D~partm~nt'of Ju~tic:e Inspectpr- Gener,a( 'Questicmnaire'

Regc;ndil19 Detain:e,es

DOJ.-On:; INVEST-IGATIV.E QUESTIONNAIRE
FOr{ REVIEWA~D USE dNLY BYINDIY1DUAL FBI ItESPONDl:rnS
"
" , ' r>Q NOT F6~WARD OR DI~EMIrjATE'
,
QUESTIONNAIRE 10: test:"O,Q,OO,09:35,

,As,of ~tt~,last.time this qu~tionnaire.wa'~, sav~~r some re:quire_d fieI~s: h.W~ nQt ~een c9I11plet~d.
Pleas~'J.e.vieWYburresponses.
•
~~

A.

".

.'

,-

'.'

P~r~onpl Infprmatipn

Pleaseprovide.the folloWing information:
ham¢:
.. ,
';2.; M.i~pJe (nltWI:
3: Last name:·
4. Entered' Oh D:uty Date .(EOO):
.~: Current Divisfon}Field Office:
6.. CL!.(reQt job title:
d. Direet.dial office..telephone number:
8,. FBI ~en ph.one· number:
9, fBi p.ager number:
to., 6e$t €QJ)tact numl?er for'you~

J.. Flr.5t

6 ~T¢ PERA~REEJ¥1!=NT

'6 &. 'rCPERAGREEMENT
6 & 7.C PERAfiREEMENT
6 &:7C

~ ~ 7C
Sup~rVisorYSeniQr·R~si.~en.tAgen~
6 &7CPERAGREEMENT
.

~ .&;'7CPER.A~R~EMENT

g 4lC PE~AGFEEMENT.
'6 & 7.C PER.AGREEMEN.t

B·, Ba'ckg rou'nd of Spe'Cifi'c O'eployme'rits or As"sig nntents
11. At 'ahy time al~~f:.septemberU t .200f., did yau setv.e',as'·a member ofthe U.S. Military, 'or as an
employ~e .or contractor of the FBI or any other government agency., ·at Guantanamo Bay'.' 'Cuba; Iraq;
!\fgh<;lni.st.~n;'or in ar~C!s,wntroll.\':!d QY t~'e. ~.:S. Mjlit~ry. or a V.,S. in~ellig~n!=~ ser~:!ce jm;qnr)e,et!on:wit~ t~e
,glpoal YIi<;lf on !e.rr~'r1
0,Yes b No

1.2.. !=nter the numb~r 0{ tirne:S ypu. wer.e;.d¢plqyed or :~S~i.9 ned to each of the.foiloWing 16caHolis,
.(GiJahtanamo Bay,~'Cuba;) lraq;;,:Atghcinistani-0r in Clny areas colitrollE:~d by the. U.S', MilitarY or a U.s.
Intell!g.~l1CeservJ~~);One,
"
For,each deployment or'assiSnment complete tile folIoWin9. section.
Location rsehO!ct one)
Dljip.lpYmJ!.nt Qnl!1sign~l!rit'~eglmoiJ,orJjeiJl~~eil): ~r i1. 5 Si gn·l)Ient en.ded·on,
.

!tf.~qf

.,,,,

~bo.u.t

or abDut

0.1/25/2004

05/0.1:/2004

i~a, Whit w~s .the gen;eral ri~t~ r~ ;:inc! p:lJrp'q~~ oj -ybur !35!sigrim.erit ~hd al:ti\iitie~?
O'p'eratio,ri's,s-u p¢rVisar fBI Bag.tlda.d

1'2b. Please provide. the· names ofthe_specific.camps, bases; or facilfties'whereyou worked,
FBt Baghdad Op'~ratrol1s·center (BOC)
.
.
i2e. NQt~;> if in(P'rm'~£ion' ab.out -2i :spe.dfic .camp, base,. or fadi ity-i~,'da:s$if)ed :al:i6ve SECRET,
please th'etk here Dr 'include in yo~r :ansWer tn~t yo~ hav.e "additJQnal infQrmatidh t1pssjfi~ 'a,hoYe
'SECRET,,'~ andl' if y.ou know, ·ia.entify the,c1assificatlon .level, ticket, :comparfrhent, prog rani, or .other
designation that;appllest9 t~e·informatlon. Do not Includetheadditjonal classified rnformatron In your

OIGQ-004983

qu-estiqnn13ire resp()nse~. bIG personnel w'ith the necessary clearance will c9htact you to ret~ive it.

Name

.L

1._ ___ == •

'__'~'

~12~. Oid you JQlntIY in~$r.view pr

,

~

....

of lJon:-fBI

Position

,

[I?LQ~.R~!y~qn":-~<='~Jl~~GB!!IDla_n.f!~'=.

int¢rrc;jgare any det~iJi~e witn non-f~I per$oiinel?

0

0

Yes

Nl=!

- ..... - _.... ----- - ""' - - ..... _- - - - -' -- -- - - .... - - ... --- - -- - - - - ---- - - -- ...... _., - .... - ... - .... --

,. With' w!l~t kinds

~

,_,_.

-~-

...-

personnel dJ!1 Y9.1,J wQrkjoint!y?"

-. - '

- - ...... - -' ..

-...

-:

0 ¢lTF
;: 0' 'Otner U.S. Military
:: 0" ~U.:S, ioteliigen:ce ag,eii'cy
;~

n F.Qrelg n ml'lItary or Intelligence agency.

': 0

O.ther

.,

.

,

,

---------~---~----~--~------~------------------------------------~----).

;ii£ Did~yQujointXY p~ii~an¥deralnee lriterv~w~~r-inter~ogatlbn'"".strategy;ob1ecti~~,-or tacties-with n~rl--,'

~J=~I pe[s6nn.~17
'

T
~

_

........ _"l._-.l..rw< _ _ .

,_._ _

....

~

~

""""\00"

0'V:es

_._"

...

_._'

a
'

" : ;
N.o

• .....

_·_'w """" ......... __-:_......._. __

~

"".

. __..... _-

:,.

,: With what kinds of non-FBI. personnel did 'You .w,6rkjoiritly?

>

:: DClTF

';

:: 0' .bther .u:S. Military
,: 0
~ 0

U,S, Intelfigen~e agenty
'For~lgn milltary:qr Intelligenc~ agency

: 0 'Other

-::: : .: :,,':: :.: '::::: :.::.:.:: : .: =::,:;:.: : :.: :: =: :.::'::':: : :-:: :-: :::.::: ::: : :.: ::: :::::: :...:':!'

:,12g. Were, yoa ever ptherwl$e Involved In detaIne,e Int~rvI~w$,or Int~rrOgat(Qn$, with Jibrl""FBI perspnn~17-

:"'

"

-

0' Yes

0 Nb'
:'
':please describe:As the Gper'atibJis SuperYi'sor, I tevieweCf ali record' :of interview.s' ofdetainees: intetViewcl! ::
:bY FBI personnel in the ITO. Many ofthese'interView5'were,c6ndLided jOintly w'ith,nori":FBI personnel. I .
:sat in o'n-discussions,·of Interview strategies'with ·case 'agents and reviewed and prioritized lists of
ipfPPOse9 intervi~w~'of det~in~es, ,r ~!~o sup~rYJs~, intervie\A{~ in CQ~t!n§cfipn Witl) sp~)ric; .inve;stig$l~ipn!?' :
:s\Jch -8$ bQmQihg rnatters;o( th~ hori1itid~ :6f U,:~, c;ivilians :d uri rig wliitfi.,I:')III<35 deplQyea to vilrio.Us :ar~a5 'bf:.
:IFaq with sn1allteams:of FBI SA's to"co,nd uct.sj:>edfic invist1datiori's.
'
,
- -.- -~ _._~-- --,-,-.- --- --'-.- -.- --.-.- - -.-~- -.~
..
----.- .

-

- --

- -- - ---

- ---

--

-- - -.--

----

~:Ilh-~" ,
A. Train'ing Prior. to Overseas Deployment ,or Assignment
is', Old. Y04 fe<:eiye, any'trafning, 'lns'truetioo, 'p~ gl,lidal')ce ~p~ifiqally in 'prep?fation for any 'Of your
~ye~sea~ <t~pl()ym~h~s.or~s$.j~nm~ti~s1'

qq. who pr9vid¢d

eyes

DNo
000 Not·R~cal{
thTs trairilnq, ili'structi9'n, or guldqrice,:an,d wher~~id Y9Li (~celve

h7

OIGQ-004984

b6
b7C

u.s. milit,ary and FBl perspnnel
13b. O~scribe tl)~ subject on which you receJve~ ,thi~,trajl'JingJ tnstruction or gL,Ji9anc~'.
I received training ana military equipment at ft. Blissr; Texas by' military personnef
concemirg the ITO operating environment" medi~l<: and 'WMO. ~ re~lved t'ralnln-g :by
fB.I perSQnnelat Quantic'Q, Vif'g'inia cpn~eming th~ FBJ',s misslon';and role in .the -:qa,
. th~ FBI's sjJ~ific cQlle~ion fequiremen.t.s.,c;md f9rce protection issues: relating to FBI
'personnel. LalSO'patticipated with the Qn-:S~erie C.ommander-and the D.eputy Dii-S'cene
Commander in a series, of briefings' by various_units:at F8IHQjusf. priGr to, deploying.
0Y¢~,
.
:0 No,
'OOQ NQt R~an
14a, WhQ provided :thiS training, jn~frucJ:i9n.j qr g~i9ance, a.nA wh¢(e pjd YQu receiVe iff.
F,IH p'ersonnel a~Q!:laNi!,=o' and ~BtHQ
140, Briefly'.desGribe the sUDstam:e,ofth'e .tr'i:lini'ng,. ir:istruction" ~tuidanee pro,vided ro;You.
We.were instru~ed j:o cqntluc.t ol,lrselv'es in ln~erviews !Hilizihg the san'l~ ,stand,a(cl.s
employed ,by fBI SNs.,working LI1 the: U.S.. The,:only" deviation: fromour existing,
procedures i'nvolved the .use'of Miranda warnings which were n0t required in interviews
c9nd4~ted, fQr i.ntE\!l.fg~Q(:E p!.lrpos~.
'
loi1e;. Was:any of the, training, 'instructIon, or guidance provide::! in writing_?
'OVes, ONp :~ Do, Not ~¢calr

or

,bYes

eNo

,000 Not Recall

16,. In pJ:eparation for anY',oJ.your ,6Ve'rs~5, deployments,pr assignllJ~:htSl',d'id'you recejve,:any training" ,

you

instrLiCtionror guidance concerning what
wer.asiJpposed to, do If you ,observed .or heard about
or interrogation'of detainees by FBI personnel,. which' you believed to
I;>e IrjaP.'pt'<!P.f1a:Wr 4np.rofesslo,na!r"CQen:b.r.e, :~bu,~IV~, -9r, unJ~Wfun

the~treatment, interview.r.

:QNo

1,7. In'-preparation 'for. ahy ,of'your overseas deployments or assgnmentS,.did y(m recelve:·any. tralnl'ng,.,
i'n~ntGtion, or,gyidgfl~ co.l.'ltemii19 whatyol,l were:suppo,~ to d'o'if'yeu obse,r;v~d or-heqrd,'q,b0ut"
the treatrn~nt,lnterview,Pf Inten;~gat!~n o'f petalriees by: n"on-FIU p~rs9hn~l(whlch Y0I,I bel[$ved
to be ina'pprbpriate,lUlprbfessional, c6.e.rcM~', abusiv.e, or unlaWflJl?·,

,0No

.lB. Train!ng During

0.00 Not Reci311

I

(j.ver~~as D~p[oymentsor'ASsi,gn.m~nt;s

18, During any of'Y'Qur overseas'de,p,loyments of' i:}$sign'rl1erifs., dip you r¢.ceive ,anY tr:a'inirig, fnstru:ction','
,or-gLiidance.CQnc~rnlhg tlje. standards of.G'ond.i.fq:applitabl~ to the.treatment) inteNiew,

inlerro.gation,of detainees by FBI pers,onnel'?

or

.

'

~0y"es
.ONo
Od,D Not Recall
18a. Who, provided this training; instruction{'Dr:guldance? ,
On-Scene Commanoer'} D.eputy- Qfl-Scene Commander, FBI leadership iii theater.
lsb. edeflit':descrlbe the substance:6f the trairiing, in'$(Uq:ipn, ,or' g:uld..anc,e, P,foVlded, to YO,i.!.
Ea~h r.o~~U()n Of f~I emprpy~~ In '~b~ tTq was, instruq:~~ -to c;:'o/ld!:ld therp~lve~in:~

OIGQ-004985

manner consistent wi,th- policies anq p,rocedure-s utilized ,by FBI SA's in th~ United
State·s.
l8c,. W~s,any pf th~ Vaining, 1i:l~tructi9.n, bt gUid;;m~e provld.!=d j!11Nri~lng7
DVes
ON:o (!) D6 Not Recall
1.9.0ll,ring aii¥ ,of yqu I.' Q~er$~a'S:d¢ploYil1.!=nts or assignil1~nt.s{piq'YQU .rec¢iv~ any't@ining, ihstry.lctiqn;
or',gOidanee.t6ncernin'g the ;~tand,ards,of conduct 'appIiGa~le. to the.l:r.eatment, ihtelView~, or
inletrogafion ,of detailiees I)y non-FBI personnel?
.'

.0 Do Not Recall

@No

,2.0.. l:;>urin:g arty. pfYQur oversea's de.ployment~ pr assIgnments, did you

rece.ive any-trainin'g, in:strutj:iorf,
.'
or',9lJidance concerning what'you,were su pposed to' do if you ,ob..se(ved ,or heard 'about tfJ,e,
treatment, interview" or interroQati0nofdetainees' by FBI per-sonnel f whicn you believed to be
Inapprqprlate,',ul1prore$~IQn~J,coerGfv~j. abusfve~ Qr unli3wri,Jj?

:<:!),Y'es

ODo Not R,ec~l{

ONo

ib~. Whp provided ttlis trainirig y instruqioll", orgu!qance1

FBI leadership In theater
:,20b. BrleflY'descrlbe the subst~lIice:ofthe trarrilng, Instructio.n', Qf gUldam~e provided to:YoLi..
AnYVlolation ofFBtppliti!=s'arid pro(edure~/vI{¢r.e.tQbeJ~P9rt~ ~o tile' jh:-th~9ter cnain

of.C0mniand.

'

,20,l=. WaS<,!'il1Y pfthe, trainin'9r 'irstru¢tion, :qr 'guidant,e' pr9vfd~ In' Wrl~rjg?
,
aYes
ONo
,~, boo Not Recall
.
,21. Dur.ln:g ~riy ofYQut bV~fsE:;a's dep,loyme,nt:s Qr a$'slg hhl,¢lit$, :diCl yo,u .rec~iye any'training, instr.J.lc~i~ri·,
org uidaliee.c6hc~tnIng what yb,Li were.su pp'osed to; do If y.ou ,observed ,or hea rd about:the
·treatmentr interview, or interrogation of detainees by non!'"f'BI personnel, which you believed to
be inapprqpriAt~;unpr9f~ssional,coerciver'a,~us,v,~,'or'Unlawfu11

·Ie.. Adeq uacy of Tra'ining
22. In Yb'tlr'ppjt1iOh, .(iid you ~e~eiVea:deq~ate, trajli'ihgr in$.irJ.!diQo; 6r gpid!'i'nt~ rdating" 'to' ~a iid,ard s
;of oonduCt by'FB-Umo non-FBI persohnel relatln~ to'treatment! JiitehlleWt or interrogation .of
:detainees prior to your deploymentm assignment?

dyes 0 No
22a,- PI~a-s¢ d'~db~,iti~;·w~v~~iii· which\~~u -b~1 ie;':e th~ tr~i~i~~:' ih~i~ctk:,~

6niui(j~~~e ~was -. ,

.. - .- ,

inadequate:
' .
..
.
While most FBLSA's deployed to' the ITO were experienced investigators who .understood the dynamics'
9f int~rvlewi.!TIany'ha:c!.never been, ~P9$e~ to'rn!lit~lY in,tenog9tio'1 Slne! ,were. unf9.tniHar With tbe
teJ;hni,qlJes Which were pe'rmi~~lbIEnoextraq: ta~!kai ~attl~fi.erd, inforrn'i3dorr from:anen~my ~bmbajant
or t~rrorist. FBI a,g~rits typita\ly tong.uct theit'jobS in a: perrni~siv~ pp,erating ~ri\l.irqnii1,ent, conducting
InterVieWs_of suspects for the puf'pose:.of gathering information to su'pp6rt ,elemehts,of'a ,speciflc.ei'lme.
Military' and lntelJige'1(;e Service, Operatives' cpnduct intervieyvs anq 'Ihterrogatipns (or different
purposeS'. Uhder:stahcHng the,.difference and knoWing ,what techniques were, p~tmissilil¢ by the mili~ciry

OIGQ-004986

23.Ih, your'opl,:!io.n, d:id' yo.u refei\1e .a,9~gL!C1te ~raln[ng, Instri;Jl=ti~n, 9r'guld..~nce relating t,o !itand,ards
of eonduct by FBI end non-FBI personnel relating to treatment/ ihteNiew, or interrogation of
detaInees during your deploymerit-or assignment?
'

OYes

0

No

---~--------~-----~-----------------------------------

23a.

------.----------

pje~s~ d$¢ribe the wrays'ln'whi,ch. yo", b,~ne'(.e th.e trajning, instl'l.!ction or gUid'ar1t~ Was

iQad.equate:
, The :s.tantla rd S oy :which Hn. :SA's .we[e:'expeoted to fu'nGti0n were .dea'r ana <:1 iCi hot deviate fmm
practices ,utilized In the .u.,S, , Any. Inadequacy In training related to what the acceptable standards of

~ S~J1c{\JnJ2!gr}pUlli\r'( ~Q9.. Ln!~I~g~.!1s.e~~T!ise:,Et;,r~<2.J.1_n~'-,so:..n~'igtrJ;g j~tt~efi~IQ,j'!t~!!~~aj;i2D~ _'~

~ _,

24. In 'your opinion/ dfd' y.oll receille,adeq,uate tralning r instruction/ or.guidanee:concerning what you

were su:ppgs:~ ~9'do ff%u :pbserv~ gr h~~rd apl;?ur the ·tr~i3~~entr l,ntelYl~w,·Q['ln.t~rrpgaJI9n of
:detainees~ bV ,FBI ,or oblj-FBI personnel,-that YQu beli~V~d Was i11appr.9priat€:, df1P.rOfe,sSiQrial,
coercive, abusive, or unlaWful?
.
' .

Q y~

<!?, NQ

-,?~a.- PleasedesGrib~'t~e w~i~-jn'W-hi!:h'you -beif~YE/th~ .~ai~~g: in~tr~qtiOn 0r:gU.i~~~ce ~was --------,
ioa"deq uate:
,Guici'ana,e Gonten:iirig. the ~oncfue;t of FBI pe,r;sonnel Wa's;\!e'ry dea,r-re,port 'it to, your cnain-of-~,tnmalid.,
What constituted 'ihappr.opriate, 'abusive/ hr coe'[cive'.behavior duri'og,:a militarY: interr.og,atio'n,of:iHl

~

enemy'combatant:or terrorist was'less clear.
t...',...

_'."

.:

........... _. _ '4' . . . ;','

"~'"

i

~

•

_

<_,

I' ...... _

1,

.....

01

•

_.

'. , ...

to/'

w.

.......

~.

..~.

••' .. .. _. .,....

• _ '"

.,).0

~

• _

..

•

•

25. (Optional) Tn whilt ways can the FBI impt0v.e,'trainihg on this s'ubject for fuflir.e deployments, or~sslg nm~nt$1

, Hay.~'.mlJitarv. alJd/or In~ellJgenc;:~~omml!fll.ty p.~JsonT)elpr.ov!Q~ pr«;l,deployment ~ri~fings to' FBI'
p,:ersonnel ~prl'f~rDing What)~ aC,t;~p'taQI~ In tenns.. of In1eJr~~Clt,on t~~hn!ques:. C,~arJY qe_lIn:e?li~:~pr FBI
perso,noel'Wh'at J::ohstitutes liiapp.r~priate~ unprofesSional/ cberdy..e!.abusive/a~d ,LinlaWfuI.behavior.

:iQ~ P,lea~e ,provide:any ~dd it(onal jnfufll)atjon:~ql1cernin!r training for'ov;er~e:a~ d-epl0ymen,t;s' or
a~s,ign'm~!its'qf F!3rlJ¢r~,Qnnel YQ.I,J 'beU~~~ is r~I~.v~J.lt;,

~~~@?;~~~~'

." -,,' : :' .-""

lJ- .' ,,~.o':"" :-_,,~~@1:,~~""'~,(,~'2-:;';",'
Introduc~ion .fa Par~ ';UJ:; Itt: ~his, ~'e~~ion; ..w~, are ~~~ing, ipTorrn,qtion reg a~d ing ,q wig~: (qJlge of

'IntervJ~'A/ or Int,er.rpgatton .t.ec~nlquesan'9 Qt~,~r.,typ,es·
YQU

of det9Inee,~re?tm,~rJtalle-g~ ~o h'Cl.v~ 9'c;cu n:ed.,

should nQt:iissLHti'e, 'j!Js,t b~,u.se w,e.~re.i:l,sklriQ· abQut a.par.Hcular tecbniclu.e OJ' pr:aCtice( lh~t we have'

In

.conclUd,ecL th::lt 'it. fact,o'~l2lJrred. We recog hize ,that some of these teehnlqties.or praCtices m~y, at.tTrries
,be n~lZeS?Clry for,safety'~.lJd ~ecuiity; In '8 'cfet~fltjon s~ttrQg. In',,?\dd~i9n(~e rec9gnjz~ that sO,meuf'the~e
Je<;hriiqy_~ gr ,pr§ictiG~ may ~Clye be~h ai,1~hori~ fqr use: I!Y niili~s1.ry qr gt;,her g~\{ePin'l~!1t ,persQn'riel.

With r'e~"p'ect tb eat,h 'identified techriique~ practice.r Of tYpe -of tofiduct.d.escribed below, we ',are seekin~

OIGQ-004987

J!1f'ofll1ation 'abQut its occ4rrence durillg or inconnectio'1 w.ith the inter:view·<;>r interr,ogation of a
:cI¢taln.~~/~r dQring; th~.det~n.ti.OJi-of'a 9.etain~e. beypnd what i~'-h:ee~ed'for saf~ty and ,se!=urity:
In .that d>ntex~,we'
ask you to. .tell us .w.hether one .or mon:: of the foJlowi.lJQ ,St:aternents .are true:

will

1.. I'personally.observed this.conduCt.
~: ~ -gbsery~(d~tai.r:'tee(s) in a .col1djtl~n thC'lt: led. me·to peHeye filatthl~' condu~ nad' occurred.
3. Deti?iO~(~) toll:! m~: tha.! t.hls c;ond!,Jct h~d .QCOJrr:eq.
'
,4. Oth'~rs; whci 9.~serv¢~f this c6np,tll:t de5~r.iQe.d it J:9 rri~"
5. I nave relevant information Classified abOv.e "SECRET"',
.ff. r never .observed this conduct nor heard 'about it from -someone.who dld.
;27. Deprii;rio~ a deta'joe'€' of fop-d, or water
a.

0

~ personally, obse.fVe'(J this .c·otii:lUf::t.

b.

q

I:obserVed .detainee{s} in .a..c::ohd ition that led me to. believe that:tliis E:onduct bad .oc::turretl.

t. O'loetainee(s) tOld me that this conduct haa oc;cufred.

d.· O. 'Others who .observ.ed .this cond uct described it to me.
e:.

0 r ha\l~ rel.evant Infgrmatlofj <;Iassi.fl~d. ~1?ove. I~S!=C~E:T"·.

f:

M I, nev,erQb~en(eeJ

lao

o

this (;ol)d u<;t nbr h<:Xj rq lCl,bbl)t it lr9mS9lJ1e~:mew~o dieJ..

jf persaoal{y,oDseiV.ed this.conduct.

t,

o .!I ~obse'rVed, defalnee'(s} liJ a,tbnd itlon'that letl.m.~ to belieVe that ttlis condUct had ,oecuHeCl.
o {Oetaihee(s) told me .that this conduCt had .dccur-r.ed.

d.

d

b'.

'

tOthers who observed this c0nduct de~cribed it to me,

e.,

o II have relevant Information claSSified above "S.ECRET".

f.

o 11 ne~ero.\Js~rved, thi~>cond.oct nor·hear~

about, it fromrsomeon~'w,hodid.

'29:. D~privi.oga deta'ir)ee: c;>f $leep" 91' ilJterIVpting ~(eep QY fretl\.l:ent:cj811 relp.c~~i9ns or 9th.er methods

.io.

0 I persOnally- obserVed this conduct.
0 I bbser~ed detairiee(s) in ~a cP.i:Jditi6h that led me' to

c.

Oetalnee(s) told me that this. conduCt had .occurred.

a.

q

d. g
..

e,
,

Others. who oDserved this' condiIct d.escribed it

belieV.e tlfat'thl's co MoCt', fici'd :ocCl.J'iTed .

to ITi~.

relevant information Classified above "SECRET".·
0..... Lhave
....
.. ... .. --- ... .. .....
'

. ....

OIGQ-004988

'II[[JI n~\ler observed this cond~ct nor'heard about'l,t from som~o~~ Wh~·dld.
g,. Please provide tl1~ ,approl{im~i~e time frame duri,ng, whien t,his,col')dyctoecurred~
FrQm' Oi/25j20Q4, to' OS/Oi/2004 '
00,0' Not Recail
h. ~he.detaine~'(sl treat~d )n this way were located at ~he ~ime In:
1;
Guantanqmo

q

Z '0"Irqq
3. 0 ~fghanistan
'1: 0 Other Lo.cation
50 Do Not Recall
i. PI~s~:!d¢,ntliyth~',d~taln~C~)
Ullkhown
'

by ncl'rne and. nlJrnb,~r;' .
.

j. ,Please identify the, person($) Wh~ heate'~ the. tJ:~taine~(s) in ihl? mCjnnElr., fncluqjn.9 ~~eir
nahle{sLar'id go\l~rrfm'eht agen~(fe~):
It W;;ls: rela'led to'me by. FBI. persohnel cohductirrg interviews at detentioo'facllities in the ITO: that
theinilitary and U..S. infelligence,agencies used sleep deprivation pnif location rotations as part of.
their: oo.r:mal Inte~rogatlon .te~t'!.nlq ues. FBI' p,ersqJ].nel 1!"ere JJlstruct~ not to participate'ln. these
te~hniql..le's and JO. t,ollP l,lct them~~I~~ in t.he $arj're. manrier:tbey cQnQu~t ,i:h~m.selves .irnhe ·U:S~

,~. Pie,ase' Id~~tify any '9tl~er FBI p~r~nl')~1 or ,non-F:B~ personnel WheY,o,bserved det~Jnee($} tr~ated
in thjs manner, Including their ha/Jle('s) and ag~ncY(ie.s):
FBI pe'rsohnel'assigned detainee interviews durihg, rotation Sand 6.
I. This .conduct .0ccurredOin conneCtion ,With:
t;O O,ne detainee
2: '¢ :Sell,eral detainees. (Z-'4J
q 0 Many 'det~jl;1!=es' (roQre; t!l~n 4)
4 '0 Dp Not Req:ili

I do not recall the names of the.:speclficS'A~'swho brought this to' my 'attention. DurIng my
d.~pi9ym,~,nt to '~raqr, I in.strlJetet! the, $~l~ reporting:. t9 m'~ lQ ~orrdut~ th~rnl?ely~~ in :the SCjlJ1e Way
'the,y.wer~ 'ex~ttM, to CQriqu~t,th¢tn'servss
the U.S..

in

'39-. Beating d ·de.tah:r~e
D I personally observed this cOiiduct.
b. D I...obseIYetl detalne~(s) Iii ,'C\.colid itionthat led me to, belieVe tbafthis tOh.duq haa \octeun:ep.
t. D Detainee(s.) told 'me that this ton'd,uct had occurred.
d. D Others' who obserVed this conduCt described it to me.
e. D l' have relevant Information classified abov.e nSECREr".

,a.

OIGQ-004989

3:1. lls(ng, water to prey~nt'breathing py a c!etain~ or to create the ~en~tlol] pfclr~wnJng

a. 0 I p~r.sonal~y observed this conduct.
b. D I obsery¢d ·detainee(s} ill 'a cond'itiQn that led me: t9 beli~ve that this; Cor'lQ\.Ict ha,~ occurred.
G.

o

·Oetai ne¢.f.s) told tne that ttiis

co!1d l1ct had :occuited.

e.

0 Others' WDO obsetited thiS cond,uet described it to me.
0- r have'Jele:vaht information classified above "SECRET".

f:

0

,d.

.3-2,

1. never observed this~conduct nor heard abQut it from.someone. who did.

Using 'hands, rope, 'or';anything' else toc;.hok~ or strang le:a detainee

.
a'. 0'-11' perS0i1aJly:ob~erv.eq this,:c~nMc.t.
b.. D l' observeo .detaine,e(s), in :a~c6fiditibn that led m~ to believ~ .that this- conduct had :bttLirreCi.
c.

D

Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had ,occurred.

d.

D

oth,ers' who obseriied thiS conductd,escrlbe<:t It to me.

,e.

o II have 'relevant iofliirmation classified aD0ve "SECRET"'.

f.

0

I never observed. thiscohduet nor 'tleard 'aDoUtit frbm,seme6ne who, dii:l.

'3-3, Threateningot,her ~q:(O!1to'causep!1Ys!\:Cl1 R~jn" fnjuryr dfsfi'gurement, (;wdeath

C.

D·it pers9oa1iy: b15serv¢i!' this 'conduct.
D II obi>e:r:v.ep d,etal,liej;~(~) In d 'coJ:1,d.itlon that led. me to believe that thiS. c.on,duct' ha~' occurred.
o jDetainee(s) taid me .that this conduct had :occurr.ecl'. '

d,

o

a'.
b.

IOtherS' who ·ob.seNed this conduct p'esdib~d It to' m,e,

I 0 II have relevant Information tlasslfiE:~d ab6~e "S'ECRETOl"
1!J.0'!I neVer O'Dserved this,conduct nor'heard about it froni someone,who did,
e:

_ . I . - _ _ , , __ - _ _ _ _ ._ .."..

-__,.. _. _,__ -- " ___, ,,,, ... '.....

' ___....".,,, --,,,.".__ ...._._ .. '

. ...-- ... -... ..... -.........

'-

34" Other tr.eatment or aqi0!l causing, Sjg.[1ifj~clnt P~Y:S!caJ p,ain o~ injurYb or ~ausil1g disftgure.rnen,t or

d~~th

OIGQ-004990

a',

( personally'ob~rved this <;ondu~t.

b,

[-observed detainee(s) in:a conditign that ied. me to ~~Ii.e.ve that this conpuctt had occurred.

0
0
c:. 0
g. 0
e.

[j~t~ineefs}tdll) m~ that this c;on9~ct had oCl;:urred ..

Otbers' who 9bs~ryM. thjs ~oJid L!ct des~iibed It. t9 me.

o Ii !i'pve r'~~va'rit infqrm'atiotl cIassifi¢,d above. "s EGRET" •

f: ~ I. n:e~er 9b~erv.ed thl? conduct npr h~r~ 'ab~lJ.t it from s.oll1etme. Who' t;lLd,

35. Placing a detainee on a h6tsurfclce o:r bufnirrg, ·a·detainee

a.· 0 (per;sonalJy ob~rvec;! tht~'COfl(;luGt.

I? '. 0 1. o.bserveq ·d#aln~e.c s) in 'a :e9n~UtJQ II that led, .m~ to qelieve th9Nhi~. cqn:QUq:. had q~c~r(<;q,
D~ti3ine~(s):told .me thqt thjs: cc:>nduct hi3d 'occHrr.ec\.
~!, 0
<1. 0 Qthers- wh9 :qb'ser:v~d this. J;;Qnd!let d.~(:r,bE¥l it tQ' r:n~~
e'. 0 L have r'e:I~v~mt information '~Iijssifie:d ab,Cive "S:ECRET"',
f. 0 r never oDserved thi!?"c6nduc.t r'lor'h~rd -.abol!t it fr0ni'sOm'e()ne_wh~did.

.3:6. Using .sha'Ckles.or other restraints.iira prolohged ,nianner

0 r personaf.l.Y'op~rved tti'l~ t;onquct.
b', 0 ~ q~serveq 'detairiee(s) in :a"cQnd it,ioH that led me to' beiieve that. this- condu'ct
~;
0 Q~~.aJne€;($) told 1Jl~ thc:1t. tnis e.9ndu~t ~i3'd 'o'q:\ln:~.
d. 0 Others: ~ho 'Ob~erV~~ ):hj~ l:Qndqct-d~s,~rlbed it to me.
e, D' !r have .releyant inforniatiOn: 'classified (!fbbv~ "s EC~Er'",
a:

b9~ oC;:Gurrec:!..

f, 1£1. I n~y.¢r obseN~d' ~nis:cplidQ~t t1pt h~rd '~:'iij(,-u~ it '(rom 'sdrTi!='pne;Whi;), did.

3'1. Reqt:Ji'rlng

a. 0
b, 0
,

a.detalr.iee~to

maltYfalii r or restraining a detalr'iee

I: personally o,bserv~d this ·~qndu~t.
r;ob,seryed detaJ.nee(s) In a reondJtlo11 thc;it led me to' b~lJeve ,th:aqh!s condyct h(;ld 'Occurred.

'<;'.

o IDetaine~(s) tpldlile t/lqt this coh<Wct hpd -qcqJrreq,

d.

D.

..- ..

In, a stressful or pahifUI position

Othel1? vyh~ 'o~~rveg th!~ to~4u<;:tdAes.~.ribe.9
.. ....

.

.. ...

-

'

. .

.. -.. -

.. ...

it to m~:

. ..

-- ..

..

...

..~.-

.

"-- ......¥_-

OIGQ-004991

e. 0
f:

0'

t ha\le releYant Informatlon dasslfled above ·!SECRETw•

[never observed this conduct nor heard about it from someone who'did.

3S. 'Forcing a.detainee to pei1o'nn demanding p'hysical exerclstr:

a. 0
p. 0
6- 0
d.

0'

p¢:rs<inally oBse:r:v~d this,tOhCi!Jct.
bb~rv'et1 defaine~(sJ in 'a.conCIitior'l th'at led me to bel1eve

thanhls co"rldud had oc61rr.ed,

Detainee(s) told me that this.oor.:futt had.oeturred.

Othe'fs who obsehled this tond ilct described it to" me

e. 0

L have relevant Intormatlon dassified abo!ole;':SECREP.

f.

L never-observed thls,conduo! nor'heard apout It from someQne·who did.

O.

:9.. P!~~se. prov!9:e thg ap'pro>~ilJ!~t~ ~ii']1e "'{Tame ~4r(1)9 ..w~ic~ ~t}js'€9ndlj~t- o~a)rr~·
From dit~SI2Q04IQ· QSI01)<0d4
ODe; ~ot Recall
,h. The detafne.e{~) tT~at~ In ,~hls way were loc¥lted ~t t~ tJrn,e 'in;

1 P Gual)t?lI"@ffi'O
2 0'lraq
~ 0 Afgnanls.\;in

40 Other LocatiOn

5 0 Do Not Recall
I. Ph~ase;.,rd~ntlfy. tl1~~detalnee($:),I:lY na,me" aM numbi:!r:
Unknown

'j. Please i~e,ntify the:person(s) who,tre.clt~ the. Q~tainee(s) In "this ma.nner., incLuding t~eir

ri~n1~rs) an'Q govE;rnrhJ~ht .agefl!:Y,(I~):
FBI SA's-mnd,'Lictirig lnteNiew~:it..detention fatiUties'fn lr'aq described the useiif Phy-skal Tridnlri,g

by military.and intelligen~ servk:e· interrogi300rs..as an ·interrog.alion tedlnlq,ue.

'

\C. Please idenlifya"ny":bttrer f~I persOhnel iit nOn-fBI personnel'wM. obseliled detai.nee(~J treated
in this manner, including their name(s) and -agenGY(ies)~
~a[19US FB:I personn!'i!:l

i".

'rhis conduct ,ol:om,e.d

in i:onli..ed:lon .witH:

1 D One,dej:a.lii~
2

3

.0 ·s~.etai detailieE$. (2-4]

a Many detainees (rrtorelthan 4,)

4" ,~, Do Not Recall

m. (Optional} .PleaSe~describe-the,rele'Y'ant cfrcumst"iuiceS hi m.ofe,:detall:

OIGQ-004992

FBI personnel described to, me the m ethod of using PT as an interrogation technique by U.S.
mllltary a,nd intellig e,nee, seJXlce 'personne!. I do. not recaIJ the Identlties'of the SA's who discussed
th!s '~ith rne during rotation 5 and 6. FBI p,er?p:nnel wer~ in~rw;:ted n~~ to. p~rticfpate in or· "

cQildone:the.\Jse of t~hhlq!l~s·:O,t.her·agentie~ Wele bt may haiJ~ b.~nautliQrlzeQ to Utlliz:e:.~hd
were further instructed to cOnduct themselves. the same way they ,conduct themselv.-es in the U.s..
39. UsJnl;1. electric;a( ~ho'ck on a' ct,etainee

'.a. D I personally observed this:co nduct.
b,
<;:~

d~

D
D
D

I observed detaihee(s) in-a.condition that led me to believe that this conduct had occurred.
Oetainee:(s) tqld lT1e th;;l~ this ~0nd uc.t had'qcc\l rreg.
Q.thers who obse!yecj th.ls con,d uct Gescrlbed It, to me.

e. 0 i have

f. 0'

rel~yant i,n(ormation

d assifi,ed i;lboye "S.ECRET'!"
r i'l!=ver ob,s~l\fe,d thiS CQI19.utt nor heard ·8l:!QU.t it f.rQffi so.meol1~ W.hQ (lid.

,,40.. ThT.ecitetfirrg tQ .us'e eJ~ctric~I'sno

a,

D, 1: perSdrlally o.bserved this.co'nduct.

b.

D

c.

D. ![jetainee~s)

:e.

D

I 'observed' detainee(s} in 'a 'coFldition that led me to believe that this conduct had:occurred.
tQld me that tqis ~ond~~t~qd·ocCij~red.!

-f"[j"
,
d.,
IOther? who ,opserY,ed t~i~ GO

I have Teleyant infQrmC!tion ~I as,slfieq abo\r~ "SEC,RET".>

f 0" iI neyer'9'bs~lV~d this 'cqDd~c t nor h~\d !=l,bQ!Jtit from~omeo.ne.

who qid,.

-4:1. InX~ntl9'n<:iiJY delayln'g :or:dEmyin-g
a.

D

iI personally observ.ed this C0nduct

'b-, D [observed detalnee(s:) in 'a'Gand ition- that led me to believe that this conduct had ,occurred:
c D.IOetainee(s) told me that this conduct had ·occurred.
~!

e.

D Otl)ers VVtlO opselYet! t,hi,s ~p, nc!uctdesqibeg I~ to r:n~::
D t bave reIevarit I'nfQrmat!olT classifled abov~ 'is.:ECRET'\

l: 0'

I ne\fer'ob~erve9 this 'co!ldu~t 'Dor ,he?lrd 'about. it .from .sqmeone who dj<:!,

,.

OIGQ-004993

,
r blihdfolding a .detainee.other ,thah during ti'ansp6rtatio'n

,

0
b, 0
G. 0
'd{ 0
e. 0
t 0
a,

I

I perso nally .observed this. conduct.
I:obse rved detainee(s) in a'.conditiorr that led me to believe that this conduct had occurred.
petai nee(s) told -me that this conduct had ·Ql;:fUrra;!.
OttJers whQ o~sery~q this cEmduGtd~Gri.bed ~t to m~
I.have relevant inrormation classifi~ .ap-ove "~EC~'!,

I never O,psl;.rvej:! thrs'COricll!~_nor'heard about it frqm sqmeqne whp dia.

g. a ~~.t!31hee tp ,~><tt¢m~IY, l;:q11:l or ho~ (oqm t~ri1 perat.IJJe~· for ext~ntled p~ri.o.ds,
0.

0

. nally 'observed this .conduct.
I perro

b,

0

I.obse rved detainee(s) in 'a'cond ition' that led me to belieye that·this conduct had ,occurred.

c.

0

Detal nee(s) told me that this conduct. had ,occurred',

can-d.ud
described it to. me..
0 Qt!:Jers who 0bserved this
,
.
'eo 0 I hj:lve r~(evant iJ:(f9rmg~iQn 'C;lq$sifi~ ap.9ve "S..ECR.ET'! ..
T: 0 I nev~r' o,b~~rv~,9 tNs ,ec,>ricj u~t nor h~ r~ .~ bou~ IJ f(dm, solJ1ec>n~

d.

. '

"

Whp- did.
:

44. -SU bj,ectin 9 a

d.etainee.

to '.iQuc!. .tTll:.isJ~

a-. 0 I per-so, nally observed thls,{!onduct,
.l
b. D·I-observee! dehlihee(s} iii..a cond'itlQ'o'thcit led me to, believe thatlhis· condu·d:· had .occu'ri'ed.

~ q

Detai nee(s) told me that this conduct had ·occurred.

0 Ot~ers.' INl)o observed this q>nd uct d'escrlbed it to m,~•.
'e. 0 t ~ave J~levarit inform,9ti9n classifte.d pbQve "SECREj'II,.
t: 0 Jn~yer-observed this·condud nor heard aboutit .from someone: who did..
d,

•

'"

"'.

'

....

,.

••••

"-.

•

...

<

•

'"

• •'

• -

.".

."

~

-

•

-,."

••

,

•

.,

-

a i:I~_talne'e·tb bright flqshing

4$.

Slll:>i~.tjn'g

I

a',
·b.

0

I perso nall,y observed this conduct.

0

lobser.v.ed detaillee(s) in a..condifion that led

Co

0

Qetal nee(s) told me that this condud had occurred.

fi~ht.? pt'tlqrkries~

me to believe thaUhis conduct had .occurred.

ld. Dlothe rs who observed this conduct described it to me.

OIGQ-004994

-,

,

-

0
f: Ii:f

I have relevant Informatkm classified above' ·\S,ECREr".

0
ti. 0
c. 0
,d. 0

I p~rs6nally obs~rVeg this,:contluGt.

e.

a.

--

..

*"

,

C>thers' who observea this conduct d.es{;ribed it to' me.
L have relevant information classified aho~e, I\SEGRET'I:..

ItI

I never.observ~d this..conduot nor'heard about It from 'someone who did.

-4-7.. Using duet tape tq

r~str:ainr gag I 'Qr pu ni$',h a~etainee

0 l' personally observed

tllis.conduct.

o II observed detainee's) in 'aco'Rd ition that. led me to believe -that this conduct bad ·occurred.
o 1[)~etalJ1e:e.(s) told me thcit'thl's. !2ondu.ct- hado_ccurred.

d.

o !others' who obserVed this roriduet desGribed .it to me,·

e.

0

I have relevant information E(assified .above "S'ECREf'l..

f.

0

I never observed this.conduct nor heard about'itfrom'someone'who did.

..48.

•

Detainee(s) told 'me that thiS. cood'uct had ,occurred.

0

o.

-

I.obserVed detainee(sJ in -a cond itio.nth'at led [m£ to believe that this co-ridUGt ha,o ,.o,ccurrep,

f.

b.

..

I never observed this:condud nor heard about it from someone who did.

'e.

a.

. --

Usil')g Ta-pic!

resp~>nsi'teams and/or fort,ed: $:eli extrpetibns

ier, 0 I pe.r:sonally o,bserved thlscondu(:t.
b.

t:
d.
e.

f.

D 'I ohserv.eei detainee(s) ih .a.conditiOn that. ied me: to beij¢ye that this- conduct had .o.ccurred.
D Detaine~_(s) told -me tnat 'this cohduc.t had -Oct.ulred.
D lothers'whb observed thiS cohduct described it to, me.
D I have relevant information .classified ~lbo\te '.'SECREP' .
0 r nev'er observed tliis -cohd ud no(heard 'g b01Jt: itfrom ,some0rie who aid.

OIGQ-004995

49'. !Jsinga

military working

dog o'n or hear 'a ,detainee' oth.er than dlJrlng ,detainee'transportation

0

I personally,observed this,.conduct.

C;:.

o !Lobserved detainee(s) in a,Gonditlon that led me to believe that this eonduct had occurred.
o IOetainee(s) 1:o1d me'that t~is' condu~t had 'Qccurre9,.

4:

0

Others Who obseryeq tb.i~ c()ndu~t d'escri.\Je,d

a~

b,

e.

It t9 m~.

o .L have relevant inrorm;;ltj<:m clasl?jfie,d ,al1ove "SECREf",.

r. 0'

I never observe"d thJs'com:!u~t,nQr'hearq abQlIt it from sqmeone'who did.

I personally:observed this.conduct.

b~

0
0

c.

d

Detalnee(s) to'ld me that this. conduct had ,occurr.ed.

'a~

I obser:ved detainee(s) in 'a cond itiorr that led me to believe that this conduct had 'occurred.
0

0 Qt,b'ers who observed this ~ol1.ductdescriped it to, me..
I h!=we relevant inr9rm~tiQn' clc;lS!?i'fied ,ab,~ve "SECRET",
~. 0
'(: 0 I never'observe'd this :coJid uct nor heard ,a bo.ut It from SOn1ebne who, dI'd.

d;

-.-

....

-,_. • •

•

..."

•

',.'.

.~

.....

",

."

•

'$

"

.....

-_.-

.-

S1. iJi.fJig :splders, s.corpion'S, ,snakes" ot:' othe.r animals, 00' Qrtiear a~detainee

a.
b',

tJ

r perSGnallY' obselVed this :eohduct.

o II:olise'rved delafnee(s) in 8;conaitiQrl that led' me to believe thanhis' conduct had ,occurred.

,

c. D·IOefainee(s) told me that this conduct had occurred.

d. 0
'e.,

0

Other? who Q!Jserved this cond U9t' dE!scrj~ed It~o m~

t have relevaD~ Inform,atlon c!assifie~ ~bove: "S~GREr"'.

f: lEI L n~ver'o,q§lerveq this

C<;>l1Q4~f'f19r.~earq ,a~<:)Ut it

from ·SQITJ¢<:>J1e:Wh.od.Jd"

5'~. ThJ¢a~~nirig to .use spiders, scqq:i,iQtfs, 'snal<;es" qr o~her anima'ls: o.n;a detciih~e

Q
b. 0
c, 0
d. 0

'a'.

I pe'!"sonally-o'bserved this ..c ondutt.
I observed detaillee(s) in 2Lco:nditioh that led me to believe thi3fthis conduct had occurr:ed.
Detainee(s) told me that this conduct had occurred ..
Others, who observed this conduct described it to: me.

OIGQ-004996

"

e.

D r have relevant Informa'tkm classified above '!SECRET".

f:

ItJ'

I never observed this conduct nor heard about it from someone who did.

,53. Disrespectful statements, han~lin9.rorlletronsinvolving:...t",",h;..;;<e"",~:i.;:,o~r~",,n,,--

a. D I persOti~lIy obS¢rv'ed, this t6n~uct.
b. D I bb'served d~rair'leefs) In ,a ,CO Ad itiofl' t.!1at; led "(ne ,to believe thi3nhis cond lid
c. D Detainee(s)told ~e that this conduCt had ,o,cturred.
d.

D

e.

D [. have relevant information classified above' "SEcRET'I.

f.

It!'

_

I
had ,o,tclirred.

others who observed this conduct described it to me.
I never observed thls:mnduct nor'heard about it from someone who did.

"Sil. Sh?\ving a ,det?\in~'s'facial or oth~r h,airiQ em'parr9S$.or humifrate:a detainee"

D r personally'obserVed this ..condtlct.
b. D I ,observed 'd~tainee(s) ill a cond ition that led me to believe that this conduct had ,o~c(Jjired.
c: D petalnee(s) told me thanhls e<:md.u.ct bad occurr.ed.
d. 0 othets' .who observed lh is GOnd ud: described it to me:
e. D ¥ have relevant information dassified abov.e '~5"ECRET".
f. 0 I never observed this,conduct nor heard about it from'someone who.did.

.a.

.
0 r: 15gr.,SCnally dbServe,d thls:conduc;:t.
b. 0 I bbserv.ed 'detaihee(s): 'ih ,a coiid'itibn that led me to b~lieve that.this· ~bhd(jct had :occurred:
,

~.

D Detaihee(s) told 'me fhat this conduct ha'doccurred.
d. D' Otliers' wbo observed thls conoUct d~scrlbed It .to me:

c.

ei
f;

0 I have relevant information classified ·aboVe. "SECRET"·.
0' r nev'er observed thiscohduct hor,heard :atkiut it'from Someone who did.

OIGQ-004997

56. Touchihg

a detainee' or acting toward a detainee in-a sexual :rrianner

a. 0 I personally observ.ed this..conduct.
b. 0 Lobserved detainee(s) In a.Gonditionthat led me to tJelieve that-thls conduct had occurred.
c. 0 Detainee(s) told 'r:ne that t~is' cend4ct had ·oc~lJrre9 ..
d.: 0 Ot~ers ~nQ .ob.serv~q t,~is cand uct descri~e9 it t9 m~.

o II. hav~ relevant inyormatign c1Ci?!?ifiep i3l!Qve "$.ECRET'!.
r. o I nev~r observe9 thiS 'cond ud !1Qr'heard a pou t it from sqmeqne who did.

e.

st. Holding deteiri¢e($) yJhp'Were npt officiaiJy'~ck.noWleQ.geCIor regi$tered a'~~l,Jdi

"d.eta I,n ln~rthe

person. '

....

byt'h~ agency

.

?!. 0 i p,ersonqlly Q.bs~rved th'is tcom;14ct.
b', 0 rO!?$erv~~'det~ln~'e(s1' In a:~9fld ItiQI-rt.hat-led me ~9 belley~ th~tt.hl~ cc;mdm;,t had 'Qc:rcu rr:8!1,·
c;

p

Detpinee(s) to_19 ·me. tha.t this:tOhcjUC~

had :oq::urre.Q.

.\;1, 0 9~h.ers Wh~ ob~ery~~ lhi~ Gpng!lct ~~:crlb~d it tl;>; rn.~:.

e. D. t h~'(e relevan.t IQfol1lJ~Jlon c1~~sifled 'c!!?dye' ".~.Et~Ef··.
f. 0 l'ii¢'ler oDs,ented this;c6ntlutt npr h~~d '.abol.!!:: it frdinSd,meone:\vhtt PIQ.

.58. Se'l)ding,a detainee to aJi6ther' cQuntry. for m6re..,aggressive interrogation
a.

...-:

b,
c.
d.:

.gjl per~nalJY o,Qserved ~his :~o.!1~uct,

.

o II obs,erved.. det9in~eJs} in'~ 'Go.ndlp~>n that led rne to' believe thatthis c;:onduct 'f}ad ·occurred.
o lbetainee(s) told mE;! t.nat tljis condlJct ~ac:l occ:;urr.eg;

o IOthe~ who ob~erve.d ,t/:)is ~.Qnp.uct desl=rlbe9 it; to !J1e.

e'. 0 r have releyan.t ilJformatiojl classified Ci b~lJe' '''--$:~C.REfI'.
f,

0

I n~ver oQs:~rved. this.:c9ndu{:t nbr hear~ :ab'pu.t it,frpm sC!rnepne~who:di~.

g:. piease prov,ide tlie approxim.cite tini~ fram.e. dU'rlng, which' t·liis,conauct. 6.cCtlrretl:
D,Dp Not Reqlll
Frem 01/25j2'OOA -to 05(01.(20'04
h. The ,d.eralnee(sJ treated In this way were: lo~ated ,pt t'he time In:'
f 0 '~l,1antanan-l'Q'

. 2: [~rlrBq
3D Afghanistan

OIGQ-004998

4 0 oth~r Locati9n
5,0 Do, Not RetQlI

i: PI~5e i,dentlfv. the detain.~(s) ,by 'riciri1..e ~rid number:
Un~n6wn

J. Please identify-the person(s) who treated the detainee(s) in this: in.anner;~ ina(uding their
name(.?) ?oq ·gov~rnme.ntu~gen!=y(i~J:
Central Intelligenc~ Ag,encY'

~.' PI~se IdE!otify ~:lTIY 9ther FBI p'er~9!ln~1 or nqn-FBI personnel :Wh~'Q~serv~.d ~e~alne~(s) tr~tet!
lnjhfs: manner, indU_oing their name(s) and ,agel')cy(~s):
FBI InterView personnel' rotation 5 and 6 '
.

I. ThIs:conductoccurred in connection wlth:-

1·0 'One detainee
~ 0 '~everal qetain~~ '('24)
:3 0 MaDY detainees '(mt;>re; than 4)
'40 D.o.N'ot RecaIi
m. (Q.ptioopl) PI~s~ de$crib~ the re!evqnt tircl)m~hinces in more:,q~t~l):

.On .ope:'oc~asi,ol1t;

t-~as'-Inforrned gy a .r!lem,b~r ofth~ ·F:.BI~~ Iil!lh V~l'!u~ Det~lfI~~ Interyi,ew team
~hatone~of the s~pjekts.
were iM~rYie'iYing was gQing"to b~ removed to .~,mt?th«::r c.o!lnt,lY by the:'
Cent@l Iflt~mgeJ1te AgE!IiCY (crA). As 1 recail" this 'c,aUsed u·~ tp ,st¢p up, Qut Interview tlmetaJji~;a.s,
we were ,g'oing to lose ,OUf -access to:1he.ind i,iid ual. J do not recall the 'iiam~ of the.5ubjel:! at the

we:

reasons'he wa's being removed from lraq.l·eannot say' itwas "for more aggressivednterrogation'!.

59. Tnrea,Jehfrig to send a detainee to a'nother country for detention or' more,a99' reSsiVi~ interrogatIon

a.. D. r persqnalIy' o;b~erve,9 tllis 'conduct.

fr· 0
c.

o

d; o
,-

[ obs~rv,eg c;let~in'~e(s) it.') ,a'c9nd ition th~t l~ me

tp

b~li~ve th~j: this co:tJdlJc~ f:t'ap oC:G~treQ.

:Det<;lin~(~) toJd rp~ that .this copd,~ct gad oq;wrect.
lOthers' woo pbser.vect :tnis cO.nduct d:escribed

it to tn~

Ie',. 1-0

11 have re1eV?lnt informati.Qn cla.ssified abQve "SEYREf"·.
J.!:- o ir- never o.b.s~rved' this ,m:nduc{ nor'h$ rd ,<;lbp~r It'from sQmepne who pkl.

6'0.

Threat~niiig

to take actioh,againsla detainee's family

a.

o ~ perso,nally'observed t~.i5>cQnduct.

b.

0.11 'observed d,et?l.ne~(s)

c.

I

in a:conditiQn that led lJ1e to belIeve th,,!,nhis q:>nduct nad 'Occurred.

n IDe~alnee'(s) told me that this tonduct had .o~curred.

OIGQ-004999

--

·"

d.

0

e.

0 r have relevant information classified above: "SECRET".

f.

~

Others who observed this conduct described it to me.

r n~ver'Qb~rved thiscontJuc~ nor hearq ,?bqut it from some0n.~ w~o girl..

'6:1,. Oth~r'tr~atmerit or aetlqn causing sevt=r~ em9~i9na[ qr psycl)ologiCal trauma tQ a ,get~ihee

a.

o II persd r') allY' observed this coriauct.

b..

0
0

e.

r .observed detainee(s) iii a,cohditibh that led me to believe tl1at tnis conduct h'ad,oGcuf.i:ed.
Detaihee(s) told me that this conduct: hadoccutred.

d. q Others who observed this cond.uct described it to me.
e. 0 r have relevant information' classified above \"SECRET'I"
f, 0 r ~ever observed thiS 'col)d,L!ct nor hecr~d ;abb~t jt f,romsorneone wh9 did,

~a.

o II perS9hal!y ,observ:~d

-

this .conduct.

e.

0
0
0
0

f.

~ 1, nev.er observed this,conduct nor heard aboutit from'someone'who did.

b,
12',

d.

~

I:observed. detalnee(S) in a,lc6nd.itlon, that led me to belJeVe that this condHct had ,o,ccurretl.
Detainee(s) told me thatthis conduet had ,6ccorted.
Otners who observed lthfs eondiJct d'escribed it to Jne.
I have relevant Information' classified above' '\SECREP'.

',6>3~ :Q,t,herlr~atmenl or:<:\ ~ej:aiI1~~ thR~ in'YQur opiri.iQJ1 Wa's, unl?rpf~qsipl')al, -undJ.Jlymr~h gr ~gg (es~!vel
;coe'ri=IV~f YilbusJve,. '.or unla)/'Jfu.1
'

a.

0 r personally o:bseiVed this ,conduct,

b. 0 I.oDseiYed detainee'(s) in ai:6ndition that led me

to.believ~ that. this G0'nduct.had occu'ffed.

c. 0 Detainee(s)' told me that this' conduct had 'occurred.

d.

o ,o~her~ W,ho observ~d t~is ~ol)duttq~s~r!bed

it. to l1'1e.

J~S.EGRET"'.
0 r have relevant information'classified
> . ..... above
. .'
,
.'
'f. 0' I never'observed. thiS
'cOhQUct
'nor
heard
'a
bout.
it"from
someone:who
dict.
. '..
.
...
.
.
.
.

e'.

~"

~

,

,

~

,

OIGQ-005000

BaYh ~.~@l~__

!I·

64.. DiCi ·Y9U observe' any imp~~s.onation of FBI personnel by anYQ.he.duJing an interview QJ·ihte[r.dgatl~n of

','
Yes
0, No

:aa~tainee?,

.d

\65. Old '~iiy q~tainee 9r ~~h~t person ,tell VQtl~hat he .qr' she had ~!tfle~$et1 the 'Ifh.per~natton ~f

fBr

p.ersoJ1.l1el -iii. c611'riectiort with:a deti:iiliee intei"view. o'r ioterrog'ation1·

.a. Yes'

{~, N'o'

66, A~~ you aware.of al)Y "~hamlf or "s~ag~" d~t-~i.nee·interv!ews·or'i,n~efr~atJ9l"\SCOJ1Ql!ct,ed for M,emo~rs

":Qf'thil!:~ c;qng~s,s ~r t,h.elr

shlffr

Q. '(~s

'

@

N9"

'

'67-, To Y'oqr' kn9wledger d,id af:\Y' military or in't'~lIigeI:)Gepersonn~1 e\f/:lr. deny or d,e!ay FBJ 'Clcc!=!:Ss toa·
'detaInee the FBI w~nted to 'qQestion .be·caus~"the_de~C\inee f)'aC;! .sustained Ihjuries 'a~er be- was captured?
QY:$~
~,Np,

.68', Did youe.ve~ ,end your- p,arficipation in or observation of a det<;linee interv.iew or interrogation
~'r;:~us~ 'of- t~e il1t_er'{~~ O( l,nterr.Qg~tlol1JT!etr.oq~'~el ~g :u~d.?

'

.6. Yes. ,0' No'

.69:. Were ybil ever toJd :th'aHllib,ther. FBtempJo..Y.ee.~'ndea hls,'or Ii¢r p.ar:ti~iRatIQn in ,oj 6.b~l1JatiQrr Qr, a
:d~ta!O¢~' rriteNi.e.I,;\[.'9r .l.n.t;~rrog<;l):rQn b~cal!~e ·O.f th~ irit.ervi~w or ifit~lr~g-ati.dn.m~th.6cfs,b'eibg us~d?'

o Yes,

YD:. [)I,lrlri~<,a'ny ,Q~ YO.!J-t pver;:;,e.a.~

.0.

No

g,~'pJ9.yrn.ei1ts Qr.a$~ignm¢Ii!~~

!:fig y9lJ,. rep:Q·~ <;lry ~.6hc'~.rn$.

r~gardin'g

·an'y:deta.lrte~' Interyl¢W l:!r Int~rr6g~tlbl1 p·rqq:lces~. ~r ,QJller typ~s pf detttlne~,trea,t.mel1.t,to.

;s!-i{Je'nd.so.rt

an FBI

•
.
QYes·
0 No
71. ~!l,r:ing .~ny '9f"Y9\-!-r-!,?v~rSl:!?S d~'p[oYI\l~nt~ or a~signr,n.ent~" ~id YO!-l.r~p.ort~ny t9!1cerns, ,r,egarqing
a(ly:det!3in..~e in~«:;!r.:y.iew gt'iilt¢rrq,g'!'it.i!=!o pra!=ti.c¢s .ol"qther ,typ~~ pf qetaio~~"~reptrJ:l~m:yOT,!
Qb~rv'¢.d. or heard ab.lJut" 'to'a nOh-.F,Bf sup~ry:iso'r or 'Pother rio·n.-FB,I pei;"Spnn'¢.I? "
I
a·Yes ·0 No
'J2~ Have you .'ever been' ordered'or-directed not to report, :or discouraged in any w~y from reporting)'
QP~rV~t1(?lJs 9r alleg~tionl? te'!ate9 to .de'taine~ tre,Cltme,nt pr i.nt~rview pr Interroga~lpnal;tiQns.or

fitGlctlce;s?

.

'0: Yes

.(!).

No

'l3~. Have'you exp'erlehced any :actu al o'r th~eatehE!d r~t~ IIatlo'n for 'repoltlng observations D r:alleg~tlons

- QT .r;le!ainee tr.eatment or in_terview:or jnte,rrogat!on <;letions or practi~?'

o YeS'

0 No

OIGQ-005001

'74. (qpilonal)· p1.e?~. proY!Qe .a.0y 911dltf9n~1 C;:9I;rymen~s r~~.~T~,ng tlj~ r.ep0'11n9 ·of c9.ncern~ p~.Iated ~~.
intervj~w 9.r {ntemigatign teGhn1.qll~s! d~~enJi~n -pra.~ltes! 9r·:otlic:.r d~t.aJne.e..tr~atm~'nt.

,I
76., 'Addifional Comments' and Recommendations~
...
. . .. ...
E?<tE;!n$i~E;! .de~rjefsf iilt:luding 1!,!~so.n51~rne:d ·~.bpuIQ. !;re' tJe1.~ .with. ey~fY FBI emplpy~e retu.ftJ.ing from an
~

,~v~t~-ea'S: a~~i~n~~ot.

~..

.

.

OIGQ-005002