:!er-? wh9 'OJ:?ser.ve.d '~{1is cO,nd Clqt d:~s~n~'ed it to Jtle:,
D I h?lve rel~varit I.ofqrrnatlon ~1i;l?,~lfl~ Ab<;>ve, "S'EC~'1 ~
0' !I ll~ver'ob$E!rv¢,~ thjs:<.;onduet n~... h~r~ ,!'iQQutit'frorn sOlTJepJ1e'Whb d,id.

·fu. rntE;intIQhally'delay/n:g '9(den){Jlig :<:i.etajri~e rt'l'edfcal ~are
;

a-·IO

I per-Sen'ally,o.bserVed this·e6ndi1d.

b, [j lI,observed detainee(s) ina cond itlan' that led me to believe that this conduct had ·'Occurred.
€:

O· Detainee(s) tOld me that this conduct had :occurr.ed.

e',

o lathers Who observed tnis cO'lJdU,G!'9,escri~ed it 1:9 me.
o !I have relevant information classified above "SECR:ET"'.

f:

M t

d '.
,

•

•

~.

'

~

•••

..~,

,

".

.,.,

>

•

•

....

'

"~

•••••

•

"

•

never-observed thfs,·coni:lud llOr ,heard 'about it .from ~omeone who did.
..> '

• ':..,

'... ,..

'"

•

~

"

"

,

. . . . . . ',',,'

.. ,

,.

....

: ' "

: 4~. Hp,Qdfrig or blintlfolding a~d~tajhee'Qther ,than ,~uting t@nsP9rtSltlon

a. D
b. 0
c.
q~

I

personally observed this.conduct.

I,observed' de'tainee(s} ill ,a.i:oriditkjn fhatl&! me

to, believe thanlifs'coilduct had .ocdirred.

o petainee(s) told me that this conduct had ,occurred.
o lathers whp opsery~d, this !;:0nqu~t~e~eribed It tp f!le...

~.l 0

I

:

;t ~ave r~Jevant Information classifie<;!'above 1!'$:!=C~Er"'.

OIGQ-005279

[!J I~ql never obse~e~ thl~:con~uct nor heard aboutlt from ~omeone who did.
43. Subjeq:ing a detainee to extremely ~91d or hot'ro9m temperatur~s for emend~ perioc:!s

a. 0
b. 0
G. 0
.d. 0
e. 0
f:

Itf

1 per.sonally ohserved this .conduct.·
I ob~l\fed ·detainee.(s) in a cond ition th'~t
Detaine~:(s)t6Id

led tn~ to believe that this cMr:l!.J\:t hadoc¢uned.

'me that this tonauet li'ad ;occurred.

Otherswhb observed this conduCt described it to me.

I have relevant information classified aboVe "SECRET't,
I never observed this:conduet nor heard ab0utft from.someone who did.

::4.4,.. -Supjecting, a ·det.ainee to 104d music

a:. 0 [: p:erSQJi~lIy .o,brerv.ed thrs::c~n.dHc.t.
b. 0 r:observed'd,etain¢¢(s) in:a '.conctitibn that led 'me. to belieVe thaUi'lis conduct had :occurreiL
c.
d.

0

Detain~(s')

told

me that this co'ndutt had .occDrreCI.

o PthBrS .wno ·o..oser:ved thiS Gond'uct des'ctibed It to me.

.e. 0 t have,relevant ibforini:ition classified c3Doye' "SECRET".
f.

6111 never·observ.ed,this:cehduet n6r'11earCi abciiit it from someone who aid.

'45. Sl.! bjectihg '9 d.etajnee· t9

..a-

O.II pe);s9naliy'6l;l.$erve~r

bri~..:.;.ht.;;..' . :.;.fla;.;.;s,:..:.n;:;;.in.;..g~!....,;;.illg~"r;,;;~s;:..·..::.o,-r ~qa;:;;.r;..:.!<;;.:;n.;;;;.es;;.;s,--

---::--

_

this.conduct.

b:. 0 tobser.vep'.d.et~Hnee.(s).lh ~:cbnditidn that led me to b'ellevethatthis conduct had 'pccurred.
C-.' D !m::tai'nee(s) told me that thiS: cbnd uct ha'd :o.ccurred.

0 Other:5: Who :oo.served ;this i:::6fidud,d'escfiDed 'if to'me.
eo; 0 [ hd\le ....erev~:fnt InformatIon ClassIfied abdve ':SECREf".
t rtf I never observed this,conduct "nor'
heard 'about it from someone "who did.
, - -" ""'.. ...
- ......... --, ,. . _,..¥_ . . ., . .

d,

• _ _ A" •• , ....

"'~-''''

.......

~-

"

--..

_ A ..... · - . . "......

~._._..,

... , . . . "

- - . . . . . . . . . . .,

. . . . . - . ...........................

"

'"

.....

_- .....

- ....

-

4,6', lsoJating-a detafneefo,r an'e~ended period

OIGQ-005280

.
.a'.

D

..

,

...

. ,

I personally observed thls,conduct.

b~ [j Lobserved detainee(s) in ,a'cond ition that led me to believe that this conduct had occurred.

c. D h~~ainee,(s) told me that this'cQndl,ld had ·occurreQ.
,d .. 0 Oth~r'? Who 'ob'$ervElC! this CObdllct 9~~~ribed It, to me.
e; 0 I hav.e refevarit information c1assifi~ ,apove' 11S-ECREfJl,.
i-f: I~r r n~er ()bserved this 'q>n!1tlc:t nor h~r~ 'about it from 'SOmeone who d19.

----

'

__

.

I

.

·47. Uslng.duct tape to restrain, .gag4 or 'PuniSh a detalne'e
'

.q

a-

b,
~.

L personally' observed thiS conduct.
L:observed'detalnee(s) In·a condition that. led meto believe thatthlsaonauct hacLoc~urred.

q
o :pet~l!1ee(s) told rn~ tha~ t,his conduct h~~, ·occ4rred..

0 Others who observed this mtrd uct' d'escribed it to me;,
0 I h'?lve'r~l~va'rit IlJf~rmatIQI)"c1,rs~JfleQ 'l1}9ve "$EC'RET".
f. 0' ~ (1~Y,en~b~ervE;'!,~ this/corid,uct nor heprd~~QQl it from $<;lmeo.n~'W~b di~.

~.~
e.,

a'.
b.

c.

...

A,..,

__

w.

• . . . . ,.,~..

.... '

. ' , , , ' , , . ,

0 I peroonaUy'nbseNed this,conduct.
0 i,observed'detainee{s), in a'c:::ondition that led

me to believ.e that this, c0nduct hadoccurrea.

o tDetainee(s) tdld me that this conduct had ,occurr.ed.

lb~her.s whn observed this coOduc,t-'~~scriqed it- ,to 1']1€;"
e~, o i~ hav~ r~levant !'ntorma,tlo[l ,cJasslfi~g above: "~EC~EJ'I'.
. f. 1tJ' I n~v~r:ob~.erv~g this'cpn~h.JGt 'O'Qr,heejr:d ',apq.ut it ,from -?qmeol'!€ Who eliq..
'd,

o

,4Q'. 0,51ng a: mHitary wQrking 'dtlQ on ,6r n~ar ,a de,t~tinee, o~her thaI) 'durili'g d¢,taln'eenra'nsP9rtcition

a. o II persOnallY observed this co,nduct.

]: 0
c. ci

I,ol)se't¥.ed'delainee(s) in ,a:cond ition 'that led me fo, believe thaftHfs condiict: had ,ocdjrred.
Detalnee(s) told me that thIs-conduct tladoccurred.

d.. 0 Othe~ whG> op:?eryed. ~~is G(),l,ldut;t~escrll:!e~ jt 19 rne.,
~.

0

ll)a~1? rel,evant ll)fgrmation c1as!iifi~ a~ov~ '''S:EC~'''.

.

OIGQ-005281

ItI'

I never observed thIs conduct nor heard about It from someone who did.

50. Threatening tq lise rnlilt.ary· working dQgson or n~ar a detaine~

0
b. 0
c. 0
d. 0
a.

I perSonaHy'observel:( this condi:fct.
I 6bserv"ed,detain~e(sJ. iii ,a <;ond ition thi:lt
Detaine!'=fs) told

led me~ to b~lie..ye that this ~ori.duct had pccurred.

'me that this cona tict had ·occurred.

Others' who .observed tms conduct described it to me.

e.

0- r have relevant information Classified above "SECREfI'.

t:

Itf

L neverobserved this '.conduct nor heard about itfmm someone. who did.

. .sf.. Using

spidersr;sc9rpion~, snakes,. or'other anim~ls on 'or l1e~r a ,detainee

0 . p~et:>9nqllY.:.Qb~rve9 this:q$ndu~t.
,b,. 0 r ohseryed tletain~.e(s) in:a 'j:otidltion th$t led me to believe that this cti'n'du!=t had pccurretL
C. 0 Detailiee(s} told me that this. (:oncl'uct had .occurtea.
a.

d.

o tothers: who 'Qbserved this conduct t1estribed It to'me:

e:

0

t 0

r have relevant iomrmation crlassifiea

ab0~ '~SE.CREJ".

1 neverobserv.ed. this 'c0ncfuet nor' heard '8 f:kiut. it from ,sOmeone. who· clid.

52", Threatenin9 to ~se $plc;fers,'scorpjon$, 'SnaKes, ()roth,~r -aIJlm~ls 9n ·a, ~eta:if"!ee

a. 0 r p~r.s6naliy QJfserve:cf tl1is cond,uc!.
b. 0 l' .ob'serv:e:d. d.etalri~e(s): In ·a :cdnd itldn that led me to, believe- that this' tond uct' Mq
Ie. 0 Detainee(s) told me that thiS: condlfct ha'd 'o,ccurr.ed.
tI. 0 o.therS: who 'ob,$'eiVed this' concl'u.d de~"dilje<l itlci m.e.
e: 0 I have releva'nt Ihformatlon classified abo.lie "SECREr".

_.f; -g.

()c(:urr~d,

r never-observed
this,conduct
nor'heara
-about it from
someone-who
did.
.
___''"_.__,,
________.....".
_v. '''___
. _ . __ ,____
____.•
./1",;_, .•..- ..~

~.

¥

~.

M' . , _ . _

........

'53'. Dlsr.espectful statemel1ts; handling, :or.actions

invo!ving~t;:,;.;h:.;:e..:.K.:.;·o;.:.ra;;;,;n~

_

OIGQ-005282

.
'a~

D

..

.

I personally observed thls..conduct.

b. [j I observed detainee(s) in a'cond ition that led 'me to believe that this conduct had 'occurred.
c.
~.
~.

D
D
D

D~~ainee(s) tolp !"fie that thi?,condljet h,ad ·occ~r.red:
bthe~ who 'ob'~rved this condu.ct.Qes~,riped It to me.

I have reievant information dassifiep a.bove "SEC.REP'.

_.

f. I~r rn~ver ~Q.seryed. this .ton.duc:;t ndr heard 'ab()ut it from'sqmeone Wh9 4id.

54. 'ShaVln,ga. detaln~'s; facial or other tial;l,o embarrass.or humiliate' a .dt;:!tCllnee
8'.

q

L personallY obserVed this'conduct.

Cl Lobserved detalnee(s) In a Gond ition-that led me to belle.ve that this Gonduct had occurred.
c. D. pet<;ti.pee(sj.told mE; that this ~OndUl;:t ni:ld 9ccl)rred.~
C!!- D otlJerp w!l9 obsery~d t~is ~o.rrd.q~~ d~s.cr!b~ it.to me.;
e.. D r h?lV~He~varit 1I)f~rm~~lon ·~lcrs.sJfl~ ?JP<;lVe "'$-EC·RE1""·.
b.

n~'l:erGP?er.\(~.d: tbis.'C:;Qnd.u~t 1).91: heprd ~aoQl:lt it frorn'?ome(;:l}le'Whb

l

011

a'.

D 1 persbriany o.bserVed

qi9.

fhls·eondud.

b. [j I observed'detainee(s) In a'condition that led me to believe that this conduct had oc(;;urred.
c. D IDetainee(s) tOld me that this conduct had :occurred.

D lathers wno obserY~d ·thi? cooduqt describ.ed i~ to r:n.~.
D ~ haverelev~nt !nforma~\Q[r cIassi.fi~g above II,S.EQRW'I':
f. !tI. I n!=v.er·ob?e~~.g' thts 'C!;!}1~ u<;t 'll<?r .h~rp 'ab,Qut. il: :fn;llD .'?9rneone: w~o

<J '.

e.·

qid.

5.6. T6.ul:;.!iinQ, -a deti'llne¢ qr actiffg toward.a'.detafnee in ~ t'~·U.aI -m'anner
a. D r personallY, ebserved t1lis_colidlkt.
I
h. D [·obserVed delainee(s} iria·.c6nd itioh-fhat led me to believe- thilFtt1rs conduct. Mad .oc.cuf.red..
. c. [j Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had occurred •

q: D
~.

D

b~hers who Dbsei:v~ 't.~is m;:mQuct~~t;:riqe9 11: to

r:ne:

r \:1av:~ relevant iIJfgrmatipn c1a:ssifiec! al?o.ve I!S:EC~'\

OIGQ-005283

~I never observed this conduct nor heard about It from someone who did.

57. JI<;>lq Lng d~t9in~(~). vyhb ~erie opt 9fficia,IIY':qc~J:lQwledg~d or reg ister~d q~ ~(Jch by tlle ,ag~n<;y
Jlej:al,ning th~ p~rson.
a.

0 r persOnalty obserVed

b.

p

Lobsetved ,detalnee(s) In :a,co,hd Itlon that led, me to believe that this' eonduct had 'occurred.

G.

0
0
0

Detainee(s),told me that this; conduct had :occurred.

d.
c-'e.

this ,conduct.

Others who observed this conduct described

it to me.

I hew,e re!evapt information t:;:lassiJj(;c! <;J~ove "'S'~CRETJI·.

f. 61 I, never ,~bsel\!eq this 'GOl)d,uct nor hei:\rd ia b9l!,t it from sOlT].e,~n~

~,fio'

d I~.

,~a. $~nding a..detaitl~ t~' pnotner coun~ry 'fqr mbre:aggressiv~'irit~n:ogati~m
'-"---'---'---'-'-"-....._~----------

D I persOhally,obselv:ed this con'auct.
b. 0 ~ observed 'detaihee(s) in a ,conCl ition that lea :me to, believe that this Gbnduct had .bciiu'rred;

'a.

c. 61 IDefaihee(s) tbld me thcitthis conduct had ,occurre:L
d. 0 Others who observed thiS condl:Jctdescrfbed it to' me.
,e., D I, have relevant inf0rmatfon classified -above 1!S,ECREfIl'.
f. 0, f !1~~er'O'~,~rve,d tbl,~ 'mndlJct no.r h~rd a ~OUt It ,fro~ somepne'wh()' dId.

'Q..

Pte9,S~ prov[qe t.he aPP[m(.iPJat~ tJrn.~Trfime durfng'Whiq~ thJs;cond~~t,o~C\.lrreg.,

Fr:om' 03/04)200210 03io,al20,02:
n. the deta'j,ri~~(:s):tr~~e~ In t!'lIS w<aY wer~ l()~?lt~ ,at the time Jp;,
l, D Gu~n~an.amo
~

',DDtiNot Recall

P Jic!q

3 '0 Afgnahistan
4 D other Locatioh
5 D D(j.Not Reca'1I
b2 Per DOD

b6
b7C

.i: Ple'qse identify the- p~rS6ri(s)' who treated the deta,inee.(s)
narrie(s~ a'nd governmeiit,age'ncy(ies)::

in th,is- mariner, ihJ~iud.ih~ t!ieir
"
'

OIGQ-005284

Detainee told me he. had pre\liously,been detained ,by' Jordanians. He.said tie had been'yelled at
but nothing, further had occurred.

I

k. Ptease Itlentify,anv. 'Qth'er FBI personnel o'r non-FBI personn'el who observed detainee(s) treated
"
).is Army'w.as 'alsO in intel'Yi~~'qnd translating in ~4ssiC!h

in this manner: incluOing their name(s) and agency{ies):

b6
b7C

I. This cdndu,ct bcturted in ,tonri¢ctiorr with:
i 0 One' detain~
20 several detaln~ (2-4}
3 ,0 Many detainees Jmore than 21-)
4 :0, Do Not Recall

tn. (.Optional). Please'describelhe.r'elevant Circumstances in more.defail:

'The,~'~taih~ Ii~J~d .a;b.Q~~ told th~:,ilit~rvl~w~~s, ,(m.Y~\f:a.ri4

that he, h~d
pr.eVlously'mterv.tewed/mterrogated by tlie,Jqrd.amans p.~lor to b~mg 'sent to' Afg hahlstan. The,
'detainee said thaUhe Jordanian Interrogators had yelled at him but done.. nothing, further,

'59. Thre.atenfng

~S' ~tm~~

b6
b7C

to ,seno a detainee to anQth,~r cpuntry' for d'eteritroh. br,more.agg<resslve Interrogation

-~

a.•
b.,

0 I personalJY q-bserve,d' Ws 'condl!Gt~

o

I c;>b~erveq qetainet::!(s) In <;l.'c9ndlti0!1',!.~)::2:~_~e.!?~~lev~ ~~a~J2~_~o~'du~~lJi3d ~:?~rret;l:,

c; ,0, 'Q~tainee(sltQld m¢ thfjt thiS tond,u~t bap ~occurred;
d: 0 'Others' Wh~ 'obseryel;l ;this pOlJdud: de$C'ribe,9 it to me;
$..

0 r have relevant informatio,n' ~ia$:sffigd flQ'pye, i"S'I:.CRET"'.

.-

f. 0' !I' neyer dbserv.ecf this:conBuc.t n'ot',hie6td aboul it .from SOmeoh,e. Who dJd.

,GU. Threatening to take action. agc;.;Cl.:.:.in;.:;.s.; . t.:.;,a. .;:,Q;.; e.; ;ta;.;.;.in:.;.;e; ;.;'e:. ;'s:. ;t';.;;;;;l.;;;m.:.;,i""IY_'

a; 0
b.

P

,c;

0

t: per~,nanY'9h~rve'l;l

_

this
. condu<::t,
'

IqbserVe.9 ·d~t~in,~e(s) in ::r qmd it,ibn t,hat jed ,me to ~eli,ey~ th~~ thi$ CQl)'du,qr. hpd :(j<;:<;:urred.
8et<;line~(~) !oJd me thqt t~js:,"ond4ct had 'q-q:(jrreq,:

g, 0

Others-who :obs.er.ved this: c:OJi~uc;;t des,C'rfbed it,tqme;
0 I.h'ave relevant jnf9rm.a~io,O ~1~SsifiM :a~6v.~, '~5j:¢REr"~.
t: 0 L n:ever 9b;;~.rved this,cQn~uct np'r·h~rQ.'abpl,!,t it trom'?oIT1e~J1e wii~-l;Ild.

e:,

.61. ',other treatment

or action ,<::aiising severe emotional ,or psy.chological trauma to a 'detainee.

OIGQ-005285

"

.

a- D 1. p~rsonaIlY'Qbserved this ~on<:luct.
b. 0 t -observed detain~e(s) in a con~_~iein' that ied 1'Jl~ to I,)el!ey~ thpUJ:tis <;ol)dl;le.t had oc;<;urretj.

-

0 Detainee(s)'toI9 m:e that :thl~ C"on~u~t had occl,lrreP.
g~ 0 OtberS' whQ pb.s,eIYed :t.his, cPJi~uGt ~esc:ribed it tq me,.
e. 0 I ,hav$. re(e~~nt ihf«;>rm'atioh' class!fi¢.d ~bove "SEC.RET".
f. Itt I, n:ever ob~rve4 ~hls ,condu~t n9r'h$rd abtlu.t ldrom SOrrle~.ne:whd
~;,

i

,

.' .

Qtd.

,

.a2. ·~lther

religious-:Gr-sexl.J'al harassment or

hUniiliation'.ofa~detainee

0 r, p~r~lJalJy- qb~rveg. \hi,s CQDduc,t.
p, 0 ['op"5erv~t! ~,e,t.alnee(st in ~a 'cc;md itJo,n ·that·le<l me t<;> b~nev~
'c: 0 D~~aj.IJe(;f(s) tpld..me th~.t. th,is,c9hd.u,¢t hi;ld ·q:C;C;:\Jn:eq •.
~. 0 6th~rs wbp .cjb:$ety~9 -thi$.l=qn~hict d.estrib¢d it tQ' n1!=!":
a.

e:

D

r: ~a~.e rel~:v~nt infQrrn~~JolJ

th~t'tj11$. CQn..dlfc~· 'h,ad 'Q~qurre~.:

,

r;:la'5,sifi~i Qb.o,V"e', "SEORET "'.

f. 0 I ri'?ver obSer\!ed thi$'c6J1cru¢t rYor'h$~d 'abbL!t it frpm sQlTf~9n~'Whq did.

,:63. Other't'reatmel1t of a' C1etaiAee .that in your. ojjihiofrwas: uO"I>rofesslbncilr unduly harsh .0J ~~Q resshre,t
.coercive,.abusive/, or unlawful"
"

a'. 0 1 pet-sqoa'l1y,observed tl)is t:onauct.

0 t ol?~rv.~d get~tne~.ts) i!i;a 'q),ng it\,?!) th~t I~~ I'D¢; 1'9' ~e\jeye that ,this ¢ond!Jt;~
'0
c:
o:etaine:e($) told· me t.ha.t thl~;t;.1;:1I1ciutt: hi;l"d ·Q,ccu[r~.
d., 0 Qthers: wh'O obser.ve.d this to.nduct d.es.dibed It to, tne.
~.

h~'~

·o<;qurrep.,

iriforrfiation i:;ias.sifiecl 'ab'ov.e "SECRET"'.
¢. 0 r h;:(ve relevant
.
..
.
f.

0 I neVer.obseiV.ed thls,oontllict lior'heai'd abOut It fron1$Omeorie"whO' did.
:

_Wt"MJlt,~@l~~:''- :~.;." .'~':~J -.; :':~.

"i> ,'" ......,'

-;·--it

·64.· Did you observ-8,ani1mpersonatib"n of FBI personnel.by anyohe during an interJlew·or'inte'rrogation of
a: cf~tainee?'
'0 Yes: .0 No
6~._ Did ,a,ny' ~~tairle~ or _o~her person t~n -you th~t ..~e.or sh~ h.a~ w.i~ne,ss~ .the 'il}lp,~r-?Onat!on :of FBI.

~

OIGQ-005286

persq!1nelln connec):!on with a'detainee interview pr

o Yes:.

~66.

Int~rrog~tlon?

0 No-.

-Are you aware of ah'i"~sham" or ·staged" detainee: interviews or interrogations conducted for Members

ofthe us; :Congress or their staff?:

o Yes

.,

'0 No

67. TO. your kflQwtedge, did ·~mY'mll.it~Hy or :irtteIli9~nGe persoonel eVer deny or delay ,fBI access: to a
detainee the FBI wanted to question because the detainee had sustained injuries after he was captured?

,

.6B~

"DVes

·0No.

.

Did you ever :end your pa'rticipati6ri in :6r bbs.erVation of a ·O~tain.ee. intery.ie:w~ or intertq~atibr'i
because Qfthe.: interVieW·or· interrogation methods. ceilig, used1

.b9"/Were, you eVE:!rto!c! .t11~.t'aQother.FBI

'0. Ye.s: :0

No

.em.ploy~e:-e.TJ.qed

hIs :or. ~er .pa.rtic;ip~tlon hor :d.bservCl,t!9F1 ofi'?l
!i~.t9inee: inte:rvi~Vj 21" !nterrQg9.t.!Qn. Rec;~c.'.!?e ·Qft.~~ i!1tervi~'qr'infe.rrogati911IJ1.efhog~; p&,ing yseQ?'

o '{gp'

0 N9'

70'. Du'ring any of your,overseas deployments .of assilinmen'tqi. did you -report any'eoricerns· regarding
a,ny' :de!ajn.~..JO~~rYl~W·9r'Jn~~rr~gat(of1 p:~~t!c;esi '<?r :o,th~F type§ .~~ 9¢ta!n~·.t~~atmen~j to ~I)' F~I
.s.~p~~~s!Jr?

:Q y~,~ :G>. ~o'
71. D.Ur:iA~ any .of~our p.verseas..depJo¥menfs OJ ass.i9nr:ne·nt'sr di9 YOil report ai')y-'.coi:k:erils le·g.ard.ing
any deta inee'interview or inter-rogation pra<rtices or .othertypes of'deta'Jnea treatment .You
o.b·?~rved 9r h~~rq .?l.90Ut,. tp'a ,non~FB~.~~pery:i~~n~roth'E;lr llon;'FBlp~rs9nn~l?
G) '(e's: ;0 NO'
72~ H.~ye yoq ~eve( b~5;ti praere~r Qr,'d.ir~tte~t nbn9 r.eport:, o:r:dis¢ur~g:ed.

in Ci.h.y·way fmhl rep·orting.!:

obsetvations ,or allegations related:to detarriee.'treatmeht or fnterview or I'nterrqgatioh actiOns 'Or'
~~
.

0"Yes
·0 No
gxperi¢p~ed i3,ni/-acflJalpr thr~alet\~d ret~li~tron fQr rep,Qlj;ing .gQsj:rvatigns· Of :ait~g~tl()n$
,of detaineeJtecitment or. fnterii'jew or roterrog.~tiori:actions or: pJ:a:ctilies?

73, H,~ve.ygl.j

Q Yes:' ·0·l'Jo

74. (Q'ption'csJ) Plea-:se, p.rovic;l¢ any .additional ~6mments regarping t~~ rep.ortlng :9.f c:;oncerns related' .1;0'
iht$riJi~w or irire'rro~fati6h~~.hliiql,lE3.S,. detehtfori pr:aGt.ic~~, p.r~ot:h:e( d,etci ir:i~~ 'trea.tm~nt. Th~ ,Ag:ent
wIth .m.e. during' thiS: deploymehqSAI
b: ifiform.edthe.supervlsor c::=JLNU {Retired
J

b6
b7C

Mjlitary, cfvUi~.n C9[lt.@ctor)J over~eern:~ ~et~ineE!!' in~ervieV!? ft1at t~e ,FBI ~'(qylp' .not pa.rljtiRa,~e 10
praetlc;e'S beyqnd norroal int~'N(ewlng/lnterrqga1.1ng technlq!Je5\

OIGQ-005287

75. Wer.e you debriefed, other. than the standard debrief in FD-?72., c.otJcernil1g, you,r overseas
or .deployment(-$) after you c9m.p!ete~ the deploymerit(s) pr as.sig nmerit(~)?

asslgnmen~(s)

o.Ves

'0· No

.76. Additional CQmm'ents:and Re,commendatIQns.;
.! have provided (on several occasions) cQmments,as·to whether we observed detainee abuse,

01GQ-005288