Depar~ment'of J~s.tic.e In~pec~Qr GenerCJI ~Qu~s,ti~nn~ire Re9.ar.ding Det~in.ees
Jj.QJ.-OIG INVESTIGATIV.E QUESTIONNAIRE
FO.R: REVIEWAtoUi USE dNLY BY-INDIVIDUAL FBI ItESPONDENTS

... ' .

DO NOT FORWARD· OR Dis.sEM·i~ATE '

. ,.

QUESTIONNAIRE IP: teSt-O.0001~9.~·

·As·at 1=""~ I~,st time thi.s,q~~.~iqnnair~.w~s !:!a\(~~j' ~ome require.d f.ieI4s: !l~Vj3:n9t
Pleas~',r.e:View

your responses.

I. "
. _.;.. ..,'
',,:,5 :~';. ,"'~"
.",~.",

.;c.•;::,'.

A.

".:'

~

~e~n,cQmpl~~ed.

.,

;";,, '.,

P'~rson~IInfprm~ti()n

Please provide; the following' information:
1. Fi(!1r liqme.
i, Mldp)e In!tfpf:
'3i Last name:.
4,. Eritered oh nuty Date (EOD):
:~: cur.r.ent DivlsiQnlfield Qffice:
6. 9.!XTel)t Jpb- ~i.t1e;·
'J. Direct,dial bffice.lelephone humber:
'8• .FBI t~1I phOrie' numl5¢r:
.~~, fBI ppger nutntierf
roo 'Be~~ c:Qotaet nur,n~er fOfY0U';

9 ~:r¢ PERAqREEJ¥1!=N.T
·68,.7C.P.ERAGREEMENT
6 &, 7.C PERAGREEMENT
6 & 7C
~:8. ic
$ped~1 Agent
6& rc.PERAG.REEMEN.T
~ ~. 76 PER'/\Gfu=EM.!E,NT
'6 '79.PE.RAG~E.EJV!!=Nr~
'6 & 'lC PE~AGREEN1ENt

*'

B. B:ackg·tou'nd of Speciffc D,eplo-yme'nts or Assignntents

1-1. At any time ciItB[~Septeli,.lfer1J"t 20.01, did you 'Serve.as·a member of tlie U.S. Military, or as 'an
'employee.or contractor of- the. FBtor any other g'overnment agency., at Guantanamo Bay( Cuba; Iraq;

:

:Afg'hQ.I.li.sts!!1; 'or'ih areq~ ·controll~by·the \J:S. ,Militqry or,q U.S. int~lIige[l~~' ser¥.ice in':~qnne,ctjQn wit~ ~he·
:9 i9pal w.~r on !~rrpl?
.
,
@·Yes 0 No:
12:. l:nter the number of tim.e:s you. w.er.e;.d~piQyed orassig ned to ~ach' -pfthe,foh6.Wing 16tati.ons,
,(Guantananio Bay~ Cuba;. Iraq ;;A~9hanistanr.or in :any, areas- controlled by'fhe. U:S. Military or a u.s.
'intelljgenc;:e s«;::rVi!:~J.;~~
. ,
For.~~th deplo\iment or assignment .complefe·the"following section•.
LocatIon (s'~lect one)'

r""....

«....

.~r~~Jli~t~~~

... ..

.'

DepJpyrri~.n1:Qr ll~~ignrrifirit'bel'J!ln' $iiJ"o(DepJ~.Yrii~l1t 9r~55ignr:n~nt~,~,de!l
abo.~t.

.or ab.out,
.

on.

12/01j20JH
01105/2001
i~~l. What wa~ the~9¢n:er;a'l natur'~ cjM p:l,Irp·q~~. qf'Y.QUr:assigri.rnenta'hq 'a1=tryft!~~?
Pro·Cess·;and int.ervieW;detainees that were bro!J~ ht 10' K~mdalia r ,Airpott.
ttb. Please provide, the' names of the.specific<camps)<. basesr or facilities where you 'Worked.
~~n~.a·~ar Ai(pprt; KatJ,l.!I'a[ldShe,bregha9
,
.._.
.,_."
".......,
12~. NQJ:~: If infp'rrn~Jion'~bpu~ a ;srie.cifj~ ',camp, ba.se,. ()r 'fac:il itV" i$da:ssifi!=d :aJ:j9.v~ SEeRET,
plea~ ch:ecK: her~ Dr include in YOljr :ansWer that Y-!:>U' have ll~ddit.iQnal·in(Qrmaiidh tl.assified ·apoYe
··SECRETr.'~· and,: if Y.OU koow( 'iB.entifY'the,dassification lev.el, :tiCket, ;c0mpatfment~ program, :.orotber

d~igna1ion .th.~t.ap'~·II~s ~9·t~ejn~ormatlol) •. po not 11"!9,1l:lde the-add.itlonafclass(fied fn(orm.atf9.n Irryour

OIGQ-005289

qu-estionnaire re~sponses:. bIG personnel with -the, n:ec:essary clearance)NUI qmtact you tq,ret~jve it.
~an:te

Positio~

b6
b7C

'=D~id-:--YO-_,U-J~·.!fntIYint~ryiew~t- iili~rro~~te~any ~~~airi~~~~~-h~~~I ~~;;n~1i ------- --'- --- ~.-:

a

L....r-::"::2:":"'¢-.

: '

·~i2f. Did You}~ihtIY
iFE31 personnel?

plan:any

0

Yes ,
0 Nq
~ ~t~in~ i;t~';ieW7 or-l~t~rrb~~tion ~st~tegY;6bjectii~

,
ta-cti~s-

or

:

with ~;ri- -.;
I

' : . 0 Yes
~ No·
:
::t2g.)Ji~r~;YQ4 ~yer-Qthi~j~ inVdlv~ jrJ J~rn¢~ interY(ew~ ~r intirtog~,ti9n$ -witlJ-~ci.I1:FBI -g€r.s~nnai =,
,Oy~?
~ N'9
~:

-

--)--.., ---'- ----

-

L~~a~io-;; r-'~:,
.
\,5e e
o.ne,

D;pj"o~;nf;r~Q;sJg-;;;;nt b~;;';n:o;' --PepioY;;n£
about
or.abo.ut,

j~iQ~nI~tjiB

;r-;;,i!!-;;;;nt;.nd;i1-o~ -- .

i

:

11101/2:002

01/10/20'0.3;
12a., What:Was the general nafu're arid purpose Ofyolirassignmenland .adivities?
Process 'C.md Interview de~fn~e~, ~t7~he $he~reg.h:an p'rison ~b<;lt·W'!lS l,!.nqet <;Jenera! bQstornt~ cPJTI,mCll)d
12p. ple9~e'Rtl5yid~'th~ nam¢S of the~spe.dfi¢.'c,;~mp:s, .bases!
~~i1.iti¢s wh~r~ yo,u Wof~ep.
Shebr.eghail 'and also Kabul
.
12c. Note: If rnforrfiation about a ,specific-"camp', 'base, or facility is .classifieda!Jove 'SECRET,
p.lease.che.ok: here D( inclUde' in your 'answer th~t you baye "a'dditiona.l irifor;n'1cltion ,dassified ,ab6ve
'§EGRET/'" <;I.Dd, \f YQU. I:<now, .Jqen~lfy~h~,c1i?~sifJ<;a.tiqn. [e.v~.I, tlcket1 Ggmp?lrtmE?nt~ prQ9ram,,~oP'Qth~r
tleslgn~tlQri Jf)a,t~ajipJie'$ to the: inf<;5rrn'aticH1. Do riot 'include the.:~dditjQnal dassffieil inforrnatio.n ifi'lout
cfuestipnriaire'tesp6'n'ses; OIG personnel v'lith the' necessary, clearance W.iII contact y.ou to receive it.

or

n,

,!_..- ':""- -,- - -- - --~ --- ---- -- --- - --- --.-.-- - . . . -- ...,--- .... -,.. . - -- --,- - - - - - - -- - ~--- ----- -"\'I.

~~!!·!lE;~~let.e~titr{,;~¥'~~~,~~~'!.~~Slt.!9ll~~JI!~~,!\~,JJ1~!I3rQ:~~C2rr.n~lt2_~h_9.-rllYQ.u_qrre~!ly!ey.9!!~q.
,~d~ri,;g,
Y9!Jr deploYm:elJt;or,~ss.ignment.:
'
~ - ~ - .........-. -- -; - - -.- - - - - - - .... -'"':-'

~

-- -

,P.osition

~j""oint~i~t~iViewQr- inie~.:Qi~fu,~a~,Y d~taj~e~~~~9~~~~~f~{rs~p~~?- -.- --,-'- ~ -~ _._----:
IL_._.
,

._.

~

__._.

Q
y~?
._.__.

'$ 'N~:r

"

b6
b7C

,I

._~--_-_--.-----~-----I

:12f. Did yoil.jo'intIY' plan any d,i:tainee iriteNjeVt/' or·interrog.a,tion :strnteqYi. o.bj~tiv·es, or'tactics Wtth non- ~
iF131 per.sor'llieI7
,I
I
r'\
t;;>;;
1
!
V Yes
.~ No,
)

,~j:2g~. -W;';~:Y~~ ~~~r:-othi~fs~ jnvQfv~ Tn~ J;t~i~~~;jnttirvi~Ws ~r'i~t;rrog~tjpn~ wlth~~o-O=fBI
'~
a Yes
@ No'
A - - - - -.- - - --- - -.-.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.- - - -

~

-personoel7'-;'
:

- - -.- - ':"'""- - - - - - -.- -,- -.- - -.- - - - - - - .

.L'

:~ .. '/~.':{~':
-

'. :;.~. '''''\''

IA. Training

.
~-

••

~

.

:.-;:

' , '• • : I

to'
'.

~

.'::: ..
." ••

~ ~

-:

~••

'l.

Prior 'to Overseas D.eployment or Assigilmeilt

1;3.~· I;>id YQU T~$jve ~ny·training, ir)struJ:.tiqn, or g!1igi:3'nce 'specll'ica](y in'p(¢p~ratipn (or ~ny'of 'i9U~

OY.etseas deployrnents Qr q~{si.gnmentS?

0Do Not Re~<:iil

OIGQ-005290

14. In preparation- for any,of'your overseas deployments or assignm~nts, did you receive any,training,
I

i·

instruc;:!:fon, or guklance ~nc,emlng the,stanqards of condl-lcr applfca1?le to ~he,tr~tment,
intervi¢W, or iriJer,rogatlQn of detaihe~s by 'FaI perso:nn~l?

G)Yes

0Nb'

:ODo. ,Ncit Recalr

15. In pr.eparation for any of your overs~s.~eploYrnerts or a?~ignlJlentsr d(d you receive any t~inIng./
Ih~ruct:lpn, br'gufdc:mce <pli~etnfng lb~,$tandards,of,cohqU,ct applitabfe'to the trea~m~n.t,
IhtervieW" or irit¢r.rdgati9h'Qf'detaine~~y ,IiQn-FBI p'ersonilel?

eNo

00'0' Not Retail

i~,~ tn. p,rep,aration for allY of Y..o.u r ov~r~~~ deP:loy,m~ts' 91' Clss'ignm¢l)gvd id you re~ejye.~ny' trn.ini ng" ,
in~trlJeti6n, or ,guJdahte cQiicerii'irfg 'what ,ypu Wer.e s.IlPP:OSed .to: dQ if~QLi pbs~hteQ or h~td :flDbut
the'treatment, .intervieWi' or ihterrQgation:bf detajnees by: FBI p'ersbrioel, 'wtiicn you 'believed,to,
be inapp'n:iprfatel, unprofessfonal~ coercive(,a'busfve~ or'unlaWful?'
-

:0'00 Not Recall
17.. ti,. prep;;H?\t;Jprd'or any'qfYQur ,o~ersea$'C1epIQyrtiet:lt~:,or ,as~ignrhe.llt~, 'did '{ou r:ece'v.e,'~ny..trainjng, ,
in'sfruCtion,'or'99idance :coliteniirig 1I\I:ltat ,:y:ou'weresupp'osed to do ifyou 6b.serv,ei:l ,.6'r he~rd 'a.bout' ;
the'treatmentr 'intel\liew~, or interrogation"of detainees by' non,.FBI personnel; which you believed·
to p~ It;I!3 pproprlat~1 unprofessionaL, 'coer,clve, ~bu,slv~; or u.nl.awfu.l?

:0Nc)'
B. 'Training. During, .overseas bepioyments or'Assi:gnments

i!3'" Dl,!riTm ~I1Y 9 f 'YO[1r qverseps d~ploYTJ1ent$ Of assig.nmeT]ts( dla YQU r~cei.ve a.ny trpin.i!').g, h.15tr!:lq:igni,
Qf ~iJ.i4.9nl<:e~cQI)~~rning the stal:t~t~rd~

qf ~c>nd_uct·appl!t:aI:He' to th:e·tre~tmehtJ]nt~rview, Qr

interrA~atiQn ¢If detain!=~s. by FBI pe'tsl:mn~17

'~No

t,!t D\Jli~g pny 'Of Y0!:l.["oversea,~cQepll?,yments or a!?sjg,nrnent~; d!Q 'YQu r~C:,elve ?ll1y't~'rnflJg', !n~tru~tI9n,
Qt'g),ljqance..cQi)Geto'i,n:g 'th~ ,st~.ndard~ pf cpn,auo; :a~JjIiQable: ~~:'tli¢..tr.~thie'l'lt, int~rYi~" 9T
Interro,gatlon of detainee.$', by n()n-F.BI p,~rsOnriel?'
:Qyes,
'2.0.. iDurlng.-any .~f YQl;Jr Pv~r~gs,depl()ym.e!1ts pr' assjg nmel'),ts, did you recelv~ Q,ny tr:a fnlng J. I n?tn.lc~IOIi,
9nIUid,qh.c¢-<;:oncet'.ri''iri,g wh~tY9,l) w~r:e ,s,t.rp-pos,~ t9: ,db if YQu . QbserY:e.d ,Q.r h¢ara 9PQUt' th~:
treatm:ent!'iriterviewr or h'iterr.6,g.atioi'(bf.detaih'ees. by F.BI personni:!l:rwhich you belieVed to be'
inappropriate, unprofessional,'coercive, abusive, or unlawful?

0Ne'

,bDo 'filet ReGaJl

OIGQ-005291

2·1. During any of your overseas deployments or assig nments', did you receive any training~ instruction L
~or'guldance concerning what you were .suPposed to do if YPu'observet;l or heard ,about the'
-tr.eatment, inteNie.w,. or 'interrdgation of ~,etail)ees by n9h-FBI perS()nn:eI, which yoj..l'b:elieved to
b:e Inappr6ptlat~, unp:rbfesl;ional, c;oetclve"a.b!lsiv~, or' u,nlaWful?:Qyes

'0No-

'000 NotReccill

I~. Adequacy of Training
;2:4.lny,?ur·opinio,ri, 'dj~ YOlJ reeeiye ac;l~quC!te tr~.iniJlgJ in$l::ruc;tioQ,'~r.9uic;lance rel<;l~,ing, ~o'sta,ndard?
,of cqO?!\.ltt byF~I,and nqn-FBI perspnnel relating to trea:tlnentj interview; or interrogation of
,detainees. pripr your-deployment or a:ssi~nme/J't?

to

... _ _ -.

.....

..:. .

'

-

-. w

o Yes

-.l _

......

_

0

No

._-.... _ _ .,,;:, '

'

'

..

_

......

_

...

'__

;.r __ -

-_. _ _ •

2;1a,. Please c;I~qibe th~ wq,ys"i,n which )/0,U, b~Ii,eve the ~ra!nil1g; in~fnJc;:ti0n'orguiqC!n~~'¥,Ja$
il!adequ C j - r e : ,
,
..',
'
'
I neYE;:( r'~ce!Ved,:any' fraii'!lng -or ,91,1 ic;la'Ji¢¢. The goly gu)qance ~e r~eilieQ ,during rtiyfjr~t dep.l~ym¢n~
was, that detainees_ at:Karidahar Airport, were tb be 'advised cif their LJ~S, C6ristitutlo'nal. Rig hts- (Mirandcib 6
warnlngs),.whlch I thoug ht was absolutely, rid reu IOU~
~he -team 'leader 8QreecJ with me,
b 7c
bL!t ~be heqqqUq_rt~rs:p~rsQnn~l-an~ tbe:tW9 ~ew'Y0rk a~.ent~-W!th·l.ls.thoug.~t we;shou.l~ ~~v{se·them
o.rU~s.- ¢Q'nsti,lUtiQnal 8,lgllts. Wh~n.r 'O!,jt bTlef~ Dlrectqf Mu~lI~r h~ !Nas unaWqO;~ t1i~t w~:wer~
.advising detainee's of iltheif" Miranda ,warnings. He 'said 'we shbuldhCiV¢, been iF! OIi ail interviews,. TIJe:
FBI. Was, ndt'a 'partdfthese",critical interViews- just after'g/l1 bedaUse Militafy 'Intelligence"did hot W~nt'
us advising someone and then they invoke and any' time. sensitive information they- mIg ht lrc!ve would
. _~e .Io~t.· '. ,'".,_,
.... _ ....
~.
A,

...

_ , . . . . .

,.

_

'

. .,

•

•

••

•

••

,_

...

_

•

__

..

'

",

_,

,

, ....

23:, In your·opinion/,did y'0u receIv.e adequate training I instruction,..,or gUidance relating. to:standard's
9f cond~!=t py'FBI and f).on:-F,~I perS0nnel rela~irJ9 to tr~tmentf 'interview, qr interr()g atjgn 'of
:9~t.qrnees);IW)ii.9 YQUr d~pIQym~nrQ:r~s~l~ hm~hp
_____

...

.......

_)wO

~_.""

_ - ....

_

...

~ Np

:O'Yes

'looI_,

,'_", _-.... _- .... ' _ _•

-

"'"' _

' _ ' ' - _ '_ _.... ,_ -'" _ _ -<: _ _

-t

-< _,

2'3a. pfease desGribe>thewc\ys'ln which you believe the training, instruction'or ,gUidance -was
Inad~quate:
'
...S.ee-:2Za.
_ , _ ., '" ..." . . . . . _ 0"" .... _
w

_

., -

_

•

-

-..

-

~

..... _

''', _ _

...

........

.._......

.....

~

_

....

_

..........

__ • __

....

,~

_

----I;

,

............. '-

_

...

•

24.10 y'!)ur~pin{orJ,.'gld:

YOl) r~_eiye ·a.de.qtJ?)t~ training,. instr.uGti9nr,or·gui~:qIiCe,ccmGeroing wh.at V9!J '
w.er!=, ;SQ,PPQS:~, ~<?,d~ jfY6.4. 'pl:l~erV~ ~t he~rdahblJt the ueaj:li1elij:, int¢rvi¢W, 'or In~~rrQg~tlp'n' of :detainee~:, DY: FBI.or: lion-FBI ,pe'fsannel,:tliat you believed was iriappropriate, linpiofe'ssibfial,
,coercive" 'abusiv.e, or Utllciwful?

,OYes

0

No

-2~a.- PJ~a;¢~~'ribe'th;w~ys~i~ ~hich-YdU b~liiv~ th~ tr~inil1g: i!1;i~~tid~6r~U\d~riC:e 'wa~ ----~ ---,
irj.adeqiJate:

_

,

" This to-pic.was·hejier discussed. I ,guess in 'the fu'turethey should at leasfti:ilk-aooutJe.
- _ _ "'( ... ' _ - . _-.

-_._~

'""._-_.

' _ _ "_ _ ' _• • -

' _ .... _

.... ' _ - _

>00'_ _

...

~

_ _ - _ ' _ _...... _ _ ...... _ '_ _

25. (Optional) Tn.what way?,~n ~he FBJ 'improve training ,Oil this

.... .r

,_ .._ _ ...... _ . - _'

.

.~

subject fpr flJture deployments at'

OIGQ-005292

-assig nments?

-

10 . Comment~'
26, Please provide.any additional information'concerniJ1g training for overseas deplo¥ments or

I,

assignmenJ;s of FE}I personnel you believe Is relevant.

. . m'~A~~~'·

,'.-

~

...

..

'

-,

¥

'w~" ""'~'ro.

....

'~

.!:'.: . . .

'1,

~

'.

<'

, . ,

~_,:,"~~:'~1·;1...~._

..:..

',·,:>;;·

'--:"'~.'".::

In~rodl;lction to Part}l~: In. th!s'sE\ctfoni:~e'areseeklngJ~ror:rnation regarding, q wrde:range,of
'intervlew or interrog,?l~Jdri~~<;hnique~~np 9ther typ!=s' of,~~tai,liee'trea~ll1~nt 'pl1eg~ to h9V~ gccu,rreJf. '

'(ou ~h,pj.Jld hl:iP:iss,(.trtle,,'jl,lst Q~$3.!.",se 'vYe,~.r~cl'sk,ihg, ~bqLJl a pan:icl\lar Je~hnlq~~ qr.R.rqcti~e! th!!lt we. n~qv.e
:concluded that it. in fact,occulted. We reco\:J:nize that ,some of these techniques.oi: p'fclctices' hi2jy-aUJmes
be necessary Tor scife1¥ and' security, in 'a'detention ;setting,. In acfdifio,n.l we rec:og,nizelhahome of'these
.teqhniques:o(' praGti~~ may ./1.C:lV:e .jJe~n: auth9~zed foru,se by militc!'Y or :o~hel.' gO'llernment personnel.

I

I

WJt,h resp~ to: ,~ch .l~e,l')tifl.¢d, tl:,€;hnlqu.E!, p.r~Ptl~el 9r'typ:e of c6ndu.c~,d~crlb.$.1below.,. wg?ar~ :SE!~kirig
'infO'Matlon about. its ocm.i,rrerice during 6.".in ,connection viitli the interview.,cr interrogation. of :a.
detaineer 'Or durin:g the~detention.of a detainee beyond w.hat is:n'eeded ,for safety and,securlt¥,
In ~h?lt co'nt.ext,. -we Will a~k Y.9lJ to tell l!~ I(.\!heth~ran~ or m9r~ of the f611qwihg fst9t~me!lt? ~re ~ru~~
,

1. 1 ~r,5ona!lYQb$'erv~d -this t'ond!J~t
Z. I,obs~fVM .d,e'tafo.e¢(s).ifIa cQnditlpji tHatlep. "tOs=:tb Q¢!.ieye tllat thr~cofiduct had pccu'fi:.ed •.
3~. Detainee(!i) told me that this Eonducthadoccurred.,

'J-.
~;

Q-.

Ci?ther$:who. Q..b~ery~.9,:th)~<;Qnq,(J9~·d~s,cJ:i!?e.9 ,it.tg m~.

J.: h:aV~T~leV?l1r Ihf()rm~t[91i C::.IP~S!f!~(f ebQV~""SE!ZRET·,.

I he.ver obs.e'r.v.ed thisc;Q'OQuct n,QJ .h~ard ,~b:out. it' from ,~QMeo:lj¢.·wh().d,id.•

:2i peeriyrng;a detainee. offeod
;;I.

b"
c,

~

.Cf •

or wat~f

o II p:e(SQrialiyobselV.ed this.~COridu~t.,
D. II' obse(\ied

de~aihe'e(s) in:a 'condition-that led m~, to !leriey~ Jh8t ~his cqrlquct haq Q'c~lt.rIe~.

o Detainee(s:). tpld me tHat 'this, conduct ha,d :occ,iJr'red,
o lmfJ.e~rS: who obsefved thiS. conduct d,~scribed ittP: me.

-~

e. 0

!

"

i

I. ha'~e releVant Itlf6rrifatlbti Classified aBoVe "SECRET".

f. 0' r never·observed

this~~ondu~t

I

nor hear.d about it from sOmeone'who. did.
;

,:28. 'Q:.~p'riVin!L~,~d_eta~~. ofclo~!:!.i,r:!9. ___.____.___._.

§

0 II'Rersonall
this
condllc,t.
Y oboorved
_·'••_...._...u·...
.•..
,>. '-'_..' '''s__

~

''"SI2..

_.

:::

w

___

.f.

_.J •

e.•. 1

.h

__

••. ___ : t

.~_

•• (J,S' ...

..k..... $2_ .... 6.

__ to

a

t_.

= •.

L.. . _..

OIGQ-005293

,

.,

'

0
c. 0
d. 0
e. 0
f. 0
b.

..
. -- - ,
I observed detalnee(s) In a cond Itlon that led me to believe thaUhls conduct had 'occurred.
"

••

c

'

'

"

-,

Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had 'occurred.
Others' whf? observed this cOl1duct-descriqed it to m~;
I, h~ve relevant Ihformatlon classified ~bov~ ..SE¢RET·....

I n~v,er;qbs,erve~ this'cQnduct.nQr hearp-abqut it .from s,qmeone. who did.

2·9·. 'Deprivin'g'8 petair1!=e.of>-,sIe6(?;

or interrupting

siee~ by frAAuent cell relol=.ations·or.6ther niefhoos: .

0' r personally observ,ed this eonch-iet.

a.

h.. 0 I,observed detainee(s}In a'coAd ition' that led me to believe that this conduct had ,oecurred~

0
tL D.
e. 0
'f: 0
c.

Detalnee(s)'told me that this conduct had occurred.
others who i)~ser:v~d t,his ~0nd u<;t ~escribed [t'to

me;

I. b,av.:~ rel,ev9nt rnforma~!(m c1a:~?H'J~.g '?l.i?t;>v~. ·~SI;C8-E:t"·.
I ney~r· 9.~.S,Eirv:~:C! ~hi.s qJ.I').C! \lc.t 119r' hea r.d 'a QouJ It Jrom:~metlnewho ~ Id.

-g. PI~.~?e proviq~ Jj:l~ ~,pprQXi.mat~ tIme rra.m~ .dl,lring. which fhj~: cO,ng'!-:f~t,o·ccurr~~i.
From Jl.f:200~2.lQ Ql!2'QO,3
Dae> Not Recall
h. Th'e '4ei:~'ln~e(s) :trea~!'ld In 'thiS w.ay Wer~ 10,¢~tedat t~ Jil'ne In:

0 :GLI;;int~n.Clmo
20 I~q

1,

3 0 Afgtfaoistan
•2J: D ;other Location

.

50 E>o-Not
. Recail
.
I. Please identify the,oetalnee(-s) by name ,and number':
.
r: did not see specific detaineesr but.1 saw- a detentloh center in 'kabul that was maintained by·the
cIA 'N.h~r~ they· ased IquQ mUsic';
.

J. Weas,e' identify the' perSoh(s)'whp .tr'.eat~d the: detairiee(s). in this manner, ih'cludillg their
name(s) arid government agencYUe~):

k. Please id.etitify- any.'otlief. FBl p~rsolrnel (:Jr non-FBI pers6noel whO,olJ'served netafiiee(s.l treafeo
in this. manner:,.iricl.utlirig their oame(s) and aget1cy(ies)~'
.

s~

I

I. This.c,QJiClu¢t oCcl-\rr~.d in' :cQntiectip'n with:

"

b6
b7C

i:O .One: detqrnee
2.0 Sexel'aJ deta in~s (2-4)
:3 $ Many detainees {more thah' 4)
.4

d

Do Not Recall

OIGQ-005294

m. (Optional) Please deScribe the 'relevant circumstances in more'detail:

we

tr

Were 91~efi a tbt:lt,of this faqllty wheh wf! {lrst g01: to l<:ab.l!1. p;~r the \l1$it' the liurn~~r'tWb'
man at the "Station' told us we should not 'go back there unless we .wanted
be ~i:t:Ofa
Cof!gresslonal hearing at some later date. Thls- info was reported up to:SSA
ithoul: any
resPP!1~e::orguipance.
.

b6

h7C

.30. aeatlng a deh11nee

a, 0
1;,

0
0

t p1:!rS!:m<;llly QD.5eIV.ed thi~ J;;orxiw:;t.
',otiiierv.ed 'detaij;ee(~}

It) 'a'C:cind i~ion'that

I~ me,to belIeve that.thiS: q;liduttJia:ct Q,ccilr!"¢d,

C,
De~ainee(sJ t.old /tI~ th 9 t thi~ ~bnQu!=.t h~tl Oc;qJttE!:d.
[]
d,
OtherS", whQ .bbsel'Y~ thiS' t.bnda.ct.de'Sglb,ed It t6 me.

e. 0
f.

0

I have'rele\!abt inFormatiO.n classified anove. '~SECRET"·.
I. never obsefv.eo tllis,conClud nor hearCl'ab"odt it.troni_sOmeorie.who did.

~31.lJslng water to prevent breathIng bya detalnee.orto create :tf.Je sensation of'drownlng

a, 0 l p¢l1i9naJly QPp-erve,d thls con~ue:t.
b. 0 r~~rved d~taine-e.(~)' in a cpndltion that led.m~:to peliev.~ t.hi:!.t.this,,:ui,ih,JC!: bap :oct:;urre~.
t: D. ~betaine.e(s:j tbld me that .this: ~"Or'iduet had -.occurrfi::L
..iI 0 Others, who bbserved .this tonduc:t' described i~.t(l, rn~
e: 0 r ba'tre 'rele:vatit Inforrnatlo.n·'cias,sl!ied ~bQv:e '!SE.GREfjj·•
f. 0 I never ooserv-,et1 thih:oili:iuct nor:hffi(d about it ftOm;someQ·rie.wtio dId.

;:32. Using hands, rope, ,or: anything else to:choke or strangle a detainee·
($;

0

r p'l;:r~nally' ob:~rved this :~on!1ud.

b. D' ~t/)b:se'rve~ detaine,¢t~): In';a t~nditl.or( th~t, I~ Il)e to b,eJle,,:!i'l that,thls c:p!'ld!Jtt.hqd dcq.oie.d,
c. 0 ·De,tainee(sj fpl.d tn~ tnat't~l!;>:qlrfdut:lh?!p o'Cc!Jrr~.
o.~hen; whQ pbse:h{~ tl}iS, C:6,nd.t,J!:;.t 11,~i:.tib~ it to in¢.

d. 0
e- O

fhav:e r~ievah{ infiirmatlon t1assifiM aboV,e ·SECRET'''.

i: 0

I nev~r ob.s.er-v¢(l Hiis 'conduct ,nOr' heard .ahOl-!l it'fiorn sdrneuneWhQ did.

OIGQ-005295

33.. Threatening other aqibn tq calise physical pa'in, injury, disffgurem~ht" or death

a. D r personalfy obserVed this:<:o-nduct.
b. 0 , I,obserVed detaloee(s} in:a ,cbnd itioh that led me to believe that this conduct had occurred.
c. [j Detainee(s)'told me that this conduct had occurred.
d,
,~;,

r;

0
0
!if

Others who observed 'this cond uct described it to me.,

r hSive relevant rnfor~ation Glassiff~~ ~~ove ','S:ECRET",
I,l)evero~serve'(.j tl;lJs <::ond.l!~t oi)rnecrr;d

aboyt it from ,somepnew1]o did.

3!r,

Other tre~trn~nt or ?~iol1 ~using signlfi,cant p:hysi~1 p,afn or injury, :o.r cau'sln'g ,df5fi,!l!Jr~m.t~mt or
.d¢C;1tb
.,

0
b. 0
<;:;, D,
g, 0
e, 0
i: '0
a.

,35.

r. personally. obsel'\led this:conduct.
I observed

det:alne~(s) In,a:col)C;lit!of) thC!t led Tl1e to bel!~ve t,hclt;tn!s'condL!q' h?d 'oq::urred,.

D~tail1~e.(s),tqld me that this:q:m9l,l<::t baQ'Occl,lrred.
8the~ ~ho oqservl?,~ ttyi!? <::o.n:9vct;d~scr.i.bed 1~"tO D1~.

I hcN~ relevant Inform,atlon c1as,sJfi.~d Clbov~ uS'ECRET" ~
1. hev.er o,bS'erved tliiS condutt )for' heard ·abo.ut it from S~fneo!1~'wbt>' did;

PJ~icili~

a detainee..pn a hot ,surfat~ bt !:ill'rnin'9 'a',detainee

0 I personally observed this,conduct.
b.. 0 ['observed'detalnee(s) In a,coAdition that led me to'. believe that this conduct had :occurred.
C;.. 0 Di?tainee(s) told 'me that t~is. c0nduc~ n,a,d :oc::curre9,
tJ: 0 8thel"S' WD:9 9bser:v~d. th,is cqJ.1d!lc~. de!?Cfibed i~ t,9 qJe.
e. 0 t have rel~vant informatjo'n cJc(s.~lfiep A!,l?'ov~ "~.ECJ~ETj,
a~

f.

r~f I rr~ver 9Q.s'erve~ tht~,cQJ:l9yct nor t)~rd :a~Qulit from's(jrn~on~'1[IIh9'dlQ,

36. :U$ltig ,shatkles or Q.thetr~strain.t.s,in, a pr6lon:ged n1,anne(

ELQJr personally observed this Gondlid. ,

,

;

OIGQ-005296

,

,.

,

b. [j ['observed detalnee(s) In a,condItlon that led me. to bellev.e that this conduct had 'occurred.-

0
·d, 0
fe, 0
f. 0'
c.

Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had :occu rred.
O~hers'wh0 observed

tt)i? co~du~td~cri!?ed it to m!=.

[have relevant IOformation cla~sified ~bov~ "S ~REr".
[ n!=ver"ops~rv~d' thi,s'cQnc!uGt n9r h~rpQbqutit from sQmeone who did.

3;7. 'R~gi..litirig·.!3d~.ta'lne:e,t6 maintain! pr (est~inih9 a':

a. 0 I

persOnalfy,obServed this coildl.lct.

.b., 0 I,;observed detainee(s} in a-condition that led me to believe that this conduct had ;occurred·.
:c; D Oetalnee(s). told me tflatthis .conduct had occu rred.
l:j! D. btbe~' wh9 obseryed l~;s cond uc;t ~re~cribed i,t t~ me;

0 1. h~Y~,re~~~ant'rnf9rm:at!<~n: ~1.a~~tffe.9 :a~ov~, .~S:
'f. 0 I.1}~ver;:9.Q?~rv.ep thfs·C9f1Q\-lCJ I1gr hE?3rp ia,p9l!t,

e:

sa. Fori;:ing ~ detain'ee. to.' perform derti~nd tng phy:slcal
a'~

o II perro'nally, observed ttHs .condtkt.

b.

D

c,

o ;Detainee(s) told me thatthis' conduct had ,o'(;curred.·

ir.,observed detaine'e('s} in.a ·cond itiori that led me' to: Delleve that-this eohdtict ha'd :oecllrred.

d. O· ;o.thers. who observed this conduct described it to me;
e.

o II have relevAnt. informa~ion c1assifieg above: ",5

f,

0' IInevero.bserved
this
heard
:about
.
.,. conduct nor
,,..
..
.- ..... , i~ fro~

.3.9,.

}.",..

,

""

',

,

,'

~meone wt}o C! id.

Us.!n!l.ele~trica·r~ho!=k .on a petainee

a. 0
b', 0
€'.

'

,j

L p'er.s6nal!y observ.ed thiS :cond,utt.
Lobserved detainee(s) in a condition that led,me to. believe that thfs c0nduct, had .6ccu·rred'.

o iDetaiilee(s)'(61C1 me tliat fhis condllGt h-ad ijcc'urrea.

d.- O,IOthers. who observed .this eond uat described it to me.
'e.

f.

0
0

I. ~qv,e relevant l~for!TI~.tion,dassr~ie~ ,~bbV~ ",
I [Iever'o.bserved, thIS 'Con,duGt nqr neqr~ C!b9l,lt

OIGQ-005297

40. Thre;aten.ing to use electrical sno,cko-ri

,a, 0 r persooalty observe~

a detclinee

~I:lis :cqnduct.

b. D

Lobs~(v~d, d.et<:!in'ee(s) in a-cond iijon that

c. D'

D~talne'e(sj

~.

e.

0

tol9

m~ thpt

Jed ,me to

be!iey~ thqt thi~ conduq: had 'Q~c;urred.

this, conduct hap oc;curred.

Others' who pbsery~,d 'thl$; q:md'!lct de'sqlbed It to' m~;,

o iI have relevant Infbrrtiatioh'):las'!iified BboV.e. "S.EGRET".

f- IEf

I nev,er obp~rve'~ th!? cQnclu~t npr'h~rd ~abdli.t i~ fr(jm ,sPmepne Wh9' dirl.

41, Jntentionally~'dela,yin!1,or-:der:iyirig ,detaidee medical tare

a.
b'o'

o II, p~r;so,nal.lY ~.b~rv~<;l ~h,s 'condu~t.
o II :opsf;rvei!' c;let;:;line'e(~)

io .Cl'cppd it.iq,n ~h?lt, led, lTle to ~~li~:V~ th~t t,hi~ C(?n'cjuc~ har;!Q~c\JrreP.

C;~

D. (DetaJnee(s.) t.ol~ .m~ t.hat t{ti~ t.ond\J~t. hqd lQe;;c'Yrre,d.

~,

o Id~hers' ~h9 t;>bsery~ this G,QnQ Uc;td~~cdb~d

~,

D. if Ii;we releVcmt in(orl1)13.tion'd13ssified gQ'oVe '':$.EC,R£T"·.

jt

t!?; IlJ,~:

f. 011 n¢V¢f'Qoser:v.ed this~cQnd UGt lib.t he,~:lfd 'abp,ullt from '$OrTl'eQn~·WhQ dj~.

,42'. HO'odil19 ,or bllhdfold ing a ,detainee'other ,thah d.u ring 'ttCllisp-0,rtatlon

a,;,

b..
c.
~.

ei

f:

o II persol)al,lY'''qbserved this ·<;onduct.
o !r,o/Js~rve'Cj ,det~ln~~(s): ,In \a'cqn<;l1tl(;m-th~t led .r:n~ t9' bellave thClt:this conduct hpdoccurred.
o !p~tqi,IJ~(s)' tol~ .f1l!= that this' col)Cluc:;t had oq::4JTe<;!,
0 Qthers, w,hp 9b~er.v~ ;tbJs conp1-(ct d,e~.cr.il:!eg i.~~9' me.
0 t have relevant IIJ(ormati9'n -clas'sitJed 'a bpy~ '(s.:Et~'!•.
0 l' n!=ver d.b:;erved' this COrlpuc.t npr h~r.d ;3bbtJ,t j't frdTT1 som~pne:·who;

ditt.

-43. Su.bjecting, i;I ,detain.e¢: to e>rti:eniely C:old or ~t room te'mpetatutes"for extended pMbds

[aJQ]r personallY observed this:condud.

OIGQ-005298

b. 0

I observed detalnee(s) In a condition that led me to believe that this-conduct had 'OCcurred.

c. 0 IOetainee(s) told me that this conduct had :occurred.

d. 0

O!hers' who observed 'this co~uet descriQed it to m~:

e..

I hav~ relevant Information dassifie.d ~bov~ "S·E~RET·'.

0

f. Il'l I n~.er·ob.s:ervl:;d thjs'~nd uct tlQr hear$! Qbqut i~ .from someone whp did.

.44. SUbiec.tili[ a d~UUrieeto Joud tnl1sR;:

a. 0' I personally"observed this.Conduct.
b. 0 ['observed·detainee(s}In a:cond"itio n'that led me to' believe that this conduct,had :occurred.
c, 0 Detalnee(s) told rrie that this cond uct nad occurred.
d. 0 O~hers who observ~ -this cond UG!" de~eribed it to 1lJe;
e, 0 r, ~cw:e relev~nt fnfor~,at!orr c!a~5:ff1
't: 0 r n~v~r:o,b~rv.ep. thts-q)!1duGt nQr",

g. p~_a.?~ proYid$ jh~ ~.Pllr.9~i{na!a time ,"fra,me dl,lrl'19. whl¢h ihj$. ~.nQ_l:!Qt:p'c<:;t,!rr~.
From (MlDJYY'f'f furm~t or M/YY'iYJ to (M/D/YY'iY format ;6r Mf'IY'IYJ
OD" Not Recilll
h. Tile j1et<;lJMe($) trea.t.~ In this WqY Vi,ere io.cated ~t fh¢ ~itne 'In:

.1 0 ·(~l1~n~~f'\ifITio
20 Ii;iq
9 ~ Af:g tianistarl

0 ,Other Location
SJ] Do No;t Reqlll

.~

I. Please.ldentlfy"the,detalnee(s) by hame and mii'n ber~
Too many.

), piease identify the. 'pers6n{s"l""Whci .t.reate"d th-e,detainee(sj iti .thls niadner, intJiJdlng tht::ir
nab'te(:s):and $lQ\ierr'lrhentag-ency(:les)t
CIA
k. PleaSe ideTiti!Y-any'ol:tief: FBI personnel Of non:"fBI·personnel'wlio-·6~seNed detai'nee[s)" trea"ted,
,in.this. manner, Induding' their name"(s) and agenq'(ieS):

Sli

I

.

b6
b7C

I. Thj~.cprldUd occurred, In "tQnrtectJlin .with

1 0 One: detijln~
2 ,dS~etaJ detaih¢$ (2-4)
3@ ritariy: detainees {more thcm.4)
c4 d Do Not Recall
..... _.
..

OIGQ-005299

rho (Optional) Please describe the:relevant circumstances in more detail":

M (>J'evlousiy; rep{Yrted.

4$, $l)bjectiog a detaine~ t() bright flc;lshing

IIgh.ts 'Or ;dClrkn~sS"

a'. 0 I perSonally dbserVed this ~bndU~t.,
b, q ~L6bserved detalnee(S) Ina,c::ondltlQt1 that led me to believe thattlils conduct had .occorred.

e: D

.Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had ,occurred.

D Others who :obselll.ed this condl:lctdescribed ft to me.
e. D' r have relevant Information classified abov.e I!S,ECRET·~.
d.,

t:
-

or
"

never observed this 'cond uet nor hB'3ra :about it from someone who'd id.

._"

,

"---'- - ' ' . :'-:"""'_':"._'-'

-_:..-:-,'_ ..

'-'

.-_--'---------

,46.. 1solatiOg a detainee 'for an ¢xtend~ period

a. -D
b.

,c.
I

:d.

e ..
f..

I perSohallyobserved this,cohduct.

0 L6bserved tlefaltie~(s) in a,c<)J1dition that ,led me to believe thanhis condutt.t:iad
0 DetcHnee(s) told me that this conduct had .occurred.
0 Other'S' who obsetv.ed -this condiJct descrihed it to me.
0 I· have releyant information classified above ·!SECRET w•
0 I never observed thls'cqnduct nor--heard 'about It from someone'who did.

-47. Using guct tape to
;a.

b.

c.
d.
e.
f:

o,cturtetl.

restraIn, ~9g I 'or pu nts.h ac;:l~tain~e'

o if j:iersOJi~ny observed this conduCt.
D II observed detilirie.e(s} in a·cplid itian tnat led me 'to belieVe .tt.iaUoi's c6ndli,ct. had "o~curr:ed.
o lDetailiee(s~, tdld me toat tnis cOJ:uj'uct had i>,ccurr'ea.
o lOtherS who observed this lrondiIct described it to me.
d

ILhave relevant information classified a'bove

0lr never observed

I'SEtREfll.

this"conduct nor heard about it from someone who did.

48-. Using rapid response te,a.msand/Qf for!=ed cell extractions

OIGQ-005300

0
0
c., 0
tL 0

I, per~nally:ob~el'\led this cqnduct.

a.
b i,

e.

f.

I'Observed d~tainee(s} in ~ qmd.ifiqn ~hat led m~ to I,l~neve th~t t(lis con:du~t h,ap'dc~urred.
,[j~tc:linee:(s')'tol~ m~ thap.his' condl,l\:t had m;:cQrred.

Others' whQ pb~,er.Y¢d this, C:OJidu~t des,C'ribed

It tQ tn~

o II hp\(¢ relev~int ihfQrmation' tl~ssifj~ Clboye, "SECRET','.
o I, never qb,s,erved thl,s condu~t npr'h~n! ab9l,1,t It 'from,sQIl1l:p,n~ wh9' gid.

'49. Using iU'nilit8ry Working ;oog ali or near a,detairiee',other tha'n,during C1etaf'nee:transpoftatibn
I, p!'lr?OnaJ,ly @bse['?eQ, \h~? :coQducf,

0
P..: 0

a.

c.;

1 observe~ d,etpinee(~) in ,a:¢9n~,i1:iOlYthat-l~d me ~9 Q,c;liev,e thSlt;tJ1Iscgndut;:t- had 'occurrerJ.,

o 'DE:!taine~(&Jtol~ metn~t thIS t9nqu¢t h~d 'o:cC\lrr~.

9. 0 qther:s' wbp :qb$erv~91hj?,p~n~!,Itt d.~s:~rlbe,9 it t~' me:. '
e: D l' h'a'le,reie,yailt j'nformc;ltfpn {:Ips.$ifie,d i;lb,dYe, "'SECRET"'.
t 0' r' never o.Dsel'\l¢,d, tl:1i$:Cdntluct no,r'hl=ard.8 bbU~ it fn~m,SOril:e9~ne.Wh9 did.

,50. Threateti.iJig 'to',use'tullitary wo'tking oogs;6ti: or tiear a ,d.etalJ'leea~,

0 l' p~r$0naO'y"O'bs!'!rve.d~~I~~oncj,L!.ct.

l!:J 0

I:observeddetainee(s) in ,a:cpng ition that

led me h,l bel!~ve thgt 'this COtl~u'ct

n?o octurre,d.,

0 O¢~~jl1ee(?J tpJd me t:ngt tbl~: c:;,ond u~,t hpq 'O~<;:I) r~~.
<;I, 0 'Ptb~~ V{ho :ob~rV~9 this cb,nq)1l::.t de~~'r1bed It ~9 rl')~
e;' 0 t'l)aVe relev?,/rit ibformation t1as,sified a boye: i~S,~C'R~" ,
f, !if ,1 o~v¢r 9!>s'~r\(~~' ~his:C9ridlJ~t npf h~r.d ,a'l;>o.!Jt: it friJmsQn:tepn~:whQ~Jd.
<:;

51. Using spiders, 'scorpions; 'snakes,:or other a'ollilals on' or
,cf..

o J perso.n~.HY o~serv~d th!? qqm!uc;:~.
I;ob,seryed det.Cll.rl'1ge(s} In 'p,-cqndJtlorqhat led IT!e ~P' be!leve thaNhls <::9nd_u~'.\lad'Occarred,

0
c;, 0

b.

d.,
,

,.

near a d~.talrie-e

Det~ine~(~) t.old rn~ tnat thiS cOhduct had 'Q~cJ.lJreq ..

o iO(herp. whQ opserv~g-,this .cOlJq
u<;:t d,e~~ribe,~
..
-..
-

._.-

.

-.,,~

..

~.-

••

v •••

•

0

•••

.

~-

~-

-

-~..

"

it ,to m~;
. .
'.'

_-~.

- ._ ..

..,

_.- .--

"-"

-

--_ ..

--.,

... ....

_

_

OIGQ-005301

e. 0 I have relevant Information' c1asslfled above ~SECRET~·.
t: 0 I never observed this.conduct nor heard about it from someone who-did.

,52:~ Thr~tenll)9 to use"spiders, :scorplons, ,sn,a~s-, or 9the,r .animals on.a detainee

a. 0 I p~:rsOnal'ly ob~rv.ed this .cOndw;:t.

D. 0
0
d. 0
e. 0
f. 0
C.

I.bl:5SerVed .de"(ainee(s} In 'a ,c6nditi6fi t,tiat led me ,to believe thatlhis. conduct had

occuited.

Detairiee(s) told .me that this Conduct had Jko'.J(r:e(l.

Othei"S' who observed this tend uct.d.escribed it tp me.
l. have releyant Inl'onna'tron classified abo.ve '··SECREt".
ne.ver observed thls.conduct nor"heard about It from someone-who did.

,53", D.isrespegful statement~r nandling, o'r~ctions involvi.rig th~ KQr:an

.a. 0 l'pei1;bili'll!y db'~rved tliis.cQndoct.

0 I.bt>serv.ed, delairtee(s) in:a cbnditi6n that led me to belleye tbat this cOnQuet baa ·6d:Ut'r-ed.
,c. 0 l1etalnee.(s) told me that thl~ condutt had .ocdlrr.ei:l.
d. 0 O.the"fs who obserVed tti1s cOnduct oeScribed It to me:
e. 0 r have relevant iriformation classifiecJ a'bo'v.e "SECRET"'.
t: 0' I never'·observed this:conduct nor heard abourl!-from 'someol)awho dld.
D.

54. S·haVirig.a detain,*'s- facial or o.ther h.atr: ·.tb el1lba'r.ra~:"Q[ hUl:niliatea de~illee

tJ [' per.sona_liy o;hsE!PJ.ed thls:c.oriduet.
D. 0 ! 6h.sei:V.ea,detainee(s) ih .a.conditii:mthat led me: to belie.ve t!JaUhis <;andliet had .oceuned.
c; 0 Detainee(.sJ ·told ·It'e that 'this torid uct had occurfed.
rl. 0 Others: who obsel'ved thIs "ctl'tlduct q,eSc:'rlbed It to me.
a.

e.

d

t: 0

I have relevant hifoi"mation classified aboVe "SECREr'.
r never',ob'served tfiiscondllc£ hbr:heard aooutit from Someone who. did.

OIGQ-005302

5:5. Placing

a woman's clothing on a detainee
(

a. D I personally observed this ,conduct.

D 'I:observed detainee(s) In a ,Gond ition that led me to believ.e that this conduct had ,occurred.
<;:. D Detajnee(s) ~old me that this condu!=~ had 'occurreg.
'<11 D Others who obser:v~t! ~bis cEl,nductdescrlbed it t9 rn~
e, 0 I. hav~ relevant rn'l'ormatfon classifiep ,ClQOVe "SEGJ~ET'\
f: 0 I nev~r observeQ thJs:conpu,ct,n(jf'heard about itfrqrn someon~ who did.

I

b',

'ct.

0 I

persoriallyobserved' this.conduct.

b; [j I observed detainee(s) in 'a Gond itiorr that led me to believe that this conduct had 0ccurred.
c. [j Detalnee (s) told me that this, conduct had :occurr:ed'.

0 Otl1ers who_<:,bservec! thi~E0l1d, uct descriQed it ,to, me..
.
e. 0 ~ hpve re~vqnt I.IJJprmatioo d(rssifi~ ab.ove U$'E.CRITl;
r.. 0 I nevero,b~!2rv~~ thls,'colidu~t.[I9r'l1§!Clr9.~bo,ut tt frorrLSQtrleon~~h.o,g!d.

d.

'5:1.

Hold,ing, o,etainee:{s) wll9 w.~te, not, offidalt~ra~kh9wi~d.ged pi'" ,regist~r.ed
tM p e r s b n . '

;d~tainjrfg

.-'---

as: such' by'the agi::ln'tY
.

D I, p~r$9nally o,bserveq this ·c.OI1~u.ct.
D I.observed ~et(iinee{s). in a~coJ)(fiti9[1thqt led me to' befieve that,this conduct
:c. D De~.inee(s) tqld m~ t.h~t lhi~ comh.!.s:t ~ad :oq:urreP,
d'., D 'Others who .Qpserv~d tnTs c'QndUGt,d:es,cri'beP it to' me.
~', D t have relevan.t ilJfbrmatl.on: <;:lassiU,ed <3bpv~ ·~'EGRE:r·!.
q;,
b~

f.

0

had 'occurred.,

I. n~ver obs~rJe9 tbis,c<;mdu(::J: ,nor heard abput it frgm'sdmepne,:wbo,:dip.

5.8. S€md ing ad,etainee:to anbj;hef c6Qn~ry for mor~..agg.t~ssive interrogation

D
b, U
c. D

a'.

I personally obser:ved this,conduct.
I 'opsep(.ed d.etaln§~(s) in a'conditiQO that led [11e, to belJeve tnqt:this condu~t !iad,'Q(~<;urred.

(je~~iree(?) t~ld 'me t~,qt t~ls ~qnd!Jct ha~ ·o~ur.req.(

-

..

,

..

..

"

OIGQ-005303

.

,

..

,

.

'"

(

D lathers, who observed this conduct described It to me.

d,

o II have relevant-information classified above' "SECRET""

e.

o i~' ~~ver obs~rv~d this 'c90duct nQr heareJ about it 'fr<;lm some0n.~ whQ ~id,.

f.

59. Threatening t9·send a d~ta'inee tQ anothercouDtry for dete,ntion prtnQre aggress,ive irtterrpgalion

a. 0

I persOnally. 6bs.eived this GOndLid.

D r observed detilirlee(sJ In a.cbiid,itioh that led .me to beUeve thanhis co'nduCt
e. 0" .Detainee(s) fold me that this conduct had ,Q,ccurred.
d . D Others who observed this condl:lct described It to me.
,eo 0, I have relevant Information classified above \~SECRET"'..
f. 0 I, nev.er ob1jerved t~'s,:COIJd.l!ct !l~)f' ~eqXd 'ab9~~ it ,from: som,eone'W~o did.
b.

a.

0 'I personally J:>l)serv.ed

b.

D

had .oc:cufred.

this.,condu.ct.

Lo15seN,eddetali1ee(s) Ir1'a:cond Itio!:l. ~liat led me'to belieVe thaUhis cbndUct had ·Occurr.etl.

c, o lDetai'nee(s) {old me tliat this conduCt had ,ocl:;uri:i:rl-.
0

d.

e. [j

Qtners, wh0 ciIJserlied this Eonduct d'eScdhed it 16 me.

II have relevant information classified above: !15ECRET".

f:

0lr never observed this'conduct nor heard about it from someone:who'did.

,a,.

0 1. peYS9naily ohperV.ed

this ,coilduc,t.

b. D I .oBserVed det~ine¢(s). ili'it corfd itjon' tli'at, lea 'me to believe thciftllis e6Mud ha'EI ,.o.c,curred:
Co D IDetalnee(s}told me ttiatthis concl'uct had .occUrred.,

.

d. D Others: who observed this cahdiJct described it to me.
.e: D r hav'e releVant information' classified abWe "BE'CRET'\.
f.

0'

I never observed this;conduet nor heard about IHrom someone who did.

OIGQ-005304

62.

Other r~nglou,s.or,sexualha~C!ssrnentOr' hum.lllatlqn ofa d¢talnee,

0 I. p!:!.rsdr'lallY obserVed this cohou'ct.
b. 0 [observed detalrtee(s) In a cond iticin that led me 'to. believe that this co.nduet had octlltred ..
c. 0 DetaiiJee(s) told nie that this conduct had ,occurred.
.....
i'd. 0 Others. who observed this cond uct described it to'me.
e. 0 I have relevant Information classified above, \!SECRET'l.
f. 0 I never o~served this conduct nor heard ·ab.81-!f it rrolIl someone who d'id.
a.

".-;-

.----------,,--~._-~---_.

._--~

~-----------------~--.-

'{53:. ,qther i;re"atmel)t cif cf d~tq il1e~ 1.hat 'in Y9..ur opinion '~dS unp'n?fe~~i9nal;uil~ljly .nar;sh or:~ggr~ssiye.1
Goereive', 'ab,u$ive, Qt .unlaWful
a;.

0

I perro'rially obServ.ed tills condUct.

b.

C!.

I-observed'detainee(s) In'a"condition'that led meta belieYe that this c:;:onduct had occurred.

0 Detainee(s),tcild me that this· conduct had :occurred.
q.~ 0 O~J:lers who obser.veq t.~ls cend lJ,c;t cj~$~r.i.Q'eg \t to m~.
~. 0 I have -relevant Information c1ass:med above: "SECRET'!_
to &1 I never'o.b,~.erv~d this 'OOJi~~tt :npf lie:ard :a QO~~' itfrqrn 'sol1Jep,ne' WhQ did.
c:

_ili:::m.~@j~~.,:,··::·:·l:~:,:.''';'.'<':·-11.
64. Did you. ob's.elv.e,ailY imp~rs6na~iQn of FBI p;ersPlin"el by.al'jyone during an IntervieW6(iriterrogatioll of

:a .d e.ta"i nee?

.

Q Yes
:~~: Dj~ ::iily ~~~Ihee. Qr:-Q.th~r .~r',P9n teJi YbU tll~~. h~ ~r :sIre Iia:d Wlt!i~~~~. ·th13 'llTj p"~r:SQflatiq-1l pi F~t
pets.o.hnel in. eonnecti6n" with~; detainee interview or' inter'ro.gati6rt?
Yes
~ No.

'6q.. Are Y.9l:!

o

aware: of ,any ':sham~" 9r ;]!stageq" d~t?llne~' i.nterviews:,~r interro.gt;ltiPf1? Wn.du~~eg [Qr Mem.1?·~r.?·

<?qh~·l)~·S. qQn~tes:s .Qr ~I)eir ~~atn

QYes'
',~7~ Tq your knowledge,.c,!i9 any military .orintel\lgenc~p~rsonrH:iI'~verpeny pT Q.elay ·FeI.acc~s to 9"
. oet?li(l¢e th~ FBI w.ant¢d to· q.ueSt.iOri ,becauseth:e .d·~t~ine~hatl ,~istajri~.(f !JijWie$,:after he' vva~ i:;aptyr:.eQ?

.

QVes:

(V·No

OIGQ-005305

~il. Dld you ·e.ver 'Sl)q your pa~lclp~tlo(l I.n or o~,seryatlql)-9f ~ oetalr:t.ee In,te.rv1el;'Y o.r 1n,t.errqg9tJon
b~~Us~ of ~he' tl1terv~w or" ir.rterr.pg"gt)p,1i IT\eihods· being .!J.~d?·
.

Q,Ves
0 No
'6~; W~re yQ.!J eve.r ,told j:f)at.ani;>th~r FBI ~iTfp'16y~ .end~d. his at h~r participa.tion in of Q6s~rv~tjon Qfr . a
detaInee intervjeW n'r intenog;3tlon because :of the interview.ai'j'nterr:09at16n methods being used?

o Yes.

<!). NQ

1P:. P\lr:1li.g, ~1I'JY of y~ul' b1~r~a~.d~~lqytnehts"Qr ~!fslg nmsn!s" iltd y{;l.l! rep'Clr:t flny.c9'n"¢e.rn,s r¢.g~rd Ing
any idetainee 'interview 0 r.' interrogation picictices, .or. 6ther.tY:p~s Of defaiIiee' trea"tmen't,. to: all" 'FBI
,supervisor"?

•

"0. Yes
70.a. Wlierj aM fo whom did 'You: .make this' r.~po'i:t:7
s~C1

'0

No:

,

.

h6
b7C

76b, Pld~ort ~elatl? t~·~0.nduct.by" FBI or nOfl-.fBl persqnn~r?:

0 f~I Pe):"s:onnel
2 0"Nofi-FSf Persdnnel

.1

f~ ent·ilY.th~ 'a'9,e.nfY. w.~tt1 ~hJ~~

70e.

OIf\

thet np r:'-FBt p,er'§<l!lne! ~~r~. ?!.fflljgt.ed.

Was·this: repqrt, In ,wr'itiOgJ

10Ves-,
2'ON~

70d Was :cin'y action taken- In tespons'e to. yo.uj" report?
+OY~~'
20Ng.

3:I£1'Do Not Knew,
'7L DUrin!rany.-ofyour: oyerneas deplqyments:.or assi&,OIllen1s, .did·you repoct.any cl'lnaerns regarding any.
,delam.ee. interview ·9'£ interrogation..ptaCtic~s lor Oilier ty'pd ef,d.e'fuiflee. tteaUti.eht":YQiJ: observed or heard

.abo~f, t~:a

n:on-FB.I. supervtso.r dr ·:other ri,on'-FB~ personilet~'
O:¥es

0 No.

.
72~ Ha.Y-¢:You '~¢r' ~~e1:J Qrdere~( (i,r ~ ir¢etet[ no.t t9 repQrt" d,.:dls:c.q(lrqg:e~ 'rn ~ny"w.?"y fr~r:n re'Po.tt'ing r
observat,ions Q('alleQatioo'$: re)ated 'to;d¢t~inee tr'Eia.tm~nt tic' irtferVl¢.w or loferr.ogp~i9j1 actio.r'fS 9'(
~~

.

.

.

0' YeS' '0' Nt:>

.

7~:.I;I?ve'Ypu ·~pef.i~~ep ..9ny .a9t!J.~1. ~r th.rea\en~ r~t~liat(9.!l' wr t~PQrti.rlg d.t,>.s~rV9tiQ~.~Oar. 9li~?ltions
Qf ,Qeta.ln'ee tr~tment ·Q.r Irt~e.rylew gr in.t~:rr~g~tI9li·a·ct.lqr(~.~r. prp'c~lq:!$!
.
q:y~~

~·~o

74. ~,Qptto!Tcll) P,[~p'~ prqyide anY'a~qitionaJ ~0mrnen.ts reQ.arding :th~ .r:eportl~g, :df ~onc~~ns. related t<;r
jli!ervi!=W. or jil~etfi1satiqhl:~c:::hnlqu.~$i pe,t~ntlon pragi.c~~... br bther Qet.9in¢e tr~9~meoJ.

OIGQ-005306

~\YA.Jg'~~'.

~~

'.1

75. Were YOu' debriefed" other -thah the.standar.d debrief in FD-7.72/ co.ncernlng y.6ul"'O~erse~s
'assignment(s) :or depJoyment(s) afteryou com,pleted the deployment{s) or .assignment(s}?
@:Yes .G'No

7,5a.1 Whq d}~priefetl yo,u?
Director Mueller
750. When Ellid where did the debfiefirig(s) occLir?

In

~i~ ~onfere:nce

rO,orn

7.5c:: ,vile~ yo~ as~ed ClPoU,t '<t~taJnee q,etefl~lon or In~~rv.i~w orlnte,rrogt,ltto,n pr~lI;+lces.dur.Jng tbl?
" • d¢p.riefil.1g(sy?
,,
eVes G'N.6,
lSd. What othe'r subjects were cov.e'reo dUring :your debriefltlg'(s)1

75e. Was"any document prepared to memo rial lze,the-debrieflng7

G: Y¢S

7-9' Ad~itional

a

N,o

,~P9

N9:t: Kh.OW

Comrr,~nt~ and RecpmlllelldC!tjqn~,:

'Thpok yq,u,
fqr your coi;)p,eration io '~.ompl¢tifl.9,
.
' . . t~i~'\ql:!~$~io.nqaJr(:l':
.
~

OIGQ-005307